Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 35 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] Morning by J nathon sh last week two 12year old boys from rabie esc's seventh grade Sher Southshore gave over to D our small nighttime in the island sh and W May happens to be given sh there three two to three times he did and Benji State statfield both sons of MD war did a tremendous job giving over the da from beginning of per until the end of with the amount of they do they knew the cases by heart inside out including rash to them they Contin follow in your footstep when they get older here you have the whole Shear here we go we'll put on some volume ready go good morning excellent Okay no Okay because they said good morning r hi no I'm assuming they said the whole share but that was on video if you call I'm the English guy that you met on convention last Friday raaba listen to this and we spoke together to Z Son on Sunday I was as I was leaving the convention I asked someone for a ride to New York despite having nearly full car he took me happily he's M the wire from flush who is close to you and sponsored micro he's talking about madash he got me a car from flush to B Park and I only realized when I got there that it was an Uber that he paid for i' like to publicly thank this amazing whose name I don't know but I'm sure that you will mdy is full of and from one to the other I want to show you this this really touched my heart as we know bamin early was killed in Gaza and here is a voice note from somebody that sent this to Robert ear was here today basically this person who's never met Robert named his baby the Y mayor here we go listen hi thank you so much for your M wishes yeah the baby is good um and it means a lot that that you reached out um again I think there's a lot of connection to that name and then also especially because I do uh Ellie stansky zomi um for the last couple weeks I kept on hearing uh your son's name and uh it definitely resonated a lot with my wife and I and um and be for us if he could grow up to be um like your son and I heard a lot of stories from a few different people um actually before the bir and after uh about what what your son was like and I think your brother or brother-in-law me message me also um about his ability to be a gebore and to not want things and just always giving um so as our CL if if our son could could grow up to be um be just like him in that way thanks so much for reaching out basically he said that he's MD wire and he does the da and he heard the name over and over and he said he's going to name this kid I think there's already two babies named after bamin since I've joined babama life is not the same this is a rebi from Dar Tor the famous D far since joined from Bak life is not the same I feel a need to let you know and everyone here know firstly I so far only saw the beginning of today's Sher besides Robert being a y and a brother who who here doesn't feel a deep conect who here doesn't feel a deep connection to him because we were all part of a real family who didn't have tears in their eyes when reell called them to give him an hug this is just what makes this is what makes MSE so special it's a much deeper connection it's connection through the toy that's what is so special about this great family I feel like byav sensitivity has grown tremendously because of not just my toy we all to what a lesson true Yan the re and head counselor in the zone Camp rebell no mentioned the new the new intro music yet such a nice touch love it welcome back home to RBS I don't I don't live in but it was great to see you back at your desk with your landsmen who have been anxiously waiting your return I must feel great it must feel great to have the right equipment and be able to have all your screens in order at the same time for selfish reasons I appr miss having you State Side a to listen to share live every night at around 9:00 p.m. for me it was nice to get a head start I know I know I can hear the shear at midnight Eastern Standard time but that's way past my bedtime on a serious note your moment with Robert Early there are no words a man that has a million valid reason not to yet presses and sticks to the routine of during a time that's unimaginable or comprehendable to most Robert you're the man I look up to and hold in highest regard your example of perseverance and commitment has raised the bar for all of us I'm sending my hugs wishing you bring sh to all welcome back your Dove eisenberger Englewood New Jersey from s to ma we have to wish a tremendous ma our dear fix whose Soni became a last [Music] night and he's here today he came right after unbelievable [Applause] [Music] all right the co of the month what oh that's what it says there I don't know what it says K Rober early voice note oh that's me that's me I wrote that I I'm I'm confusing myself I want to tell you something very special that I heard from Robert yesterday Robert's wife when she was pregnant with B Yamin she was on bed rest and I guess I don't want to used the word boredom but out of not being able to do anything she started learning and to the point very interesting B the has never spoken a word of lashara in his life that that's what the family testify so Robert did a whole group of he has over 600 people on on his WhatsApp thing so if anybody wants to join but it's a very interesting thing the mother learned while she was pregnant the son never spoke for the of worldwide official Mitzvah motivators the to many many more grandm also known as fil bur thank you his new name is Pinos I mean his old name is back to his old retroactive clarification his name is p my grandmother brain intact un Le your full potential should be and tremendous success in all my Endeavors out of the month that come for from supporting here we go we're holding by the brand new M because we had a late start yesterday today's also not that much better but we'll see what we could accomplish today brand new Mish brand new Su the sponsored by remember yesterday I asked the question how's it possible that a ax does something you you owe money because of it but if you do the same thing you're poter here it is sometimes you're for your axes your Bulls but not your own sometimes you Potter when your ax does something and if an acts do something really embarrassing to somebody you're Potter but if a human being is somebody embarrass somebody if your axe knocks out a tooth or eye of your slave Potter it doesn't go out but if the master knocks out his ev's tooth we said even a dentist H I'm talking about tooth even a dentist that knocks out his own these are the mistakes you're talking about it's or the ey okay just just wondering if he himself does it to his own slave the slave goes out if an axe causes damage to one's father and mother so but a human being who damages his own father mother causes them some sort of injury where they bleed or an internal bleeding you poter why because of if it then we you don't pay if an ax lights a fire causes a fire to burn down a bail of hay on because it's it's different but if he himself Burns hay onas if a person's we're gonna see something amazing that even when you're not on the lowest level of sh whatever not you don't pay it's very think about it person burns down his friend's house in chabas $2 million mansion He doesn't have to pay even if he did it by by mistake but but you cause your friend damage no because it's shabas and if it was you this so even if it's you don't pay what huh oh we'll have to see maybe we're you're going to be you're gonna have a lot of fun the next M so I don't know if this let's do this here's the if somebody causes the destruction on chabas he's M he's Potter what does Potter mean oh so that's another to know that anytime it says Potter byas it's Potter but it doesn't mean you allow to go destroy property on chabas allow to do all these things on CHAS it just means that you're not all the M let's say you take I don't know you're doing on Chavis but you ruined it while you did it you poter the two of that you're over even if you destroy besides one who um damages another human being or lights of fire why says Rashi because from the fact that the tus says that you're permitted to do a bris chabas that means that only bris you're allowed to but to damage an organ that causes blood or whatever it would be a why does it have to say it's to do BR you're you're damaging you're causing the body damage so the fact that says that you're permitted only in that case you're permitted but other cases also from the fact that the T says that that was you can't heat up the the lead give fact is that otherwise it would be you want to say that saying says the so said you're saying things that I don't want to hear in here go out I forgot who they said it about I think it wasu one of the brisker or maybe it's the brisker I think it's that somebody came to talk to him in learning he try to get out of it so the guy started saying his pull then he said wait a minute told this kid do me a favor leave the room I don't want you to hear you know like to your ears like it's like you know get you get out of here you're saying such you yourself leave what you're telling me are two things that are not in the mishna what about our mishna it says in our Mish we must be saying that our Miss talking about an interesting case where a guy go goes over to a random person in the street cuts his arm what are you doing I need a little blood for my dog okay so it's it's it's not it's not a it's not a it's not destruction it's actually it's good he's getting food for his dog let's say you know it was very common in the time of the gar that the the weddings were on Friday so the wedding went a little late after so he you know what he going do for the he needs a little ashes so he made a fire new you allow to know it's one of it's a big Mitzvah to put the the the the ashes on the so he didn't stop make a fire he made a fire because he needed the ashes okay let's see if this works if your axe your bull lit up a bail of hand shabas you're if you did the same thing everything the mishna has to be consistent we're going to talk about a case by the sh it's the same thing by the human being by the human being the same just like an axe doesn't need why would axe need burn so so to the human being doesn't need it V nevertheless he's Po from paying why you see that even Cal he's not it's not for the not for a good cause for no reason at all he burnt a ba just like a a sh Burns for no cause so to the human being there for no reason and he's A's say this is one of the most interesting ever no no no when axe burnt the ba the axe needed it he's doing it for a reason what was that speakers so we could turn off the speakers no we didn't we didn't use them so why are they AR even this is a genius ax like the guy said the guy said to the guy sees a person playing chess with his dog he says wow this dog is m a genius he plays chess with the human beings gu says genius I'm beating him 41 this guy's M genius uh A lion attacked him gave him a g bite the M he needs to to burn the wheat so they coroll and and apply the medicine to his back he needs it says how do you know that's what happened the because first he burnt it he went in the sh showed up he sees a fire he knocked it with a sword and he burnt the thing he waited for the ashes he went then he started rolling in it it happens to be that in in makus we learned that on chabas you're not supposed to take the ashes and put it on a wound because it go into the wound and it looks like like a like a tattoo like Serv Kaka so you see they used to they used to use that for so the bull saw his uh his owner doing it he ah let me let me try that also yeah little bit what seriously a bull is that intelligent he knows how to use there's a whole thing about animals that they they some animals could use tools Believe It or Not crows are one of the most intelligent they're the most intelligent birds they could use a stone to get food uh monkeys use sticks to to scratch themselves you know animals do stuff no yeah a aami a aami but I could prove it oh hold on a second I forgot to show you this one seriously this is uh very important ah this is a sh being Mander in the in the AER he's putting the the ashes on his back okay says are they so intelligent yes he knocked off the cover of the barrel everybody knows that Papa was wealthy because he sold beer that was his thing he's a he sold a lot of beer so the the sh knew that alcohol is good for the teeth he drank beer and he was healed he felt a lot better here we have a we have a picture of that also oh okay F so first of all I had a shil and if anybody has a good answer please answer the it's not the same case to me at least when when a a bull knocks off the cover of a barrel and he drinks something he knows okay so he knows that cottage cheese is good for stomach ache he knows that beer is good good good for his teeth but to say that a bull lights a fire he created something new like baking a cake he created ashes and put the ashes on his back that's like a hole level thear says over here that they understand that there's something called medicine that you could heal like if you have a pain you can go to something and and drink it or you'll feel better so they could also so exactly what noan was saying I was thinking when I was learning this gar and therefore I will show you this video we don't have audio I'll give you a little it was uh for my birthday last year it was a birthday that I celebrated for three months straight and my deari no Gary up there and Ai and what's your your Budd we went we went to Kenya and uh we saw something very interesting I've never seen this before or after neither did the guys in the thing basically I set it up there was a bunch of lions eating a small Buffalo and there was basically nothing left to the Buffalo and suddenly as the guy the last line all the lines went away there's nothing left there's just a puddle of blood and there's like a leg and a little bit of the head and all of a sudden the the mother Buffalo who's baby was killed she came back for revenge and She chased the other the lion away and then it looked like we're not big in this but it looked like they're doing a funeral ceremony they stood there in that spot for at least I don't know 5 10 minutes going around in a circle looking at the blood and sniffing it and going back and coming they left came back went back and they going literally in circles we felt like they were in pain that they right that's 100% like you saw that they had emotions like so I thought okay we're talking about a bull and these are buffalo are bulls they're very dangerous most dangerous probably in the in the Safari they're unpredictable you don't know that they're going to come attack you and here it goes re boy say here's the line running away with that last piece this is Gary Gary took the whole thing [Laughter] that's a St on your baby so over there is the you'll see the C the the dark spot is the area where the the baby was eaten there's only blood left basically they come they sniff and they cut it's a whole it takes a long time we're not going to show the whole video but they were watching the the and there was this mother there's a daughter there's a we figured it all out how I have no idea this they're obviously not eating it they're sniffing in this took a very very long time anyway fine you see it you see so I'm trying to show that they have some more intelligence than what we think they don't just eat grass and go V there's something going on okay F interesting this is the r Papa that his bull had intelligence the continues with for a different reason how could you say that our Mish adds up that whatever the bull does the human does whatever if the the just like a human needed it so the bull also needed it to the point he's trying to heal himself now how is it possible as the doesn't know what busha is there's no busha by an animal there's no embarrass oh you embarrass me there's no embarrassment by an animal if you don't know what busha is how could it be that if you don't get embarrass yourself you're not going to know to embarrass somebody else so how does the mishna say that if the sh was a human being he's Potter it's not the same thing as a human being embarrassing because the human being does have kavana and doesn't have kavana you're telling me that they have to line up they have to be equal no you're right he didn't intend to embarrass he intended to damage you don't have to have intent if you're if a person damages another person he he I don't know knocks off his arm he had intent to damage his arm he didn't have intent to embarrass him but he's for The Bu so to the ax if he intends to damage a human being and it causes bu that's just he doesn't have to pay but you don't have to have you don't have to have that intent says the mishna is not talking about a case this interesting case where the bull needed the ashes no just here comes a huge huge that the reason why your PO is not because this the death penalty even without the death penalty everything happened he burnt down the God just like your axe doesn't know what he's doing the human being also didn't know what he's doing so he should pay let the human being pay your was he burnt the godes on purpose soz is going to be even if there's no so he's not but he did something that's you don't have to pay for the $20 B what if you tell him he did it by accident on chab he knocked down a lantern and burnt down $10,000 worth of hay so he should pay he's not getting Misa so let him pay say ra even in that case he doesn't have to pay at all that says in the here's the P sorry what just happened here look what the says very interesting if the animal if you hit an animal you a human being damages an animal you pay what happens when you damage a human being the person dies doesn't pay he never pays he only dies it's either death or nothing there's no by a person by damaging human being yeah the difference in L by only when a person damages animal what does that mean whether you did it unintentionally or intentionally this is a whole different level sh means you Tred to kill this animal he killed that animal it's mistake means he he was driving his car and the the guy's bull ran in front of him it's not MAV that's a that we said the says when you kill somebody a person kills somebody it has to be when the axe goes downward not when he's lifting up the axe you that you don't go to gulls for that it's just throwing everything in doesn't really make a difference so when you you you damage an animal you kill an animal you have to pay no matter what every type of D so two the human being is the exact reverse just like by of every single situation so to by human being you're Potter in every single situation so now take a look at this for a second it's three steps here step number one is by a bull your always therefore step number two is that by a human being you're always Potter on paying even if you killed the guy by mistake so if the guy is worth $100,000 he's NBA player he just had a $15 million contract you killed him by mistake whatever that means you went like this by mistake and you killed him completely poter you don't have to pay his family anything so step three is which is you're always Potter even you hear the three steps we start with a always human being you're always when you kill a human being something that's similar to killing human being which is you're always poter so you don't have to pay for the godish that you burn by mistake how can you say that AR is talking about that he burns by explains like we understood if had he done it on purpose he he needed it you have to if it's you need the the ashes then I could kill the person so in all cases be Potter M unbelievable thing burn down a guy's house by mistake onab po now I want to show you this three the animation and tell me what that is here we go you can do it on the full screen if you want oh there's no sound come out okay basically there's a two one is running after the other and they go behind the trees and then when we find the the guy in white is injured he's bleeding from his leg the sh is how did he get how did he bleed we saw a situation something led us to believe that the the ax on the right caus a damage but there's also a stone over there maybe it happen from the stone so what is that called we can't prove that your ax did it maybe it was injured by the stone so this is going to tell us a bunch of cases of over and over and if you in theor each case has a though theor doesn't specifically go through it Raj points out and just one is is okay says the very simple cases one was chasing the other one one says you damage me seems like a very strong language that he knows what he's talking about they're both witnessing what happened and he says not true I'm not assuming that he was damag but with a stone it seems like literally I saw the stone damaging my my my a my bull is perfect he never did that like we say throughout CH you have to prove it if you want to you want to take money from someone you have to prove it there two bulls owned by two different people and they're both chasing one bull same idea each one is going to blame the other why turning and I don't know her name what's her name where's Robert's wife my what Shir it doesn't sound familiar my holy son of Robert mayor Robert and jly and may if Ru owns both bulls and we know for a fact that a bull we witnessed the bull attacking the other bull but we don't know which one okay but if one bull is large and one bull is small what's because when it comes to time what yeah the is going to talk about that that it's interesting thear discusses but we know that a is only let me let me get to it real quickly yeah only what he's worth so it makes a big which bull attacked my bull if if if I if I go after a smaller bull it's not going to pay everything you only pay 50% and and your bull is only worth less than half the damage that you caused so there's an argument here I say the larger bull attacked me it again another case if you claim that it was the that caused the damage you only pay 50% I say no the M caus the damage you owe me 100% if there were two that were owned by one owner two that were damaged one was large one was small and there was two was four bows two attack two one was large one was small same idea I could take there's enough money to pay for my large bull because the large bull is the one that attacked it because anyway the small one is less damage okay we'll go after the small bull now he flips it he says the small one is what attacked your large Bull and it's not enough money to take out of it same idea I'm saying that you owe me the full amount because the mood will cause damage says for this we need to know the very simple of we have it throughout CH that if somebody is certain about what he's saying and the other one is uncertain he doesn't know he doesn't he doesn't know who attacked his bull was it the stone was it another bull I don't know something happened so B we always go with the one that's certain the famous question that ra actually asked me when I was a kid in uh I learned called and he asked this question and uh nobody understood yish nobody understood him so whatever I answered him but I knew the answer because told it us we're Lear about then the question is why don't you believe the shemma guy the Shema the guy that says I don't know he could have lied he could have said I'm a bar so he has AIG why is the you should trust the guy that said sh because he could have said and the simple answer is we do trust him we trust him that he's a sha we believe him he's a sha and bu is better than a Shea very good no just to give a little bit of explanation of what bar is I say I don't know okay you don't know so too bad on you you don't know I say I saw with my own eyes that this is what happened it wasn't my ax that that that did the damage so I believe you him there's a famous in in 10 days we're going to learn sh the famous case of uh a bull that attacks a cow and we see we come and we see the aftermath we don't know what happened we see that there's a fetus there's a calf dead on the ground and we don't know is it because the bull attacked the cow or perhaps she gave birth beforehand and the the the the calf died by itself so that's called which means that there's automatic suff here without anybody asking any questions if we show this picture to Azan they going say oh it's a good child I don't know what happened you don't need Ruben to say oh it happened before and say it happened after you don't need that it's automatic so when it comes to that and says famously 5050 now obviously just to explain real quickly you can't have a guy standing by the bz door and everybody that walks in he says hey you owe me $1,000 oh it's a suff you have to pay 500 it's like I described that Bez and see the situation it's you see by yourself that there's a there's a problem here there's a real sh what happen there without anybody saying anything what exactly thank you got to learn many many so and the is going to go to town on him going to go against him he proves from this mishna that we don't pass like we don't do this we say look here's a case in our miss all these cases even if they all say we know for sure we know for sure it's there's no here in our so you see our doesn't go like his case even when you're telling there's a there actual suff suff even when two people are saying they know for sure that's not a real that's two people that say they know 100% what happened there yes yeah because at the end of the day bzen will have a suff two people come and they say they know 100% it's funny how people do that all the time 100% I learned that this Kat no 100% in this world even in a in a dispute between okay I'm not even gonna say it now we but there's oh that happened on purpose there it was a Simon saying in all disputes come out in all disputes there's no 100% there's a 8020 there's a 100% is 100% everything else in this world is is this there's there's a reason why there's Republican and Democrats you can't say oh they're 100% wrong they're there's such thing sorry so says yes even bar and Bar two people 100% sure that they know what they're talking about has a suff who told who told you that our our talking about a Maybe by a it's only when two people come I don't know a real I don't know so B I don't know nobody I know nobody knows anything so say when two people are so sure about a situation how do you know that in that case maybe in our case admits I'll tell you why he says I know for a fact not true he doesn't say I don't know he says it's a very strong which is interesting I don't know if I'll remember T brings that all the way in the bottom last T three words he says because it doesn't fit in so much with the gar later he says sometimes ly could also mean that I'm not so sure fine but right now we're holding like is a very he's very [Music] certain oh so we have to remember this little piece over here papa says everything has to be consistent so if the beginning of the mishna is I'm certain then the end of the Mish I'm certain so let's let's see if that works one was large one was small the is better for him to say that the larger animal damaged him so he has more to to collect from and he says no you have less to collect from same case we're gonna learn a beautiful ins okay we're making a little de here what happens does a says you owe me I saw a large animal attacking me how do you know what do you mean I saw with my own eyes 100% the larg animal attacked me okay the other guy says no was the small animal attack so if he can't prove it if the N can't prove that was a large animal how much does he get from the small animal let me ask you a question when he says I am 100% sure I saw a large animal attacking what he really saying is that 100% sure that the small animal did not attack and I'm you from the small animal that's called that there is a t that says there is that says that by you saying that I admit in and You by you asking me for you're admitting that I don't owe you so if I admit to you that I owe you instead of I'm because you were you said no you only so from over here if you're telling me that he's a we're talking about bur and over here so you're telling me that it doesn't go like so says again let me just make sure here let me just show you this real quickly the the r is and the sa I didn't put here B fine but the saer is that says the so is saying if you're going to tell me that the r is talking about a bur and bur so two the save has to be bur bur in that case the Nik is saying the large animal attack me and not the small animal so from your de you're telling me but if he doesn't bring aah at least he'll get from the small animal but he's M him the small animal as T say maybe that that's not a good de maybe it means he doesn't get anything okay so says in the that he gets something says so we have to say it's talking about a case of and this is going to get really we have really really good charts here check this out the chart is beautiful you see the sa the N says that I saw an animal a large animal attacking it's a bar and the saer and the the ma is a sh wait a minute that make you still didn't answer the question says the G who who's the one if it's like this case on this chart that the N is the one that says I know for sure then you didn't gain anything because again he's saying I know for sure that the large animal did it and not the small animal therefore he shouldn't get anything and you're from the mission he get something check out the chart look at the chart beautiful I did it myself oh so the Nik doesn't know it makes a huge difference when the N says I don't know if the large one did it the small one did it so if he can't prove it he gets from the small one because he wasn't anything he didn't tell anybody I don't want from the small one say I don't know it's possible the small one did it it's possible the big one did it I don't have a r i don't have a r at least give me what the mazik is saying the mazik is saying I know for sure meny what ises what does the mazic say what does the mazic say look at the chart I know for sure that the cotton did it okay so pay you money did me and I don't know so pay for the little one oh listen to this say look at this chart it's getting better the chart I don't know what they do with without charts take a look at the chart oh so the r also has to fit they have to be consistent wait a minute that doesn't work so well what is going to say when a guy the says I don't know I don't know I don't know what damaged me what he's going to say what he doesn't say why is he should say look at the it's beautiful boom we have a shi and that makes sense are these cases consistent you know how we say oh it's impossible the r is B and the sa is doesn't work like that over here it's B but the other one and is that consistent is that the same type of case huh yes or no yes kind of yes or no okay says now you see clear why the Raa and the sa are not not the same because in Thea the N is in the sa the n a sh so it's not the same type of case says it is considered the [Music] same look at one more chart I did here like this is not the same two bares on top compared to and bar on the bottom that's a different type of case but this that's the same type of case oh we have to say a wonderful day here says hold on what else what else do I have do I have another chart okay so um have a wonderful day and RAB if you don't mind let's say till them together this everybody together we say together [Music] for [Music] think