Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
good morning
R not as good as last night but very
good very good thanks for having me
again we're at the bsky home um typical
fashion I have a flight pretty soon
unpacked the whole thing so if we have
to stop in Middle we'll have to
stop um because of that we're not going
to do a whole lot of emails just one
good morning rebell this email has been
on my
mind this email has been on my mind for
the longest time and I finally push
myself to write it I'm not gonna mention
his name even though he put his name in
there I'm just gonna take out his name
he's a a very good friend of MD big part
of MD comes every day to the m of people
WR and saying how they started learning
for the first time in a long time and
many similar
scenarios then they go on to say how
they the D has changed their lives from
A to Z in a very positive way I just
wanted to put out a disclaimer that it
also works in the opposite way been
learning with you since the beginning of
bras and being a part of such and
learning day in say and day out has
really changed my life in majority in a
majorly positive way unfortunately this
past summer I fell off the bandwagon
after came back on after the summer for
a bit with the outbreak of the war
certain opportunity that arose from that
and you leaving the country have really
fallen off so and so two oh and so too
has my daving learning and even chalom
bias I'm hoping that writing this this
will itself push me to get back on the
wagon and turn everything around once
again thanks for everything that you do
for clol Neer waiting your return home
okay listen hopefully I'm I'm on the way
home I did bust my knee a stickle I the
truth is I busted my knee I played uh I
ripped my ACL when I was a teenager I
had two surgeries and ever since then
I've been struggling with my KNE I
haven't done anything since then over 30
years and now just uh when was it two
days ago or maybe yesterday I don't
remember when it was my knee gave out so
i i k doesn't really Bend I went to
somebody today a specialist so if they
call me back and say this is a great
appointment with a great doctor I might
have to cancel my trip stick around for
another few weeks but meanwhile we have
a flight tonight and we're trying to
catch that one great otherwise they
probably have to come back to the the
states it doesn't go
away um what else do we have here yeah
the
of is the last
day the mother of she has a terrible the
same that my mother had when she was
49 and
thewi you like how I go
from that's how they wrote
it oh y schz he's in the house yeah it's
you no where is
this your name is y
Schwarz what's that nor shim shimy BR
you think okay shimmy Brun it's the same
noly the same yeah looks the same
awkward
no I know his name is shim BR but now I
didn't he's the mat Bakery guy he giv me
mat all time he say his name over and
over today call me okay that's what
happens you gotta go I hope the gamar
doesn't come out like that
shimmy oh yeah I said
thatz Schwarz who Schwarz I know
Schwarz
f94 restarts the da the it's better for
us I'm just thinking now this is the
first time I saw this one it's better
for us that he doesn't do the da because
we get a lot a lot of people that send
in that they should start it's a big
money maker for
MD and by Adam C in memory of H the art
of the day Adam and the Art of the
month for that come from
supporting okay so let's see what we
have as I was leaving uh my brother's
house not all the art was in place Yosi
was getting it done so bear with
me we're
holding on top and we were
discussing says this idea that if you go
into a carpent
let's see what we have here okay the
carbon's
workshop and it's not on the screen here
it is yeah carbon's
Workshop H so he went through this whole
thing that he gave you permission to
come in didn't give you permission and
he
said did he say on the first case that
he gave permission didn't give
permission Potter from
GS and you're in four things you're not
in the bottom one embarrassment but if
somebody again so this is a the
carpenter doing work guy comes into the
shop and ends up going out in an
ambulance or
dead so if he had permission didn't have
permission but he said if he was injured
you have to pay him these four things if
he died you don't have to go to GS we
saw chat that it's so severe what he did
guls doesn't even help no the shot was
that it that he doesn't have to go to GS
two lines
down
says is on this
case so here's
the right we saw this yesterday person
goes into the forest to chop wood goes
with his friend he has an ex he starts
chopping wood and the axe finds let's
see the
head it it his friend and he dies
what's
says okay what does that
mean that this come to comes to exclude
if somebody puts himself in the
way you threw the Axe by mistake you
didn't know the guy's there but you
threw it by mistake and it hits a guy
the guy didn't come into the axe says
what's what's the case that somebody
comes into the
object imagine to yourself a guy he has
to get rid of his refrigerator lives on
the fourth floor so he takes he looks
out the window he looks right and left
nobody's there so he takes the
refrigerator he starts pushing it out
the window the neighbor below he hears
some noise so he sticks his head out to
see what's going on and that's the last
thing he
sees 3D
so no 3D today not in such short notice
so gu looks around nobody there takes a
stone throws
it and this guy all of a sudden Peaks
his head out you know curiosity killed
the cat yeah curiosity is not such a
great thing sometimes we are curious and
we do things that we shouldn't be doing
we we see things from the war or
whatever then then we have why did I
look at that thing it's curiosity and it
destroys you got to be careful with
curiosity okay
so he sticks out his head and that was
the end of that guy you got a A
Stone so
what's Potter why because of this
P that you're you're because you didn't
know he was there but if he looked and
he wasn't there and he came into the
picture
then this he said it not on what on the
on the whole carpenter shop on
this so could be over here means that he
was negligent he should have thought hey
there's always people walking by there
so this like this is what we call what
do we call
this where is
it it doesn't matter no not this that
that's with a animal with a Shen talking
about you do something doesn't matter
where you
are and therefore you have to pay him
for lost wages and medical and all that
stuff why don't you have to pay for bu
again because you have to you have to it
has to be pre you have to be mcav and he
was MAV
says whoever took this and said that he
said from
the one who said it on this case
certainly on the carpenter because over
there he's a lot more negligent but he
said come in he saw the guy he's a lot
more negligent so certainly
he's but the one who says that you're on
the carpenter
shop yeah on this you're completely po
you don't go to go you don't go by the
way today if somebody has to go to gas
not that they do but if somebody has to
go to gas in dangerous cities where
where do you go you go to
toon these are all or KES I think it's
called up north you know it's not to get
to get about with
that back in the day somebody worked for
somebody else there's no you know
automatic withdrawals and and wires and
you didn't get a check you went to the
guy's house you knocked on the
door now the guy has a trick up sleeve
what do you do when you have all these
employees they come you have a nice dog
that kills
people the dog bit him and he died
Potter what does he Potter
from remember what ker is ker is not
a I'm gonna beat that ker I'm knock that
ker out what is it called you
know ker is when you you have to pay for
when your animal kills somebody
we could do a little Kar when your
animal kills someone you have to pay the
value of that person and what do you do
with the animal let's say it's a snake
let's say it's a dog whatever it is the
animal dies even if the person came to
your house any animal that kills a human
being you kill
it so argue they say that the says these
guys came into the house they have some
sort of right to come in because they're
coming to demand
payment but if my dog kills them I don't
have to pay for damages I don't have to
pay
ker since these workers these these
employees have
permission therefore he
is what's going on here what's
exactly if this guy hangs out in the
city interesting there's two types of
people it's people that are out there
you know at this time of the day where
is he usually this time of is he is he
on a job site or he works from his home
office we have to know big
difference
sorry if you usually find them out in
the city
so they shouldn't have been in the house
there with the dog and if he's usually
in the
house why does say that is
Potter the guy is always there they're
they're coming to pick up the check he
should be
careful very interesting there's a
person sometimes he's home some not we
don't
know I wouldn't say the story in public
but because my told to me this morning
and it's so you just understand he said
he once taking a shower in somebody's
house there's a knock on the door she
said yes so the guy walked
in so he thought the guy's going to say
oh sorry you the guy starts doing stuff
there so he realized he said yes the guy
thought Yes means okay you could come in
and then then take care took down roll
of toilet toilet paper whatever for the
our people says the gar that they they
speak different languages you say Yes
means yes come in or Yes means hold on
I'll be there in a minute what does yes
mean M that's the question here I'm not
saying that guy was normal but maybe
back in the time of the gar you say yes
how does It Go in English I don't know
how do
you my family H did
you about the food okay whatever it
is he said
yes who is it no if you say who is it
it's a question but you say yes could be
hold on like what you want yes like what
do you want or yes come in yes you have
permission to
come no I'm actually y you with time
it's just it's not my fault I don't have
enough time to to
[Music]
prepare and the the other one says No
Yes means stay right where you are I'm
coming to
you
um what does say
over so there's a little
here he says if so we're talking about a
guy that's in between sometimes he's
home sometimes he's not home but what if
he's a guy that's always home
Says Yes means stay right there where
you are but if he's the type of guy that
that hangs outside of the
house then yes means come in so himself
says in those days yes could mean come
in yes could mean stay where you are
depending what type of work you do if
you work from home yes
means stay where you are and if you work
outside of home so yes means come in
that's what he says so since we're
talking about a guy that's in between so
now we have a what what exactly happened
here
say so we have a that in this case a
person says yes he means stay where you
are don't come don't come in and if you
did come in and the dog killed you then
it's not his fault it's
employee comes in to demand
payment that's our
case it says over
here even though he came with permission
now we have to understand am I Potter he
came in with permission why you Potter
you told the guy to come in then your
dog attacks him why you
Potter because we must explain
to what he meant is he said hey
yes you have to if you don't understand
the language of people it could cost you
your life he said yes what he meant to
stay right there where you are doesn't
mean that you should jump in into the
dog's heart okay
says let me see if I can find it here so
just go through these this is Carpenter
guy oh I don't know if I think Yoshi did
something better so let me go find them
this is from the face still
oh so it goes like this very simple
stuff it's the same idea over and over
we have a time in a m a Time pays 50% of
his damage time is an animal that only
damaged three times less than four the
fourth you have to start paying full
amount M he did it already three times
fourth time he pays the full amount the
other difference is time pays
only the value of the animal itself
whatever the value is so if this animal
damages a Ferrari worth $100,000 he only
pays
the, whatever he himself is worth that's
it the animal is worth thousand that's
all he pays okay
so like in this case two bulls that
cause damaged each other they they saw
each other they just went crazy started
damaging each other so here we go
this one has $50 damage this one has a
$100 damage what do we do so we say the
total damage is 50 in other words the
one that did 50 $100 damage his bill is
only 50 because you have to deduct what
he caused damage to the other
one so look what happens here if I ask
you the question think about it for a
second it's very interesting this
is
the bull on the right he was damaged 100
let's say the bull on the left was
damaged
50 so the bull on the left has to pay 50
to the bull on the right but he's a Tom
so how much did he pay 50 or half of the
50 50 is 100 paying half of D no they
cause each other Dam so perhaps whatever
damage they cause each other we're going
to pretend it doesn't exist the 50 we'll
take it off the bill so now what's left
is only $50 damage to the one on the
right now we go and say hey he's a Tom
he has to pay 50% of that 25 25 so
that's what Raji says so here 50 is 50%
and then he only pays 25 in okay other
trying to
argue
whatever is left over in the difference
you forget the 50 that he cost the 100
that he caus now there's only 50
difference he pays half of that from
whatever is left
over well here's another case both them
are black they're mature they're they've
done this a bunch of times
before they're both M so they have to
pay whatever it is to pay the full
amount so the case is this guy did 50
this guy has to pay the full 50 the
difference is 50 pay the whole
50 now also don't forget that the the
time only pays whatever he's worth if
it's the
$25 doesn't pay the the whatever the
damage it's too bad that's all he has to
P what if one is a one is a
m m the basically it's the same case
over and over is wonders why do you have
to say all these cases
okay if the one who caus more damage is
the m so he has to pay the full amount
if the one that cause the damage is
a then he only has to pay
50% two human beings that had a nice
fight a human being is always a there's
no the concept of that only exists by
doesn't exist by so therefore you have
to pay the
full what if a human being had a nice
fight with a
bull not a smart
guy what do they call those guys that
that go against Bulls whatever he's
practicing matadors Matadors it matter
stuck the knife into the bow what they
do whatever so he has to
pay to
pay what if this is interesting what if
the bull that the human being is
fighting with is
a or the bull cause damage human
being a human being always pays the full
amount but since the bull is
a argues
it's not true when a bull does damage to
human being he doesn't pay half there's
no such thing is time when it comes to
human being even when the time is
damaging the human being he has to pay
the full amount he doesn't get off
saying oh this is the first time you you
attack the human that's what says
says like
this
let see what we have here oh stop I
didn't show this yet
okay let's see it again I didn't
even this guy damaged 100 this guy
damaged 50 he has to pay the full amount
if you reverse
it then the Tom pays 25 excellent great
job Yoshi okay what else does he have
okay we're going to get to this one a
second
says see at the end we could actually
see the here after it talks about uh a
causing damage aood causing damage a
bull killing
somebody like this you have to
do because we're talking about a bull
damaging a human being so when a bull
damages a human
being right you even see the here first
it doesn't it's not
all talking about says you have to pay
half amount if it's
a pay the full amount this is me doing
it don't don't worry about the art it's
rudimentary but just to see how it works
now you'll see soon why I did it like
that one on top of the other the time is
on top m is on the under that and then
you have that says
so
says no did I
skip so two when a bull attacks a human
being
so says look it
says that just whatever payments a bull
makes to another bull those are the same
payments he make to human being so if
there's a concept called by a and the
first three times he only pay 50% so if
he attacks a human being for the first
three times he attacks human beings he
only pays
50% not if he kills them because if he
kills them it's a whole different story
it's ker and kill
him
F so now
makesense this this Mish meaning the
last I just spoke about the last Mish
what's the last Mish I spoke about I
just that's not part of the those are
the what's in red and M in red I added
right m is that's the bottom one the
closest thing okay if he's a m you pay
the full amount but you don't say that's
on the
to there is no time when it comes to an
animal striking a human being
says so
again it's such a simple chart but I
think it works because when we think
about what are you talking about here it
is here all
the it's like the bottom one not like
the top
one okay so now according to he he
doesn't he doesn't act as a Tom when a
bull strikes a human being for the first
time in his life he has to pay the full
amount
how much where from what how much we
said full amount from his his body
whatever he's worth or the from the best
real
estate you see on this chart I put it in
green it's the last last word meaning
from
himself on the one hand he acts like a m
he pays the full amount on the other
hand he acts like a
that it's only as much as he's worth not
from the prime real
estate what do they do with this
because
learns like this this bom
that say goes on everything so what's
that he doesn't have to pay if a bull
attacks a human being what does he pay
damages
doesn't have to
pay certainly not but he doesn't have to
pay lost wages and medical
bills when it comes to the four things
yeah the T says a human being to his
friend bull that attacks human being
doesn't have to pay these things great
why does they need a special
word if I learn
it it's only coming to
exclude pain now what's special about
pain remember we said it a number of
times s is not something that has a
monetary loss person a lot of pain it
didn't lose anything the other things
repo you have to pay medical bills
that's a monetary loss Chas you sitting
at home lost salary you have to pay for
it that's a monetary s doesn't have
monetary loss I think from the entire
list you only e the bull doesn't have to
pay for but other things he doesn't have
to
pay maybe the bull should pay the the
bull the owner of the bull should pay
for his Bull's damage for and
CH says
the
if a bull was worth 100 and it killed
or it it gored another bull that's worth
200 and the N the one that was damaged
has nothing left from his the corpse of
this animal
worthless he could go to the damager he
could take the damager the the bull why
would he want him I don't know maybe
he'll just he'll he'll take revenge on
him take him use him as a as a plow and
the owner the mazik can't say I refuse
to give it to you that's my best tractor
I'll give you cash instead he can't say
that he has the right to go and grab his
bull this goes according
to
that first you have to go to B you have
to see how much everything is worth and
how
Etc no immediately it goes you go and
take the bull
himself what does that
mean when you damage my bull you just
become a regular malva and AA you owe me
money you owe
money now they become Partners it's not
like you owe him $100 now you just
became Partners in everything in the
bill that caused damage as
well
possible it says that after a bull
damages you sell the bull and you split
the
money the p is talking
to the the
Bez
what's it just occurred to me I might be
really slow seriously I week I was
thinking to myself when you learn a
gamar and you want to understand what's
going on so what are you trying to do
exactly you don't understand the gar you
break your head to understand the like
what's the logic behind it sometimes you
don't understand the logic so what are
you trying to do I think until now I
don't know maybe maybe I just caught on
it now maybe I knew about it I don't
know so if I'm slow forgive me I used to
try to figure out what is this Tana
saying against this Tana like what are
these tan saying I'm trying to put my
head into the the head of the tana and
then I realized it's really trying to
put your head into hm's head what did
AEM mean not the Tana hasm said you pay
half you pay whole you do this you do
that why why did hasem say that I think
it's a little bit it's a little bit
stronger no I don't anybody think like
that okay but here they just reminded me
because it
says he
he was he told you have to divide the
money was talking to the and that you
guys are Partners now so where do you
see a real what
is could I just grab this animal or not
okay that's a nice if we're Partners I
could just grab your animal if not
partners then you the guy could get away
with
cash
what if the one that was damaged decides
hey this animal that damag my animal I'm
making it heish they didn't go to bezin
they didn't do anything I'm making it is
it yours are you partner automatically
or you have to go to bezin
First could the
damage the owner of the damager animal
could he go ahead and sell it
according to all he is he's he owes him
a little money okay so he owes him a
little money the
M if if I owe you money I could go sell
my car say oh don't stop don't sell you
don't have a lean on my car on my metal
so if if he just owes him money so then
it's a good
sale perhaps
says no you have a lean on this animal
it's yours also it's the N it's the the
one the party that was damaged and you
don't have right to sell
it that's see over there it doesn't work
to sale in other words he has a good
lean on
it so R knew about this because as we're
going to see this there two braces here
says no it's not a good
says have that says not like you rebi
how do you say that it's not a good sale
it says it's a good sale so says what it
means
is now you would think that this is
like no
this that what that if the guy goes
ahead and sells it I could go and take
it away from the
buyer the Turning of
the D my holy nephew son of Robert ear
and
mayor Robert Early son two sponsorships
for
his says
the you're telling me it's sold it's
sold but if I want it I could go grab it
so then it's not sold what is it sold
for in what way is it
sold that if he used it he he took the
animal and he plowed a field with it
good good for him he got a free he
doesn't have to pay for that until the
guy comes and takes his animal back the
one that was damaged goes ahead and
takes his animal then then we're
okay but meanwhile he can use it and pl
with it it's his the guy again you have
ruven and shim ruven damaged shim's
animal goes shim I mean ruing and before
sh has a chance to grab the animal he
goes and sells the animal it's a good
tractor he sells it
the guy went the guy that bought it went
and Pla a bunch of
fields then shim wakes up he says Hey I
want that tractor it's a good tractor
let me let me grab that animal so he
goes in and grabs it all the fields that
the buyer plowed they were for free like
he gets his money back from ru and he
also got some plowed
Fields
says let's say you borrowed money and
then you go sell your
car it can't be we never heard such if
you borrow money and you sell your real
estate you sell your house bz can go
come and take it but nobody ever heard
that if you borrowed money and you sold
your car you sold your tractor you sold
your drill that bz is going to come and
take the drill away from the guy that
bought it we never heard of that of
course you're
right we
have remembers what is
means it's three
words a guy says I'm borrowing money and
I'm putting this aside this slave I'm
putting aside for you you could take
when you come to man money if I don't
pay you cash here take this guy that's
for
you that when you say you could come
and collect from this thing that's
different
says but what if you did to your slave
then you could go and
collect however if you do the same thing
that's we're talking about a bull they
said that this bull is in if I don't pay
you back come take the bow but it
doesn't work on a
bow you can't go and
and say that the sale never happened
it's it's a I'll explain to you why
why does that work on a slave in other
words I say I I borrow $100,000 from you
I have a slave that's worth $100,000
here this slave he's he's a computer
programmer he's great whatever makes a
lot of money if I don't pay $100,000
take the slave then I go ahead and I
sell the slave so you could go and grab
the slave from whoever bought it why
because everybody knows that this slave
was already there was a lean on him that
he was designated to pay a loan slaves
are are different everybody knows who
your slave is what your slave
is a typical bull nobody knows anything
about a bull but a bull that that damage
something then people say oh that's a
dangerous Bull and they know about
it and therefore you could make
him would work on such a
bu
he said
this so you have a bull that damaged and
the guy went and real quickly he sold
him off for good money or he decided to
be even worse he said okay I'm not going
to gain anything I'll just give it to
give it to
the so it's a good
sorry if he tries to sell it's not a
but if you put it to it's a good again
so there's a difference between selling
and making it selling it's not good
yes who exactly sold
it so we have a contradiction here
either way you look at it there's a
problem here the sale is no good hegdish
is good explain why if the sale is not
good then you can't make it hegdish if
the hegdish works then you should be
able to make to to sell it so that thear
is basically asking that different words
maik so who did it who sold what if the
maik the owner of this bull sold
it so that goes according to very good
go according to says you can't sell it
why because it's already owned by the
damaged party you don't have to go to B
okay but how explain that yes it's owned
by the damaged party but the ma the
damage J can make it why
because because then goes according to
another that makes no
sense so that you can't say this word
goes like this word goes like that
doesn't work so who sold it the guy
that's not even involved in the party
he's he's the one that was damaged he
goes and he sells the bull that's still
in the maik's
house so why isn't the good sale because
it goes Accord
to says it's not yours yet you have to
go to
B so how come he can make it
makes no sense again we have a problem
says it's talking about that the one
that damaged he's the one that tried to
sell it and it's not a good sale he's
the one that tried to make it heish and
it is
goodish it works like works
like you try to sell it it's not a even
according to you're the ma you're the
owner you're the one that caused the
damage you can't sell it but it would
work by the way she says on the spot it
would work a little bit for plowing for
RIA
Radia
the even according to I cannot sell it
why because there's a lean over here
don't sell a car that has a lean on
it but if you try to give it off to the
mikdash it is does work even according
to says that the masz has nothing to do
with it the whole entire Bowl is on now
by the by the damaged party the ma could
go ahead and be
why exactly that's the only way to get
out of these
things okay it really shouldn't be heish
shouldn't work at all it's not yours
you're the damager he used to be your
bull but too bad your bull went ahead
and caused severe damage to somebody
else that guy gets your bull now so you
went ahead and you made it hegdish so
that people don't say that you could
make something hegdish and just grab it
away from hegdish with without anything
without a penalty so we made a xier we
said yes you're right people don't know
people don't know what happened they
know you had this bull everybody knows
what car you drive right nobody knows
that yesterday you got into a car
accident and now you have to give you
car away to the other guy nobody knows
that so then they know they found out
that you took your car and gave it to
hegdish and the next day you're driving
it again or the other guy's driving it
so they're going to get mixed up here so
they say
is you have to give something to Hees
you can't just take it back from you
have to pay them a little bit even
though you had no right to give it to
heish at all but people don't know that
so they see that you paid up you gave
heish $100 and you redeem your car even
though your car is $10,000 can never
give it away can never sell it can never
sell it can never give it to only
because people might not know the
situation so we pretend as if he is
heish is
heish take it back it's not yours to
give could I take your glasses and give
it to hasem no you just took that guy's
Bull and give it to Hashem but because
people don't know it's that guy's
bull
so
short this is basically the same thing
again here
well you have a bull that only damaged
three times or less didn't go
to here we have a contradiction he sold
it it's a good sale it's
good he slaughtered it heed it he gave
it away as a gift it's good
but he went
to says it's not at
all Give It Away give the meat away
nothing if you owed money and they come
they grab it the the the Mala comes and
grabs your animal actually whether he
lent you the money before it caus the
damage doesn't matter when when exactly
you
money
why
because the you only pay from the value
of this animal
that's the the animal that caused damage
three times this is fourth time
according to so whether or not you went
to
bz if you sold it your mag
you it it's
good then come the the lenders and they
come to grab
it
why so you could grab the animal as much
as you want why because the guy's gonna
have to pay real estate when it comes to
you grab the
animal whatever is left is left so the
the guy that gets damaged is not going
to go after anything he can't go after
anything whatever the animal's worth the
one that damage the animal that damaged
his animal that's where I'm going to
collect from so you go and you sell that
animal the guy gets zero but over here
by if you sell that animal the one
that's damaged is going to get whatever
the damage is he's going to go to his
real estate and take
it so let's look into
this you so you sold it it's it's a good
sale not like you thought doesn't mean
100% this a sale liia meanwhile if you
play out with it good good for you but
you have to give it back
you thought that it means that it's a
good
no it's just
it's you it and you gave it as a gift
it's good
gift meaning okay you you gave it as a
gift so he only gets to use it once or
twice for plowing until the guy takes it
back but if you shed it and now there's
meat
let the come and take the
meat in the where talks about the sh
damaging another sh so it
says you split you sell
it says over there the word he's alive
how do you know that you go after a dead
bu yeah you have the the
nice that cause damage to the other so
you can go after that bu maybe only if
the bull is who said if you he's dead
you could take it
me whether it's alive
or so what's going on here
if it says like
this the question is why doesn't he come
and take whatever he the okay so let's
say meat is worth $1,000 let him take
$1,000 well you're
[Music]
right but now it's worth less than
before so who has to suffer the
consequence when it was alive it was a
tractor was worth $2,000 now it's only
worth a thousand he has to take the
loss and therefore very interesting
happens
here if you damage your friend's
lean let's say you you burn Hisar we're
gonna see in a second you you destroy
his lean now a lean what's a lean you
can't it's not a physical thing a is
just it's a concept and if you you
destroy the proof what did you
do
huh but you didn't what did you destroy
show me what you
destroyed but where is it it's destroyed
what you a car is here I destroy the car
the bull is here I destroy the bull over
here I took your ability to collect
which is on a on a piece of paper that's
worth two cents and I burnt it now what
what did I take away from you it's not
tangible it's not tangible it's not
tangible it's a ability ability so
where's the ability so you still have
the ability
where's
it
replace let's see some examples the the
bottom line is you know what it's
called grma very good it's called a
grum yes I took away your ability to
collect but I'm just a g I didn't I
didn't take your $2 million and burn it
I just took away the the the secret card
that says that you owe me 2 million
that's that's that's just a
grandma over here I went I this anim was
worth 2,000 now it's now it's worth only
,000 I took away $1,000 from you I took
away $1,000 of ability to to to collect
payment by
it of course he's he shouldn't be you
shouldn't go after him if he just shed
the animal no you
should it's funny to me it's funny
what's the difference between a live
animal and a dead animal just the the
the ability that he's breathing oxygen
so I took away here he is it's same
animal Dead Alive okay you can't say
that in in every kind of uh situ if I go
and I kill your animal now you're gonna
owe me that part we were talking about
he's trying to collect and he's trying
to collect from a live animal so here
here's the animal here it just happs to
be it doesn't work anymore it doesn't it
doesn't walk it smells a little funny
now but it's the same sh the only the
only difference is a minute ago it
went that's just oxygen now it doesn't
was able to things yeah but that's not
physical
that's what he's
saying but maybe in other situations you
should
be now there's a beautiful Rashi here
it's like uh seven eight lines from the
bottom that is also not because RAB the
famous RAB said
this says
rash RAB was a very important person but
what is he
saying going ra RAB but and from a very
rash is coming to
explain what do you mean I shouldn't say
this in in I shouldn't say this RAB
already said it okay RAB said it and
sometimes he he's not it's not a
mishna so I want to repeat something
nice what's the big deal what are you
what are you getting mad at me that I
said it again it's not if you're
repeating a a mish okay a famous BR says
rash know Raba is on the level of RAV
RAV was the first am right so he was
like a Tana he could he says something
like it's like a mish RAB it's
interesting rabba lived two generations
later but
he he so he was on such a high
level it's as if was literally in a in a
mish and therefore thear is asking
what's this R also said this says like
this I remember reading and I looked it
up today it it's true that Pablo esar
famous
uh drug lord he probably one of the
wealthiest people that that ever lived
he used to make $420 million a week for
20 a
week so he's on the run and his daughter
this his son said this his son is a
changed his name he's men today so his
son wrote a book I guess or was
something and he wrote that they were on
the run and they were so cold that the
his daughter his sister which is Pablo's
daughter got hypothermia you remember
this and he he burnt overnight he he
burnt $2 million in dollar bills to heat
up the the
room a little different this is not uh
this is star talking about checks if I
burn your check check is not
money dollars might be
different again
ask you burn the the bills your stories
of your your friend
poter RAB said this you hear it's a grum
it's it's not a physical thing he ask me
yeah it's actually discussed there does
have value somebody pay
okay I only took away a piece of
paper
if you have this field and there's a
lean on the field and I go ahead and I
and I dig a whole bunch of stuff in
there and I ruin the field like
that it's literally like
digging holes in the
ground and the says and it's not a
problem I mean it's a problem you get
all these things I think
you're it's just Ines than here in this
world we can't if you go and you burn
your friends star for a million dollars
they're going to get you good you're
going to going to put you on the grill
toss you around a few times but in this
world we can't come after you because
it's only
grandma have a wonderful day and
hopefully I'll see you oh yeah from next
year uh hopefully will be
fromes unless I stick around there we'll
see let's say
something we'll say it together
okay
[Music]
for
foreign
fore