Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 23 by R’ Eli Stefansky

welcome all the guests so first of all what's your name Colman Helman from Chicago he been with us since you vus since you vus first time I ever met you wow and your children what are their names are who does the da n niss sh what's your name again David Lain David sh welcome all the way from what Baltimore or Detroit Detroit Detroit all right so B the she is all those who were injured during the war all the all the hostages they should return home safely all the family members of hostages of of they should have they should be in good state of mind uh we'll just read a few emails and then we'll get going dear belly I came to shabas 3 weeks ago because I needed some in my life this is a person who wasn't part of MD as was going through some personal family trategies and boy oh boy did I get firstly people were asking me if you're not in the wire why are you going aren you going to feel awkward the answer no everywhere I turn people were just so nice by the time I left on Sunday I was signed up and here we are 21 days later having Mr daff with you just needed to get a piece of the rack currently the head counselor for the Zone Camp AKA ur's boy division we put out this song attached called listen to have tons of maybe even play for 30 45 seconds during this year people will love it all the best someone you inspired Big Time Yakov Levon let me see if I could play it here I don't know if you'll hear it here we [Music] [Applause] [Music] go you know the song okay beautiful hey hey so he starts off hey I'm 14 years old and I started to do the da I'm in nth grade in yes I was in New York and they asked me to speak in D and I love d That's you know I went there for a bunch of years when I was a kid and it just it's very difficult for me to to leave and go speak it takes but I did speak yesterday at sh a very and it's here in Chicago so not not a something about but place we're learning a voluntary she to try to finish it we just finished the third peric in the third per there a big of today's D has to do with it I hope the there knows s furthermore at the end of the third per like the last BL and a half it has to do with the B I knew it because of rebi I'm thaning re on how much rebi taught me and showing everyone how it is to do and how much affects your daily life thank you again I took a few BL early I just got up to and at the 27th minute Mark you were introduced for the first time to the idea to have a cruise ship for the SE I have to admit when I first started with MD Y and heard the idea of the cruise ship the SE I thought was very far-fetched but after I'm not sure if one cruise ship is going to be enough so a number of things first of all what happened was somebody says a joke I think the cruise ship I'm like you know we're during Co and things are not looking good let's just you know make itm we'll talk about a cruise ship I said it's it's not going to happen but then as time goes along people keep on saying hey what about the cruise ship now what's very interesting is that when I go to different places I ask people so since when they do the da so they like to tell me since bras I said with me yeah yeah yeah since bras because the rule is that in order to go on the cruise you have to be at least like shabas bras time so a lot of people suddenly became where were you last three years no no no been here like sad but he he didn't say BR he said yamas right yamas you're gonna keep on coming here we need we need people like you life shum all right what else do we have here so let me just go back and say the sponsors the sponsor for the unity of pares of the reg sad very sad story Table Six won't be said this boy will have was in a skiing accident almost two years ago and is paralyzed from his waist down we should learn for him [Music] worldwide and let me just make this a little bit so that doesn't kill me okay here we go and the art is sponsored that come from supporting so two things first of all if you haven't done so I think only half of what we wanted to accomplish in terms of Havas was taken there's many more DPP him it's very very easy you go on you just listen to the shear while you're doing something else and you put it on 1.7 speed it's 30 minutes you skip the emails whatever the other thing is we're still looking for sponsors for volume two above a you can go to sponsor md.com any amount is appreciated all right so I have a very simple Shiloh if somebody has a a dangerous dog let's say has a pitbull and the Pitbull Lo kill somebody here in America people get killed all the time from pits and and dogs like that Hally speaking what do you do to the dog kill probably you kill a yeah t talks about a Bull T talks about a bull is there enough between a bull and and a dog okay you're right we'll see that a little later on I don't know if people correlate they say yeah the Tor says kill a bull I don't know if they put one one together there is no difference between a bull and a dog and a snake and a dangerous any animal and animal that kills a person a bird parrot that kills a person has to be put to death if we had B MD and everything else so we're in middle of a su oh that's that that's the song We're mle of of is fire you you lit a fire and went out and caused damage what happened here is it your is it's your force your personal force that caused it or it's like your dog that went out and and caused damage like your bull that went and caused damage we saw different nun yesterday what if the fire is not yours you took fire from somebody and did it so if it's your mama and it's your dog it's not your dog if it's your fire if your fire is your Force it's your Force doesn't matter where it started from I'm gonna see some interesting things today so we're holding five lines from the bottom of is the one that says that because of it's your force it seems like the collaborates with why because it says so first of all I have two a and so let's see this POS for a second a fire will go out that's a lotion of human intervention or Not Human intervention no human intervention it goes on its own it destroys on its own it has a mind of its own so to [Music] speaks then it says the human being is the one that lited and is responsible here he lit it up so the beginning of the PA seems like it happened by itself it decided to go by itself then it says so [Music] says it's why is the person the M because it's his force that caused it and where do you see to explain this exact that's on the screen this it starts up basically the Bryce is explaining R is right it's interesting how he made it into a and which the Bryce itself is explaining this it's a NE that came out of his property that caused damage it went by itself the end it's you that did it that like say it's your force and that's why you're says you know my my friend they were when they were children they were still friends the whole the friends say my friend he that's the good according to the says that fire comes from your the reason why you're fire the the is because it's your it's like a bullet that comes out of your gun it's your force that caused it here's a picture is a hidden object and says by fire you P from hi now the question is if fire is your Force so so obviously if you go ahead and you do something with your hands there's no there's no T of of T where do we see a we see interesting this we see some interesting but we never find the when it comes to a human being a person is always where do you find here's here's here so if we have to understand according to why would there be something called how does it work so we have to explain so before I forget I just want to say there's a famous POS so I forgot one of the Reb said that that there's three or three ideas that we could learn from a an arrow and comes to the the children number one he says that if you're off in your a little bit like any like when when you shoot a missile you're aiming it at at a country if you're off by an inch in the beginning so by the time he gets to that country it'll be off by 25 miles whatever it is right so when it comes to have to be on okay then the more you put into it the more you pull it back then the more you repay and then then he says but if you pull too much and you do too much then the string snaps and hits you right in the face so it's also that's also not good too much so you have to it's a delicate balance but the more you put in the more you put in the more you get out so so again the question is how do we find an idea of Tom in the explains it's a beautiful thing he says here so here's the picture very very nice we have a a person's his yard there's a nice wall and there's another on the other side so look what happened when he lights this fire his his arrow is limited to the wall shot the bullet he shot the gun the bullet could only go up until a certain point so at the time that the arrow left his hand there was a wall and was limited to that wall what happens in this case comes a goat stands let's say on the wall knocks down the wall threw in a goat anything the wall fell down after he lit the fire it happens LS a bonfire in his backyard he's making a barbecue there's no reason to be any damage whatsoever It's contained so his is limited his there is no now now that the fire jumps the wall and the wall fell down for another reason so it's no longer KES there is noes KES was limited up to here yeah so in American law you say that the person is responsible for the reasonable reasonably foreseeable consequence of his action foreseeable consequences of his action says our attorney in-house attorney Ste oh let's let's let's see see if I get there hold on one second I might have skipped here hold on yes so yeah so the first part is the was no that's it was up to the wall now the wall fell down he didn't know what is it called again Steve the reasonably foreseeable consequence of his action the reasonable foreseeable consequence of his actions good thing I'm not a lawyer or a doctor because especially now with my memories I can't even remember simple words can't remember your name okay as great beautiful explained it nicely there's no what do have to do so even if the this this object that you destroyed is out in the open you should also say you because there's no Arrow the arrow was limited to the wall this is beyond the wall beyond your foreseeable I already forgot what he said huh reasonable kids are but it's even more than that your is up to this wall it's not an invisible it's a real wall when you shot it there was a wall so that so Hally went up to the wall I can't be M because a goat knocked down the wall that's not you that's something else so you have to say says the G unbelievable now this puts a a Twist like we don't and we stay with this according to says that a fire is your arrow it's your Force when I cannot get a person for an arrow like in this case the arrow is out of here it's gone there is no more Arrow past the wall I'm going to get you for M now turns into your dog the fire is your dog and there was a wall here but your dog went beyond the wall okay somebody knocked down the wall and the dog damaged Beyond the Wall so now I'm because of because it's your property that cause damage so what are you g to ask me but how should he know about the wall oh he had the opp the opportunity to fix the wall and he did it so in terms of the K it doesn't matter even though you have the opportunity to fix the wall and you did it there is no more K because Arrow only goes based on the moment that you shot the arrow at that moment there was a wall I'm not anymore I it came down and I was able to put it back up no that's not my problem because at the time that I shot it it was up on the wall that's my up the wall but there's a new it's called the of your property nothing to do with your Force if you have a dog and it's in your backyard foreseeable or not foreseeable there was a wall and it came down and you were able to put the wall back up they warned you and they said now you're if you didn't put up the wall and it went into the other and damage so even according to so we had what is fire says it's the arrow says it's your property now says says it's also your property so then where's the difference between it's like a bull your fire turns into like a bull you didn't close the door in front of you knew about there's a problem your bull is about to escape they warned you you have a fire you're right when you shot the fire there was a wall but right now today there's no wall and they warned you about it if they didn't warn you okay but they warned you so you should have gone and picked up the wall prevented the fire from escaping you didn't that's your bull escaping wall is it it doesn't matter shared wall you had the opportunity to come with an extinguisher and put it out in terms of you don't have to you to you shot a bullet at a wall you're in a you're in a in a in a gun range you shot a bullet and there's a wall there so then somebody comes and takes the wall down you're not you don't have to go put up a wall cuz when you shot it it was 100% M for you to shoot there was a wall somebody some Su came and took down the wall that's his problem but when it's your property it's different than a bullet when it's your dog you can't say oh there's a wall there so what if there's a wall but now there is no so make sure your property doesn't go damage that he holds both what's the difference in other words so the the the question is more when the fire is yours that's the question when the fire is not yours so according to there's a big if the fire is not yours you're not at all right that we didn't understand it so well but that's what he says says if you go you take someone else's fire it has to be your property it's not your property so we do have but in your fire where's the where where's the so right according to says so but so no will just throw it right away there's no B because he didn't intend to embarrass the person it wasn't intentional but if you hold its your Force like hold this you when you damage someone you have to pay these four things if it's your dog that damages someone the only thing you have to pay is NE you don't have to pay you have to pay damages you don't have to pay for medical bills and all that stuff the the four things the not being able to go to work and and and the four the total of four things you don't have to pay when it's your property when it's you yourself like Rebellion says it's you yourself it's your Force then you are so that would be the between whether or not you have to pay the four V [Music] I'll just say this because it's a short alond it's it's throw it out there I thought about it while I was learning so I said okay fine there was a king that was very good at the at what is it called archery so he heard that there's like a a world class archer in his kingdom he said I want to see like let's have a little bit let's let's do a it out so they brought the guy in so the guy says you you go first the King was able to hit the uh Bullseye you know within let's say the bullseye you got three arrows within the bullseye the other guy he couldn't get into the bull he got it like on the side but every one of his arrows hit each other so they said listen the king wins the king is the better Archer so very good as he was leaving the king he whispered to the king he says listen you noticed I'm able to hit the same Arrow I could also do the same thing in the bullseye so so why didn't you it's not the cover it's not cover for the king I didn't want to up the king what they give the king so the King was very very excited he says okay I'll give you you know whatever had he shown the king that he's the better Archer nothing he would have G up it would have maybe they would cut off his hand who knows what so the is that not always do you have to win lot a lot of times it's better not to win even if you know you could win say not I know my kids will make fun because I'm very competitive so anytime I play basketball I'm like that guy you know when they were three years old they try to swatted and but okay not always you have to win okay so going back to this case okay we see it again why why not the dog takes a a bread and on the bottom of the bread there's a hot coal as you can see if you look closely he drops the coal and causes a lot of damage so the M says on the bread you have to pay the full amount that's Shen so says who who the the owner of the dog mentioning dog and of shabas the came came to a city and he wanted to give us drush so the gab said no no no over here doesn't like Tyra you give us jokes M but no Tyra please no Tyra so he said okay I'll tell you says guy that was supposed to go through the the forest and they said you can't go through the forest there's a lot of wild crazy dogs there he said don't worry about it I'm gonna say and the dog can't touch me it's fine it's okay guy comes back to SCH he's stitches on his face on his hand bandag he so what happened he said the dogs wouldn't let me say the P okay what happened to the owner of the coal so according to on the actual godish how much do you pay half an now I have to say the is going to change its mind soon but the understood that we're talking about two different B here there's a guy that owns the godish a guy that owns the bread so thear is asking according to they only pay half the the should also pay half why why cuz his property damaged is damaged to should pay the whole thing the whole thing you should pay it's m it's property so his M went in in damage so says no he's not he took care of it he made sure it shouldn't happen what do you mean he watched it how did watch it if a dog was able to get in there think I have a picture here oh dog went underneath the the fence he dug out a hole and he went underneath that you should know that for the most part do a dog could get underneath the fence so if so so shouldn't you then you should be liable what kind of fence do you put up you're your owner how do you watch your flame a dog was able to get in says Ty is no all you have to do as much as normal people do to keep people loud you have to worry about all these other circumstances a dog coming in that's not your thing I just saying in our I had this massive bookcase actually still have it in my house big bookcase and it was like this far away from the wall so I brought a bunch of my friends it was like eight people were pulling and pulling and we got one guy got between the bookcase and the wall and pushing and we were all couldn't move it and then I remembered that this gamar reminded me this that Stam Stam windows in St even though they have metal bars or like they're wide open like this like this why cuz the Arabs come with car jacks and they put it by the by the by the bar and they just go like this and opens up so I took a car jack I went downstairs took my car jack put it between the wall in my bookcase it went like this like that the whole thing moved no problem moved it a seriously I put a piece of wood on the wall put a piece of wood on my bookcase it didn't cause damage to the wall you see how thear just reminds me of different things random things no no seriously I mean my neighbor and I just beautiful uh metal you know things what it does is it keeps kids from falling out windows but not the the G it's a joke literally a joke they come with the car jack okay anyway just thought if you have a place in you should know about it or in America a door is nothing it's as if it doesn't even exist the dog in in five minutes just goes like this to the dirt and goes right in as we see in different places in the world the dogs the rats they know how to go like this and get under the ground it's not a problem I'm talking about so we're exactly this occur the damage the fire burnt some random person bail we learned that when it comes to Shen it has to be in the of the in the of the dog stole the bread you're only right if the dog took bread from place a stole it from place a brought it to place B and ate it in place B so we actually had a g the whole thing to discusses it over here and I had a big problem that I found this all the way like towards the bottom like I would say like eight lines from v l so basically says over here that there that it's not about the taking and I actually spoke about it then it's not about taking the bread it's about where you eat the bread so certainly the bread has to be eaten in the where he stole the bread so then what where was this baale of hey also in the of the okay so both were there fine end the story [Music] says so it's very interesting how do we view the inside of the mouth of the cow maybe as a muscle you have the a car and the car is in the of what's the inside of the car how do how we view the inside of the car you view the inside of the mouth here's I have an animal that's owned by a maik the animals inside the of the what's the inside of the mouth is it the property of the ma or the property of the N it's a big problem why because it says and that's basically what the is going to prove it says that you have to eat whatever the animal eats is in the property of the one that was damaged so if the inside of the mouth is considered the property of the damager it's his beh it's his car it's the inside of his animal so then you never so says as because if it is considered the property of the in other words the simple meaning the ti is what is your bread doing in the mouth of my dog well your dog took my bread I didn't put it in there yeah is saying is that it's in the wrong R it's in the r of the ma yeah didn't it didn't come in there uh you didn't have the dog didn't have ch to take it but nevertheless the says that has to be in and it's not so T sticks in if you want to go with t t says to explain a little bit better what if put it into the animal's mouth the animal couldn't get it by itself and put it in there that's what's going on here so again is do we consider the mouth of the animal the property of the Nik or the property of the maik you're probably thinking to yourself well for sure it's the it's ruan's animal so it's ru's mouth but if that's the case the animal the owner of the animal should be Potter because put it in there therefore and the animal's mouth excuse me is considered the mazik and the mazik is Potter short turning the D sponsored by my holy nephew son of Robert May and another sponsor mayor [Music] Robert mus for myself I was in and no fix wrote To Me I'm here by Robert early I could put him on the phone so I said who half like I'm in have like I'm lazy I'll do it later so I said I'll do it later so I did do it later I called him nobody picked up and I missed my opportunity L Miss [Music] opportunities because we have the question what's the mouth of the of the animal people [Music] what do I do it's here for like the last three years doesn't go away I know in I went to him he says I don't see anything top one of the top guys in the world you know any other in you have another guy that's even better it's better than him wow I'm not going to say anything that they don't see what you're saying and if you say now I'm gonna get hopefully I'll get an email from one of the enes that's watching what do they say they like to say it's um what is it called uh when it comes up like at night um re reflex as a reflex yeah you should put your bed like this and this I know all the tricks oh so here the is asking obious question if you say that the mouth of the animal is considered the owner of the animal's mouth give me a good example of how it's possible that an animal eats and he's in the property of the damaged person the mouth is the damager so how could you be in the property of the damaged one of my favorite we'll just show it for fun why not because of my friend Mary Cy we'll put the shut off the volume here oh no that didn't work okay basically the animals rolling around enjoying himself on top of fruit and and it crushes Rashi says like like horses and and and I I've seen this with my own eyes they like to roll in the zebras like to roll around the dirt I've never seen a horse but I guess this the same kind [Music] of so what's going on so Raj sticks in a beautiful thing if you remember that b b all the way in the bottom the brings this POS to to teach us about Chen so says over here you need this like the tooth will destroy completely there's nothing left so if so if it's rubbing its back on a wall there's a lot of things left all the stones all the bricks that fell down are still in the world if it's rolling around on on on fruit there's still fruit around me there's a beautiful million dooll picture on the wall and he decided to to scratch him on the wall what did he just do he destroyed the painting he took the fruit and with his the power he's able to push it into the mud or whatever it is now the fruit are worthless T So this mice I mentioned it with Rob earli because he was my neighbor then I hope he doesn't remember the mice it's not one of my mice I like to talk about but basically there was an anti-semite on my block on eate Street on Avenue P and she left let a dog a German Shepherd out on my daughter and the dog scratched my daughter's face in front of me so I'm not going to say exactly what happened to her she wasn't in by the time it was over she wasn't in good shape so sh is is she not because the cop said c said that what do you mean she she didn't do anything the dog did it so I said I don't understand could you tell a murderer that he didn't do anything the gun did it it's like oh it's different so is there a TI I got a little scared when I started learning the Su but then I realized that over here the gar is talking about somebody else's dog says like this this the story that happened you take a dog you bring it to somebody here go bite this person in thear I'm not making this up she like this woman did Big she's supp to go she called or the person caused the dog somebody else's dog to bite somebody you take a snake you go like this Potter guy's Potter Potter the guy that created the whole situation seems like the is gonna go away from this at least the second part that it seems like that the owner of the dog is you hear this I take your dog I go over to somebody say go bite and he bites so the owner the dog is why because his property caused damage the guy that did it the russer that did it he's not because he didn't bite it's not his property what if you tell me that the inside of the mouth of the dog is considered the property of the damager lay why is your hand in my mouth in the dog's mouth meaning again it's hard to understand but it's it's deeper than the the the meaning over here in other words the guys the guy that owns the dog could say where did the damage occur the damage occurred inside the mouth of the dog inside the mouth of the dog we said is the of the maik it almost doesn't make sense but he could have such a because it's with it's in my property yes I get that you put your property on the guy's hand and the whole thing but at the end of the day in terms of this Nez he should be POS because it's not his propert it's you came into my property says you trespassed what were you doing in my why was your hand in my dog's mouth which reminds me of another M I just thought about we my friend and I we went to this um Ed Ed Car Sales place and they had a doberman pincher I told my friend don't go out of the car the the dog was coming over to the car he said don't go he says no it's it's people are supposed to come here it's just part of so he comes out of the car and the dog grabs his arm and latches on and wouldn't leave go so I I scream to the owner the guy comes out and no matter what he was pulling and yanking smacking in the head at then he didn't have real damage like didn't pierce the skin but it was that it was was really really tough like he couldn't get his hand down he was trained I don't know what it was so you could say why is why is your friend's hand in the dog's mouth my you could go ask him his name is he lives in Flatbush oh you're right nobody's here the owner of the dog is not he's not the one that caus this whole thing and it's not his and the the if you want you can say Hally it happened in his property your hand made it into his property because the dog took its canines whatever they called those the long teeth so they were outside of the mouth outside of the mouth is already a different as person in my neighbor the one that wrote all those F he's very very close to why that he tried to kill the tried to kill kill so he can marry it says it's better that that he was married that she was married it's much better for him told him because didn't know that didn't know about the but it comes out that had learned so then he would have done it I thought it's a natural thing I didn't know you have to know the Ping okay I guess he's just laughing making a joke but that is right that the knew the then we wouldn't have nobody would ever die we wouldn't have other mishan because he would keep other mishan alive he wouldn't try to trip him up with the apple or whatever and he would just marry okay fine you take you take a snake and you you make the snake bite somebody so this is a picture I found online I've seen this done you know if you go to these zoos whatever they take a snake and they put the fangs of the snake on a cup and out comes poison right that's how they extract poison Venom huh venom venom venom thank you Venom so the question is where's the Venom is the Venom in the fangs and when you push the fangs in a certain way the snake has no choice but the Venom just comes out or the the Venom comes out when the snake wants it to come out first like bites you with the and then it could it could inject you with Venom or sometimes it doesn't inject it's up to the snake sort of thing so what's Happ because if I take a snake let's say I take a dog take a dog and I hold him backwards and I whack a guy over the head with the dog what's that I'm who cares if the I use the dog as a stick as a as a sword so if you take a snake and if I go like this 1,00% the Venom is going to come out because that's where the Venom is it's not like a bee or whatever that he has to sting you if you just push down on the cup like they do in the zoo the Venom comes out so I go like this so basically I shot a guy I I took a I took a a knife and I killed somebody what's the difference so if you say it's right there the guy that did it you got to kill him he's he's a murderer so you kill him but the actual animal that did it Potter you don't kill the snake the snake had nothing to do with it you forc the venom out of the sake snake the the snake has full control whether he want it to come out or not so you have to kill the snake so that answers the question that it doesn't matter if it's a sh or a snake or a dog you kill an animal that kills another human being provided that the animal knew what he was doing and he had intent but the guy that put the snake yes he's a big rush and I'm sure he's going to get a lot of in a special place for him up there the whole thing but in terms is he a say you can't say that he's uh what is it called the top in America um when he thought about it premeditated premeditate it's not a premeditated murder because sometimes a snake decides to the V sometimes not but once again we go back to this far which needs a little bit more explanation if you say that the the mouth of the animal the inside of the mouth of the animal is owned by the owner what is your hand finger doing inside my snake's mouth it's my not that why is it doing there but in terms of he can't be 100% he'll be in other ways but not bezin cannot kill to kill the snake to that's we don't use oh what is it doing about he's a killing snake he's a snake that just killed a human being the is done how do you know that if a snake or any animal kills a human being and he had no choice he's the nicest dog in the world but somebody a guy came into the house and he attacked him and killed him how do you know you have to put the dog to death very interesting a g comes in the middle of the night into your house a Jewish guy let's say comes into he GH fell in hard times and the bull came and killed him the dog came and killed him so you'd say what are you doing in my in my the sad is you have to kill the the bull you have to kill the dog what about the owner of course the owner is Potter he doesn't have to pay the the value of the person why do you say that they completely my Bo what were you doing there who told you to come to my house in the middle the night again not American law normal Common Sense law if you come into my house and there's an a wild animal there in my house that kills you it's your problem not mine so why in the world do you have to put the sh to death it's not fair you came into my house my my bull was protected he doesn't kill people but if you're GNA go into his pen in the middle of the night he might kill you so why is it his fault why do you kill him an animal that kills a human being put him to death that's it there's a family called and the goats will come into's property and eat up his vegetables and his grass and everything else tells his famous tal right the one that lost his memory he got sick and he forgot his to used to throughout always reminds him there's always back and forth between and so he says to [Music] tell I'm giving you a project now go make sure these goats don't come into my property why should I go if I do go I'm you should put up a fence says that's against the go the right fence you have goats make sure they don't come to my property why should I have to put up a fence says that didn't want to get into it he was too lazy so to speak he wanted to get out of it as re told him we if told us to do something we run and do had other things to do and he wanted to be so he told listen it's not going to work don't worry I'm not going to go there it doesn't make any sense they're not GNA listen says the let's say that it's the other guy's fault it's the fault of the of the goat owner how is it possible that there ever a goat in somebody else's property you have to make sure your goat is in a cage the goat got out it dug underneath the gate the fence fell down okay so in the terms of the owner of the go went out and then would if you're coming from going upwards and those who are going from making a the people going to write to me oh you made you made now going back these okay so rash explains that since people used to eat the meat as soon as as close as possible to the right otherwise that all will get ruined there's no freezer there's no whatever so they would keep them over there by the marketplace until Market Day came and then they would check but these goats are causing trouble now the m even if they let's say were they allowed to We Tell the owner two three times he if he listens he makes sure they don't cause damage great if the troublemakers so we say we're gonna right now earlier than the market day and take whatever you you're going to take a little bit of a loss that's because these animals are already ready to Beed a regular animal that's not my animal causes damage you can't sh it I want my animal I want my animal but he's going to be sh anyways when on Thursday right now it's Sunday Sunday is not a great day to sh because we'll barely have any any customers no so you take the loss says the mishna why does it say two or three yeah yeah I don't anytime the says that kind 4050 if it's 50 so you why 40 yeah says says sponsored by and in other words how does believe it or not many of you might have not known this A M A an animal that did the same damage three three times becomes a m do you know he could do chuva he could do chuva like human being can do chuva and he goes backwards becomes a top how do you do how does an animal do chuva like a person take some anger management classes and we we provoke him and we see if he doesn't do it great how many times how does it work the famous I mentioned in the beginning of the we're not going to go over it now but perhaps we can learn from this about if you say 90 times you have to say 90 times in one day three days he bases it on this m he tries to bring a ride from this m it has to be three separate days to be a m if a if a axe kills three animals in one day that's not enough it has to be three animals over a period of three days and had he become about he sees an Axe and he doesn't he doesn't Gore him he doesn't three times it could even be in one day three times in one day even when kids poke him and bother him you know people that have normal dogs normal dogs not like my but if you have a dog that's trained so a kid will go over it poke it in the eye and it won't do anything that's a a normal dog so this kind of bull kid goes pokes it even though it already killed three animals now it's Cal so once we see that's calm it's going to be Cal for other animals different D here we're talking about animals children okay but the idea is that he did tra you see that he he went anger management and now he reverts back to being a that if he does do damage he's only have a wonderful day G shabas good week if you're shabas 8:30 ra your oh we got to say we'll say [Music] together [Music] for markazi