Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 12 by R’ Eli Stefansky

live from Merchant one in Miami for coming thanks to all the guests uh tomorrow seems like the last and final sheer for me for a few months I'm gonna be back bem February time but Wednesday morning my wife surprised me with some tickets to Chicago back to Chicago before we start sheer let's start with we'll say it all together [Music] for she sponsored all the that were lost the 5,000 239 kidnapped people I think it just went down they just found a woman they thought she was kidnapped but I mean found her she's not alive um that's how bad the the bodies were burnt and just lot a lot of tire for the m so everybody should have a and we should see a g should come tomorrow or even tonight we'll accept him also a goodes um just before we start we have a very guest all the way two guest from Tor what's your name Charlie Salman Charlie Shell Shell Saltzman sh and Y feder so when I was in Toronto last time over a year ago I met yti in a shorts in the kitchen what what was his name our friend the AJ AJ oh he's wearing the whole merch beautiful that's old merch wow AJ Shore that's right he hosted us put up a big big SE over there and I spoke to you about joining the D you haven't missed the D since that day it was amazing R say here's some pictures you don't have to send me anymore these are pictures that I receiv received 30 to 40 maybe some of them even 50 different people sent them in so let me show you you don't have to send it to me anymore thank you very much this is this actually came with a little bit of a change it says I got it without that uh Heber but this is it makes it even that much better he's a guy doing the da inside a pit in Gaza this I received many many many times these are the in the parliament in Gaza and somebody put me in there then somebody even put this in there it might take you a few seconds to the joke I don't know if you remember that guy but he's the guy that that's a doctor that he's Rafa what guy he's the Hollywood guy he he had a baby he was injured he's just he happened to see missiles then he was crying then he was he died and now he's part of the shear here he is he's part of the shear no he's whatw plywood in plywood yeah yeah he's a big actor um this is a beautiful picture of a guy learning the da inside a tank it says after the Mitzvah of to demolish the terrorist we don't forget West hem has many groups that learn thei this is from Simi sugar did I pronounce it wow our gets together after each to celebrate accomplishments there are a few of us who are MD Wix and who learn with you I myself started with you B and was hooked with your overview there's another email that I might read today that also the guy started from Y A lot of people left the shear on y so there's two TP there's two groups those that stuck it out through and those that did it introduction the Balman Brothers I I don't don't don't boother you know I'm going to be skipping around there so not perfect that's not how he wrote it D has made a huge difference in my life I was more of a shabas learning with a group of friends more kibing than learning but at least it was something thought though is different it's commitment to learn every day usually early morning after show before work I start with the first and I've been your tal for nearly two years been live to sh MD ybs Chicago and possibly tonight in Miami which he is I love how you teach your energy how you keep it interesting the animations visual learning and overall this guy Remy is he's done Kaka that's it he's hooked for Life B taking future learning with the 3D maybe that's what he means I've also started with using the has changed me for the better a sense of purpose being a part of great and keeping me more focused then give with inspiration keep doing more enough about me attaches a picture from K and say from this past left to right I'm going to show you the picture so remember Alman he had the cake made me in the middle so you'll see simy in the middle Josh Felman and David baratz then logo was a great Added Touch we're all so excited each day looking forward to Mak with you wires in M Square Garden if it's big enough should give you the strength good health and focus to keep going every day mayal Simi sugar PS make sure to zoom in to see the mdy logo what do you think I am I take a picture and here it is re voice here's the picture of the cake and he wants me to zoom in to see the mdy logo that's how it is beautiful cake gra that doesn't matter what you guys ate it it's not meant to be it says on the ma of new Hamstead West Hamstead ARA I can't pronounce his name anybody mait something like that the daily learning chart is amazing since he's anonymous can you ask him can post the chart in the ND website and made available to download thank you that's the chart that we had yesterday the guy does so could you please put it on the site okay hi today you're pileg to get an email from Australia i' like to join the da don't worry I'm not expecting to receive a gamor I think we do send garas out there people think Australia is an island with a bunch of zombies having to no we have some very do Farish is there Yumi and uh Hill's brother what's his name I forgot his name already we have a bunch of people there there's big there ra a k have different communities you can feel attention of the war of Israel a pro Palestinian owned restaurant burnt down and they blamed it on the Jews for some odd reasoni what oh I'm going the wrong way twoyear anniversary rebell first of all I want to thank you for giving me the opportunity to learn da with you on 11:14 it will be two years I started learning the da titness with you and it's approximately 800 D and 12 later I never thought I could do it I haven't missed a day for the last two years most of the time I learn with you some myself I to do every morning my wife knows how important this to me every so often during the day I'm working and I think about the da he says you hear this he's thinking about the D middle of the day besides learning the G I've learned many things during the past few years that I never would have learned including the many different that we learn on a daily basis I also just finished my first year of doing still continue to do it every week two people that talk about I know he stress so my new goal this year is to do much as I can hopefully increase my learning at the same time I'm currently involved with the local chabas visit patients local hospital also three months ago I was certified as a chapain so I may be the first MD white chaplain I'm hop no no no no we have others people chaplain wrot already thank you again as you say it's not about the D it's about the Yi Jerry Isaac oh did I show the picture with your friends I didn't oh yeah I did okay you're right he forgot you didn't see the attached photos from Al celebration in Venice Italy we chose Venice because it a city where the first sh was printed featuring The that we currently have the as I reflect it's not fomo that I'm experienced for missing the significant Chas in the US but I now recognize it was a miscalculation on my part and I deeply regret not attending I've already began saving for the massive cruise in three plus years G rose so I have some news for I just spoke to the and they want to make another shabas in a year from now that's when we're going to finish here we're finishing Bama and and if you're new to the she you don't know there's noing during she you didn't know that ah okay because because 20,000 people gonna hear you it's not gonna die yeah no even in t to me and I'm Gonna Knock You down but whatever so this uh the shabas is amazing and we're looking forward maybe maybe we'll do another one do we have time for another no penny gild will do yours tomorrow for the unity of the month the month Grand second SP of the week Mark schwarzman for dear friend having surgery second my brother-in-law Rand the famous shom randf zik LEL and the Art of the mon sponsor supporting so just yesterday we had a little bit of a sh you see over here the it says in the we finished off quickly so we'll go back we're not going to go back to don't worry about it top of there's a comparison between a slave and a Cara real estate how much of a comparison is there so one thing's for sure you buy a slave the same way you buy a piece of real estate but what other things are they similar in so we had somewhat of we saw that not going to ask a question was a little bit uh didn't want to get into it and he kind of lied he said no no don't worry about it uh a slave is like like metalin you don't go if a if a yam somebody go a lot of money apparently pretty wealthy guy but he didn't have a lot of real estate he died and he left slaves over for his children not a poor not a poor guy he has slaves could the one that let money go after the slaves Orman held that slaves are like metalin they're movable objects yes they're similar to car away the way you buy them certainly but not not in general and therefore you cannot go after the for their slaves and in the name of said you could he didn't want he didn't want to get into the whole argument you try to avoid me I know you try to avoid me the two people came to to each one first guy walks into the r he tells him his whole story The R says you know you're 100% right he leaves the next guy comes in tells him this whole story the RO looks at him he says you know you're 100% right so the rabbits in she walks in after say I understand tell him he's 100% right you tell him he's 100% doesn't make any sense he looks at he says you know what you're 100% right because if it doesn't make a difference it doesn't make a difference let this guy think he's 100% right let this guy thing all everybody's right is it's very annoying when you tell your wife you know you're right you're right and all she realizes you're just messing with her they don't like that so that's in Auda like a guy came to toang of ketki he says uh what's your Me by ABD do you stand you sit he said my Min is like what my father did no what what did your father do he did exactly what his father did I don't want to get into an argument with you and start telling you yeah I'm a lak I sit and I see them all right they stand all the whatever don't don't worry about it it's it's Bader I call it good um this is a funny story actually the guy comes to rner he says I I need the r to sign on a on a document here that says that auma has the word situs you hear he's not listening already learnning okay listen this a so says give me the piece of paper he signed yeahum has the word and the guy went around and he got like another 100 they all sign the what was his he said like this if a human being could carry objects on his back and he has to wear tias so par that cannot carry anything not a lot of oil certainly he has to wear tizas well is 100% right what's you're not gonna have a par now anyway go let you think that has to we TI the bottom line is sometimes you have to be quiet and just pretend everything's good and go vter that's what happened you know you're right I'm not getting in dark says three lines from the top B there's a story that people were going after the they didn't have real estate but they had slaves and said it's fine that you could take from slave what does that mean to us that a slave is like slave and real estate is the same and the same thing said grab the slaves so didn't like it is of the opinion A Slave is like there's no such thing so he says Z you better give everything back you're dying you made a mistake in if you don't give it back I'm going to go and take your your Mansions your houses I'm going to just take it from you your sometimes you can take from a d right if he makes a real mistake that's not before you don't you don't take you don't take away but if it's if he made a mistake in a mishna everybody has to know a mishna what do you mean why should they have to give anything back you have first of all have they all say the opposite of we just said two stories one from we said from from that what they all hold that a slave is like k and you're you're arguing with everybody not to the point where you're going to be to come out of pocket what's it says very good it says in the it's and you're going to have a a bad eye to your brother you're not going to lend them money you see it says in the the is concerned it's like somebody just asked me like if you're allowed to give back brand for a loan so people are not going to give loans yeah you're right it's a good CH but says why would somebody want to give a loan right before when comes it's m Alan all loans are you borrow a million dollars you don't know what scent the Torah says you don't know so nobody's going to want to [Music] give it's a sin not to give alone invented a new thing called a this is what it looks like you write a littlear and basically you're giving it over to bzden it's as if it's already um paid it's already in the the hands of the Mala okay peasant does it for you so the says you need car to back up the loan and then it's K like you ready were with the loan so over here is a big problem this seems like what does not equal because you could do a pris on a k you cannot do pisal on a slave so they're not the same says ver you see from here a slave and K is not the same okay so now just going into some there's something called Kyan aav here it is yeah we learned it in K oh so if you purchase Cara you make a Kenyon on the Cara then you are all the things that are in the in the Cara like for instance I bought my Dr Ines from a couple that were so they sold it to me with all the furniture they asked for more money for the F so I didn't have to make a Kenyon and lift up every piece of furniture I bought the apartment it included that Kenyon included all the movable objects there's dishes we basically didn't do anything this apartment we didn't buy beds everything was there this is uh oh I didn't want to show this one but okay this is a bunch of stuff here this is one way you kind of he he's kind of together with mat he kind of a uh a little yard which is real estate and he was kind of the cat the oven everything that comes with it okay if a slave has metalin and you purchase the slave you don't acquire the metalin you don't acquire the cat that's on the slave so what do you see that a slave does not equal slave and two different perhaps we have if he sold him slaves and so he sold them a bunch of stuff how do you do a Kon in a slave just like you do on a let me see if I I have here this by the way is just another older thing this is Ked that car okay that was the older one this oh this I hope it's not too confusing this chart but there's different there's different options here if you purchase a piece of land you are kind of theal what if you purchase metal are you kind what if you purchase there different so here we go you made only on the slaves like so if you make aak on a slave you purchase the slave let's say with a star you don't get to to get the K you have to do another K in the k if you made a K in the that's the first one on the right what if you bought that's what we said if you the you automatically get all the movable objects but you it only works one way from to other things not from other things to what if you bought slaves and movable objects if you made on slaves oh so you see the second last one to the left you made a king in the slaves it's red you did not you weren't kind of the cat and now I'm gonna push this button over here and over now it says in other words that's what we're gonna have here is just in this case what could the answer be why does one say one say because if you view EV as a so you could be that's called but if you view a slave just Asin if I'm Co this it doesn't mean that I'm Co to this it's two separate things it's a contradiction it says if I make slaves I am I have a simple answer perhaps that's are slaves like that's the whole sh that we're asking today is a slave like a piece of real estate we know we had a POS all the way in the beginning that talks about I'm not going back I can't go back there but the the talks about a Cara talks about slave it seems like they're similar so you can say yeah this similar for some things not similar for all things I'll prove it to you A Slave could walk a car could can maybe there's a difference no you could so you could does what the class you could we don't have a clear Riot to anything maybe perhaps you say a slave is like according to everybody and then we have a problem oh you say that if you that that you could be that's perfect why because a slave is like Cara so if you purchase a slave it comes with all the movable objects we're gonna have a problem what's the problem that the says you need a slave that doesn't move what's the case of a slave that doesn't move going tie it up right since you guys all three of you from that one table remembered what does it look like in the picture lay you got the teddy bear you got the you see I'm trying to say that sometimes these pictures are babyish immature but you remember them irons with the chains there you go so says the gar this is a very fancy word it's it's it's designed to confuse everybody but all it means is movable objects is movable and nonmovable real estate and everything else possessions that don't have a guarantee in other words movable objects when you purchase real estate it comes with all the furniture and all the other stuff the refrigerator whatever the chairs everything nickname I do I purchase it I give money to buy the property it includes all the furniture typically speaking you have to do whatever you have to do now when you purchase real estate how do I know this listen to this gave his kids this is where we learned the whole concept of Kyan aav again what's Kyan aav I buy a piece of real estate aav how do you say agave in English the way by the way yeah on the on the way I I also acquire the movable objects I didn't oh that's too much for me too much I didn't do that's how you write it you don't talk like that you ever said that to somebody but thank you virtue oh by virtue of okay he gave his kids many gifts and listen to this one it should have said he gave them money gold and real estate that's not what it says he didn't it doesn't say the and it says with with him what is the word IM K he gave them real estate and through the real estate they acquired the MD otherwise it should just say what's him now there's a nice question here there there's two things that could have happened there maybe there were kind of maybe put all the jewelry in the real estate and when they were C in the real estate they acquired the jewelry that's called K it's different than K aav means by the way on the way virtue ofr concurrently so says something beautiful the only way K works is if you acquire the then you acquire something else so it's a two-step process it means simultaneously the only way you could do simultaneously is K KAG means I'm concurrently literally it it's simultaneously it happens I'm I'm I'm I'm acquiring this real estate and at the same moment I'm acquiring the the gold but K would have to work slightly different would have to be he they were and a second later through King they were kind of it's just a okay very interesting says a story few stories over there that because I think it's today is comes to they came to Alexander Alexander mdon says they said we want half of Israel of Israel half of Israel why because we're the son is is the son of ab he gave so we get half half and half interesting gamar not that they they claim the whole thing claim half so the gamar says there's a person by the name of look it up over there and he says listen I want to argue this if I win okay so I it's not me the toy one and if I lose you just say some loser he's not even part of Cl he doesn't represent us he didn't count let's let's let's let's send the real the big guns in there okay fine take a shot now it happens to me the gor brings a few stories that he want he's pretty good very good he comes in there and he says what are you arguing with you bring a ride from the T like what's your thing yes your T from your T it says in your T that yes is the son of a so we want have he says oh then if you're going by the to we Lear this week that it says that a call he gave him everything that's it says if you're going to go by the T you have to go all the way that's it they were quiet and they walked away so I thought I thought it's very to the that we have now in and what's going on over here F next so is just showing us that we don't have a forced proof when you have proof it has to be solid this is not solid why because I could dance on both I could say if I want I could tell you a that everybody holds a slave is like and I'm gon to go the opposite so I'm you're not forced in any direction you know what the slave is movable it makes a lot of sense the bright that says that when a slave holds mental in his hand there's zero kaga you know why because slave is not slave is doesn't have a and this that it says that a slave could be because he's wearing it he's wearing a necklace whatever he's doing he's wearing the the jacket so he's kind when it's on him so what the slave cannot be K why because he's a moving he's a walking [Music] so I guess Yoshi wanted to remember this forever so he made this chart for the enjoy this is a this time a beautiful he did but check this out I like this one it even has a little sign that says on it with the MD chair the bike left okay so walking does is not interesting how do you how is this thing right over here how is it relevant to us today a droney a car why are a car I have a moving car I'm driving down the street someone takes a a bag of Dunkin Donuts throws it into my car it's a moving yes or no the they talk about it I don't know what they say but I know that there's a big is a car a moving car is that a you have four walls sort of but it's a moving it's a moving okay a thing that I was thinking about bam gotta stick mus in once in a while that a person could also be bar it is a barous it could be a killing machine it could be a lot of things it could be a Su give be good things bad things but when a person when a person um wants to take inventory of himself some the person has to stop when you're moving you're moving you're you don't you can't it's not good when you're in the grind the day-to-day grind everybody like the 9 to five and get up and you go you don't have time to to what's the word I'm looking reflect reflect that's reflect that's the word I was looking for you have time to sit back and think for a second where am I what am I doing in my life how are things going great not where could I improve you're in this grind you're that's you're not kind of when you're when you're on the move so to speak you have to like stop think just take a minute to to reflect so you're going to say the slave is standing who said he's walking like this he's walking maybe he's standing still and therefore he could be kind anything that has the ability to move then even if he's standing there's no Ken says the here let me show you this the oh so here's the slave that's walking and here is CFOs this it I think this is slight slightly different he's but Kaos means he's tied down he's a slave he's similar to K but he's not going anywhere the whole problem is that he's a he's capable of walking he's not capable of walking he's tied Anda he's kind of he's kind of that teddy bear now what about animals that that whole I show you a chart with all the sheep and this and that the you bought a piece of real estate you're kind of animals aren't they aren't aren't they maybe that's a little bit uh further um he let me see because T over here brings down could be more to get later on yeah let's let's talk about it later on hopefully I remember fine so says what that he's holding on to these objects and he's tied down therefore [Music] he's what about we learned in that if you make a K on you are able to to acquire the slaves that doesn't work with what we just said we said a whole list that if you have K you do not acquire the slaves says because the slaves are inside the car so then you are kind says so you're telling me that the BR that says that it doesn't work that if you purchase real estate you don't acquire slaves must be that they're not in the car itself you bought a house but the slaves are outside somewhere in a different house that's great if slaves are like that's why whether this let's say this uh this computer is inside the house you're outside the house you're not a slave is like a computer he's a so if he's inside the house outside not what if you say that a slave has of real estate why in the world does slave have to be inside the house you should remember this from if you learn if I sold you 10 fields in 10 different countries I'll give you an example I remember the example then also what was the example there was I remember there was I I forgot where that chart was no but if a guy owns a franchise of hotels so he has a hotel in has a hotel in New York he has so he bought 10 pieces of land 10 10 pieces of real estate in 10 different countries or like fishal Klein took me on his boat last night was it last night and he showed me he told me the names I don't want to repeat names this is that from guy that he has house Mon and here's his house on Indian Island and here's this guy that has this his Jerry kushner's house and the people have a house here house there house here yeah there are people like that you don't have to come on to Crazy examples here in Miami is like that so if I purchase a whole franchise of hotels do I have to go to each hotel and make have to travel the world the answer is no I just have to change the lock on one hotel in Miami and all the 10 hotels around the world become mine interesting T is over here by the way there was a guy I said this story before because I don't like this guy at all he's a bad guy a guy made an announcement that all his fruit in his house because and you have to get rid of it you have to burd it he said my apartment with all the fruit is he comes this and changes the lock on the apartment it says you were the apartment with the fruit I'm C the apartment do something about it so he takes the best what do you do you have a m I was not joking I wanted to be Ming my fruit but I thought that everybody's gonna be normal about it and not not steal my apartment says no your M apartment he's your you said your he it's my apartment so there's an interesting T here all the way in the bottom four lines in the bottom says anyway Ty says based on this TS maybe I don't know if it's based on this but they said oback they said you know who heer but the guy on the first floor was KET as because the guy on the first floor owns everything above him the second floor is right in his property just what when they built it they get but once it became heer he was cing it basically there was a way to just brush him off and tell him you know go fight it's not your apartment it's the guy on the first floor and the guy on the first floor gives it back to him as a Matana but it's interesting because T says here there's no K you can't purchase a piece of property out of another piece of property if you buy the first floor you can't uh acquire the second floor as agav but you could acquire it as he says okay huh something like that not really but okay I hear what you're saying yeah all right at least is paying attention here my so where are we no so hear the question if a slave is a piece of real estate and I bought this real estate here in Miami so the slave he has in New York should be n automatically just just like I'm cing to this piece of K I'm cing to all my K around the world including the slaves that are like Kara why does a slave have to be on top of the Cara in the K so he explains them beautifully and you probably remember this answer from there as well so whoa let let me turn it around ask you a question and based on this question you'll have an answer to your question as well according to you that say you say that a slave is a movable object what so so what if it's why does he have to be inside the b b we already established that the the objects that are n with the don't have to be on the K it can be anywhere the K works even if it's somewhere else oh you have to say that there's difference between movable objects that move that run away a slave is a movable object that moves so even if you say that a slave is but it's a move it's a moving I do so that that was an interesting SP that we had over there in Kar says it here as well the Earth is all connected the entire Earth is connected so when I purchase the hotel here in Miami the hotel in is connected to it through the Earth so I make a king in there I make a king in there but a slave is not connected to the ground he is not that the question is what about an animal you telling me that when I when I'm k a i cannot be k something that moves all animals move so T makes a distinction yes they move but they don't have Das it's not moving it's it's not the point that they're moving the point is that it's it's an object that decides to move to different places on his own like a slave that's why he can't be C animals not like that fine says the it says in the mishna right we just had a new Mish test that if a person damages a an animal that's not owned by a private citizen he's and the Mish uses interesting if you damage an animal that doesn't have what does mean means the for you to benefit from an object owned by the if there's no then you're if there is then you wonders why do you have to say such an interesting just say if it's an animal owned by a private citizen you're not by pring your Potter what's this well there's there's a there's a there is a third category here there's something that does have in other words it's only by the let's say but you are not what's that so if you damage that kind of animal you would be what's a good example for that says interesting we're doing a little bit of Kum here not to be and scared it's stuff and easy but there's two things this all the major like are the lighter ones easy ones so what happens if you damage a that's 100% B mem Potter what if you damage an animal that's you take you it and you get to eat it the get to eat right so who owns it is it aem's it's yours it's private what is it so somewhere in between is considered that it's owned by the owner we're going to see soon it means before you it here so first of all we have this POS that we had the other day when your bull damages your friend's bull it has to be your friend not hashem's now this says we're talking about here a guy gave a uh how do you say collat I'm losing my language here how do you say called in English collateral okay collateral thought there a better one fine but it says there's something to do with Hashem here and it says in his friend so you see there's only one word in between on the one hand it's it's on the other hand it's his friends what's an object in this world that's a little bit of hashem's and a little bit of yours now don't be oh everything your not talking about when it comes tobas you have a carbon that's 100% And you have that's what say this talking about that you had a collateral that was Kum he gave you an animal that was already designated as a schl let's say as a p and you went and you lied and you said you don't know what happened to so you have to you have to you have to pay the whole thing so and it's considered owners fine we learned in you hear this a guy takes a piece of a carbon and tells a woman you see this pul over here it's mine does it work doesn't work why it's not his just said it is his it's it's considered his says when the animal's alive it's his and can be the woman with the whole animal over there we're talking about the animals already shed it's already was already so already got and now he takes that piece he says oh it's not yours we always have the shil right you go to a wedding could you take the meal at the wedding and that meal is it yours not yours it's yours to eat not not to do business with maybe I don't know over here it's a similar sh it's yours to eat yes you're allowed to eat it but it's not yours to sell it's not yours to to be woman with it to do business with it and has a better lotion than that you eating from table it's not yours yes he allows you to eat but it's not that that much yours not yours to the point where you could take it and bees a woman okay fine when it's dead we we agree that even basically says it's it's K it's not yours but when it's alive does he really argue and say it's yours so firstborn Animal by the way it's a big problem even today firstborn animal is has how do we get away how do we get around it how do we buy a steak in the store maybe we're buying a we're not allow to eat it what do they do what they do no how do you you hear this Remy how do you eat steak today maybe it's a maybe it's a f born animal no you have to count it make sure not count no that's that's something else that's Meer Myer's counting every 10 boom is a first born animal has it's right away it's I don't know it's right away oh you have to have a of a you have to make sure that the GU is a partner that's why if you have a whatever it is I'm sure they do something about it anyway you gave No I gave the the M kuna M kuna is every animal that you sh you take the the jaw and the C someone stomach and the sh a little bit of the this you give it to the they do it you give it to the Bas also that's something else we just confused three things together you see what's going on here we just confused the B with Myer and Mata it's all good that's why because we live in this world in America we have no clue it's flying we don't live we don't know seriously we don't we don't live it it's not important to us we're not Farmers we don't she we don't care we just go to the story get a pound of meat Andel they used to live it like everybody had a couple of sheep and C this firstborn you had to know this is the first this is the you have to give it to the C take it and give it to the C and if it's a m what do you do with it doesn't have a m it's a whole what about in America is the in America the could sell the when he's without a when he's alive and if he has a let's say his ear you know today they pierce the ears and they put a number over there that's a mum what do you do you not let do it on purpose you do it as is right because all the K want to do it so they don't have to bring it to the B English they can eat it like that so if it's you could sell it even if it's it's yours to give it to a woman so he says that's only in our days why we don't have don't they you could put it on the it's not yours it's not yours to give to B that it's yours oh it's yours that's only talking about when the is in in America if animals if if means it's not the best thing to do but if somehow an animal showed up from America then you put it on the shouldn't but according to that it's yours you can do whatever you want with it that's the's Point wants to say really say that when it's alive it's yours and right just like uh something else answer not everybody ages with and then basically says it's yours say it's not yours talking about is one of the 24 gifts that gets that he's entitled to that's different of of Kun is not the C's ever it's he's has the the option of eating it but it's not his Hashem says you could eat it but not yours to do business with raai have a wonderful day for coming tomorrow is the last day o'