Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 103 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning ra [Music] boys I have to tell you 10 Israelis make a much better ah than 50 Americans okay today good yeah come sit sit who's in America Ai and no I don't know is not feeling so well Bo say it's great to be back for the wishes for uh Missing me I missed you here we go this is in a random show somewhere I don't even know where this is but two people learning the da so yesterday I realized that it's it's on smartphones but in America it's pader you know it goes over here in you'll never see somebody like this with a smartphone I mean barab him Donnie find sent me this picture I think Donnie saw this on something on a where is this Bou in the five towns here's another Tesla but this is shitsky writes that by his son in the hotel if you take a look at the shampoo the the brand name is [Music] a and here's he sent me a video of yidi luz's brother um and this is what yidi lit's brother has to say we'll put on the volume here your brother I learn every day said what do you mean he says since you brought pass away I was aware I never heard from L then I mean like two years ago and I was aware about it and since then I started learning and I never missed a day say I want to thank you I was very strange to guda before never learned anything but I got very moved and I got hooked on Rebellion rest thank you so much hi rebell I'm a fan of viewers one of many that gives Anish in the kenberg sh Lakewood there are few times that sheer members ask if I would be able to show diagrams simar to what you show on your she the she I'll be giving today T is particularly important as we'll be learning a bit about is there a way they can share the PDFs that you work so hard to prepare while you're alive how bad would that be thanks Rosenberg all the best Rosen so I don't know exactly how it's done I know that there's Shalom so let's say hello to the guest what's your name not a guest but what's your name Vineyard oh M getting older where you from Toronto Toronto galic isn't the doctor here oh the doctor from Toronto very nice also not guest um yes so oh we were talking about the PDFs you say what on the app the app I think the app was the app up and running in bras so all the PDFs should be on the app where else can you get it that's that's the best way on the app the mdy app the co of the month none sponsor for the unity [Music] of it's a whole month that the entire on the birth ofia Ruth her name is sopia like to Vision Rose Sophia Rose Sophia Rose Ruth I don't know about the Ruth part say [Music] isand in memory ofand would be commemorating in honor of it says I am O Okay in honor of no not in honor of in memory in memory of a who would be commemorating short you want me to say this he would no not anymore not up there okay who do we Comming Chuck Jagger's birthday today that was huh that was ABI okay that was Obi he would also say that he loves soup okay David fineberg shim day one listen to this D fireberg is here today day 1, 151 of doing the D since BR D B in honor of 1500 days since br couple Ben wow did anybody know that 1,500 days it's insane unbelievable huh no that's when you say double 1500 days ago we moved into this Bas Med 1500 days ago there wasn't no bookcases there's no lights no windows there's no windows they had huh floors we didn't have a floor no I don't remember what we had we had we had um we had like these um what do they call them those projectors that gave very poor lighting had a big sign behind the ma the we had a iPhone on the table taking the shear so when somebody moved it it was on a plastic table so when somebody put their hand down the whole thing started shaking the fourth sponsor for today by mayor DJ Taki who's over here Yosi schlomo Danel Yona Andi in honor of the birth of a girl to M and shf know he's here last night with his father may they be to raise her and all their children to life of now I have one a here I hate to say this Taki you're here but if mayor DJ Taki Yosi schlomo danil yon Andi get together to sponsor it should be for a whole month what a bunch of cheap skates each guy chipped in$ three and half dollars Taki what is going on with you of the month Anonymous for the child his daughter healthy baby now that guy that sent me an email you don't have to send about that that's fine it's only 17 days and I realized I saw that they ordered very few garas maybe like 400 garas so I called N I said Nel em a story called him last night at 12:00 I said what's going on here said we don't have money this I said no no no no matter what we need at least a thousand people to join B right what kind of business is this he's going to drop the ball on us what boys if anybody wants to step up I don't know he didn't he didn't answer me I wrote him I asked him the question today if somebody sponsors like $5,000 or so we could put your name in the front of the gar I don't think it's too late I know they ordered already is it too late to might know one or more but when will it come do it today I know and especially if you had trauma not let's get these people out of the traum let's do a you'll be the sponsor we got to get a thousand people to join B huh people are here ready I know but they they could help other people join all right R we're holding all the way on the bottom of B we had a story like 10 lines from the bottom we're not going to start there I'll just say B if somebody buys real estate from somebody else and he feels like he has to use somebody else's name in the contract if he uses you know he writes down Trump in there be mared nobody's going to bother him the the the head of the whatever it is the r Gala somebody really that I'm not saying that he's but somebody important that nobody's going to start up nobody's going to be on the field or whatever it is yusa this that there shouldn't be any fights he goes he makes him a little bit of a boo boo he put somebody else's name in there he figures if he put somebody else's name it'll help him out then he has K he wants it on his name he wants to give it over shami talking about sh and the baby last night he told me aa you could stick it in over here so I don't forget he he knows somebody from work that he was having some issue with the real estate I don't know tax I don't know what it was so he put his own property bought a house he bought he asked his father you can put on his name says sure help out the son and then they both were nter the father and the son were nter and the other Sons want the house now the grandchildren they're saying it's our father's house he just put it on zade's name cuz he had some issue technical issue it's not zade's house he said no it's on his name we're going to take it we want it so now this guy realizes it's not good not so good to have the R's name so he wants he wants to change the name so it says like this alling by the three lines from the bottom but if the guy comes along and says I'm buying this field I'm buying this real estate on condition that Donald Trump changes his name eventually I'm gonna write now Donald Trump Donald Trump has no clue he's over there in New York somewhere I'm gonna write Donald Trump people see Donald Trump they'll be they'll run away but in a month from now I want you to write me a Newar that says Ellie on it okay then we go to Donald Trump we say listen Donald got a problem you uh you you appear as the owner Ines on a piece of property we need you to switch your name why should he do it what kind of is this you're making me sign like who I don't know I don't know who you are why you why you why should I get involved there besides I'm the type of person I never sell any real estate right people that are extremely wealthy they don't like to sell I have uh I told you about this guy unfortunately partnered up with a guy a billionaire doesn't want to sell I have nowhere I can't go I can't move forward stuck we I don't sell it's a buer for me to sell not that he said that but that's that's what so much money why do I need to sell I just hold on to a fav the uh I think it's a medish this is the guy if not it's a great story was walking down the street I seeing like a must saer I don't know I don't know what somebody will write in a guy was walking down the street in the middle of the night come the police and they grab him they start beating him up so what are you doing here you probably tried to steal so he starts screaming leave me alone I'm the king's cousin what are you doing so they they they stop beating him up said okay we're going to find out if we find out you're not so the next morning they bring him into the king King he said your majesty you recognize this guy he says no remind me how we related the guy says listen we're not related but these guys were beating me up the only way out of it was to say that I'm related to you and they stopped pitting me so the king said oh you're using my name to to save you okay that let leave him alone that's it's already it's a it's a cover for me where else this guy is using the king's name he's the for his for his sake some times yeah sometimes it's uh sometimes but you know what don't force me to come now to to court and start signing documents that not I'm just saying why would a person do it sometimes a person does it for for so what's in this in this we had it was it was a very hard sentence to the beginning all the the beginning somebody buys a field with somebody else's name we don't force the guy but if he says Al Manas then we force him but the says why should we force somebody that's not even involved in the sale right we don't force Theos we don't force Donald Trump to do anything we're talking about the seller should he write another document let's say to We Don't Force the seller to write another document that makes sense why should the Celler write another you lied to the seller the seller thought he's selling it to Donald and now you're coming to him a week later say no no it's really me that's it I don't I didn't get paid for this you bought it for me I did my job but if he made a condition with him I'm an ask you should know I'm writing now Donald tomorrow I'm gonna come to you and we're going to write another star yes no that's also no at all why would I think that he has to do that has to write another if he already wrote AAR you should have known there certain understanding over here why am I writing somebody else's name here I'm just doing some sort of trick I'm trying to save my property I don't want other people to come and and take it from me so I wrote a very a very famous name in there or something you know that I'm just I'm not throwing away money you know that I didn't buy it for the I bought it for myself you see I'm struggling here to get a mortgage and this and that what do you think I wrote to's name to save me you should have understood this I thought I was sure that you understand what's going on you're going to write me another no yeah yeah I saw something fishy going on here I thought you're doing a deal with Donald you're going to go to Donald at you're not going to come to me I'm not to write to you write you another I did what I had to do I don't need to understand all your sck and what you what you meant to do what you you didn't speak it out I don't have to do it again but if he specified I could also say a bu your field on condition they do 25 jumping jacks I'm allowed to make any condition I want so if I made a condition that you're going to write me another star of course you have to write another star what's the he didn't really specify it what he did was he said in front of the you should know like sort of I'm telling you right now we're signing a document now we're signing a deed in a week from now I'm coming back to you guys we're going to write another one say now he he didn't really explain who he didn't say who he says I need another star from who from Donald or from the seller the the seller could say oh I didn't understand I thought you meant that Donald is goingon to write another no that's why I Was Myself and I said in front of you in front of the witnesses you know I want to write thear from you Bo that's of the moving on to the next says interesting story raah gave $1,000 to the flax guy here take a bunch of money for pish and he didn't pick it up he didn't take it he left it by the guy he's the dealer when I need it I'll come take it we're going to see exactly what the story was why did he do it and how he did it the price of the pon the flax went up so this guy was look look he's a pretty decent guy he's a nice guy he wanted rafah to make a nice a nice amount here was let's say doubled in prize the says he sold it all he sold the the flags what kind of problem could this be bo what kind of issue is this who who said why is the riv he put in $11,000 and the guy's giving him $22,000 he never picked up his Flags garnished huh ex even I don't know I'm saying what I'm asking what could the problem be you're saying it's not a problem Rivers did he make a Kenyon here did he not make a Kenyon it already exists but he didn't make did he did he did he do M on it did he do what did he do here yeah okay so let's see what the problem is first all there's another PR nobody said this one how did the guy have the right to sell it he didn't call him up say Hey you can make maybe the guy doesn't want me to maybe doesn't want it to be sold maybe ra wants the the P A guy comes to the the marketplace he comes a couple of hours earlier than every body else you know one of these guys when I was a caterer there's like always like one or two people they show up like an hour before the wedding sh here I am and they like right was the food is not starting it's always like you know like a real some has a lot of time on his hand the guy shows up to the to the to the marketplace he looks around nobody's there and to his luck it start tremendous snow storm tremendous and what happens is all the guys the horses and Buggies they can't they can't show up he's the only guy there with with a lot of merchandise but the buyer start rolling in and he's the only guy there with the big buggy he thought he's going to make 10,000 Ruble comes the guy says listen I see there's nothing going on there I I'll offer you 15,000 Ruble for your stuff see what's going on he says no no no no deal comes another guy I'll give you 20 30 he's flying he's like wow unbelievable prophet kider he says you know what I'm going to wait till tomorrow next day somebody comes and offers him 40 50 garnished he's not he says you know if it's going like this can you imagine tomorrow 100,000 kids he goes to sleep wakes up in the morning and there's hardly any snow left it starts started to melt and sure enough as the marketpl is come in all of a sudden the the horses and Buggies start pulling in one after another so he goes the guy knew you want 50 no no no no no 40 30 nobody wants his stuff even that's it he's left with go garish the garnishment n what's the N the N is that we right now we're in a very big snowstorm this is our time is coming up most of theas they're up there they're not capping anything whatever they did they did we're in a snowstorm in a snowstorm was tremendous Prophet Mish doubled he sold it off has a big problem on his hands could he take the prophet or not what should I do could I take the money can I take my big profit it depends says ra it depends when they sold it they announced I'm selling raf's Pon I'm selling his flax okay so the guy that bought it knows that it's for ra so the money was given basically for rafah he was just the the between the goto guy the in between guy but if they don't announce it you're not allowed to take the money oh so is going to go into this now what's going on here what's the problem so yesterday we learned about Mo we saw fromel that the seller needs to know who he's who he's giving the who's who's who's about D over here so who told who told him who to do the keny to so now is that what RAV meant that they need to know exactly who it's going to ra didn't want to do business ra didn't want to give four to take eight he wasn't trying to do a ribus deal here he wanted the flex and it went up in price Anyway by itself M the guy that sold it had no right to sell it he's a gin now even though he meant the for the right thing what what oh let's see we'll see so maybe he did I don't know but at this point the guy took the money for raana this understanding he's going to give him this pishon in fact he he even called him up he said listen I made a deal for you but in terms of he did the wrong thing yeah he was trying to do the right thing but he shouldn't have sold it without his permission so if he's Ain what do Ain whatever was wor worth at the time of the sale how much was it worth in the time of sale double the price he sold it at a profit meaning he has to pay so all he's doing is the guy that sold the flax is just paying ra back what he deserves it's not a wasn't a a loan and then he paid him double for the loan he's just giving him the money he received for the the pishon says I'll explain to you what's going on oh somebody just wrote to me an email that he did a a search and it comes up like 5 600 times the word alone how much 62 612 one less 613 that's what he wrote ah 612 it's a tremendous amount of times that you should have Ari you know arry no I'm saying like you know you know so many you should have noticed this that it's not am I right that it's not doesn't come up in another it's just interesting that it's here all the time I'm read they said you see what it says here so Amon is a new word for us Amon means that rafah gave him money before he even had any merchandise the guy didn't have any pishon he's a pishon he's a flax dealer right now he didn't have one piece of flax in his inventory RAF gave him money he gave him $1,000 he said every month give me I don't know $80 worth of pishon whatever it comes out gave $1,200 every month give me $120 worth of pishon for the price that piton is today so you go to the market how much for 120 bucks you get a pound of pishon okay you get a box of pishon so that's what I want now if the price goes up the price is locked in so the the seller the seller doesn't care why because this the buy the guy that sells it to ra doesn't care he gets us $1,200 today he could go today to the market and buy $1,200 worth of pitone and give to ra when he wants or he could decide I'm going to take the money and and put in the stock market I'm I'm going to make a fortune he knows that right before PES the prices shwed up to the sky you know he doesn't care every month he's going to give him the same amount of pishon for the locked in price of today oh now the question is when that month comes that the pishon goes triples in price does he have the option to give him a box of pyton for the for the Triple price or what if he doesn't want to give him P give him I'll give him money I'll give him cash instead of 120 bucks I'll give you 360 three times the cash says I could give a person money today it's not ribus I'm giving him today it's his option to buy it all today if he wants he could save the money put in the bank account and lose money and then buy it at the higher price and give me that that amount tomorrow that I could do as long as he gives me pay is of the opinion that he cannot give him the money instead of the fruit says if nobody announced your name then it's an it's you gave those trust here you gave the money up front right that's what happened ra of gives the the seller money up front comes a seller and says I want to give you double the cash instead of giving you pishon I want to give you double cash RAV says he can't do that however if there was a sale says RAV if you actually sold Ra's piston you're not giving him cash because he didn't buy the flags you're giving him cash because he took the flax and you sold it to somebody else for the other price and you announced it you said this is rahana's flax I'm selling to you and the money goes from you to ra I'm just the intermediary what's the word whatever something like that okay you you're the between I'm the agent I'm taking money from you and I'm giving it to rafah so that's not rivus yes it's double the price but I I made a sale for raana I sold it to but that's only if I mention and I say not because of the gar that we had yesterday that the the seller has to know who he's selling it to Etc over here it's because otherwise it's an AM and am ra says you know how to take money instead of you're not allow to return money a higher amount than what you received in money but if you make a sale you could receive that extra money says the sponsored byen a tremend and somebody steals a PR right so that's the minimum and he swore that he didn't steal so here's the it says we're going to see we're going to see the full pu later but right now what's important is more the guzzle part a person Steals and he denies it and he swears falsely so there are three steps he has to take if he swears falsely if he doesn't swear falsely he returns it but if he swears falsely they never stole it so what does he do number one is you have to return the principal number two the you have to add a fifth so if he stole $100 he has to add $25 which we call a quarter but when you have a do25 then the quarter becomes a fifth so he adds a fifth and in addition to that you have to bring a carbon oh so if he has to return this money he has to go all the way to mod to to pay him back by the way mod is mdy in case he yes you have to go all the way to the end of the world in order to pay back the the famous M with he he he came from Europe he used to come all the time from Europe to the United States everybody knows there was in the United States when the war broke out and he chose to go back and he died K he wanted to be with his but you can imagine going from Europe to United States not oh I sat in the middle seat and Coach neb you have to take a bunch of trains until you get to the port in the port you take the the ship all the way to this another two three weeks on the ocean kid you get there right you know what I'm talking about it's it's no not a cruise bus fire Cruise you're talking about a wooden boat something ker he gets to to America and it's not going well so what is tell me says listen there's a guy here that owns textile the largest textile company but there's good news and bad news the bad news is that nobody's ever seen a dollar from this guy stingiest guy in town no no what else what else could be wrong he says oh and the other thing is that he used to be from he's now he's Loy he's off to D what could be the good news so the good news is that he he learned with you in the same class back in Europe oh says okay I need to go see this guy so he goes he goes to the guy heing with himoing smoing finally gu says no what are you doing here why are you in America says why I'm in America don't laugh at me but laa my button for my K keeps on popping off and I went to a bunch of guys in in in Europe and they put it back on you know the wind the this it pops off all the time so I came here to so I heard that you have an unbelievable textile company maybe one of your guys could so back on he says no no no seriously I'm serious I came from Europe says what you went four weeks on the ocean this no I'm not muga tell me why you came here he says oh you don't understand why he came here for a button but you came to this world for you came all the way from there for nothing how do you explain that oh then kid nine months later he [Laughter] camea and he donated to mdy anyways now in order to be y you're not allowed to give it to the kid maybe if the kid gives it to the father you'll be but at that point when you give it to the the guy's son you're not now doesn't mean you have to that you have to understand somebody asked me last night and I wasn't clar about it but now because he asked me doesn't mean his you could give it to it means don't give it to a guy hey give it to him like un unofficial will see more of it this is a special this won't make sense on its own I could give it to bz but the guy lives in Africa what do you mean give it to bz but bz you can give to and if the guy that was stolen from dies give it back to his all the m is saying now is the main thing is the K we don't care about the you have to travel really far is for the for the principal so if he paid back the k didn't pay back Toth or he was so once he's the principal I don't have to travel but he wasn't that's not important if he both on the principal on the but he left three cents that's not important have to go to the principal are very important so if you paid back not the principle he left the full there by okay what if he paid back the $100 but not the 25 sponsored by G ha for success and sa return of all the hostages and so the fifth is 25 and he lied about the 25 he swore the second first is I didn't I didn't steal the 100 and then he wants to do cha he pays 125 but he didn't pay 125 he only paid 100 now he does he feels bad he has to pay 25 it hurts him why should I pay this I swear I paid you he makes a so he has to pay a quarter of the quarter 6.25 and then he swore that he even paid the 6.25 and he didn't that's a third so has to pay 1.56 theit he keeps on paying a Fifth Fifth until whatever the 1.56 is less than a then he has then then he doesn't have to do that anymore because the say becomes the principle so now since the principle since the is a principle now you have to travel to M for the 25 before the Mish says you don't have to travel anywhere for the 25 it's just the it's just the 25% I don't have to but once you swear on it now the becomes a principle and for that you have to travel now it doesn't have to be AA it could be he gave it to you to begin with as collateral even for aone is aone if you swear on any money even if it came to you legitimately it came to you he gave you a loan you lie you swear on a loan pay a fifth here you you stumbled on a in the Middle Street you found somebody's glasses you swear that you didn't find it all these things you always pay the principle plus a fifth you have to bring a carbon even if it came to you through aone through whatever it is says the it seems like the only time you travel all the way to the end of the world is it's if you made a it's based on the but if he didn't swear to him you don't have to travel all the way to who does our go according to doesn't go here you go RAB Bo beautiful picture guy's on a plane and he uh oh he decided to steal whiskey from uh what's it called the luggage compartment on top has no idea who he stole from now he tries to he drank it now he tries to return it and uh everybody says it's mine something like this I guess I don't know he stole he doesn't know from who right say there's a there's a p pocketer the side of the P Pocket a woman stole her purse steals her her wallet or whatever comes home and he notices that his cell phone is gone so he calls up his cell phone and this woman picks up says hello can I help you she says yeah I'm I'm missing my cell phone so she says yeah and I'm missing my uh my wallet she say what do you mean she say yeah you were pickpocket me I pickpocket you she like wow not bad not bad good job says I need my phone back I need my wallet back gets there they meet up of course they get married and uh nine months later they had a baby boy this baby boy is born with a M he's like this m like this so they bring him to the doctors they try to pull his fingers AP garnish so they bring him to the r and the r says what what's what's going on that's that what do you guys do she said I'm a pick pocket her he says I'm a pick pocket her ah okay I have he says give me your necklace so she gives him she gives the rub the necklace and the r takes the necklace and goes to the baby he goes like this all of a sudden the baby opens up his hand and inside the hand was the Ring of the lady that burden that was the problem the M us how do you say it nobody so last night last night I said the story D was on the floor I said watch I'm going to say the story in English not a single person is going to laugh thank you from the time because how do you say I don't even know how to say me in English that's the problem oh so he opened up his hand and all of a sudden the Ring of the Midwife was inside the hand so I'm not a after all see I'm not a oh fine where are we all he's a big G he doesn't know from who he stole knows what Y is gonna do here he'll just take out the Laughing part he puts down the bottle of whiskey and runs away it's a big says says that all you need to do is put it down and run like has to pay a bottle of whiskey to each and every person says the our that says that if he swore falsely has to go all the way to according to even though that he swore yeah even if he swore he doesn't have to go to m he can just put it down and go away says forget about it's not even talking about it's talking about with you still have to pay this is how you get out of this how you so I just want to point out that this whole until the top of tomorrow's you know seven lines it's showing us how thear goes back and forth how does go now if it was would say like this our Mish goes according to and it's talking about this in this case like explains no the is taking us in Journey on a journey to see it cannot Bea it cannot be raran it can't it has to be this has to be that it goes back and forth It's a whole here it is when does say have to pay a bottle of of whiskey to each and every single guy it's when only you're right it's talking about in Cas so our mishna does go Accord to if you swear falsely then you go to m if you swear falsely you have to pay and you don't know what it is you have to pay each and every guy where did get this idea from when he swears falsely he has to give it to him when yeah you're right even though he swore of nevertheless said you don't have to you don't have to give each and every person you just put it down and you run the by the way it doesn't really mean you put it down and you run soash points out you give it to the bezan and bz takes care of it who somebody has to prove it's not literally put it down and they start fighting it that's not he's not going to be like that give to bz give toz and and uh until they could prove who they are and how they how if they're really the person the Belzer told me that he he found 250 shekele in a store so I guess it was folded so he decided he's going to return it so he goes did anybody lose money and they're looking at him and they could see it's 200 she so five people said yeah we lost money that's what he said five people he says how much he says come here how much 200 200 they all said 200 okay forget it you know you have to you have to prove you have to you can't just say oh yeah yeah sh it's me I I you stole it from me doesn't work like that you have to prove to bz and then you can take it says look I'll prove it to you Karen imagine somebody stole something from somebody n Ro he's now in America so now he has to take a flight you know how much flights cost now to go to America especially if you find out a half hour before you're leaving it's like coach is like thousands of dollars one way I mean I felt like an idiot the guy sitting next to me paid $3,000 less than me and I wasn't sitt I was not sitting in business and it was one way one way not going to tell you how much I paid for one way I want to get to this KES he booked two weeks ago but I'm saying there's no there's both of my flights one seat left that's what they told me one seat left there whatever is raking it in right now B they're going to put our Shear on there all this money they're making they don't know about it but they should so they made it to that if it's so much money to go from America and you only stole $15 they're not going to make you pay $3,000 to to come pay pay back so what do you do you bring it to bzden and you bring it carbon and that's it that's great if I know exactly who it is that's just it's hard for me to get there it's very expensive okay give it back to the owner how through bezin you put in bezin somehow I don't know how bezin contacts that person or if somebody's missing something they go to bzen hey bzen do you have anything did anybody ever return anything to me you know they have those organiz like these things you go in America uh you know missing money I forgot what it's called like you just call hey by the way does the government owe me any money no okay and then they okay whatever different different time I go him but in this case where there's five people or more he doesn't know he stole from at the end of the day donor is not getting his thing back for him this we're not going to we're not going to make a special so we're talking about that there was he swore yeah we said according to must be that he swore and that's why he pays each and every one a different story this is a story of somebody that took it with permission so I'm think a great example would be a esrig in the esrig marketplace right there there's 100 tables there you tell the guy hey can I can I can I show this s to my Rabbi here he's right over there five minutes later you come back now you're confused I take it from you from him does this es look for yeah yeah it's my es give it to me you go to the next guy no but I think it's him everybody says yeah it's de as now what do you do you didn't steal it you had permission to take it you took it my father always says this it's yish you have to know yish he says uh once told I didn't steal it I took it so it's a big difference not him over here it is a big difference he had permission to take it so in that case even agrees he puts down the in the middle and walks away so according to rash he gives it to bz the money the money yeah the may but whoever it is has to prove it so where is the is when he stole what are we talking about a case in both cases have to be similar only when he swore do we have whether you could put it down in the middle so look at this even when it came to when he took aone but if he swore falsely even on something like a something like a loone so even if he swore falsely when he took the ESG he took es the guy said you could take it to the rabbi and he swears falsely says he says on this he holds whatever he has to hold and he says I never took a as so in that case he has to pay an AS Plus a fifth plus a carbon even though he got it with permission in that case there shouldn't be any enough Comm between and rean why he he took it Bish so how can you say we're talking about a story with remembers who is huh does anybody remember where we had a story in this I said then it's huh I don't know what D what was the story [Music] I'm going to show you I'll show you the picture then you here you go that he was very sick and they came came to visit him and he had a a goat tied to his bed and they ran away they said he can't be he can't be he's not righteous because he has a goat who has a goat and there just and turns out it's Ruda yeah who yeah we spoke about when we saw that there's a that he took it with permission but he forgot who he took it from yeah sometimes you go to a diamond store you say hey can I see this piece of jewelry I'll bring it to my wife then you forget who it is a lot of money and comes to the is you take the jewelry you put it between the two stores and you walk away or according to Rashi give it to the Bez same story right now you telling me the of the whole is we're talking about how could what happened he swore falsely that's why that's why you have to pay each and every person and you have to bring a carbon and a and everything why so what's maybe when he was younger he did something wrong and later on he became a you see from here that a person could be a big not a today a one of the highest levels right even if he was once upon a time it's not everybody can do Tru and become that can't be that when he was younger he was not a and later on in his life he became a so it is talking about that he made a anyway I'm thinking to myself right now I just thought about this why would we say when he was a young kid when he wasn't okay fine but anyway let's say that's the story we know for a fact that they were both they they they were born righteous and this story right over here I believe was we said right then we Pro that was from the mishna the famous from the all right so now we're going through the steps here we just try to prove that R it's not R maybe it's R tomorrow we're going to see that's both r when he swears falsely he has to pay each and every person talking about and you have to give him there's no way out of it you have to give it to him now you don't know who him is you have to give teach and everyone you have to even go all the way to M if even though you didn't swear since you don't know know who it is fine we'll stop right over here have a wonderful day for coming out tell your friends and I'm here I'm back and tell your friends about B oh should we do shales let's do [Music] shales