Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 10 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning we're gonna start over the for those who need a lot of um over shabas my son's principal from teram K his first cousin was killed in action um like a 39y old they had a whole group of older they went into a house that was booby an apartment that was booby TR and I think four of them were killed instantly I think we had five casualties over shabas unfortunately so for we're ding for all those who are injured and of course for the kidnapped kids women adults we could say it together say [Music] for thank you very much again to the Saka family for hosting us welcome to all the guests there some people that have never been to the share before so what we do is we start off I I receive numerous emails every day and I pick some of the ones that I like and I read them off first of all to get to know different people from around the world and also to give us and inspiration some of them so here's the first one dear rebell I'm not sure if women write you emails or not I'm going to write it anyways first of all I would like to thank you for an amazing spiritually uplifting chabas of AK so want to share a story of AK of MD I really want to get away for shabas was telling my husband that this shabas would be a win-win for both of us I get to go away for chabas while also getting to see your mdy family in action my husband told me that with a pending saav sh we cannot afford to go away T is when they call you up for the Army to to come serve now this pending T if you're a certain age you don't really get it right away say his chance that his income would dry up any day it's unbelievable not only they go to war but they lose their income while is very by the way you could do a on vehicles so the Israeli Army says I want all these ambulances so they told like and we need all your ambulances we need all your trucks they go to people you have this kind of um Machinery whatever we're taking it we need it for the war effort that's it's not only on human beings but it's also on Caleb as well the the Wednesday before shabas my husband went to a family affair when he came home he says we can pack as we'll be going to the chabas when I asked him what made him change his mind and he said that another family member from mdy was also at this Sim and he not only offered to pay he made him make the reservation on the spot for both of us and our son as well I was and still am moved beyond words how someone that their only connection she wrote family but she meant mdy family their only connection is through mdy would do this for us my husband will be leaving I'm ding that should come before he has to leave thank you I'm purposely Anonymous I did not tell my husband about this email so once once again o I left in the email by mistake maybe we'll have to erase it but it's something about gifts so if anybody wants to buy a gift okay usually take those out um the that we had over shabas not just the and just the between different members people that wanted to come like the K guy that wanted to come and he wrote me an email literally Thursday night and by B shab he was already there just people stepped up and donated money donated time was unbelievable dear Bell thank you so much for making us able to host this lunchtime learning program using the amazing we are a group of 25 Boys in high school in London now learning every lunch and unfortunately we do not have enough sponsors for the food and drink we are providing a small reward for incredible amount of learning this is this is the poster we made to get the boys to sign up and some pictures of us learning thank you organizers mik Sheriff sinceer since unbelievable young kids learning more to during the day this reab I thought was very interesting I was after she here yesterday what time was she over three-ish went home I had to start preparing for M shabas sitting on the balcony and all of a sudden this is what passed by what you're hearing the music is from this boat check this out oh you can't hear it [Music] Israeli flag two from guys A1 and5 million dollar boat that only could sit like three four people but it's a beautiful boat and they were singing anyways it's beautiful my name is Max I am a myology andology fellow at John Hopkins in Baltimore two years ago I didn't own a book with a Hebrew letter in it I didn't own a keepa or a mza I hadn't been to in over 10 years this past month I made a on traed K by learning with your and reviewing with my R RAB Schwarz want to thank Morty wein Schneider who I met in Miami for encouraging me to learn the da this reminds me of a story that happened to me today in Miami in a gentleman comes over to me Two Gentlemen came over to me and one of them said there's somebody in this room in KES that wasn't religious for many years and he was doing the da and he asked him why are you doing the daff if you're not religious he says I do the da he says today he's a sh shabas and the D brought him back so I said is it you he said no it's not me so I I looked at the other guy he says sh I do the da every day so I fig so then I asked the guy that told me the story I said do I I have to look around the room to find this guy he said I don't think so I think you already met him and uh it was a big for me that this guy wasn't religious and he was doing the da is amazing not the first time I heard the story but anyway here's a person he wants to thank Morty wine where I met in Miami another Miami story for encouraging me to learn the da we met after daving M and he offered me to give me a ride home to my hotel he found out I was starting dating that week and he told me that he's also looking for sh he told me that kki said as for find to learn 40 days of K he pressed the gar into my chest and told me is in tracted kushan now he said you learn from me and I'll learn for you he gave me that GAR and I started learning the D the next day he kept and kept going past 40 days and made my first CM ever I pray that I will Merit to complete many more thank you for the incredible fun and engaging she has taking me to Great Heights I D should only continue sincerely Dr Max bratsky and here's a picture of Dr mat braski at his seal beautiful Ma Ma G rose Ellie brings yet another massive massive benefits specifically to this new your Mas from Real Estate your M from Real Estate are real and tangible you're living it and bringing examples that come from real life because you've lived it re turns D is super relevant thank you and one more dear belly wow what a shabas we learned we laughed we cried we ate we got inspired we ate we listen we sang we ate again we sold stenders we removed we met the Mish we recruited we connected and above all we gave and then we ate again a truly epic and incredible experience my advice for those that didn't imag to 10 is to save up now for the CM masas my complain the shabas went out too early huge SC to all that made it happen attention detail was magnificent shimy and Nomi leafman Manchester for 844 days amazing that 10 people came in from the UK for this unbelievable and finally for theity of mother for being upon his wedding tonight I don't know what night he means oh Sunday night my great grandfather my namesake direct desc that carries name the of the month from supporting take a look at this chart right over here and tell me what you think the should be there are four people sitting on a bench and uh pretty heavy fellow and I say heavy because the gar talks about him calls him heavy in fact a lot of say that all those guys on the bench are heavy what should be the if he sits down on the bench and couple minutes later the bench breaks what's the and this is a sh that's relevant to today relevant very much if you live in you live in how is it relevant any I can think of a of something that's relevant who sits on benches these days and breaks them well there something that breaks very easily and that's the elevators elevator what if you have four people in the elevator and comes a Za guy he gets onto the elevator he breaks the elevator what's the how do you know that that is true that's a that's very good very good it's a the guy that pushes the button very nice ah all right so let's see PS six lines from the bottom so if you remember here take a look at the chart for those of you who are brand new and haven't learned bakam yet and haven't been with us it's very very simple the first mishna tells us that there are four different types of maik there's an ax and we're talking about specifically the ax here I'll just show you all the things the ax has three things that it could be Karen Shen and Regal not to confus the new guys we're talking about Karen now we're talking about a ax that Gores with his horns bar is a pit somebody makes a pit so again Char is you have a bull and he goes this bull damages today in today's world will be let's say a dog that bites a bar you have a pit you left open oh I could say tell you the story that I haven't said in a while and that is that when my father was a rebi in charos in the 70s we went to the bungal Colony I was only about three years old I'm sure you remember the story and uh on shabas as a three-year-old we decided we're going to build a treehouse so my good friend y sasman who's a rebi today in shash and I and some other we went out to be M shabis as three-year-olds and we were looking for wood and I found a large uh piece of wood large piece of um what do they call it um plywood thank you piece of plywood and I'm thinking to myself wow this is an amazing piece of of wood to to put as the base of a of a treehouse so I lifted up the piece of plywood and I started walking with it to to lift it up and not realizing that it was the covered to the cess pool of the entire bungal colony and I fell into the cess poool and the piece of wood covered me and my three-year-old friends didn't know where I was I just disappeared from the face of the Earth they looked around I was here one minute and I was gone now I'm inside there like drinking the water and swimming around and his Gish screaming nobody heard me and to make a long story short somebody flushed the toilet supposedly and it caused like a little bit of a pre and it shot me up hit my head in the plywood and for a moment that had like a two-inch thing and I scream hey they realized I was in there and they went they called my father and I was saying the story over in Chicago and as I'm saying the story over R Brazil the Riva walks into the room because he wanted to see my shear and he says I was there and it's a true story he was there so if a person has a pit like that and he opens up the pit he he digs his pit he's as as a maik he's a maik he caused damage he caus a kid to fall into it now in that case they covered it so everything is good it's not their fault and then you have mava which we're not going to talk about he is there's more pizza Bo I know the is hungry please eat now because it's gonna get cold seriously eat and we have fire what the gar is going to do now is going to tell us for all the new people and all the old people what is the difference between a sh and a bar and a fire what are the pros and the cons in what way why does the T have to talk about all these things why is it not enough to say hey you have a dog that damag it covers everything because it doesn't cover everything each thing has a specific says let's talk about each one against the other one if you look at a bull that Gores with its horns or it could Gore another ways with its teeth but it has a over a bar just means it has something that a bar doesn't have and by the way bar also has something that a doesn't have otherwise you wouldn't need at all in the and not in the what are these things so this is think about it if this is your only day doing you are going to be learning many manyas you might be embarrassed that you didn't know these things so it's a great time to start the da every da is brand new in Chas K is the concept that when a bull kills a human being the owner has to pay for the human being there's a Kyer it's a certain amount of money now that is only for a bull that kills and A Shard doesn't have it if human being falls into your pit and dies you don't pay that when a bull kills a slave you have to pay 30 she out if a slave falls into a pit you don't pay n when the bezan says okay we're talking about he's done this three times already the ban says okay we got to kill this animal done you cannot benefit from this animal whatsoever but if this animal fell if if if the something fell into a pit you could benefit from the pit here's the first of all it says in the you see the idea of in the okay then it says like this real quickly if a bull kills a human being a man or a woman and the person dies you got to do kill the kill the animal and then says can eat the meat so the says means you get zero benefit from this animal you cannot sell its horn as a you can't sell its hide for a sa ofra you take it and bury it that's it there's nothing to do with it it's a special its nature is to go and damage doesn't have any of these things we just mentioned it's not it's not its way to go because it can't go you don't pay ker you don't pay the 30 of EV and here we have it says in the this is about oh no this is I want to say this uh okay we'll keep this for some some other time has something that a doesn't have it immediately was created to do damage only K has this idea of it has to do damage three times the first three times it only pays half the damage a bar doesn't have that the first time it causes damage it pays the full price say now let's take the versus fire fire has something that doesn't have we just said these are all not these are not we just said it compared to a bar a b pays for a dead person oh that's why I brought that is is the POS that a bar pays for a sh not for a human being that's what you see in this and not a human being great has to pay the 30 if he kills a slave this is the we had yesterday if you give the bull oh I should have showed that that video again for the new guys what a okay we'll show it to the guys later so if you give a bull to a a coton and it goes out and does damage we said yesterday it's the the grip and his force that cause it whereas not in fire okay what does fire have that a bull doesn't have fire your mood right away like a bar now you would say okay it seems like fire and bar are the same we just the same that you said by a bar we said by fire so so why in the world do we need both fire and a bar because they're very different the bar has something that a fire doesn't have was created to damage when you give it to a death mute in other words a and a if you set a fire and there's a human being there and the human being gets burnt you're Potter why why you Potter again there's a fire you lit a fire guy standing right there you lit a fire and the fire goes real slow and burns him kills him why you Potter because he should have ran away now what if the person dies the person is tied up so Rashi says here you don't have to pay why don't you have to pay because of the concept of here's a concept meaning that if you are then you don't have to pay you can't get punished twice it's not double Jeb something different can't be twice if you pay with your life you don't pay anything so in a case where the guy's tied up and he burned him to death then he's not to pay he's and if he burnt him alive and he could run away then he should have ran away and what's the that fire has over a pit because the fire it's the way it is its nature is to go in damage so I want you to remember this line over here it's important line for the that a fire is used to eating eating anything things that are good for it and things that are not good for it it eats everything consumes everything what does that mean we have to explain says the now the is just GNA ask a number of questions why don't we say more things for instance you should say that an a bull has something that a pit doesn't have it's a good Al to remember that if fall into a pit you Potter the owner of the pit is Potter but if your bull goes ahead and damages Caleb you again if somebody's walking with his iPhone or something he's busy texting and he trips in a pit and his phone goes into the pit and breaks he's Potter but if your bull your dog goes and bites somebody's phone so why don't you say that says it's a little bit of a to remember every step here the reason why it's not mentioned is because it goes according to who doesn't hold this because holds that if Cale fall on a bar ask the okay you tell me it's so then everything has to be so how does he explain the next part that fire has over a because fire goes in remember we just read that line before that fire eats things that it's not not even for it's not normal for it to eat eats everything consumes everything now what does that mean what's normal for fire you throw in some firewood and what's not normal iPhones computers chairs tables not normal for it bar consumes everything everything that goes over it's normal for a lot of things to fall into a [Music] bar how can you make distinction between wood and Caleb is the one that says that so the way to get out of this question is to say that is something else you thought means Wood versus Caleb no something else so first the tries something else okay so it's not review it's so then the question is if it's have a g difference that we didn't mention the difference is Cale how you don't say that a sh is if it breaks a iPhone and a bar is Potter if he breaks iPhone how come that's not in here in the differences between a sh and a bar says the the famous answer classic year sometimes we have a list of things and we don't put everything in the list but that's the next question always in ches if there's a list and you're missing things from the list you have to at least be missing two things you can't give me a list of 25 things and say you know what I didn't say number 26 because I didn't put everything in the list sometimes you do that if you at least omit two things but one thing doesn't make any sense once you making a list you compile a list put that one thing in there if you want to make a short list and you're going to take out two items great so we have to come up with the second item oh something that's hidden if you have something hidden in a bail of hay let's say the iPhone is inside the B you poter if it catches on fire but when it comes to a bar this's interesting Rashi here and they explain rashi rashi talks about the on top of and everybody asked we just said so they explained there's another Rashi and maybe that's the on this Rashi over here also we're talking about an animal inside a sack the animals covered if the animal's T he's covered and it falls into a pit then you're you for the animal all animals that fall even if they're Tom but if it's fire then you're Potter so again we have two differences between a bar and fire when it comes to ton fire your Potter and Bar your Potter in a bar in in a so we have two items that are not didn't make it to the list or we could answer ah you asked me before that something that that's normal for fire to consume and we said it means wood and what's not normal Cale and we said but no you you made a mistake you remember in the beginning already had this SL that if a fire went ahead and uh how do you say it like darkened up the stones burnt the stones what singed scorched what are you doing here by the way it's good thing he came singed that's what it means that not Ro sometimes Flames go up a wall and and then burn a wall that's not normal for I have another question here's another thing that a is more than a bar you see how many we learn these unbelievable means that if a person designates an animal as a carbon that carbon you cannot use you can't do anything with it and then the carbon befalls a m comes about M so it's what do you do you redeem it and you're allowed to eat the meat no problem however there's certain limitations to it yeah even they redeem one of the Li Pati is that you can't feed this animal you can't feed this dead animal you could eat it you can't feed it to your dog you can't feed it to your animals the problem is check out this where is it over here the POS says that the dead animal should be his his means his you do whatever you want with it it means even to give it to your animal feed it to whoever you want to your friend to yourself to your animal that's so soon as the says we know that's not referring to in other words if fell into the pit the would be if it killed this mdash again mdash is an animal that became pule to bring you to the B MD why because it's it was grazing before he brought todash it broke its leg so you can't bring it on the on the so if a shark comes and kills it if it falls into a pit Potter why because it says and at the end of the day you can't use it for everything you want so you can't be referring to so we have another according to we have two things on the list that didn't make it Tom and so now we have a third thing great but of course to you didn't leave anything off the list so why did I only leave out one thing which is no you did leave something off the that what that if the animal went ahead somebody plowed a field comes your bull and it's having lot of fun on the plowed field goes and mushes the dirt right back into where it came from so now you have to hire another tractor and redo it so that's something listen to this sounds funny that's that only applies to a sh and guess what it doesn't apply to a bar because it's impossible that a bar will go and flatten out field so he's saying it's not I hear says I don't like that why we already said that that the na in a bar is that a bar doesn't go and damage so here here's the case that doesn't go and damage so you can't make that into two cases fine we learned in that if a person does a little bit of damage a little bit said is very important to us these why maybe not you guys live in Tower 41 with all the beautiful elevators and stuff but also in Tower 41 us inish the elevator is small could only hold five people Max and once in a while after gabas shabas even five people not a good idea it tells you there's a little symbol like a guy on a scale and it goes it shows you like this won't go now says if a guy did a little bit of damage so he has to pay like the whole thing what's the case I think he did real quickly and this was 2 three in the morning what time is 9 o'clock at night in I just roll n o'clock here 4 am. this Yoshi doing something at 4 a.m. literally I I spoke to him 10 minutes before she and he said I'm working on this I'm going to something really really quick I didn't see it yet let's see what he did this guy did nine okay and he did one for a total of 10 because we know and the wearing is galic we know that 10 kills an animal less than 10 damages an animal so says this where do you have the most boy R in the world in Gaza unfortunately well maybe not in the world but one of the top countries in the world that have tunnels and all this stuff so we're gonna learn beautiful suas here with very very niceas if a person digs nine comes the other one and does the 10th says the the last guy is whether the animal died or whether the animal was damaged we're going to have to see it's a rash says we're going to learn later on from theim it's very interesting because you would think listen the first guy did nine there's enough in the nine to damage the next guy did he did a one extra which creates death okay so he should be on death when some something's damaged both of them should cheer in it I don't know whatever no the last guy should be should have to pay this goes not like rebi which is interesting because who wrote the mishna rebi so what he wrote in the in the mishna doesn't go according to him somebody dug a pit that's nine comes another person and adds one makes says Reby like I would have thought maybe that the last one you're right he created a death trap because we learned that nine doesn't kill and if an animal dies in nine it's not from the pit he had a pre uh pre-existing condition thank you but this this guy made it 10 so he created a pit at kills but the nine already causes damage so the guy that added one didn't create damage damage already existed says re therefore both of them should be no our m is talking about that he added one just we're only talking about the Death part and that goes even according to Rabbi everybody agrees that the last guy is like rebi some say that it goes like this maybe this doesn't go like rebi our misses or Papa me it goes like does go like re because we're not talking about we're talking about okay there's other cases not only this pit that went from 9ine to 10 there's another story you have a wild bull one of these professional balls that they use in the stadiums you need five people minimum to to tame this guy to hold on to him to SLE him around and one of them decided to take a nap napped on the job and he caused damage that fifth guy that decided to take it easy he's what's the case if you need five people he's such a wild you need five and without him he's gonna he's gonna create damage of course the fifth guy what's no he doesn't you don't need five you need only four M it what did he do by by by leaving so it can't be that's not a good case have another case there's a fire there's a fire that's going from here to there it's going three feet comes a guy and brings a bunch of straw and lays it out on the floor all the way to that wall and when it gets to the wall burns the building down so that is somebody that did something look he lit the fire the ru lit a fire it could only go two feet if it goes two feet it does zero comes shim and says oh there's a fire he likes to play with fire I want to see he wants to see how this building is going to burn he takes a bunch of takes a wick and just stretches the fire out all the way to the to the building and it burns down the building if without him it didn't go anywhere so it's P that is so it's not says rash it's called he did everything now just take now without looking inside in your art Scrolls and everything look at me for a second I want you to think for 20 seconds is there a difference because this is what gamar is all about understanding differences between different cases is there a difference between this case that a guy made a fire let's call it n of a fire comes the second guy and makes one extra of a fire and it reaches the building and burns the building down is that different than a guy that dog nine in a bar and comes another guy and digs another is there a difference logically could you think of a to make a difference a distinction between the two cases I said 20 seconds think think here the fire could go and would stop and he added one and it got to the building where a guy dug n and comes another guy made a 10 okay what are you saying no it would stop at 9 stop dead at n cause damage so that's the difference no because the fire wasn't going to cause any damage if the second person would have come right the guy the guy but causes could TR travels n and you added one yeah nothing was GNA happen Nothing Gonna Happ okay anybody else is always stationary and the fire has always so you're saying the opposite nature to advance yeah fire yeah so Rashi says like him Rashi says the fire it nature is to advance but in this case it's on a sidewalk it's on concrete it's going to die out after n it's zero once it gets to nine it's just gonna die how's it going to continue you added that extra you did everything Hally in logic you did 100% that the guy that did nth did zero because as is nth is zero and you added one so you made you basically took a a torch and lit the building that's what you did you did everything when it comes to a pit the first guy did a lot he did 90% of the damage he created a pit that if you fall into you're going to break all your legs and most of your bones you might survive the other guy came and he added another kills the animal okay but the first guy had a lot to do with it says the in this case so you're talking about a fire that without him it doesn't go anywhere so what did he do he didn't do anything fine and now we get to this case oh I wanted to show you this POS before no this is for later okay so here's the story again five people sat on a on a bench and they didn't break it they're sitting minding their own business reading the newspapers comes a guy the guy comes and breaks the bench the last guy has to pay because it wasn't breaking without him he caused all the damage Pap Papa Was a heavy set fellow or sadic he's very heavy and it has to be like him so T points out here because it's very interesting that if he wasn't heavy there's something called if a person puts out a bench you have it in different places people put benches you have I told you like when you walk up a Hills a lot of people have water fountains people do or other people I was actually wondering how come there's no benches from I walked a half hour from where I where I'm at all the way to to 41 half hours like where's the benches I'm almost 51 plus the 16 flights of stairs F 16 flights yeah anyway they didn't let me do I said it's not it's my mishas I don't go in an elevator on even though it has and everything's perfect you guys go they refused to go and they went they climbed the stairs with me everyone every well there's five guys they all climb the stairs very nice to them I didn't I mean I was upset about it but whatever so if you have a bench that's meant for people to to sit on then then if you sit on and it breaks you're Potter yeah everybody has their story I had one of my uncles that we haven't seen in many many years he came to our house and there justr and he s in a chair and poof to the was a big bush anyways for us so it's he's not but if you're heavy then that's what the is saying you're heavy you shouldn't be sitting on it then it's not it's not it's a little bit oh which reminds okay we're not gonna go into this so we don't have time now so that therefore T says it's possible that all five people were heavy because if they weren't heavy then they're all poter anyway to begin with okay now it's very interesting you ever wonder how come here in America there's a lot of heavy people everybody has to go on a diet I mean heavy meaning we all myself have to be in a diet why because maybe we can learn from pap theor says in that he was he was a he used to uh catch animals he used to trap animals and he used to eat them fact is in chabas thear says that his sons asked how can we tell that it's chabas we eat meat all week long and we drink wine all week long so and what is so I think that's the issue here we eat we eat and eat meat always restaurants mom is pounding meat it's here it is so happens to be I think we're the first K in history in mdy I offer the guys money for losing weight they lose weight it's certain every kilo that lose we gave them an increase in their salary and happens to be that when I moved to so a lot of my friends they were very heavy and I said you know there's a show in America called the the biggest loser we're GNA do the Biggest Loser everybody put in like 500 Shekel into a pot and the one that loses the most weight is going to is going to win now they said it's not fair because you didn't have to lose any weight I didn't have to lose weight wait then so I said I know but I'm going to put the money in just to be and unfortunately I won the pot I lost the the most weight seriously and since then three of those guys got the surgery and say they're all okay so going back to our question you know what we could go for a second more over here it says like this what's the case if without him it wouldn't break he broke it if the bench could hold five people he's a sixth person that comes along so he's it would have broken any way without him might it so then what did the sixth person do nothing says okay SOA that's why we're not counting it because it doesn't make sense what something's off here but at the end of the day it's such a good question you're asking so how do you explain this this this mishna so Rashi says you only say over here because it's a real miss the other ones are bres this is is important for us to figure out what's going on what's again you hear the question if it would have broken anyways so why should be if it wouldn't break without him so what's the he broke it pretend the other five guys weren't there he sat on a bench he broke the bench he's who cares about other five people what's going on here it would have broken after two hours two minutes whatever it is an hour broke after one hour we were planning to stand up after a few moments and go V you made it go quicker and therefore you should be have a mmar so you should tell them without you it wouldn't have broke so here's a very very interesting sh this is something I wouldn't have thought about to me it doesn't make sense logically but the says it there's a when he sits down on the bench he could tell them you had you should get you should get up the guy walks into the elevator and the thing goes like this the scale shows not so you can tell the other guys you guys should leave the elevator not me why why me so you'll say but logically you were the last one last one should get all no the gor says he has a good ta number six could tell the other five guys you should have stood up and that is a good ta for some whatever reason I'm not exactly sure why but in terms of the elevator that's what he was saying that says that it's it's not the last guy or the first guy it's the guy that pushes the button because the guy that pushes the Button he's the one that broke it it started going up and then got stuck on a certain floor that's his problem he shouldn't have push the button it's not going into the elevator as much as pushing the button to go up the that's what he TI us anyway says what happened was he didn't sit down he went over to his friends and he like leaned on the shoulder hey What's Going Up Guys what's going on and poof it broke so interesting SP also I'm not exactly 100% sure how it works I would think that leaning is not like you sitting the tal of the says maybe the is because they struggle with what could be the logic in that why is sitting down with my whole body different if I lean because leaning is not as heavy not as much so I think maybe your Potter maybe it's not as bad no your pressure your force that you put on another person that's like your own body okay we have more more cases person beat up listen to this guy got beat up by 10 people with 10 bats whatever it is whether was together one after another and the guy died so what's as far that they should be Potter so Rashi here says because we don't know who killed them and others say theot is that you have to have each in each one and you didn't have so let me just find this here oh there's a that says here's theing so learns means any part of the nefes in other words you have a guy that's about to die it's gonna die anyway and this is every moment of Life Is Life I had a friend my friend that lives here he still lives here in North Miami Beach his daughter drowned and she they they took her out but she she survived for another like two years and there's a big fight the doctors here held that they have to pull the plug and he said not he okay so take her home and he dealt with her for two years why because believes that every moment especially if a person is alive and can still do Mitzvah and and say and make a every moment there thing as oh he's gonna die anyway that's says call nees call any moment that that this kid this person could live yeah he got beat up with a bat nine times over the head but you came and you did the last one you're killer you're because you're because you hasten the death you made it closer than it was supposed to be you're supposed to live for another 10 minutes you took away 10 minutes of this guy's life and every minute in this world you could do so we have a case of that you you telling me this one case of a bar n 10 here's another case nine humans and one human nine people hit the guy and and the guy the final guy did the damage it should also be in the M the final guy is says we're not talking about death we're talking about killing we're not talking about people killing not talking about killers well we did have and we said it's not like RAB right before we said oh maybe you should say this doesn't go like RAB when it's re against we said that's the so that's great however over here it's you want to say that he says call that even a little bit that say that's not good to say like against the that you're in so this is a very interesting sh think about it for a second before you look inside think about it my dog kills your animal so I have to pay for the animal how much I have to pay uh a bull cost let's say $2,000 right I used to buy a lot of bulls back in the day right when I had a meat business don't go into that $2,000 now my dog your dog killed my bull how much do you have to pay me $2,000 or you say listen you keep the dead bull do whatever you want sell it I don't know to sell it as kalal even though it's not pretends whatever sell it to some guy or whatever yeah it's worth something right who's whose problem is it this dead animal does the guy start from scratch he gets a brand new animal $2,000 or he gets only $1,000 let him deal with the dead animal it's a good says he's only the difference between a dead animal and and a live animal in other words he only has to pay ,000 he doesn't have to pay $1,000 $2,000 let the owner of the animal deal with the dead animal terrible thing you see that from the mishna that the owner has to deal with that animal and it's say so in life as well that you don't have to start from scratch a lot of people think that they do the DA they can't just this week five people told me the same thing they think that if they started the D in bama they have to go back all the way to bras have to make up from lost time it's not true sh is a ferris wheel the day you start even if you start on that's the day that you started CH and you're gonna finish CH and test it just goes around in circle you don't have to go and it's in many things in life you don't have to yes the tra we're starting from here we start from here and out you pay the difference between the dead anim you don't have to start from scratch you have to go all the way back and pay fine how do we know this we have three here and the is going to tell us that we need all three that you pay you have to make it up you have to make the difference you don't have to pay the whole thing if it's a plan on Words it says by if you're watching an animal they're paying you to watch an animal just remind if anybody knows there's a house on Pine Tree I think it's owned by a FR person beautiful massive house and the entire sh I saw two guards in the front anybody know what's going on over there DJ it says Happy Thanksgiving on the thing two guys outside and one guy in a unmarked car the entire shop is from morning to evening yeah the famous DJ got it okay just thought wondering I thought maybe because the mat of what I don't know really not like this because there's a nice um the guy has a tinted windshield you can't even see the wind all I saw him coming out it's a security thing whatever okay fine it's there the whole day it's two three guys just in that one spot crazy I guess people just come in there they want to say so again this is another plan words it says that if you're watching an animal and all of a sudden uh wolf comes and grabs one of the animals you VA Aid means a witness right don't have to pay the TR so we learn instead of Aid because in the T there's no in the T up until you see from here you don't have to pay for the actual carcass you only have to pay the difference between a dead animal and a live animal and the third thing is means that the damaged party gets the dead animal who told you going that's it I don't know what that means what do you mean if you think that Thea goes to the one that damag not the dam not the person that was damaged but the one that damaged the here here's the you pay an ax for an ax what does it mean just stop right there you have to pay an ax instead of an ax me means say that goes so we need all three by the way you'll get used to it is always quicker and always easier than if we talk about it's not so common that a person goes ahead and kills an animal it's that you you hire a Shepherd to take care of your flock and comes a wolf and grabs one so think that he should have to deal with the dead animal it's common take care of it I say it happened by itself didn't do anything comes a wolf and grabs it that's not you something else it's outside source but when which is let me just see for a second oh you human being if You' say the human being and the when it comes to a human being killing an animal it's not common and when it comes to Shar he didn't do anything came an outside Source a wolf came and grab wolf Rashi says wolf not me comes a wolf and grabs one of the animals it's not you it happened by itself but when your bull goes ahead and damages so it's not outside Source it's your source and it's common I think you should deal with the carcass this is a beautiful question and then we're done for today it's only because the says that the N the one that is damaged gets the dead body Asar it's common sense that that the N should get the dead body why think about it how do you pay a n every time you could pay him with brand you can pay him with anything you want we learned so why can't you pay him with a dead body here's a bunch of dead bodies again let's say that the dead animal goes to the mazik okay so goes to the mazik comes the maik says here I have a delivery for you gives it right back to him he's allowed to pay with whatever he wants any currency goes dead animals a bunch of brand that you have no use for anyways it'll take you 400 years to finish it in your yogurt what are you gonna do with bran so what are you gonna do with de B let them at least sell the guy I don't know what it's a beautiful if the has a bunch of dead animals he could pay the with it allow to pay with BR so if it's his own animal he owned it to begin with just leave it there no the is that until they they figured out that the animal's dead and this and that it went down in value now it starts smelling now you can't even sell it for meat now the only thing you have is a couple horns and a little hide whose problem is that the N the one that's damaged he has to suffer the consequence we're going to give the mazic as if this animal's perfectly fresh and anything that happened afterwards that's all up on the that's the have a wonderful day for joining and we'll see you tomorrow at 9 o'