Daf Yomi Bava Basra Daf 72 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good [Music] morning ah you want L I'll give you L here L one of the nicest edits I've seen in a long time from Ariel check this out meny where are you let's hear oh perfect so perfect again know what he had enough but you know what in his mind appreciates it it's it's unbelievable oh I wanted to show you the that do okay different time um [Music] MOA green look get a lot of these emails and they never get old never once again you know what it is but gives me a lot of and it gives the the whole team and uh it doesn't get old thank you for changing my life dear Rabbi Ellie stefansky my name is MOA G he has his name here on the screen but okay I'm not going to say his name I am 34 years old old I never have had the opportunity to learn in a Yesa as I was thrown out when I was 15 years old since then my life took a very different path I went straight into the workforce and from that day I never opened a gamar again from 15 to 34 recently I came across a podcast where someone was talking about you and your sh I decided to check it out and I can't even begin to tell you how much it has touched me it's been years since I felt any connection to toy learning but through yum that spark has been reignited instead of spending hours lost in Netflix and other distractions and now find myself eagerly waiting for your Shear your energy passion dedication have given me something I didn't even realize I was missing for so long I just want to take a moment to say thank you thank you for giving me and so many others like me a chance to reconnect with our heritage in a way that feels genuine and accessible please don't give up on what you're doing there are countless people like me who are depending on you and your sh to keep us connected and inspired with heartfelt gratitude Mo so I'm asking I don't I don't think I've done this in a at least not in the I want him to reach out I want to I want too with him I have his email I think and uh I'd like to to connect with him do a little interview um this is from St jakowski I've been meaning to write to you and wish you at a good health apologize for missing the last day in Chicago and several others but I was on vacation with my family but problem need to write today is the morning this morning my wife tells me she's going to Walmart and asked if there's anything I need I said if she wants she can return a yishai book I bought through the walmart.com website that I realized after I received it was a duplicate of a book I already had then we started arguing whether one can return to Walmart a yishai book sourced through a third party seller he's saying because the the guy selling it to Walmart is a I said him it looks strange to the clerk but why not we left it at that we left that I would return the book not her then I'm driving to work listening to you not even s minutes in you're talking about the circumstan on which one is permitted to return an item to Walmart fortunately I had no D to return it when I purchased it so thank you for the head to go ahead and do so a true kiss from hasem on the importance of you to me personally as well as our bond in Friendship wishing strength good health in the coming year and Beyond Steve [Music] jakowski um I just want to say that since it's last night was we're starting yellow we're starting a brand new peric it's Kai to put on your status and tell people about this year to get to join we did it in Hebrew last night and over a hundred people joined from status alone for the Hebrew we could do better we have more people and more statuses and we get more people so it's your opportunity to rack up get people on status as you know we are going to Europe and I would like to dve in personally for anybody that sends me a name we're going to put together a list of names and I guess there to leave the names there by the C will leave by every C I personally will D and I hope you know just don't load it up with thousands we'll be okay but if not me D them with me we we try to di for you will be my we're going straight into we have a a longer da today a little bit on the complicated side so we're going straight to the there's a lot of gaki emails unfortunately and we have stuff but we'll get to it different time sponsor the month business the sponsor for the safe and Speedy return of all the hostages Mel for the and safe speed return of all our so since I put that in two people reached out to me Dr Mar daber mber he's also sponsoring a full month and Mr Anonymous $1,800 also for the same exact thing and the few people I saw another one I think it's might be in here also that is welcome to join we'll do a massive thing for the they should all have and they should all come back speedily matching rebell donation for the month by the way the month is supposed to be 26 not 18 a disc yeah yeah yeah okay I was giving myself a discount I didn't know I didn't know what it is I just went in I figured $1,800 to cover it what are you saying that all these people say par they pay 2600 yes ah I didn't even know that wow okay so we have to up it then or I'll just do half a month and the other guy will take over the other half I'll be stingy okay I hear should do half half a mission maybe they'll be home in in weeks and then it's stop LGE oh all right so we have another Judah David is sponsoring with me how much are you giving thank you you are a big donor actually you do have a good heart you want to give the scooter I got you there okay official M motivat memory of Mrs must recover from a heart surgery Ben R my dear friend markazi a man who makes dreams come true thank you rebell for everything you do the famous famous cman from the five towns we used to hear from him M every week at least but this is very sad first yard side of my beloved daughter had milberg she was only I think 29 years oldis zacharov remember him 14 months after graduating I finally got my first job as per my pledge also to reell MD that we should be to see more kisses from now I understand it after reading that email that yeah of the month for fori and the White staff to continue to make T So enjoyable for so many guest what are your names all in the back yeah Father and Son wow who's the father and the son yeah where you guys from who else I saw some other guest somewhere what's your name from every day oh what's your name Harris y Harris Gail Harris from another local okay Sher is here he's finally here voice give him a big warm welcome m is here unbelievable such you came on the perfect day let me tell you one of the easiest stop him in sh when we have a do like this this the gar shows us the depth of the gar how deep it could go and we're only going to touch the surface there's a lot of a lot of calculations holding cup so I say to you first of all tomorrow is a brand new peric a really brand new per and it starts off nice and easy with d of but even on a day like today do not check out do me a favor don't check out we're going to be learning howas even if you walk away with one concept about let's say how it works you don't understand the whole you got something you you achieve something don't despair if I find you sleeping during the shear today let me just try to give you a overview and you don't have to understand that I'll try to do this again I'll do a quick overview of what we're going to be learning today basically and you decide to yourself if it's complicated or not the other day yesterday before we learned about on the right side we have Ellie stefansky on the left side we have Judah David I'm just kidding Judah I'm waiting for your donation my friend where is it you see a little pressure is going to work a little pressure anyway fine like it was too insulting Jud you insulted no not at all I didn't think no he's not insulted he's fine look at you look at you he's all nervous that it's all the what I'm the I'm the raw I'm the raw I'm the raw he's he thought about giving much more than 1800 okay good if he was in my position he' give much more fine upon him the the gar says there's two types of people people that sell meaning when they sell something they give especially when it comes to well see one item if they're selling a field everything that has to do with the field the Cara goes I'm selling everything I don't leave myself even a sidewalk to get to my swimming pool I just give it or that a person sells but he's a little stingy and he leaves himself stuff he leaves himself over then we had rauna here's rauna rauna says if a person sells a whole field all the green he sells the guy this guy in the center he's the seller the guy on the left is the buyer and he left himself he says I'm selling you the whole entire field besides two trees does he leave himself the dirt underneath the trees or not and then we said that according to everybody oh well where's the alma here here the started the guy leaves himself the dirt underneath even if you hold like even who says typically he gives everything away rauna says in this case where he kept for himself two trees he doesn't give everything away he leaves himself we saw in the mishna rim says there's a lot of holding cup here that's that's all it's it's easy stuff but we have to hold cupim in the mishna says that if a person gives over to heg she gives over the field it includes even very strong powerful large entities of trees such as and Sycamore Caravan syamore where typically he would hold them for himself when he does heg dis that goes with it now it's very how does that work with Runa yeah Runa says when I keep for myself two trees I keep the the dirt underneath yet when I give when I give Hees I give everything with the trees with everything so the gar says now the switches it yesterday we're going to go away from that that in fact doesn't agree to this idea it's not like in other words he keeps for himself he he gives everything away he gives everything away so when he gives heges a field it he gives everything away it includes the K tree it includes the Sycamore yeah you ready lost me huh should I start from the beginning okay we'll do this again and we'll see it inside we're just we're just doing a little bit of a overview so we had now two cases we have Runa that a guy keeps himself two trees and he he does he does leave over for himself dirt we have the case of heges where he gives the field that includes the trees he doesn't leave anything for himself according to why because he hold great we're gonna see a which just the the entire Bry is beautiful and if that's why you came out from the whole she it's good because it's easy to understand the whole idea of the botom line is that if a person plants three trees but not in the proper way with less uh area needed so he could he's mag this just the trees but not the dirt underneath and this is problematic again if he plants three trees not in the proper way maybe I'll show you a little picture here um where are these trees oh well this it's a whole Su but he planted Three Trees like this but not with the proper amount and distance between the trees let's say they're closer to each other so he donated to heges only the trees not the dirt not the dirt underneath now who does this go according to everybody [Music] holds and the gar says that the end that it goes according toim that it's but that he only M the trees with problems according toim holds which is going to show us by but ra means that he keeps he keeps for himself the dirt underneath so that's basically what we're going to go into and thear Bas at the end all the way at the end of the day thear says one thing hold on a second the gar says one little thing at the end and we're going to jump into the says in the mission that we spoke about you look at the last words in the missim says when a person gives over to field he didn't he G he gives with the field he also gives a beautiful tree the says a very interesting thing he wasn't saying according to himself he's talking to and he's telling don't you agree that it only includes a tree but doesn't include other things that's that's what thear says at that and that's basically what we're going to be seeing today in a nutshell let's do it slowly and inside and hopefully we can get something out of this the says like this all the way top what's interesting is because it's a it's a continuation it's really if you look at B it's six lines so basically we stop the middle of a the whole D you know it's based on how they uh laid out the pages but we're smacking of says shim the Mna that a person who donates is Mages a field to heish nothing's included only the special trees the and the shikma are included and that goes according to the said his rebi who holds and he doesn't hold on to the to the dirt very complicated words but very very simple it goes like this if we look the way if you have very small trees small ones you could plant 10 small trees in an area of 2 and half th000 am which means 10 2500 / 10 is 250 per tree yeah you basically get not this one 16 by 16 15.8 by 15.8 250 square amama per tree now let's go back a little bit there's called if Yeshua gave somebody a field and that someone gave it to his children and went from generation to generation is that if somebody in the family takes that field and donates it to the B mikdash even it's a even if it's a huge field the size of a c tremendous 75,000 Square armor okay an Alor is 2 feet so I don't know how to do the math it's not 1 15,000 square ft is it no okay 75,000 Square very large field you have to redeem it from the B you buy it back you gave it as a donation to the B now you want to plant corn on it so you go to the B you say hey I want to get my field back the T says it's a very very cheap price it's shek but prated there's 50 years in a y so that means it's basically a shekel per year so if there's five years left to the yil you give the B how much five shekele it's really 148 because it's for the next year so you give it one and a p okay let's call it a shekele just to make it easier shek and a p again there's a very cheap price let's say you donate to the b a beautiful sycamore tree and it's worth $1,000 and you want your tree back you go to the B mdash and how much do you pay the B mdash $1,000 plus a fifth you're going to have to pay them $1250 right a fifth is a quarter really so you're paying $250 on top of the ,000 tree but if you have a giant field at 75,000 Square ammo which is an AM is double in a foot so you do the your own math you only have to pay one shekele I don't know how much a shekele is per year okay so if you have 10 years you pay the B on the 10 shekele if you have 50 years left to the Y cuz anyways in the Y is going to come back to you for free so if you want it earlier you have to pay the this one now what if you plant a tree on your property and you want the property back you pay back a shekel for the property do you get the tree back well depends if the tree is buttled to the Cara you don't pay anything for the tree if it's by itself then you would have to pay for the tree individually $1,250 for the tree and one cheze for the car so now let's see inside this is great this week get and if you walked away with this then you could go to sleep for the rest of the thing the rest is just back and forth like like fine but let's at least do this part person donated to the BD Three Trees where my three trees oh I had them everything's mishab where are my three trees oh here I think they're here no wow I just had them and I clicked off of it maybe this oh Three Trees here we go person donated Three Trees to mdash nothing no K nothing and it was the proper size the way he planted them the distance between the trees and everything around the Tre was perfect for a person who's trying to redeem from the how did he do it the same relative to person planting 10 trees in a saw we said planting a 2500 amama so 10 trees in 25 amama is500 amama is 250 amama per tree great so what's if a person person does this person donates these three trees and this 250 am per tree everything is included including the dirt underneath the tree including those little baby bushes everything is included okay therefore now makes beautiful sense now when he wants to redeem from the he gets a discounted price of a shekele per year he could walk away with that whole entire thing if there's 5 years left he gives him five shekel sh everything is great okay this is what we want this is what we're going for here just to show you inside how it works red this these are the years it's a shekele per year let's say there's 10 years left he pays a shek in a p oh now what if it's less than 250 like in this case it's 200 Amo he didn't he didn't donate it with the proper amount of land and this R is the case that we need to show with the other cases here um these are the cases that we're talking about today Runo all the way to the right we said If a person sells entire field but he keeps himself two Tre trees he sells the dirt underneath then we had the case in the mishna that's the center case if a person donates a sycamore tree you see that the big large tree in the center then he also what I'm sorry what happened was you're right no he was he's ma to a field he's M to a field sorry he m a field says it includes the syore tree and now we have a third case that's what we're talking about now all the way on the left that is MDES Three Trees but without the proper amount of spacing between the trees it's only 200 hour per tree oh so here we holding yeah six lines down if he had less than 200 or 250 per tree a person was magish one tree then another tree and then another tree it was three separate when you donate them individually it's separate acts of heges then you did not give any car underneath them yeah similar to let's say I know this people taught me I watch people let's say you're on a diet okay you're on a diet and you eat a half a piece of cake and then five minutes later you eat the other half you don't there's no calories there right if you nibble at it and you eat entire piece over certain amount of time doesn't count that's what it says over here it's from the from the right here if you one and then another another tree and then another tree it does it doesn't it doesn't add up if you did all three together oh then you get the calories one yeah P this this is that's science scence this P science no it's different acts of Hees they're not they don't they don't combine what I did yesterday has nothing to do today so now trees that don't have the right amount they don't have all the calories they're not 250 they're only 200 or they're one after another so when I redeem it then I only give the the exact value of the trees but not I don't get away with one shekele per year on the whole thing on the whole deal because the is not included here what if I I donated all the trees to the then I donated all the underneath them so I think it's a package deal now now you go to the say listen one shekel for the whole if I did it together it would be a shekele per year so I did it individually but now at the bottom the bottom line is right now the B has a whole field with trees on it so let me just pay one cheel no good doesn't work first you have to pay for the trees says who does this go according [Music] to is of the opinion that a person he sells everything so when I give the trees I give them so it should include the dirt underneath why is it when the tree is small when when when when the area is small it's 200 like here on the left side 200 per tree it does not include the dirt underneath in fact thear ask everybody holds ya why why does everybody hold this in this case hegdish if I'm giving something to hegdish I'm large I'm giving a gift I'm going to be sting so what's going on here how does it how does it work with these other cases that we saw on the side over here on the right in the center even shim says I give the when I when I when I field I give more I give theun says when I when I leave trees for myself I'm large I Leave myself some dirt so I'm going to give how does it work exactly certainly if I'm selling to a random person I sell him with a with a big heart so when I'm talking even who typically say on the left over but in this case we're talking about but a person that's is be so we have to say this's a third opinion here what does hold he like his cannot goly so it must be that this new that says that when I donate trees that are not 250 amama in area just 200 amama let's say I do not donate the K it must beim who holds like r that what but we said why don't we say it's ra because it'ses holds not so nice there are people that are stingy when it comes to also believe it or not and he gives a donation TOA but he holds back he only gives $1800 instead of 2600 not so large so now we have this case where a person donated to Three Trees the red trees all the way on the left side of the chart and it's less than 250 goes according toim says he ra he's he's stingy and he leaves himself all the ask the but the bottom line is it doesn't jive with another thing that we learned it says in the mishna that if a person here the center case we forgot about the center case how does the left case go with the c case in the M also and he says that if I donated a field I also donate the tree on top why but I'm sorry and he says he explains because he gave it he gives it with with uh with the tree otherwise get from because otherwise he'll right why does he give it with the tree because otherwise the tree is y Yik he gets from the ground which is what which is hegdish so you see there shim holds that he does give the dirt underneath the tree so I in ra let's again he said this case with the three trees he donates the trees does not include the dirt underneath but according toim it does include the dirt underneath in the mishna because he says that the the trees nourish from the ground and therefore he must give the trees to heges meaning that the dirt underneath is heges he didn't leave the dirt underneath for himself yeah how can you say that IIM holds Rim holds he doesn't give the dirt underneath if fact he didn't give the dirt underneath then where where are these trees nursing from from his own dirt that he didn't give and that's not a problem then he wouldn't have to give the tree todes the only reason he has to give the tree to Hees in in the mishna not in this case not to be confused this case is he donated the trees themselves in the mishna he donated the Cara and it includes the tree so but the car underneath the tree he shouldn't have given he should have left it for himself according to because iron raw he's he's stingy he doesn't give the the dirt underneath the tree so how does it work with so the says so we do sponsors okay we have new sponsor the famous yob sitron who's done a few of the films for us and in fact they hired him or I don't know ex you know what I don't know I shouldn't speak I had nothing to do with this but I heard I'm very happy I heard he's coming on the Europe trip and he's going to be the official photographer so he's sponsoring by by S films and L nishas the six hostages that were killed this week H famous HS somebody remind me I want to go be at least you're supposed to remind me okay and URI and edin and almog and Alexander and Carmel so now the comes up with a big bigti himself in fact when he talks about a when he says that if a person donate the field it includes the buser tree the carab tree it includes the Sycamore he wasn't talking about himself he holds a guy doesn't give any he doesn't give the dirt nothing but he's saying you at least should admit to me that there's two levels here basically there's two things going on here there's there's a Matana I don't know if this will confuse people by the way uh when I got back from the Hebrew sheer last night I realized that nobody understood what I said not even one well some understood a lot more than me and some didn't understand anything and so we decided to go back to the drawing board and I think I don't I look it up Yoshi wrote to me at 2:40 in the morning says okay I'm finished I gave him a bunch of stuff to do and he's the middle of moving and he's not happy I mean he didn't say a word but I'm sure he's not so happy about it when was it I'm just he said not to say anything so I have to say two 53 a.m. just finished there you can see over here you could you zoom in on this send me a screenshot okay later remind me I'll send you a screenshot not now the bottom line is um okay listen if one person or even if I myself understood a little better soim in the mishna I wish we had a a screenshot we do have a little bit here oh no not this one Kobe did it but he I don't know why okay if you see here this is the mishna but it's uh the last Last Words unbelievable is coming with B here is not giving himself what is doing is he's talking to he's saying something very simple you guys remember yesterday we're talking about a guy gives a present he gives him Matana it includes what meni everything everything what does everything mean even a factory on top even the wine press a bar a do a gas it includes everything CU mat when a guy sells something and you say he gives it's not everything there's a different levela the when I sell the item I'm selling I give you 100% what am I selling you I'm selling you a field I'll give you the whole field I don't I don't leave over a sidewalk on the field no no don't exaggerate don't say I gave you everything it doesn't include uh the Sycamore and then the bar and the do no of that not I'm get in that thing that I'm selling just that field I'm giving you everything so tells what about heges what about Hees when a person donates the hegdish you I I I I hear what you're saying a person gives large you all said oh when to give hegdish large but how large there's two Madre and large this's this's large and this's very very large this large I give you the dirt and this large where I give you everything including like a Matana like a so says at least agree with me that he's not so large that he's not the the category of mat large like this not everything there's a mat all the way on the left that's that includes everything there's the that at least on the bottom I just did it like this MDES at least agree with me that it's not like a Matana I'll give you something a little bit but not all of it that's what he was saying in the [Music] mishna according to me I'm I say people are stingy through and through when they sell their stingy when they give the they give the the stingy and he leaves himself land and everything but you say that a person is generous I want to know how generous in what category don't you agree with me that it's limited to only the tree the the the the boxer tree and the syore no even the b gets even the bar the gas everything and everything okay so what comes out so now I don't want to confuse the too much but yesterday we said even we started this year that Runa let's go back to Runa okay we started off this rauna that a person keeps for himself two trees that's the the whole person keeps two trees he he actually leaves himself a lot of dirt underneath the trees and that could go according to everybody and then we said no no no it doesn't go according to everybody remember we said no that only goes according to because holds by because Rim holds likea we have to take Rim out of this whole thing Rim didn't get along with this whole run and is gonna hold like his Rea so we we we we said this run doesn't go according to everybody but now we're saying no is not even arguing anybody is just talking to in the mishna he doesn't say his own thing so we don't have to say go and we could go back and say the bottom line is this is what's what's going to happen that everybody agrees to Runa now there is no going likea because Rim wasn't arguing was talking to and telling don't you agree with me that it's a different level of of that he's not giving the so at the end of the day this that when a person leaves himself to two trees you see what happened there he left himself two trees it includes the dirt underneath that could go according to everybody fine now we're almost done over here one little one little piece this is already like a new and we can pick it up from here so Al this whole case remind the uh where is this this case this case where a person well this is not the real case this case Okay the case of 200 am per tree not the proper amount you're supposed to have 250 200 so it says in in the in the braa that it doesn't include the Carri underneath right that if you do it doesn't have 250 he's Mar this just the trees not the K who does this go go who does it go according to who does it go according to it can't be and because they both say the so the reason why it does not include the because it goes according to who says okay so far so good this simple now Maybe not maybe I lighter stickle whatever to it says over there that if you did it one after another you you mag the trees and then you mag the car at two different points in time but think about it there's a beautiful question that comes up here you own a field and on the field is trees if you donate just the trees not the field so you have to redeem just the trees if you donate the field and it includes the trees then you could get the discounted price of one shekele per year what if you donated the trees by themselves and a month later you donated the field by itself too bad you have to you have to redeem the trees you have to redeem the field let me ask you why today right now at the time of redemption when I go over to the B MD and I ask the gab the Sham over there the the gizbar I wonder redem my field with the trees it's all one package deal they're all together it's all Hees today what's the difference so what's the answer was entered into it was entered into he and but today today it's one today oh oh so you have to you so there's a question here do we look at when it entered when it became hegdish and there was two separate times or do you look at today and today everything is one package deal it's allish together that's in fact do we go at the time of redemption today or do we go at the time of Hees when he was Mages hold on what but today today is the day that he's coming to redeem and today it's all one thing it's all [Music] he cannot be because shim throughout sh is gonna prove perhaps holds that we go by the day of redemption and today what are we looking at we're looking at a a field that's hegdish and trees that are hegdish you should just have to pay one chele per year sh no thousand for the sore tree how do I know this okay very simple case we even have a nice drawing for it here you have a father who owns a field a son comes and buys the field from his father now is this is no cuz he didn't inherit it from his father he bought it from his father so the the kid messed up if he wouldn't have bought it for his father if he would have waited for his father to die he would have inherited and then he if he even if he consecrated to the he gave it as a donation it be the cheap price of one shekele per year but he bought it so anybody that buys a field from anyone has the right to donate to the and when he redeems it he has to pay full value of the field you don't get a special discount price so this son is no different than anybody in the world so he takes the field and he gives to mdash so at this point in time he has to redeem it for how much full value the thing happened is that the father went to the he's gone he's dead so what happens now he went bye-bye so now the field really became his as his he inherited this the rights of why not the rights of huh exactly so we have a problem he bought wait a minute one this this field the already bought it but is going to remain on this field forever and ever and ever it's going to go from generation to generation in fact when y comes it's going to go back to the sun he gets the rights of when goes back to him but he also bought it but he donated it to the but when did he donate it to the when he was not his when he didn't have the rights of when he only had regular rights so how do we view it now he comes to the he shows up I want to redeem my field they say wait we have a problem do do you redeem it like a son who inherited and he it's a shekele per year or it's a million shekele per year because you when you donated it you warant as you didn't have the rights as theza so what does say we go that's the question that's our do we go by the time of redemption or do we go by the time that this could have been could be because he's a son and therefore he gets the benefits of as and he goes by Redemption holds that it goes by the time of redemption now here's the same case with a little twist mayor says no this person comes to say a much simpler case that what there's a father and a son bought it from the father but the father died and then he gave it to heges so now it's like what AKA said over here not Rea AKA but he bought it and by when he bought it maybe he lost a little bit of his rights so for that mayor says oh says he didn't lose the rights but there's a much smaller because he was mag already when he he had some sort of Rights of came to him his father died let's put them together soim says the comes to tell us purple green red anybody that's listening on has no idea what I'm talking about and says this purple red green the question is the green happen before red or red happen Okay but that's the but based based on how learns the at least we have a um a source theim holds that we go by when you Redeemed by the pigon like case number two over here the same says just simple stuff the case mayor says the case on the bottom over here that his father died first and then that's too simple you don't need that how do they know that case that top then the father died if a could tell you AES and you have a smalles and a very large KES which one is thek telling us the smalles you have to go step by step you can't jump to a giantes so just asking why didim say that the PK is telling their giantes that they were magish and then the father died maybe he the father died and then he was magd maybe that's what the is coming to tell us the smaller KES because you see from here there's no whether the father died first and then he was MDES or he and the father died zero Naina the is when did I arrive at the to redeem my field at that point did I have rights of or did I not have rights is my father gone at this time not my father his father no not a good you so so we have a problem here if Rim in fact holds that we go by the Redemption then he doesn't fit into the Bri we want to say the whole PR goes according toim but that that wouldn't work ifim hold that we go by Redemption so is going to say no doesn't hold that we go by Redemption just in this special case that we see on the screen over here then we go by Redemption why over here why because theah uses a funny right simple what's thisy business over here so okay in this case we go after the P but in general we don't go after the whole of the Three Trees could work with reim is over now we're going to something much simpler and we'll finish the this Tre that we're talking about this very important tree it has you could look at it as a piece of car and you can look at it as a tree depending what you want to do with it you could view it as a tree right we always said that if you have three trees if your magish three trees you get the dirt underneath so it could it could join forces with another two trees you have two simple trees plus this giant sycamore tree that's worth $10,000 but at the end of the day you have three trees three trees includes land and this is also there you get the however we view this tree as independent Force if somebody sells a field it does not include the syamore tree and therefore once we say that we have the same exact in another way a giant Hast stack a very large one has what does that mean so is one of the that if you left two bundles you have to give it you have to leave it for the Oni if it's three you don't have to what if you have two regular siiz bundles and one giant one that's twoo s it's like the sycamore tree Sycamore plus two trees Equals Three Trees a giant Hast stack with two small H Stacks equals three Hast stacks and therefore the balabas can come and take it it's not for that name and it's also on the flip side we could view it as a giant tast stack it's not it's like a sycamore tree it's not it's not part of the typical um if you if you forget a giant pile of hay a two the cannot take it this exact case that we had until now that if a person is a field Does it include the and the as the didn't we just say that we have in that Cas we're just telling you that you should know that is not on his own first of all we said that shim wasn't even talking wasn't even arguing he was just explaining and he he's trying to prove his point but when it comes to this case he holds that when your MDES uh a field it includes right he said it includes the and and holds like him and gives him backing [Music]