CONNECTING SHIVA ASUR BeTAMMUZ & PARSHAS PINCHOS - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

I would like to dedicate this morning shares my grandfather Ruven Shiner the father of my uncle Reblazer Shiner the founder the supporter the driving force behind his shul Makam Tyra Makam Makum of Giladim my grandfather called his yard side, his fourth yard site is the Chabis. Just uh a brief pointer. My grandfather born in Scranton, Pennsylvania as a boy went to Ty Vadas and stayed there for the rest of his life. He was Marbet's Tyra for over 50 years. A person that liked everybody. He was he liked everybody. Didn't make a difference what type of person. He liked everybody. And people felt it. If I ever was walking with him, people came from across the street to tell him a good chabas to say hello to him. He liked people. People liked him. And he was able to relate to everybody and anybody at Talmid. A lot a lot of Talmid. Anytime he met a Talmud, no matter what stage of life and what type of person his Talmud turned out to be, was able to relate them to connect them. He's a medish. The medish brings what's the most important PK in the Tyra interesting if you're asked what's the most important PK so there's a three-way one T says is the most important P another T says so loving every there's a third that says from this week's para the carbon the pos of the carbon tot that's the most important pekk which is very interesting of course the carbonid was very important but it's the most important pig in the whole tyra and not Not only that the med says and said that it's what's what's so important of the carbon total. So the moral explain explains that it's the carbonius a person to be consistent to do whatever he has to do and avoid on a daily basis. Not only when he's in the mood does he da does he learn does he do a person does it day in day out like over here the morning comes every morning hot cold snow my grandfather was that way learning on a regular basis on a daily basis literally till the end of his life in Tarvadas He never changed daring. He was always early to daring. He never changed. It was always a tidius his way in life as throughout his whole life. We're holding now today Friday between that was yesterday and tomorrow Shabas Keshas the Gmorra it's a Mishna in our maka it's not this week's staff but if you'll allow me it's in the maka the Mishna Uh the mission the beginning of the fourth per the mission says what happened that we fast what happened? So the Mishna lists out five things that happened. One of the five things says the Mishna that cla no longer brought the carbon tot in the B mikdash the carbon tot of this week's para we stop bringing the carbon tot and that's one of the sad things what we're being that we no longer bring the carbon tot we mentioned that in the yesterday and we said in the botting it doesn't just say another line or two later we said not only is the Tommed was bottle in other words from Shas on we no longer brought a carbon to the B mikdash an extremely big void but also zak what's zak zaklim carbon so not only did we stop bringing the carbon we stopped bringing the further we also said in the yesterday bottlu carbon we stop bringing carbon Nice. Why did they stop bringing the carbon on Shabbas? Now we know the story behind why they stopped bringing the carbon to they really had a hard time bringing the carbon tomed up until Shiobas. You was surrounded from Assar Betavis two and a half years before that. And they had a hard time getting the the kvasim to bring in a carbon tot. They paid a lot of money. They used to let down a box of money over the wall. And they used to get the carbon to carbon table on a daily basis till they were advised on the other side that you know why you can't get into your because the carbon is protecting Clalus. So stop giving them the carbon tot. That's what happened on Shiovas Thomas when they let down the money instead of a carbon coming back up the Garra says a Kazer came up. So they no longer had the carbon tomid. What's about the other carbonis? So the tomid they stopped. What happened with the other carbonis? If they no longer had carbonas already for a year, let's just say and the only carbon that they brought was the tid. So what does it mean? What we said yesterday in the in the bottle had carbon other carbonis. We didn't bring the other carbonis anyways before. It seems like they did bring other carbon and it stopped on. Why did they stop the other carbon? The tomid we understand they didn't have the carbon tomid so it stopped. But what's about the other carbon? So explains not this but he explains yard was this past Tuesday Thomas and he explains on this that the says the carbon over. So Rashi brings from Kazal that you need more zer by carbon. What? Zeras to take caution cuz carbon cost money. So the moes and kiss it cost money. People should not bring carbon. Slack off about it. Zerus to be careful. explains and he takes it a little further and he says that being that we have the Dasha that the first carbon for the day is the carbon and if you do not bring a carbon you cannot bring any other carbon ice you really have to make sure that you could bring the even if it'll cost you a lot of money what is a zero is to pay a lot of money for a carbon because a carbon cost a couple hundred. I hear that's so you can understand but says you know what the zeros is the only way you could bring carbon throughout the day is only if you have that first carbon the carbon tot so even if it'll cost you thousands of dollars to bring that carbon totid you still have to do it cuz if you're not going to bring the carbon tot you're not going to be able to bring any carbon ice so therefore you need a zeros to make sure to bring the carbon tot spend as much money as needed to bring the carbon so he can bring all the carbonas. And that's what he says. That's what happened up until Shabbas. They let down a crate of money, a lot of money to get the carbon to so they should be able to also bring the other carbon. So what's the clear takeaway from the that when we have the that you could only bring that you bring the carbon first it's not only that it's first it's if you don't bring the carbon the is closed for the day there are no carbon clear so back to what we said yesterday in the that we know the Mishna says because they They had no they no longer were able to bring the carbon tomid but because they were no longer able to bring the carbon to mu bal the other carbonis as well very clear they brought the other carbon up until shiobas but once there was no carbon to the mbe was so to speak shut down and they did not bring other carbonis so that's why we said yesterday Tomid the island of Ze and Botlu had carbonis because if there was no Tommed there was no other carbonis the thing is that it's not so simple this din this concept that if there's no carbon tomid you no longer bring any carbonus on the misbeh this that says you don't it's closed is shot down this in two places about it in what happens a day in the mikda they didn't bring a for whatever reason they didn't have any they couldn't bring aid could you bring other carbonis this is son-in-law of yak is on the and he says these are the you can look up the gar yourself but it's clear clear that the garbara says that even if you didn't bring a carbon tomid we still brought other carbonis it's mafurish later after the gumar derive it in was purish on measid. Just read the lash and he says clearly also that if there was no carbon tot we still brought other carbon when we say that the carbon comes first and there's nothing before that. If you brought a carbon, that was first. However, he spells it out clearly. You weren't able to bring it that they couldn't bring a carbon. They didn't not bring the other carbonas. They brought other carbonas. speaks about it clearly also that they brought other carbonis. So this that we said from the that they didn't bring other carbonis in the gar that they did they did bring other carbonis. So, first let's try to and then we're going to get back to the says that they didn't the is of and he says doesn't mean to say that they didn't bring it if they didn't have a carbon. It just means that it's so important and that's savian zerus to take make sure even if it cost a lot of money. It means to say that the tomt has to come first at any price. No matter how much you have to pay you have to bring the carbon tot first. But of course if there was no carbonid we still brought the other carbonis. this that the says going migdar now till they paid a lot of money it doesn't mean that when you couldn't get a you didn't bring other carbonas you we brought other carbonas we did bring other carbonas but you have to make sure to bring that tot at any cost so the says that they brought other carbonas of course they brought other carbonas but they only brought other carbon without If there was absolutely no way how to bring the carbon to then they brought all the carbonis. So that's a good on the garra on on the arim from the garra. But what's about what we said yesterday in the bottla carbon? Why was a bottle of carbon? The carbon was takonis. Why didn't they bring the other carbon? Cli soul did whatever they could to bring the carbon. They let down a box of money and it didn't work. So they did not have bottl. The mission has made botthammed. But why the other carbonates? I would like to share with the ash based off what's mur in the rashbash the rashbash one of the rishim the son of the rash bits says the gdes that in the mid Midbar throughout the years in the midbar cloud did not bring the carbon tots also did not like the minora maybe once or twice he says the second a few times did not bring so from the did not bring the carbon the order there's no there's an order the order is makave just wanted to show them you could see it inside very crystal clear my grandfather my other grandfather my mother's father Lubart wrote a safer on kchim when he was 18 years old Zman rabar he brings the and he brings this rash and he says a big and he says that this that when you don't bring a carbon tid you don't bring other carbonas how you could understand is only carbon a carbon do have all the All the avoid of avoid was stopped as opposed to a carbon somebody needed to bring a someone wanted to bring a you could bring that's how we explain the says that they did bring carbonis and as we see in the rash bits he says says that when they didn't have a carbon tot he lists out a carbon they did bring is the words of my grandfather of let's jump right back now to what we were bothered in the lion of the that we said yesterday that it says carbon what do you mean carbon was able to still bring carbonis like the miss the garbonus means carbon is aim what's a carbon sore a schlam there's one schlam that was a carbon sour we just had a little over a month ago was a schlman so any carbon sour what we said yesterday bot carbon But means carbon all the migdash stopped as opposed to a car was yes brought. So everything is the what we said in the [Music] So really it's all good. We could stop right here. But in the title it said what's the connection between shasabus and para's pin. So far we didn't really touch upon paras though the para speaks about the carbon but what's the connection to the para we really focused on asks the following question. Why do we need two sukum in the tyra to say that the carbonid comes first? We said in paras why is it necessary? In this week's para paras we learn we learn the gammor over there from the later that you also bring the carbonus beside Besides the carbon tomidt what's besides said the gar it's a Mishna the Mishna says first you bring the and then afterwards you bring the the other carbon so what do you have to have another comes first you have to bring the first because it's it's comes first tot is every single day the tid and a mus of Shabas of once a week, once a month of Yam. So why do you have to have the P in our para and the PK in par? So the give tom the mikdash answers the following and he says from our para of of that themed has to be first then call todd what comes more often the the carbon tot that's first you would be able to bring the tomid and the musive at the same time. What does todd mean? He cla what does todd mean? Does todd mean that the todd has to be first or it's just now let it be later. So you have to light them and so what does the todd say toddler says that may has to come first or it's just saying that you know to do later you have the carbon tot and the carbon musf is it only that it's now going to come later or dafka has to be forced. Could you do them both together? So the big says, you would be able to bring the carbon tot and the musf together cuz it's not you're not violating the it's only if you bring the the later you're violating. You can bring it together that says the has to actually come first. That's why we need the second. This is not so posh because says in the general of doesn't just mean that it's now going to be later actually means it has to be first clearly so then you don't have the terrors why do you have to have both our par that says that that tom first automatically is telling us that you can't do it together. So what after the in our paras why do you have to have the of [Music] the has a different it's actually in the says and we spoke about the concept And is only a discussion when you have both in front of us like the example I gave you before you need to. So which one do you do first? If you're a person that dins my every night, let's say over here in the night after night sader 9:45. So the poin brings it then you later there's no tad is only when you have both if they're not both in front of us then it's not there's no question which one you do with the oneu says this if from our para of course the carbon is comes before the but let's say you don't have the carbon if you don't have the carbon atom So you'll bring the musf and when the tot comes about later on you'll bring the carbon tot for that you need the par to say that no bring the tot here and do the first be of themed themed before the carbon m but from our para itself we wouldn't say that the tot has to be It's only but I want to ask you the following question. I don't know if the briskerv asked this question or they asked the tud briskarov this whole part two what we just spoke about that the tot has to be first if even if it's not or you can't do it together both carbon the carbonid and the carbon musf which the pix says the tomt comes were both the same type of animal was and they were both called an the you don't have to have in mind for exactly what type of carbon the only thing you have to have in mind is that you're bringing item so that the Tory says that you have to bring the tot before the when The kan brought the carbon on the misbeha. It was the exact same carbon the to the morning the tot and the musf. So even if he was bringing the musf first what he technically it he didn't bring the mus first cuz he had a mind of bringing this lashem. So if the right thing is that the comes first, it will be an I'm sorry it would be a Tid. So back to the question that the TT has to be first. The Tmed was anyways first. The Talmud was first because the only thing the client had in mind was that it should be. So there are three terutism parrots number one is what we mentioned before if you could bring it together if you hold that you could bring it together that's where it's noa even if you have a mind if you're bringing them together the opposite I said it wrong like you can't bring it together if you cannot bring it together that's where it's going to be neg if you cannot bring it together that and You bring it together over there. It's a steer to kaidum another terret. There was another two terut. There was a big difference between the carbon tid and the carbon musf. None of the actual carbon. Number one, when you brought the carbon, he was to bring wood at him. Two logs of wood. So if you brought the mus first, which means you didn't bring the wood, that's how you're showing that you weren't bringing the carbon tot. The same is also if you bring the is that the carbon tot had to be checked for four days. muker is it was even in other words if you brought a carbon tot that wasn't muker wasn't checked it was possible so if you brought the carbon musv that was not checked if you brought it first for a musf it would be good for a tid it would not be good so now that the is that you have to bring the tmet first it's very clear that you have to what was the question the question is what difference does it make anyway ways. It doesn't make a difference. It does make a difference because if you bring the tot first, you have to bring it with logs of wood. You have to bring a carbon that's muer. So to conclude and just sum up what we spoke the first part of the Shia was the concept of this that when you don't have a carbon tid you could still bring other carbon but maybe not carbon then we spoke about that we need both that the carbon is and then Which of course if you learn that you can't bring any other carbonis after the carbon that was not brought that's why you need both drashes but we needed to find other roots because if you could bring carbon the pos then we have to understand why you need both sukim and we concluded by that the tot is first they're both the same carbon and for that we said these navas have a wonderful shabas