Chulin 65

Today's is and we are 11 lines from the bottom of today's being learned as so we're moving along at the tail end that's upon everything's upon but at the tail end of perfus discussing the related to the simonym of an on that note. How do you know that an egg that's hatched by a non-cooser bird is itself non-coosher says hayana? So one of the many that the mentions as being a non-coosher is the bas hayana. What is the basayana? Ostrich bas. But the describes this bird as the basayana. Does the have a daughter? Now why not? The yana can have a daughter. The can have a son. That daughter makes sense in the event that the animal is going to deliver the child from its womb. But being that we're dealing with who hatch and lay eggs. So the word the word bas is actually an inappropriate word. So what does it even mean? Bas it must be that the bas is referring to the egg. And why would the mention the egg and not just mention the probably to teach me and that is that just like the Jana herself is a non-coosher bird. to an egg that comes from a yana is going to be a a non-coosher egg. Maybe the name of the ostrich is not the yana, but the name of the ostrich is the basayana. You're asking aasha basana must mean it's the egg. Oh, you see from here the egg is also non-cooser. But maybe the name of the bird is the basayana. meaning maybe the way to describe the ostrich is not it's but says you can't say that because it's a this sob describes as like the in the midbar just like the ostriches they mourn and they whail in the midbar that's the way was circa the but The ostrich is referred to not as the basa but rather as the yano but the gar says I hear what you're saying can you tell me that the ostrich is not referred to as the basana meaning this seems to suggest that what's the name of the ostrich it's the yano but there's another this is a it says again same context talking about the mourning of butrol is going to mourn like the vasano kibos and says the gamar No, the name of the bird might be the I what does it mean in that evil? When it means it's not that the is the name of the bird. It's the bird's name is Dana because she's alb meaning is wailing and mourning like the m wales and mourns over her daughters. But is another it says they're going to reside there again. But again you see that the uses says but not that the name is the but there's another it says this talks about how was singing and like if you're going to tell me the name of the bird is the so this is peric right but if you're going to tell me that the name is really the and the is referring to the bo doesn't make sense that an egg could sing shira it's posit that the name must be the place again tomato tomato. How do you know that the bait of a tomato is itself? Tommy is itself? We learned it from the basay. Why we talking about the talk about the must be that the bas which is the egg because it doesn't really have a bas is in the talks about that you should know the egg that comes from is going to be tommy as well. But the grace accasha is the dilahu. Maybe the name of the bird is the hay. And even though it's true, you do find that the bird is referred to as the but there's so many that seem to suggest that the name of the bird is also So although it's true you find that it's referred to as the we also find that it's referred to as the basana which means there's no dick to be had from the fact that this pik describes it as the basin used to describe it as the basana and if that's the case what was dictar says let me explain knew that sometimes you find the yana and sometimes you find the basana and just from the word basan in and of itself there was But the he knew that the of the way writes this in the is that the word and the word can be two separate words. In fact, it is two separate words and from the fact that it's two separate words that this is not like the we're describing the ostrich but over here means the daughter of the it means the egg that the egg is going to be non kosher but the says is that in the fact that the takes bas is that a riot that it's him two words maybe is that it's supposed to be written that way even though really it's one word and I'll prove it to you because of the betrays is that the way the writes in the iss of but this is what the of was that that's the way it's supposed to be written and we know for sure it was one person it wasn't two people Which means that just because it's divided into two doesn't mean anything. Could be there's a this is way right you have you have there's of how you write. So maybe that's punct the way it's supposed to be. So again, what's the dick? If you find that the could be referred to as the basayana, so maybe it just means the basayana because it's two words. Is also two words and it's one name over there. It's different because there is. It's true that writes it in two words. He would not be able to put it on two lines. Being that it's one name, it can't be on two lines. this is something that can be written even on two lines. If it could be written on two lines must be it's two words must be when the it didn't mean the ostrich and let's just refer to the ostrich the way your mio did in a or the way did and the way some of the other nim did. No, what we mean is the daughter of the Jana. Jana doesn't have a daughter. It lays eggs. It doesn't naturally deliver a baby. And as a result that over here means the egg and that was the first part of today's now from seven and a half years ago in the last we have a a raid bite that gets in a little bit to this of because the truth is I think if you ask the man on the street how do you know that something that comes from something non-cooser is non-coosher. So he's going to make a beline to that would be the intelligent way to go about this. The over there says that how do you know the of a non-coosher animal is non-coosher is because it says the word guml twice in the parish of the simum of a kosher animal something that this whole week of centered around and the extra mention of guml teaches me that not only is the guml non-coosher but so really we have two to this idea that something that comes from something non-cooser is non-cooser. We have And we have here in the asks the why do I need two different interesting to note and this was the point of the rabbite from last that when he brings the of the brings it from he brings he actually does not bring to explain why the thought that the more often another thing we talked about in that is that we know that uh buy milk from an assuming you didn't see him milk the cow is problematic right it's known as companies but uh the premise of is that you can't just go and buy milk from a non-Jew because how do you know the milk's coming from a a kosher animal? Okay, maybe it's coming from a non-coosher animal. Oh, the rabb would send you to if that's the case, why is it okay to buy eggs from an Why are you not concerned that the eggs maybe came from a non-coosher animal? In fact, that's So we make such a big deal. You think about right you would think we should also be making such a big deal as it relates to eggs. Yet I don't know that eggs has ever entered that realm of where it takes on a life of its own from aik and from a hashkic perspective. So somehow the we get very nervous about that maybe it came from a non-coosher animal but when it comes to an egg that this again is all part of the raid bike from seven and a half years ago either way moving along. So going back to the mission, the mission said that as it relates to the sim of my friend, but as it relates to the that already said. So really this part of the Mishna was the topic of the entire week of not the easiest week of the dy but it was the topic of the entire week now is going to really give us the postcript because after this next we're going to learn we're going to go from birth to grasshoppers we're going to bring over to but in the meantime one last price of which again really came up a lot over the last several dos you know for sure that it's Tommy in the event that it has that or it has a crap or the cork is able to be peeled off you know for sure that it's meaning if it's race you know it's if it has an ethic and a you know it's tari says where's that you have to come on to the ethic and if you don't know that It's Dyrus. Meaning if you saw it be Dyrus, then there's no point in even having this conversation. Let's say I didn't see it being Dyrus. That doesn't mean it's not Dyrus, right? Just because you didn't see it doesn't mean it never does it. So if I'm looking for a positive that this is that's the it's going to be said this is the of our in the he said but the is the price explains it a little bit more and that is that you take you take like some sort of string and you stretch it out and you put the birth you have it perch itself on top of this string. If it divides its toes, meaning two toes here and two toes there, that's a sim that it's not a readily, but rather it's three quarters here and it's one quarter there, that's a sign that it's going to be said. Any o that snatches its prey out of the ear that's going to be faith. Is that true? Does the same thing. And when you read the gamar, it sounds like referring to the right. every that but if you take a look at Rashi Rashi says Rashi seems like he's learning it was a specific bird that was known as other say no means you know many kosher birds but Rash doesn't learn that way says it was a specific bird was called but it's also that's a sign that it's the same thing said it means that it snatches its prey out of the ear and while it's mid ear it's very athletic while it's midair it goes and it eats it as opposed to it catches it comes down and then afterwards does its thing said in the event that you have a bird that lives together with that means it's if it lives with Then already it's going to be right. with going like I think it's time to it wasn't for that. to desire with the we know is one of the non-cosher birds and being that desire hangs out with the it's a sign that he's one of his must be it's his men seems to be the author of this idea that if you hang out with someone to well that's a sign that you're isn't that but says it's not even though it's a wonderful but it's not because I feel you could even say that is going said that as long as you hang out with someone else that's a sign you're from his men and that's why even though they look very different but if you hang out with an when a said they meant say but means could be when you're only a but if In that instance it could be that's considered a and you're going to be believe it or not. This concludes the part of peric eluchus just to speak out one is not like a full but just to speak out one and that is for further uh analysis in the lumbus of the so there's actually a for it's just one lus that I think opens up the a little bit one of the reasons the of is challenging. It's not just because you know the pictures and the visualization and the hamasha there's a lot of good work that's been done on that uh you know bismo there's a contemporary s that just came out that's called which is incredible unbelievable detail in terms of understanding you know some of the some of the different but when you learn the especially if you learn there's different questions in the and there's a lot of big and but just one for and that is said that when it comes to a behemoth so what are the sim of a kosher behemoth it's maf's para and it's malar when it comes to a fish right we're going to speak more about that so it's notes when it comes to grasshoppers that's the next we're going to talk when it comes to so and if it has an a and a nikl then it's going to be said that look at the amishna the mishna gave form of anar it's in right because if it's so if it's in it's going to be it has the it has the ze and the is going to be but the first simmon the way theishna expressed it was the other three if it has a and a it's going to be now from there we know four of it's because if that means if it's going to So I have my sim like I have it by all the other animals in the animal kingdom. But the Mishna presented it in an inongruous way. The first mention from the standpoint of how you would know it's the other three how you would know it's now from how you know it's but the first of from there I know that if it's not it's going to be but that it's from here that really it's of the other three is a sim of it's not a sim of Tyra. So you're right if is going to be you would have to establish that it's an ano dy but it's not because is a sim of tyra it's because when it's dyus it's a sim of and only if it's could it be because otherwise it's going to have a sim of but of this three of and the three the mentions for the mentioned is one sim of and that sim of Tommo is that if it's obviously if it has a sim of Tommo it can't bear I could have all the simum of Tyra at the end of the day it's going to be to so I need to establish that it's an ano in order for it to be but not because is a of a sim of Tyra ano is just a riot that it doesn't have the sim of now I could have my sim of tyro to go and make and the truth is if you think about it is in the g of The Zeph is in the G of the O. The Corkavan is in the G of the O, right? Is it nicot? That's a variety of what kind of cork you have. So these are all in the G. The simra is going to be in the G just like the simony of a behemoth, the simony of a fish and the simony of a it's always going to be in the whether it's or not. That's his conduct. That's his anho. That's the way it behaves. And in the simra it only makes sense those are in the of the is not a sim of tyra it's a sim of you have to make sure you don't have the sim of of in order for it to be this really opens up it's a big p in terms of understanding the so if you want or a week's worth of daf with that idea it's definitely a a big ps it up can move on in the He learns that other maybe didn't understand it this way but either way on that note we turn our attention from the to the grasshopper. So just a little tiny bit of an introduction before we start the next part of the suka. So the Mishna said as it relates to grasshoppers. So how do you know if a grasshopper is kosher or not says the Mishna that when it comes to a if it has four legs and four wings which said these are these two larger legs that allow it to jump and the wings cover the majority of the grasshopper in those situations. It's going to be so if you take a look at the inside which is going to be the background now of the rest of the so which is where all these are discussed the latter part of the para there's any that walks on all fours. So it's a sharet right self-explanatory it flies it's like a bird that's also self-explanatory if it's non kosh stating that however the following although is technically and it's going to be okay and that is if it has on top of its legs to assist it to allow it to jump. In other words, we're describing the the grasshopper. And from within that world, the following is what you're allowed to eat. This is the parish in the so high level says twice. This is something clue. But there is something that is okay if it has these extra legs on top of its legs to allow it to jump. And then we list four examples. Now it's obvious that from these right here, Kazal learned the fortun that we have in our Mishna. In order for a grasshopper to be kosher, it has to have which by the way is uh pretty straightforward that it would have to have if it's not there's definitely no hater to be able to eat it. Additionally, it has four wings. It has those extra wings. said in the also has to be called and all these different are somehow extrapolated from these here. One point that I think is worth mentioning before we really really get into it and that is as we're going to see Kazal had two highlevel ways to interpret these. One was that the way you dish in this is like a prat. Think about it. The says notar. So I'm giving you an example of what you're allowed to eat. It has to be that has that's and then there's a list if it's like a grasshopper and I'm giving you specific examples of when it's going to be okay. There was another approach Kazal had and that is this is not a clu but rather it's a clatu. How so? That first that's a climb is a pratt but then is another clum is a pratt is another cl is a le is another cl is a le is another cl. So too high level again in terms of the detail that's the rest of the but high level you can claim. So if it's a cloud you have a more inclusive setup in terms of what might be considered a kosher grasshopper. If it's a pra you're very limited whatever means and means whatever means and means either way this is just a very very high level hakama in terms of the detail that's something that we're going to really get into either way the said and one of the things we mentioned was that the wings have to cover the majority of the grappy It means the majority of its length the majority of its circumference said for that reason being we have a suffix whether it has to be or this is who throughout says that if you have a suffix let's just do both and he says here too with regards to a grasshopper that doesn't have the lion those two additional uh legs that allow it to jump, but it's going to have one eventually. That's a good example. So, it's not born with it, but at sometimes it it develops it. It's going to be considered. It doesn't have to have it this second in order for it to be considered that it has it. The civ of the is with an al if theree however is is with. So the you have the d as if it's with an alf and it's with meaning if it has the it's kosher and if it doesn't have it's kosher. Which one is it? Oh what it must mean is it means that if it doesn't have it now it's going to have it. So now it's but it's going to be it's going to be okay. The truth is there's a lot of in the you find out who says jump but the this is one of the because is with an al if decree is with above but the bottom line is is we learn from there that even if it doesn't have it now now it's with an alf but if it's going to have it later with above it's going to be okay my zak We mentioned that what's the example of the grasshopper that fits this criteria? It's called what is said. It's what's known as the tonu another. What's the different species of grasshoppers? Why does it have to say it four times? The first leminoi of the is coming to be which is similar to the arba. The second mention of it where it says lemo that's coming to be the grasshopper. The third one that it says by the that's coming to be. And the fourth one that it says by the that's coming to me. Now first glance it seems like a very innocent price. What's the Arab the Som is the Russian the is the is the guardian. What does the ter mean when it says lumina lum because all four of these species have something that's similar to it. The has similar to it. That's from the the has the sh that's similar to it and that's what's from leo. The has from it and finally the has the I don't know what any of these things are but it is coming to be from that that's going to be included as well right pretty straightforward just putting names to the faces right definitions to these words but the truth is as we're going to see this is a very lumpish and it takes us back to the tiny introduction that we made earlier and that is essentially the time of this price is saying that the way I look that the leminoi and the three lemos of the pekk, they're just examples of additional grasshoppers that are being included in the grasshoppers that are kosher. It's all associated with a grasshopper that's mentioned by name. So when we're going to be marba, we're going to be marba something that's minoi, something that's similar to it, but we're just adding. So we have the it's the not just the Arab because it's the amino together with the and it's the with it's the with the but here's the punch line. The punch line is that all those lino are just additional. In other words, the way you tish in this entire parish over here is as a and a sounds like anything that fits that criteria can be included. That's a cloud stating that this is as it gets for and then we go back to So what you have here is which means the only things that would ever be kosher are literally these things. It's the go, it's the Russ, it's the Nepal and the which of course meant something once upon a time. But the bottom line is it's this and nothing else that's going to be included. Now is going to bring another and the ton of is going to have the other mahal in terms of how to understand the and the is not going to learn this as a clop but it's going to learn it as a a clatu cl and the second are the leminoi lemino lem. So that the luminoi is not coming to be marba a specific grasshopper but it's a cl which by the way allows you to be marba in fact allows you to be marba more because now anything that's going to be kra is going to be now just in terms of the setup the is going to bring a baa it's a it's a longish bry so we'll go through the bry and then the gumar is going to ask five or six it's going to start in the end of today's daf and go in ready to tomorrow's d but different basic some of them like jumping off the page age, pun intended, but uh some very very obvious on the bry. So we're going to have to go through this knowing that the gar is going to address a lot of things that might bother us as we're moving along in this says they had a regarding these few. What does it even mean? So rashi says what it means is is that the says as The word Arab is a prino is a cloud is a prat. Lem is a cloud. Is a prat. Lem is a cloud. Is a prime is a cloud. Notice this is not like a cloud cloud. This is a cloud proud clu. So you have clawless and there's a lot of things flying over here. And Rashi adds to that that because there's so many clouds of prats, you know, there's going to be something extra. There's going to be an extra cloud of prat floating around, right? that's going to need some sort of usage that we're gonna have to figure out what exactly we're gonna do. But and can say this because it's so the author literally of the cloud gives you an epic oneliner says here's the bra when it says go it's referring to the govi which by the way in the previous braer what was the arba it was the govi I'm pointing this out because almost nothing else when we start defining the names of all these grasshoppers are going to with the previous take a look at Rashi Rashi asks all these cashes some of it is even going to ask but either way when it says it's coming to be and how you being because is similar to the go which by the way that also shims with the previous price right the croman was the leminoi and it's going to be included. Now, the way it's being included, however, is not that means the way it's being included is I have a anything that's what's the it's going to be included and it's for that reason it's going to be included. yellow above gapas based on this clu I would think that the only thing that could be marba is something that is a grasshopper but it's gabakas so a gabakas means it's bold right it doesn't have any here so grasshopper you know doesn't have a full out of here but the grasshopper has these things that are popping out that are quote unquote here and if it doesn't have it we refer to it as uh gapas now the araba and the cyus kman had Noah, which is another way of saying it has here, right? It's not a I would think based on the you could only be something that's which means it's not a be if you have a grasshopper that is a gabakas based on the I wouldn't be able to be that's why it had to say the is a grasshopper that is a gabakas. Which one is it? It's zeno. It's the nepo and that's going to be included lem when it says lmk that's au for the meaning I want another on the other side of the so I shouldn't only be the but I should also be things that are like the solemn so just like I have a ka for the I also have a ka for the but the bottom line is the reason the hadn't mentioned even though I have a cloud brought the cloud already for the arba what's the reason for that the reason for that is because if all I had was the cloud brought the cloud from I would think it has to be an how do I know it's a so that's over here the kamash one now notice by the way that what how did this bryer define the solemn we defined it as the if you go back to the previous bryer the solemn was the Russian it was the additionally what was the leo here we didn't even have in the previous what was the leo of the earlier it was the right that it's hard to forget but the bottom line is Rashi Rashi asks these catches the is going to ask some of it Rashi addresses the rest but either way but even after it says arba and it says so I would know that if it's included from and I would know if it's also included from and not just them but anything that's similar to them but I would think it's only If it doesn't have a tail, I don't know if it has a tail because the even though they're different in terms of not but they're how would I know something that has a the says and what's the ruin which was the solemn in the previous right in the previous was the neo but either way and that's coming to teach me that even if it has a zone of it could still be included. Why say because I want to clarify, right? That's the that's the By the way, we're going to see soon that the also is a in case you were wondering. We know it has a butak not. It's actually very important. It has a additionally we know. Who's that? That's the that's the cargo. We also know that if the grasshopper is in it doesn't have a a tall head, so it's going to be included. And the reason is because the arba, the solemn and the cargo or all are in above. How do I know if it's right? So I figured out Z of Nishkov, but they all have in common that they're in Ro. How do I know to be Marbo that if it's still I can learn it from mention they're all unique. So based on now the jumps off the page, it's going to be a big part of the Gmorra's analysis of this is what do you mean? And you know if it's not a shva is where I'm debating whether this should be a factor. So I have one place where the mentioned the and it has that too. So I know that that's not a reason for it to be excluded. But here all three grasshoppers that were mentioned up until this point. So you almost can't even read it either way. Continuing along in the says the what about the another one of these grasshoppers if I would have thought it's to have the name and that's why we mentioned that last uh grasshopper the to tell me that there's a a criteria and that is actually it's not and it says that even if I have all the affformentioned but if you're Like that's answer you're at another very hard part of the Ber to read where the question jumps off the page. If maybe all you need is to be all you need is you have a cloud. You have to be if the are all that it has these four criteria if I only am when do you see that that alone would be enough that's going to be the well actually tells you that no absolutely not it has to have all the bottom line is this is the second bryer that gets into the weeds of uh how we define these different uh grasshoppers and as we mentioned high level this Bryce is learning Not not a clinim but rather this is four clatu claus clearly very wordy and the gar now is going to do what it does says the gamar first cautious again let's set this up a little bit better the way the learn was that's a so technically if you check off the fact that you're have those based on that you would be okay. And then we got involved in a prat as for but then we said I would be anyone that checks off the basic boxes of what an is but additionally I would think it has to be how do I know if it's a go I'm tell you another part the is a he's also included and not just him anything that's in the what about an animal that has a zonov. They too don't have zunovs. So I don't know if it has a zonov. It says and based on I would know. So teaches me if it's not a gabaka. Solom teaches me if it's a if it is a gabaka. teaches me if it has a a now here the interjected not based on the symposic and that is what if it's right because all these things are in what about if it's oh I have a cl I have between and they're ALL WHAT they have all these sim and I don't care if it's gabakas not gapas not zonov so why should I care if it's I'm going to be even something that's and finally from the fact that it says that's actually that's not it tells me it has to be so the first is going to ask is going back to the which again was more the price because that is not learning up the puzzle for now but going to the ter once I know I can make it and I could be Marba Ethan Ro What do you mean? The three that you're trying to make the are all how in the world could you be something that's maybe you'll tell me at the end of the day means it has to be right. It doesn't have to be the same thing. So once I see that I have three proim and all three proim have in common these four. So it has these full and even if it's not it's going to be this right again the criteria of a so why would this not be enough for it to be why the then have to mention the why do we mention the because I would have thought maybe only if it has no but if it has a zun of not why would you think that they have these four things in common I have A DOUBLE CLATU SO I NEED THE ter you have to say meaning just like the had to tell me because otherwise I could have made a and I could have said maybe there is if it has a or it doesn't have a so for the same price maybe you can go ahead and you can tell me that there's enough if it's not where in the world do I have this cloud cloud that's going to tell me from three things that are something that's made a whole revolutely edited a you have to say that that part of the is actually learning up the it's not it's actually learning up the it's because the word is extra you know why you didn't have to mention was the second one right you didn't have to mention the you could learned it from the cargo meaning mentioned the arba and mentioned the now remember what was unique about the it has here what's unique about the solemn the wasab they both didn't have a zon what was unique about the cargo the cargo has a z but we mentioned the cargle also is a gabakas why so let it say arba which for our purposes is gabakas and zonov and let it say cargo which says the and if you tell me those two I'll know already the you know why cuz the what are you going to ask regarding the mala you going to tell me I can't learn it straight up from the is the that's why the price in real time we said that you had to mention the but the you tell me as opposed to doesn't have a and if that's the case said you want to know what the time of the price was saying. He was saying why have to write the you know what the answer is not to teach me the I can know from I can know that from but I don't need it to teach me the because the itself I can know to something else and you want to know what the something else is it's to teach me the bottom line is makes the first critical addendum to this price and that is that when we learned the price in real time. How did we know to be? We knew it from between the and the but after further review that is an incorrect statement. I know it directly from the I would never be able to learn that from and don't tell me cuz then I'll tell you and if the needed to tell me to know the well then the should have to tell me something to know between the I know from the not from the mahhatad in fact you want to know what I know from the mahhatad I I know the from the mahad. So why did tell me if I know it from the mat? to a situation where it's so we have these two approaches right now in terms of how to go through this par just learn the parish right either it's a and cl with eight or it's a cloud protocol a super eight cloud protocol says the practically speaking What's the in between the two prices? Now the second B is called because I said how do you know the first B is what does it even mean? Rashi says that we're referring to the first time of ism is referred to as Rashi says is because it was these brains were prevalent in all about midash and everyone knew this like today you know rashi then you knew the term which by the way very often is rashi but this was something that was uh per permeated all the mrash and that's why it was referred to by as but the bottom line is what is the practical I know this is a and this is a is okay. You want to know what the is? It's that holes. Let's see it inside. everything that we spoke out of news and it's things that are completely similar to the prat right similar because ka prat but I'm sorry it has to be 100% the prat it has to be has to be one that's just a way of saying has to be 100% similar so therefore being that all the are so it's only these as opposed to anything else And not just the one, the one I don't need to be but that's going to be enough because it's not but it's and if that's the case we're gonna be and if that's the case we anything that's similar And what's similar? What's similar is we're going to be something that's so what's between the first price and the second. So here the speaks out what we spoke at already five times. The first price of the we put a name to the face is in the therefore it's only what's even worse. What's going to be the is going to be one thing the is going to be is going to be in the event that it's according to it's not going to be included according to it's going to be included why why according to it's and according to I just want to speak out two hearts just the first is so if you do the on You would say, "Oh, there's not why is there this holds?" So naturally, move on. It's going to be more inclusive, right? Very, very straightforward. Oh, if it's more inclusive, you be marba more. What do you marba more? you're going to be marba even but just notice in the of the it's a little misleading what we just said because the way we were mar from the clat was really the way we were marsh was not from the clat how we mar the because we argue that the didn't have to say so and from the fact that the said So we were mar from the brought the right let's just meditate on that for a second. We're saying oh between the two braces is why is it ankamina? Is it a clat or is a clat? Oh clat is nothing to be marba. If it's a clat well then there's a a lot to be part it sounds like but 100% wrong. It sounds LIKE OH THE CLOUD BROUGHT TO CLOUD address that was part he said there was no way to do that so how do I know I know because extra but here's the point if it's au then was never EXTRA BECAUSE EVERY PRATT was needed if however you can dish in the parish then is EXTRA BECAUSE I COULD HAVE learned so from a mahhat between the and the using the why did So you're right at the end of the day the emanates from the fact that it's A CLOUD BUT IT'S NOT A DIRECT HIT. IT'S CLICHE BECAUSE that's how I'm going to learn just in the gar very it's this a tricky gum and this is I think a main reason why this is a little tricky that's the first thing needs to be spoken out second spoken out is says the says it's a huge according to nothing else according to I I can't imagine there's nothing to be just to speak out this second a little better after hearing the first right what we just said is that even we're not marba from the we're from the fact that the mentioned so which it didn't have to mention mean that you could dish in the ps of the protocol But it sounds like from this morning you're not even anything from the right what do you mean from the from the you're not even anything I know that from so what are you being it sounds like you're not anything it can't be there's no again this is the but we're just making the cash a little because even is not FROM THE CLOUD THERE HAS TO BE something that's if it's I can't believe there's no so struggles with this second could be there was no other the only was the really doesn't even have any even is only because you didn't have to mention the and the only isn't you'd have to mention the because you so it's like all in that world but the bottom line is the bottom line is says the that's what's going on how could make a cloud over here the cloud and the cloud are not the same right the first cl is a very inclusive claw it sounds like right as long as it as you'd be allowed to eat it. It sounds like it has to be a shouldn't the two have to be similar and they're not similar. The first is very inclusive everything sounds like has to be similar to the similar to the to the it has to be somewhat similar. So is that okay? of is that in a situation like this you could and oh by the way you say even if the two clouds are not similar you want to know where it comes from it comes from this right here actually speaks out very could be the reason didn't learn like and the The reason learned the whole parish as a clu and not as a was because of this it's it's only that was able to learn the because they hold throughout that don't have to be similar to each other but didn't hold that way it's it was aes in the yeshiva of and because they didn't learn this way it's for that reason they held for that reason that They held that all you have is a only we're going with the simplest ter. Yeah, believe it or not, there is noina other than the a welldeserved exhale. So as it relates to raid, just want to say over a maramokuml that Nakimin showed me. This has his signature written all over it and it's from a safer called oneness but I think it's Kadai to give a little bit of a wordy introduction to who exactly the author of the safer styit was. So the styitzk was written by Y whose name was Rabbitzk Gueta. Rabbitzk Gueta was born in Libya and when he was in his 20s he moved to Italy and he spent the rest of his life 50 plus years in Italy. Now Rabbitk Gueta was obviously a big he wasabis for him. He was also a very very wealthy person. And in the introduction to the most recent edition of Galash which was printed by Shalom in the there's a very very long told us of the and talks a little bit about who this was. Incidentally, the first part of the introduction was written by a hagula. But either way, in the told us to the tell a story and this story is the background in terms of how exactly became the phenomenal gir that he was now as it relates to the background of the story. So there's a footnote here. If you have the safe, it's page 13 in the I'm reading from footnote 11. The story that we're about to tell was very famous. This was a well-known story during the lifetime of the first person to tell the story that's in Tunisia. It was printed again in over there. It's referring to this incredible story. The one that we're going to read now this is coming from and this was printed in that's 1934. Either way, this is an exact excerpt of the story. So, the background to it is isa is uh Yid Libya. He's now 20 years old. He moves to Italy to make a parnasa and he got a job working as a shamish working as a butler as an executive assistant for some incredibly wealthy Italian Jew. This is in Lava, Italy. Somebody extremely extremely wealthy. Now it seems that this gir was a very big bout stalker. Now he was a big bstalker but he had a soft spot for the yidden and the yishov that were living in Eritis. And as a result if somebody came from it the shadar by the way just to frame this he was born in the year 1777. So this is late 1700s early 1800s. So when Ashadar would come from Eritrol to Italy, he was the mach would stay by him. You know, that was a good spot. He would give him big and he took very very uh good care of him. Either way, the the Balamisa tells the story. It's a little interesting that this Gir used to like chap a little bit with Ravitzka Gueta. Sounds like he was doing it in justest. You know, I think in 2026, we'd say this is a little on the spectrum of the way you're not supposed to treat somebody, but this is the way he used to deal with him and he he would chapter him a little bit. I'm going to read an excerpt. So there was this big this person he comes and he staying in and he stayed by this by whom used to live and this took care of him the way he always took care of this. He took care of everything that he need when it was time for this to leave town. So their wanted this uh person to you know don't try this at home you call him and you know you're here raising money for a very important cause why don't you call HIM IN AND WHY DON'T YOU ASK him for I mean everyone in town gave you money there's no reason he shouldn't give you let's see how he's going to respond the child comes in front of them after he finishes eating and that's his kid's boss tells He's going back home. He already accumulated all the money he needs. The only thing he's missing. He has everything. He just needs you. Don't cause him any delay. And you give him an appropriate. Give him what it is he needs. Sounds like hippo. But then the goes and he opens up the pinkest that THE he starts telling him gave this gave you know he starts throwing out all the big numbers and then of course he comes to the end you know he mentions his grace and his big that he gave So he turns to this kid and he tells him everyone's giving all this money and you're not giving anything and he can't leave unless he has your inappropriate. go ahead and give him something heard. He ran and he went to his little uh you know pouch where he used to keep his few dollars that he had. He had a few dollars like a few extra coins and he comes and he brings it the and he started counting all of them in front of the and in front of this and it all end added up to one golden coin. The child said, "And he said, if you're willing to give me a give it to you, but I want a from you." They started laughing again. But he found him. They found him. Either way, after spending a little bit of time to him, Rom was very uncomfortable. And you could see he didn't want to take the money. But he told him, "He snore from you the money. Take the money." What I do and he gives me everything. got to go along with it, right? So he goes along with it. was and he says no problem and he give his coke and just picture he takes his little uh thingy I don't want to say piggy bank but he takes his especially not when you're learning and he takes it and he empties it all out into it and as he pours it down then he bends his head down he says he's ready for this when he saw the child and how badly he wanted the and he literally he depleted all his accounts for this. He spread out his two hands on his head. He started to cry. So I give you a and my hope is when I come back to that and you're going to give me the same exact he made sure he locked into the micer and the but he says I'm giving you a should be a big you're going to give me the same exact that your that your master gave Right. He took his hand and he kissed it. Right. And he went on his way. And this is an interesting postcript to this. After the leaves or after the leaves, the went and he said, "By the way, this was all a prank. This was all a joke." And he gave him back all the coins and he gave him back the during that year. One day, this kid is walking by the He's walking by the port of Lava and he sees that there's a big toml, there's some big shipment just came and all the tradesmen are there, all the buyers, all the sellers, and there's like a very very uh big bahol, and he sees they're taking these big uh containers off the ships. People are bidding on it. People want to buy it. Anyways, this child, this innocent child is walking by and he looks and he was like very takenback at a certain uh container that came with a whole bunch of boxes and just spacing out just amazed at what was going on he started pointing at that box. Well, it seems that in Leverne at that time, the way it worked was that if there was a bidding process going on, you know, when they're selling aliyah, you don't want to buy aliyah, like you know, you put your head under your dollars because in the wrong sh you might end up with maf or something that you are looking to buy. So, this person is pointing at this container and it seems that if you pointed at something that qualifies as a bid. Turns out, unbeknownst to this kid, he just bid on this massive container that just came. Now, you're going to ask, who would ever sell it to him? cuz it turns out the sellers there knew who he was. They knew he worked for this, the biggest in town. They assume that this G must have been on it. Anyways, this kid has no idea what he just did. He turns around, goes back home, and you know, to his somewhat abusive existence, right? Couple hours later, the walks outside and all of a sudden He sees all this huge shipment. He's got these suburbans are coming in his direction trying to figure out what's going on over here. Like he turns around that like does anyone know what this is all about? So first he thinks it's the wrong address. there must be some mistake in identity until finally he finds out that his shiking this kid just took Nama without him knowing and he basically just TOOK DOWN THIS HUGE NOW HE TRIED GETTING OUT BUT HE couldn't do it cuz believe it or not based on the done he was stuck with it he was not happy about it but he said okay it is what it is okay I'm going to pick it up inside again couple hours pass he said you know I wonder what's in here like what we what we bought destroy him. Like what do we say? He has no idea what he even asked. Like what is here, right? He's already he calls all his uh guys and he says we have to find brokers. You know, we got to get out of this mess as quickly as we can. You know, ideally find one buyer that takes down the whole shipment, but he has no idea what's flying. But saw was absolutely incredible. and and what he had heard because when he started hitting all of a sudden he starts hearing a strange noise, right? Music to his ears. He starts hearing a little jingling sound. It sounds like coins that are locked up and they're hidden over there. Says, "Bring the sledgehammer." And they come and they whack it, right? And they do a on this thing and all of a sudden that's what it was. I have no idea what this is. But there was some thing that they had bought. The weirdest that he had bought was only the first two or three. But everything inside of it, you know, guilt, right? And became money. He said he stood there for a half hour. He couldn't believe what was going on. And then he remembered something. He remembered the Shadar had given to this N when he was chapping with him. And he remember how he told him, you're going to see I'm going to come back in a year from now. You're going to be a like your master is. And he such because he realized this is for sure the there's no question in the world. There's no question in the world. And he said, "If that's the case, if that's the case, it all belongs to him. It belongs to him because this was never meant for me. This was 100% meant for him." He goes on, he tells the story how they started opening up all the other boxes. It was all money. Every last box was filled with money. The rest of the story is that apparently some pirates had taken over some ship. They had these wears. They came to Lever. They sold it thinking that they were going to make a couple of shekels. Little did they know what was really hidden inside of it. And because of the bra of this uh shad, it all ended up in the hands of this and the thisuva understood what was right and he went ahead and he gave it he gave it to this and it was through this that became an skipping a little bit. Now that he has all this money sitting in an account, he was he decided he wants to learn. He hired a very to teach him. UNTIL HE BECAME SOMEONE AND SO INCREDIBLE HE BECAME A HE IS the fascinating story this is how he becomes but the story doesn't end there at the end of his life he had a he lived till he was 80 passed away in the year 1857 throughout his life really he went in the custom he always felt to the he would always take care of the shad and he would always send money to and his dream was one day to one day to move to the end of his life he made aliyah he moved to when he was invas took his incredible wealth and he invested in the Jewish infrastructure invas so we're all familiar with the earthquake that happened in the year 1837 is famous and there was a lot of destruction that took place is the one that rebuilt built the he rebuilt the he kept the coil over there. He put money into the bakar. In fact, if you go to the in front is a plaque. He is the one that gave the money to rebuild and to rehabilitate. It was because he had this soft spot there. this ro because his ash all came about through what it all came about from this incredible story that took place with the shad he's buried today invas people go to his he's the author of the safest reprinted not so long ago either way this is the story of a story of story of incredible and incredible incredible it's interesting by the way that in his I'm looking at it right now. This is in page he writes he heard that he passed away and he talks about who he was. These are the we all visit today. Forgotten hero from Jewish history. So what does this have to do with more specifically what does this have to do with grasshoppers? Good question. If you take a look on the mission that talks about grasshoppers, this is what he says. I'm going to tell you the truth. When I was younger, it was one winter night. I was in my house and I was locked up. I was learning the grasshoppers. I was learning Rashi who says and Rashi says that the feet four feet and then two other feet just say it has six feet right I mean that would make sense being that it has four wings I couldn't figure out why it can't fly I was trying to visualize in my mind. I'm trying to figure this all out. And as I'm trying to make sense of this, all of a sudden, a bird a grasshopper fell. who was so handsome and I picked it up with my hand and I looked at it and I found all the rashi said on it and I saw on its stomach it has something that looks like a a red and I saw the wings were folded on top of each other and it's probably why it can't fly because it has these double wings in the morning. I brought it to him by name. This is the and in fact this is a an incredible story an incredible story that brings right here that he was going through the grasshopper and he's trying to figure out what's going on here and all of a sudden Adam know he said his house was closed it was so and plitling all of a sudden this grasshopper shows up and he brought it to bes he looked at it And all of a sudden he was able to understand the in the to the so they bring that in 1847 there was a Moscow whose name doesn't have to be mentioned he lived in Triesta so he was an Italian Moscow he wrote believe it or not he wrote a a contress he wrote a mis it's not the original but he wrote a mis it's called and you can't make this up I'm reading here from the of against it's a very thin it has seven pages inside of it very interesting it's very very interesting what is it if you go through it he took this piece this one somebody took the pain to take this one piece over here in he wrote a little seven page on it and he makes lasonas I I'll just read you an excerpt has a good punch line. Right, that's how the piece starts. That's why he says and this is he says that he describes this grasshopper as he says he said so how do you know this was a handsome one? How does he know this is the govern piece after piece and this one point of his whole lutanis HE'S LIKE IT'S IMPOSSIBLE FOR SOMETHING LIKE THIS TO HAPPEN HOW COULD IT HAPPEN YOU'RE SITTING IN A CLOSED ROOM AND ALL OF A SUDDEN a grasshopper showed up and this Moscow couldn't fathom how something like this could take place and imish wrote a to make his point he made notice from him and everybody knows I mean this is the most famous story in the world right everybody knows that not so long ago when he was working on his called which is printed in the he had a mis there's videos of him saying that this story took place by him where the bay was in in such a situation OUT OF NOWHERE EXACTLY what he was looking for was coming so I don't know if this is the same grasshopper or this is a different grasshopper but it's unbelievable and it was interesting like I was thinking not to read this right why would I read this I said okay brings it in so Uh maybe you could read it. I mean the brings it. So why can't you why can't you read it? But then I afterwards it's just the opposite. He brings out you go through this. He can't believe it because it's we know it happened. This is a miracle that we saw with our own eyes saw and was to everybody. This is something that we saw. So to the contrary, this is something that can happen and something that did happen and it didn't happen once. This is something that happened bahava. But it's so interesting that the grasshopper is showing up to help you figure out who he is, right? It's very hard to figure out who the grasshopper is. But you know what the grasshopper does? He shows up just to end with this. I don't know this just the herish I had. I'm going through the gamar, right? We had this windy gamar with the clal pros and the cloud pros claus. I just want to read an excerpt. Don't worry about it. But just to read one excerpt. those words, right? This is only true if the grasshopper comes and he has no if he comes. Go through every single cloud. I didn't go through all of them. HOW DO YOU KNOW? WHAT'S THIS? WHAT DOES THIS WORD MEAN? I I COULDN'T touch the word. I had to prepare. I didn't know how to type the word. I looked in every art. I couldn't figure out what does it mean. It means if the ARISH COMES AND HE LOOKS LIKE THIS, HE LOOKS LIKE THAT. WHAT'S GOING ON OVER HERE? COULD be there's a remedal away in this Arab used to show up. I don't know why doing I have no idea. Right. Makus Arab these are the barbell said the gaga god of gil came from the I have no idea but the bottom line is the used to show up this if he shows up and you know you look at it but maybe a little bit of a that word don't know what it's doing here and it mentions it 20 times GO THROUGH IT WHY why is why is what do you mean habo when was the last time a grasshopper showed up at your front door the terror says it's happened and it happened more than once it happened in 19th century Italy by Rabitzkua happened more recently in 20th century Penbra by Ra Kfski. Either way, this is the story of the He