Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Chulin 60
5 views
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Today's DF is
and we are at the two dots in the middle
of
today's being learned as a
so in the previous
we turned the page literally not only in
voice, but really in the entire
and we began the portion of
that deals with how we know when an
animal is kosher versus not kosher. A
behemma
uh fish, a bird, even a grasshopper. And
this is really going to usher in a whole
series of daffin and raid that relates
to one of the most fundamental aspects
of Yiddish guide and that is kosher
versus non-coosher and what the
definition of kosher versus non-cooser
is at the very end of the previous dam
brought a bry the mak to that is theft
right here in that discussed what are
the simonym of aaya [snorts] versus a
meaning not what of a kosher but within
the world of kosher animals how do you
know if something is a how do you know
if something is a
of a isser
in fact it's so it's like eating it's
like eating on it carries with it of the
of is so obviously it behooves us to
know how Does one know the difference
between what a is versus what a behemoth
is? I know it's kosher, but can I eat
the if it's a I can't eat the if it's a
I can't eat the and the B has said that
here's the rule. In the event that the
animal has
then it's and you're going to be able to
eat the in the event that it doesn't
have and that means it's about and you
won't be able to eat the at the end of
that there was one line the as it
relates to the animal of the
even though it has only one Karen. So it
has a Ken but doesn't have. So is it a
kaya or is it a behem? Again the
definition of a kaya is car
is it doesn't have caray. Well the kes
has one kin. So do you say it has one so
that's more than none or do you say it
only has one which is less than two said
the keres even though it has only one
kin the of the is going to be mut. Now
the first line of today's daf is going
to be a mera that the great amay rahuda
said and that is defining what exactly
this kesh is. So it's some interesting
animal has one horn. Sounds a little
like a unicorn maybe. I don't know. But
it has one horn and as a result it has a
unique status in the world of kin
because it's somewhere in between the
kay and the beah. It's bashmas. The kaya
has two horns. The b has no horns. Well
this has one horn. Hence we have this
conversation. But after the Gumarra
brings this one line, not even a line
from Rab Yehuda defining what exactly
the car is, the Gmorra is going to
digress and this digression is going to
take us through the end of the DA into
tomorrow's d even the digression
is going to be
in fact some of the more often quoted a
in comes from one D tucked away here in
Dam I think in the middle of parake
Krafus. This is a very welcome
digression. So today's DAFF is very
different than most of the previous DAN
that we've been learning. Very different
than a lot of the daffin that we are
going to learn very much a light
breather.
So on that note, so again the B said the
even though it has only one Ken we view
it as a is going to be most said
[snorts]
you want to know what the Kish is. It's
the deer that roams that's native to the
forest of Elo. So there was a place
called Eloy and there were deer there.
That's this car Tigris Rabuda said. By
the way, on the topic of bey tigris,
which was a certain type of kaya is
that's the lion that was found in Elo.
[snorts] So Eloy was some region and
there were animals there. the
the of that's this the
lion that was in that's this says the on
the topic of the
is so big its head is so wide that if
you were going to measure from ear to
shining ear you would find that it's 9
long which is approximately 18 ft. This
is a serious monster
said
as it relates to the deer this
so you want to know how long it is it's
16 long that's approximately 32 ft so
this place was clearly a place you don't
want to be hanging out but the bottom
line is these
are very unusual creatures on that note
says
the
muscle. You know the Pik says that is
compared to a lion said it
vibes
is referring to and the roy told
you know I know you make a big deal
about this bos wow your god is like a
lion and when he roars who's not afraid
[snorts] but my ravi I think you're
underelling cuz para katalar let's be
honest a good sniper a good sharpshooter
can take out a lion so if Your god is
merely a lion. Well, I don't think he's
even that strong. Told the guy. Oh, you
think he's just like an ordinary lion
muscle? He's like this.
So the said interesting you know what if
that's the case but you know the I'd
like to see the de meaning you're
telling me is not like a regular lion
but he's like this legendary lion. I'd
like to see the deo.
you told him it's impossible. You can't
see him. He told him I'm the case.
Nothing's impossible and if he exists,
you're going to show him to me. So had
no choice
and left its natural habitat and it
started making its way towards Rome. par
when it was 400 par away from Rome.
It gave a rom and
all the pregnant women in one second
they all miscarried their children
because of this shrek that they got from
the roar of this line and not just that
the wall that surrounded the city of
Rome fell down
when it came a little bit closer now was
only 300 paras away it gave another roar
and
And people's teeth and mers braces
started falling out all over the place.
It was such a shrek from what this lion
was doing. And even the case,
he fell off his throne onto the ground.
There was some sort of earthquake.
Something very very dramatic took place.
You know something? Maybe I uh overstep
my boundaries. Can you please do me a
favor
cuz I don't know what's going to happen
when it comes 200 paris away and 100 par
away. And then when it's actually at the
doorstep of my palace so I think I've
seen enough or I've heard enough send
them back. The says
and the lion returned back. So we just
mentioned in exchange that happened
between the
does what it always does in these
settings. It digresses and then
digresses from its digression.
I want to see your guts. This is similar
to the previous story. In the previous
story, the like
and the says I want to see. That didn't
go well. Now he said, you know
something, I want to see.
You can't see. Right. Even tried that
and it didn't work.
I'm going to see him. I want to see him.
So told the case, let's go outside. So
he took him out. It was a day like
today. And he had him stand outside told
him look at the sun,
right? I need my sunglasses. I can't
look at the sun. So he told him the day
or the sun
which is one of the it's one of the
servants of
you're telling me you can't look at
how you going to look at the it's not
something you can do third exchange
told
I'd like to prepare a meal
for your guy I'd like to feed him told
says, "No, it's not possible. It's just
not something you could do." Now, the
truth is, could you serve food on the
proverbial level? The answer is yes.
That's what a carbon is.
in
in the parish that deal with all the
carbon
explained that really the Mishkan was
set up as the residence of and that's
why there was a and that's why there was
food that was brought meat and wine and
carbs in the form of the but either way
the case I'd like to just deliver him a
meal told him it's not possible so he
said I might why not gave him a clever
answer he told him the
Because when arrives he comes with his
whole pomalia and as a result you have
no idea what a big banquet you would
have to prepare you would have to make
I'm telling you this is not something
you could do
no I want to do it and I'm going to do
it says okay you want to do it do it so
he told him go out
you should go to the banks of the river
of
it's a very big area right you can fit a
lot of people there so if you want to
make a big party that's a good location
and he said that's where you should set
up shop.
So the queser went he hired a staff and
a team and they spent the six summer
months preparing the suda at the end of
the summer a wind came
and what it did was it took the entire
meal and everything that was set up this
tent I don't know what was going on
there and it swept it into the sea.
Then he spent the next 6 months, the six
months of the winter preparing another
meal. This time rain came and again it
swept it into the sea and it all uh
sunk. So the case told what's going on
over here why can't uh all of a sudden
out of nowhere the elements are taking
out my meal
told him
this is the the mopup crew right these
are the cleaners of the sweepers and
these are the that came they ate from it
and then they cleaned up after them
meaning this is just like one tiny
of the crew of you couldn't even feed
them so I said, "You know something? If
that's the case,
I tend to agree. I think this wasn't
such a good idea." Another exchange.
So, the first three exchanges that we
had were between the
first time he wanted to see the second
time he wanted to seek. The third time
he wants to prepare a meal for now, it's
the daughter of the
Your God is a carpenter. How do I know
that? Morayesh
made the roof of May. But it sounds like
works, you know, he's an artisan. He's a
carpenter. He makes roofs. The say is
[snorts] that the daughter of the case
was trying to say that didn't create the
world. Meaning that went and he built a
roof on top of something that had
already existed. But really
didn't create a yesh. This was the
belief of Aristom
and this was what the of the daughter of
the queser was and she came but in a
mocking way and she said
I'd like him to please make for me a
misa. So what's a misa? So the English
word is a bobin. What exactly is that?
So once upon a time when people sewed
and they would weave so they had their
needles they would stick it into some
implement right that's where they would
put the needle that was tied to their
threads she said make me some
said you want au the quote unquote
carpenter to make this for you no
worries
went to din and heaven
this daughter of the became a mitzy
And because she was a mitz, she sat in
the streets of Rome.
And they gave her this. They gave her
this misa. Why? Because the custom in
Rome was
any person that was.
And this would sit in the shook and
would take the things out of the bobin
into the bobin. This was a way of being
everybody that this person was a
messiah. So it's a strange custom but
this is what they were na in Rome. The
bottom line is she got what she asked
for. Right? She said that I want a to
make for me a misa she became a mitz and
once she's with ms by default this is
the way they used to treat the mits I
see the way right says
the reason they used to do this was that
people should know that the people would
for them one day was walking by
and he sees the daughter of the is
sitting out in the street and playing
around with um this babin
told her mis tell me you like the misa
that you got cuz if not I could try to
order a better one a nicer one are you
okay with what you got said do me a
favor
can you please go back to your god and
tell him to take back what he already
gave me said I'm sorry cuz we have a
once he gives something he never takes
it back and no he gave you something I'm
sorry this is something that you are
going to be stuck with. Either way, this
concludes the first portion of today's
daf. Not so intimidating, right? You
don't need pictures for this daf. This
concludes the first part of today's daf
that deals with the exchange is
between
and the first three were with the fourth
one was even with the daughter of keser.
Now the truth is that we know from
different places in shasta
had many many exchanges with the of this
is something that is in several places
most notably
where he has the famous debate with the
but this is again a in something that's
interesting that you know we've talked
about so many times over the years and
that is you know we're familiar with the
tan and more from their teachings. So we
know Rab Yeshua is the bout of Rabazar
but obviously there's an issot that uh
underpinned these uh great great sadikim
and no two sadikin were the same in
terms of the way they [snorts]
interacted with people and what exactly
their aid was and one of the hats the
banana wore was he was this incredible
asin and he was a pale Yeshua because of
the the protector that he had with the
Roman government and that's why there's
so many different gumaras that talk
about this special kayak rabish had and
we've spoken so much about rebel over
the years rebelazzar 28 years old rebel
the nidoy and that took place at the end
of rebel's life the muik of rabia
etc etc rahua who is bpla so the visual
is very very different but the most
notable aspect of rahua is is this
unique
place that he had within the Roman uh
government circles. He was a nickn over
there. He had the respect of the
officials and like the Gmorra says in
different places because of that he was
able to be po Yeshua either way one of
them for that is says the
so for a brief moment I mean literally a
brief moment the returns to the regular
program and talks a little bit about
animals and their horns and their hooves
etc. Yehuda said an axe.
He has a wide stomach
and he also has very wide hooves.
He has a big head
and he also has a very long and a very
big tail
as it relates to the it's just the
opposite. He has a narrow stomach. His
hooves are narrow. His head is not big
and his tail is not so big either. says
the
why does this matter? Right? Why are you
telling this to me? Says the no it does
matter because if somebody sells a you
better make sure that it checks off
these boxes. It has a
if somebody sells a you have to know
what he's selling. So it's
if somebody sells one of these animals
what the expectation to get in return
is. So we just mentioned now the hooves
and the horns of the
The ax that was m so brought a carbon
around the time that he was born and
that sh was a unique
number one it had only one horn like the
kerish at the beginning of the dra how
do you know that the says
mafris this is a hill is the one that's
talking obviously and he tells I want my
that I'm telling you to
and more than the paraff and it's a
reference to the that was m now what's
the it says mine and the understands now
that mine is a now should have two horns
why one oh so you see from here that the
brish had one horn but the says mrash
why is mashma one if it said I would
understand but mr is actually more of a
two macron it says the Word without the
Y it's like me Karen Karen and that's
the paras of the horns were born were
created before the paras war. So this is
out of the ordinary because usually an
animal's born with its hooves and it's
only afterwards that the horn develops.
But's case
the actually came out
and that's why it comes out that
now one second only the horn was there
and not the paras the answer is no
really everything was there as we'll see
in a second but at the same time when
the animal emerges it emerges head first
so what emerged first what emerged first
was the karen and that's why it's kind
of kite
where paras says the what's the
martition the we just mentioned the seat
of lashem
first the father mafris and afterwards
the [snorts] process so the bottom line
is two things we learn from this vita
mafim
the first thing we learn from there is
that the marisham brought had only one
horn the second thing that we learn from
there is is that the horn Horns were
created before the parasites or they
emerged to the before the paraso. What's
the usually a is not born with a torrent
but here was born with a torren says
this member of the second mess
said oh my
oh my when they were born they were born
they were they came out fullsized not
just
created meaning they were told that they
were going to be born and they were born
and not just that they were born
that they themselves had chosen. How do
you know this? It says
that's referring to the last of the
three things that we just mentioned
means. They were created in the that was
chosen for them. It was something that
they were aware of and it was something
that they signed off on. So said that
when the world was created beginning of
time
it came
everything was created full size they
had they were told before they were
created that they were going to be
created and it was also in that they had
chosen but the bottom line is what we
need is the first thing
that supports what said
usually the doesn't develop its horns
until later is the was different. It was
that when it's going to have the horns
therefore it was created
another me related to
said [snorts] the following
that everybody knows. What does this
mean?
This P was said by the Now who exactly
is the
says that the is the
by the way on this right here who says
but is the soal
when did he say it
>> [snorts]
>> Now
said this to the trees that when the
trees emerge from the ground they should
come out. What does that even mean? So
what it means is that each tree should
be individual and they shouldn't all be
together but aruas. So you have this
type of tree, you have that type of
tree. They should be distinct. They
should all be in their own little
dalamus. They should all come out
separate from each other. says the
at that point the grass made they said
as follows
wants that when we emerge we should not
be we should be
why would say
the point is this if you look in the
when tells the tree to from on the
ground who says it should be eight
by the grass. It doesn't say but when
the grass heard that told the trees that
you should come out leino so the grass
said one second if the
trees which are
are told to become lei shouldn't we be
the same way and it's not just oh if the
trees so to us it's not just it's a
the trees which naturally don't come
be careful and don't come
that we naturally come right the grasses
are all
certainly we have to be
it was for that reason all the blades of
grass came out how do you know that
because the
even though never told the grass to come
out
And they came out
when the saw this got up and said,
"What does this mean?" He says
that because you see
in the mitzvah of that the grass was
from the gave the trees. How exactly
would want the grass to be? And it was
not when the saw how the Bria is
subordinate to the
so the said
again this last was a little nuance in
the
tells the third day of creation the
trees to emerge says they should come
out the grass it doesn't say they should
come out but when you see me it says the
grass also came never told the grass
lino why they come lino the terret says
The reason is they made a and was that
if wants the trees that are not
naturally
to be careful and still not to be than
us who are naturally certainly we have
to be careful not to be they went ahead
and they did the of and this was
considered an unbelievable expression of
and it gave incredible
said
on this note the asks an interesting
question
if somebody would make a collion he
would take two different types of
grasses and he would be he would graft
them together
according to who was who said that the
grass were never told to come what would
be would it be an is there not in his
sky. So we're familiar with the is there
with two grasses or not? Now what's the
reason uh to say not cuz Hashem never
said the grass has to be lino. So if I
go ahead and I take two grasses and I
make them together being that there was
never at for them to be lino maybe it's
not meaning by trees we know there's an
Indian of but that's maybe because
but by the grasses who never said it so
maybe over there or maybe do we say
to what the grass
so maybe it's as if it's and it's for
reason to be a problem and says take on
the one that there was never a lumin but
then at the same time they went ahead
and they emerged so I could hear that
maybe there would be an maybe not maybe
not because there was no maybe yeah
because that's the way they emerged and
the says for this we're going to have to
wait for
the says again we're digressing now
within In the the context of
it says
I think this is a everybody knows
there's another says
which one was it created the sun and the
moon on the one hand the says they were
and then in the next breath it says
which would suggest one was big and the
other one was small. Are they both big
or is one big and one small? Says the
created the sun and the moon. So the
moon,
isn't it possible to have two kings that
are going to share one crown? Meaning
the
the king so to speak on this world. How
could you have two that are going to
share the mus? How could it be a sun and
a moon that are both going to be king?
Allah told the moon, you're right.
You're 100% right.
I want you to make yourself smaller.
It's like this. You won't be the king.
There'll be one king and you won't be
the king.
I ask a good and this is the reward.
RIGHT? I WAS TOLD I ASKED THE GOOD YOU
SHOULD REWARD ME FOR MY GOOD. Why are
you punishing me for my good? Says the
told the moon I hear what you're saying.
I feel bad. I feel bad. But at the same
time, I'm going to give you a little bit
of an because he did ask a good kasha
and it's technically unfair for you to
lose out so badly.
I'm going to give you something that
you'll be able to be by day and by
night. Meaning the sun you only see
during the day. You don't see it at
night. But the moon sometimes you can
see by day as well. So you can be that
you can be by night.
So the moon told the myan
it's very nice that you could see the
moon sometimes during the day but it's
not giving off any light it's not doing
anything it's not beneficial in any way
because what is the value of a of a
light during the day right
of fame right there's there's no value
in it
I'm going to give you something else I'm
going to give you when is going to the
months and all
It's all going to be based on you,
right? We count a lunar year, not a
solar year.
It's true that the primary calendar that
we use is the lunar, but the solar also
plays a role, right? That's
has to fall out in that time. So, we do
make sure through the to align
the solar and the lunar, which means the
sun is also playing a role. So, it's a
you're not really giving me that much.
And it's fact, it's a
and is and it's referring to the two
that I mentioned earlier in the either
way.
Yeah, I'll give you a different zill
just go
says what I'm going to give you is
thatim
are going to be referred to the same way
you're referred to. You're the [ __ ] and
this is something that you're not happy
about that moniker is something that
the greatest of the great are going to
be referred to
saw that despite the fact that he
seemingly gave something pretty cool to
the moon but the moon wasn't happy
says well if that's the case I feel like
I must have uh done something wrong.
We can't even say these words out of our
mouth. Who said I need what it is I did
and I want the yidden to bring what's
the
find that often not in the context of
the but
it says over there regarding the
the special that was brought with the
wasap
for me. Why do I need aap?
because
now this we just uh went through and
we're going to go that you know over the
years we've referred to so many times
in tomorrow's raid we're going to
revisit this
as the
said the says
when does it say that
on the third day of creation that's when
the trees all the vegetation
but the problem is another it says
And that's referring to after the
militia was born which was the Malish
was anab. So uh when was the vegetation
created was it on the third day or was
it says and what we learn from here is
that really on the third day all the
began to
but it's remained underground literally
at the doorway proverbially speaking of
the ground. So it's there. It's it's
budding. It's sprouting, but it's it's
[laughter] not coming out yet because
the car's holding [snorts] it back until
came
that they should come
and
it rained and caused
because really he was ready to beat
without but Hashem wanted and he figured
there's a good way to get because
needs things to Bro
will fulfill his so to speak of having
but the bottom line is it's true that on
some level created on another level it's
they were created they were literally at
the entrance way of the until and that's
when everything came out says the on
that note
had a gina had a garden so earlier we
had
now we
Papa, right? 10 sons
and
papa took seeds and planted it in the
garden of nothing came out
rain came and everything started to grow
and he said
this is I'm living a microcosm of what
said happened in the beginning of time
in the beginning of and by the way we're
going to stop here but this last is
fascinating because you see that this is
the tea uh of how things grow
created in the tea, right?
Is the tea. This is
that there's an idea that of course the
world had to have agitation and created
already on the third day but ultimately
without feel nothing was able to come.
So a person could do all the in the
world but when it comes to
that's the over here it needs
did everything created everything by but
he needed a little bit of and that one
and that's what caused everything to
come. It's possible a person could have
things that are literally at the
doorstep of being of coming out of being
but there's that that's needed to take
it out and this is something that was
literally back into the original
created all the
everything but it needed a to bring it.
Who knows what we have waiting for us
that we need that one
that might be able to bring it out.
Either way, we're going to come up for
breath, exhale, pick up with some more
aada, and then return to our regular
program, then come back to some more ag.
But for now, as it relates to raid, two
from
both on the same gar. So theor had
mentioned
the was
a very unique sh this had developed its
horns before its hoof. So ordinarily a
sh is born with its hooves and it
doesn't develop horns until later. But
the sh of was
first it says mine. the mafris and then
it says mafris. So you see the mak
before the mafus what's the beer in it
the beer in it is saying that the sh
that was mak was born literally fully
matured and being that a fully matured
has horns this also had horns now it had
hooves as well because a fully matured
sh has hooves so why was
it's because it came out head first and
therefore the karnov emerged into the
one before the paristed
This supports something that said I'm
call
were created full height
and they were created meaning they were
given the option to be born or not to be
born
and not just that they chose the in
which they were going to be born as the
says
So
supports what said and that is myas when
they were created
and they were created as well
in kadoshim paras vious.
So he brings a vious theious rabb says
on that
is the
and he said
not
but
what does the word mean?
It's some sort of deer and created man
like a deer. What does that even mean?
So the medish goes on and the medish
explains that just like a deer
is fully developed. So too was created
fully developed.
And added to that he said when they were
born
they were born as if they were 20 years
old. This is a medish on the
now at first glance this medish is to
the me of which is
said that were created and that's why
the
was
so you see
which is an interesting way of bringing
out the point. But the point is is that
were created already complete and added
one. He said what does it mean they were
complete? They were
but if you take a look at the medish
they all struggle. Why 20 years old? Why
is that the magic number? Why were they
created like they were 20, not 19, not
21 or frankly for that matter not 30 or
40 or 50? What's the
created 20 years old? If you take a look
in the pirish of the maru, it's one of
the maf on the side of the classic
bracious. So the marzu says that
[snorts] is because the scientists claim
going back to the ble he said but the
scientists claim that when a person
reaches the age of 20 he stops growing.
So a person grows up until the age of 20
but once he reaches the age of 20 at
that point he stops growing and the
truth is it's
in the beginning of so we know the says
the beginning
was told to take a to count every but
not every it was only
why when they're 20 years old said Evan
Ezra says because
when a person is 20 his DS has developed
and at that point he's not going to grow
anymore again
usually a person stops growing when he's
20 years old and it's for that reason
you START COUNTING FROM 20 BECAUSE YOU
ONLY START COUNTING once the person is
already
that you want to know why said 20 he
said because this is
and it's
because when a person turns 20 at that
point he already reached his full height
Right? And the point that [snorts]
was trying to say was that and were
created fully developed in their full
height. It's not it's what's to
me
and this is the same idea. It's
and that's this point of the fact that
they were created 20 because 20 is an
age that you find is already
he brings that the
classic uh commentary on the bracious
rabbi. He brings another he brings this
in the name of
why did say they were 20 years old? Is
it because we know that Bezdon shamat
doesn't punish a person until he becomes
a godle? At what age do you become a
god? When you're 13 years old. But be
shaw doesn't punish a person until the
person is 20 years old. Rash brings in
two places. Rash brings in the beginning
of par also brings it in par.
This isn't
punish until the person turns 20. The
says that malus on this world is 39
malus. It's
but we know that the Gmorra says that
whenever they give malus it's
right it's 16 mus
what's the he said is because malus is
always a 3x it's three times the minimum
age of when you can be punished I mean
that the minimum age of punishment on
this world is 13 malus is 13 * 3 it's 39
the minimum age is 20 * 3 AND AS A
RESULT it's 60 but either way this is a
dua that sh doesn't punish a until he's
20 years old said
that we know that other the day he was
born he sinned what was the sin he ate
from the sadas and when other ate from
the
punished him you think it was the
punishment of all punishments and was
told that you're going to have to return
to the ground you're going to die
[laughter] was punished right they were
both punished
how could
be punished. They weren't 20 YEARS OLD.
THEY WERE SO IF you're how can you be
punished doesn't punish until you're 20?
The terror is
they were 20 years old and we know they
were 20 years old. That's how they were
born. So therefore, THEY CAN BE
PUNISHED. AND THERE'S NO PROBLEM WITH
THE FACT THAT THERE'S NO PROBLEM WITH
THE fact that they weren't 20. A peasant
doesn't punish UNTIL YOU'RE 20. THAT'S
GOOD for was coming to say
after it brings the
is obviously a pun.
Why? He said because although it's true
that bezen doesn't punish a person until
the person's 20.
That's because we assume that a person
until he's 20, his d is not fully
developed. And they don't punish until a
person is fully developed.
but [laughter]
that was created.
It's it's that
wouldn't apply. What's the
kash is that the fact that a person
becomes mitzvah when he's 13, he becomes
when he's 13. That's right. It's a
mitzvah. We know the rough says in the
chu that it's from the
so that's a that's
until a person's 13 years old it doesn't
matter how intelligent he is how smart
he is he's going to be punished but as
it relates to
with regards to
that's because we assume there's a
certain
that a person doesn't have until he's 20
by the way it's a
with that a child is not let his
father's
ka assuming he inherited it until he
turns 20 years old because until he's 20
we assume that on some level his hasn't
been fully developed but the point is
that as it relates to
that's not like a that's not
that's because we assume usually
speaking until you're 20 but if somebody
is a a bent and he's a a genius he's
brilliant and you know he's a and he
walked down the knowing like a mull
So you going to tell me a person like
that is not
of course he is and as a result that
person could be punished even if he's
less than 20 by the way just to go down
memory lane for a second is in this and
that is we spoke about this once right
spoke about it more than once the
[snorts]
famous
where the tells the story about
a very young who was rabbi brought to be
in the the makdash. That was the deal.
And uh sees that all the people are
running trying to find a kite. He says,
"Why are you trying to find a ken?"
Says, "Cuz we have to sh the carbon and
we need a kite to do the says what do
you mean? Everyone knows." And they
bring him to a and a says, "You're
saying very good, but
is
we know the rest is history." the marsh
I don't understand was going to get
misdi
was a little boy he was a kon and if
he's a kon how could he be punished as
it's wasn't going to give it's posit
that a wasn't going to give misd
but what a wasing was that
and they were going TO PUNISH
HE SAYS, "I KNOW WHAT YOU'RE TALKING
ABOUT. YOU HAVE TO BE EVEN older for
they have to be 20. You're telling me
that it wasn't that he wasn't uh 13.
It's that if you're not 13, I have to be
be punished." But it's what do you mean
for that you have to be even seven years
older?
when it comes to being punished
even though there's a number of 20 but
really there's a concept there's a
concept of having a child who's fully
developed he's mature beyond his years
and as a result someone like that could
be punished and it was clear to a that
IS A CHILD PRODIGY he's a budding
superstar and clearly he developed at a
much more rapid pace
that's a there you can't just give
somebody mis says I don't care how smart
how intelligent this person is. But when
it comes to shim the number of 20 is
really
and that is it's not a number it's not
an age and if it's not an age it's not
going to be an issue
a little but he says he saw this that
says the reason he had to be 20 because
otherwise he could have been punished
it's not true 20 is not a real number 20
is just we assume at that point the
person is is fully developed was clearly
fully developed before he would have
reached the age of 20 so you don't have
to be madik that He was born 20 years
old. HE WAS BORN ONE DAY OLD. BUT this
was and because it was for that reason
this one. This is the second shot that
the say what's the
memb
which Ezra quotes in the beginning of
pariso and that is that a person reaches
his full height when he's 20 years old
and it's the ladies
brings this
by the way this piece the brings all the
different uh that could be the brings it
and others bring this and that is the
idea being was because usually in they
don't punish until somebody turns 20 but
we're going to be punished must be they
were created already
I want to suggest
maybe you could say
that uh is really very novel in terms of
why and would have suggested that a
person has to be 20 years old and that
is that it's yuda and
that a person doesn't just have one but
a person has five nephesh ru
and the kadash with his brings as a
marumakim to this the play Yeshua
Yeshua says that every person has a
that's something that's
as it relates to that's the fourth level
of that's something only
refers to it as like
that's what is and that's something only
the great ones as relates to that's the
highest
The only person that was ever
was but the bottom line is there's five
levels of three of them to every person
that take a look in the so was written
by he was the of the great great
[laughter]
this is a
he says as follows
When a child is born
and he emerges into this world,
he gets his
that's the lowest level of soul
and if he's going to behave properly
when he turns 13, he's going to be to
the second level. And that's the level
of
because that's when you become a proper
and you know what happens at that time?
What happens at that time is that's when
a person gets the rook
and if the person's going to continue
going the right way
when he turns 20 years old at that point
he's going to be
there's three levels of that everybody
is and that is
but they don't come in one shot they
come in phases when a person's born when
he becomes mitzvah it's and when he
becomes comes 20 years old. At that
point,
when does a person get? He gets when
he's 20 years old.
When he was created, THE SAYS
he was born with. When does a person get
to? You get to when you're 20 years old.
not not physically they were tall like
they were 20 years old not
that now all of a sudden they could get
they don't have to be 20 years old to
get because you see
even though he wasn't
means the spiritual makeup because
ordinarily until a person's 20 doesn't
have
was created
means He was
you get when you're 20 like [laughter]
the said like said if that's the case
that's
and he says
that HE WAS CREATED FULL
what does it mean that he was created
full means
what's the in what way was
It's because
it's because he was not only to the not
only to the but he was to the as well
and because he was to the that's where
it was that he was created from the
truth is this is very very insightful in
terms of understanding mitzvah in terms
of understanding you know 20 which is a
huge huge number, right? In as much as
we said, oh, 20 is lava, but it's lava
dafka, meaning there's exceptions to the
rule, but as a rule, it's a it's a huge
huge number. When a person turns 13, so
obviously he becomes a right now, but
it's not only based on a physical
maturation,
but really there's an component to this
as well. The said that when a person is
a he only has a nephesh and when a
person's at a bar mitzvah I don't know
if a bar mitzvah boy has ever been told
this but when somebody becomes mitzvah
he's to
his different his spiritual makeup is
already he goes from being someone that
has a nephesh now all of a sudden he has
a ru and then when he turns 20 he's the
20 year old birthday right you know
people have a minute they fast the day
that 20 they stay up the whole night and
they learn right there's different
It's because yeah, there's something
real happening. It's not just a number.
He's being now to this is like a even a
nicer thing. But to all three of these
things and because he was all three
things that's
because that is where it was manifest
that he was created.
He was created
that's the first R the second R which is
shorter and that is
the says
funny right make sure you make a on your
roof because otherwise if somebody falls
you're going to be guilty and the way
the Torah describes The person that
falls is
what does means?
This person that fell in this PK was
and had already been decreed and
predetermined literally from the
beginning of time that one day this
person was going to fall
because this person didn't fall yet.
as if to say this Pik is already saying
that all the people that are going to
fall and we're referring to them as
being
that it was already predetermined that
the person that falls was going to fall
if that's the case. So why is the person
that didn't make a
but there's an idea that anything that
happens to a person was already
predetermined. Fate had already decided
that this was going to happen and it was
decided so long ago. It was decided
already.
The question is what does this uh even
mean? Right? The question is what does
this even mean? See brings from the
recante who that really the whole of my
when the world was created in that lied
the potential for everything that was
going to happen. Now it didn't happen
yet but the the seeds had already been
planted for all those things to happen.
Now how does this reconcile with free
will and okay this is and this is
obviously way beyond the scope of this
raid but the point is there is an idea
of
the course of
brings on this
all things that are created.
When they were created, they were
created knowing how they were going to
be created.
And told them at the time that they were
created all the things that were going
to happen to them.
that before a person's born tells the
person every single thing that's going
to happen to him in his life. He tells
him all the challenges he's going to
have. He tells him all the good things
and he tells him all the bad things.
The is going to come easy. It's going to
be difficult. You're going to have it on
your own. you're going to have to come
on to other people says
and all of this a person is on himself
before he comes into this world before a
person enters this world he's told
exactly what his life is going to be
like and he says are you interested or
are you not interested
THAT'S WHAT IT MEANS THIS PERSON KNEW IT
WAS COMING TO HIM BECAUSE he was
actually told before he came to the
world everything that was going to
happen. And not only was he totally
signed off on it, in other words is
saying that this
comes down on this world before he
emerges, he's told what his life is
going to be and he signs off on it. He
says, "I'm okay with this." And that's
why when this person falls, it's
because this person was already aware of
the fact that he was going to fall. It
just punct happened today. But he knew
that it was going to happen. Not did he
know it was going to happen? He signed
off on it. At the end of this piece, the
kadash quotes again from the
from
the great [clears throat] great this is
and we'll end with
he says quote
is prepared to send a new soul into this
world who sends the malik That's he's in
charge of all the souls and he pulls out
and turns to the nephesh and he talks to
it. He says he
want you to enter your spiritual the
physicality of this
because your body your physical is going
to come from this.
And then he tells the Malik, I want you
to take this nef bring it to this tip.
And he says, I want you to show him,
listen to this, a showcase of different
gim, different bodies and DIFFERENT
POSSIBILITIES OF WHAT your life might
look like. And he shows him a tall
person, a short person, a person who's
complete, a balm. He shows him a kal,
somebody that's weak, a ge, somebody
that's strong, someone that's handsome,
a someone that's not so handsome. say
literally customize yourself. I want you
to go I want you to choose exactly what
you're going to want to look like when
you're on this road. And then the Malik
tells this nephesh that I want you to
know. So
that this world that you're about to go
to is referred to this is going to be a
very short uh very transient existence.
You're going to be here for a couple of
years. If you maybe a little bit more
than that, but at some point you're
going to expire. you're not going to be
here anymore.
And afterwards, you're going to be and I
want you to know that the decision you
make for what you want yourself to look
like and how you want to feel and be in
this world is going to impact the way
you're going to be and what you're going
to look like the way you're going to
feel in THE OTHER WORLD. IN FACT, THEY
tell him
if you're going to be in this world
could be lost and you're going to be a
and he says if you're going to be very
wealthy in this world maybe in the next
one you're going to be poor or vice
versa. He says I want you to understand
you're not just deciding for this world
because the decision you MAKE FOR THIS
WORLD WILL actually impact could be in
the reverse what you're going to be in
the other existence. [laughter]
And then the tells him you get to
choose. You get to decide how exactly it
is you want to be.
Says there's some there's some
they say you know what I want to have a
good run on this world. I want a good
hundredyear run on this world. And
that's what
but then there are people that are
smarter. They're that get it and they
say you know what I'm going to be in
this world and I'm going to I'd rather
have it good in the next world. Skipping
a little bit says,
"A person can never have tess.
Why is my friend better looking than
me?" [laughter]
Because everything you chose this, you
picked this body. You have kindness. YOU
SHOULD HAVE KINDNESS on yourself. And by
the way, you were smart when you picked
it because you understood this is a
transient existence and it's for me to
be a little bit from my years on this
world because like this I know that in
the next world I'm going to have it good
meant when they said
you can almost never hear these words
the same way again.
is this something you're interested and
Hashem told us to every person and to
every being every existence when we came
down on this world we came down with
it's a fascinating idea it's a fact we
can't remember what happened before we
were born right but uh we existed before
we were born and in that existence we
actually picked and we chose the we have
in this life and the things that are not
so perfect and
This these are things that we chose.
These were things that we picked. And
when we did it, we were clever. We were
smart because we understood that people
need to see us in this world. And we
felt that this was something that we can
handle. And in our infinite wisdom that
we had at that point, we realized this
is this is a good thing. This is this is
you want to have Tus look in the mirror.
That's who you have to have titus on
[laughter] because you picked it
are all for our good because really
really
and every time a person has a little bit
of an he should realize that he took
this upon himself and he did it because
he was
and he was a and he realized it's for me
to be a little bit knowing knowing
what's waiting for me
Here from the first and the second and
this is classic
and we'll stop Yeah.