Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
There's a well-known
story
about a mechanich
from Israel
named
Alexander
Benun, and he was affiliated with the
with the rashid with the network
of
Aliyah Yitzchak,
a network of Chabad schools in Israel.
And
in the course of his working with the
schools,
he came up with
the 10 divrei
of Chanoch, like 10 fundamental rules of
education.
And he was in with the Rebbe
and he shared with the Rebbe his 10
Chanoch rules
based on his experience running these uh
this network of schools.
So, the Rebbe looked over the 10 rules
and gave some type of affirmation or
approval
uh and then added with a smile,
"However, you forgot the 11th rule,
which is
there are no rules."
So, what what does that mean? The 11th
rule of Chanoch is that there are no
rules. I mean,
there are no rules?
That's that's chaos. That's
absolute uh
wild abandon. You can't educate children
with no rules. Children thrive on rules.
They have to have rules. They have to
have structure. How can we say that the
11th rule of Chanoch is there are no
rules? Let's just do whatever you want.
So, you have to understand what it means
there are no rules.
There are no rules doesn't mean that
children don't need rules.
There are no rules means
that educators and parents should not
bind themselves
to preconceived notions and get stuck in
a box of what they think every child
needs because it's just not so. There's
no one set
way that every child needs to be
educated, which of course we know goes
all the way back to and Malachi
who said in his wisdom, "Chanukah l'naar
al pi darko." Educate the child
according to
his way.
So, there are no rules means just
because something worked for one child
doesn't mean it'll work for the next
child. Just because something worked for
one child this day doesn't mean the very
same child is going to benefit from that
same thing the next day. We have to
improvise, adapt, be flexible, and do
really what the child needs. That's what
it means there are no rules. So,
when we speak about
schools,
when we speak about choosing a school,
the right school,
here's the main thing to remember.
It's not about which school is good and
which school is not good. All of the
schools are good.
All of the schools are great. In fact,
for some child, every single school is
the very best possible school that could
ever exist.
And then for another child, that same
exact school
is not good at all. Because for that
child, it's not conducive to what the
child's needs are.
And it
we really requires that parents have the
courage
to recognize who their child is, what
their child's needs are, and do what's
right for the child. We so often talk to
our children about peer pressure, don't
succumb to peer pressure. You don't have
to do something just because all the
kids are doing it. But the reality is, I
think more than the children succumb to
peer pressure, the parents succumb to
peer pressure, that there's this
tremendous stigma about being different.
Nobody wants to do anything different.
And then what happens in many cases,
it's gotten much better over the past
few years, but what used to happen
almost all the time, it was a disaster,
that nobody would do anything even
slightly different until it was already
a point of disaster. Meaning just keep
stuffing a kid in the wrong place even
though he's clearly not thriving or even
the opposite of thriving, but just keep
pushing him through because that's
what's deemed normal. And God forbid our
family be off the beaten path and we do
anything that's unconventional.
And then these children are literally
being sacrificed at the altar of social
norms. And in the end
all the terrible things that the the
parent feared end up happening anyway
because the child falls apart. So
we don't need to wait until disaster. We
don't have to wait until the collapse of
the child, God forbid,
to say what does my child need?
Could it be something different? Could
it be something
uh
less
of the standard, less of the norm.
Now
let let me just explain a little bit
more what that means.
There's no inherent superiority
to being normal.
There's no inherent superiority to being
different.
Okay, a lot of times what happens, you
know, there's an expression
to the man who only has a hammer,
everything looks like a nail.
People discover a solution and then that
becomes the solution for everything.
They want to have that be the answer for
every question.
So people say, "OH, SMALL SCHOOLS,
THAT'S THE ANSWER to all of our
problems." Why? What if a child's doing
really well in a large school? What if
that child thrives on the energy I I I
he he
What if the child needs the the the the
you know, a lot of times the larger
schools have a a a more tight structure
cuz they kind of have to inherently have
a tighter structure because you know,
have so many you you have so many
students and it's just not as flexible.
It's not as tailor-made. And but that
child thrives on that and that child
actually is growing. Why would you say,
"Well, you know what? Let's give him
Let's put him in a in a smaller school."
Maybe he doesn't need a smaller school.
But then you have another child could be
that child's very own sibling. Could be
two children growing up in the same
home. And for that child,
he desperately needs something that's
more bespoke, more tailor-made,
something that's more individualized.
So, there's nothing inherently superior
about saying, "Let's stick with the big
legacy name brand, call it uh or brand
name schools."
There's nothing inherently superior
about saying, "Let's go off the beaten
path. Let's try something different.
Let's try something uh unusual." It
all depends on the child.
So,
don't become
a uh let's say
do- don't become
married to a particular solution as if
that's the solution for all cases and
for all children. I remember one time
I don't think it was this year, maybe it
was last year.
I put out a voice note before the first
day of school.
And I said, "Parents,
I'm begging you, don't send your kid to
school if it's not the right school. And
even if you don't know where you're
sending him, don't just send him because
it you're you're warehousing him. Don't
send him for a glorified babysitting
service.
If you need to keep him home, keep him
home."
I remember I sent out that voice note. I
sent it out on uh the Soul Words
WhatsApp group, I think, you know, to
like my to my list.
People, I guess, ended up forwarding it.
It went way beyond where I expected
expected it to go.
And how did a lot of people take it?
People were coming over to me saying,
"Oh, you're saying you should homeschool
your kid."
No, I did not say you should homeschool
your kid.
I said, "Don't just send them for the
sake of sending them. It's better keep
them home until you have the right place
to send them. Don't just send just to
send anywhere."
If you have the right place, by all
means, send to that school.
But when people heard it, they all you
like I said, if a person only has a
hammer, then everything looks like a
nail. So, they oh, "Keep your kid home."
No, if that's the right thing for that
kid, keep that kid home. But if that
kid's going to do well by being sent to
the school that they're that they're
enrolled in right now, by all means,
send the kid to the school they're
enrolled in now. The point is, we have
to have
the the creativity, the flexibility,
the uh open-mindedness to say what does
this child need, to know your child
first of all, because you can't make
those decisions unless you know your
child. You have to know who your child
is as far as their personality, their
strengths, their weaknesses, their
challenges.
And also, to know the lay of the land as
far as chinuch, to know what's out
there. It behooves every parent to know
what the alternatives are, what the
options are. Even if you do end up
sending to one of the the legacy,
mainstream, uh
larger institutions, it's just good to
know what's out there. Thank God in
Crown Heights, there's diversity, there
are options. Um there's generally good
professional courtesy between the the
educational institutions, which is an
amazing thing.
Uh which I don't think maybe people in
Crown Heights understand how unusual it
is. If you go to other communities,
other citizen, where there's basically
one option,
you know, everybody sends to that one
school, and that's it. There are no
other options. Crown Heights is an
incredible place where you have
options, it behooves you to know what
those options are. Even if for your kid,
you'll end up sending them to the same
place that you went, and the same place
your parents went, cuz if it works, you
know, if if it ain't broke, don't fix
it. But, to just know what the options
are, and that the options are available,
and that when it's the right thing for
your child to have that flexibility, and
not to be confined by your own
self-imposed limitations of
self-consciousness, my
what are people going to say about it?
The what the stigma, what's going to be
with shidduchim, we're going to become
unusual. There's no unusual. There's no
unusual. A parent who's doing the right
thing for their child's chinuch,
and making sure that their child
thrives,
that's that's that's not considered
especially in today's day and age, like
I was saying before, when you don't do
the right thing by your child, it's a
formula for disaster. God forbid I don't
want to talk about it in the in the in
negative terms. So, when you do the
right thing with your child, and you are
sure that the child thrives because you
are recognizing what this child needs,
really all that that social stigma and
that fear of being different, that's in
your head. It's really in your head. And
the truth is,
the more that people do what's right for
their children,
the more common it'll become.
The more common it'll become,
the easier people will be able to make
these decisions, and also has another
residual effect, which is, you know,
people always have I don't know if it's
a
if it's a legitimate excuse, or if it's
more of like a
you know, it's a way that people have a
rationalizing not doing the right thing
for their kid, but sometimes people will
say, "Well, I don't want to pull them
out of the mainstream place because the
smaller place who knows if they'll be
around forever." You know, people have
have those fears, but here's the thing.
If you do what's right for your kid
and that becomes more normalized and
more people are doing what's right for
their kid, then the
optional places are going to have more
enrollment, they're going to be
stronger, and they will be around. They
will be So, it sort of becomes like a
self-fulfilling prophecy. "Oh, I'm
afraid to put my kid in this place
because who who knows if they'll be
around?" But, put them in and then when
you put them in, your neighbor puts
their kid their kid in, and then someone
else puts their kid in, and then these
schools do thrive. So, the way to create
more options, which is good for
everybody, by the way, it's even for the
parents
who don't send to those schools, it's
better for the whole community.
Because the more children you have who
are being engaged
like like we said, "Chanoch l'naar al pi
darko." Who are being engaged in a way
that is actually fitting that child's
temperament and that child's needs
educationally, socially, and so on and
so forth,
the stronger the whole community
becomes.
So, you you it's not just the to the
benefit of your child, it's really to
the benefit of all of us that everybody
thinks out of the box and you do what
your child needs.
Now, I just want to mention also
the idea of
small class size.
I want to repeat something I said before
about
there's no inherent superiority to one
thing or the other, it depends on the
kid. Some kids are going to do better in
a large class. So, I'm not saying
everyone needs a smaller classes.
However,
I will mention you something that
everyone said about smaller class size,
and actually
it's uh
coming up. It's in It's Shasman Grama,
which is a poor mesicha
in toughshin lamed base.
So, it was actually older bachum who
were complaining
about the bachum who, instead of
learning in 770, were learning in Beis
Torah. So, the Rebbe said a sicha on
Purim
about small class size.
That when you divide up
the groups according to learning levels,
and you give each group more
tailor-made, individualized
learning.
So, the Rebbe says this this lotion.
So, you decrease the class size in
commas, in in quantity, and you increase
in aichos, you increase the quality.
So, this is an educational concept that
the Rebbe spoke about, that by giving
more tailor-made attention, more
individualized care, you actually create
a better
uh experience for the students. Now, I
was even speaking about older students
who
are more or less on their own, more or
less self-sufficient. How much more so
younger students who need much more
attention, much more focus, much more
care.
Um
I think I'll just say one one more
thing, which is
that if you look throughout
the Rebbe's igrus,
whenever parents would write to the
Rebbe about chinuch and about school,
the Rebbe's one theme that almost always
is repeated is the concept of yiras
shamayim.
That education has to emphasize yiras
shamayim.
That there are many different
considerations that people
seem to be concerned about regarding
their their child's education. Um
the Rebbe says the most important is
yiras shamayim, which means
not just the child will learn
information, but the child will become
a moral person with good values,
somebody who knows right from wrong, and
is able to make good choices on their
own.
And this is the concept of "me do tell
me them Harvey".
"Stand up many disciples". What do I
mean "stand up many disciples"? It means
that a disciple is only a disciple if
they're self-sufficient, if they're able
to do what they're supposed to do when
nobody's watching.
Meaning not what they do because the
teacher is watching them and is going to
give them a sticker
if if they do what they're supposed to
do, but even outside of the classroom or
even after they leave school and they're
on their own, they're adults, and they
have an internal moral compass.
Okay, so
the main thing
the main consideration is always
what will the child gain as far as
morality and values for the rest of his
or her life. Will this child grow up to
be someone who can choose the right
things
even when nobody's watching. That's the
main thing. Now,
what does that mean? How how do you
actually know what
place is going to ensure that. So, first
of all, definitely, I mean, there's many
many letters from the Rebbe about this.
Um
to make compromises in Yiddishkeit
for when it comes to school, the the the
Rebbe was
always against. In fact, the the the
Rebbe mentioned many times that the
greatest assurance of health and of the
future livelihood of the child is always
going to be a strong background of
Yiddishkeit. It's always It always comes
down to the spiritual foundations,
always. There's no other consideration.
Okay.
But the question becomes
not should I compromise Yiddishkite.
Maybe there are many good
not just Yiddish options, but Siddish
options. They're all very They're all
Kedoshim. They're all holy.
So, how do you understand this or that
one being more conducive to Yiddishkeit
or not? And that basically comes down to
the most basic idea of Chinuch,
which is that
what a person will internalize, what a
person will come away with, is what
counts much more than what was just
said.
One of the great rules of Chinuch is the
teacher knows what he said, but is Does
he know what the students heard?
And not just what the students heard,
what the students will remember a year
from now or 10 years from now.
So, you have to actually ask yourself,
where does this child stand the best
chance of internalizing
the core values of Yiddishkite?
If this is a child who needs more
specialized attention, this is a child
who needs a less socially competitive
environment, let's say.
If it's a child who needs more
flexibility, uh if if it's a a child who
needs
a warmer, more family feeling in order
to absorb Yiddishkeit, okay, then
Yiddishkeit, you have to put the child
in that environment. But everything goes
according to what the child needs. So,
let's not make one rule this way or that
way. Only send to big schools. Only send
to small schools. Only home school.
That's ridiculous. In fact, if you're
really, really
being Machanech Al Pi Darko, and you're
really looking at what your children
need, then it's completely possible, and
indeed I've seen many families like
this, where one kid is going to the big
school, one kid's going to the small
school, and one kid's staying home. And
then the next year, it mixes up again,
because maybe there's a better class for
this kid. And you have to be flexible.
Anytime anybody's just doing the same
thing for all the kids because that's
what we did, that's what our parents
did,
you have to ask yourself, okay,
sometimes it's really true. That kid
could be that there's a there's a family
where the same school works for all the
kids and their parents and their
grandparents. Could happen, but really
if you are
taking a look at who your child is, if
you know your child, then it's very
possible that you're going to mix and
match, you're going to do different
things for different kids, you're going
to do do different things for the same
kid in different years.
Again,
there's no one solution. We don't have
to be married to any of these solutions.
People take it to such an extreme where
they say, well, I'm going to
I'm going to cross this bridge and I can
never return. First of all, I want you
to know that the climate is not like
that. I mean, in Crown Heights at least,
I can tell you from from the moistest
that there is
a mutual understanding, there's an
openness, a professional courtesy
between the the the the schools.
It's not like you make this decision and
now you're stuck with it and now this
kid can never go back.
Do what makes sense for your kid this
year. And then, you know what? Next
year, you'll re-evaluate completely from
scratch again from Don't do Don't do
something again just because that's what
you did.
No such concept and do what's right for
that kid the next year and for each of
your kids each year. Okay, but the main
thing is we have to be courageous.
Can't succumb to the peer pressure, to
the stigma, to the to the the social
norms
and
accept the God-given duty that you are
given. Hashem chose you
as your child's
main educator and part of being their
main educator
is to know your child, to know what they
need, to know what the options are.
Baruch Hashem, there are many, many
options, and do what's right for your
child at this time
on a case-by-case basis. Don't get
locked in.
Don't uh
be stuck in the
mochin de-katnus. We need mochin
de-gadlus. We need to be able to think
creatively, innovatively.
And what parent wouldn't do everything
that they can do to give their child the
best possible chance
of of growing up to be successful in
life.
Yeah. So, the question was, what if you
have a child who's doing extremely Do
you Do you say extremely well
academically, but is struggling
behaviorally?
Yeah, but as a and I guess as a parent,
I see that as a symptom of another part
of themselves that they're having a hard
time
Yeah.
Okay. So,
this is It's always difficult
when you have to sort of evaluate
where your pros and cons. It would It
would always be nice if the options were
clear options. Like, this one is all
good, and this one is all not good, and
then Okay.
There's always yesh bozeh, ein bozeh.
This one has qualities that the other
doesn't have. Which, by the way, is the
same thing with schools.
Please do not pretend
that there are not trade-offs. Of
course, there are trade-offs. There's
always a cost-benefit analysis. There's
all You're always giving up something to
get something else. So, there's no
scenario in the world where I'm going to
send my kid to this school, and I will
lose nothing because of that decision.
You're going to lose something. You're
going to lose something. The question
is, what are you gaining? And what
you're gaining, is it significant enough
to offset what you're losing. So, a
scenario like this,
let's say, I mean, it could be that
there's another place where behaviorally
he'll do better, and he won't lose
anything academically. But, let's say
it's not the
Moshiach's not here yet. You don't have
such a perfect option. Let's say you're
going to have to compromise or sacrifice
some level academically, but
behaviorally you'll gain. Okay, let's
pretend that's the scenario, or maybe
even that is the scenario. Is that the
scenario more or less, or something like
it? Or Okay.
So, here's the thing.
Chinuch is not hora'ah, like the
pedagogue that speaks about in Klalei
Chinuch u'Drachav. It's a short little
book every every every educator, and
really every parent, should read it.
Hora'ah means
teaching information.
Chinuch means
guiding the whole person to be a mensch.
So,
there can be a student who is amassing a
lot of information,
but you see that the complete person,
the complete picture,
is is not gaining.
And
because Torah is not just about
knowledge, it's not just about knowing
information, it's about being a mensch.
It's about knowing your purpose in the
world. It's about middos toivos. It's
about
having a sense of of identity and pride,
really.
Of of of
holy self-esteem, not a secular
self-esteem, but self-esteem that's
based on your neshama as your primary
identity.
So, you really have to make
a decision, like
if
a child's education in one place is only
serving one particular part of them,
meaning the intellectual part.
But it's not serving other parts.
Maybe other people would say other
things, you know, depends
how you view Yiddishkeit. Some would say
Talmud Torah K'neged Kulam and that's
everything, that's the end all, the be
all, and become a gadol and a Talmud
Chacham and that's it.
I think Chassidus would say
be a complete Jew.
So,
in the ideal scenario, you wouldn't have
to make that decision. The child could
have his cake and eat it, too, or in
this case, the parents would have their
cake and eat it, too. They would be able
to give their child the best of both
worlds.
But if you have to compromise
one area in order to strengthen the
whole child,
to me, like you're weighing one area
versus
the whole child.
Now, intellect is one part of a person.
It's not the whole person.
It's not the end all, be all.
If a person is just uh
and and and if they're they're just a
professor,
they just have a lot of knowledge,
but it's not integrated.
That's that's not really the purpose of
chinuch. That's Torah, but it's it's
it's not it's not chinuch.
And very often, by the way, a child who
is doing well academically, I'm not
saying this is the case in the question
you're asking, but it is quite common.
A child who's doing really, really well,
or you said extremely well,
academically, generally, it's because
I mean, there's a combination of the
education they're getting, but
a lot of it has to do with personality.
It's just a kid who is more
he takes to learning more naturally. So,
a kid like that,
ultimately, if you put him in a in a in
a that's fostering his development as a
person as a complete person, as a whole
person
he ends up doing well in learning
anyways because he's just got that kind
of a brain.
Quite often, quite often that's the
case.
The question was about a child who maybe
he's enjoying
he's
placed in a school where perhaps he's
enjoying it now, maybe they have good
teachers who are connecting with the
child but it's a clear
compromise in Yiddishkeit standards
where it's just just
In our standards, in our standards of
Yiddishkeit.
I have I'm not saying it doesn't exist.
I haven't seen
a letter, a minor,
a hero from the Rebbe
telling somebody to make a compromise in
Yiddishkeit.
I've never seen it.
Um
And the Rebbe is always very concerned
with
is the child happy? Do they have
friends? It's not just about are they
learning? You know, it's also about is
the child well-adjusted as a as a
complete person? And yet you always see
an insistence on the Rebbe's part for
the highest standards of Yiddishkeit.
Which
I don't know if this answers every
person's question, but
I think Baruch Hashem that's part of the
amazing
opportunity that we have today where
there's so many options within
Chabad Chinuch in this neighborhood.
It's like
perhaps in the past a person felt like
they had no choice but to go
somewhere else like literally to leave
the community because
there were just no other options. Today
there are so many more options within
our community meaning where we have our
standards
and and our our connection to the Rebbe,
which for us is
really the foundation of chinuch is that
it's
uh it's a siddur chinuch. It's in the in
the spirit
of of the Rebbe's guidance that the the
Rebbe's
worldview is given
uh
the most uh
most decisive or the most uh
most important regard.
And
I I don't think I'm not saying that
nobody is forced
to make these
comparisons today or to look outside of
the community today, but
there's so much variety and diversity
all under the banner of a of a Chabad
chinuch today that
thank God it's a lot less necessary for
that.
Maybe that somebody's in a situation
where that is their their reality,
but
it's it's it's certainly more than ever
before
the options exist.
And they're all siddur chinuch options.
You know, they might have different
styles or or flavors and with this or
with that, but it's all you know, it's
all Chabad.
Which is, you know, it's an amazing
thing that we have those we have those
options today.
Yeah. The question is
what if you really have a family like I
kind of described earlier where one
kid's going to one school, another kid's
going to another school, but one kid
maybe is home this year,
and
you you think there's a lack of feeling
of like cohesiveness where we're all on
the same that we have the same identity,
we all have we're all on the same page.
Um
You know, there's a famous story
that a guy complained some of these
different everyone tells this story with
the different Rosh Yeshiva or a
different rebbe. When a father comes in
and he complains and he says uh
"Rebbe, I don't know what's wrong. I
gave all of my kids exactly the same
chinuch and this one turned out like
this, this one turned out like that."
And uh and the rebbe says, "That's the
problem. You gave them all exactly the
same chinuch."
Chanoch l'naar al pi darko is a is a
serious thing and you have to be
courageous and you have to be
willing to do what's right for your kid.
And
you don't get to choose what's right for
your kid. I mean I mean you get to
figure out what's right for them, but
you don't get to say, "Well,
I want all my kids should have the same
thing be right for them." That might be
easier.
It might be easier on a lot of levels,
not just socially. I I keep coming back
to like social stigma. Even practically.
Just it's easier for everyone to have
the same schedule, the same vacations,
the same this, the same that. Or or like
you're saying, maybe mitzad the the
feeling of identity that we all have we
are we're all
we all belong to this school, you know,
sort of like team spirit.
Yeah, that would they that has
advantages. Everything has advantages.
Everything has advantages and
disadvantages, but you don't get to to
pick and say, "I want to have a family
full of kids who all are perfect for
this school."
And if the reality is
that one kid is good for this school,
one kid is kid is good for that school,
one kid is good for staying home this
year
and you're doing what's right for all of
your kids
that's your identity.
And in fact, I would argue
that's a much clearer identity
than just, "Well, we're doing the
default thing. We're doing the normal
thing. And why we sending you here?
Because that's where I went. That's
where my father went." You know, let's
you know, legacy. Let's you just keep
sending them.
But when we do what's right for each kid
on a case-by-case basis
that's a clear identity. That's a
statement. That That shows you actually
have some
beliefs that you're standing for. Now,
I'm not saying that a family who sends
all their kids to all the same place
doesn't have a clear uh shita in chinuch
because it could happen that all their
kids are all good for the same school.
That can happen. But if that's not the
case, then you have to do what's right
for them. And don't uh
don't worry about being wishy-washy that
it'll appear like we don't have a clear
identity.
Doing what's right for our kids becomes
our identity.
And And for a child, ultimately,
what's what's the most important thing
for a child?
It's security, it's safety, stability.
And
when they know that you are going to do
what's right for them,
you are monitoring them, you're watching
them, you understand them,
you have a knowledge of their unique
needs, and you are constantly tweaking,
reevaluating, and doing what's right for
your kid at each moment,
that gives the child the security to be
able to grow.
So, it might feel like it's a lack of
security because we're doing something
different and we're
Security comes in many different ways.
There's many different forms of of
stability.
Sometimes the most unstable thing is to
send all the kids to one school year
after year after year after year. It
outwardly looks stable cuz it's just a
uniform thing. Everyone's doing the same
thing. It looks very, you know,
cookie-cutter. But if the kids are not
thriving, if they're not doing well,
then that's the opposite of stability.
So, you know, we sometimes we have to
look, you know, you know, into the
penimius of things and not just the way
that they appear outwardly.
So, the the question was you talked
about where you went to school
and you felt a very strong identity with
being part of that school, that
community, and a pride, and uh
you're wondering if it if your kids, by
not going to such a school, are lacking
that. And the answer is could very well
be they are lacking it.
But everything's a trade-off.
Now,
it may be for you
having that sense of pride built into
your identity as a member of a certain
community
was really important for you.
Maybe that was so important that it
outweighed other things that maybe you
didn't get. Not saying there were things
that you didn't get, but even if there
were things that you didn't get, you
have to look at the child. Yeah, you you
bet you there are certain kids who they
thrive on that identity, and that
carries them, and they're not the top
learner, and they're not the most
social, but being part of an identity, a
group, and having that group um pride is
really important for them. Then there
are other kids who they're totally not
into that, and and they'll never be into
it, and and it's just not how they are.
They're not social creatures, they're
more introspective. In fact, maybe they
even get overwhelmed by that type of
intensity, maybe it feels socially
competitive to them. So, you just have
to know who your kid is, and do what
makes sense for them. I think that's the
the main idea that we keep coming back
to is know who your child is, know what
their needs are, and this then just have
the courage to do whatever's right for
that child.
Uh-huh, that's a very good question.
The the question is, there's the
mainstream is the default. At what age
do you start entertaining other options?
Okay. So, what you're It's a great
question, cuz what you're asking
essentially is bidacus
in a subtle way what I referred to much
earlier
tonight when I said, "It used to be
people would not think out of the box
until there was a crisis."
Things had to finally collapse before
they would entertain anything outside of
what you call the default.
What you're saying is sort of like a
subtle version of that, which is okay,
there's the default,
the normal thing, and then we'll we'll
we'll we'll watch and we'll see when the
when the normal thing isn't working,
you know, how bad does it have to get,
at what stage does what at what stage
does it require intervention, and then
we'll we'll come in and we'll we'll take
them off from what the default and we'll
put them on an alternative track.
So, that's still the same idea of
I'm going to wait for things not to work
before I think creatively.
And what I'm saying is
think creatively from day one.
Now, it may be very probable that the
default is perfect for your kid.
In fact, I would even argue the default
is
good for the majority of kids, which is
why it is the mainstream, cuz it's the
it's it's a good option for the most
amount of people.
I don't think it's an accident. I think
the majority of people probably do do do
well with the default, but don't assume
you put them in the default until they
start showing signs that it's not
working, and then
then you change it up. There There's no
default.
Clinical neuroplasticity is from the
very beginning try to figure out what
this child needs
from the youngest of ages.
Don't wait till they're 10 or even till
till till till they're five.
Make the right decisions for the child
from the very beginning, from day one.
I think that type of thinking needs to
be more
uh popularized.
It doesn't mean that all of a sudden
everyone's going to go run and pull
their kids out of the big schools.
Big schools are great, and for the
kids, they're probably
doing what what they need to do for
them. But, when that's not the case,
um don't wait until you see signs that
it's not working. Be ahead of it.
Do it preemptively. Know your child well
enough and know the schools well enough
that you can make those decisions
beforehand.
Like I I I'll give you an example that's
very very like parve because it's so
normal because it's like something that
everybody does and no one even thinks
twice about it.
Let's say somebody is sending to a large
school, one of you know, the main
mainstream schools. And let's say
there's five third grade classes. And
you would find out who are the different
teachers, and you know your kid, you
know his personality, and you know which
teacher has which style, and you would
request, or maybe even more than
request, you would try to get your kid
into that particular class because of
that teacher.
You wouldn't wait. You wouldn't just
say, "Well, let's wait until Hashvin and
see if my child's not thriving." If you
have information, and if you're a good
parent, you try to have information
ahead of time, then you're going to try
to set your kid up in the right place
for him
from day one.
Well, just take that same premise
and expand it to to schools.
Figure out what's right for the child
before you send them. Before you send
them. Don't send them and just let's see
how well it works, and if it doesn't
work, there's options.
I don't think that's the right way to
think of it.
Know what you're getting into before you
send your child.
I should also mention one more thing,
and I want to I don't know how I'm going
to say this without saying it in a
negative way.
I think I'm going to have to say it
negative, and then I'll try to say it in
the positive afterwards,
which is
the
the effects of a negative emotional
association with chinuch
are
beyond what we can
fathom. So, when a child is
and I don't want to give anyone a guilt
complex here because we make mistakes
and we send our kids to the wrong
situations all the time and then we have
to after the fact adjust it. So, I don't
want to make anyone feel like they have
to get it right
every single time. But,
when a child does have a hard time
and we're not ahead of at least
taking care of it as quickly as
possible,
the toll that that takes, the negative
emotional associations that they build
with Yiddishkeit
because of
being in the wrong class, having the
wrong teacher,
the wrong peers, the wrong
whatever, um
it it's significant.
And we need to do everything we can to
spare our children from that. Okay, that
was saying it in the negative way. Let
me say it in the positive way.
If we can get ahead of it preemptively
and set our children up to have
a positive emotional association with
Yiddishkeit because they enjoy their
educational experience, that has
lifelong benefit for the child. So,
instead of just saying, let's go for the
default and when it's not working, we'll
think about changing it up, let's plan
out everything, let's do our research,
let's know our kids, know the schools,
and set our children up for success.
Are we always going to get it right? No,
and in that case, we'll also have to
change things up. But, let's do our best
to set it up correct the first time and
that positive experience the child has
where they feel good about school, that
becomes generalized to their whole
feeling about Yiddishkeit for the rest
of their life in in ways that are just
absolutely invaluable. You said that
already. So, you're talking about a
situation where a child already was
failed
and damage was already done, God forbid,
and the negative associations were
already formed.
And at that point, we're really just
trying to save this kid. Right? And at
at that point, it really is about where
they're going to feel
connected, where they're going to feel
safe, where they're going to feel sense
of
belonging.
Um yeah, when you get to that point.
But, I think
the whole point over here is we're
trying to not get to that point. And
because of all the options that exist
today, that didn't exist in the past, we
have a lot better chance of getting it
right the first time.
Or at a at a much younger age or at a
much earlier stage, which is
it's a wonderful thing that we have that
ability today.
But, yeah, when when when when someone's
at that advanced stage of just having
been burnt out
to a point where, you know, the whole
thing becomes
a double most to them, then yeah, then
the the the whole
job becomes curative at that point. What
can we do to to win them back, to win
back their trust?
Yeah. But, again, the main thing is not
to lose lose our kids' trust. Instead of
having to gain back their trust, we
shouldn't lose their trust. And the one
way that we
don't lose their trust is by taking care
of them the best we can
ahead of time.
We do our best, and Hashem gives uh
Siyata Dishmaya to every parent.
And even with that, you know, we have
Bechirah Chofshis and we're limited, and
we make mistakes, and we try to correct
our mistakes. But, to the extent that we
can get it right the first time and do
what's right for our kid, we got to try
to do that.
Okay. Fine. Good.
All right.
That's a Yiddishe Chesed Shel Nachas.
Okay.