Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
I don't think a a child's job is to make
a parent proud. Parent child
relationship is the most effective and
important mental health intervention
known to mankind. Those parents are in
their child state, they want to be
friends with them. So, but the minute
the friend surpasses them or starts
being more successful than them,
>> right?
>> Then in the friend relationship, there's
that jealousy in a weird way.
>> What is a grandparent's job? Whatever
you're able to give to your child in
this healthy way is setting his marriage
up. There's nothing more scary
to a child
than losing their attachment.
>> Is there a time that when a parent can
yell?
>> Okay. We are privileged to have here
today a
parenting expert.
His name is Shua Saxs.
Um we will discuss uh fundamental
elements
um of human experience and I know that
you use a lot the word attachment and we
will dive into this. We're going to try
to figure out what attachment is. Shua
helps parents um create longlasting
relationships, meaningful relationships,
tries to help parents create a safe
space for their children. Welcome to the
struggle.
>> Thank you so much.
>> Thank you. Thank you for coming.
>> Thank you.
>> Okay. So before we're going to get into
attachment and all these um you know
important things I just want to discuss
with you you know I just want to become
aware and help people become aware how
important parenting is. Parenting is the
foundation of everything. You know you
talk to professionals you talk to people
all over they will tell you that
everything is rooted in childhood.
Right. The the first people the child
encounters when they come into the world
is the parents and the first 20 years is
the crucial years and then you have the
rest of your life to unwire or to deal
whatever the case is what was going on.
So the
>> and the avoid of having creating healthy
children is parenting and I don't think
people take it so serious. You know,
young people, everybody wants to have a
family and everybody wants to have
children and it's all beautiful and it
comes with all the bells and whistles.
[snorts] But the emotional part is so
crucial because that's what the
therapists say today. Talk to every
adult who already who's in the middle of
parenting his own children is is all
about their childhood. And while they're
raising their children, they're in the
middle of reparing themselves. It is an
unbelievable topic and a crucial one
because we also see today teenagers and
there's a lot of talk about ODTs and
this problems and that problems and
rifts and families and what you're
coming here what you your message is
let's start from the bottom. Let's start
from the foundation. Let's start from
the beginning and let's figure out how
the aayas that a that a parent has and
let's let's let's do this the right way.
We want to talk about attachment and
it's an interesting word and we want to
know if you can explain a little bit if
this is attachment is a positive word.
Is it a negative word? Is it a scary
word? Because attachment sometimes is uh
they use it for you're attached to
another human being which is toxic which
is codependency.
Explain what is attachment.
>> Okay. First of all, thank you so much
for uh having me on. Um so first to your
first point of just how important
>> connect
>> um the parent relationship is um Bessel
Vanderlock who wrote the body keeps a
score um he's he's quite um recognized
he says something very profound which I
think talked to exactly what you said he
said the parent child relationship
is the most effective and important
mental health intervention known to
mankind. Wow.
>> So, there's everything out there. Um,
and I think everything out there comes
from a desperation
where, oh no, we have to get help for
this or oh no, there has to be help for
this. And that's where the energy is and
that's where the the
movement happens to go to somewhere. But
I think that hopefully inspiration
beside not just desperation but also
inspiration can can help almost like nip
it in the bud. If this is true that it
is the most effective mental health
intervention that's powerful. There's a
lot of mental health interventions. Many
of them are amazing
but like you said a lot of them are
really coming to undo what could have
happened.
>> Okay. And so sometimes it goes like a
child seems like they're doing okay or
parents are not up for a child's
temperament that they're born into a
world with a certain temperament and
being in tune to that can really help
down the line like
just saving families money, time and
effort. Um but then to the point of what
attachment is. So attachment is it's an
interesting word. You're right. Yeah.
>> Um, basically it's a very simple um,
it's very simple. It's basically the
relationship the child had with their
parents.
What type of relationship that was. So,
it's really I'm going to there's they
break it down into four parts, different
types of attachment models, which is
what you were saying. Sometimes there
could be a codependency type of
attachment.
Um, and there's different levels.
There's anxious attachment, a type of
attachment. Then there's the ambivalent
attachment. And then there's the
avoidant. And then there's um
disorganized, which is something a
little one of the symptoms will be what
you're saying where there's that that
codependency,
>> right?
>> But um let if we're talking attachment
really
>> healthy attachment.
>> Exactly. Healthy attachment. And that's
what that's what I'm saying. That's will
be the drive to it. And everyone talks
about it. I'm going to say everyone
talks about attachment, love,
being connected.
Let let's see if we can figure out how
to do that. Um some tips or even some
like shifts in our focus and like what
we assume to be true, maybe shifting
that a little bit so that our child will
feel connected because sometimes our
idea of attachment and our idea of
connection is not really what this child
needs. Right.
>> So it's it's um so that's really that's
what it is. I think um the thing that
we're try we're striving for is in the
clinical world it's called secure
attachment.
>> Mhm.
>> And secure attachment is something that
a child is feel secure and safe and seen
and loved by a caregiver. And what
happens is is that gives almost like the
motor or sort of organizes the child in
a way that now they can go out and
explore the world because guess what?
Even if something
happens that
he didn't succeed or he got hurt by
somebody, he always has a place to come
back to to that secure place.
>> Right now you're talking about both
parents attachment, right? This is not
only one parent. I'm talking about both,
but one one can do it too,
>> right? Because what happens is that
sometimes one has a different
personality than the other. And here the
child is a total different personality
and now we're trying to make
attachments.
>> That's right.
>> So what you're saying is that even if
one has a healthy one, it is going to
help for this child to be safe and
secure.
>> Absolutely.
Sometimes I think what you're alluding
to is one parent might
have this disorganized piece where
they're a little scary sometimes loving
another time, but then you have that
other stable parent.
>> That's definitely [clears throat] an
anchor, definitely something helpful for
for the for the for the child.
>> Um, if there's like the negative pulling
back, it can fill in the pieces. But I'm
going to say even one
a child that knows it can come to their
primary caregiver which normally is the
mother.
But really anyone can do it.
>> Yeah. And that will help the child. Now
let me ask you a question. What if the
parent uh did not have a healthy uh
attachment to their parents? So, here
we're talking to young people or
middle-aged people who still have young
kids in the house and they see that the
kids are like, you know, acting up and
the the relationship is not where it's
supposed to be. But there's clearly
there was attachment issues to their
parents especially, you know, Holocaust
survivors or, you know, even another
generation away from the Holocaust
survivor. This is this is this is not so
simple to unwire. [snorts] So we you see
yourself in a place where there's can I
know how I don't know how many kids and
the population is growing but the
parents had no attachment.
>> It's a great question. I think that's
where the education has to happen. I
think that's where um even I'm going to
say even the acknowledgement
>> just the fact that um you acknowledge
that uh you didn't have that attachment
and the willingness that you want will
suit the child
>> that will set you in a place that you'll
do better for your child.
>> Wow.
>> We'll ask you a question. Take a
scenario where you have a young adult,
30 years old, raising a family, 40 years
old, and their parents, it it was it was
a hard childhood,
and they're listening to this now.
What do you think their childhood would
have been like if their parents sat down
and watched something that that shifted?
Oh, wow. Really, there's development of
a child. Really, a child's not just a
piece of furniture,
>> right?
>> Really? were able to just we're able to
to achieve.
Whoa. Even if that's all that they got,
don't you think that you as that
four-year-old would have had a bit of a
different childhood?
>> Absolutely.
>> Or less of a scary one or more of an
understanding one.
>> So, it's really it's really just that
just the knowledge and then reading
about it, experiencing it. I'm going to
say even
trying to experiment little things and
seeing if it works. Those those type of
things absolutely a huge shift. And not
only are you changing something,
here's what what I feel so strongly why
it's so strong to your point like
exactly like you're saying.
You're talking about a parent raising a
child now. But guess what? His parents
that raised him a certain way were
raised by their parents who were raised
by their parents. Just as
acknowledgement and the ability to shift
a little bit is literally changing your
future grandchildren's lives,
>> right?
>> So, and your children's marriages cuz
that's an attachment also. So, their
first attachment is going to sort of
follow into the next relationship of
marriage. There's so much that you're
doing in just that,
>> right?
>> You literally stop, you know, they said
during co you like one person moves away
and then it stops the whole thing. So,
that's literally what you're doing.
You're like moving the flame a little
bit away so it can't catch on to the
next thing.
>> That's amazing stuff. The awareness is
such a powerful thing.
>> Forget about doing. Doing is coming
after. But first have introspect.
>> Absolutely.
>> And and and and see where you're going.
>> Absolutely.
>> Tremendous.
>> It's it's um
so much of the work is the parents work
and that's what's hard. We call it child
rearing, I guess, but
>> everyone calls it parenting. You're a
parent. It's an interesting word also.
>> Yeah.
>> Like you said, you're parenting
yourself. Like you're learning how to
you you you're becoming it's it's on
you. It's on the parent. The the verb of
the parenting is really on the parent,
>> right?
>> To be able to grow on their own end, be
able to become more empathetic.
>> You're learning on the job. literally
learning on the job. If you're if you're
willing to learn on it, you grow so much
and you change as a person. Your
relationships change in your marriage,
your relationships change in business,
your rel cuz you've got sort of a broad
idea of what can really
like help a tantrum. What can really
calm someone down?
>> Right. So what you were describing is
attachment in a positive way and that
fulfills the child. It it sends off the
child to school or in a very uh safe and
secure uh peaceful knowing that I'm
attached to my parent and my parent has
my back. We're both attached by the hip
and it builds the self-esteem in the
child.
What about attachments when it comes to
uh friends? Uh is there is this also a
healthy way of being attached having
like a squad? I have my my people or
people who belong to a cahila is is the
belonging part of attachment and is it a
healthy is is there a healthy attachment
when it comes to community? So
absolutely I think you're touching on to
one of the pieces of attachment in what
a way to
connect with a child is to fill their
needs.
>> Right.
>> When we fill a child's needs, they're
able to rest.
>> So a a parent has to know what the
child's needs are.
>> That's right. So you touched on one of
them. One of the needs is a feeling of
belonging.
>> Very very strong.
The feeling of belonging
really comes from this emotional
connection. When a child feels
emotionally connected to someone, they
feel like they belong. They feel like
they belong to their father, their
mother. They feel like they belong to
their family, their nuclear family,
>> that feeling of belonging. What I'm
going to say is I want to go the other
way. I want to say if a child was really
given that and that was actually I don't
want to say like stamped but maybe like
vaccinated in you know like it was in
what what occurs is is that it's easier
for them to attach and belong to the
right groups
to the right communities
>> to the right friends because they know
what healthy feels like.
>> Correct. They don't need. See, everyone
says, "Oh, they're in pain and they need
to go run and they need to go run to
something else." That's so true. Now,
let's go back. How do we not create
that? When you give your child that
sense of belonging
through emotional connection, which is
very hard to do,
>> right? But and we can go through how and
what to do. But if you give that what
you've done is you've sort of wired in
their system that this feels super good
because everyone's wired for a
connection. Everyone needs that healthy
emotional connection. So they're not
going to really it's going to be a lure,
but it's not going to be that like push
that they have to get rid of something
that they're missing and fill it with
that because they've actually had that.
Well, you you're saying something very
profound and let let me let me I'll I'll
tell you what I heard from you and tell
me if I am correct. What you're saying
is that if a parent is providing a
healthy um connection, a healthy
emotional connection, a healthy
attachment, secure attachment with the
child,
what is going to happen is that that
child is going to look for healthy
relationships outside as well.
What you're saying is in other words
that you're preventing
a ton of problems of bad friends, bad
environments because first of all the
child doesn't uh need to go and fill
this void from someplace else and on the
other hand this was modeled to them.
They know what respect is. They know
what empathy is and that child is giving
over the same empathy. Same the child is
looking and searching and magnetically
pulling the same type of relationships.
>> That's right.
>> This is crazy important to know for a
parent.
>> It is super important. I want to I want
to add something take it a step further.
Trauma is is an event that's happened to
somebody or hasn't you know a sort of a
neglect or whatever. There's different
types of trauma. There's the complex
trauma which is the, you know, the
emotional pieces. There's um incidents
of trauma, one-time traumas, constant
traumas, all different types of traumas.
The ability like I was saying to go back
to someone and to connect with somebody
that you know is there
I don't want to say takes it away
>> but it takes a huge ingredient
>> out of what the trauma is.
Trauma is an event but it's also a wound
inside.
And a if somebody has that template and
the ability to go to somebody and say
this happened to me,
>> this is happening to me.
>> Right?
>> I want to just take a simple example,
bullying,
>> right?
>> Why should a child have to hold that
>> in their little undeveloped brain and
sit with that?
>> That's traumatizing to a child. What I'm
saying is is that that's wounding.
There's a wound inside and that wound
needs to be healed. They'll heal it in a
hundred different ways with bad
medicine, like we were saying, go to try
to ease that pain, ease that. But if a
par if they can go back to the core
because they know they can and they have
a pathway to go there,
that takes away so much of it.
>> Wow. That will help minimize the trauma.
>> It's amazing stuff what you're saying.
It's fascinating.
>> But what you're saying, tell me if this
is correct, if I understand it
correctly. What you're saying is if a
child is not comfortable enough to go to
the parents and share let's say the
child was sexually molested or the child
was bullied or any other trauma was
going on and the child [clears throat]
doesn't feel it. You have to feel this.
This is not about the parents telling
you you can come you can come and talk
to me. The child has to feel
>> experience that
>> that they can come and [clears throat]
share this with the parents and be
validated and be believed and and and
feel the empathy.
You blame the parents for that because a
little child would say he's embarrassed
to go say it. I mean, how can you make
the child become more but it's really
not the child. What you're saying is
that the parents should step up to the
plate because if you don't build an
environment in the house that you can
come to me and you're comfortable enough
to come to me and also know that if you
you will be validated then it's the
parents responsibility.
>> I think it's very important I always try
and keep things as positive as as
possible because I truly believe and
this is really really important. I truly
believe that every parent does whatever
he or she can do at the moment. They
really, everyone wants to do everything
to the best of their ability. They just
don't necessarily have that ability at
that given moment,
>> right?
>> Things change. I'm going to say a parent
that parented their first child's very
different than one that they parented
their third or fourth child,
>> right?
>> Because there's so we've grown. There's
so much differences in in the
temperament of the child. I'm going to
say in what's going on at home in
financial situations everything's so
different. So,
but I think every parent tries their
does the best of their ability and this
is just to give a parent the knowledge
and just like how powerful they really
are.
>> Correct?
>> In a good way,
>> right?
>> Not in a way of trying to say, "Oh,
you're to blame. There's no one to
blame."
It's much more of understanding
parents that have young children to be
able to cultivate this environment in
their home
can really really help them. Not only
help a child be feel like they can come
over, but it builds resilience in the
child. The ability, like I said,
something goes wrong, it's not like the
world's over.
>> You're able to come back to something.
>> Wow. That that is amazing stuff.
How would you describe unhealthy
attachment?
>> So the un I think that unhealthy we can
go all the way to the other spectrum.
Unhealthy attachment's something there's
a couple types of quote unquote
unhealthy, but like the one that really
stands out and what a lot of people
will be in therapy for, let's say, is
something called disorganized
attachment. Disorganized attachment is
something that where it's very confusing
to a child. Sometimes a caregiver is
available and sometimes they're totally
not
>> but like in very extreme ways. We're all
human. Anyone with secure attachment
need meaning in that relationship a
secure call it a relationship or
connection. There's going to be times
where the other person checks out or
screams or gets upset. That's for sure.
But the
constant pattern of sometimes totally
there and sometimes actually sometimes
scary.
>> Yeah.
>> Meaning the parent scary to the child.
The child you the child starts there's
so much stuff that's happening but on a
very surface level they start they start
learning that relationships aren't safe.
>> Right. Like Monday is one way and
Tuesday is another way.
>> Yes. and relationships aren't safe. And
even if I'm in a relationship, it might
just change. So let's take a marriage or
a friendship,
>> right,
>> where that where where they can't hold
it, not because they don't want it, but
because they don't know how to navigate
it. So if one day the friend decides to
walk with another friend, they see that
as that Tuesday every Tuesday or
whatever that parent just
>> got upset or angry or whatever. And that
triggers that peace in them and then
they can't keep that relationship.
>> Yeah. That messes with people's minds
tremendously. And that this is between
adults, relationship adults.
>> If you blow this hot and cold all the
time.
>> Yes.
>> It's messing with people because this is
probably one of the worst out there
because the messages are coming in not
clear.
>> Yes. And it's so confusing like a child
that's developing. So like if you want
to think of a child's brain as like as a
ton of wires.
>> Yeah.
>> And those wires are not really
solidified into any circuit or into
anything when they're born. And as it
when I say development, I mean these
wires are literally being stretched,
moved, put
>> pathways are being created. So
when you start creating the you
literally are developing these pathways
to be like no we got to short circuit
here or we got to do this or we got this
is the way the brain is formed.
Yeah it can be it can be extremely
challenging to undo. Do you find in your
practice when you talk to people that
children feel sometimes that the parents
are threatened by them or jealous? You
know, as soon as the child becomes a
little bit older and they they they look
at the child and they feel a certain
distance,
uh where does that come from?
>> So, I think it's interesting that you're
asking that. I think that really goes
into
um [clears throat]
not a parenting style, but there's
there's sort of like um it's it's it's
sort of like a state of being in
something called a a child state. A
child state is a a place where like
sometimes we go, we get a little silly,
we have fun, you know, we like sort of
let the child inside of us like jump out
and have a ton of fun, you know,
>> but like it's not really a great place
to hang out as an adult all the time,
>> right? Like I always think of it, you
know, we always had someone in our
class, I don't know if everyone can can
think of it of it this way, like we
always had someone in our class that had
like always had the best Nash, but like
I cheer and they always had pizza for
supper and they always like it was like
a party in their house and we're always
like jealous like we wanted to go there
and then we would go there maybe for a
sleepover and it would be like gmach and
really nice but then like I don't know
by the time by the time be done. You're
like, you're ready to leave.
>> Those parents are in their child state.
That means that they're they're they're
really friends with the child.
>> They want to be friends with them. So,
but the minute the friend surpasses them
>> Uhhuh.
>> or starts being more successful than
them,
>> right?
>> Then in the friend relationship, there's
that jealousy in a weird way.
>> That's fascinating. But it's the
emotional immaturity or the need for
more emotional maturity on the parents
end. But it's not just in parenting
usually that these parents are this way.
It's really across the board.
>> Mhm. Wow.
>> Now where is the balance of a person who
wants a healthy secure attachment wants
that friendship you know wants that
closeness but on the other hand a
balance of respect also.
>> Absolutely. And I think that's very um
confusing to people. And I think people
um say it's either or,
>> you know, like just love them, just give
them whatever they want, just love them.
And then there's like but we need
respect. I would never say that to my
father. There was a certain respect for
that.
>> So there's many different levels to
that. I'm going to say the strictest
parent can have the healthiest
attachment. It's not a steal,
>> right? It's all in the way that you do
it and I think it's a lot in the focus
of what's my goal.
Um, but absolutely it's not a steer at
all. I do want to touch upon what you
just said. It's very interesting where
there is the need for respect and I'm
going to say 50 60 years ago that was
demanded.
>> Yeah.
>> And we gave it and we need it was just
it was almost like part of the culture
that it needed to happen that way. for
some reason now it's not there and if I
can explain it a little bit I think it
it's not fixing it but I think it's
helpful for parents to understand even
grandparents to understand what's going
on with their grandchildren
I think um 50 60 years ago
there was a the dynamic really in all
relationships if you would take
relationships on a whole so like take
principal to teacher teacher to child,
um, business boss to to employee,
husband to wife, father to child. There
was a certain
I'm going to say like role that everyone
had like the father went out to work,
the mother stayed home or or did
something it and each one had their
role. Like it was like the father would
come home from work, he did this. And
from a child's perspective, looking at
those relationships, it wasn't equal.
It was like whatever what Tati says or
what what your father says, he said, you
know, that there was no equal democracy
or dynamic that was happening that way.
principle to to arbi also there was a
there was there was something very like
[snorts]
I don't want to say removed but there
was there was a a clear hierarchy of
like what's going on and then you would
and then let's take
um a rebbit child same type of thing
what started shifting is that all
relationships really around started
becoming more 50/50 or democratic Right?
>> You know, both parents worked. You asked
T, okay, maybe Tati will say, what does
mommy say? What does Aba say? What?
There's this back and forth. It wasn't
like one had to say in this and this one
had to say in this. It's really everyone
working in tandem.
>> Same thing in schools really. It's
shifted like the assistant is really
like the rebby in a child's eyes.
There's no clear power dynamic.
So if a child is seeing that now, why in
heaven's name like want to lean into a
relationship where it's all like pushing
you down? All they see is equal.
So that's where I think the shift
happened. And that's where I think we
have to lean into that, fill that a
little bit, but obviously keep our
respect. Obviously
kids can't rule. That's anarchy. That's
not something that's that's um healthy
for a home and it's actually scary for a
child,
>> right? Even the child doesn't expect it.
[snorts]
>> Child doesn't want to run the house. The
child wants authority. He wants to see
that the parents the father's a giver,
you know.
>> Absolutely.
>> He you know he can he can protect me if
I need to. If he has an opinion,
>> someone that can protect me but also
understands me.
>> Correct. Now you mentioned the word
grandparents and I'm going to throw it
in there. Okay. Is grandparents also uh
in this dynamic? Uh there is healthy
attachment and can they make al can they
also help abusing a child
>> with with control or because sometimes
in these families this is going back
they're very imshed and if the
grandparent says something it affects
the child because the father is going to
do what the mother is going to do what
the parents want what their grandparents
want.
>> And how does that affect the child? a
grandparent.
>> Yeah. So, so I'm going to say really
directly if there's a lot of exposure,
I'm going to say exposure without a a a
weird parent around because like even
like little comments
>> although right away tights you up as you
know you're the troublemaker or oh here
comes the whatever you know.
>> Yeah.
>> It plants something in a child. It's so
powerful
>> and they're like sponges. These childs
are like
>> and they look up at the grandparent and
I've heard it a lot of times that the
grandparents would
>> kill a child with their with their words
>> and you think what is a grandparent's
job [snorts]
>> just have to give wafers no
>> hugs and wafers and tons of gifts you
know that um yeah it
>> but but but it's it's very important
that the grandparents should know what
their job is because your bird
can kill somebody.
>> Absolutely. I'll take it even a step
further.
Grandparents,
again, you could talk to parents or
grandparents, but when they when a
grandparent, even after a child is
married and has a family, there's a
reason why they're calling the grand
their parent to talk to speak to them,
right?
>> To have a relationship.
what happens in that relationship is
going to affect the child the next
afternoon because the parents feeling
either really good about themselves or
not so good about themselves based on
what's been going on.
>> Right?
>> So there's there's a yeah it's it's it's
part of this whole nuclear family
system,
>> right? And uh that brings me to just uh
maybe this is the first step but uh how
important is Schulmbai is if you're in
the middle of forming a healthy
attachment with a child and the two
don't get along they don't see eye to
eye
this attachment flies out of the window
right there and then. So the first thing
is you have to first have your ducks in
line and then we can talk about
attachment. Is that true?
>> In a way, for sure. For sure. It's a
huge bias is huge. I mean, think about
we're talking about children and
parenting, but think about the safety in
the home,
>> right?
>> What it feels like
>> there's arguing and bickering and stress
and all that all that really heavy
stuff. Children absorb that.
>> Absolutely. [snorts]
I think um
you're when when you're able so for sure
in terms of the marriage piece there's a
ton to work on. You have to work on that
relationship and you're going to the
attachment of your own attachment style
and your own stuff is going to get going
to be in that relationship.
But you should also know that whatever
you're able to give to your child in
this healthy way is setting his marriage
up
>> for success. Mashem, there's someone
else involved also, but you're giving
him the best chance and his children's
and then his children's marriages and
then their children. So
>> it's huge. It's tremendous.
>> It's huge. So it really starts way
before like you're saying like really it
starts before
the parent as they were a child how what
went on for them and it's going to
affect their marriage their relationship
at work their relationship with their
children parenting it's you know it's
every relationship and we're all about
relationship
>> it's a combination from all levels
>> and that's this is not an easy task
we're discussing over [laughter] here
>> definitely not easy and I I think it's
It's to bring out the
implications of it,
>> right?
>> Can hopefully have people think about
it.
>> Um, shift just a little bit
>> a little bit just a little uh point of
view. Now, how early
is a is attachment formed for little
children? Which means from what age do
they start to recognize that this is my
parent and this is what I need. I need
love. I need validation. And I need
understanding the back and forth of a
relationship. Adults we know.
>> Yeah. Yeah.
>> How young is is is a child uh educated
in this subject?
>> So I'm going to split it into two, but I
I I'm going to go back to uterero.
A lot of what we're talking about here
is not a child knowing, it's a child
feeling. Mhm.
>> It's a felt sense that the child has
that they're okay,
they're safe,
they're good enough, they're wanted.
That goes back to uterro.
You're you're with the mother and the
the child senses just like they're
developing in a physical way. They're
they're sensing their brains forming and
this is a felt sense. It's implicit.
Implicit something they can't remember.
It's subconscious. It's it's within
their system,
>> right?
the child's born.
Um, I'm going to say 0 to two years old
is actually the most fundamental
part of what we're talking about.
>> Wow.
>> As crazy as that sounds,
>> because a parent would think at that
point the child doesn't have any
feelings yet,
>> right?
>> Because we we connect feelings with
brain
>> with words
>> with words or developed brain.
>> Yes.
>> And you feel like it's a from zero to
two. I mean, now we're just feeding the
child and changing diapers.
>> That's right.
>> You're saying that from 0 to two, the
child is developing feelings of being
needed and wanted
>> connected
um in a implicit way in in almost like a
>> blueprint way not in a way that he'll be
able to say,
>> right? But um absolutely
I'm gonna say it's a huge ingredient in
the attachment. It gets tricky after the
age of two when they develop language
and
>> but if a if a if a parent is in tune
with their child for those first two
years of life, it's it's [snorts]
absolutely
um it's a game changer. I'm going to say
in terms of even in terms of
responsiveness um I call it mirroring.
That's something that I I think is um a
huge skill which we actually do very
naturally with our kid with our children
when they're 0 to2. So what happens when
the baby's born or what happens when the
baby's brought home from the hospital?
Baby cries, we we rock them. We we're
we're we're literally following their
cue. The baby's sense is is that this is
allowed to be happening and someone's
there for me.
>> That's actually what they feel.
But if a baby's left crying, you know,
used to be the thought was just let the
baby cry. Don't hold the baby. Don't
hold the baby cuz they're going to get
used to, you know, but if if you're
looking at it from this point of view,
it's actually you're doing the best. Um
you're helping the child develop in in
the most safe, secure way.
>> You're introducing the child to healthy
living.
>> Yeah. Yeah. And the child knows in its
bones
that it's okay to have needs.
His needs will be responded to. So let's
go back to the something happening in
by bullying in school or some sort of
event that
of abuse or something in their bones.
They know they can go to their mother or
father.
>> Wow.
>> Yeah.
>> That's beautiful.
>> Yeah. How um should a child that feels
neglected by limited parent
child you know wants to be needed wants
to be uh you know heard and understood
and there's nobody home.
What should a child do at a time like
that? The they already have already a
mind you know they know already you know
teenagers or whatever
>> teenagers.
So
if a teenager is willing to listen to
this, it's finding someone to attach to.
>> So what you're saying is that they can
find a teacher.
>> Absolutely.
>> Or anybody else to replace to substitute
a parent for attachment
>> if that's what's if that that's it.
meaning it's obviously not the natural
or the best I'm going to say like the
most natural or the way things are
supposed to happen but you can
definitely feel it in that way if you
have someone an in tune moa or teacher
and someone that really holds on to you
but and does it in a real way
>> you can feel a lot
>> wow so this is a message for teachers if
they can spot a child who has unhealthy
attachment. Uh a child who is uh not
secure,
they may step into the game.
>> Absolutely.
>> Wow.
>> I'm going to say
these children are spotted by abusers
with a laser-like focus.
>> Correct.
>> They know them.
>> Yeah.
>> It's clear to them. They're like they
know. And so
yeah, if a rebby can spot them and be
that kind, nurturing
figure,
>> wow,
>> it can change a child's trajectory for
sure.
>> That is something. And what if a child
is living in a house and they cannot
make the parent proud? Whatever they do
is just not working.
>> So I think there's a couple asking a
question that way. I think there's
there's a couple there's a couple things
it sounds like from like assumptions.
>> So
>> I don't think a a child's job is to make
a parent proud.
I think a parent's job is to see the
child for who they are and try to
cultivate anything and all their
and all their abilities to bring it out.
>> The way you do that is by seeing the
actual child
and not what the child's doing, how
they're doing, or what they're doing.
>> Right?
>> It's not about a behavior or what
they're or an action or an
accomplishment that they're doing,
>> right?
>> Because then it becomes about the
accomplishment.
>> It should be about the child. This is a
very important piece. It's interesting
you asked it that way and I think I
think it's important to speak out.
The idea of praising our child or
complimenting our child, it's a good
thing and it could and should happen.
But it needs more than that because
the message and and I think the the
message that we give our children when
we comp when we compliment or praise
something that they've done is is is in
a way it's a positive type of judgment,
but in a way we're judging them and
we're saying you passed the test.
>> Okay? And deep down the child feels
this. They might not they might it's
like almost like candy. Like it tastes
so good when you hear it from a parent
but it it doesn't last well. The more
nurturing
attachment connection piece is when you
see the child
not about what they did but you just saw
the effort the child put in or the or
what they've tried to do or how much
they must have thought about it before
they did ABNC where you're seeing the
actual child's effort
>> as opposed to their accomplishments.
You're acknowledging the child. you're
looking at the child and this gets very
mixed up.
And then
I I believe that this message is a very
powerful message to children. And what
happens is is that let's fast forward
fifth, sixth grade. Let's fast forward
again to high school. Let's fast forward
and things aren't going away and we're
not accomplishing exactly what we're
supposed to do.
those children are much more and I'm
going to say in the society it's much
easier to just give up on it forget it
disposable what we call like a
disposable society but that's be I think
if you get down to the root of it is
because everything was about
accomplishment being amazing always
being able to do and only focused on
that not focused on any effort so why
should I put in the effort
>> right
>> you know we say
I really think that that's that that
should be the focus of every of of a
child's childhood in in what they're in
in what they put into it cuz they know
they accomplished. It's almost like what
do we say the first thing a child comes
home with a 95 or 100? You got a 95. Oh
my gosh, you got everything right.
What's that message? It's so subtle.
What's that message?
>> You got 100. I'm proud of your 100.
What? How about if a child would hear
something a bit different?
Wow. I remember how hard you studied on
that. You went out to your friend's
house late at night and you studied and
remember we reviewed that one and it was
on the test, right?
>> You don't even have to mention the
hundred. They know they got 100. They
know you're proud just from the way you
are. Just for the way you you're
everything about you, you're giving over
proudness,
>> right? It's much more about looking at
their effort and how much they tried and
that makes a child feel seen. We're
talking about seen.
Um, so I think the premise to that
question, the whole dynamic is a little
off, but
um, he should seek out someone that does
see him for who he is,
>> right? Because if a if a child what if a
child is going through what you're
describing, it feels like that he has to
feed the image of the parents. That's
>> right.
>> You know, in toxic relationships,
um this is between a spouse and a and a
and a and a a husband and wife or
between children, the golden child is
people are jealous of the golden child
because the golden child has it. Uh but
in reality, the golden child works twice
as hard as the regular children.
>> Yeah.
>> Because they know the punishment and
they know the reward that is going to
come. So they're always on their toes.
>> It's not so easy.
>> No.
>> To be the golden child.
>> Absolutely. And they're they're not able
to be genuine with who they are.
>> Correct.
>> Cuz they have an image they have to keep
up. And the way that sort of formulates
later is that it can be hard to
think that you're genuinely
skilled at something or you're genuinely
good at something, you know, because
>> you've never that's not part of your
>> Yeah.
>> your blueprint
>> and that's very destructive.
Now let's talk about um you you
mentioned trauma before uh
illness in the family or even sometimes
a child is ill or the parents are ill or
children from divorced homes which is a
huge topic.
>> Yeah.
>> Happens a lot lately. There's so many
houses who are going through this.
>> Now you're talking about children um who
are coming from divorced homes.
>> Yeah.
What is healthy attachment over there?
Because here they have their own issues
to deal with that sometimes for some
reason these children blame themselves
when the parents divorce which I will
never understand but this is part of the
game and who even talks about healthy
attachment when it comes attachment to
who one parent if you know if it's great
if both parents understand each other
you know and there's no negativity
spewed at each other but if there is
where does attachment where's attachment
Yeah.
>> So, you touch upon a couple things. I
think it's important to understand in a
child's world, ch children are very
self-centered,
>> you know, they don't like sharing. They
don't really get another person's
perspective so easily. Like, it's hard
for them. We like that develops a little
later. and children it doesn't
necessarily come naturally especially in
a home that didn't have that and that
probably was in the home they grew up in
that they they didn't really see that in
the parents marriage if assumably
because
>> of the divorce. So,
um,
being that they're so self-centered,
they make it all about themselves.
>> Even
if it doesn't make any sense.
Everything's about them. So, it must be
something I did. It must be something
that must be something that that has to
do with me that this is happening.
That's the first way of explaining it.
There's another way to explain it. This
is the attachment piece.
There's nothing more scary
to a child
than losing their attachment. Having it
and losing it.
>> Wow.
>> It's safer to say it's my fault than to
say there's something wrong with my
attachment figures.
>> Wow. That is crazy stuff. Now not only
that this they carry in this self um
it's all about me uh into relationships
later in life as well.
>> Absolutely. This is all part of the
attachment. This is all part of their
developing this what relationships are
about.
>> So that is profound because
>> what you're describing is a child in
when they're young
>> will will it's going to become about
them self-centered.
and for the reason of losing the
attachment for for losing that security.
They're petrified from that fact. And
then they take the self-centeredness
when they become teenagers. And then
they take the self-centeredness into
their new relationships, adult
relationships, and it's a damn word
spiral from there.
>> Yeah. It's it's almost like it was it
was implanted like it's in the it's it's
wired. there's there's rewiring that can
happen, but it's wired. But I think in
terms of a parent being able to
to what they could do is that obviously
there's no point in blaming
another spouse in front of the child.
That doesn't do any good.
Um but it's showing up for the child
however they need to be showed up for.
So, we might not think that their
experience
is what should be happening. Like, let's
say they're just terribly upset about
something and like it's not such a big
deal. Like, I don't know. Like, you have
a safe home and well, every other shabas
you'll go like not such a big deal,
right? That's invalidate validating.
But it's not about so much doing a
validation move. It's much more of the
ability to see
the experience of the child in the way
that they see it
>> and lean into that.
Super difficult to do.
>> That's the epitome of I'm going to say
empathy.
Okay, that's what empathy is. Empathy is
the ability to believe the other
person's experience without painting it
of the way that you think it should be.
>> Right? which is taking away so much of
yourself in the picture, which is super
hard. But I believe that's the core of
what attachment is. The ability to look
at your child who you don't even relate
to like you're on up here, they're
there, and they're on the floor
tantruming about their doll. Their
world, their doll is major. your
ability. So, your ability to lean into
that and really empathize and it might
feel a little fake for you in the
beginning, but the more you do it, the
more natural it becomes. That's what
gives the child the ability to feel
safe, seen, heard, soothed, attached,
connected.
Everyone talks about loving your child.
>> Yeah.
>> But that's such a hard
that that's so unattain like what does
that mean? What does it mean? almost
superficial.
>> Exactly. It's a word. So I want to I'll
say a just for like very quickly
you learn you should love your friend
like you love yourself. If you look in
he doesn't translate it in the typical
way you would translate a he translates
it user.
And every time he speak he translates
aba he changes to rakim rakim can be
translated as mercy but I want loosely
translated I think it's empathy
>> empathy like feeling putting yourself in
someone else's shoes
>> and showing them that you're in their
shoes
>> right
>> think about going to be somebody
>> right
>> what do we do are our phones on no are
we sitting like this no we're staying
slouched
in a way the less we talk the better.
>> You just look at this person like uh
what you know I I feel you.
>> Yeah. And that person feels that you
feel them.
>> Correct. You don't have to say anything.
>> That is
empathy,
>> right?
>> And I feel like that if that goes on in
a child's life,
>> it's heaven.
>> Not always. It's heaven on earth. Is
that what you just said?
>> Yeah.
>> It's heaven on earth.
>> And it's a it's a basic tenant for And
if again, I want to say this again. If
that goes on in a child's life, that
child will be able to do it to his
spouse, to his friends.
>> Correct?
>> Because he he knows what it feels like
and he has a lingo and he knows he it's
in his bones.
>> So when we rock our little zero to
twoyear-old, we're giving over empathy
without words. We're giving over empathy
like viscerally like we're giving it
over.
When a child's, let's say, from a
divorced home that's really sad, sad,
we're able to be in his experience for
just a minute,
that's very healing cuz he doesn't feel
alone in it. Someone's experiencing it
with him and that's profoundly
impactful, like healing,
um, helpful,
and it's super hard. This is like the
hardest thing to do. So what you're
saying is that even if one parent
>> from the divorced home has empathy
>> Yes.
>> and is is possible to have healthy
attachment with your children the
children will be fine.
>> Listen
this you never like saying things
definitively.
>> So what I like to say is that there's
you have you have a cake and you have an
ingredients in the cake. There are main
main ingredients
attachment nurture huge ingredient
nature also big ingredient. So there's
temperament of a child is going to be
but part of the attachment is tuning
into that temperament right not every
single
>> no child is the same. No child's are the
same and we're not trying to make them
the same.
>> Right.
So,
um, but yeah, you it absolutely the the
ability for a child to feel that way
comes from when a parent is able to feel
what's going on for them
>> takes a lot of work. And the word is not
skill cuz if it feels like a technique,
it is,
>> right?
>> And it's not supposed to be that way.
No,
>> it has to be that you genuinely are
feeling what's going on for them and
taking out what you want out of the
situation for a minute. You might want
to push them in a certain direction
eventually, but first you have to hit
their system, their lyic system, their
what's going on for them
>> and calm them down. It's like sometimes
think of it, you know, you think of it
developmentally, so like on levels, you
have a
three-year-old that's
terribly distraught
that they that their doll broke. What do
we say?
Our first reaction, we'll get you
another one. So many other ones. Okay,
so this one's broke. We'll try to fix
it. Blah blah blah.
All trying to fix the problem. And it's
nothing wrong with that. But
developmentally,
it's like a 25year-old or a 30-year-old
losing their diamond ring.
>> Yeah.
>> What would they want to hear first?
We'll get you another one. What's the
big deal? You have other ones. You have
fake. Like what? Like
developmentally, they're on the same
level. First they have to we can go
there eventually. First they have to
feel like whoa there's someone else in
my loss. I lost something. So now for an
adult it might take much longer. For a
child it happens within a minute. It's
not like I'm saying it it's like you
know life changing but developmentally
it's very very similar. It's
interesting.
>> So what I'm hearing from you is that if
parents
have no empathy for their children the
children are doomed. [clears throat]
or I'm going to worse sometimes empathy
>> and sometimes
bashing like this for this disorganized
that we're talking about.
>> Wow.
Let me ask you a question. Why are
parents struggling to be vulnerable and
open and have open conversations with
the with the children? Why is there a
certain distance that they feel that um
[clears throat] that they can't share
certain you know they wouldn't there
conversations that parents would not
have with the children
>> I think cuz that I think the question
starts way earlier where was the where
was the connection before you had to
have this difficult conversation
>> they never built on it is what you're
saying
>> there was never it was it's not there
able to say I know this is an
uncomfortable conversation but I have to
have it with you that seems seems so
scary because you're not in a connection
or in a relationship with them and they
don't trust you and in a way you don't
trust their reaction. So it becomes it
really starts way before and I think so
many of the a lot of issues that are
real real issues really the question is
what was in place beforehand to help our
children weather the world
>> right
>> the world's not an easy place to be in
>> no
>> it's a lot of ups and downs
and we can't control that as parents as
much as we want to like helicopter and
help and save and push and work, you
know.
>> Yeah.
>> Ultimately, your child has to weather
the world and they need this to be able
to do it.
>> So,
it's not about it's not so much about
what's happening now. It's really about
what happened before.
>> Mhm. [clears throat]
Yeah. That's why this is important. So
the awareness
>> the earlier you can start the better you
know
>> um
>> there's always hope can someone uh fix
uh a broken relationship later in teens
>> thousand% means grown adults it's called
repair
>> repair is um
sometimes more powerful
than if it didn't happen.
>> It's like a it's like when two people
are making up and the and the bond grow
strong
>> way way stronger and way deeper that
could happen between a parent and a teen
as well.
>> Absolutely.
Absolutely. And I think um
there's a way to do it but it takes this
piece. That means it takes the parents
ability to say I'm going to listen to
what you have to say and it could be so
hurtful
and I could have every excuse in the
book every cognitive excuse. Ultimately,
I believe that this is what my child's
experiencing
and I'm going to at least be there with
them in that
doesn't mean that you have to agree with
them, but you're together with them.
They're not alone in what they were
experiencing.
>> It takes a lot of courage from a parent
to admit
>> Yes.
>> that um you know, I did what I could at
that point in time. Like you said
before, every parent tries their best.
every parent and it takes it's I'm going
to say it takes a lot
I don't want to say admit I think it
takes a lot for a parent
>> to believe the child's experience as
they're saying it
>> right
>> without coming in with ways to paint it
>> right
>> that's empathy
>> right
>> every time we say I I understand how
you're feeling that's already not
empathy because it's Hi, I understand
how you're feeling
>> or I get you
>> so it feels right. But
real empathy is completely aligning
yourself for the moment with the person
so they feel like they like imagine if
you go to Shiva and you go I get I
understand you
>> right
>> it's like okay you know
>> but if you're showing them and so much
of empathy is actually facial expression
>> not so much words it's more limbic
system feelings
>> that brings everything down and brings
the temperature Yeah.
>> Wow. Amazing stuff. Um,
how should a child deal with uh sibling
rivalry? There are parents.
>> I know why uh you know I talk to people
and
talking about attachment
>> pinning one child against the other,
>> one jealous on the other, choosing
choosing him like bad vegetables.
They're choosing the children who feed
their image
>> and they're throwing away the ones who
are not.
>> What kind of wreckage does that leave on
a child's psyche?
>> Yeah, that's what it is. That this is
this is
this is the attachment is damages.
Damaging. That means the most important
relationship in my life is not showing
up.
In fact, it's damaging. So, what does
that say about other relationships? Can
I trust anyone ever in the world?
can never trust anyone. You know, these
type of
>> these children are set up for failure.
>> Yeah, children are resilient and they
have ways to cope with it. So, I'm going
to say is that they sometimes you'll see
someone that really is like amazing and
they came from such an interesting
background and how's that up add up,
>> right?
>> That's great.
Usually they're doing their own work,
but a lot of times they're coping
mechanisms and it comes with a package.
That means someone that you know there
can be a lot of pent up anger and
frustration within them and they're
channeling it in the right way. That's
great.
>> But then if it's not able to be
channeled like when you see a lot of
adults with terrible anger.
>> Yeah.
>> Terrible anger. Like really the driver
of that is a frustrated feeling. I'm not
getting your needs met ever for the
longest time.
>> Losing your trust in the parents and
then losing the trust in the universe.
They're losing the trust in any
>> every relationship, any person. And it's
very it's very hard to live with someone
like that.
>> It's very hard to do business with
someone like that.
>> It has its perks. That means they're
probably won't fall into something bad
or a bad deal because they're so
cautious.
>> They Yeah. the everybody is guilty.
>> Mhm. Mhm. Yeah. It's really hard to
trust people.
>> Yeah.
>> They lose their trust and to build back
trust uh you know, welcome to the you
know
>> therapy world.
>> Yeah. Now what if parents and and you
know parents parents are parents and
we're human beings and sometimes we lose
it.
>> Sometimes we feel that we need to yell.
the parents who are not physical, you
know,
>> yeah,
>> are yelling. Yeah.
>> And uh all these other things.
>> Um
>> this is when something is going wrong
and for the right reasons. You know, we
had a hard day and everything is going
south,
>> right?
>> And uh
is there a time when a parent can yell
or is there a time for for time to lose
it
>> and it's okay? [gasps]
>> I think there's a difference between
losing it and and yelling. That's first
of all, um,
usually when someone's losing it, it's
not because someone told them it's okay
to lose it. They just lost it. There's
no way to control it. But,
>> but yelling, here's what I what I think.
Think of it as like a 7030 or like
65 35 type of balance.
You scream, you get frustrated, you
don't have space for your child. put it
into the 30% basket and that's totally
fine. Consider that the golden standard,
>> right?
>> We're human,
>> right?
>> In no way
is should anyone come and say you have
to do this 100% of the time. That's not
healthy for a child either cuz he has to
have some sort of
up and down a little bit also within a
safe relationship,
>> right? So, I would say call it 7030.
And anytime something goes bad or
anytime something's um you don't you're
not proud about the way you made your
child feel or the way you acted, throw
it into the 30 basket and you're in the
and you're in the golden standard,
>> right? There's always a repair that can
happen which can take the whatever you
put into the 30 and pump up your whole
day into 150 when you come over to them.
And some people aren't comfortable to
apologize to your child. So what I've
come up with is the idea that you
apologize that this has happened.
You don't have to personally apologize
if you don't feel like
>> I think you can, but there are people
that will don't can't or don't feel
comfortable. So this is like a step
under that. You apologize that this
happened and you're really sorry that
this happened,
>> you know, like it it had to happen
because I lost it. But you know what?
>> I really I'm really sad that that it
happened,
>> right?
>> And that shows so much to a child
because it's not saying I'm sorry, you
know, like it
>> it has to come with the meaning and the
and the
>> How about ignoring it and thinking that
it's going to go away?
>> Yeah. The child holds on to it. Um, but
again, throw it into the 30 and you're
in the golden stand.
>> You're okay.
>> Yeah.
>> Because what you just did is you you
showed your child that you're a human
being.
>> You're not Superman.
>> Absolutely.
>> And he's also the child is also going to
experience
>> Yeah.
>> You know, he also has tantrums and also,
you know, so you're human.
>> You're actually communicating with your
child human behavior.
>> But you know what?
It's not abuse and it's and you you grab
yourself
>> and just teaches your child that you
know your child will actually look up to
it rather than um
>> Yeah. And I think there's there's a
there is a place in every in every
I'm going to say day situation where you
could let your children know about your
thought process and that you're not
Superman,
>> right? like you're stuck in traffic and
you're upset and you feel like it's just
worth it to just turn around because
we're not going to get to the anyways
>> and that's how you're feeling because
that's probably how that feeling,
>> right?
>> And then you say,
>> but you know what? Let's go. Let you let
them know the process and that actually
is so impactful because you're not
telling them how to think. You're saying
it about yourself and they by osmosis
take it in.
>> Right? Let's move over to schools. We're
talking about parenting and part of a
child's life is the school. A huge part
of a child's life is the school. Now,
is it healthy to have an attachment to a
teacher? You know, sometimes you have
these children who have a crush on their
teacher.
>> Um, is it healthy to have an attachment
to friends? Is it healthy to have an
attachment in the school environment?
>> Absolutely. For sure. I think the
unhealthy attachment patterns that you
find in the school
>> is because of the attachment pattern
that is not going on at home or the
opposite of it where they're so seeking
to be validated, so seeking to be seen.
So they'll do crazy things, they'll do
stuff
>> and like when you jump to school and you
think about behaviors.
So, you know, they came out with a
diagnosis, it's odd, opposition defined
>> disorder.
>> And if you look at the description,
it's a child, the way I like what I'm
hearing, it's a child who's who's who's
so discouraged.
>> Yeah. Like's opposing authority.
>> All his needs are are are so unmet that
the only way he can do it is by pushing
back at authority. and then he gets some
sort of adrenaline, some sort of
>> rush that he's he'll feel better. It's
like his drug. So, so of course it's
doing that for him. But like if you're
going to start looking at that and not
really what the motor and the the
vehicle for what why it's happening,
you know, you might get a child who's
going to be a little bit better on
medication in school.
>> Mhm.
>> Let's say for let's say this type of
thing. But are you hitting the core
issue?
>> Right. You're saying they're
misdiagnosed with all these names
sometimes, but really what's missing is
something from the house.
>> Yeah.
>> Now, I had a Makan over here who, a big
Makan for a lot of years was telling me
that, you know, how do schools handle
bullying?
>> Mhm.
>> And he says
bullying has to do with the child's
home,
>> where the child comes from. it was
someone is bullying in that house and
that's why he comes to school and he
bull I mean it's not a school issue
>> so I think it happens in the school so
[laughter] so absolutely I think that if
you want to get down to the car to the
to the to the bottom line
>> two things
it's how children respond to the bully
because I think parents can help
children respond to bullies in a certain
way and help them understand exactly
like you're saying this bully is in so
much pain that the only way to get rid
of it is by that adrenaline rush and
that dopamine rush of making you get
angry or making you feel down
>> and so explaining this to our children
and when we hear of a bully we can we
can punish the bully and try to control
him but I think there's a lot of that
has to happen but there's also a lot of
understanding of like what's going on
for this child what's going on for him
why is he doing this. It's not a natural
thing to do. There's something when a
child misbehaves. I'm saying this in
home. I'm saying this in school, saying
this in camp. When there's misbehavior
from the child, that's not the problem,
>> right?
>> The problem is is that there's the
child's not
is feeling discouraged and and um
feeling like something's off and they're
their needs are not being met, cold, the
batteries not being full, whatever, and
they need to fill it with something
else. and that's why they're doing it.
Um, so whose issue is that? You're
right. Getting down to the to the, you
know,
>> right?
>> It's going to be the the home.
>> Yeah. Uh, what's your feeling about
schools? Um, their emotional support
that they're giving the children versus
academics. Do they is there a bigger
percent? Do you want would you like to
see more uh emphasis put on emotional
connection and feelings than curriculum?
>> So
I don't think it's a steer.
>> I think it's both
>> and each one on the higher standard and
one doesn't take away from the other.
>> Right? There's little we can do to teach
our children
how to emotionally regulate and how to
be better. You know, they could like
fill out a worksheet of how you're
supposed to behave. Push comes to shove,
they're in the yard, that worksheet is
in one ear out there. It's really about,
I think, the ability to be mocked with
what's going on, to have the child
system calm down, look at a system, see
what's going on, calm a system through
the empathy piece, and then put down the
rules. Like, for sure, this is there's
rules. You're in school. Of course,
that's what happens. And of course,
teaching has to happen. And has to
happen. And that's where we we send our
children to for that's that's that's so
much of it. But I think I think it's
like that
thing before or that there's so much on
a Reby's plate nowadays that I feel so
uncomfortable even saying maybe
something else like add another thing.
There's so much that they have.
But it's like taking that child that
they saw got hurt by another child or
maybe by the reby's own words and going
over to them at the schoolyard and
repairing it in the way that we talked
about
>> that you're not you're doing that's what
they're going to remember from fifth
grade. They don't remember anything
else.
>> What are we do you remember fifth grade?
Do you remember exactly what you
learned? We need to learn. We need to
develop our brains and all that stuff.
But that will be something there. I know
myself I remember there was one specific
like you know you remember that rebby
>> right
>> and that gives you that feeling.
>> What message do you have for a teacher a
rebby or a rasha of how to be sensitive
and use empathy
in the classroom so they can spot a
child who really needs it that they can
change that kid's life forever. M yeah.
So
just one one way is to you see a child
that something's going on and and um
taking taking them over maybe privately
and just saying like hi is everything
okay. Now when we say that I see that
there's something wrong or something
must be bothering you. That's not
empathy.
You're already projecting what you're
thinking. That's already in the next
step. Let's back up for a second.
>> We have to sort of take a deep breath
and like back up. Let's lean in to
what's happening for that to that child.
What's going on in his world? Like, is
everything okay? And if a child is shut
down and sad, in a way, he needs someone
that can feel that sadness. So, you're
not going to be like, "Hey, Yankee,
what's going on?" It's going to be a
little bit sad like when you go into a
Shiva,
>> right? It's good. Not to that extent,
but you're the energy you're going to
give over is I get you.
>> I get you.
>> I feel you.
>> Here's the thing. When a child feels
felt, funny way of saying it,
>> that's what takes them out of whatever
at least brings them out of the
>> shutdown or the fight mode and puts them
into their higher brain, prefrontal
cortex, and they can talk about it and
they can process it.
>> So, I think it's I think it's empathy.
And there's so it's very tricky, but
I've actually come up with a way to do
it and like a um
just like little pointers so as to help
the person feel like you get them.
>> Wow. And this is saving a person's life.
>> It could. It could. Cuz when if
something more use the word sinister is
going on or something else, they'll be
faster to come over to you as a rebby
>> cuz they felt so safe in that moment
when you just gave them even just a
little bit of space, you know, and they
might on the surface look like they're
pushing you away, but that could also be
a test. Is he going to respect me?
>> Yeah.
>> Cuz I've never been respected my whole
life. Every time I say go away, they
push back at me and they make me
whatever. here. It's like, okay, so I
want you to come over to me. I'm here.
You know, and you give them that.
There's a lot of ways to play it and
read into what's going on. You know,
they might like shrug their shoulders,
whatever. That's
>> if no one was safe until now,
>> you're not just from one conversation
going to it's a process.
>> Yeah. What about since we're on this
subject um
>> sharing with the child let's say
about the
when you talk to a child this language
right the surrender language and you
look at the world you know trying to
control everything but we can't um there
is
it actually shows the child
a different side of you that also models
to the child when they'll go out in the
world that it's not the end of the world
and everything doesn't have to be the
way you want. How important is to add
this into parenting?
>> Wow, I can't believe you just asked me
that question because I've been working
on this
thought.
I think absolutely it should be talked
about. But here's the thing. We all talk
about it.
>> We have to feel it.
The way it's so it's really interesting.
The way I think you can actually give
over to your child the sense of Hashem,
the sense of amuna
is through this empathy. Because what
the child as a zero to twoyear-old, as a
three or fouryear-old, when they get hit
by that empathy and they get hit by that
mirroring or what, however you're you're
making them feel felt, you're not
touching them, but they're feeling felt.
>> Correct? And what that's doing is it's
programming their ability to feel like
they could feel felt by something or
someone or something that they don't see
or they can't touch or grasp.
>> Wow. It's powerful
>> extremely. And I think these are the
tents. This is the base how if you we
all want our children to be connected.
So doing this actually I think is the
blueprint and the inoculation for
anything that might come against it
because their their systems wired. We
all think Hashem is here. Hashem is
there. Hashem is surely every
>> but the ability to feel that
>> right
>> is when they know my father's here all
the time. My mother's here all the time.
Not sitting and hovering over but when I
need them
>> they're here.
>> I calm down with their presence. What
you're saying is that you're emulating a
physically
>> and you're teaching this child when this
child is newborn
>> that there is a higher power. There is
somebody to rely on when you'll need and
you share then later you share this with
the child and you tell I'm relying on
this too
>> connects
>> and and this is a it's a huge foundation
for zero from zero to two you start then
>> this is called preventive parenting
>> yeah this is this is um huge you know
it's very interesting um the paras
speaks about
and he says something that had a
profound impact on me
[snorts] and he he he says a very it's a
long thing but he he basically tightes
up what is and he says what it is is
>> the the ability to be dakashem
>> yeah but the vas in English is what is
it yearning clinging what's the word of
the
>> attachment
>> attachment you call the veus attachment
>> absolutely
>> the lavka boy is the goal Yeah,
>> that's what that's why we are here
>> and all the when a child can see all the
mitzvah as a way to continue on with
whatever connection he's yearning for
and and that
makes the mitzvah so much different,
>> right?
>> But [clears throat] how can you put
someone that's a disconnected human
being to every human being and say now
connect to something else,
>> right?
>> How do you do that? But if you can in
put it inborn in them from the
beginning,
>> you're acting like the an agent of
emulation
from Hashem to us
>> experientially.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. It's
>> very powerful stuff.
>> Very powerful stuff. And I think that um
the child you put the child on a
foundation of
uh such security.
>> Yeah.
to know that there is Hashem and your
father is also relying on Hashem. Your
Superman in your eyes is also relying on
Hashem.
>> I guess I would ask you the question,
what do we all want from our kids? Like,
you know, as a goal longterm, we have
like short-term goals, but like what's
our long-term goal of for our children?
And I think it's two things. I think
it's to be connected. So that means to
us and to the
>> it's also to be resilient
>> in this world we live in
>> to be resilient we get knocked down we
get pushed back and all that comes from
this piece of empathy and connection.
>> Wow.
>> Yeah.
>> So the veus the t of the veus is
attachment.
It makes sense. Unbelievable stuff.
Yeah.
>> All I can say is thank you.
[sighs and gasps]
>> Thank you.
>> Thank you not just for the tools that
you gave. Um thank you for sharing a
lens
>> that we need to look at as parents and
the way we look at ourselves and the way
we look at our children.
>> And that is a a a beautiful awareness
and a beautiful lesson. And my to you is
you should have in everything you do.
>> Amen. especially on the holy mission
that you're doing that you're helping
families heal.
>> Amen.
>> I want to thank you for coming. Thank
you.