CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 91 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] >> I go to work boys I I don't know what you mean but this is my life in Lincoln Wood. Sadik I love Olive. We're holding 6 7 lines from the top. I'm a mother. 29 so the title is is a car that I'm saying Thank you for saving me. I'm a lawyer man. How do you know we're talking about the second here the whole season the second. In general when the person is about the second it talks about the flower the oil and the wine. I'm going to try to point out where we're talking about only the wine. Play the minion. I'm a lawyer man. Always ever so this we had yesterday. I did this chart those remember from this possible we learn all sorts of things. The red is a mute the green is a reboy. And from the words I never have those two words so from the I I learned title. In the second I tell you. They never have teaches us Schwan. So the more says what the title love is ever cool. What uh a title is not why can't it be included in the words ever why do you need a special word I I don't tell you love is ever cool. Says the more it's rich. So that I don't have to go to the bathroom like when I suck how many birds come with the title of a boy say 40. There's so many breads so that's instead of the second. I shall mail another. Let's see if we can find another here this another. He also comes he has three carbons and has to bring plus he has to bring breads. Now think about it boy in the second you still have to bring wine with the with the another. So that's the more so that I mean I have some shiny meaning over there by the another he sees only holding two types how we are kicking. I mean but by the title we bring the the comments in how we are kicking the whole lot four types how much more long. Tells us with all the types of breads you can't get away with it you still have to bring the second. Says the more I don't know what the following another I'm a double below by either. Why if we go back over here to this possible. Let's see if I have another one. I don't know. Just did that from before okay. Why do I love is a type of a another so isn't it included in the following another. The second line from the top on the possible the following another should I been a double. It should include I love. I love I love I mean of a season issue of a sham cloud. The following another I've been a double product. So you should do a good job here. Who is those great job. But in the cloud product cloud cuz we're very worried that people will have trauma from cloud product cloud. Cloud now that we saw all the characters there. The season issue of a sham. Bring a carbon all these are included they have to do what we're talking about the second of a boy said the whole day today is all about the second. I see some issue of a sham all these guys the net and a double the pace of the car. The ocean cut they all need the second. So that's a cloud. The following another I've been a double product. So now we're going to go to the next one product. >> [snorts] >> Where is it? Oh oops I think I went too far. The following another oh. So it says in the first in the possible only another another. So knocks out all the other guys becomes a cloud. Cuz if we stop over here cloud is a generalization includes everything product in the cloud product if it's a cloud and then a product then the title is telling you exactly what I want. But once the title adds another cloud it becomes a sandwich then it's not everything and it's not only the product it's something in between. Right? A cloud means everything a product means only these two but when you have a cloud and then a product and then a cloud so then the you generalize but it has to be similar to the product. The following another product. The right choir. Whom? Who's the right choir? Slow moving today. Oh. So I add some stuff but I just took off some stuff. So I added the mice and a piece of cause I have a color. And the cloud is cloud by the way we're not doing a lot of cloud product cloud so don't have any trauma we're done. Cloud product cloud e out of done okay now product as we similar to the product. And what's the similarity my problem of those of a sham boy. I'll cut. It doesn't come for sin so that would take off the cut off and the ocean. I would say cut off the ocean boy I'm a cut. I'll be the car and mice and a piece of but I'll include the car and mice and a piece of sham boy I'm a cut. Oh. So tell me what you mean I love. So what do we have here? So I want to show you I just I just redid the initial chart for a second. First of all I love. Includes the net and a double. And then what do we have? So I don't take everything out. Let's let's do it for a second hash the civil law. That the I love takes out the car and the mice and the piece of. Cloud product normal. Cloud product normal normal is by so what does it just include if I took out the car and mice and a piece of. So what does it include? My problem of those of a choir women. I've called you know you choir women. It's something that you're not choir right now to do the hobby and this comes to include blood is kosher. The offspring of kosher what more awesome. So if you look over here you did a whole whole sucker. Tomorrow means if you find a a nicer bigger animal you say I want this to be instead of the original that's awesome but it becomes just like the original. And that also requires the second the offspring over here this little baby here. This little baby Vlad Schwan and the Vlad also requires the second Vlad I love I mean I might try what how do you do that let's see. I don't I don't see him there either. He's not in there okay but the I love that comes that that's what we learned yesterday we have extra we have a what extra but you have extra funds in the base of a big dash or extra wine that goes over the top so you buy you sell it you buy an I love for the kids in the back but I don't need that the real. That's the famous one but we'll show it anyways for what's next. The ocean goes to Kevin's land you try to get it the moon. And what happened? Oh you you sell you sell it then you buy another one okay. The call is walking the whole lot of sham the bottom line is at the end of the day the possible tells us that all these things require the second besides the cut off and the ocean. So let me just see. Okay here. So comes out like this a little bit of a change than what we had before. The bottom line is the season issue of a sham I love I love we learn not the red means it's a mute. Not a car and mice. I comes to include title that's how we started the second I comes to never comes to exclude the min call the following another another comes to if you anything that comes from a car for like a a cut off. And then the rest I just left in there that's not from today's second but the the top changes slightly. Okay. That's like the mask on the second so in other words here I'll show you this. Just to remind you what it looked like when we started this year looked like this. The more changes basically a few of the remove them based on the cloud product cloud. Okay. So the more I wish down I love the Russia. I'm learning I. For Russia the following another I've been a double love me now we have to discuss every single time we have an I. So let me just show you what I did it real quickly I don't know if it's going to help or just here. There are four the more is just going to say there's four I's. There's I love I never have the same possible there's three. I love I never have this possible that I just showed you yeah here look look over here this possible. You see it says three times I never I never have I so I just put them together like this. And basically it gives you the four options. If you have two different you have but it's the same type of carbon. Let's say it's an I love. But there's another and another so it's two different things. That I learned from I never have I the I and I tell you there's no need to suck in that case. What do I do the following another I've been a double. When the carbon is different in both the type of carbon and the type of a barrel but the type of thing. And then you have says it's the same. The same but two different types [clears throat] of carbon honest. Let's say it's an adult of of so it's the same but different carbon are you Islam? And finally you have the same human the same the same type of carbon. Like an when it comes to another another Islam. That's what I learned. So let's just see it inside. The four what I do the four eyes. We can just leave it on the screen Mark. What do I need to split it up? Maybe have to bring both another and another. The what? Both another and another. Holds that the the valve connects them and says that if you have two things in the in the same possible there you have to do both of them. They're both together let's say. So that's why it says I I separate. This is You don't need to do both. The above a keyboard or the above that connects them in this case is not connected. Why? Because there's a I in between. That's according to that they get connected even without the word when we had this whole thing. You need we don't need to. By So the Torah says that we together by it doesn't say doesn't need to be together. But the above a keyboard puts it together. What do I need this I? What if I see another or another? What if you bring two carbons together? Hurry up lion arrays you together. Maybe one is should be good for both. No. You need to bring two. Let's say I bring two types of carbon honest or another and another. One is another one is another. It doesn't matter. The is another the is another. What if they're both of them the two types of You have a two different types of but they're both another. Same another they're both one another one another. Maybe one is for both is okay. The kids are we have four different possibilities and that's why I need four different eyes. Always it's actually the beginning of the possible. Maybe you need to bring two when when you do one one but it's another you know what I mean another. But what if it's not it's two carbon honest but the they're they come for two different reasons. It's another so two of them two and two are one so maybe you should bring one of them. >> [clears throat] >> The following why do I say Islam? I think that's when you bring two one is another one is another so they're very different. You know I said this already. Oh it's one sorry it's one another or one another but this is going to be one is enough. said if he says I really oil one is enough. Why? You learned it from him oil carbon. But he doesn't learn the I. Focuses on the word I. What does he do with I? If he already learns it from oil carbon I in my carbon I what does he do with I? It is two types of animals literally two types of animals. How do you have two types of animals? A cow and a sheep two types. I will know you have two sheep to go with maybe one is enough great. What do you do with the possible castle? Okay they come they come different days so they need different they come in the same time. We learned in the mission we did look up child but it's all like that. It says in the mission I I pointed out. I don't have the whole list but remember we have a list of 10 different carbon honest. I can call them and catch them and catch you catch them. And it says the five of the of the carbon honest need the five gold. From the the carbon honest that don't need them so I can you have on the on the right side on the you have a hot and awesome. But the hot and awesome also have a situation where they do need when by the Sarah. The hot and the Sarah let's see. Here. This is the right? He brings three carbon honest or another. And he also has to bring a minute. [snorts] How do you know that a has to bring a minute? The total of a barrel says by Sarah. Three of flower. Oh. Nobody asked this question. Let's see if this teenager knows. What's the difference between a minute is very important. I don't know if you know this cuz I don't know if we learned it. What's the difference between maybe you have it in a I don't know. What's the difference between a minute they just bring by itself and or a minute that comes with a carbon. It's the same the same flower the same oil. But one you bring on its own and one comes together with a carbon. Do you know the difference? I what? No. By the way could be this also the flower and oil is called also. Sometimes it's called wine some of it first the wine some is not it's a little confusing. The mission says it actually means even the flower and the oil. Okay it's a very simple thing. No I'm saying they're identical in what they look like. Their ingredients are identical. There's one major difference. The one you bring a minute on its own so you put the on the the rest goes to the on. Whereas the one that comes together you know this? The one that comes together with a carbon it all goes on the barrel. So that's why they I'm just pointing it out here cuz the says the minute by my cousin of a barrel. It's the type that comes together with a carbon so it all goes on the barrel. It's very different when it comes by itself the kind of get to eat from it. I've already been that I'm already talking about. The the minute that comes with the carbon. So here the word means wine. I don't know if it needs wine the wine. It needs wine. And then says and the word is in the same So the kids are we have in this possible three of them to teach us these three carbon honest. Ask the of the table of a barrel. Two of them the hot and the awesome why don't they learn those two from the barrel? Oh. So this to understand this is very simple but we learned this a number of times we're learning specially. So why am I showing you this? Because you're supposed to put the here underneath the Islam. Now it says the now we understand what it means here. What if you put the here under the the wrong path? By the hot or by the awesome they don't go together different times like one is when he finishes his the other if he messed up the middle. But the point is what if you put it under the wrong path? Oh. So the word zevach us hot and asham. So my also why do I need three different words? Yeah? He learned oil oil zevach and the oil. Three words. Why? I can learn from the word zevach chata'os and asham. That's only when they're equal. Osham and chata'os come to do something different. Then by by the metzora. The asham comes to to allow him to to to go and and drink wine etc. The chata'os comes to give him a forgiveness on the tzara'as. So therefore being a tray right, that's why I need the oil zevach, the oil the oil and the oil to teach us because the chata'os and asham are different. Then again, the chata'os metzora needs wine. Who told you zevach is referring to the chata'os metzora? Here was the nazir. Let's see if we have anything for nazir. Oh yeah, this guy. All in the beginning we had the nazir. The what? Maybe it's one of the the chata'os and the asham. All the nazir. You see over here it only says chata'os cuz that's at the end. The asham is if he messes up. Okay. The point is how do you know this person is doing the metzora? Maybe he's talking about a nazir. Can't be the same. Woman chos this is by nazir woman chos this is same. We're talking about an oil and shlamim. I thought I remember last week shlamim oil afilu chata'os that the chata'os needs the sakan. I have a klal here. The oil was there and then beforehand in the psukim. What do you have to say? Two-year-old oil comes for willingly through another called You only do the sakan when it comes oil and I may I need the zevach for the metzora. Oil oil The what? Oil of metzora needs wine. When a woman gives birth she has to bring two two korbanos. She brings a sheep for an oil and a bird for a chata'os. If she's poor then she brings two birds. Instead of the the sheep for the oil she brings a bird oil. But a regular woman brings a sheep and a chata'os. How do you know oil means they have to bring wine with the oil of a metzora. Maybe it's the oil of a woman who gave birth. Yeah. So every 10th one he's supposed to say my he's supposed to take a red thing. But what happened was on number 10 he said it's a nine and number 11 he said it's 10. And number nine he said to him because he got all mixed up. So what do you do with number 11? The old cottage what do you do with number 11? Where are we? Oh. You bring the 11th as a shlamim. It's called this but not it's not a it's not a it's not a ma'aser shlamim. And it requires the sakan. Why do I need a pasuk? It's a mistake. And the mistake is more common you have to bring the sakan with it when the ma'aser does not require the sakan. Right? We already we already established in the beginning of this year bechor ma'aser and pesach do not need the sakan. And now you tell me number 11 needs the sakan which is more common than the what it came to replace. I'll tell you what Shas he says. You ask me why who told you that the pasuk is talking about a metzora? Maybe he's talking about other stuff. But the pasuk has three rebuyim. What are the the three three words? Oil oil and zevach. What? What thing has three korbanos that need the three rebuyim? The only I can think of is a metzora. We're continuing. What do I need the word oil? I already have it in pinkos. The ram that Aaron brings on Yom Kippur. Every Cohen Gadol brings on Yom Kippur. You have to bring the sakan every Yom Tov from the word of dechem? All korbanos that come on Yom Tov. Perhaps when it comes to the individual he doesn't have to bring the sakan. So the first thing that I I had a problem with Rebbi Osei this should bother you as well is just yesterday we learned that a yachid does have to bring the sakan on Yom Tov. I'll remind you that we started we were talking yesterday about what korbanos you have to bring on Yom Tov. The shlomei chagiga and shlomei simcha and oil re'iya. And the Gemara already established that those you need to bring the sakan. So why would the Gemara say over here oil of the yachid oil? The the korbanos that a individual brings on Yom Tov don't need. Of course they do. So they say the pshat is beautiful. Since so many didn't come to the same English that day to bring the oil re'iya the oil shlomei chagiga the shlomei simcha so it's considered a korban tzibur. You hear? Interesting pshat. Cuz the tzibur comes. Why is it any different than than the oil of a woman who gives birth? Why would I say she has to but he doesn't have to? I think you know a woman gives birth every could be every day of the year. There's no special specific time. I would say it's man. But the Cohen Gadol brings his korban on Yom Kippur he doesn't have to bring sakan. Come ask him that's why I need a special pasuk. His his korban is is I would think it's different. No. Oil What what I do with the oil? The rabbis say Here we go. The palgas. What's the palgas? The palgas is a sheep that was supposed that if it's in the first the first 12 months of its life it's called a keves. From 12 months on it's called an oil. Month 13 I think it's it's it's it's own thing. The Gemara is going to discuss is it is it a a bre'a bifnei atzmo even? It's not. So we have a is it its own category? Meaning check this out. If a person makes a neder I'm going to bring a keves or a oil he wouldn't be able to bring a palgas. It's it's it's own little category. A one-month category. It's not. A krivei if you if you did bring a palgas as a korban maybe oil oil oil oil. You have to bring pretend that it's a oil. Here I'll show you real quickly just to remind the oil. The oil all the way on the left brings two sort of oils and four log of shamen. Versus a keves on the right only brings one and three. He has double the amount of flour and one extra log that the oil. So what you do is you bring the most. You bring all the the flour and the oil of the the the larger ram. And you make a condition you make it night that if it's not if it's not a ram we'll see in a second. But you have to bring another korban. Maybe this guy you know it doesn't work for you. You have to bring another korban. So I need the pasuk to teach us that the palgas even though it's its own individual category you bring the sakan with it. He argues on He brings this. He brings sorry. According to stuck in that he makes it night. That's according to Rava. According to it's not night. It's a category by itself and there's a pasuk that tells me that in the 13th month you bring this the korban. But according to I don't know what it is. It's either a keves or a oil. It's not a category by itself. So what do you do? You bring your palgas and you make a condition. The safek cuz it's only a safek. And what's the condition you say? If it's a oil so I'm giving the two isaron of flour for the oil. If it's a keves and only needs one so I'm giving it one and the extra will just go as an edava on the on the mizbeach. But it's a safek. It's a voice. Like you think the Torah is coming to tell us that if there's a safek animal you bring that's not how it works. So the Gemara says you're right. According to I have a problem. I don't know what to do with the oil. Next sugia. The shaar oil >> So this is simple Gamara. There's a difference here. I showed it. I showed it again. There's a difference between the of the ram all the way on the left and the of sheep. So I think that also when it comes to bulls, there's a bull and there's a calf. The calf is a year old and everything above a year, okay, what the Gamara does is it says, "Listen, it's like a sheep." Once it's 13 months old, 13 14 months old, it's already a par. So maybe it should have different type of So I have one All bulls are in the same category. All the vision of bench and style. All there's a difference between them of a year old and a 2-year-old. You don't have to make a difference Keep on making differences. When it turns 3 years old, maybe it has even more the time of all the time of all the time of all the time. Not the item. You have to keep on making a difference between also by the females you should make enough community between a 1-year-old and a 2-year-old. I'm going to all the time of all the time of all the time. No. You know, it's only by the males. I'm going to all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time of all the time. You have to keep on making a difference between a goat and a 2-year-old and a 1-year-old. I'm going to all the time of all the time of all the time. They're all the same. Or a papa. All the time of all the time. So the papa this is all the time tested us. So you know, they asked the question over here. Why is it all the time of all the time? He only asked for papa. No. Unless you know, they add he has the whole year. Papa saying over. It says over here all the time of all the time. I don't know if papa was saying all the time of all the time even though it was only him. Basically. All the time of all the time. All the time of all the time. How much wine you bring when you bring a female sheep? That's what That was his question. It was a test. How much wine do you bring with the female sheep? Says all the time of all the time. We must listen I brought a writer from the mission. The wild says all the time of all the time. So I should all the time of all the She's So the way the way it works is you went to a station and you paid for your wine and your and your flower and they gave you a settle. And on the settle it said one of a few different things. But if it said all the time of all the time so it meant that you paid for the of all sheep all the time of all the time older and smaller the the large and small not older large and small Who's the It does not include 2-year-old males. In other words, that answers question that what? That the of a female sheep are identical to the male because you get the same settle whether it's a male or female. All the time of all the time. Have a wonderful day, a wonderful week. Thank you for coming. >> [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a share today at sponsor.com or sponsor [music] at .com.