0:00 / 0:00
CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 109 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky
111 views
- Good Morning - 108B - 109A - 109B - Have a Wonderful Day! -- MDY presents: "Nothing but the Daf", R’ Eli Stefansky’s MDY (Mercaz Daf Yomi) Shiur in a concise format - all the clarity of the full daf Shiur, with Reb Eli's unique charts and visual aids, without any extras (emails, stories etc.) Perfect for Chazarah or anyone who wants a quick, focused Daf.
Chapters
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[music]
>> Good morning
Rabbi
We are holding by the mission on daf kuf
ches amud beis. Hoymer
Echod mikvasai hekdesh v'echod mishvarai
hekdesh. Reboise, you think about it
without the mishnah.
You said you have a whole ranch,
thousands of animals. You said one of
these animals is is hekdesh. Which one?
Which one?
So we have a concept
of
v'chol mivchar nedavosecha
l'Hashem
It should be mivchar, to be the the the
top.
So hoymer echod, one mikvasai hekdesh
v'echod mishvarai or he says one of my
bulls vo yelishnayim and only have two
hagodol shebahem hekdesh.
Mivchar nedavosechem, you got to get the
best. So now we take the same, we apply
the same reasoning. You have three
and he said the best, which one should
it be?
He didn't say the best. He said I want
to give one of the bulls. It should be
the best.
What's the difference between two and
three? Says the mishnah
shlosha, if he has three, beinoni
shebahem hekdesh, the middle one.
This doesn't fit into what we just said.
>> [clears throat]
>> So the gemara is going to explain. I'm
just doing chazarah here.
It means
also the middle one. Of course the top
one cuz the whole mivchar nedavosechem,
you got to go to the top. Also the
middle.
>> [clears throat]
>> So two of them are kodesh. So now I have
a problem. Two, how do you get out of
two? The gemara gives you an eitzah.
beinoni shebahem hekdesh Pirash even
yedama Pirashti I I remember designating
one, I I don't remember what, osham al
yedei avo ben yedama, my father died and
as he was dying he said one of the bulls
is hekdesh. Hagodol shebahem hekdesh,
let's take the number one, top one, the
largest heaviest, most kishmak, most
expensive one, that's the one that goes.
Mivchar nedavosechem.
Says the gemara from the fact if there's
two you have to give the number one,
alma madish b'yofa madish, a person
always donates with a largeness, he has
a good eye.
Aima save us, then what do we do with
the middle case? Beinoni shebahem
hekdesh. If he donated one out of three,
you give the middle one. How's that
possible? It's the top, it's the number
one.
alma madish b'ro madish
Omer Shmuel choshesh umafli beinoni. The
pshat is no, it's not only the middle
one, it's also the middle one. The top
one for sure goes to the hekdesh because
mivchar nedavosechem, you give the top.
But also the middle one. Dilga b'katan.
Hold on a second.
We're getting there, we're getting
there. All if we finish the sugia and
you have a question then you'll ask.
Dilga b'katan ain yofa hu because
the smallest one he is
kodesh. As the gemara heichi ovid, what
should he do? He can't bring two animals
to be some English. Each one is $5,000.
Omer Reb Chaim bar Rav Huh?
100%. Mamtin loy ad sheyuman. What you
do is you wait until the middle guy gets
a mum, falls a mum. You send him to
kaves land.
Umachalei d'kedusha sheba godol. B'mana
afsha.
Either the kedusha was on the top one
and not on the middle one at all, and
even if it was on the middle one and not
on the top one, we're going to move the
kedusha, the owner is going to move the
kedusha as it has a mum, I'm going to
transfer, that's a better word. I'm
going to transfer the kedusha from the
middle guy to the top guy and only one
is kodesh because in fact he only said
one.
Of course we're talking about we don't
know what's going on. We we takka have a
If we knew what's going on, great, but
we don't. So we got to we got to make
sure that we
dot our i's cross our t's. Omer Rav
Nachman Omer Rava bar Avuha, lishono el
hadomer echod mishvarai hekdesh, if a
person said one
out of
my all my axes, he could have meant the
middle one. Aval Omer shor bishvarai, he
uses different lotion. The axe of all
axes.
So now the axe of all axes means number
one, that's there's no question that a a
guy says axe of all my ax ax shor
bishvarai, the axe of axes. And what if
he says
house of houses?
He has a bunch of real estate. He says
house of houses.
L'chora means the biggest nicest house.
The nicest penthouse. Okay.
shor bishvarai hekdesh hagodol shebahem
hekdesh, there's no question that a guy
uses such a lotion, the axe of all axes,
he means the best, the best of the best.
toyra b'toyra yikra, he meant the most
chashuv.
Okay?
In this context a lot of people love to
to be chashuv. This time this chashuv is
is an ox. The most chashuv is an ox.
Aini Omer Rabbonon bar Chiyya mishmei
d'Ulla, hoymer l'chaveiro bayis b'veisi
ani moyach l'cho. I have a bunch of
houses, I'm selling you the house of
houses.
Mareh aliyah, he shows him the attic.
The attic in the time of the gemara
wasn't very good.
You have to walk up steps, it's hard to
get to. It might be a little, you know,
there might be a little slant in the
roof. It's not kishmak over there.
So why is it when a person says the
house of a houses he shows him an
aliyah?
Lama shmu d'griya, the gemara is going
to make a distinction like that soon.
Lama shmu d'griya, isn't it because I'm
showing you the worst, not the best?
Loy, m'ula sheba batim. Look at the word
aliyah means a ben aliyah, like somebody
that who's who's growing, he's he's
working his way up. Aliyah in fact means
the best of the best.
What does the best of the best mean? The
penthouse. I'm giving you the best. Not
the not not the attic that you're
thinking, I'm giving you the best.
So zogt die gemara, meisevei, have a
kasha.
shor bishvarai hekdesh
If a person says
shor bishvarai
the axe of axes, the axe of axes
>> [clears throat]
>> and what does it say second later?
V'chein shor shel hekdesh. Yeah, let me
just put them up on the screen together.
You don't really need it, but
one case is shor bishvarai. What does
shor bishvarai mean? Top of the top.
What's the next one? shor shel nisaraf
Says in the seifa
v'chein shor shel hekdesh nisaraf
acherem
Reboise, I pay attention over here. It
says v'chein. These two cases are
identical. Shor shel nisaraf, meaning I
have this is a bad case and we talked we
spoke about it in King's Ranch in Texas
or whatever that that place is, the guy
has 800,000 [clears throat]
acres, right? The property is worth $9
billion the property. Owned privately.
35,000
cattle, at least.
And I take one
one shor, I want to get him good. Take
one shor that's like this and throw him
in there.
He's a goner.
All 35,000, what are you going to do?
There's helicopters over there, they're
trying to herd the things. Cri- it's
like larger than Israel, 850, I don't
even know. It might be like the size of
Israel. Something crazy, meshuga. So
you you could really mess a guy up with
this case, right? V'chein shor shel
hekdesh nisaraf acherem, hekdesh got
mixed up with others. Hagodol shebahem
hekdesh, what do you do?
You take the largest one and you make it
hekdesh.
V'chulam yimachru l'tzarchei oilos. In
both of these cases, reboise, I even in
the first case, shor bishvari, why? Cuz
it says shor bishvari then a second
later it says v'chein shor shel nisaraf.
What do you do? Top one, top dog, the
top shor goes to hekdesh, but what do
you do with the rest? All of them must
be sold because you don't know which
one, maybe one of them is is a oilo.
Each one has a safek b'kedushas guf.
Safek kedushas dam, it's a massive
kedusha over here. Each one and all
l'tzarchei oilos. U'dmeihen chulin. And
then you take the money, give it to
chulin.
So it's a kasha. We said only the top
one in case number one, shor bishvari,
only the top one, we there's no mention
of selling the rest.
Terei gemara, shor shel hekdesh nisaraf
acherem, that that halacha of of that
you sell everything is only in that,
only in the second case of shor shel
nisaraf. Aval kein omer the identical
cases, terei gemara hagodol There's two
halachas. One is that you you give the
top one to hekdesh. That's takka on
both. V'chein, in shor bishvari, shor
shel nisaraf, both cases you give the
best one to hekdesh. Now there's a
second halacha that you have to sell the
rest. That that second halacha only goes
in the second case of shor shel nisaraf.
Meisevei, question. Bayis b'veisi ani
moyach l'cho. Here comes Gershon again.
I'm selling you the house of houses.
v'nofal
And one of the houses falls.
Crumbles.
Mareh u'nofal. He tells the buyer, I'm
sorry, your investment is right here in
the rubble.
Eved b'avodai ani moyach l'cho, I have
100 slaves, I'm selling you a slave.
U'meis echod mehem, dies. Mareh u'meis,
he so shows him the dead one. This is
what you bought from me.
Preik gemara b'mai l'tzei dein ofal odei
meis. If you tell him he gets the top
one, bayis b'veisi means the top one.
Let's see what fell.
Let's see if it's the penthouse, let's
see if it's the bottom. What what fell
exactly? What broke?
Says the gemara l'keich kamra, you bring
me a raya from a regular transaction
between two human beings. shani l'keich
d'yad baal hashtara d'achtina The guy
that has the the the sh'tar is he always
loses out. Hamotzi mechaveiro alav
haraya. Hashas d'as oh. d'yad baal
hashtara d'achtina Hamotzi mechaveiro
alav haraya, the one the the the buyer
of this house loses. But when it comes
to hekdesh, hekdesh doesn't lose. Hashas
d'as lo yesh oh. Now let's go back.
Yiluf tem aliyah d'griya. So you could
say when the guy when Gershon ben Moshe
was selling this guy, uh Michael ben
Shitrit, he actually sold him
an attic, not a penthouse.
Over here aliyah doesn't mean the best
of the best like Gershon showed Michael,
that this gorgeous penthouse on top of
the MDY Tower.
He actually meant aliyah is a ga-
garnished, bad something bad. Why? Yad
baal hashtara d'achtina. Because at the
end of the day
>> [clears throat]
>> the the the purchaser that has a star,
Here starts that God of time.
Starting the die for starting that God
of time.
A real
law. Yeah, if you read about me in this
a person says himself, I am I'm I'm
donating an oil. So obviously when do
you bring oil? You bring the base of the
God.
So this is that God of time. You know
what I'm going to say the story twice.
There was a crazy story in Clyde Israel.
She made a sad dick was a coin God of 40
years into the by Shani.
When he was Nifter, a lot of things
changed as the Mars going to tell us.
They stopped saying
British coin God of with the Sham of a
fire rush with Sham of a Sham.
A lot of things happened.
As he was dying, he said, "I want my
second son to be
the coin God of Haniah."
And his older brother Shimi was jealous.
And yeah.
Shimon and Shimi. Shimi, yeah.
And Shimi did some terrible things as
the Mars going to describe.
He wanted his brother dead.
So Haniah runs away to Alexandria and
builds the base of the God.
Something like this.
So obviously if you're going to bring a
carbon in Mitrayim in Alexandria,
you lay out there.
Lay out there.
A real law. Oil shock even in this coin
God of but if a person says I'm bringing
a oil law and I'm going to be mackerel
in this coin God of you can even make
this oil law goes in this coin God of.
You make real of this coin God of but if
you mackerel in Haniah you out there. We
have to understand what this means. The
Mars going to discuss this. How in the
world could you bring in oil law in a
base of a mixture that's outside of
Jerusalem and say that you are out
there?
It's not a real Shimon of a sad dick.
It's not the Shimon of a sad dick. It's
real Shimon of Shimon by coin. And so
oil law. This is nothing. It's not a oil
law. It's a regular animal. You can sell
it. Do whatever you want. You can ride
it. It doesn't matter. It's not oil law.
Now, same thing similar case. I already
knows a person says I'm going to be a
loser. You got to be in the God. He has
to remove all his hair in the base of
the God of just like this.
The in Gila of the base of Haniah you
out there.
Sorry. Sorry. Skip the in Gila of the
base of Haniah lay out there. And if he
shaved off his hair in this Haniah I
have to say in this base of the God of
lay out there.
I already knows that I got to be in this
coin God of but if he says I'm going to
do this. I'm going to shave my head in
this Haniah,
you got to be in the God. He should
originally in the hot killer shave his
head in the base of the English from
Gila of this Haniah you out there.
Again, understand what's going on here.
So we Mars going to say it's not a real
loser. He didn't really not in the
zeros. That's why if he did it in
in Alexandria you out there. The Shimon
of a loser ain't the loser. He's not a
loser at all.
Ask the Gamara you out there. How could
a person be you out there? Person says
I'm going to bring it in this Haniah
you out there.
It's oil law. It's oil law. Home make
the cut law. You're killing it outside
of the base of the God. If you shut it
outside of the base of the English you
be high five cars. If you killed it
outside of the base of the English you
killed it. It's not a How could you be
you out there?
If you choked it you didn't check it. So
you killed it. So you How could you be
you out there?
I'm going to not say coin of a real law.
Oil law I'm going to actually describe a
real law.
We're talking about a case of a person
case. Once a person says I'm bringing it
in
in this Haniah, so what he's saying is
I'm bringing oil law without any
responsibility. If something happens to
it, for fallen I don't have to do
anything. If I choke it to death, I'm
not going to have even if even if I
myself kill it, I'm not going to have
anything. So you out there with me. I
don't have to I don't have to bring
another one. Doesn't mean I'm you out
there
of oil law. It just means
I fulfilled my obligation with this
animal. This animal I don't have to take
care of it anymore. I killed it. Fine.
Next. Continue your life.
>> [clears throat]
>> But let's say in a coin army let's say
you take this animal and you take an a
street knife and you shut it in this
Haniah. What happens to you? Cars. Then
you will be high five cars cuz you shut
it outside of this coin God of.
Only of all the matters let's talk about
the next case in the mission. Aren't
they identical? Say with the coin army
already knows that I got to be in this
coin God of you got to be in the God. If
he says I'm a loser that I'm going to
take care of the hair in this Haniah in
Alexandria, you should look at killer do
it in this coin God of. You make real of
this Haniah you out there but if you did
it in Haniah you're okay. Okay, now
we're going to ask coin army already
knows that I am actually high five
coin of a loser. So obviously have to
say it's the same case.
I'm not taking responsibility on these
animals. Great. The problem is
loser come to the mercy coin of a loser
of the Mishka show.
In order for a loser to start drinking
wine and be metal of maze and
everything, you have to bring coin of a
loser. There's three coin of a losers.
There's the hot of the flame of oil law.
You have to take care of yourself. You
can't say all these coin of a losers are
without a prize.
Hello I'm a real of all of them
with the real of all of them. Says real
of all of them you got it wrong. He
didn't bring a oil law. He didn't say
I'm going to take upon myself a oil law.
He's talking about a gift of a Sham.
Sounds like a oil law. It's like a oil
law but it's not a oil law. It's
[clears throat] a way of saying a gift.
I'm bringing a gift to a Sham where? In
Chicago.
So there's no there's no more of the
base of the God of over there.
It's not even a oil law. It's time an
animal.
A new double. Like a like a gift. Not in
the double to the base of the God.
In the double in a different sense like
in a bomber. Like I'm I'm just giving a
carbon to to Alexandria.
I'm bringing something to a Sham.
Like a like a making a coin God of coin
of a Sham. Coin of a Sham is coin of a
Sham. Nothing to do with the with the
base of the God. It's not a oil law.
What? He wasn't mad this It's not
mad this
Yeah. We bought it's key oil the way
that's the way I can describe it is oil
law. It's not a oil law. Hello my real
of all of them with the real of all of
them. Omar and he says himself he's
arguing with this coin God of to if I
can get there I'm very close. I live in
a lot. I'm right here by Egypt. I just
bring it over there.
I'm not going to bring it all to
Jerusalem. So I don't know what to do.
Let's do it. More than that I don't want
to trouble myself. No army and the same
case would be by the army
of all of them he's trying to he's
trying to give himself see go for him in
the army himself you know to get a
copper law but he didn't mean to
bring a carbon in this coin God of. He's
arguing with this coin God of to if I
can get there and cut my hair off in
this coin God of great. Play with the
real of all of them. I don't So So if
you're going to shut the animal like
that in Alexandria you're not high
you're not high five cars in such a
case. It wasn't mad this
Real of all of them law loser is the
coin of a loser when we're referring to
a loser you're 100% oil law. I'm going
to ask you to describe a real law.
In other words it's two of them over
here. There's the loser. Loser is he
didn't mean at all
to be a loser.
But by [clears throat] oil law,
oil law is a true carbon. He did mean to
make it a carbon. He just said I'm not
going to have a prize. You ask me but
what the loser should be the same case.
No, loser is a different case. Two
different cases. Loser he didn't mean it
for real. So therefore you could cut his
hair off in Alexandria and not worry
about any carbons cuz he's not a real
loser. By oil law it was a real oil law.
Just this type of oil law that he What
it means you out there means that if he
kills it, he doesn't have to bring
another one.
A real law. Oil shock even in this base
of Haniah. If a person says I'm for sure
oil law in this Haniah they could be in
the Israel. He he shut it in the Israel
you out there. The owner of cars. How
how did he get cars? Because it's a real
it's a real carbon.
He thought in his mind that the mid bar
still has good show from the time of
motion of a real law. So he said let me
I want to I want to be mackerel in the
mid bar. They could be in the very odd
in. You out there with the cars cuz he
designated as a real oil law. He's high
five cars. You out there means there's
no prize. He said I'm not absolving
myself from any responsibilities of the
this animal dies or even if I kill it
myself I don't have to bring another
one.
There's a law of all of them
listen to this David you have to know
this.
A coin that performs over the Zara can
never do the the real of the base of the
God.
What about if he did the real of the
base of Haniah? If he worked he
worshiped the base of Haniah. He helped
he helped Haniah out.
How can you have to show me show me base
of Haniah will you show me show me base
of Jerusalem? It's also for them to
perform the real of it but it's for a
different reason.
It's not a the real of it as much as it
is a Zara.
The answer of the real of all of them
certainly and the Mars going to prove
from here that base of Haniah is not of
a Zara from here.
The answer of the real of all of them
certainly if you do have a Zara you
cannot perform the real of the base of
the English in the army. I can
real of all of them in the base of
Jerusalem. If you don't know what a
bomber is, let's just I'll keep on
talking over here while this is playing
in the background.
There's a there's a bomber in the base
of Jerusalem came off the masses of the
camera came. If these coin army they
they brought uh
sacrifices on a bomber and so it's a
mess back in somebody's backyard in
Thomas River or something.
I'll go upon him.
Came off the masses of the camera came.
A real of the coin of a real mumem says
the Gemara says the Mishnah that this
coin we we we treat him like a bal mum.
Call him a mumem
they cannot be makriv a carbon but they
they split they cannot be makriv
in the base of English but they can eat.
I don't know like a bal mum.
All right the coin should shochat avodah
zarah.
If a coin performs shchitah for the
avodah zarah and does teshuvah all the
cases here are cases that he did
teshuvah. Carbon
he can continue performing that avodah
in the base hamikdash why?
All right
my crow where do we see this in the
pasuk? You sure you saw
the the key word is yesharshu.
That a coin who did
he was meshareis he he performed an
avodah in the base hamikdash
I'm sorry to the avodah zarah. The whole
base of Israel the mishkan and the ohel
moed
it's a a stumbling aveirah. A coin that
did the avodah in the mishkan and the
ohel moed and the avodah in the base
it's a terrible thing what they did that
they were meshareis the avodah zarah.
We'll see my shver
each year in the chiyuv and then he says
afterwards you cannot perform the avodah
in the base hamikdash. So the Gemara
darshans this the word yesharshu yovah
shareis in shchitah lav shareis. Anybody
that learns vacham and even if he didn't
learn vacham you all know
that a Yisrael can perform the shchitah
in the base hamikdash. How can a Yisrael
perform shchitah in the base hamikdash?
Because it's not what?
Because shchitah
Oh first first Mishnah in Chullin.
Usually the Gemara like and we're going
to even see more what? Akol sharein akol
sharein the shchitah because it's a
Ah okay.
Stam shchitah yeah stam shchitah he's
right.
Akol bonem almost the first Akol bonem
shchitah shareh bizar in the base
hamikdash so you see it's not a shareis
the Torah's talking about a thing that's
shareis. Says the Gemara
By the way Shachris is in 12 minutes
whoever's waiting for Shachris.
You all see shchitah lav shareis. Itmar
what about the next thing? Zrikah. So
this I think will really
>> [snorts]
>> hit you as a massive chiddush. Zrikah is
100% an avodah in the base hamikdash
it's the number one avodah. It's the
mechaper.
So what about a coin you hear this Dave?
A coin who performs zrikah by mistake.
He thought that it's mutar to to do
zrikah in the base hamikdash to avodah
zarah.
Could he perform the avodah later on in
the base hamikdash?
You'll be surprised to learn that
there's a shittah that says it's assur
for him to perform even though it was a
complete mistake.
>> [cough]
>> So shogeg bizrikah he thought that it's
mutar to do zrikah to avodah zarah and
Rav Nachman says carbon he can continue
it's no problem continue doing the
avodah. Rav Shishis says ein carbon
he cannot.
Rav Shishis min amei d'Orah how do I
know this? The pasuk the base of Israel
the mishkan and the ohel moed. It says
two words mishol stumble oven an
aveirah. My love oi mishol oi oven the
Torah's talking about two different
things the mishol is a stumbling by in
other words you didn't do it on purpose
and oven that you did deliberately. Oi
mishol shogeg v'oven meizid.
That that's the pashtus. Rav Nachman
mishol d'oven.
You stumble to do an aveirah.
So now it's only meizid according to Rav
Nachman according to Rav Shishis it's
both a mishol and an oven shogeg and
meizid.
Rav Nachman min amei d'Orah
you have a chiyuv coin that never shogeg
b'cheit or b'shogeg. It's referring to
this pasuk of avodah zarah melamed
sh'coin is kaparah on the atzmus.
A coin can
forgive himself. If a person does an
aveirah he'll go a coin himself will go
to the base hamikdash and do do a
kaparah themselves. B'mai? What does it
mean? How? Eilu b'shchitah that's not a
chiddush. My ear is shogeg v'meizid
nami. If a coin did the shchitah to
avodah zarah b'meizid he could continue.
Why? Because it's not an avodah we said.
And he can continue doing avodah in the
base hamikdash.
Elav no but he's doing he he does
teshuvah. Elav bizrikah. It must be they
did he performed a zrikah b'shogeg. Rav
Shishis lav leilam shchitah.
No we're referring to shchitah ub'meizid
lav and it's not true if a coin does a
shchitah on purpose
he cannot perform the avodah in the base
hamikdash. Why? Nasa they stick in here
koimeir l'avodah zarah.
You're right.
Shchitah is not an avodah but there's
another problem he becomes a koimeir.
A koimeir becomes a a priest to avodah
zarah and a priest to avodah zarah
has no place in our base hamikdash.
Vozdu tamai and they each go according
to their own reasoning the itmar heizim
shchitah. If he did avodah zarah and did
teshuvah by shchitah Rav Nachman carbon
he can continue he can continue
performing the avodah but Rav Shishis
ein carbon he cannot perform the avodah.
Rav Nachman carbon he
did avodah he didn't perform an avodah.
Rav Shishis ein carbon
nasa koimeir l'avodah zarah. The the
problem is a meshareis avodah whatever
it is you want to garish but the point
is he becomes a priest to avodah zarah
and that's why he cannot perform the
avodah in the base hamikdash. Rav
Nachman min amei d'Orah how do I know
this?
The sany coin shav d'avodah zarah
v'shav. A coin that performed avodah
zarah and did teshuvah
carbon he can continue
his carbon is a beautiful thing Hashem
loves it b'mai b'mai? Eilu b'shogeg if
he did it if he if he did an aveirah
by mistake b'shogeg my b'shav what does
it mean he did teshuvah? Shav amedu it
was a complete mistake it was an honest
mistake.
Eilu b'shchitah b'meizid he did it
deliberately. V'bizrikah and if he did
it by the throwing of the blood on the
mizbeiach he shav my avodah who cares if
he did teshuvah avodah shareis he's done
and gone for the rest of his life. He
performed the avodah in the base
hamikdash to avodah zarah and he cannot
perform the avodah in the base
hamikdash. Elav b'shchitah must be they
were talking about shchitah.
Rav Shishis
lav leilam shogeg we're talking about
that he did it by mistake. V'he kamar.
So he take twist the words a little bit.
V'he kamar im shav mikarah if a person
has never done an aveirah to begin with.
D'chiyuv b'shogeg how is that possible?
He did an aveirah completely shogeg.
He's thinking honest mistake he thought
it's mutar to throw blood to avodah
zarah.
What was he doing there? I don't know.
But he thought it was an honest mistake.
Carbon he can continue he can continue
performing the avodah in the base
hamikdash. Im lav but if he did shchitah
b'meizid ein carbon he cannot.
Great so that's the end of that. What
about hishtachavah l'avodah zarah? A
person bows down to avodah zarah didn't
uh shecht anything he bowed to avodah
zarah and he did teshuvah. Rav Nachman
carbon he can continue
he can do teshuvah from that. It's not a
shareis it's not Rav Shishis ein carbon
he cannot. No he can't.
Hoidah l'avodah zarah. Again in with
words he said Eliata he said Eliata.
He talks to avodah zarah said
said thank you to avodah zarah and he
did teshuvah. Rav Nachman carbon he can
continue
Rav Shishis ein carbon he cannot again
Rav Shishis says no. Says the Gemara to
all these cases hishtachavah shchitah
hoidah all these things. Why? The ashman
easy stuff right?
The ashman kamai so if it says only the
zrikah part he did zrikah by mistake. By
he kamar Rav Shishis all the shareis at
the end of the day this guy performed
an avodah that you do in the base
hamikdash and that's why he says that he
cannot do the avodah anymore in the base
hamikdash. Shchitah shareis it's not
considered shchitah is mutar by a
Yisrael.
We said even a woman right? In the base
hamikdash.
So it's not considered shareis. Eima lav
Rav Nachman?
Maybe you'd admit that this coin can
perform in the base hamikdash. We no he
can't. Ashman shchitah avodah he did he
did a maiseh. Avodah hishtachavah avodah
he didn't do any avodah there's nothing
there's no animal involved there's no
avodah. Eima lav maybe this should not
stop him from performing in the future
avodah in the base hamikdash zrikah.
Ashman hishtachavah it says shav avodah
maiseh but maiseh he bent down on his
feet he did something with his body.
Eima lav hoidah b'dibbur b'alma
throughout shas talking is not
considered a maiseh.
Eima lav maybe that shouldn't prevent
him according to Rav Shishis from doing
the avodah zrikah.
V'ein tzorech lomar d'lav avodah says
the Mishnah certainly if a coin performs
avodah zarah certainly cannot do the
avodah in the base hamikdash.
So now we say the story here comes story
time.
Midei kamar in tzorech lomar d'lav
avodah from the fact that the Mishnah
says that base chonyo has this halachah
but if he performed avodah in the base
hamikdash uh you performed the avodah
zarah you cannot do avodah in the base
hamikdash.
Certainly he can't perform in the base
hamikdash. Michlal d'vei chonyo lav
avodah zarah. If you're comparing avodah
zarah to base chonyo you say certainly
v'ein tzorech lomar that means that
avodah zarah is worse than base chonyo.
That means base chonyo is not avodah
zarah. Tany kamar base chonyo lav avodah
zarah. Sanya. Oiso shanah Shimon
HaTzaddik go l'olam. That year the
Shimon HaTzaddik died he was he
performed the avodah I believe 40 years
in the base sheni.
He was from the anshei knesses hagdolah.
Omar lahem shanah zu hu meis. He said
about himself this is the last year of
his life. Omar lahem anachnu you look
nice and healthy how do you know you're
going to die? Omar lahem kol Yom
Kippurim nisdameli
zaken echad lavush lavanim. Every single
year
an old man
wearing white
comes to me v'nis'adein lavanim.
V'nichnas imi he goes with me into
kodesh hakodashim v'yotzei imi he comes
out.
Says Tosafos top Tosafos.
Nisdam zaken echad lavush lavanim
b'shamei parvech chalom l'eiv moed b'fi
even a malach can't go in there. The
shchinah
mishani the shammah shchinah hoisa.
Perhaps I can't say for certain perhaps
he saw the Ribono shel Olam himself
kavyachol in a in a form of human being
as an old man
dressed in white.
Shanah zu but this year nisdameli zaken
echad lavush
if it's like Tosafos says Hakadosh
Baruch Hu dressed in black as an olive
in the
vinegar
he didn't come out with me.
Right after Sukkot call of them.
We named
from that day on they stopped using the
fire rich.
Used to say you can
in the no more.
They felt there's no more there's
nothing to save them.
And on his deathbed he said
he
I want my son
to be
instead of me. This kind of
here's a person who has jealousy from
his own brother. What does he do? Wants
him dead dead his own brother because of
jealousy.
Peleliu
It's not a pillow.
Those who know know.
Chutzpah
He's 29 years old than me.
He's going to be the even though my
father said to be a young one to be
let me teach you how it's done. Of
course he knew how it's done. He saw his
father doing it hundreds of times.
But maybe he didn't know how it's done
and then inaugural inauguration you wear
something special like the king that day
something
I'm going to tell you my my dear brother
what you have to wear is women's
clothing. You have to take your your
your wife's dress.
He'll be sure
some some sort of hide from of women
and he put on a belt of women so a nice
pink belt have me
put him there by the fire. And then he
runs and he tells unbelievable from
goes to to the to the other
room to
the side. His beloved look what he
promised his wife.
He
promised her if I ever become a I'm
going to wear your clothing.
Make sure
they want to kill him.
So he ran away from the runs
away and ran after him.
I'll show the second video tonight
tomorrow.
And that's why he ran away. He was
supposed to be the he had to run away to
Alexandria. And over here it says that
he built that he did it
in the Zara.
And they said one more lie in
this shimmy surely
he's never the prime minister of Israel,
but he had such jealousy if somebody
was already there. And is removed a lot
of
jealousy is so great.
We'll see you tonight if an April have a
wonderful day.
>> [music]
>> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout
the world. Sponsor a share today at
mdy.sponsor.com [music] or sponsor at
mdy.dab.com.