0:00 / 0:00
CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 103 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky
1,175 views
Thanks for learning with us! () Good Morning () 102B () 103A () 103B () Have a Wonderful Shabbos! -- Take the Quiz: Kahoot.MDYdaf.com Support the Shiur: MDYsponsor.com Where to Watch & Listen Find us on your favorite platform: https://mdydaf.com/learn#platforms #DafYomi #EliStefansky #Menachos #MDY
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[music]
>> GOOD MORNING BOYS.
I
LITTLE
BOYS ARE SO SMART TODAY. WHAT A DAY. I
FEEL IT. HOLY mayor haray alay and
machmas.
You know
that there are two types of minchas.
There's many types of minchas.
But two that are very very similar but
done in their their baked in different
ways. One is a machmas a very short like
a pan flat pan.
And one is a marcheshes. Round shallow
thank you shallow pan.
And one is a marcheshes a deep pan. They
have the same ingredients but one burns
off the oil quicker and therefore is a
harder like almost like a matzah kind of
thing. The other one is more like a
lafa. More like a chewyer kind of dough.
If you remember we had this.
>> vessel?
Would you like a machavat or a
marcheshes?
>> the the art is amazing the
the havar is a little annoying to me.
>> According to Rabbi Yossi Hagelili, a
marcheshes had a cover while a machavat
had no cover.
And according to Rabbi Chanina ben
Gamliel the machavat is shallow so
there's no room for the oil so the
mincha comes out hard. While the
marcheshes is deep it bakes in the oil
and comes out soft.
Okay. So
if a person
promises he makes a neder, I'll bring a
machvas, I'll bring a a shallow frying
pan the heavy the marcheshes hoymer
machmas baby marcheshes. In the end they
end up bringing the deeper one it's a
completely different mincha.
So he's not yoitzer. He has to bring
another one.
The marcheshes baby the machmas the
opposite. He said I'm going to be bring
the the chewyer chewyer [clears throat]
one the thicker one the heavy the
machmas and he brought the flat one.
Masha heavy heavy.
So you don't have to throw it out. Why?
Because mistama he meant he had another
nedava.
He had something else going on in his
mind. He did another nedava a different
time.
But this that he promised
a shallow one and he brought a deep one.
You weren't yoitzer you start over. But
don't throw out the one you brought
because maybe it's for something else.
What
think about for a second you'll all know
the answer. If somebody says zoo this
flower right here zoo is that called a
neder or a nedava?
How do you know?
Zudive zoo.
So but what does it mean? What does it
mean it's a nedava? It means that if you
point at something say this
then that it's this. You can't change
it. Zula hobby the machmas you point to
this flower you say
this flower I want to go in a shallow
frying pan the heavy but he took this
flower and he put in a deep one. Now he
made a possul. Made a possul. You can't
you can't talk about this particular
flower and change its designation from
shallow to deep.
And the reverse is also zoo. If it's not
it doesn't say zoo but he said zoo the
marcheshes the heavy the machmas. He
pointed to the flower to the bag this
whole bag bag is going to go in a deeper
one but it went in a in a shallow one
how is it possul? Now you can't even use
it.
Hoymer haray alay shnay esronos.
Yesterday I told Benny this this
marshall so I think
I'll say it over. If somebody promises
to bring to the base I'm going to bring
this two animals
200 pounders and he brings one 200 pound
animal. Yoitzer or not yoitzer?
No way. Not yoitzer. But the same amount
of pounds. It's a different type of
animal it's a different type of thing.
If a person says I'm going to bring two
minchas two
each one requires its own kemitzah its
own aktara.
But he doubles it up. Instead of a
typical mincha is how much? One isaron.
So he brings two isronim.
But he did it in one kli not yoitzer cuz
he promised two.
And the same in reverse. If he promises
one
and he brings two. So let's say with an
animal he promises one gezunta hefty 200
pounder
and instead he brings
two smaller ones a hundred but he did
double. Oh it's good. No not good cuz he
promised a 200 pounder and he didn't
bring a 200 pounder. If a person
promises one mincha of of two isronim
and he splits it up to two. It's not
that he did double he didn't bring what
he promised.
Hoymer alay shnay esronos. He said I'm
going to bring two.
Lo avay b'kli echad. I'm going to bring
sorry double measurement double
measurement but I'm only going to bring
it in one vessel.
V'hayvay b'shnay kaylim and he ended up
bringing in two.
B'shnay kaylim v'hayvay b'kli echad.
So basically he doesn't have the right
amount in the kli. He doesn't have the
right kaylim.
Masha heavy heavy v'day chavas lo
yoitzer.
So he can continue bringing it again
perhaps another time he made such a
neder and he was it was two. So let him
bring the two and I'll have to bring a
different time the one. But now here's
the interesting case. Oh no aelu b'kli
now the same thing if he points at it
instead of saying zoo he says aelu these
this is the flower b'kli echad baby
shnay kaylim.
B'shnay kaylim v'hayvay b'kli echad. He
specified the flower that's supposed to
go in but he ruined it by putting it
into different types of vessels two
instead of one one instead of two. Haray
lo possul because he already designated
the flower this flower like a nedava zoo
aelu and can't change it.
Same case
same exact case but there's a little
variation at the end. Haray alay shnay
esronos lo avay b'kli echad baby shnay
kaylim.
He said I'm going to bring two isronim
in one vessel.
And he brought it in two. That's exactly
what we had before. But
amru alay his friends are standing there
and say what are you doing? Amru alay
b'kli echad nadarta. What are you doing?
You're messing up. So if he ignores it
he shnay kaylim possul. What's the whole
svara here?
How come you could continue bringing
your carbon even though you mess up? Cuz
perhaps yesterday you made another neder
and it fits your other neder nobody
knows about it. But if your friends are
making a comment they're they're they're
trying to fix it. And you don't tell
your friends hey no no
you got it wrong. I I made a neder
yesterday. You're right you're right you
heard me say two kaylim but right now
I'll bring one kli cuz on Sunday I said
one kli. You should explain yourself. If
somebody says
if you just ignore them that means you
don't care. If you don't care that means
you're messing up now.
I realize amru alay b'kli echad nadarta.
What are you doing? Why are you bringing
two? He shnay kaylim possul. B'kli echad
if he listened to them that's not a
chiddush. He listened he changes his
whole mouth share this question.
Haray alay shnay esronos lo avay b'shnay
kaylim. If he promised to bring two
isronim in two kaylim v'hayvay b'kli
echad he messed up on the amount of
kaylim. Instead of bringing two
klishores he brought in one. Amru alay
his friends again making remarks shnay
kaylim davar. What are you doing? Why
are you bringing one you said two.
He shnay kaylim sharem. If he brought in
two he listened to them he changed your
your your route sharem. Here's a little
difference. The son of the kli echad but
if you put into one kli k'shtay minchas
shnay isronim. This is alacha if anybody
recalls we learned about this. We have
two minchas that get mixed up. So if
they're not completely mixed in and you
can make out the two minchas. You see
this is mincha aleph this is mincha bais
they're both in the bottom of a giant
frying pan so you just take a kemitzah
and you go weiter. Nothing happened. If
they're mixed in then you have a
problem.
Says the gemara what's the chicha?
The kids are simple chichusi here. Why
do I need two different cases of a guy
messing up between a frying pan and a
deep dish and a guy messing up between
two isronim one isaron it's the same
idea. So diashminan hakamaitsa mishum
d'omar if we just talk about a person
promised to bring in a marcheshes and he
brought a machvas mishum d'omar machvas
marcheshes.
I will okay that's why you completely
messed up the type of mincha it's a
different type. I will did you do the
machvas? You bring the same type. Did
you do the marcheshes?
Ami did you do the nami otza? You
brought the right amount it's the right
amount it's not in the right kaylim.
So I think I'll let it go let it slide.
Maybe you doesn't have to redo it. No
you have to redo it. Diashminan
and if it only said the case of the the
amounts and the kaylim
mishum d'kol polay glo. At the end of
the day you're breaking up your carbon.
You promised the a gezunta two isronim
like a what's two isronim like 10 pounds
and instead of you wrote two five
pounders. No good.
The kapolay glo aval hasam polay bay.
But by the marcheshes he brought the
right amount he just brought the wrong
kli. I'm going to let I'll let it slide.
I don't know exactly why but I would
think so. Sricha.
Tana rabonan.
Masha heavy heavy v'day nidral yoitzer.
We learned that
you could bring it but you have to you
have to bring it again. You continue you
don't throw it into the garbage. It's
okay it's a good he probably meant he
probably had another neder in mind but
he has to bring another one. Reb Shimon
oymer af he day nidroy nami yoitzer. In
all the mishnayos every case if a person
said a marcheshes and he brought a
machvas a machvas marcheshes you're
yoitzer. Zoo
lo avay b'machvas. If he said only this
this flower I want to bring in a pan
and he ended up bringing it in a
marcheshes it's possul. Why is it
possul? Take it out of the out of the
marcheshes and start all over again.
What what did the pan do? What did the
what did the marcheshes do?
V'tani like kishum klishores. We learned
that the klishores doesn't have an
effect on it. Amarbai like kishum
mikarov. You're right it doesn't have an
effect to the point that you could
continue bringing it onto the mizbeach.
Aval kishum mipossul which we had the
other day. It has enough effect to make
to ruin it.
V'amar abai like shono b'shnay mishnayos
neder.
A person on Sunday says I want to bring
a carbon mincha to the base hamikdash."
And on Monday, he goes to the store and
he buys a bag of flour and he takes out
from the flour.
So, when exactly does he decide that
he's going to bring a frying pan and a
deep dish?
At the time of his nether, when he says
when he specifies he's going to bring
a mincha a marchesses.
Now, when he pulls the flour out of the
bag, at that point it's too late, you
can't decide then.
According to Reb Shimon, you decide only
then. As you come to shas nether a
vishas of frasha, when you're removing
the flour from the bag, light. Why?
Kashira da'arto. Says in the possuk
as you make a nether, a vow, v'lo kashir
efrasha, but not when you are
separating and removing and and putting
aside the flour.
It bar nami. Omar Reb Nachman Reb
Chanina, Omar Reb Nachman Reb Yochana
lo shalu elo shekavan bishas nether.
Avishas of frasha loy. You have to say
by the time that you say the nether,
it's all about Again, once again, you
see the idea, it's about
your speech
your dibur, not the ma'aseh of removing
the flour. So, when you say I'm going to
bring a mincha
elo shekavan bishas nether, shas of
frasha loy. Why? Kashira da'arto v'lo
kashir efrashto.
Zok to Mishnah. Hare ha'omer hare alai
mincha min asorim.
There's something called twice lashon
rishon twice lashon acharon. It's it's a
mussig in all shas.
A guy contradicts himself. He says
shtusim. So, do I take his first
the first part of the sentence? Hare
alai mincha, period. S'orim? Bananas?
Shtusim?
I don't
Everybody knows you don't you don't make
a
mincha out of banana. So, that part I
ignore. Or perhaps no.
The guy was saying Hare alai mincha. All
of a sudden he realized, "Wait a minute.
Mincha? I have to drive now all the way
to the koisel."
Bananas. So, I'm going to erase what I
said by saying shtusim and that's going
to erase the
So, it's it's it's a machlokes between
Shammai and Hillel. Do I go by the
first? Do I go by the beginning or I go
by the end? Homer alai mincha min
asorim. He messed up. He contradicted
himself. I want a mincha but I want it
out of barley. Every mincha in the world
is made out of wheat besides two that
are not noge'a today, yavim and achitim.
We say he meant to bring a mincha.
S'orim I don't I ignore. What if he says
kemach? I want to make bring it out of
flour. Again
only a soiteh brings kemach. Everybody
else brings soiles. Yavim soiles. Bring
it like a mensch.
If he says v'lo shamen v'lo levona, new
Those of us who learned menachos, what
mincha does not have oil?
You know how the Israelis remember? They
said mindi arba.
Shlei choiteh nisgar. They all remember
that.
They remember it how? Why a guy that
does a sin, he should gain and he
shouldn't have to pay the $2 that the
oil cost?
So, that's how they remember. Choiteh
does not bring oil.
V'lo shamen v'lo levona. He he messed
up. The only people He's not a He's not
bringing a mincha because he's a
choiteh. He's not bringing a mincha
because he's a soiteh or a shaita. He's
bringing a mincha because he wants to
bring a mincha. So, he messed up. Yavim
shamen v'lo levona. We ignore him.
The second part of his statement
disregard. First part of the statement,
Hare alai mincha, bring a mincha like a
mensch with levona with soiles.
What if he says chatzi s'orim?
He has it. We all know a mincha must be
at least 20 s'orim. He ignores it.
Yavim s'orim shalem. We ignore him. And
he brings a full s'orim.
Isorim machatzah. This is a good one.
What about isorna, one and a half? Yavim
shnayim. There's no such thing as one
and a half. So, bring two.
Reb Shimon poiter. Reb Shimon says every
case in this Mishnah poiter. If a guy
says, "I want to bring a mincha made out
of barley." He doesn't have to bring
anything. Shlei isnadiv kidai chamin
isnadivim because that's not how people
say it. So, if he said it the wrong way,
that means he wanted to erase his
initial comment. Instead of us just
saying, "No, no, no." He says, "S'orim."
And s'orim means nothing.
Am I nether pischoy imayu? Isn't he
trying to
change, rectify whatever the lashon is?
He in the nether
he has an opening. Omar Chizkiyahu,
homani bishamai. Oh.
So, here's the machlokes between Hillel
and Shammai. Hillel will say, "Oh,
before I show you this, let me just show
you the characters." There's the
characters. You have soiles and s'orim.
Soiles is is you know the number one.
Most of the menachos are made out of
soiles. And who's the last man standing?
Rishon. And s'orim is
lashon acharon. So, when you see the the
soiles
Hillel say
the the acharon stands. The the barley
is the one standing. Twice lashon
acharon. And Shammai say twice lashon
rishon. You go by the first part of the
statement. Hillel say you go by the
second part of the statement. Says
Chizkiyahu, I go with Shammai.
Our Mishnah goes like Shammai. Again, a
person says, "Hare alai mincha." I want
a mincha.
So, he has to bring a mincha.
The second part of the statement,
s'orim, I ignore that. Disregard. So,
I'm twice lashon rishon. Chizkiyahu says
this Mishnah goes like Shammai.
Slightly problematic cuz we go like
Hillel.
How do we fit this Mishnah into Hillel?
Homani bishamai. That means twice lashon
rishon. Disnan, hareini nazir min
agrogrois.
A person looks and he says, "I want to
be a nazir." A nazir is somebody that
refrains from grape product. He doesn't
drink wine, grapes. And he looks at the
at the at the figs and he says, "I'm
going to be a nazir from figs."
So, again, once again, we have a pelgina
dibura. We have hareini nazir, period.
I'm going to refrain from grapes.
Uh figs? Disregard figs.
So, that's the the classic machlokes.
It's not hareini nazir min agrogrois min
adveila. Dveila is you know iguli
dveila, something like this where they
press the figs together.
So, is is is words contradict each
other. Shammai omerim, nazir.
Shammai said he's a complete nazir and
we disregard. So, in other words, twice
lashon rishon. Let's grab the first
words, disregard the second. Hillel
omerim, nazir. We go by the second
words. He he meant refraining from figs
and that doesn't exist.
So
that's Chizkiyahu. Chizkiyahu says I go
with Shammai, everything's great.
Says Reb Yochanan, I prefer to go with
Hillel. And in fact, the Gemara is going
to say that
that Chizkiyahu also goes with Hillel at
the end.
Reb Yochanan omer, "Afilu teima Hillel,
we can go with Hillel. Bo omer, ilu
ayisi de'a she'eino kach, lo ayisi noida
kach l'kach."
Says Reb Yochanan, I go even though
Hillel says technically twice lashon
acharon and he said barley and there's
no such thing barley, but he explains
himself. If a person explains himself
right away, he says, "Listen, I didn't
do the daf. I don't know anything about
mincha. I tried to be a smart guy.
That's what I have at home. I said, 'Let
me bring a mincha out of barley.' If I
would have known there's no such thing,
I wouldn't have said I would have said
wheat. Okay, so bring a mincha out of
wheat."
I'm explaining what you're doing. Omar
Chizkiyahu
lo shalu elo d'omer mincha min asorim.
S'orim is something that exists in the
base hamikdash by a soiteh by omer. So,
okay, so he messed up a little bit. Aval
omer mincha min adashim. If a person
said I want to bring a mincha from
lentils, that's what Reb Aryeh Simon was
asking. Loy. He's completely poiter.
Asks the Gemara, "What's going on here?"
L'choira, if you say twice lashon
rishon, so the guy says, "I want to
bring a mincha." Period.
End of the story. Bring a mincha. The
fact that he added on
a watermelon or lentils
ignore.
Michti Chizkiyahu omer omer d'Shammai
omer d'Shammai. Omer d'Shammai mishum
twice lashon rishon loy. And they go you
just use the first words. Malim min
asorim malim min adashim. So, what
difference does it make if he said
s'orim or adashim?
Says the Gemara, "Hoder bei."
He actually holds
Oh, I forgot to put this in here. If you
go mincha min adashim
poiter.
Why? Because you're going by the
adashim. And that's why he's poiter. So,
in other words, I hold twice lashon
acharon. How can you hold twice lashon
acharon when you hold twice lashon
Yochanan on the other hand says it's
problematic also. He says that if a
person says mincha min adashim, you you
have to bring a a mincha. That means
that I I I stop. I go mincha, period.
So, that means I go by lashon rishon.
But he holds like Hillel that says
lashon acharon, but that's not the way
the Gemara's going. So
hoder bei.
The real question is why hoder bei? Why
did he take it back? Maybe there's a
difference between adashim and s'orim.
And that's what the Gemara's going to
ask. By adashim, there's no mistake.
By by s'orim, you can make a mistake cuz
that's in the base hamikdash. But nobody
every every even even a guy that never
learned menachos in his life knows that
you cannot bring a a mincha out of
lentils. Ask anybody. Go to shul
tonight. You can ask them, "Is a mincha
made out of barley or wheat?" Nobody
will know. But if you ask them, "Is a
mincha made out of lentils or wheat?"
They'll tell you, "No, no, no. Not not
lentils. Not for sure not."
Yeah.
That's 2026. Not then. Hoder bei.
Says the Gemara, "My time of hoder bei."
What's the real reason? Omar Reb
Mesharshiya, "He had a He had a problem
with the Mishnah." Chizkiyahu.
If it's true that like that the Mishnah
goes like Shammai, then you go with the
first words and we don't go with the
second words. May you return mincha min
asorim listing min adashim.
Tell me about shpitz chiddush. When a
person if you go with lashon rishon, a
person says mincha, so even if he adds
on some something silly like like
lentils, we still go with it. Ashma mino
Mishnah d'tayei. The whole point of the
Mishnah is that we go it's a mistake.
Bisorim tayei. You can make a a honest
mistake between
a a flour from wheat
versus flour from barley because in the
base hamikdash you have barley also
sometimes. Badashim loy tayei. Here
coming up mamesh shlishim yom kodem
Pesach, we have the omer coming up. It's
made out of barley. Badashim loy tayei.
But nobody's going to make that mistake.
Reb Yochanan omer, afilu min adashim. If
a person says, like you see in the right
bottom corner, if a person says min
you have to bring it. Why? He
holds that the whole mission is going to
be silly. What is the mission to tell
you? And the whole point of it is silly
is why even though they typically hold
they go by the last words. And the last
words were so iron and that's a no
gooder. But the reason why we go with
the with a lotion ration here is cuz he
made a mistake. He explained himself. He
said had I known I wouldn't have said so
iron.
We should have tell you beside him to
tie him.
But
loy toy. In fact, but in a dozen he
doesn't make a mistake.
So
you should go with lotion akron
according to this rule.
He goes like this. But he's telling his
guy I don't understand you. Why did you
come to my team? Why did you reverse
your sheet? You went from saying that
the mission goes according to the sheet
and the mission goes according to the
sheet. That I have a problem with. Why?
Stay on your team. I don't know what I'm
talking about. We shouldn't like to tell
him in a dozen. You hold as far as you
proved it from the mission that the
mission used the word
so iron instead of a dozen.
Duma, maybe that's not such a great
question. Duma let me buy maybe the
mission was saying
loin by a dozen
and that certainly is no addition in a
dozen.
Because a person
took it back and he's he's going with
the first language.
Digging a man
who toy. The reason I did mission uses a
lotion of so iron is because maybe in
the carrot so iron a person can make a
mistake.
I feel all the lotion ration still go
with the first lotion.
Duff.
When a guy says this this whole thing
that twice lotion ration
got the first words in a sentence is
because he said array a lie mincha. The
armor mincha he says array I
I want to bring a mincha. I will armor
mincha. But if you didn't say array a
lie mincha what did he say? Says Rashi
listen this is a little tricky you got
to write it in with your pencil. He said
array a lie minchas.
It's a big difference. If a person says
array a lie mincha so iron so I could
split his words. Anybody speaks Hebrew
knows array a lie mincha period so iron
is another sentence. When a person says
array a lie minchas
so iron the so iron goes together with
the word minchas. You cannot split those
two words. They're together. Minchas so
iron. It's a mincha of minchas means
mincha of
so iron.
I can't break his words. And therefore
you don't say you need to bring it he'd
be partner.
Cuz he said specifically you can't make
two sentences out of one sentence. If
you can't make two sentences out of what
he what he said. So what he said is a
contradiction and
therefore he's partner. You can't call
my law. What
is this over?
What about in the mission that says come
out the mission doesn't say what he
said. It doesn't say in the mission
array a lie come out. Look higher.
Come out you will be so lost. My love
the way you are my mincha. He didn't say
array a lie mincha come out. He probably
said looks like in the mission he said
array a lie mincha.
Array a lie come out. Sorry. Array a lie
come out he said. Now
a person Rashi explains a person doesn't
say anything love at all. Person doesn't
just stand say things.
So may law
when he says array a lie mincha
then then then he's being serious. Array
a lie come out. My love the way you are
my mincha. Even without saying mincha
he's higher. So
the armor mincha no you have to say he
said no only in the case where he said
array a lie mincha like Ziri says.
Now so
free me. The way you are my mincha is
also in the mission.
You will be so lost. My love the way you
are my mincha. Loy the armor mincha. He
said mincha. How is so iron? The way you
are my
mincha. Loy the armor mincha. But the
mission was setting up this question.
You will be so lost.
What about the end of the mission? Says
if a person said one and a half he has
to bring two. Even though I am mincha
so ask the more
once a person says the word mincha
according to you Ziri he says mincha
he will be so lost. Then you say twice
lotion ration. When a person says mincha
then
the what the first thing that he said is
good. He will be so lost. You will be so
lost. Like come out. Why is he higher
two?
He didn't say anything on the second
part is nothing. His twice lotion ration
goes on a full mincha. The second part
of half is nothing. If you want we can
see real quickly. This will be twice the
amount of what he said.
This will be the amount of what he said.
If he didn't say the word mincha he has
to bring two. Boy you see that because
he explained himself away if I would
have known. Even though I am mincha he
said but if he says the word mincha and
he says the word he's so lost. So the
word mincha goes on the so iron and the
half is nothing. Am I why should he
bring two? The way you are my mincha and
come in you Ziri say you have to say the
word mincha. So now he did say mincha.
But only on one of the two words. Okay
how is so iron? The way you are my
Ziri says if you don't say the word
mincha this is gives a better here. If
you don't say the word mincha you don't
have to bring at all.
So over here he said mincha
he's so iron the half. So the mincha is
going to go on the so iron part.
And on the half he never said mincha on
it. So he shouldn't bring at all. So
you're right.
The the when he didn't say one and a
half he said a half and one.
And the word
time out. So look what look what the
more does here. Little different than
what you think. Let's array a lie half
is so iron so iron. Yeah we're changing
it around a little bit. The key armor
mincha so the word mincha right there
and then means a full so iron mincha. If
a guy says array a lie mincha how much
does he have to bring? One is so iron
without explaining how many so iron.
He will be so lost. You will be so lost.
And when he says I want to bring a half
the way you are my armor on the half
part we're going to disregard
completely.
And then the armor is so iron my so
iron. Here's what's going on here.
He says mincha that's one.
He says half is so iron that's zero.
And then he says he's so iron that's
another one. One plus one equals two
that's why he has to bring two.
But
if he really says
mincha in this mission
not I don't understand. You tell me that
a person doesn't say love at all.
A person he said over here mincha.
So why does he say he doesn't have to
bring anything? He said array a lie
mincha he should at least have to bring
he should have to bring so iron.
Am I am I
there's another slightly different
sheet. We have twice lotion ration we
have twice lotion akron and then we have
a we have a sheet that combines the two
and says listen if there's a
mission bubble if there's a steer here
then we have to disregard everything. We
have to we have to we have to consider
every statement that he says. So we're
going to consider the first statement
and the second statement. But they
contradict each other. So
so nothing. That's why he doesn't bring
anything according to the sheet.
And here we're going to come to one of
the
a classic.
It's not a bottom mincha so iron. I
can't wait.
It's not a bottom mincha so iron.
We had this already it's like a hazard
for us. A person brings a giant clay
of [clears throat]
60 so iron. A typical mincha is one so
iron. Maximum is 60.
That's the maximum so iron. It may be
that it can go in one vessel. And really
I see
but what if he goes over the limit he
does 61? Maybe 60
and half and half.
It seems from the mission that you bring
one clay that has 60 and one clay that
has one. Don't break it 30 and 31. Just
60 and one. It should came maybe beyond
the reason
on Sukkot. It should came in Shabbat.
That's the most you could ever bring. 60
and half.
Here let me show you beautiful thing
that you did here.
Every every sheep you bring one so iron.
You see they're holding one so iron in
their hands.
And the the aisle is two so iron per
aisle.
Cows are three. 13 times three is how
much?
39.
18 times one is how many?
Very good.
Two times two?
It's four. So
four plus 18 is how much? 22 and 22 plus
is 61. Even if you don't know math you
can cheat and look at the top. It says
61. 61 so iron.
So that's the max 61 so iron. So he says
if the people brings this is
interesting. No one is going to love
this one. If the people brings 61 then
you know what? Take one off the
community of an individual. An
individual can bring up to 60. I'm going
to make it simple for you. These
39 that you bring with the cows with the
bulls they
18 of the sheep they
they never go to the same bull. How did
you just make a mincha that has 60 in
one bull when the bulls and the the
sheep never go in one bull. It's also to
feed and mix it. Can't mix different
different types of
the point is physically speaking you
cannot mix more than 60. I'm
going to say you will be so lost.
60 you could but 61 not.
I'm going to say
I'm going to say I'm going to say call
me
me.
What are you talking about everything in
in in a lot of stuff like that.
You need 40 to be
able.
It says you need 40 to be
able.
You know you will be so lost.
but
40 minus one little drop
the smallest amount, you cannot do
tfila. So,
they ask the question the matter
maybe so this is
how do you know if a person says 61?
Maybe
the famous if anybody wants to remember
this matter.
The matter the famous story
of Shim'on bar Yochai coming out
like Lag Ba'omer.
If you want to remember where that story
of Shim'on bar Yochai is, everybody
knows Shabbos daf
lamed gimmel Lag Ba'omer. So, it says
over there that that's why they started
calling him Rebbe Yehudah
that's the whole story that started the
whole fight. The Romans wanted to kill
Rebbe Shim'on bar Yochai
because Rebbe Yehudah bar Ilai he stuck
up for the Romans.
He said
This whole thing that we just said
So, in you bring 61
you have to bring 60.
This you mix in the morning this you mix
in the evening.
So, what what kind of
Bring something that you can mix. I'm
sorry.
What? 60 you can mix? 61 you can't? Here
this guy like this.
I'm
calling
this is how it goes in the whole entire
you can do about it. I saw this 40 saw
the smallest amount of liquid and you
have to
listen to this. This you have to
remember.
Because in the video you're going to see
you're not going to understand what it
is.
You need a full egg to become tamei from
a sheretz. If it's less than an egg then
it's not tamei.
Less than an egg is not tamei. Some
people
one sesame seed. If you have to cycle
Oh, let's do midos. Let's do midos. The
boys should check this out. I love this.
Midos with the measuring tape.
Ooh.
Yes, this is it.
No.
It's not kosher.
Now it's kosher.
Oy vey.
Of course there is a chatzitza.
CHATZITZA. WHAT ARE YOU TALKING? THERE
IS NO CHATZITZA.
Maybe let go of me. Is that better? Shut
be quiet and let two talmidei chachamim
argue in learning.
Okay, let's just finish up here.
Three
gives tumah for for a zav nidah that sit
on on a chair on a piece of beged.
If it's missing one hairbreadth
have a wonderful day.
>> [music]
[music]