CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 59 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] [screaming] We're holding dunes by the Mishna. We're talking about the whole per is about what animals are, what animals are kosher. Today we're going to go into the famous famous Malra mafus suga. Very very interesting stuff. So the mission says if an animal has too much blood time of the garia even when people got sick they would do a lot of blood letting they would take out blood they do it also for animals too much blood they have that thing today something too much blood an animal that smokes >> no I'm kidding >> has smoke inhalation has too much smoke in has a good >> cold will kill an animal. Just kill it. It's poison. A human eats it. It's nothing. I don't know. Nothing. Not a big deal. An animal that ate these kind of things that could kill it or even the the feces of a chicken. This is super interesting. What's bad water? Bad water for human beings is water that you left overnight. You left migula, not overnight. You leave it 2 minutes. You're not watching it. It's my mulum. Same thing for an animal. It's bad for the animal. Why? Because maybe a snake put its venom in there. It's bad. That's not It's not one of the 18 traers. So, it's kosher. But let's say let's say the same thing would happen with a cow. If a cow ate a chocolate, it would die. So if a cow ate chocolate, you're allowed to eat the cow. It's not going to do anything to you. It'll do something to the cow, but not to you. Some things kill a cow, don't kill a person. Something kill a person, don't get a kill a cow. If a cow gets bitten by a snake and there's the snake venom in the cow, you have a problem. You if you eat a steak, you might get the venom. It's problematic. So that's what the Mishna is saying here. It's like eating chocolate. You eat the cow. Not a problem. If it eats poison, human poison or a snake bit it, it's not going to be a because it's dangerous. says, "I if you feed this animal, it's what's [cough] this is. If a if a cow eats this, it's very dangerous for it. I I have a I have a video to show you. It's I I'll prove it in the video. It's very very bad. It'll make holes, puncture holes in its intestines. Imagine if if a cow has holes in it intestines and drinks something, what's going to happen? It's going to spray water everywhere. It's very bad. So, I have a question. >> No, no, but in a second. It You're telling me that if it eats, it becomes a tra. Why? Because we know that if the intestines of an animal has a small tiny hole, it becomes a tra. If it eats kilus, forget about it. It's going to have 20 holes. The problem is it says somewhere else is as kosher. The animals not the things from our has too much blood as smoke. Here we go. So if you give that pill to not the end of the world it's not the end of the world. >> Yeah. Like all father-in-laws but if so we already saw the problem. The problem is the says over here and we learned in the bry that's tra. So what do you do is the kiltus this yellow flower over here. We learned that it makes an animal tra and then we say that it doesn't make the animal tra and we have another problem if you eat poison if it and that's a problem because said if you eat poison and the mish says eat poison it's you're it's strafe next thing so we got to the question but we have to finish off the bra if a snake bit this animal or a rabid dog ate bit the animal it's not a it's not one of the 18 but don't eat it because it's a danger what do we do on the one hand it says makes the animal the other one says not same question if you give the animal that's that's leaves then it's okay it won't kill you give those >> those uh pits with the what are the seeds? Forget about it. He's a goner. Some like what's the answer? How come one place says that poison makes animal tra says poison does not make animal traum the chocolate? If it's a if if it's a poison that kills an animal only an animal like chocolate, then you're a human is allowed to eat the meat. But if it's poison that kills human beings, it's in the meat. So you can't eat it. Just side question. We already spoke about her. So why you saying is one and the same? You're right. Tab. We're talking about two different types of poison. Okay. My teal. What's this teal that we're talking about? In English, it's called asinite. You know what that is? I don't either. And in Hebrew, you don't speak Hebrew, so it's not important. It's very It's very poison. It's great. It's like a little bit of a Here we have a if we'll ever get to it. If you eat like three shekel worth of that we said before makes holes in a in an animal. Can you imagine what it does to a human being? On an empty stomach, empty heart his skin will literally fall off. I once had a story with myself. Like I said, I only ate one, not three. The talks about three. One, if I wouldn't have jumped into the pool, my skin would have fallen off. I I was when you know the you know, you know different things. It made me live because if I wouldn't have known, I would have just s sat there and all of a sudden my skin would have peeled off and he probably would have gone bye-bye. So gives life to the owner. He eats 16 eggs. Don't ever try this. 16 eggs, four or 40 nuts, visha, and seven uh caper berry things and a a re of honey in the summer empty stomach with open heartbe the the strings holding up the heart are going to snap because gives you heart attack. [snorts] They brought this deer. They wanted to eat a deer. They bring him his rear feet was severed, broken. So, so this is just the chicken. I don't have a good one for we were learning the chicken one. It's in this area of the foot. What you do is it actually it has the gar tells us it has 16 different strings. It's a stringy kind of tendon. 16 strings. You put your finger in there like this guy. And this is what Rav did. He did it to the deer. He put his finger p gave it a pull. He saw that the strings are intact. They're not they're not falling apart. Great. You could eat it. He wanted to eat it, you know, rear. Go to the restaurant rear. Uh, well done. I want to eat it rear. The problem with rear is that some of the juices, some of the things are still in there. Aren't you scared that maybe the reason why it can't walk is not because it got some maybe it was bitten by a snake. It's like paralyzed. So now right now it has snake venom in it and you're going to be eating it rear. You didn't you didn't cook it out. It's in there. Very interesting that another gar the famous gar that saved Rav's life. Rav was had a terrible stomach ailment and gave him this thing that made him run to the bathroom something. I don't remember the whole thing. It's very embarrassing for Rav and Rav cursed him. He says whoever gave me that that medicine that saved him actually shouldn't have any sons. and tak raval never had sons and rav felt really bad and uh rav always gave a lot of honor a lot of covet even though wasn't even close to raven learning ra was considered the gull and he was much greater the always talks about raven ramo because of that story here's another time and was a doctor so knew this stuff and saved him again he says so makanta if you're right. So, what should I do? I want to eat this deer venison, you know. So, he says, "Put it in the oven. Slow cook it." Nah, don't don't don't do this rear stuff and you'll be able to tell. He put it in the oven. Pieces started falling off. He realized that this this meat is infected with this venom. And Hashem saved here. I was here at the right place, the right time. I saved you throughout every secret. You know, all the secrets of the Tyra. Thank you. You saved my life. Great. So, now we're jumping into the super interesting of the of the animals. The tells us that in order to be co you have to be mal paraso. What does that mean? Chew it. Chew its cud. What does that mean? And split hooves. So maligerra the cow eats and all the grass goes into the car. That's stage one. It's a big giant bag and it mixes in there with all but it doesn't break down very well. And then from there goes to the basicis makes it into small little balls. It has like you look at it looks like a a honeycomb. And the grass goes into those balls. And then from there, it pops it back out somehow. I don't know how it works exactly, but it goes back from the same pipe that it came in, goes right back to the mouth. And then the cow chews it again. 20 times on each side. He says 20 times. That's what he said over here. >> 20 times each side. >> Chews it this way. Chews it that way. Then when he swallows it somehow, I don't know how this thing works. It doesn't go through that whole thing again. It goes straight to the hems like uh it's able from the consistency it knows it directs it to another place the stomach number three which is hems and from there goes the ca okay now every animal in the world that's malagra and kayo deer also the malaga is kosher besides what there are animals that are malager two types of animals that are mala but they're not maf they don't have the split hove what's a split hoove looks like anybody want to take a guess if you didn't hear this she before what doesn't what is maliger but doesn't have split hooves here's a split hoove the bottom looks literally like two separate feet completely split we know that a kazer has that >> but it's not maligerra >> what's malagera regurgitates its food but doesn't but doesn't have it's only one animal one big animal called a camel >> and a small animal >> rabbit >> rabbit very good okay this is the we're in the beginning of the that's in the so the tells us there are 24 non-coosher birds you have the owl and aer And there all these things 24 anything that's not in the 24 birds and there's tens I don't even know look it up a how many birds are there tens of thousands I would say right >> species >> how many species there's thousands 1000 thousand species anyways there's 24 birds that are that are tra the rest are kosher but we don't know there's no sim what's kosher maybe maybe that bird that you're thinking of eating >> [clears throat] >> I love this picture. This is from This is a parrot. A parrot, there's two things you can see in this picture. A parrot takes his food and picks it up and brings it to his mouth. A pigeon doesn't do that. Chickens can't do that. They don't do that. They don't use their their feet as a hand. A parrot, an eagle, I saw the hawks. They kill an ant. They start eating like this. Like like another interesting thing you see on this picture is that a parrot has four fingers. But what do you see over here? You only see two. Why do you see two? Cuz two go in the front, two go in the back. That's another simmon of trafe. A kosher bird doesn't do that. All his fingers, all three are in the front. >> They have like a one or that here is a is a kosher chicken. All in the front. So that's a sim of even though the doesn't give us we have a sim. So dus over here doesn't in Hebrew means to pounce upon and kill over here means to hold your food in your hand. It has an extra finger. So here's extra finger and we go with extra finger means that little one in the back. and vape. So what's a zeppek? So up. No, that's too much up. >> Oh, here we go. This one all the way on the left is where the bird eats. It goes into the esophagus, into that tube, and it goes into a little sack. That sack is called a zepp. That's the first stage. And then it moves on to the corkan. People eat the corkan, but I don't even know how to say it in English. Nebro's kavan a pipic I think. Yeah, that's what it is. Yeah. So the the the kavan has a inside pocket inside like a layer. This yellow on the right if you could pop it out quickly that means it's kosher. Peel it off. [clears throat] >> If the the bird puts two fingers on this side and two fingers on that side, we're still when it comes to grasshoppers. There's a grasshopper as long as it has four feet and four wings and two jumpers here. So you see on the on the grasshopper he has four legs in the front but these giant guys here's like here it's its wings are open and because that's the next thing that has to be says the you need its wings to cover most of its body in addition to all these four legs two jumpers wings the whole thing it needs to be called because you know Today we don't eat grasshoppers. I actually have a whole box of grasshappers at home that have a so usually when we talk about grasshoppers I bring to it's in in but some Moroccans but they have a messy and there's about 800 says 800 types of grasshoppers. Here's a fish. Is like um >> no. How do you say it in English? >> No, like uh like uh like uh they used to wear >> armor like armor >> and the uh >> the snapper are these guys on top or on the bottom like wings. All you need is two of these armors and one snapper. And this is it. Have to be part of its skin. That when you look at a fish, it looks like he's flying. He goes like this with his end of this. So now the the the Bryce says a rule which is the is going to say that we have to just flip it around. The words are good but they're said in the wrong order. Anytime you find an animal that regurgitates it food, it chooses its you first of all you should know it doesn't have teeth. And since it doesn't have teeth and it's malag it's tar. That's you should know the every animal that's mal that can't be a rule the mal a camel regurgitates it food it doesn't even have teeth on the on the top why is it if you're telling me it doesn't have teeth on top it's here's an animal doesn't have teeth on top it's says like what are you talking about it has teeth take a look it has something called ni like in English it would probably be called kines What does the art school call them? >> Canines. >> Canines. Okay. You sure? >> Yep. >> Cuz I don't have my English art school here. That's an >> camel has canines. >> Canines. Yeah. Canines. Guess it has canines. Those two teeth on top that's enough to make call teeth. So that's within the rule. Ask Beng. What about a little camel until it's six years old? Doesn't have these upper teeth. Visu and the obvious question on that is so so what but it's breed its mother has teeth so so it's not okay finally says better questions haron hierx v and here like a rabbit that's what we call them here are the two of them they regurgitate their food and they have teeth on top yeah So this is a a very difficult uh line to explain. There are people who have a lot of problems with this because the rabbits that we know today do not regurgitate the food. So talks about it. He has a whole thing. He says ne is not what we just because we call it today in Hebrew a rabbit. It means something else. But what is it? Some one shot I saw is that the rabbit after it relieves itself, it will eat its soy. So that's called regurgitate. Okay, different but it's a it's a whole it's a it's a topic. Where does it even mention teeth in the this is the rule? If it doesn't have teeth, not if it we started before if it's malo it doesn't have teeth then it's star. No, if it doesn't have teeth, my friends, if it doesn't have teeth on top, we saw by the two weeks ago and it just has teeth on the bottom. It just about the whole top. What? Oh, here's a camel. Oh, very nice. This was from our thing. I took it. >> You took this picture? Yeah. >> It doesn't even have an Eevee. Doesn't have canines. This one, this must be less than six years old. Oh, it has something coming out over there. You see they're starting to come out in this picture. I'm not joking. You took this picture. Wow. >> Well, compared to the bottom ones for sure. It doesn't have top ones. But anyway, so check its check its uh feet and see if it has split hooves. Besides, of course, you know what looks like. So, check its feet. No, they're chopped off. Check it. We were on the safari and I asked everybody said, "What do you think about this animal?" We saw tens of thousands of these in one shot without a gizmo. It's called the wilderbeast. For miles upon miles, they were during the migration, before the migration, after I don't even know. They have a million something. We saw tens of thousands and thousands unlimited. The the eyes you go through them and they run the va beast the vay it looks kosher to me. So is it kosher or not? Nobody talks about it kosher. So he says like this if you're in the midbar all you need to do is look inside it mouth. So tonight, tonight I went on Google and I looked this is what I came up with. Look at this. This is like uh the dentist, the wilderbeast dentist. I took the the x-rays. It has bottom teeth that doesn't have upper teeth. This the guy on the left is the upper teeth. Doesn't have upper teeth. Comes out according to this garra is kosher. That's what we thought. It looks like a regular behemoth over there. And you know how much meat you can get? Wow. Millions for free. It's all It's crazy. unlimited. The buffalo, the zebra. Well, zebra is not kosher, but the giraffes maybe says. Oh, then you can eat it. What about this says you can eat it? You're hungry. You're going to eat something. Unless you know it's doesn't have the teeth. If it has teeth, then you know it's you have to just recognize that it's not a camel. You have to know what a camel looks like and how it acts. If you know the wilderbeast is not a camel, you could eat it. But has kines you should know the small the younger camel doesn't have any teeth on top. You know that there's there is one animal that even though it's mala and it doesn't have teeth. This beno doesn't have teeth. Even the young one only the young one. So maybe there's another animal in the world somewhere in I don't know what in in in India in Pakistan I don't know what you check the whole world maybe there's a animal over there that that doesn't have it kosher the only animal in the world that's malo and it's not kosher and doesn't have the split hooves is a camel and the next puk which is the that's it. The one who rules the world. He knows and a lot of people want to prove that the is real from here because there's millions of species of animals and what we they went through they saw all the animals. How do they know to say that there's only one animal in the entire world that's mal and not maf? They never they never found a steer to this who only this who you're going on the way and you don't have what to eat and you find that animal that you can check its mouth to see the teeth situation. So look at its feet. It has split then a star and make sure it's not a pig because a piger he's showing over is maligra I'm sorry not maliger it only has one stomach you see it doesn't have it doesn't have the four stomachs the whole situation that a cow has >> and this those who know they have these in these are one of the worst enemies of farmers >> they kill you have them also in in >> the wild boars. You can't get rid of them. You they kill them. >> Ah, swine is a pig >> and swine >> swine like swine wild swine swine >> swine. >> Okay. So here this picture you see that that the has split hooves and yet >> Okay. So, as long as you know that it's not a kazer, it looks something completely different than you could eat it. >> Right. No, no, no. We're talking about I could prove I can't look in its mouth. I look at the let's say the villa beast. I say, "Oh, it has split hooves." It's a riot that he's kosher. As long as you know that the vild beast is not a khazer because also has split hooves and he's not kosher. But there's only one animal in the world that that has split hooves and is not kosher. That's the khazer. Ask the may there's another one. Same question that we had before. Oh, maybe there's another animal that's like that has split hooves and it's not a malo can't be same as we said before. If it's who only the who know there's only one animal in the world shows you that he's he's a big look look at my feet. the famous thing [clears throat] for the third time. You walk in the desert, you can't do the first two tricks that said before because its mouth is all messed up. Its feet are messed up. What do you do? There's a third trick. You look inside into into the no into the flesh of the animal. Here we have a picture. What number is it? Usually I have it mass on a normal night I have >> three. You have a new one from >> 63. Wow. [snorts] Crazy amount of things. Uhhuh. Means if you look at the meat over here, it goes in two different directions. Where? By the bow, by the tail. Here. I like this picture even more. This one is different. It goes, you could see the the grain of the meat goes in different directions. Wow. We're already an hour into the We're still on. This is bad news. Says it's 2 2:10 in the morning. If it doesn't it doesn't go both ways, then it's Tommy. All right. You should know there's a wild donkey called the All right. It has meat that goes two directions. Make sure it's not that donkey. Then you know it's 100% kosher. Same same question we had before. All right. Maybe there's another thing similar to this wild donkey. So no, we have a we have a a we have a tradition. There's no other animal besides and kosher animals that their meat goes in different directions. It's by the tail like you see in this picture right over here. What? What? What's the simmon of a of a of a of a venison? Those who ate venison, how do you know what's do you mean? What's a sim? It regurgitates it's power. Great. No, I don't want to know how you know a deer is kosher. I want to know how you know that it's a deer and not a cow. How can I tell the difference between a what it said? If it has horns and has pointed uh hooves, then it is something like this here. These are pointed. You see like that. >> This is a kosher thing. >> Yeah. The homes >> the No, not that it's kosher sim. This is a sim that's a that it's kosher. It's malro has split this also has split you see but it's pointy if this whatever this has horns. You don't have to check. The only thing I I didn't understand so much is a cow has horns. >> So we'll see that that has to do with the in a Yeah, the Gmorra asked the question, not me. >> The same thing. >> I asked the question says good. Okay. If it has the the hooves, you have to look at the the answers. >> Oh, says the car has one horn. You're allowed to eat it. So wants to know that the car over here is a giraffe. It actually has four stomachs. It's mala. It sometimes it has one horn on top and we don't need it because we don't have the word. But a giraffe is has all the that would be actually not a says what there's a there's a rule. You have a goat. It has horns. A goat has horns and has those pointy feet hooves. How do you know? Because I know because the says of here is the poss. You're right. But the horn has to be. What number is that? I'm looking up and down here. It's crazy. Wow. V this stuff. here means that it's layered layered like an onion. You see like that. So that's one of the says a bull has this kind of horn and you're not eat all of a deer you eat. Remember that. But a sheep and a cow you allow this part certain of your ladder. You saw but most of you say it has grooves in it being on something like this. these grooves. Wow. All these wives are mish letting their husbands [laughter] but a goat has these grooves in it and says being on you need that they should branch off as what about a deer's horns are not split says oh is being on. So the two two ways to read it is either it's round or it's pointy. If it's split, you don't need any any split need that they should be layered. They should be round or with a point that has a bunch of grooves in it and that they're next to each other. And that's why we had a problem with this goat from what happened. They had a bunch of fat that came out of this goat, but they weren't sure if it's that you're allowed to eat the fat or it's a you're not allowed to eat the fat. But said you're allowed to eat from it. And he said, "You will be satiated from the fruit of when you hear from another man." In other words, I [snorts] learned well from a Rebi. My Rebi told me you're allowed to eat this kind of goat. So, I'm going to be I'm going to be satiated. I'm going to be full. You're allowed to eat it for what? this e of the and I just want to make sure that e of the is not with the commercial later okay just be careful who says the kind of don't say in front of him that is that'll make him feel bad and so so what he's the so be careful don't don't don't fight with him have a week thank you for coming >> [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor atmop.com.