CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 5 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] So, we had a we had a tremendous from and today we're going to knock it out. We don't we're not going to go with it. But anan says that somebody that worships he's a good you could still eat from and says where do we know this from? We know from the story of a made a bunch of steaks and he made a tremendous barbecue for and his men and ate from and was at sadik. You did not do. So you see that you're allowed to eat from somebody that's so the goes through a few questions. How do you how do you know it? We're holding like 14 lines from the bottom of the base. Who told you that that the Russia he was the maybe I was one of's men but he was a he was one minute he was he was a sadic. [snorts] He hid 100. He was not an Avi. He hit a hundred. Well, you asked him. He had a he had there's a cipher called the valley. He hit a hundred Nim in two caves and he saved them. He saved a hundred. He worked hard. He said he risked his life like you know think about the risking risking their lives saving Jews. He risked his life to save a 100im and in that he got it was a special person. So maybe was the one who's the and for that for that certainly says no it's impossible for a human being to that much if you remember the video from yesterday there's a lot of food on the table it was impossible for him to everything there's 7,000 yidden that did not worship was basically all of society came from that 7,000 Every everybody else was wiped out I believe here I only left over 7,000 all those knees that didn't bow to the to the bow to the says yeah but they weren't around to they were all hiding from the Russia who killed all the who killed everybody Maybe was a bad guy, but maybe his people were all good. That's not how it works. If you have a a bad leader, all the people are going to be bad. They follow him. So maybe people are also no good. They're the ones who ate the bad meat. the whatever the bad guys the people from so the people from ate because they're all so bad we already established that there's at least one good but he couldn't okay soak for the good people but a value was around and whatever ate and the thousands of people that came they all ate the meat from the tra guys it's the same that we said a second ago When the leader is a Russia, all his people are it goes by the leader. Follow the leader was a good person. So all his people were good and therefore they wouldn't eat from that. And from the fact that they all ate that meat, you see that you're allowed to eat meat from somebody. They weren't that bad. Maybe they weren't m Shabas. They weren't they did they kept the just had a little little and that's okay according to [clears throat] maybe whatever's people his own people ate and people also maybe they came with their own says you see that you were very friendly. They they did everything together. They were best of friends. Oh, this is the what the says best friends. [music and singing] Then they went to war together. Says, "How do we know that they accepted the all the bad stuff and the good from we're we're the same. I'm like you. You're like me." So I accept upon myself all the you do. So when it says right then that same P the two words later it says my horses like your horses. It also means my horses and your horses we all accept they accept all the of yours. Your horses are like my horses. They're like tanks. Horses is a tank in those days. Whatever happens to your tanks going to happen to my tanks. We're going to war. Whatever happens to your horse is going to happen to my horses. We're going we're in this together. So is not referring to it's referring to our bodies, our physical being. We're going into war. Whatever happens to you, however many people are not going to make it, they're not going to make it from my side either. know that he took upon himself all the was to everything that that happened over there. They're sitting each one on their own. They're wearing the the the clothes of of of a king of in the gates of mame. It can't be physically a threshing floor. Well, you think there's a threshing floor as you walk into the by the gate over there. What's what do we sometimes refer to as the threshing floor? That's the Sanhedrin. This something like this. They would sit The 71 would sit in a half a circle. Why? So they could all see each other and you don't do it in a complete circle because then you lock everybody out. It would be impossible to come in. Let's say you want to stand in front of the Sanhedrin. How you going to get in? It's very So you have a half a circle and like this. So that's what it means that they were it's referring to the Sanhedrin not to literally the the uh the threshing floor. They accepted they accepted their says maybe I have proof to which like I mentioned before it's not going to last but we have proof that what that somebody who's a tremendous if you thought about it before we started the you say to yourself guys he doesn't believe in the he he's worshiping someone else you're going to trust him for a says yeah so the gar goes into the beautiful story. He decreed that there should be famine for three year famine. So was upset at him. Well, you're putting an embargo. He's going to go kill him. So you had to run away from him. So how did how did he how did he live? He ran away into a cave. The ravens, they bring him every single day. are a meal of bread and meat and also in the evening. In the morning and the evening. Oh, what's the where did this meat come from? It came directly from the kitchens of this says why why from should be from maybe some people actually learn from you but that doesn't fit into this he says that that's what the does he shows you who's in charge the person that's trying to kill you is the person that's going to feed you I'm going to make it like that he's feeding you every day so the says like this ali You can't bring any r from there. This is ravens from and whatever is sending him ben meat. I could eat it. It's from the you don't bring a oh where did it come from from he could eat it. So says we do allism especially when they're obviously you have to come on to the gave it you have to come on to that answer >> says the >> what's the answer >> no but obviously if you don't say from you have a different problem is not so you have to say automatically have to say came from she says Obviously, if he got the the the the meat from the raven, obviously, what's the problem? Is it from a Jew or is it from a guy? So obviously came from a Jew, but obviously it didn't it doesn't come to be uh of [snorts] so we we're learning means a raven literally a raven. But how do you know if I want to break it down? Maybe their names were cuz we've seen the Pikrin. [laughter] Urban two. It says there was a guy his name was. Come on. Two people with the same funny name. Two urbans. You're right. The two people punct have that same funny name that that they're named after a bird, not sama bird, a raven, but maybe there was a place called and they came from there. So that's that makes more sense. Two people from Irvine Irvine. They came [laughter] from Irvine says they came and they they they captured a narano. Now anybody that learned with us or throughout what's up until the age >> 12 what's a nar from 12 12 and a half is holding here. How do we know here? Here here we go. Boom. from from 0 to 12. A naira is from 12 to 12 and a half provided she has sim. A bear is from 12 and a half till 120. So how can you put those two words together? She's 12 and a half. She's 12 and she's also below 12. How does it go? So calling her how can you call her the same thing? They're opposites. They're they contradict. the is that she's actually a but she happens to be from the city >> says if that's the case if they in fact came from if there were two people that came from a place called it should have been called New Yorkers you don't call it New York if two people come from New York they called New Yorkers two people come from they called let me say LA [clears throat] I have another and this is a freebie. We learned this yesterday that is somebody that's and he's a big has going on in his house. He has a nice says says everybody's permitted to even somebody without and even somebody that doesn't believe who are we referring to over here if his brothers they died after the so they they pass and he cannot have one he's a perfect Jew and of course he can be aos He's a guy that's mal in the bris. He kicks it. He he he looks down at bris. It says that if somebody that that that doesn't believe in something, you're allowed to you're not allowed to if he if means everything besides things that have to do with and eating. Sorry, he could do. He said, "Not he could do that." What? Somebody that doesn't believe in something in the one of the mitzvah in the Tyra. He doesn't believe in. So that's like somebody that doesn't believe in. What's the difference? It's the same thing. So why are you repeating the same case? It can't be that you're repeating the same case. Let's let's go with what somebody doesn't that does. He's a lot of he's a lot of that's I'll say no absolutely not that's too much. Why? If you if you deny have a desire it's like you admit the whole and if you do have a desire it's as if you deny the whole so you deny the that's it. You can't you can't check he's a m to and that's the big that even though he's he's a he does he he doesn't believe in ina but we could trust him in which is in the same category it's food and like says that a m to a guy that eats cheeseburgers we could trust him as a So it says in the so it's not everybody which is talking about not everybody can bring a cannot cannot bring a carbon here. Let's see here. Oh wow. It went in order. That was not that was by mistake. Let's see. I I did this uh literally at 7:05 minutes before sh but it happened by itself. Maybe somebody did it for me. No, I I copied from another place. So it could be goes let's see if it goes in Oh. Oh. Maybe Yoshi got up and he did it for me. M. No. Cuz then the l wouldn't be touching the tough over there. M. A m cannot bring a carbon only in can't bring a carbon but in the nations if you have a he could bring a carbon is going to talk about this there are human beings that act like animals they're not mentioned what does that mean they don't they don't they don't they don't keep the they don't keep mites so they're animals wrote You hear this? It's Why do we accept a carbon from a guy that does deliberately? He does it deliberately. You have to give them a chance to come back with chuva. And if you push them away, say, "No, I don't accept your carbon," then they're pushed away forever. SM like all the psychologists today say you have to show them a lot of love never push them away give them the chance to come back there are two who we don't accept from so we have to understand what this m is one thing that's number two somebody who does have a desire with wine >> [snorts] >> There was a thing I didn't show yesterday. You have a problem. Here we go. In the ratio we had from just remember the word. [clears throat] So he said m can't bring a carbon. Then it says he could That's not that's not a big you see over here I wrote the whole so no he can't bring but the the middle part is if he's if he only he doesn't believe in one thing he doesn't believe in he could bring a carbon we have a problem we just read besides somebody who's a m and somebody who does a deserveth wine So, let's do the saf [snorts] the purple. What's the purple or not? That's exactly what we said in the red. The red says, "No." So, you're not going to repeat yourself. And if he's only for one thing, not for the whole it says that you could. It's green. It's okay. is one thing. It's not two separate things. He's not a m plus somebody does the he's a rashi says over here it's a beautiful rashi he says and we do all rashies these are very severe okay he says that is like Somebody does says he believes in another entity this you don't believe in the rebu saying that didn't rest and that's why I'm not resting I don't believe in that whole thing so it's very severe what do you see from here we just said that the word m over here m the purple we have to say we have to write over here I didn't have time m that's what it should say and what do you and what and he cannot bring a carbon so you see not like you see somebody that does have a desire hold let's go let's go back goes away from somebody who does have a desire cannot be a good tot says my husband you bring me a whole that you could bring a car you can't bring a car we learn from another from the different oh in the name of that what only if somebody is willing willing if somebody you Tell him, "What are you doing? You're eating." He goes, "O, are you serious?" That's a guy that could bring a carbon. Not a m a guy that says, "I know that it's but I don't care." A guy that says, "I know it's I don't care." Tomorrow he can't bring a carbon maybe. If he would known, he would have taken it back. That's a person who bring a carbon. But if he doesn't take it back any but according to everybody according to both of them a m cannot bring a carbon let's just let's finish this then I'll do the sponsor says in the look at this in the same in the same word after word same line it's almost the same person who doesn't care about always eats but blood he doesn't drink and he drank blood by mistake that's theina if you hold that had he known like had he known he wouldn't have done it so over here also had he known his blood he wouldn't have done it so everybody said not this is a typical this is a classic so he just said and and what just happened it's we're in a kasha in a ter what are we doing over here it's a kasha we're in the middle of a kasha why does the gumar say before that we learn mum not from the word m we have another pos we have another source mammar is the first two words on the gives us another source so what's going on we have two sources that says the same thing says no one sources tell us that he can't bring and the other one he can't bring and I need both this guy's not he's not royapar he's a bad guy we shouldn't be able to bring but I would have it's a gift toe We should we should accept it. Why be mean to him? You don't have to. So you don't have to bring it. Don't bring it. I don't want your your Russia. It's a it's a it's abomination. But why should why should I have a meaning? You should take it because mendy always says what does he say? Meni what does Mendy say? Let's hear from you. Ahar guy guy guy guy guy guy guy guy guy guy guy did an event he say you know what you don't have to pay $500 you're such a bad guy even $500 you don't have to pay that's not right you should pay a thousand not you shouldn't get out of it how many we're going out we're doing what every time that a person acts like a behema says you're like a person like a so the word refers to the raatory It's referring to great people. They're very, very clever. They're very smart. They have tremendous. Nevertheless, they have a tremendous Okay. Over there. It says next. So, it's referring to a great person. When it says animal by itself, it's referring to a person that acts like an animal. Says what every time they say together it's a good thing is basically so over here explains these are bad. These are people not that very good. Never learned never read. They don't learn. They don't learn. He didn't even Okay. So you don't want to. So at least be a go with no for all the people that don't have children. [clears throat] So says over there, so it's a bad thing, but it doesn't say together. There's a word in between. It says, "What do we do? Can we stop over here?" U okay have a wonderful day. Thank you for coming. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor atmop.com.