0:00 / 0:00
CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 3 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky
180 views
- Good Morning - Introduction - 2B 6 - 3A - 3B - Have A Wonderful Day! -- MDY presents: "Nothing but the Daf", R’ Eli Stefansky’s MDY (Mercaz Daf Yomi) Shiur in a concise format - all the clarity of the full daf Shiur, with Reb Eli's unique charts and visual aids, without any extras (emails, stories etc.) Perfect for Chazarah or anyone who wants a quick, focused Daf.
Chapters
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[music]
>> Good
morning, Rabboy say.
We finished Maseches Yoma this past
week. Hi. Rabboy say, daf
Today's daf gimmel. We're going to start
from the bottom.
So, this is what we had yesterday.
It's very clear.
The first four words of the Mishnah,
Hakol shochtin u'shchitasan ksheira.
So, the first two are in green, second
two are in red.
>> [snorts]
>> First two in green is go, it's
l'chatchila, in the first place these
people could do shchita.
>> [snorts]
>> U'shchitasan ksheira is after the fact.
U'shchitasan ksheira is after the fact.
So, what we need to figure out is who
could do shchita in the first place,
and who could only do it after the fact.
We have six
six shittos, and we're holding all the
way in the bottom of that base, on the
base.
Two lines from the bottom.
Shitta number one
was [clears throat] Rabbi Bereloy,
who says
that we're talking about somebody who's
tamei,
and he's trying to shecht Rabbi Bereloy.
Here, let's see.
Ah.
So, all you guys weren't here last
night. This is sheretz.
Letah, this is the number one tamei
thing in the world. Everybody thinks
it's a rat. No, it's this guy right over
here. He's the number one tamei.
He can still do shchita, how?
With a long knife.
>> [laughter]
>> So, Rabbi Bereloy,
that's Rabbi Bereloy, l'chatchila,
somebody who's tamei
could shecht
a regular animal. What's the big
chiddush? The big chiddush is, cuz he's
makpid as if it's a carbon. Why? He
wants to get used to
dealing with carbonas, eating carbonas
when he's tame. So, even though it's
tame and he accepted upon himself not
and you can't check the carbon when
you're tame, that's for sure. You can't
touch it.
>> [clears throat]
>> So, he's the hot killer. He's tame. The
hot killer if he uses a long knife, go
ahead and check.
Make sure you don't touch it. Go ahead
and check. The hot killer in the first
place. So, what's with the avid?
He's actually checking touch him and
he's not supposed to check touch him.
But, after the fact he checked it this
$5,000 animal and comes to the rabbi,
what should I do? I was tame and I
brought a carbon and I checked it. So,
the rabbi says, "Did you touch this?" He
says, "100% I didn't touch it." Without
a
So, then say, "Okay, after the fact the
rabbi is going to say it's a good
carbon."
Throughout the sugar we're going to have
to see these three things. What what's
the killer in the mishnah? What's the
avid in the mishnah? And then the next
slide the cool on to shock to.
The good news is that the gamora repeats
itself six times in a row. 30 words.
What's the cool on to shock to? It can't
mean the shot of a carbon that we just
mentioned a second before cuz then it
would say "and if
and if these of a carbon So, what's the
cool on? It must be what we're talking
about.
Like usually it's within what that chief
is. So, right now we're talking about
tame or carbon? Oh, the cool on to shock
to shock to. If they shocked it carbon
and somebody saw it the cool on to shock
to. We have to put the word there.
And they saw the cool on to shock to and
they saw.
Somebody is watching is a eight of a
hot.
And if the the shaker ran away, so we
asked the guy that saw it, "Did you see
if he touched the animal by mistake?"
No, he didn't touch the animal. Okay,
then it's kosher. That's the cool on to
shock to. Okay. So, that's the first
thing.
Now, the gamora asks, "What kind of tame
are we talking about?"
What do we all see in the video that he
touched?
A sheretz. Why? Why why why do we see in
the video it was shared? Maybe he
touched a dead person. So, for that
we're going to see a beautiful halakha.
Another gadol. Every day we learn new
halakha.
The way it works is
And this is of course for the new
people. The guys that were here for a
year or so know this inside out.
And this is second nature.
This is the chart of tumah.
It goes
in levels of tumah. The worst The worst
is av avos hatumah.
Then it drops to av hatumah. So,
a dead person is the worst of the worst.
You can't get any worse than that.
A sheretz is one step below. It's only
av hatumah.
A person who touches a dead person, who
goes to a funeral touches a person, he's
only a av hatumah. He drops.
That person that touched a dead person
that touches food or
uh another
whatever it is, keilim,
it drops one level to a rishon. A rishon
who touches
food, it drops to a sheni.
Okay.
So,
person went to a levayah, he's av
hatumah, touches this. What does this
become?
Does it become a rishon? It should drop
one. No.
Big chiddush. This becomes what I am.
If this touches a dead person, this
becomes a dead person. This becomes av
avos hatumah.
If a person who's a av hatumah
touches this,
so this becomes av hatumah.
Asked the Gemara, if this is av hatumah
and then you slice the animal with this,
you do shechitah with this, so what does
the animal become? One step less. One
step less One step less of av hatumah is
what? A rishon. So, it became tamei.
What did you gain? By a long knife. He
said, "Oh, if you use a long knife, it's
great." But you're tamei.
And you touched the knife. And the knife
is like you.
In fact, the same question could happen
even if the knife is not like you.
The knife is you is is better, but let's
say
It's still a It's still a obvious shiny,
so maybe it's no good.
So
or re-shine we can get it to be a
re-shine even if it drops level it could
still be a re-shine.
I call upon him. So that's the word's
question.
Hi Tommy D
what happened? How How exactly is Tommy?
Now this only applies what boy saying
that's the of today another this I just
told you is only when it has to do with
dead people.
But when a sherds touches a knife the
knife doesn't become a sherds it doesn't
become a batuma it actually drops one
into a re-shine.
As the Gamora Hi Tommy D Tommy
how do you come Tommy? If you Tommy if
you touch the dead person or let's say a
person that went to Lavaya. So person
that went to Lavaya is a batuma. But
here Gamora here Gamora.
The knife has the same halacha as the
dead person.
A batuma so he's a batuma.
He becomes
a batuma. The Tommy the sakin. So then
he makes the sakin the knife a batuma.
But as the sakin the meat the baser.
Then the knife goes and touches the meat
so the meat will drop one level from a
batuma go down to a re-shine. So he's
he's a re-shine.
Hello a lot of people get so nervous
when they hear the whole thing of tuma
tahara. That's it. That was the whole
that's basically it it keeps on dropping
levels and that's it. There's a few
little variations and stuff but that's
that's the basic tuma tahara that a lot
of people are not familiar with.
Hello says the Gamora the Tommy the
sherds.
The sherds is a
>> [snorts]
>> av and the and and the knife drops down
to a re-shine. The boy saying
the Tommy the mace.
The The person sherds the re-shine.
Right. The person No no no.
The person right, 100% The person
touches the sherds. The person becomes a
rishon. Thank you. The person himself
does the av hatumah, the sherds is av
hatumah.
Anybody touches the sherds drops a
level. Becomes a rishon.
We both say l'eilu d'tam'ei meis, we
could say that he touched a dead person.
We could go into b'da chumesh chana
d'rabbah. We're not dealing with this
kind of knife. And that's the question I
asked yesterday. What if you do shchitah
with a plastic knife? Are you yoitze?
Yes. You can be yoitze with a with a
with a rock, with a with a piece of
glass, with whatever you want. L'eilu
d'tam'ei meis against you b'da chumesh
chana d'rabbah. This is about kosher
b'mei b'tzor with a rock, b'mei
schuchis.
The Shach brings down that it used to be
the minag that everybody used rocks.
Sephardi used a rock. Used a rock.
Until Dovid Hamelech threw a stone at
Golias
and the rock asked permission from the
metal to pierce the helmet. So, the
metal said, "What are you going to give
me?" So, he said, "I'll give you I'll
I'll trade with you. You let me go in
now and then you can become you can use
knives for milah."
The the the
Who else brings it down?
The Prisha brings it down.
In hilchos milah.
Going to b'da chumesh chana? Say b'mei
b'tzor, b'mei schuchis, b'mei chumesh
chana.
We both say l'eilu d'tam'ei We said
already. Abaye amar nafka Again, we're
trying to figure out three things in the
Mishnah. The first four words.
Hakol shochtim seems like in the first
place who shchitah doesn't share seems
only after the fact. But then we also
have the third thing in the Mishnah,
what's going on with if there's a eid
echad that watches, it's kosher, what's
going on over there?
Says Abaye.
And Abaye and Rabbah say basically the
same thing with a small variation.
So, that's two for one.
Abaye amar kitani hakol shochtim afelu
kusi. We're talking about a kusi.
A kusi is a a person who became
uh there's a whole nation that came to
Klal Yisrael they they became gay room
and there's a in shas whether they are
gay ray MS. Do they do they really
become gay room? But later on they
became a little bit more relaxed but
it's too late once you become a gay red
sabbath. So that's it. It's like a
regular Jew. So if you become relaxed
you relax they you have a serum or
they're fakers. They only wanted to be
part of the Jewish nation but they were
they were forced by the lions. The lions
were killing them so they said oh we
better do true but we better be they
pretended to be gay door real gay. I buy
you goes with the with the with the
sheet of that they're gay ray MS. Gay
ray MS would say that they are 100% plea
gay. And if they do shita
we will eat from the shita says a by the
first place
on condition that somebody's watching
them.
Why? Because they are marked with the
races. They're marked with the they
won't touch something that didn't have
shita.
The problem with the cootie mar that
they're not marked with the bonds.
They don't have a problem with the evil
they see the mix show cuz if an evil
they see the mix show means don't put a
stumbling block so they don't put blocks
in front of people. If it's not a block
if it's a pillow they do put it cuz it
says in the third don't put a block.
They don't have a problem
giving people treif.
So I go
in the first place but I feel cootie.
Why? Cuz they're gay ray MS. The
it's only when a Jew is standing right
there watching.
But
if you have a
like they have in a lot of places today
you can't afford a that's going to sit
there in the kitchen day and night 24/7.
So he comes in and out.
Somebody comes in and out says a by you
do not that that's not acceptable. Can't
do shita.
And this is after the fact if he did it.
You cut off a
they also they have a problem with
so make sure it's a nice big piece.
I call it motor. Do do the do the test.
You know, the the poison test. So, if
you if you trust
if this guy is going to eat it, he
doesn't eat treif.
He he keeps all the races. So, if he
eats it, then you could be so much on it
after the fact.
Okay?
If he doesn't eat it, then it's also to
eat from a shrita.
Now, we're going to do this another five
times. We're going to do it each time a
little quicker.
>> [snorts]
>> Let me show you
over here on the just in the chart.
It says in the Mishnah
besides the
cannot do shrita. Why? Because they mess
up the shrita. They could do shihia,
they could pause, they could do drisa,
they could they could uh go downwards
instead of slice.
They could do halada, go in between the
two simanim.
And then it's covered and then cut.
And then immediately afterwards it says,
"V'chulan sheshachtu."
Grammatically, it doesn't really work.
What's v'chulan sheshachtu? These three
people that we're talking about? No. If
it's these three, we'd say v'im. V'im
shachtu and and if these three the
shachtu and somebody was watching them,
then it's good. The word v'chulan is no
good. We're going to see that question
five more times today.
Each time is a free bee of 30 words.
>> [snorts]
>> Can I do why? Shema yeshu, shema
yidrisu, shema yachalidu. Let's see the
beautiful pictures again.
This is what we're going to have today.
This is also we have a special artist
that didn't you didn't see him. He does
this 3D stuff.
This is halada going in between the two
simanim.
So, now right there that's where it's
possible. Why? Because it's covered and
you cannot do a shrita that's covered.
So, this is a question if covering with
a let's say a scarf is considered
covering, but certainly if the animal
itself is covering and then you do the
shita it's for sure assur. This is drisa
going downwards.
And shihia is something like this.
You do one siman and then you take a
coffee break and then you come back and
do the other one.
Says the Gemara, the kusi shachatahu
ahayo, so then we have to understand the
third sentence in the Mishnah that if
there was somebody to watch them, then
it's okay.
Vim shachatu mebaile, then it should
have said different wording.
Where what did I skip?
We're talking about this right there.
We're talking about the katan. You're
pretending the
katan and other people. No,
if these people that we just spoke about
Elakusi, so so usually it goes back to
the
the shita we're talking about the kusi.
Abaya says we're talking about a kusi.
Ho amris, but wait a minute, how could
it be that you need somebody to watch
them?
The Mishnah is saying that if somebody
saw it after the fact it's okay. No, but
if somebody's standing there watching
him, I feel like
so let's see the shita of and the Gemara
says kashya.
Remember this kashya because the Gemara
later on is going to say how come
uh Rabbi Barula doesn't say like Abaya.
How come so and so does cuz there's a
kashya on Abaya. Doesn't fit in so well.
Here's Abaya's shita.
This guy is a kusi.
If a if he watches him, if a
watches, then it's okay.
So now come Abaya says the kusi means
the kusi if a watches him. If a
goes in and out
goes in and out, in and out, once in a
while he shows up.
Then, you know, sometimes they show up
once a week, once a month, once a year.
I don't know how it works exactly. But
today with the video cameras it's a
little different, a little better.
Okay.
Omar Rava,
I have a problem with what you're
saying. Cuz
we know even today, think about it in
our days.
If you go to a restaurant and there's a
there's a mashgiach that's
he's not there in the kitchen. Once in a
while he comes in
No.
Yeah, it's okay. It's okay.
It's okay. It's okay. Rava says I'll
prove it to you that it's okay. What's
the problem?
I'll prove it to you.
If you sell a bunch of wine and you
leave
and you have a Jew going in and out,
Okay.
What's the what's the what's the idea of
what you're saying?
Cuz I'm concerned that the guy Not I'm
concerned. The guy The guy is concerned
that the Jew is going to catch him.
The the hashgacha guy The guy that's
working in the restaurant is concerned
that he's going to get caught. But it's
not
You're allowed to if
even a selling wine are not
concerned about
I'll show it, but just this is the older
one.
This is a guy
Um the the concern is that he's going to
go into it
and take some wine.
And then what is he going to do?
He's going to have to repair what he did
cuz it's obviously sealed, right? It's
not an open bottle. So he's going to
repair it.
That I'm not concerned. Why?
Because he's going to get caught. It's
It's going to take 2 hours until it
dries, this that. So that's actually
what the guy is going to answer later on
that what's the what's Rava bringing a
raya from something that takes such a
time to
where over here is just a slice of the
knife and he has the chef maybe he'll
mess up.
So it's tomorrow.
They tell they tell
does it say anything about
That's what
if he did it and he left the guy by
himself doesn't say you should leave him
there. If you left him by mistake
Do you have it then it's okay we'll let
you Use that wine
and another riot that you say is okay.
Again
we're talking about wine that's kosher
and it's by the guy let's say it's in
his house. You don't have to sit in his
house live in his house in order to
drink it and
he'll have
he's able to go in and out once in a
while and it's motor.
Therefore
I agree with you in principle that we're
talking the mission is talking about a
coozy.
I could show you that he is talking
about like like a bias said. We're
talking about a coozy and in the first
place but I'm going to show you
I'm going to fix what you said. You said
the Israel is standing with a newspaper
two holes and you're watching the whole
time. No, I'm saying that it's talking
about a Jew that goes in and out. After
the fact you found him there wasn't a
guy there and you found out that the
coozy did
what do you do?
Give him the taste test if he could eat
it. I call it what I could if he eats it
great. I call it what I could like I
So let's just see what you should do
here.
We have Robin now.
He's the guy.
He's the guy he's the guy.
Okay. So Robin just changes a little bit
that's not that the Jew is standing
there he goes in and out. That's the
And if he if he if the there was no
the Kusi did the Shchita, so then you
give him to eat. Now, we have to
understand the second the third thing in
the Mishna. What does it say? "Chos of
the Koton even though he is
A a deaf mute and a Shoyta and a Koton
We had a demonstration here of a Koton.
We had a demonstration of a Shoyta.
Basically, I told her to look at the guy
next to them.
The even though he is a mute
Then a Koton cannot do Shchita at all,
even after the fact. Why? Shema Yisrael.
What's going to help me? Maybe they
paused in the middle. They
went downwards. They
hit the knife. The
And when it says in the Mishna
that if they Shacht and there's a
a single witness, then it's okay. Even
Koton if it's talking about the line
before, I look at it. We're talking
about them. So, the word doesn't fit in.
Maybe nobody should say maybe
nobody should say that the Kusi did it.
However,
he said before
that if there's a
the
in and out, it's okay. So, why do I need
a witness to witness the whole thing?
Kasha. It's a good Kasha. That's why
people don't say like Rava. Rava said
like this.
Another
So, I just want to point out while we're
here that Rava is actually fixing Abaya.
You noticed. He says
Abaya says Kusi. Rava also says Kusi
with a fix. It's not
Maybe it's a Shchita.
But, Rava himself doesn't really hold
that. Rava himself is going to hold like
Ravashi. Because Ravashi actually brings
Rava as proof. So, Rava could go with
Ravashi. That's That's all I want to
point out. Ravashi said like this.
What's the case? How come the Yisrael
Again, going back.
What is these two things? How come it
means in the first place go ahead and do
it? Or
it means only after the fact. What's
going on here? What's going on here?
Talking about a guy that went off the
derech.
And he's a mumar.
Now, there's two types of mumarem, two
people that went off. There's people
that do it because they enjoy treif,
they enjoy whatever they're doing.
And there's mumar le- le-haches. There's
mumar le-ti'avon, mumar le-haches, two
different things. One guy is about
ta'avah.
And he does it because he believes in
the Ribono shel Olam, just he has a
ta'avah. So, guy like that, you could
rely on him to a point. He's not going
to be mashal other people. He's not a
guy le-haches, but there's a guy that's
a rasha. He does it He doesn't He
doesn't even like pork, but he eats pork
on Yom Kippur. Why? Stam.
Le-haches, to upset.
That guy, you can't trust at all.
So, here's That's the It's the older one
that that
a burger is $3.99, but a kosher burger
is $10.99, halavai. So, so he goes to
McDonald's.
But when they're they're right next to
each other, and they're both $3.99, why
are you going to McDonald's? Cuz you're
a le-ti'avon, you're le-haches.
So, says Rav Ashi, we're talking about a
mumar. And a mumar could shecht in the
first place. I could be some of the
mumar. It's a big hack in in always was
since I'm a kid about shechtim, mumarem,
some of them are not such big
yirei Shamayim. You know, every place
that you go, you always have a guy or
two that Who knows what? They're doing
it for the money. That is
So, mumar le-mai?
Le-chol ha-veizidim le-ti'avon. about a
guy who went off. He's He's bad in
certain things, areas in the Torah, but
he does it because he's about ta'avah.
Be-chida Rava, you see? It says this
goes according to Rava. So, Rava could
actually This could be Rava. Not only
Rav Ashi. Rav Ashi is the one that wrote
the Gemara. He's the last from the last
Amora'im. Rava was way before.
But this could go not way before,
before. The Amora Rava, "Yisrael mumar
ochel neveilos le-ti'avon." If If have a
Jew who went off and eats nevelas
because he has a taiva, but it's exactly
what I don't like. You do a bedikas
sakin, and it's one of the things I
don't like to do. It's basically I'm
going to do it on the other side. You go
like this, you run your today you run
your thumb like this. Bedikas sakin
isn't like
You're
allowed to eat from him. Why? Because
he's he's not going to do it with the
evil motion. He believes in a stumbling
block. He's a frum guy.
He didn't do a bedika last laugh.
It means shchita isn't the heart.
So, what's what's the bediaved part of
the mishna? The l'chatchila is if you
you give him a knife bedikas sakin, you
give him a a good kosher knife. Go
ahead, chef, cuz you're not a you're
only mumche l'davar.
But if he didn't check the knife, lo
yishchot. He shouldn't do shchita.
Bimshachat, but he didn't listen, he
grabbed it, he shchated. Bedikas sakin
acharei. So, check it afterwards. Nimsah
b'yofa, mutar l'chatchila.
If the knife is good, you're allowed to
eat from the shchita. Bimlo pasul, mutar
l'chatchila.
Now, we Here we go, freebie.
We have to understand the words
of
The mishna is talking about it. So, it's
just saying the shchita in the middle.
L'ei Israel, mumche and now we're going
to take Ravashi's shita. We're talking
about a guy that went off, either
bedikas sakin isn't like. If he checked
the knife, charem l'chatchila could be
even in the first place. V'el d'lo
badak, he didn't check the knife. He did
the sakin of the gehasha. What's the
problem? Check it right now. And if this
knife is good, it's good. V'd'lo sakin,
if there's no knife, k'chachin lo havai.
So, what good is it that somebody else
saw it afterwards or at the time? Dilma
b'sakin d'guma shochet.
If somebody witnessed, he doesn't know
whether the knife is good or not. He
witnessed the shchita. Maybe he's is a
knife that has a a little dent in it. A
nick. And a little nick is a problem,
why? It's equal. You could pull the
We'll we'll talk about it. We'll pull
Don't worry, we'll get there sometime.
But the problem is equal. Ravina So
we're going to have two Ravinas.
Slight variation in Ravina.
So
there's two things, two halachas, two
two types of shochetim. This is shochet.
This is shochet who
is a mumcha in halacha, he knows all the
halachas inside out.
When I when I first met Rav Bais Fish,
our official shochet,
the amount of Torah that he knows, the
and then then he quotes from this one
and that one, he do like this, and just
tremendous the bucky in halacha.
And then there's a muchzak, a guy who
did shchita at least three times and he
didn't faint.
So that's the difference between the two
Ravinas. One he starts off the
l'chatchila on a person who's a mumcha
in the halacha, another one he's a a
muchzak. Let's see.
If you know all the halachas, you could
shochet in the first place. Mumcha
even though you never proved yourself,
you never shocheted in front of us, and
we don't know if you faint or not.
Remember when we were learning shochetim
by Rav Shchita, I I I gave him a fair
and he knew everything well.
But if he doesn't know, then he
shouldn't do shchita of him shachat. But
if he did do shchita by the night so, if
after the fact we've gave him a fair,
if after the fact we've gave him a fair,
you have to know what's in a k'mira when
you gave him the fair. At the end of the
day he knew the halachas.
If he didn't know the halachas, then
you're not allowed to eat. Remember we
had Mordechai, the guy from Texas that I
ruined his cowboy hat?
If you showed a little blood during
shear, he faints he faints during shear,
even on on on on a screen. So people
have that, so you have to make sure they
don't faint.
We're talking about it. shochet
I love
you. So we're going into
this part is talking about people that
are not they don't know that
as you
know why if you give him a little
afterwards it's enough to say
because then the day is not here. We get
the army.
In itself second
all my attorney
begin all my hockey time. This is what
is the question.
If you saw that guy in front of you
three times then it's a good
even though we don't know if they have
they know that or not. But
if a guy three times in front of you
didn't he didn't think but
you got to be careful maybe you'll
faint.
Maybe
my brother
but
he was also
I don't know what you're talking about.
I didn't think. I just saw you I saw
your head crack the the concrete. No.
You must sugar. You thought I was nuts.
That guy is sure what's the matter
that feel of the light.
My mom is free begin. No, it's
unbelievable the matter does this again.
Because they could pass a lot. The
question is
how high is we have to know what the
third line of the mission is. You leave
my mission I love you. We're talking
there. We should
say different word. I love you.
We're talking about somebody who didn't
do it three times in front of us. But I
don't know
that doesn't fit make sense because you
said that if he says I know for a fact
that
I I'm good
but I don't know
I know for a fact that's enough. So you
know what the lesson I come under the
shelter, can't ask him.
So now the Gamara just goes one by one.
So now I have the whole thing together.
I don't know if it'll help or not, but
Ravina, Ravina is the one that says we
just finished Ravina talking about
Mumcha. He's a Mumcha, he knows the
Halacha, he doesn't know the Halacha, he
he faints, he doesn't faint.
The Rabbis rule the first shot that
we're talking about Halacha in the first
place, somebody who's Tamei.
Abaya and Rava and Rabbah Shmuel and
Ravina, they don't say like Abaya. Abaya
and Rava both say what? We're talking
about an Akum.
Rabbah Shmuel says we're talking about a
guy that went off the derech. Le'amri,
why? Mishnah Dekashilu.
The Chulin.
The Chulin. How do you explain the
Chulin? Nobody had a good answer for
that.
Okay, so if you remember in we even
mentioned it today in the morning, right
when we started, there was two Shitos,
two Maybe we didn't. I don't remember
anymore.
What
Our Mishnah talks about Tamei when the
Mishnah in Zevachim talks about the same
exact case. So there's two shots. The
Mishnah in Zevachim is the main over
here, it's just derech agav. Or our
Mishnah over here is the main and that's
derech agav. Then the Gamara says,
either one you could argue with and
that's why they don't like that shot of
that person is Tamei. The what?
L'achlushin d'amris chacham that our
Mishnah is the main source of the
Halacha because it's Chulin we're
talking about Hilchos Shitos, so we
spoke about somebody who's Tamei. Adir
Abba bar Chana maker,
over there is the main part. The Korban
over there we're talking about Korban
and
we're talking about somebody who's Tamei
in Shechitas Korban. L'achlushin d'amris
chacham maker, if you say that Zevachim
is the main part.
But over here it's only derech agav
because we said Chulin, so we're talking
about Kodshim. Tamei b'Chulin go fella
it's derech agav lay.
This whole thing is wrong, why?
The whole shot is because a person who
accepted upon himself to treat mundane
things like something that's Kodshim, it
has the Halacha of Kodshim, but I don't
hold that. I hold that if you try to
treat it, you can't treat
this this Gamara like Kodshim, it
doesn't work.
So you can't treat a non-animal like
culture.
Everybody doesn't agree with the shot
that we're talking about somebody who
knows the law as well or somebody that
did it three times. Like
in the first shot in that we're talking
about in the first place. If somebody
knows the law, even though he didn't
prove himself, he could check.
Shame on him. Because
anybody that deals with
knows his stuff. He knows the law. You
don't have to give him a
test. Like listen to him. Look at the
name. Shame on him.
We're talking about somebody who didn't
faint three times.
We're not We're not so concerned about
people fainting. How come doesn't say
like a buyer that a
with only see in his
this guy standing there? Because he cuz
he proved that you don't need that that
if a person is
that's good enough.
We're talking about a that's
don't prove to me from the wine that
takes 2 hours to to to to seal and and
and and and what's the word? And use a
You're going to use that
hair dryer and all It's a big process to
get the seal well good. And then he's
worried that somebody's going to walk in
on him.
So,
over there the the guy doesn't have a to
touch the wine and he's scared he's
going to get caught red-handed.
He has permission to do the deed.
Actually, I don't like that of Rashi.
Who says that we're talking about a
moment? He doesn't say like a buyer and
cuz he got wasted. They're both of them
are talking about
cuz they're not real gay. They don't
have the right to share.
I buy Rashi. I buy and say like Rashi
that that is more Rashi.
I hold I hold my gay eyes. I'm telling
you. He wrote the Gamara.
I buy and say like Rashi.
And I buy and say like Rashi we're
talking about a moment he's feeling like
all the rubble.
Cuz he doesn't hold that a moment could
check. But
but why doesn't Rashi hold that a moment
could check? Why doesn't he say that? He
says 100% he does. Al Rova is going to
say that
our mission is talking about a mumur.
Look at Kilo he could check if you're
standing there. And so why did he say
he's talking about a Kusi? The
Koma he's just trying to fix a buyer.
You about to say he's talking about a
Kusi. Don't say he's talking about
he's talking about
have a wonderful day.
Merit the schutz of spreading Torah
throughout the world. Sponsor a sheer
today. mdy.sponsor.com or
sponsored.mdy.com