HaRav Ahron Walkin - Dina Dmalchus Dina

today's topic Dina DeMarco sadena is broad itta compasses a lot a lot of different issues we'll begin by going through the macaron the Gemara where the Gemara speaks about this halakhah Dena Dena who Sabina and will try to explain the what and the why of Dina DeMarco sadena and then we could see how in a modern day in our day lives how it applies so let's begin by Pasha translation Dina tomorrow sadena the law of the land it's a simple translation law of the land is law where is the Schuyler what's called Dina and what's called mal kusa now it becomes complicated halacha seems pretty simple Dina the Marku sadena got to follow the laws of the land what's called laws and which mark Husa what's called a mouth was a government included what's mouth of my office is simply a king of Uncas what's included in mal kusa so the truth is Dina the mouth who said Dina is Shmuel helada so remember it's not all over shots whenever you're gonna hear the word Dina mouth who sadena remember you'll see our marshmallow over her arm our school it's small whom said denied about who sadena interesting when it before shoe what did they say what a meatball my Shmuel Shmuel said demon about who sadena what does that mean well smoo invented Dina the man who said Dina it's an interesting art and as the share progresses well maybe understand better why old why it's at the shoe invention let me give you a little hint we don't know if there's it what the McCart of Deena demo who sadena is and if there is one in the Kumari you're not gonna find not in the car and not the reason why Dina the Maha sadena which is going to lead the way to have a very fierce McLucas many Regina the weirdness comes from and the why and of course that's going to be then Africa meanness in halakhah you can understand that where it comes what's the Makai and the why it's gonna have a lot of Norfolk Amina but in Choctaw of the Gemara as we begin the all Marshall it smooth smooth the Makka dish of Dina damaja sadena so you're gonna find it in four places when you look at the Gemara right around the side the Gillian is going to send you to form the Kairos of Dena Dena who's the Dean of the Amish world so let's begin with get the mission says Kailash dice island by Korea's saliva cake oven I for peace your face mayhem I they can have insurance documents documents that are Jewish let's I guess for lack of a better for nak a guy you should document shine my lobster is it's a cluster of documents and even if it's not signed by either it's binding according to you the Shiloh the game ovah says capacitor Tommy lysine or methylation on my tongue it's March about all documents are kosher whether it's a mass or a sale a deed of sale and whether it's a proof some a lot of times you have a star it's just to prove something it seems in the Commissioner Lesnar says they can murder but why finish like mr. riah right it says have a little paper and signed by people it's Araya but if it's to make a matter sense mara means this itself is the binding force behind them in here up but it's not a real star we know there's a surgical time the theorem wait a minute says the guimard oka pausing the tiny waist I'm a that lies the Matata like my maxima CEO Suzie come by you who the corner because we don't need this time because the money itself is biting but bit but but lady says the Gemara hard the economy started are you but I'll move the lab you have Zuzu come I love them and I'm sorry because when we start air law my torn dog what about my partner says the marble michael kearney live behind starter my stylist i superb Alma it's not a real star in a locker not only star that has Qingyuan acarya LP the tango we know there's a star in the title this thing mother says I'm a small bean elusive Deena since it is binding in the legal courts availa we have Deena the Medusa Deena so this is the first place where we find Dina Matos Athena okay now what is this Deena damaja sadena that's that the judicial the legal the courts they're correct they have a strength to make law so therefore if it's a legal document it's accepted in Halawa in the title d knock them out who said Deena I see you working on every word I'm saying that's it whoa such an old cache of what you know you know the Sonia so the questions where it comes from then we'll know which they write so there are ballot but before we get there what is it what is Deena mahu sadena and the answer is court when the courts accept a legal document it's accepted in Hollow that's what we have over here see it's not only a star AIA but even a star matanda that actually makes the kingdom it's not that competition I'm not saying anything that deep it's a very simple thing mr. hallelujah yeah good bring me your papers and anything I sign that your government law it's a legal document it works the legal the jurisdiction the Gemara in the dardan is the famous one and the most so to speak controversial the more in a dorm clock Assam and olive speaks about taxes I think your mother says are you a lot of a taxes are you like make your nether to promise that you did pay or you don't have to pay your taxes says the your mother has all said you're allowed to make such a nether it doesn't make a difference if you're trying to evade the taxes it's called need ray Langston and you could evade the taxes says the game are evading taxes Dena dumb a lucid II know that you're not a ladder with a taxes because of Dena democracy do so that's tax legal documents so we have so far the Gemara by the comma speaks about confiscation of property you know they make bridges and they make all types of roads exactly which means they're able to take your property and build on it what right does another you'd have to drive on property that was taken from crime daughter's friend and the Gemara says that's Dena Dena who sadena so we have eminent domain government property that's the durum Baba Basra Nidal atomic base yes what is eights and eights of mrs. Parker a to miss McAuliffe what right do I have to make a road in somebody else's field yeah but what about the Giri the bridge itself the Gemara says and you're allowed to go through the bridge it's both the Gemara team speaks about I could charge you for going on the bridge right they do charge a guy on the bridge yeah but that's awesome right but there's also Kirk involved and also once I might say I'm gonna have a rough time I see I see we have our days cut out for us but what does Giri is she means they may kiss you and they make the mark speaks about both cases the Gemara speaks about making bridge what I mean is the only thing that happens would to make a bridge I can make a wood to make a house it's a barrel so the pit that they're taking Lin and they're confiscating land and what's the point do the Gemara that they own there's an ownership that the government has that they're able to have property property is not so to speak you're the boss the government is the boss still not so let me tell you more about the bathroom the matter that the Basra discusses can i buy with money character and the answer is of course my is kinda nice in the legality of book of bubble you needed to have some kind of a document my stomach today also you can't just go buy property it has to be with staris so the Gomera wants to know if i bought with money does that enough well I love Kapur you if I didn't have the Stars I don't have any transaction done by a legal paper the Kenyan is not funny ever on our small beam of the mouth who sadena alright I'm ready to go I'm ready to do with you let's go you ready so give me the four cases let's see the four cases and what's the common denominator the first case is staris legal documents if you look at Rashi Bezdek now she refers to the besan of aqua which means that were judicial the judicial hazekiah la la cabeza many was shining him as we soon will see seem to say it's more of Bnei nya Mitsu Vimala dhinam so therefore their courts are able to set policy does that have to do with the government per se / ho not clearing the riche inot many we showing them discuss that but from Rashi and the case of the gomorian given the story is court courts have a higher legal authority to make rule the Dharam is taxes and I will not discuss taxes because I'm a smart guy yes okay next okay but that's we understood so the Gemara actually says that we're it's not fear the taxes it's a malik it's luck which means is it's not legal it's not the distributed fairly the rules then you could have avoided like i said i will not touch taxes today please i beg legal holiday well so these them up who Siddiq okay you're here so I'm not touching tax please don't go there privately come over I'll tell you about taxes okay look the next case we have is the Casa and that is that they're able like he said I'm in a domain they can come and confiscate your land your properties and say listen it's ours and bubble baths row seems to be more in the business the commerce they set the rules of congressmen they say can Yanam need a star you can't just make a Kenyan I pay and that's it it has binding rules lalala okay what else is including a Dean of the mouth who sadena a lot and it's complicated because we need to fully understand like I explained before what is the MacArthur and the why and then we could apply it interesting like I mentioned it's not in the Gemara there are all martial small said why did she will say where did he get it from not clear so if you look at the resign him they argue on this question the most simple of all is the true Bazar Gangnam since I'm above you got to live in peace Shalom with the Medina that's it you guys you live here let us say for a lack of better term how car insight or Eve listen you're living among people when in Rome yeah it's a darkish all in bad PR you are mental me there's a car it's a tithe any Moussa schmooze you want to put into it that's it the pants are with you Shiva you go to mr. Shiva wants to learn a booster schmooze from this hell off okay whatever it is that lava is get along with your neighbors that's the story all right you got along with the people around you and appreciate the government what's the take a legal holiday sky Connecticut good Souls I know this isn't true Versailles Gangnam where becomes the question what happens if they're not gonna know about it that I didn't listen to the rule it's not gonna cause a big friction it's not a problem they don't care they they turn a blind eye is gates and Shawn so then it's not a problem lot locker if the whole thing is that I have to respect so to speak that I can cause friction and tensions if they don't care they don't care so possibly you could come and say all the non buying anybody called not enforce things that they don't really care about there was no Dena Dena who Sabina because it's not inherently how luck a good sweater I said this too many guitar so many toys came over the is it's an interesting harder if in my own house where they don't know the difference is they're still legally somebody called dean d'mellow sadena Lala and if you know for sure they're not gonna find out in a case where they won't find out you'll be shocked to know how many such cases we have everything it'll be interesting we'll be talking about them later the practical will come later that's it walk over the black what no I'm saying something else you need to follow their laws I mustn't comment even the boat it was the the the the bridge anything which they tell me I must do gotta listen to them yeah that's a good horror yeah I understand I can see you want to look in the case of other Basara how does it apply Shaolin with the Medina well I guess when they set up a society with rules and I followed III here in this particular case just don't go on the bridge you mean you'll swim to Staten Island that's what you want to say okay maybe yes with the Staten Island he angle on the Verrazano Bridge I hear you're harder but I like I said I hear I hear but it's not because you have the other cases of the Gemara you know it's each case you could sit and pick is it mama SH but this is in general more or less derived in a broad sense you lived here behavior okay he's smiling I you what date let me tell you what you're smiling about because you know you at ten o'clock everyone's gonna tell me I'm not and then we gonna get all right now these are my big things a low-paid okay Halabi of caste and a guardian and she look another the shins time I pass us mama give up English sorry toss them a lot hemella and you better listen to that now laugh there's only one thing you're the King even a glazier King to sign that love is that they tell yourself that you gotta listen you've got to be supported through King even a guy you're shaking huh pasta yeah but the pastas back yeah they're alive they're saying poshest Malakand applies even to a king when your domain according to this we can come and say maybe it's only then it's the king it's a monarchy today there's a monarchy right and I could talk about England mentok submitted with the Malka Malka sugar but in general we are New York City America we have the concept of monarchy many acronym ask then according to the guy in has to have a chanela it has to be a mongoose with the melech maybe raashi like I told you says story that the artists are er Caius has to do with best many Roisin him okay you know we have a president do you want to call him a Mela you you same customer welcome Ellen he's like a melon all right that is the Feynman Elif can't get impeached peace easy knows I let me tell you as the goes on I have a lot of jokes about these things gonna keep it to uh there's a Raschi like I said that says that has to do with Basden many was shining him learn that banane I Ahmed some alladhina since the Taira tells the malkos to set a birthday dinner so we need to listen to those BOTS Atheneum so the origin of it is what man hat Tyra and that's your good question you asked me is it man I tell you that or is it the dry blood snowflakes are shining and it's based on this question is it because you have to have Shalom yeah that piece so then it's only troponin right it's no there's no car in the toy room except after Uncle Michael record yeah I don't it cannot be my card but if it saw him toss the malapa mela or it's been a night amid Silver Dollar Dean in and if they don't put Dean in the higher me some ha tada so the origins of Dina DeMarco sadena are we're in the tire - bomb in bubble baths renouned Dollard that I quoted to you is really what are we called the Makar but where everyone starts from because right because there says the - bomb taxes - and my son no ninis whatever they cook yeah yeah yeah he says he aside the site is Shibuya Medina you accepted that when you decide to live in a place you've accepted and all the people have accepted on themselves in English they call it a social contract so we have two very fancy words eminent domain and social contract those are the two things that everybody's gonna say social kind of you live here you've accepted Coppola Malaysia macabre male you see the words in the respond McCallum you accept so let me tell you okay so let me tell you so there's a Truman suggestion that discusses your question okay so you know that we this would be a lot of discussion that later yeah I'm just laying the groundwork first you know I'm gonna be tunneling and mixing and matching we're gonna way we're gonna get into this real good I understand what you're saying but let me tell you all that Truman's attention the truth we know each other for many years the tumor sedation says what happened to the guy says I don't accept the government I'm a cop I'm a Democrat Republican Republican Democrat cousin he's not my president is my doctor tumors that fashion we don't care why first of all who cares about you your father was here before you maybe he accepted either either like I'm exhausted but I what was his name again Roosevelt for the NFL - Dez no idea but they worship Roosevelt yeah but now they know what religion yeah three time in the observation River the loser belching to them yeah Jenna all right I'll companion your father except okay and even be able to say that you did it let me put you Livius that means you accept it so you're saying to mrs. eshton I didn't say it when you live here you accept but this thing you can scream cry Vic I um that's one of your rights and they're very crying futile to let you do that the bottom line is you're here that means you accept to be here and if you accept to be here except to be a hundred percent yo-yo so after with a ship you'll work it out go defend me you're my lawyer okay good now the Rambam let's talk like a piece of ice then I'm observed yeah well like you yep Mikado tell me whose money are you using salt swish column of the tall's medallion you accept you accepted yeah if you're using the money that means you accept to be here I never saw a guy trade my little blighter his chicken in the backyard is he's Michael parlor become up you're using the money here and if you're using the money here so Rambam say Lipari k you you to taking the Rambam I think Rambam de l'épée okay I love you test the fact that you're using the money um the place you're living in that's are you that's Araya that you're Makabe that you're Makabe says the base Yosef so wait a minute what is that a proof of what is that a proof Jacque the base Yosef first of all he's the Christ mission summit as he says but shame there aim the Medina is owned by the government the medina is owned by the government they own it Connie lamella what becomes the shy let's say let's say a person yeah he's not he's just traveling he's traveling Europe so there he also accepted that's cool I live here I accept the medina is owned by who by them by the government Punk them traveling through and the nail of therefore what that means I also lose except Olivia right Sarah I'm traveling and I'm passing by how do we apply the smart of the Regina sorry I spoke it over with many Shiva's PI scheme over the years and I think the shot is the fact that you agree to pierce into this place that means your acabo whatever this government that you're in is family you're gonna be using their police in case you need it you need something you'll be calling the police from there that itself means you're macabre you don't have to have what do we call birth positive its birth that you have a birth certificate living here the fact that you come in to another country and you're willing to rely on their services and you rely on one that's what I rule also so the fact that you went in there I like you're smarter that's really what I'm trying to say I don't know maybe the lords of Dean of the Medusa has to have some kind of acceptance and I'm searching for some kind of that you've accepted and when I pass through I usually accept but if you're saying that you're running and you're hiding and you're just maybe not maybe not that's the smart yes sir then a Phenom II that that would be thus far as if he's if he's a Mela now crystal let me tell ya there's an old famous guy the guys that steal a sham I'm Luca well Michael bag are you what's the filler between mellow commercial feel ashame I'm Luca or my slugline he says that by Claudius or Mel Mel's accepted accepted by others Berkeley we accept so Kela sham I'm Marshall but over the gun they don't accept him Caesar my soul it doesn't say Deena demoys shil it says Deena de Maio Husa it has to be some form of acceptance if he's a ruler and he's a dictator spot it's not accepted say I'm a we've to listen to a dictator I hear you are but it's very possible with all these dictators there was a lot of benefits and the people like their dictator yes you could and then the way and this is a big topic you know we could talk for weeks if that's that's the shower all right I yeah well that's called my Musa but I'm just trying to tell you the word is my loosen up moisture and there's a filler between amount clue said on my show now where is this that's the Gemara in kerf you're given with the Gemara says that's what for example in the guard marches by marcus it has to be that he's accepted it has to be that there's some form of has been in the wars it's max time he's coming in and forcing everybody and and putting laws on people that they can't accept all right that's the question so let's discuss the famous shyly and that is does this apply in Eretz you see why Sparra is that it's owned by the mela the Mellon owns basin Medina's Conda Leela Mela not in okay I'm gonna be careful I am NOT discussing politics here okay how much Ghazi I la Gola my sir the Medina you know what let's just say the lid let me I want to be very careful about they say okay the land is not owned by the government tonight you stroke l'll ask me who run the Pirates as Miss calculus Martin when you own Lynn not in America a boy site people think I'm barring property and the Malick owns your property la loca and ancestral you're buying land like yours that's just wrong miss calculus faulted and they're having very little Kinyon if any over your over artist Rawls park of the land itself government no matter I'm not gonna get into the word government there but I'll clip on him the land is on this calculus forum so they're on in the Dharam cup Qasim and I love says clearly and therefore an extra straw there is no Dean of the mouth loose Adina that's a good question but whatever is the government definitely doesn't own it III wasn't discussing if you own it I said you could hold it I see I'm gonna take off my hat siren yeah they're giving me a run for my money okay planning you listen I may say there aren't a capacitance then it ain't you stroll this doesn't apply rounded arm cuff catch them it out there are bomb argue some safe as a whole i refresh mr. Simmons i McGowan new dolly that in air controller does apply because again maybe it has a lot to do with the real soiree of why Dina Matos Edina is it that it's Connie managed to him or that he has jurisdiction the government like to throw I mean whatever it is they have jurisdiction and it does apply Dina Damascus Athena in and to stroll as well minik the meaning is that yes there is Dean of the Medusa as a brain the Braxtons acronym that today even though we could start the saying well there on it's not Connolly Lamai seduce Edina applies energy so that's what just said yeah yeah so come closer way okay that's exactly what we just said could be totally the shy look yeah if it's about owning then you have Iran if it's about social car dude I was the not you mean very good very good Lamesa everything we spoke could be tied to money that's what I think we were talking a little bit right it's about who owns and money and then and and can your name and business it's tied to money what about dealing about who Cedeno when it's not a money issue does it apply for things which are also not money now place it let me discuss this if you learned that the mellah were the government it's there by limb they own they own your land they don't own your money they own your money i if anything it's more about the land and what they could tell you to do on their land then what they could tell you to do about your money right stay your ground some states yeah that to protect yourself a few you feel you're being challenged you can take a gun and shoot that person Massachusetts you could protect your by killing the other person I don't know I used I'm also had rules no I don't know why wait ahead you want to know if Dean of this doing Dinah's that's your question I'm not I to different topic for different gun control and I see there's a lot more in this question all right so here's the point the point is maybe we could come and say Dean of the mob who sadena is more about the land because it's about Kenyan and they don't own our money right there is a schita in the rich item but it could be it's about living in their own property it's living in their land maybe what I'm trying to do is I'm trying to get down - no I'm just saying I'm not no I'm asking no of course the host is money it's all money the question is why if you're gonna learn the smaller is that they own it's about they be owning something yeah they don't own my money they might Almighty might land they might own the streets but they don't own my money and yet we find that it applies to all cases of money dilemma Husa may be more relevant than any other issue it's a more money money it's all the cases about money so I picked found a remaining item a beanie anus says another Suarez this isn't about the bathroom a dollar on the days that Dina Medusa is Health Care Bears in Africa African mouths who say Africa they can be mouth care they have the right to take from you just like the best and has the right to be mouth care so they have rights on your money you see wrapping yarn is addressing money we're gonna make a one-minute Hazara on all of this because it's important to see it from all the different angles of how there is shine emphatize Dina them of who Sabina one thing you gotta walk away with there is a thing called be nama kusa Dina and you'll be surprised how many different factions of people will say it's not smoke like you're showing him if that's what it is I mean you know sexual gave us a beautiful sheer for today you know what he did he said how long and didn't tell us why which gives us the open road so to speak to say and to learn that we don't know what she was how love is maybe I don't know I never spoke dripping do you know how do I know it's maybe well Claire it's because there's a lot of a vested right half cos bezel that's it's a dinner bezel that's a bezel to kailasa rabbi sigh it's a big topic and again what I could do for you is two things I could give you that you should have a broader scope of understanding what it is and later you'll see how practical cases in our daily lives it's so interesting okay and I do know that what time does the sheriff then when I'm done okay I wonder with the Dean of the markussi Dean about the time of the shearers okay now grab a neon you know like I said says that it has to have capacity F many say it has to do with the mouth loose that they own the property the government that belongs to that or it's about social contract right Leslie smoke from the rest box there's an interesting base like the base Yosef says that it's only by kesef Dean of the mouth who Sabina doesn't apply to anything else that's ash in solitary chibi she brings a lot of the cheapest it's only by money why you start hearing the round it's about half your best and half curse it's more about money than it is about anything else so it's a whole different way of looking is Dean of the Mongoose Edina directly I gotta listen to my government or these amaku sadena they have rights either on the land or on the money there's a political regime you've all missed moon above I'm an hour and the cottage goes with this it's a very interesting Raja and the cousin issue deals with this la vaca the people are Connie lamella you're owned by the government the government owns you so they have the right to tell you what to do that's a very interesting huh you're gonna look it up you're gonna work on it's a very interesting topic no over the years over the years it's a raspberry Lamas problem has initially cool to punish but to Zion tests so over the years I've asked tessai intest they own you the gun as I asked the question I mean we're democracies the heck of the whole like the whole Constitution is they don't own you maybe maybe communism capitalism okay so you know that I'd worked on this for years and I came up with a stick Allah Mohammed Robles and I think it's a lot there's an interesting Russian too darn Perry K I see Dawa they could expel you that's call they have rights over you and I think that's what it means it doesn't mean they own you they own you legally to tell you what to do they could tell you to leave you like that's a good sweater now we gonna go into what immigration and then the border and the thank this you'll go home and deal with it that's a social project a social science project later but you see is it about the money so let's see a Clara Boise before we get into the examples of mice you ready yeah now by site beer maku sadena yes don't play around uh because I got that big deal I have went to PI scheme and then they went that that that did him a severe case of paper taste of basil you know that make a taster really is either because they don't know the Soviet or make the taste is because it's not clear what it refers to I say so let's say may either at the shot is because these are my puss Adina you accepted Deena Marcus Adina is the courts what about it's not in the court what about rules they have nothing to do with court uh-huh maybe then there's no thing about coos Adina maybe the mucosal Deena means that the mound has the right do we have a milk today in Steven the mob who said Deena means that they own the Kaka is the makuu sadena that they own da you do they own you it's not clear what the Dean of meiosis Deena is Shmuel just left it without an explanation okay so let me give you a few examples that come up over the years interesting examples somebody called me he passed a stop sign the cop listen you passed a stop sign wants to give him a ticket the guys beg and please don't give me the tickets it's points and my parents and blah blah blah blah blah okay so the cop tells me just plead not guilty said I wrote I started writing the ticket plead not guilty yeah and once you go pleading not guilty going from the judge if I say maybe that should I mean I won't show up I'll be drunk that whatever whatever you started a ticket the traffic ticket all right maybe you won't get the points offer could you plead not guilty if you're guilty I'm guilty I try to get away with this here's the Dena Dena who sadita is you know I'll do this traffic violation and you got caught doing it and here's other shilin which I was even surprised about is it and this is a shot when I go boys I cook the bucket she looks good very very proud you're saying good you're saying good so let me stop I tell you that list and I knew this guy is Lee's gonna get it from his parents I knew this I knew what was gonna happen so I have to find some kind of a so I said to listen I I love that you had such a have I mean at least to be a missa but it has to do with the system they don't care if you don't get I found a technicality they let you walk they'll let you up so cleaning that guilty doesn't mean I'm not guilty forgive me I want a case I want to I want to go in front of a judge that's all it means it does no law you have to be very careful here when you plead not guilty that's what you're saying no LS that the swirl you were saying when you plead Maggie but even you're saying it I don't think that's an issue yeah wonder why you're sitting next to that crew figure out why is this table the élysée is it accidently yes I agree with Joe I can't tell you I've done in the past all right listen stop doing stuff like that do you tell the truth you tell the truth I don't know my rep your palm probably would have said yeah I did it rule I do now have to cool off that suddenly called have class how are we gonna talk about that that's a big part of this Sonja which we'll get to later I've called polymer join the middle was on my shoulder clear Shabbos he's just for hearing and if in the legalities and then he wrote the wrong date so that's the war that you needed you're not fired that's it very good good hold on but if you go I know but let's say you know for sure your guilt IRA or you you know for sure you're guilty you're right you aren't proven in the court but you know for sure what else okay we're just getting into it now all right - I'm good sick days vacation things it's legal right so vacation vacation day huh it's rule these the Medina's her very soon everyone is gonna have ten workdays I thought the rule was gonna be I thought so they're gonna have that ten days of you you got to work yeah okay okay I'll component vacation days I don't want to give it and the guys mask him with the other bike okay so he's a guy he's not gonna be mask I don't think you're the cool and I'm who you have to give you vacation days sadena okay so again I ask trip trying to Miller this he was at my shoulder right that was like a punk this Shabbos he was there and he was there a whole Shabbos or I asked if everyone other I just kept on saying Rabi why do you tiny restriction I've bears on the lake which I'm Miller okay she told me first of all vacation sit we give young to get the hunters that's it that's your vacation base it's not so relevant here's a better question can I give them it last a minimum wage so the truth is what's the Schuyler let me tell you the question is is there a DIN damaja sadena in a private transaction between two people so we found in the case of the Storace right with the kenyan in the car car that they need you they hold you need a thyroid doesn't work yeah but the question is so it doesn't work it's not a question of its officer the Gomer never really said over there us or not austin says it doesn't work it's not a kid you could go and claim it's not a kenyan because you don't have you didn't have the legal papers behind it all sure its business i'm a lot except he accepted i accepted yes that's exactly what comes in loaded still helped you a little bit more um the Maximus is a better idea oh yeah maybe not yeah yeah she's saying Ava Shawn that's what you mean that part so they won't find out about it right but they want that's right but maybe they won't find out about it I mean how would they find out about it huh so that's the question what is again every case I'm going to give you you're going to tackle it with all the information above what is Deana the Maheu sadena and what is how far does it rule every activity and action that I do in the country that I'm in is business between two years included hazards hold no and it says no maybe between eating and Gayane whole different topic maybe but between two even private business up the class emissions not they Gail I want to make this [Applause] that's what it seems from the Gemara that he could come and claim Deena DeMarco sadena now I want to discuss further what let me tell you something there's a lot more layers to this topic that I will give you I will I will uncover let's talk about for example like I said paying cash in the school right so let me tell you something cool top class how long I've cause how long means you're not I steal from a guy yes you're not allowed to steal from a guy and nobody holds you a lot of steal from a guy it's not true there's no such thing tie your soccer maybe if he makes a mistake and you keep it how long can tells you not to keep it you'll never see Branca the smile brings down no one ever saw a block of him tell you and then this kid is shush am to return it there's something called half car salvo if I don't directly steal I just avoid not paying what I have to pay the Gemara in Baba commandeer says of course how la is murder I've caused how la is moved I'm not telling it's a good thing it's a nice thing it's not examine so many learn that they're not paying in a tax on the store is called path cross how long what does that mean he's money he's he's too bad the gunman's being today or something and I just ignore it it's a good it's a it's a high now again I'm not telling you to do this I don't that please don't walk go out and say Rob I will I didn't say anything okay I'm so far just giving you the whole background information you want to come to me privately I'm gonna tell you what I think what I don't think it's not there but this is the secret ingredient in the Saudi and that's called tough class Oliver yes that's right yes that's a perfect example did I tell you to be half cos although I told you that I didn't tell you to do it you should be the hottest I'm so sorry because I'm dying the carpet crying please all right you guys gotta need a good moment I want to tell you a good story no my son I got the nice I thought the whole thing was about one Shana my son taxes that okay so listen to a nice yeah I have a letter from Isaiah the lips move daughters volcán a guy asked him about a certain business it was a little bit of a shrew that plays our best for my back I say the rights to him two more I need eleven shanaynay knew both of us you're shopping new aides are tough it's hi we were both in robbing and you saw the rapper and you heard from the red but you asked me if you a shady business you don't remember the stamp story that he went and he ripped up the snip what am I trying to tell you if you know the story of the Huff Italian yes you should not be doing anything I said here today you should say I'll pay and I'll give and I'll do you're right but we're not living in the world of the cuff Italian we wish we wish it's definitely an ideal to get to the question is basic hell off the motor officer and there's a Soviet called off class hell buff and it applies to a lot of with the taxes and so on and so forth it's enough said on this part of the topics copy we're doesn't seen this year that's a free-for-all I'm sorry I'm looking at the topic it I saw a deal - Maku sadena there's rules here what are you talking about after what should I tell you I the world of the Huff it's I am alibi okay rebutted for you I would believe it if you would come and tell me that you would do this on you I believe let's move on copyright laws that's the story the story was he came to him I heard that it came to him the guy returned the spa room that's what I heard from Isaiah the guy who turned the spa room there was no stamp on it it's so he was sending it and wasn't even sad he said the same thing I was sending it back but the club Stein felt that it was sending it for him I'm in a mistake yeah that's the way that's the way huh all right whatever okay let's move on okay as they say you see Isaiah Isaiah halav I we should be the toughest guy no matter what that story is they don't say it about me and you about you and they don't say about me now let's talk about Dina them out who's against the Mitzvah of course not right for example if the maoist tells me no mila norm it's Itza that's clarf in patch bats kala kalah semi-cooked no crash they can't override and why is it even a discussion because it deals Marcus Athena is that a ricer huh so that's even why it's somewhat of a discussion when they have against mitzvahs against things rules the government okay now here's an interesting Shiloh that the Pisgah children are daya the rule in general I understand what you want but the rule in general is they can't dictate Mitsos but let me tell you where it's an interesting Schuyler you know pinion I've been we all know we look for the coins what happens if you don't have the coin you get that definitely pay money why are we paying money remember the Rambam says it works on Dena Dena Husa Dena especially today yeah the dollar but it doesn't it's not backed by anything backed by anything huh so here's the Schuyler could I use the Mongoose Athena that it's money for your positive mitzvahs so there's an interesting Pisgah chuva and he says could be you shouldn't use dollar bills for pigeon had been now you're starting to see how Edina my elusive deep ok so then it shot the cash yes it may be copyright laws big it sir I don't want to go into a hole I read cause of copyright laws but there is a base year tough that says it's based on dealing the mouse loose Edina you look on the back of the sperm they say according to the rights of bedlam either the right copyright copyright it so has it's a base year talk ok you every day Simon race I in hey Simon raesha I hate base hit spot the not Kamini would be very simple if you're where copyright is about stealing from the other guy so it's even a proof though it's even one penny which means even a syllable of a song if he's mocked but he's knocked it right a small line from a safe if he's knocked in Mokpo the question is it's not really her luck it's very hard to understand that there's hyung-nim in this gala so you say it's cop then only what the copyright laws are whatever according to the law is all sir that would be austere so again it does see a very big mouth Amina if it's copyright has to do with Dean of the mouth lucifina and it's only going to what the law forbids alright let's talk about as they say Sitka's dick is recycling recycling laws and I'm who you have to recycle that they want it they tell me it's laws I get a ticket for that right so I'm I'm equipped to recycle anybody ever thought about that well no I am I'm aloof to recycle let me discuss with you recycling in a few minutes but I want to talk how this could be very interesting it wills for example a secular will is not a coin to pay right laughs yes what is it because I have unfortunately sometimes I it's early in the morning and I yeah but the question maybe it's also to do because they're dynamic loser all right so let's talk about an interesting thing the secular wills I don't know if you know that in the tire of the car get speech nyam girl isn't doesn't is not a yesh so what happens if you put and you make a secular will and you want it that should be according to the will that you made so we spoke that look I read this Rama and the cousin ish follows this between two Eden there is no tomorrow study how did that is the supply get between me and my childhood so the flavor there's no deal Amakusa denotes that the Ezzor God the true formation but it's really was before in that fuser mitts Allah kind every I may say that so you got to put that into the into the equation there's a Mitchell the kind of REM ace if somebody signs a secular will so it could be binding because of Mitchell okay and debris I'm ace even if it's connect the Halawa that's the question that's the whole question these are my host Athena legal back in there but it's you like I woke up mitzvah kite mitzvah like I am did a I'm Mary and I'm not gonna get in more than that it's a big topic it's a children from the receiver you need a license are you a lot of do real estate without a license I mean they definitely have the rights and the commerce they have the right to put rules hired the officer I don't know if we need to put propose yourself as a broker you know I broke they do it let me people do it whether they work us as a broker are you allowed to do it if you don't have a license legally you're not allowed to make sense that it's these allow who says you should be allowed to do it now let's go back to the recycling okay you know the oldest thing was when we were kids the jaywalking all right the jaywalking they hold its officer in it's it's still in the books I think well they still rights on the books the jaywalking but you don't get a ticket for let's talk about are you a lot of speed a lot of speed there's nobody on the road are you a lot of speed now if you somebody else on the road and you're also speeding in a way that you're putting yourself in danger you're Russian or it's a us so to remember that I didn't say you're a lot of overly speed but you want to go over the speed limit so if Sheinberg does that sound it's a famous actor of Sheinberg and he says that they only ticket i came up to ten money yeah unusually ten miles so till ten miles you're allowed to go because they don't ticket that camera fifty-five they don't take it till 65 65 you're not allowed to go but only what they because they ticket huh huh that's do the enforcing that's where the enforcing comes in all right so here's really my shine when they tell you 55 it's really because they want that you should 65 but they've did you can tell you 65 go sadly all right so they tell you 55 or maybe even 55 disaster but they want they said normally okay so this has becomes a shiloh when they enforce or where they don't I'll give you a good example are you allowed to build Asuka in the front on government in this street you're not allowed to but they don't say anything they give you a week to the exact Widow and wink wink you have a week to take especially if you in Williamsburg right that that's the point the point is is there a problem of who says Dina you're not allowed to do it you know you don't even realize that in Jackson there are additional yeah you now let her have a suck in your backyard zoning was and it was a big Schuyler what do you do Wow huh all right now you're starting to understand here do you know who sadena maybe I shouldn't maybe I should find the place to put up my sukhothai my porch huh so one thing I could tell you I don't think they employ I don't think they're gonna come in and stop you so then again it has to do with will they enforce it or want they enforce all right are you allowed to claim bankruptcy it's an old Schuyler right it's like the cop who told you go please not guilty you won't get points I thought I'm trying to tell you I yeah I'm just bringing up how you see this is a relevant Schuyler if you take it seriously nama kusa Dena now are you a lot of climbing let's go fits this fits a a lot of claim bankruptcy well however you should never have to you should all be ziko you have a broccoli ready while we're at it okay now I do want to tell you there's something called a Siddall about life people don't know this it's a crush mr. zimit south of Zion but if a guy can't pay we make a repayments in there is something called the payment plan that you can pay it over a certain amount of years it's called seed or Lebel clay but you're not Potter you're not that you don't have to pay it ever so the question is bankruptcy you say I don't pay enough to pay you I don't have it goodbye and good luck so receiver tamesha's that's a very famous chuva says you're allowed to clean bankruptcy and even though and how long do you owe the money to the guy and we know that there's no ball there's no Dena Mahoosuc an egghead I love that are you but here there's a lock why because Dean about who's in business there's a concept of Dean atomic Husa commerce either because you accept to do business in the land as the business rules or Allah Meister they have some kind of kayak and even the credits or even the credit sir you're not happy with the sack what is book to me there's no push it it depends on what side you're on it's very positive when you're the guy claiming back brother this guy the creditor inside a party except that we say the creditor accept so that's a pity I don't soap on it was a big tumble for many years ok let's move on price regulations that's what Palmer to Eden no to Eaton to God and putting their rules are there rules they then cotillion claim bankruptcy that's the Shila how about you never happen price regulations price regulations the government tells me I can only sell this for a certain amount there is such a thing still today or it's really that employ doesn't apply so much okay alright let's talk about I give this immaculate late payment late payment there's a clause there's something called the late claimant clause okay so you signed in the contract it's part now let me tell you a big rule a lot of times you're gonna scream how raucous Medina mokou-san go to delete IRA read the fine print of what you signed remember that that's a lot a lot of times you're gonna calm actual this and this and screaming yelling the beard you sign things when you sign certain things so the question is late payment I think is in the contrast some of them have in the contract what happens if it's not in the contract so there's an interesting cognition those in the lucu Tim so cuz it says between two evening it's not binding so if they get a common claim there's a late clause there's that and I'm sorry Dena mahu sadena does not apply between two Eden okay you know let me tell you when you find something you need to return it Ishod Vasavada what happens if it's a Nagar ish neighborhood and I believe to me rayvon but the law is that you have to I mean the laws he had were doesn't make a difference American law after return what I mean I there's laws you find you have to return right yes okay but if you get caught it can be a force what I mean it's not enforced - they can catch you I'm silent it's not gonna for they don't care how about you found it it's a needs and it's after years it's after you still are locked it's yours it's yours yeah let's say there was I say if she knew us but in America we love to return okay so let me tell you an interesting thing before you get to your story you return it to the gut to the police guess what's gonna happen they can enjoy it that's that that could be a putt that could be somewhat of a header not to return if you know that it's kataka get back to the guy who lost it then an economy but if you return it they don't know who it is you know where it's going Kalavati it's going into the back of the over there with the police and then in a box somewhere okay they're never gonna get find the guy and it's never returned it what I mean by good well you have what means little civil and if there is and if there is a name of course you have to return the laws of the land you have to return it with me some guy leave something in your and your watch you call it and your taxi of course you have to return it I mean okay let's talk about that's the nation on let's not talk about that I don't want to get involved but I could just tell you that a big part of that soldier is no Dina the mouth Kusa oh yeah I will talk about it I don't want to get vaccinated to talk about vaccinations well I could tell you you know they always say that they can't force me you hear why because of pikuach nefesh right and plumbing PMI shamily kappa that's their big yeah i don't have to vaccinate i'll say come TMI Shamu wake up well Shamu protect me maybe do the other way around maybe take the vaccinations and you know and I shall protect you from that from that how do you know which sad the economy I'm not saying it please don't get me involved it's about cupon and i just want to tell you that dean of the mouth who stood Deana is very relevant finally Estella at 10:15 that was the cutoff time I learned over the years how to do it exactly all right grab Lisa let me give you a story all right you want to say let me let me let me let me just end with the following cuz I like I said I want to keep to the 10:15 cutoff point my session when we got married originally many many years ago we lived in easy miss apartment I don't want to tell you happy to been in Queens and a good neighborhood in Queens in cube are nice galore we had a lot a lot of hockey no so sorry a lot of unwanted guests all right extermination and extermination and now who pays for that exterminate who has - is it the landlord or the person the time the guy who was living there so Tommy the Dina DeMarco Sabina is that's right everybody knows that anybody who has one of these apartments knows okay iron box if you don't know and you go but you forgot that's the real story you forgot okay so let me just tell you I was by rakaats grew up at the time and there was such a big thick waffle in mom it's a high get even the mice them something to kill each other so much it was so nice in the time ice there was nice as overnight mice and then who has to pay and how am I gonna and it was a it was a lot of money all right and they were both younger like the tenant usually is also you're okay kid sir so the guy came and claimed the mother said Dina you got to pay for it he came back and he said that's what your ruff said I went to my Grove something my roof yeah my rub said that I'm not looking if the pay I said well I'm a Cornish poppy initially I met this rough and I set him to tell me did you really say and I'm cleave to let the owner delaila not Maliha did you say he says yes or no I I wasn't sure exactly and if I did say it's a now okay which means yes he learnt already is to plead the fifth all right I tell him wanting me but there's been in the mountains sabina see he says to me in that is look we are you living are you living where are you which punch are you living in the Dina look who's that apply to you he says to me let's do I'm Marcus Medina there's no halakhah because you Wilma Kabul on yourself and therefore that's part of the cup if your Makabe on yourself not to follow in business steena the Maheu sadena that's the rule you accountable that's what you McConnell on yourself that's what I said I'm just telling your story oh but then you have to pay for it - why let's talk a minute if it's if it's Marcus Medina you could always come and say it's not me it's you I was after we're all in this there is such a halakha it's not the time to details of this point all I'm trying at is that he was explaining that sometimes when you do business and it's understood that we're not gonna follow Dina tomorrow Cedeno meaning both of them I love you finished on the ship side I wish you all right yes maybe different maybe different point day which I say is you can't scream beat them up who Sabine if you if you kill yourself to get to the if I might clear advice you love