Likkutei Sichos Vol 10 Vayeshev 2 Rabbi Leibel Schapiro, 5781

you know here the tsukim talk about irudan tomor and it says after his wife passed away and tomorrow already had left because she first was married to two sons of yehuda and they they both died she left back to her father's house and then the posix says i read the positive not this positive the first possible possible day says to to be there when they share the sheep of his to be there to watch and she says he went up to him and then the next boss says like you got the summer layman it was behold your father-in-law is going up to timnot to share his saying so she went and made up a plan how to meet him et cetera et cetera that's the first thing so the left we're going to talk about the second so you got the thomas and the second project where we said that it was told to tomorrow that etc and what's that cetera that he's going up to mighty grash from that position quotes the the words it says she went up to timnot explains like this basically russia asks akash later on so here it says went up there it says it went down and this is the same city so was it high up in the mountain or was it down in the valley did you go down in our plastic his mashem it was going up and there it says he's coming down answers it was the middle of the slant of the mountain that was the middle of the mountain in the middle of the slant of the mountain if you go for one side you'll be going up you could go from up down because the city is in the middle of the mountain so sometimes if you go from one to side you're going down if you go from the other side from the lower part from the rec even part and you're going up to the mountain team are you going up because it was in the middle this russia answers this theorem so the third problem you have to understand like this is this question comes up on the previous possible the game of thrones the previous posters i read before it says that he went up to timnot and and he says in the order that russia says that the ghost on tim on the city because the other fortune like nezra learns that vayal doesn't go on him going up it means going up to see the sheep how they shoot a sheep but rashford learns vayal goes on the team now so rash already the position already said that they were going up the team though he should have said this cash over there the first time it says that hey the best here it says going up and by only things that somebody who learns that will have a question so all the rashes are to explain what is not something that's not understood in this process doesn't do that in other words if russia does do it it's usually the second time when you have a positive here which makes sense then when you come later on to opposite which contradicts oh russia but when russia doesn't answer that question before because in this position at this moment there's nothing hard therefore in our case exactly itself there's nothing nothing not understood to tell me but there is akasha you could ask from apostate and he him shifting where it says that's what you say we already learned that is going up but not here should only do it over there you learn both learn this but now you come to the second place and now you compare it and obviously the rebel always says that the talmud must be a good head that rash is written talmud that remembers everything so he remembers that so he has a good question over there should say it but russia over here has no reason to because in this project there's nothing hard third gosh we know that russia is medium to every detail so why does russia have to be mighty for lamer he says when he asks the contradiction he asks that by shemshin it says this seems to be extra maybe russia brings that post again in that post so from that we already know word responsive is written that you're going down to tim or your mastery would have been enough he would say simple very short kamehameha would have said like this here it says and it says another position so besides the cashier why is he asking the spirit here that's a different problem but even if he is asking this theory here why does he have to mention that by simpson it says in other words if russia if the posse wouldn't save a yada chimchi if he wouldn't bring that bossie then maybe russia would have to say where it says because we don't know where the positive is tasha can't just say some other place it says i mean maybe he could but it's not so proportioned because you wouldn't know where to find other passage but since rashes said quotes the possible it's available so we know it's hirida so why does russia have to start off by saying this discussion russia asks here that the the city of timno is a contradiction of sukhim the gemura has the shiaway actually but cinema giveaway satan gives three to discussion number one shim shin shin is ghana shimshin that when he went to timno he was embarrassed with it which means girish rashford says pleased him he married daughters of pleasure which he was not allowed so sin is going to steam that caused that so that it says it which means that the word vader doesn't mean physically going down but yet it means he was going down in massive his situation in status in rochester [Music] one answer basically that bashimshin the yeah that doesn't mean he went down physically went down in rukhnis that we do find actually that the world too one was in the helicopter one was in the helicopter and there were two cities there's no problem and think about answers one was up almost down the third terrace is cognitive no we're talking about the same thing the one the awesome if you come from one side it has to be going down which means it was in the middle of the mountain if you're coming from the top of the mountain to get to timnots you have to come down because it's in the middle of the mountain if you go from the other side on the floor you got to go up and that's basically the tenants that the russia brings the third shot means physically it means in massive situations he went up and down russia brings it many times russia brings this idea that it could mean going down in massive it could be aliyah going up in mata we find that so if russia brings it into different places you could say it the second shot where it says you could say it's a very easy thing it's very simple it could be two cities the same name especially that we do find actually that they were taking two cities so why does russia not give any of those truths when he picks the third edit that it was in the middle of the mountain and he had to go up from one side and go down the other side especially the fact that the first fruits the other two truths are before these last that they're closer to the what the meaning of the posix seems to say than the third one because that's why they're first and then the order says that even if it's a first shot it means it's closer to the positive because it's closer to the shot because russia is shot but the gemara is not shocked but still it's understood that anything that fits more to the positive mother would bring it faster even though it's there in canada who says everything absolutely brings the last status which seems to be the least connections master of the order to the simple chat of the puzzle nevertheless russia chose this shot so he's asking why is this shot better even just looking at the team especially that they're better they look seem to be better because the mother brings them first sabir because the answer goes like this explains this is not interested mainly to answer the contradiction that by yehuda it says the word and it's contradiction for the lotion that's not what russia is mainly interested why like he said before shayna talmud talmud who learns this russia has no idea that there's a contradiction because he didn't learn the other passage yet so this is not mainly what russia is trying to say there is a question that russia has and the word themselves in this posing when it says he's going to tim the cash is like this is why does the when it says he went the team let's say he was up like this there's no problem let's say help me there's a mountain so you have to go up but why is it important that you have to go up to timnah why does the positive pick that claim it means like to the story that they told that he's coming whether they told her he's going up or not after my daughter came the equipment's going to be the city that you have to go up to the mountain well why would they mention it he said any difference maybe what difference does it make uh as we find some is not to explain the style of going how you were going if you're not it's not important you don't need it the theta doesn't mention it here's an example we find that we ill earlier because whatever is written earlier so that we could refer to atomic talmud learned already says take them up to one of the mountains now when it says take him up to other mountains so some people would think means bring him up as a curtain doesn't go on going up to the mountain but the river here brings if you look in russia you bring him up to the mountain but not that didn't melee bring him up as a corbin so there the tater says bring him up to the mountain and still because of then it says later in the prosecutor it says he went to the place and then he said they came even though they were going up they were taking haram when he took him to the kids it was going up it doesn't say but tampa is a portion the reason is very simple what difference does it make how he got there so oprah you have to go up or now number two but the trailer doesn't tell us tai chi zoo is how the trip was if it's not the gate to the indian see the fact that in the positive value to the one in the mountains that ever says in the order of 14 why does the posix stay there take him out to the mountain whatever says there it has to say since he wants to tell him it's a mountain goat so then when you say go when someone says go to the mountain how do you speak go up to the mountain because we're telling you where to go go to a mountain of the mountain but when we're telling you go it happens to be that you're going on a mountain would we have to tell you got to go up and therefore done so here too looking also since there is no specific reason why to tell that that he was going up that yoda was going up the team knows however the lamborghinis that you got the thomas heard they would tell her that your father-in-law hey listen she's going to find him on the way okay jacob why is it important for the tater to write ayla because the word ayla seems to be telling us something in other words you see sometimes the the shyly is on the pausing why does it say extra words it could have said here it's not like that halo canelo would be the same amount of letters is the same but hailer is the standard lotion if i tell you go someplace go i thought you know someone is coming ayla is already going up saying something specific so normally the standard lotion would be say if it's not negative how you're going go he's going going on you go why would we special go up even though the pale is going up but that's not the standard lotion but if i stress the word that is going up that means that there is something special in the idea that is going up but the question is here well what's so special about going up all she had to already told her that he's coming to tim doesn't go meet him there whatever you want to do so therefore russia has akasha so it's not that bothering russia russia has the possibility not he has a problem and russia doesn't provide the kashi like russia usually does not russia usually does not write what the cash is russia when he brings up and he touches in most cases he doesn't bring the cash after you read the russia you figure out yourself what the kasha was so here ashley doesn't write this this cash is something that you can figure out yourself there's a problem here why does it possible now this will explain why russia didn't ask the shy land the previous passage where it also says there up and here it especially makes sense in the beginning that this portion of the theta it says you'd have went down from his brothers it means he left his brothers says what does it mean he went down that the brothers lowered him from his greatness in other words he was before that the king of the brothers and after they sold the a7 they saw how their father was so upset and it was yehudah's idea to sell they lowered him in his madrega even though simple it means he went down in physically no rashes says not now oh yeah stop stopped at lehman it would make sense abraham was there that there's a continuation to that that he went down in this madriga so now it says thomas and his favorite museum the story of thomas that came out of it why does it say because so the previous process where it says dasha has no kasha why dictator stresses vayal theta wants to tell you when the brokens say you're talking about in the previous process which says means like a third party but they said [Music] talking to us about so it's like a third there's the traitor telling ghost what yehudah [Music] in aliyah and his madre is like the mother says yeah sadiq and children et cetera et cetera so the traitor could do that so when the terror tells us about yehuda so the terror is telling us so that there tells us physically things what he did repeating what someone told her not to talking about somebody of the tater talking about the tate is telling us you know what people told her and the traitor is quoting the statement of what the people told tumblr behind the expression that the people used when they told this the tumor had what do you think the guy in the city there knew what's going to happen later that he meant an alien they came in if so because of this that we asked before why it says ayla when he went to team the west nigeria was going up and came and made this that's where the kashic comes so this answer we asked you before why does russia explain this at this point not on the preview the grievance on there's no question they could learn very simple the traitor says he went up and did the potatoes telling us yes it's no problem but now that we're saying in this process we're repeating potatoes repeating what the people said said here we have akashi the people don't know this that they had on the liberals now someone might ask at this point i'm just saying uh kasha that people may ask but if the tate is quoting what the people said to her maybe the people said it they didn't mean anything they meant gosh me so they were not so when people talk you think they're careful in every word samadhik though kasha is in the theater with everything he's medulli why do you stress aliyah but what people speak so the terror is quoting what people spoke what people told her so they used the lush nailer happened to be going up there whatever so what's the problem why can't we say that that's though and you don't need a reason why they said daily but i understand that even the tater quotes what people will say dictator will only take out the words of what they say what's negaye i'm sure when they spoke to they didn't say just these words and that's all he said call me it didn't say a word before i'm sure they sat there you know he's coming all kinds of and the tater picks only those words which are negated to know but it's quoting them so if the traitor said this and i'm sure they said going up he's going why would they have picked the word ayla assembled the theta is trying to tell us there's something there and you can't say that the reason is because that's what they spoke and you can't say the reason is because that for sure they didn't have a mind and we're talking about what they said to her and the terrorist media this is what they said there that's what ash has a question to answer that's what russia brings in the contradiction not that russia's bothered by the contradiction here so in order to answer the question why the possible so russia says like this in other words by he says answering the contradiction that will answer the real question we have here and what was the answer that says he went up to they were going up for one second going down from the other side basically there are two ways to get to you know that's what we see from the contradiction and that will answer the positive white white that will answer the question why the posing here says that people told her that it is going up um now that we have and the fact that we have listed that we have to say one is going up on two ways there so now that we know there are two ways going to tim no but there is so you can go from the top of the mountain down you go from down up soro at me evolution they love them so that takes away the kasha why they people told her your father was going up and the tighter brings it so the taylor's medallion they spoke and they said going up he's there and now we understand because that's negative to what they were telling her what were they telling her that you have a way your father-in-law is going and you could meet him now since they had two ways to get the team though how would you know which way he's going so they had to tell him he's going on the way up they had gosh a zoo yo the torment by distress that going up tomorrow she'll be able to meet her meet him so the answer why it says ayla is because it's negative what they were telling her they were telling her we're to meet yehuda and they were telling us he's going up but how do we know that this there are two ways which the answer is akasha why it says going up that's because there's a there so this theory is just an introduction to understand why it says here that they told her he's going up he said that's why and understand why national doesn't pick the other answer that the mother gives that there were two cities called team though is only because like we said before if you're going to give the answer that you could have two ways one it was in the middle of the mountain you could go up and could go down so that answer answers why there's that shot and that answer in this theater answers why here it says since it was in the middle of a mountain you've gone two ways this explains why they had to hint and tell tomorrow his point is to answer the question but he does answer this theory that's why if you look at shift in russia doesn't say this doesn't ask the state it doesn't answer it and over there is the place where you should answer it because there are we know this politics but the bottom line is whatever reason russia already answered it here for other reasons because he wanted to answer the word but since he answered that he doesn't have to answer the the street over there so that's only answered if you say it was in the middle of the mountain lakota and if the answer that there were two team notes you could also answer the same thing the two teams should tell which team not to go if they would tell her you know your father-in-law is going to team now but there are two team notes you have to know which way says no no i dilated this won't be so answered the ef and it seems like one team that was on top and one team that was on the bottom the two teams and they would then maybe she they said hey let him know so to tell you that he should realize she should realize which team that he's going to so you could answer saying two team nurse and we understand why they said ayla because they have to tell her which mountain which one is going the one that's on top so he says it never says no because number one lay bait because there is something if you want to show which city it is the way to say which one it is if one is on top one is on the bottom you don't say go the difference is only go up or go down keem sonam there's another possibility by a different city so that's how you say so they would want to tell her that the one on top you say go to basquiat an alien go here it says go to the stimulant that's the way you say it that's the way the names of the cities are also but you don't say a top and the bottom so the eight other places we find that when city is on the top once at the bottom you refer to it this is the top one this is the bottom one because one but not you say go just by saying go up or go down there's a second sweater since the one that was telling it to her just gave the name that's all marshmallow in the smoking sophie his mash me that there was no place to uh they didn't tell the word steam though it's mash that they're it's not because there was exotic with another team because only one was closer when they said going to team they're like when you live in a city close to a certain city and you say go to a place like let's say go to here to florida and there's another fourth quarter they'll create some place fire and you don't have to say you say go to bulgaria no everyone knows it means this one. so here by the fact that they didn't give any other simon him just by saying go to timna you would know which one it is but you don't have to say go up he's going up so in order to tell us which team node is and another things if there is no spotter if there are two teams for sure they will not close one to another in canada idea lazy if they're not close there's no need see i don't know exactly what the difference in base and gimbal that since they're two and they're not close to each other so there's no need to be media to which one he means by saying ayla because normally you do what you say like i said before you say go to go to the city if it's close to you is that city you mean that city you don't have to give any any but so this is what he says given what he said in bases that we see it from the words of the person that he didn't say any so aside from the words of the guy who said he said going to him that shows that there is no suffix which one that is and also since they were not close because we wouldn't have two cities closed the same name so since it was not closed so there's not even a need to do it not only from the words that's probably the difference in base and cable basis only from the words of the of the guy who said it we understand that they didn't have to say which one it is and certainly don't have to because without the guy saying it without the fact that he said that lotion because if it's far away you don't have to say we understand clearly that when you're saying go to the city we mean the one that's close okay so maybe we understand each other we understand why russia brings the cash in here we understand why russia doesn't bring the other truths that doesn't sound right but not because of what it says here which is there just add some zach how could it be not so rare to build a city in the middle of a mountain and he explains why yes we understand some people build a city on top of a mountain why no big showing even though to build a city on top of a mountain is very hard it's very hard to bring up the the material for building the city of vedasham to work on the top of a mountain is very hard it's the mouth the city is the top of a mountain it won't do such good business but if your city is on top of a mountain who goes there who's going to go there except it's very hard to walk up in the top of the mountain so it means that not too many people are going to come here so if not people are going to come here why would a person build a city on top of a mountain so why would people it's hard to build there and it's hard to do business there why would people do it sometimes we forgo these problems people choose to build on top of the mountain for protection from an invading army the best place to have a city in the top of the mountain it will always have the upper hand against a war against the enemy that will fight king the enemy is going to be down and you're up you'll always have the upper hand so sometimes people would choose to build a sea in top of the mountain we understand yes there are some people will build it at the bottom of the mountain even though it's not so easy to protect it but because it's a better place to make business and it's easier to build some people will do that so we have reason for some people to build a city on top of the mountains sometimes and the development is not so good because it's not on the bottom it's after all higher up so you still have problems of schlepping the stuff and people not coming there how many are going to be messiah doesn't accomplish protection from the enemy because then it make it come from the top and you'll be in the bottom so what's the purpose why would people do that but h different on the top of the mountain this the houses are one on top of another we see that different places so that's not such a convenient thing so why in the world would people if you build on top of a mountain so you have on top of the mountain all this is the people hold the house but it's a middle middle you have to build a house on top it's it's some others have to do that bishop being a city in the middle of the mountain is not a common thing you're talking about so it's more sense to say we would have said it's been easier to say that grandma's team that was on top of the mountain well the father was based out of shayna's how we're going to answer the two contradictionless contradictions that we find one place down if it's on top of the mountains always you have to go up so you could say let's means that one place where it says up going up means one thing and one place where it says going down me something else the call had within you because each time it means according to what the theater is trying to tell and explain like this you could say like this when it says like we said before because the prosecutor is not talking what the trader says the talk what the people said when the people said he's going up them up to tim not they didn't mean they didn't know so that means very keep shooters it was on top of the mountain he went up the launch says going down there he's talking about it went down so when the tail is telling us what happened to shimshin yeah the tater knows what's going to happen to him and the tail meant going and it we would have said that such a shot and there's a mile in this shot over the shot that was in the middle of a mountain because it makes no sense to build a city middle of the mountain so the mail of what is the shot here we would we could learn that by it was on top of the mountain that some people built a city mountain and shin and the yehuda went up pushing the mountain that's what's over here and by shimshon that says they ate it he's not talking about he's really going in the same city going up but it says it because he could say it because it's not someone talking to the traitor the posting is not telling us what someone said the shimshin the this shot and russia still like actions have to say that the shot is that it was the middle of the mountain in spite that it's not common we asked takashi why does russia and he quotes one posse but he says you should know that it's so we must say it must mean on top of the mountain and here by yehudah we're saying it definitely means going up to timno them struck him that there were team now one is up on one or the middle and you have to go up and that's one from one side you have to go down and once i get to go up the motor there gives an example of of a certain city which was the middle of a mountain so the episode why does he might have to give an example here maybe for this reason because without an example it's hard to say so the mother says no we find it happens it does happen it's not common it's rare but it happens so here also it happened must be we must stay because there's no other way to answer the contradiction and since that's the only way to enter their contradiction so now we know why it says here ela because since this from the contradiction we understand that there were two ways to get to team from up or down and she wanted to meet yehuda so they had to tell her which way is going so they said he's going oh so she knew where to stop and we're to catch him that on the way up she would stop him says who could go up on the mountain of hashem so on that post it says actually it says another also serving hashem is like going climbing a mountain and you do or we know the kasha oh there are tapas veiler where someone climbs the mountain he actually the house you can't stop in the middle of the going up the llama is already middle of the slant of the mountain you're going up you go up halfway you stop there you can't do that it's almost impossible shall you make it if you stop it's almost impossible you won't fall so what do you have to do and all of you have to come if you start going and you're going in the middle there you can't stop you got to go up if you don't continue up you'll fall and since hashem is compared to a mountain climbing that you always have to go higher and that must be laid down not only because the person should always get better someone says every person always has to go higher and get better but it's not only for that reason also today lefty actually looks how you need it to make sure you don't fall see according to the first thing is if you don't go up which is not good because you shouldn't be going higher but if you don't go higher you'll stay you're stable you are you're missing out going higher but the emphasis is no it decides that you're going to fall behind stopping by but you should never be satisfied with the aliyah how high you came till now stopping here as satisfied with the aliyah yesterday and not going from a higher to next madriga say foreign the reason is because you always have to go higher with kedashiv therefore according to this neighboring base that's in the second day you didn't add another one so what's the problem so you didn't go higher you didn't add more he says no leisure it's not only that that day you didn't advertise all of the kadashi by angelo you didn't go hiring the government the day before and the shade if you didn't add one the second day you're missing wait why am i missing i didn't do leslie yesterday why am i messing with it yesterday should i keep my behavior if you didn't do this either of adding another one you're missing yesterday yesterday the first day to light one candle is the top top header there's nothing more mood so yesterday you did the top either today if you only lit one you did like yesterday but you didn't do that either same thing third day if you like to the third day yesterday you did the hither today you're doing the same thing yesterday but today it's not either so you're missing yesterday yesterday what you did was a heater today you want to do today with the same heater of yesterday you have to go up so here we see that if you don't go up higher you go lower even if you're stopping and you're not doing less not doing less than yesterday yesterday two you're late to doing two he's still missing because yesterday the two was the hidden room says why does it say by team no one plays going up and one place going down because it's the middle of the mountain the mountain is going up the middle of the mountain is means in middle of going so what russia is saying it's all going up or going down there's no stopping that middle of the mountain so it's up or down so that's why this bossic teaches us that there is such a thing as the middle of the mountain which is mountain is available and there is when you get to there's a middle and rashi says the middle is going up or down because if you stop in the middle of this you're going to go down unless you're going up and just like that when you went up in because he was the great-great-grandfather of that says allah periscope it says the when the breaks through the borders will come up so just like over there by yehudah he went up the mountain so brought you he brought the child parrots and paris is going to be vegas to the fulfillment of the promise it says the helpers will come up in the mountains so this is ms opinion that by a mountain if you come to the middle of the mountain you can't stop and not go higher because you'll fall lower it's only either and you always have to go up and it's connected to handicap that we see always have to go higher and it's not not only you didn't accomplish going higher you didn't even reach the level that you reached yesterday that means you went down on the level that's not how hero would take from here okay