Chanukah: The Imponderable of Rav Yehoshua'le M'Kutna

this torah class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay marver abbas i want to tell you a lambda sha imponderable from the say for yeshuis malcolm who wrote do you say for yeshua's my grandfather told me that his grandfather somehow was involved in publishing the safer not sure how exactly but rishon mikola was one of the great kharifem in poland and he was nifter in the year and he was born in 1821 in platsk in poland and the rim said about him that any city any generation that has show me is uh not a door yasayim in 1885 together with his son-in-law vox and he accomplished very much he came back to poland ultimately and that's where he passed away well habishow mikuna has a very interesting question and it's really an imponderable um and it's it's something that's very difficult to to wrap one's head around and come up with a a conclusive answer to but that is the the rahman pascal's like this nikomaru says that a person has that money he should sell his garment to purchase their hanukkah so if you have a jacket and you don't have uh money to purchase narconica so you sell the jacket to buy the narcotic very good maybe maybe not but now hanukkah you have to it could be a pesach nowhere does the gemara say you have to sell your clothing for near shabbos you don't know shabbos doesn't have pursue menis even though there's a juvenile why not you're being mufasa in the biggest miracle in history brian but it could be that doesn't need person because that the agreed to that it's hashikaka protest that needs a person but anyway pastor says you only have to sell your clothing for hanukkah and not for nervous uber the gemara says that if you have a choice you only have money for their shabbos which is adif their shabbos imagine a guy who has no money so he has a jacket so he sells his jacket to buy a candle what's he buying the candle for but now that he has another hanukkah if the gemara says they have a choice between hanukkah and their shabbos you know but then now i didn't have to sell my jacket in the first place so what does a guy do who has no money and now it's friday nights right before friday night and i understand you have to sell your jacket for now hanukkah now it's shabbos i don't have to do it for shabbas so should he not sell the jacket because you don't have to sell your jackfruit no shabbos should he sell the jacket use it for hanukkah and but the kumara says we only have one candle use it for their shabbos so that's the question that's the imponderable again upon so what in the world does a guy do who doesn't have money and now it's not it's their uh hanukkah coming up and they're shabbos does he sell the jacket and use it and then use it for their shabbos or does he not sell it in the first place or does he sell it and use it for nakanika so there's three options you sell the jacket for hanukkah but now that you have it you use it for near shamans one option is you sell it for hanukkah and i don't have to use it for their shabbos because it's only if i have a candle nor shabbos is other but not if i sold my jack or now i don't have to or i wear my jacket to show and i don't light anything those are the three options that i'll let you think about once we're at i'll tell you one more question ravi show let me cut on hanukkah is my apparently has a different methodology the rama's methodology seems to be kashivos so you have yom kippur you have purim and then you have chanaka kara voice i wish everyone an amazing childish guy you've just experienced another torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com