Challenging Shome'a Ke'one Questions - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] uh [Music] [Applause] on the notes this is this one up here every word of the yeah the seeker you definitely have to hear every word okay so we learned hashem that for most mitzvahs almost all myths you have to have a deburr and a diva has a certain connotation it has to say the words here is not khadibur and usually is not working for mitsu unless a person ever has no other choice the question of today was chemekena how does that how's that classified so first of all jamaican is very real it's we said it's even mitzvah boy because he's listening but how it works so that the two main shot him which might be one but or both either yates with yoshimiya so there's two currencies of dieber and smear or more than that by listening you get his mitzvah with all the he during therefore the cs kapayum would work because there's call ram and asera is transferable because you get the full mitzvah just like you get the mitsubi kiddish as if there's a cause when a person needs shame then it can't be it's so if he can make a brock himself an aurum who can't make a barakah it can't be a chameleon even they'll say well the one that's making the broca's dress but if it's jamaica aina it's real a person who's in a matzah miatsoya in a machine of soya can't be making a dirty diaper typically is this is the rice of making a bracha in its presence of making a broccoli yamaka of course it's the same problem it's only said with a friar person you have no other choice but a person jamaican or listen to someone making a brah yamaka is unacceptable when a person's hands are unclean so if you can't make the bracha he shouldn't be the shame even though the mavaro's hands are clean because any solar gulf inhibits one to three eighths which is america it's very clear that you shouldn't because if you can make the bracha you can't be right with the baraka when you have to stand als abraca for example magilla so not only the shots make stands but the sea bastard stand as well that's why according to some ashkenazim or someone say or even he recorded our torah nisbet because only heroes anything beyond that is a problem there's another because that's the derek of mood by listening to bashir and therefore the derek of lima it becomes torah one of the wonderful listeners asked me he went through the share for many years and he finished or even but he never learned to gemara he just heard it can you make a see him is that enough of a siem tapata uh tinus bakaryam or siam on the night of the under nine days he answered absolutely because he listened to me even if it's not the real jamaica arena but it's definitely a physical in it and that's the tourist halimut a next question if a person is in a place where he can't learn because his preachers at magola so he can't learn he could definitely think in learning and he could even listen to a recorded cheer because there as long as it's not dibor anything less than deep was neither rebecca we even had a stuff it could be could even listen to someone saying because it's still not deep or but certainly almond says that looking in as safe as mother whatever is not a halal says when a person focuses some place is looking at a gemura then it's considered like like a theme as an ayam and even out of talking learning because eyes closed helps with magola so if you're learning in gemara and you keep your smear perfect you could even probably learn with the roots as long as you don't move out of the gemara listening to kids abdullah during only kadusa is the meaning but with the evidence if he heard it it would be okay kriya satoru and meshaifa does not need chemicals the same reason we are not verbal that if you listen to abraham it's like you sick or the like because half sick is totally in a physical divorce not in chameleon when a person cannot make a broken himself again he should not be listening in any of these cases when one of course should say i mean when you make up when you hear abraham that that's muslim the smear but it's not my akiv and that's why he didn't hear it he's not he's yet to be evid and the last question was an interesting question can a person hear a part of a broke up and combine it with his ending that we don't do by megillah and by someone swallowed a word you could add a word but definitely to combine two halves are not proper another wonderful listener to edit another chameleon is inshallah because the best response is that's like you answered and when you you're a good chemaya that's school of a shelters