Carrying That Is Medically Necessary On Shabbos - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] like to welcome everyone to today's sh from har on carrying that is medically necessary on shabas sponsor 718 851 8651 email is.com Smith a while ago we heard the shil from someone who had a certain medical condition and he had to carry on his person at all times medicine just in case he has an attack it was an giant attack and the question is what do he do for shabas if there's a place where there's no a today we talking about of course where there's no a is there any hat of him to go out with medicine somehow maybe with we had a sh that has a very severe allergic reaction to some foods or to a be bite and he has to carry at all times an EP an EP pen it's called epip pen which basically if he has an attack and he can't breathe it opens the passages and P could save his life but then again it's shabas and a third child that really was interesting this could be in a gay if someone has intervenous or he has a any type of uh feeding tube so typically they attach him to the machine when necessary but to make it easy at all times what's called a port basically it's attached to the place where the where the insulin or the feeding tube goes goes into and that little piece of plastic is attached to his his goof at all times so if he whenever he needs insulin needs um the feeding tube they attach it and again it's something that stays 24/7 is a to go out with her on chabis cuz basically it's functionless so the truth is it's easy for us to say don't go out stay home but tell a person for the rest of his life he's on the house of rest on chab and is not the right thing if if it's not the right thing besides the fact that he's missing to he's missing but it's also very detrimental to someone's Health when he can't do what he wants to do but it's not worthy because there a talking about a different things something that's a person and say this alone that he can't go B if someone loses social life even for shabas because you can't do it that's a terrible tar so here we have I guess the two superpowers we're talking about a person's health which is so important we're also talking about theab and to tell a person to stay home every shabas rest of his life is that is going to be a very difficult to accept so the question is first of all is there any because the fact that he's a you see we know that has two very big over of an average person number one says that although is very when it comes to a for he can even do a for those that have elderly parents and they have an aid a and and the parent is a so the aid could do anything the aid could cook for the person of course if it's not Bish put on Lights carry because when it comes to a even a by is across the board so we see regarding a this's one significant of a additionally a regular person can't take medication pain relief but a could so we see regarding two major there is a for so our question today is maybe we'll apply that to carrying medicine or will soon see other questions an insulin pump and and the various shist of a that needs something maybe there a special for then of course it be to go out with what he needs but maybe we could do a little better because we know we all could wear BM we all could wear why is it of course you have to wear but why is it m why is it so the explain it becomes part of the person it's B to the go so maybe we'll say that a that needs this medicine or or this pump or whatever it is and he goes with it all day seven days a week maybe becomes part of him so it comes to mind first is a another common question that comes up in different forms and that is a person that's unable to walk let's talk about an older person or a person that went through an accident and he can't walk without his can the question is is it m shabas because don't forget you know we get used to it people go with canes but he's not wearing a cane it's not a he's carrying it carrying as in what's the he to carry a can today we have the question regarding crutches for those that broke a foot have crutches today there's a more a much more comfortable way of getting around it's called a walker you push the Walker it's much easier to walk more recently they devised something a big big for those that need it uh it's called a scooter crutch basically one foot is broken one foot dysfunctional so he walks with the Healthy Foot and the other foot's on his scooter and able to walk comfortably quickly are these things mut is a wheelchair mut on chabas no doubt about it it makes it makes going a lot easier crutches is very very strenuous so again in s how could someone go in a wheelchair he's carrying the wheelchair he's transporting the wheelchair the P discuss I saw the mar writes emphatically B Simon the end of Simon y giml that for a person to bikee on chabas a healthy person he gets on a bike and he drives through the city is no doubt a because he's transporting the bike he's pedling it that's the way he moves the bike and other P say this as well a bike is a form of so why should a wheelchair be different the fact that he pushes it with his hands so he's transporting the wheelchair so here we have a beautiful sug which has again its own and that's based on says the quoting a number of a a person that's lame unable to walk on his own two feet and as thear stresses he can't walk without a cane then it's mut to go with a cane if he could walk it just makes it easier then leave it home for chabas but we see a person that cannot walk is allowed to use a cane on chabas but's even more there on this that's he got better but he's still weak is allowed to use a can on Jas oh so we see a special hat regarding a Kan he's carrying it a can to me is the worst child he's carrying a cane so maybe this to our premise when someone's a and he can't get around without his medicine or his happen maybe it's m but it's very hard to accept that or better yet it's a nice way of saying it's wrong the comparison from a cane to medicine is wrong and I'll tell you why the MS is why is a the fact that it helps him is not the stresses if he could go without the cane he can't use the cane so what's the heta of carrying a cane and writes clearly in that if he could go without the cane and he takes the cane it's a so it's not a the question is so why then is a so if you look at the rush in be perim Sim which is the m of the of he has a KAS a could take a cane a Suma who walks fine but he needs it for Direction cannot use a can the rush what's the so the rush says two key words that we're going to use for all for all of these Shas and basically since he can't walk without the can day it becomes his shoe the cane becomes his shoe why P it without the cane he's immobile he's paralyzed he can't move the cane he walks so the rush that the cane is like his shoes now the delay I found the whole list that use a better term I think and that is reg now the rush didn't use that so not saying it's better but it's easier to understand a person that can't walk but with a cane he walks the cane becomes his foot so we have the that the reason why he's m not because he's a because he can't walk without it and now it becomes part of him the blind person has Good Feet him it's no NOA what's Tak the of shoes what's Tak of clothing because it's so much of importance to him it becomes bottle so the rashes that a cane that gives me ability to walk becomes his shoe becomes his foot there's no Isa wearing shoes or going with feet on chabus you can understand if he's basically okay but he takes it just to be reassured there's no why because it's not regularly day he walks without it but more so than your how could you compare a cane to Medicine the cane is his foot so it's m the medicine is not his foot he needs it so stay home and don't need it so the comparing a cane to medicine is wrong but we could do better but listen to this how every word of is so important the allows going with a cane on chabas how about crutches so all the P say if he can't walk without the crutches and the crutches are helping him walk so it's regular day I it's two crutches so if he needs two crutches that's his feet I should mention the poim say that if he only needs one of the crutches then don't take two but to take in crutches whatever he needs is regularly day now again to show out the contrast the will soon speak about it it's a per it's a PM about masks and costumes one of the examples is a person that goes in the street with stilts healthy person but he has these two sticks you know he talks about when you're going in mud could be on purm this year PM is there of shabas so shabas becomes part of PM can you go with Stills on on says no why not why is still different than crutches ter is p crutches is regularly day and still a so we have crutches and a can today they devised a wonderful help it's called a walker a walk is much easier than a can but all the and all the if you can't walk without the crutches without the Walker the same hat what's the difference it's more convenient there more there's no Isa in fact the Pim say that the the scooter should also be M them because if he can't walk without it and this helps him walk it's the same het of regular day so we have a cane crutches walker and a scooter crutch now let me show show you how the word regular day is so crucial what about someone that can't even walk with a cane he has to be wheeled in a wheelchair is it m onab to go out with a wheelchair so POS it if he can't walk without it why not say day and it's because this is the way he goes and he quotes The Rush that is min day but he takes it a step further and he says maybe C maybe a wheelchair is a better than a cane a cane he's carrying it let's be honest he's carrying it but it's m a wheelchair he's sitting in it maybe it's like a Mal Bush that encompasses him and it's more M but no doubt about it Raa holds that a yid does need a go to push him he gets in the wheelchair and he pushes himself the is reg day in fact goes so far to say that there's no heta to have a go push him around because he could do it himself if does himself it's perfectly to have a do it is certainly know have to forget to push Hima holds that a wheelchair is like a cane why have a go so that's no doubt about it that the heta of a wheelchair is saw all take the same approach a wheelchair is a new type of reg day however I must tell you there's a big and think about it it's it's quite obvious a cane is legitimate reg day cuz with the cane he walks with his own two feet that is regy day in a wheelchair he is not walking in fact wheelchairs are designed for people that don't have feet so how does a wheelchair work it transports him it moves him who said that's AA of reg day the day is that the can becomes his foot and he walks with his own two feet heard when he was confined to wheelchair so he was very positive he said wheelchair is the luxury of old age instead of struggling to get from place to place I get a shur service he gets wheeled around that's a good understanding it's not regular day he's being driven in a motorless wheelchair so the before was printed he just says don't compare a wheelchair to a cane a cane is M and a wheelchair is the wheelchair cannot become regular day and take the same approach so according to this understanding there's no het for the year to push himself the better option if it's do it we're talking about when it's not that be but the beauty of the is the word reg day makes all the difference in a simple question of a wheelchair is it regular day or not Nowa must have held that if he gets around that's the regular day medicine is not regular day now who am am but I was thinking if a person lives in a place that's not it's probably safer to have a go pushing why according to the is no good that's the only even that holds it could do it but he still is M that if a does it in a if then you have this very very challenging but so it'll be perfectly M for the to whe himself does point out two problems number one when a person is Wheeling himself and gets to a curb I guess he's talking before today's curbs are wheelchair friendly but what you doing gets the curb so says if someone's around could lift the wheelchair and put him up on the curb's carrying the real problem is when he gets to his destination let's say he lives in a walking so that's how that's good but gets to sh and it's a fly of stairs he says that wouldn't be a see has a whole if one guy picks it up partially the other guy the other way but but practically speaking the AA would be for someone that has a wheelchair and can't get it up the steps cuz you're not to carry it up the steps before shabas attach to the railing to the whatever's outside of the Sho or house a chain with a combination lock and when you get to Sho or get home you lock up the wheelchair and leave it downstairs hopefully some will help him up the steps but even the had of car caring there's no have to carrying the wheelchair up the steps and that's something you have to keep in mind in advance to work at an Nat but what what the beauty of the sug is that a crutches a scooter crutch The Walker are fine the only issue is by a wheelchair because we can't say by that according to some reg day so now what do we have we have this of reg day is very helpful in that group of questions but now our child of carrying medicine or carrying an EpiPen it has no relevance whatsoever because the EpiPen is not regular day it's very important don't get me wrong if he has an attack it's it's life and death but it's not regular the day the why don't we say that the for the Suma the cane is is a of the day but there also thing regular day we find so that's why because regular day and that's why medicine so it could be very helpful and also has its own group of is somebody ask be a very simple question he has a pretty deep cut and he has a g Pand and has tape over it is to go out with a G pan with a Band-Aid that's easy that's the everything is a little mysterious is an oldfashioned Band-Aid it also was medicated so it had a Raa so is saying you go out with a medicated Band-Aid I guess there's no problem with because maybe there's an affection I why isn't it carrying that regularly day so says it's like a jewelry now I don't know about you but why is a Band-Aid that's bloodied considered a but there's another and that's based on a mish and again those days they were very into not unconventional healing as we'll see from many garas but they would believe a lot of these Kamas these sort of Supernatural Ru so says based on a mishna you allow to go out with a certain type of grass that he attached to his person and it's there I why isn't it carrying means appr proven um charm if that's the right word but it's not again not a regular conventional healing it's a supernatural so you L to go out wearing a grass NE necklace why is that M so if you look at Rashi on that m listen to this rash is being really aggressive a little grass is not only a it's a malush again we are puzzled why is the end of also wonders why is says it's a malash and convinced it's a malush why is it a malush but wait re more another this based on a gar and again those days they were a little more into this than today you allow to go out on chabas with a which is a grasshopper egg this even more unique a person has a fox's tooth that he's wearing imagine some comes to sh shab this morning there's a fox's tooth dangling from his neck people run away but this perfectly so says it's not dark because in those days it was a all these are the most unusual is what's the ter is and this is the rash and both say that it's like a malush and a and we're puzzled so let me tell you the last and then we'll apply someone has a wound on the bottom of his foot and he's afraid to go to sh because he might step on something and might open the wound or affect the wound so he could wear a piece of he could wear a m either a coin Mish or a piece of metal on the bottom of his foot he attach it to the bottom of his foot you wear this on the underside of the foot because it's a Rua and it protects him from f the damage make up your mind what's the is it both and or maybe M protection is enough quotes that even if it's not it's doing nothing but it's protection it's maintaining what we have m is enough of a so this is really broadening the he of Rua Rua K Fox's tooth fine even fine what's theat so again what's the head of wearing a malush what's the of wearing a now you know we we live with Thea but we don't learn with theun I heard once what's the so don't have the ter is very P something that is normally worn becomes part of a person the ra has suching different a bottle to the person if it's normally one it's fine Rashi and based on the gar is expanding that to any because isn't it logical that is a bigger so any that's worn is the same of not it's not but anything that's worn has the same like a now of course you can't carry it in your hand because like a Mal has to be worn but the is we called of a becomes part of the person like a malish like a both so we have two shining examples of and oh so now do we do we find what we're looking for is that had to carry an EpiPen or medicine not push it why because the the the the fox's tooth whether we don't even though we don't believe in it today but in those days it was considered an ongoing Rua wherever he walked he had his grass or his Fox's tooth and it was constantly functioning it was giving him a RAF the even the case of mam was a constant when someone has a angina and has an attack he has to have shabas for him but when he's sitting at home he has no problem when he goes to sh he also no problem why is he carrying his medication he might need it but until he needs it it's not Raa it's not not a m a m means it's prot in him every moment he walks on the street this is just in case that's not the conventional so we learned to this but it wasn't an effort of futility we learned about regy day and we saw a number ofas wheelchair crutches scooter crutches Walker that's one then we saw Rua and will soon give examples is also mut but that's not yet the het for carry medicine so probably is is a talks very clear about dealing with if you have be ask through any and again people have elderly parents who typically are a by Sak so a guy could do whatever they need if the person wants a hot drink the guy could cook up the water then the what about a yid tending to another yid so there are a number ofas but M says clearly that for's needs a whether himself or another there's no difference for the needs with a sh for example if he needs an LED light which is and there's no go available the himself or a the family member with a sh with an elbow could put the light on the and this all the agree there's another and that's in sh not as big of says we could have a and there's no available the could do it with this a big interesting does not mention it's very rare but he says there's no doing a so he doesn't mention but he does argue but and clearly goes with this as see test so here we have a much more promising hat that if there's a that has a need either himself or a family member could do an with so now let us try to apply this if a needs medicine and let's say there's no medicine at home there not it's not a s but need medicine so a family member could go to a house next door whatever the case that it's not a a caralis will go through the backyard to a house adjoining your yard which typically is it's even though there's no and carry the medicine in a shin now a very good Shin will soon see he put the medicine in the Hat in between the lining and the had itself for medicine it works and it's a good idea we'll soon see another m w in that in that choice but more specifically talking about our who wants to go to sh wants to go to a wants to go toas but he needs the medicine at all times so the het would be to carry the medicine in a place it's only a c with a now you'll say why can he carry in his pocket already for the same money that's in the pocket Isa in the Hat is a sh now so the is because of the of the so it has to be a legitimate theim he says this only works by a place that's not carus if you're living in a big city and it's a it won't help and he also adds that the is what you need he shouldn't carry like he does during the week a pack of it and puts it in some place in in sh he doesn't need a pack of it if he needs the most one or two that should suffice now does add that if he's in a place which is he be that most of our cities are which is a great great say that but what for us when a person's in a place that's not it's a pretty straightforward to carry the medicine with a now the all the follow that lead carry with the first one that said this to my knowledge that's famous for that the Ang me giml writes the year was 199 T and the government decreed that a person must carry ID at all times even chabas if he's found if he's caught without ID he get beaten imprisoned or both and people were bewildered what he is going to soash has this the fact that it's he calls it a three the fact that it's a says going to one of his and there are three three first of all it's a caralis most European cities most small cities were caralis it's and he's carrying the ID in of I guess he couldn't put in the Hat but maybe put it in the between his shirt and his undershirt but made wondered why is he calling carrying an ID you need it to show why is and the same could be on the medicine so I saw in the pis he has a a and he says he's right because if he carried it to and he was not approached by a policeman so didn't e it if he got if he was approached by a policeman or he needed his medicine suddenly then it's m without a now but the EM is when you every moment you're carrying it he feels secure that he has it but the emus is the the angle is famous for this that carrying something to get out of trouble that's probably the but other wonder why so this might be you know so think about that but one thing one thing we have to understand which I I'm a little concerned about all these say the only is for Mitzvah going to again going to wouldn't be if needs it for his health people have to go for a walk went for a walk every single day in fact including shabas so not a stroll but Health walk I would think that's says that what needs is if he needs the fresh air he needs the emotional health so when they say walk it means a walk that's purely for the pleasure of it there is another het that many poim say when possible and I stress that because you have to be focused on doing a right let's say a person lives in a big city and it's so the whole he falls away so there is is is famously quoted as relying on this that even if you're living in a big city and carryings of but if you go from your house to without stopping anywh along the way that's called since you never stopped it's reduced to now the lumus is not for now but it makes sense you never stopped in so here if you could do it safely I quote that that's an alternative go from your house straight to the Shool and don't stop now that's good if you live in the a a suburban area but if you live in a big city something call the red light and what you doing you get to the red light you know my told me he once walking withen kski and another they're talking learning sh it was during the week and the B was very upset minded he started walking into the street when there was a red light the ruen grab says don't get killed please so here also you can't walk into a red light so to do like the joggers do when they get the red light they stay and they jump up and down that probably won't work because he stopped so the eight is keep on going around now he might get arrested for being what are you doing he's walking around so that's why it has to be practical now I did see also this is beautiful of Germany he does not talk about per se but he he has a whole stickle if and he says that they're they're based on a there's no carrying above T so that's why keeping medicine in a hat has a as a double mil besides that it's a it's also like some they are burn right away has a beautiful you want to see the he feels that the best way to carry medicine is find a place in the lining of his coat or in a tie and put it there on a permanent basis we chabas daddy says the fact that it's inaccessible cuz it's sewed in makes it sort of a bottle to the bagged it's in the pocket it's in the lining of the coat and that makes it bottle because you basically forget about it until you need it and he has an interesting which people ask me this they have a long winter coat and a penny fell from a hole in the pocket deep to the B you can't get to it he says if it's there and you can get to it it's bottle so this is his M put the the medicine in a place where it's attached not attached literally but connected to the clothing now what one thing he doesn't explain but I understand is but he has to take it out when he needs it but evidently until he needs it it's tough to where it is now as you see carrying medicine is not so P it's based on if again I'm not saying this is possible always if someone has a condition and he's moving anyhow it might be advisable to move to a place to have an AR but should avoid the problem or at least place a Band-Aid a G Pad that's that's the case of and it's m even if the the wound is healing and only wearing the Band-Aid to protect from an infection that's also the case of that but someone has a cut and it's fine but it's unsightly it's not pleasant and he wants to cover it P it for the Aesthetics of it for the kmetic purpose of it so this and that if it's attached to him that even though it's not a it's not even but it's a of his appearance so carrying wearing a Band-Aid over a wart that he wants to conceal if it's he's wearing it it becomes part of it it's not M it's not M but it's good enough someone PAB he walking he was cing he he hurt his knee and he thought you can't wear a knee brace on chabas I said what's wrong with the knee brace a knee brace a back brace a rupture belt all these things are at that's one and there's no braces or these type of things for the teeth again they're attached to the teeth they're for the teeth straighten the teeth is ongoing that's m a case of a ongoing ra the only question is is retainer now see are different types but some retainers you wear by day and take it off at night so so the says and that's if he's not wearing a day and night it's not B but I did see the says the fact that you're wearing it for most of the day and it's healing that part of the day why is that enough the only issue is with the retainers some of them when they get to a later stage they only wear when they go to sleep rest of the day they don't wear it so that's hard to say it's bot the by day the ask an interesting question which is a good better ter but the question is also valid Dentures false teeth but let's say someone takes it off at night like typically the case so why isn't the same Shila maybe it's not completely part of the person so he says that the ick of the braces of of the false teeth is the appearance and I gr quote from the Ada that the most common reason wearing dentes is the improve the apperance so once it's considered a a than even if only by day you're only in the street plus it makes it easier to to talk but the end of the day dentures are much better than than the bite plate or the retainers and that's all people have an air problem and they put cotton in their ears so says it's [Music] for wonders why is for unless he's sick so he says it's not a it's keeping out the cold a now there is a new came out of the Ki recorded them and in it says there that was not unless he attached the the cotton to his ears which I don't know how but most po can feel that if it's securely fastened in the a itself that's okay a sling for broken arm is perfectly people have a bracelet or a necklace for rheumatism so again it seems to work shabas in ladal his only problem is why but if it works it's fine an Ace bandage that's not glued onto his hand but it's attached with Clips is the same says and what's the problem there is a more of a challenging issue and this is unfortunately where people have certain Medical conditions and they must wear at all times what's called a medical ID bracelet or necklace that basically has their Vital Information the blood type their their allergies and one person I forgot the details long time ago but he said if he collapses and they treat him the way they treat a person that collapsed that could kill him he has a different type of problem that he has to be treated based on his condition and he must wear at all times a necklace that says what to do I hope the members are you know aware of that but here we have a person that must have Vital Information but men don't wear necklaces and this is not a a bracelet so the question is unlike the previous cases he's wearing a kameha which is an ongoing Rua this is not an ongoing Ru it's not even on going shme at that point cuz he's not he's not sick so here we come to a beautiful the one of the giml he lived in Vienna don't forget but he writes when I was in France when I was in France and the government decreed you have to wear a that's conventionally Ted as a yellow star this goes back a long time ago he had to wear a yellow star so I said since you have to wear it at all times it becomes part of the person and this is quoted in you must wear is as long as it's attached to the B that a Begg could go out with his ident an EV could go out with his identity why so says there a beautiful discussion and he says whatever a person wears 24/7 becomes part of him and therefore he says a this necklace this ID necklace that he wears 24/7 and in the next C he says a person that or a or some they confused they don't know where they are where they where they live who they are same hat they're allowed to wear a bracelet with their name phone number address he's very emphatic about that that that becomes part of the person of course in for the soldiers that have to wear those IDs if they need a blood transfusion and RAB Falcon is saer all say a ID brace that's wor 247 is Bott of the now a beautiful he's a little more it's page 183 says only in a but the other do not seem to be concerned about that a common question should be more common the a person's wife had a baby will call him and they give him after the birth a bracelet ID for one reason to gain admittance to the hospital you want to visit your wife or baby show your ID so that's not a malush it's not a and it's not one forever so most po hold that's like carrying a key to get into the hospital or carrying a card he's not sick now maybe shom bias is a factor but get I people go n don't worry you tell the guy before shabas or you cut up before and you hide it in the hall you get now sometimes some hospitals they put on onto you a sticker with a name number whatever it is so that I saw some more because if it's stuck on it's like the pads that the stick on if it's stuck on to be there maybe it's more bottle to the B that's questionable but that's more of a than wearing a bracelet someone asked about wearing a right Bendle on chabas so WR the Bendle during the week as we know many question that but if you wear on chabus during the week so but cut B he says hor is not it's like a from the future maybe it's only mut in a carus so I guess he's equating that with less than a item but again if you go with the that he wears it constantly it's almost the Y of the co masks during the co epidemic so a mask is not a malish and not a but maybe it's a Raa maybe even if it's not a Raa it's a and that we said is M Anda for the person that wants to wear to protect himself together with millions of people like was around the world it's easy to say that would be like one of his maush at that time the fact that it's worn by millions of people makes it more of a het the dying in his on Co Sim he add especially the fact that it's disposable so it's warn p as a ongoing it doesn't have enough of us and his bottle it this reminds me of the question about a reflector a reflector that's worn in L A so the poim hold not only you could you should wear it when it's needed and it's based on AI that call and this is a it's a very necessary so definitely during Co when someone wore a mask to protect himself is M the problem is when he's he holds I'm not I'm above it he has antibodies whatever the case is he doesn't wear it for himself can he wear it for others so here the answer is of your own is and someone else doesn't count you know someone came to for asked him tell me when you give someone a knife a sharp knife how do you give it do you hold on to the handle and he takes the blade hold on to the blade and he takes the handle so the child says I don't know but I know when we give it we hold on to the blade goes yes you're right but to be more careful not to damage Yim than be damaged himself so I'm thinking that's applies to a mask is also part of our and Tak this would be and has two M for this that for someone else is also I saw a beautiful TR he brings two garas that you're allow to wear something not to Mas someone else so either way you look at it the mask was m i some people only wearing it for the government so that we have Mar angle if there's a fine he might get I don't think get imprisoned but that would be enough of what's interesting is this discusses Mas not but in he says you can't go out with a perm costume or from which is a mask why not because it's not a malush not a and that's why on purm this year purm is Friday into shabas certainly you can't walk out with with with costumes with a mask the only thing which is probable is if someone wears a policeman's uniform so that's a for that's if he's a dresses like a vice versa fine but a regular mask just to cover the face on shabas would be awesome now the epen is a pretty simple Mas if he carries it there it's m now you can't keep it in the Hat they typically keep it in the socks definitely a shin way and that's fine now what I mentioned earlier when we began the port it's called actually the right word is catheter but the port is attached to the person and that's the way they put an in infusion IV or a feeding tube so that is problematic at first glance because it's totally dysfunctional it's not using it he's going to Sho there's no IV there's no feeding so he's carrying a port but here many says this they say since it's attached to the person and he always goes like that it becomes B I'm not sure why but he is not so convinced considered but it seems that this would be part of the person and Tak the Pim point out that that's something that's worn on a regular basis becomes part of the person and now we can say the last group which is a g for many people is the an insulin pump not just an insulin Port but they have to walk around today it's a lot of that it's much easier people have diabetics especially juvenile have this and they have a insulin pump that regul Ates how much insulin is needed and some of them even provide the insulin so it's wonderful and it's a wonderful said but it'sot say it's bottle how is something as significant as a bottle and in the page 189 feel that there's no you're carrying something of great a Band-Aid his bottle but not a pump now r whatever is a an ongoing is bottle and he's even make with this insulin pump the redeeming factor with the insulin pump is that it's ongoing it monitors what he needs and it provides what he needs so we could say it's not POS but at least else is and the is some people that have light that they can't breathe on their own and they have an oxygen tank it's not a big one it's either small that they carry in a backpack or they wheel around on a wheel but this rabash and the say it's very important but how can you be make by with a he's carrying a real important item there with the is fine but again the this is in his is as is the that if this is somehow even what you will is M the he needed a basically to record his heart activity to see what's wrong see that is more of a problem because it's not a it's it's a much ler to know what to do and also the doctors say that really you could skip a day those that needed could skip a day so that should not be warned because again it's avoidable what's what is when someone needs something and it's considered a and he's wearing that would be big for starting the world project today 100,000 Eden B will be taking part in thousands T of thousands sh throughout the world thousands of sh please me with the great expenses involved in all learning by sponsoring a share for $1,000 call 718 851 8651 or 85339 for taped we don't talk we should be seek we learn today that basically shabas is shabas but a person is a person the of is not just a it has to be somehow either a it's Mar right then M and it's part of the person that's the basic cloud stop to carry medicine if it's not is not a so what we saw basically is that this one group of of shus when something becomes regular day a cane if you can't walk without it is M crutches Walker scooter crutch I should mention even if it's not a Mitzvah if that's regularly day it's without aah you can go for stroll the wheelchair is had to look at it either regular the day or not is is it better to ask go or a y could do it but going up the steps you have to make sure that a y doesn't do that but that you have to have a go if there a which often is not a leave it downstairs and lock it up that's or any type of any type of physical or metaphysical or is okay but the het is it becomes like a and a malish or in one because it's but something that is mut the M caring medicine which is not a and it's not a you have to have a with a carry the medicine in one's hat and in a place only there the Band-Aid a pad anything that's protect someone is M even if it's not M even if it's to cover an unsightly wound it's also m a back brace a knee brace braces Dentures retainers they're all is okay a cotton in the air is okay sling for a sling is M rism um necklace is okay ace bandage is all a medical ID most certainly in a a father wearing a neck a newborn father of the newborn a an ID bracelet should not be worn if it's stuck on to his bed and he goes a whole shabas some more the right to Bendle depending when he wears it if he wears it 247 it's probably mut the co mask is M the pur mask should not be worn on Pur the reflector should be worn especially if you wear it as a belt M no the EP pen carry with the EpiPen to carry with the sheen is okay the port typically the theel is M Ivy insulin pump an oxygen tank that's a much moreish because there it's something of and some it should not be used certainly not in a