0:00 / 0:00
Can I be considered Moral without Mitzvah Observance? Your 30 Minutes of Enlightenment
269 views
In an effort to illuminate a difficult subject, we explore the moral imperative connected to Torah observance and belief in G-d.
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
so
jack decides to
go jogging on the promenade
which is right on santa monica beach i
used to live in l.a
right near santa monica there's a pier
over there people can go jogging the
weather is
almost always glorious so jack is going
on he's going early in the morning
he wants to go before those all those
annoying people on their uh
on their new fashion segues right he
wants
you know their rip sticks he's going
early in the morning jogging
and as jack goes jogging in the morning
[Music]
he looks out into the ocean and the
sun is rising and well the rising east
sets in the west
no it wouldn't be rising there rise the
other side but
either way the sun is rising it's a
glorious day
and he sees all the way out in the
distance
what looks to be a man drowning
the guy is going like this said he's
flapping him the guy's far away and it
does not look like he's swimming
and jack has this moment where he says
that guy is far i'm not sure if he's
drowning
i'm fully dressed i don't know if i want
to get wet and then he says no
got to do this i got his and he takes
off his sneakers really quick
jumps in the water swims and says he
happened to have been an amazing swimmer
in college
he swims all the way out and as this guy
is going
under he rescues him
he pulls the guy out of the water and he
sees that it is his neighbor tom
tom his next-door neighbor
was the one drowning and how fortunate
for tom that jack saw him knew how to
swim
there is no question that tom tom's body
would have washed the shore
days later and no one would have known
where he went
and jack saved his life amazing right
saving someone's life okay
a few days later jack
the great savior knocks on tom's door
tom opens up and tom says jack
my buddy my neighbor my savior my angel
come on in come on in it gives him a big
hug
come on in anything i can do for you i'm
all yours come
have a seat and jack sits down and
tom says what can i do for you you want
a coffee what can i do for your buddy
i just owe you everything and jack says
okay i'll tell you why i'm coming i'm
i'm really uncomfortable
sorry but my in-laws are coming
and they were supposed to come they were
supposed to come
later but they're coming earlier and
they're coming tomorrow actually today's
sunday they're coming monday
and i promised my in-laws that before
they come
i will repaint the guest room because
they're very afraid of the lead
in the in the walls an old house they're
very very neurotic about it and i said
i'm going to repaint it and i did not
know they were coming this early
i called up every painting company no
one's willing to send someone out on
sunday
i would do it myself but i i just can't
i just can't
i it's a two-person job is there any
chance tom
that you can help me paint this room
really help me with my in-laws and tom
says
you know i wish i could i wish i could
but of all days that you came to me
you don't know this about me but i'm an
avid golfer i golf
once a month i have this slot in the
club
and if i lit
if i don't go i you know i gotta wait a
month
and i wait all month for this and i wish
i could help you
but the t is waiting for me i'm sorry
i'm sorry okay
people over here jack saved tom's life
the week before jack is in a bind now
he needs tom's help and tom cannot help
him
because he wants to go play golf but i
don't want to go
i'm not looking at it through jack's
eyes i'm looking at it
through hovering above looking at the
scenario eyes
okay so maybe jack does expect maybe he
doesn't but
you know sort of like we called the god
view right
and the god view okay you understand the
difference between here it's not jack
it's just like he needs a favor he saved
your life
okay if a guy saves your life
and he's in a pickle that's an old
daddy word dead word he's in a pickle
he's stuck and he needs
a helping hand and you're available
technically you can miss golf for the
month and be there for the guy who saved
your life
but no you got to go golfing
[Music]
do you know do you know what we call a
guy like that he is
lacking a moral compass you're immoral
it's more than ungrateful ungrateful as
i gave you i did something nice and you
didn't say thank you
and do something nice you would be
you would be you know deep in the ocean
no one finding your body perhaps
you'd be eaten by sharks right
you're an immoral human being
okay maybe maybe i'm being judgmental of
him and maybe
golf is his life okay i i hear that golf
does that to people
that's why i stay far away right but
you're an immoral person
now now let's bring this home and this
is
this is where this is where we unload
the bricks
this guy saved his life how many times
how many times audrey did this guy's
life get saved
by by jack
well i think just the ones just the ones
just the ones
um is he going to need jack to save his
life again
right he's not going to need him in the
future he's right
that was it and yet
he's immoral so let's look
at who we are we are people
whose lives are saved every second
is your life being saved right now yeah
because your heart is beating your heart
could stop eating
you didn't pay for it i didn't pay for
it right
your your aunt your antibodies are are
fighting the good fight
right your ears are hearing pretty good
your eyes
your immune system everything about you
so the almighty
saved our lives gave us life in the
first place
saved our lives daily that's why we say
in the morning
give us he gives us life every day and
we're going to need him for the future
oh my goodness
what the almighty has done for us
is so much greater than what jack did
for tom
[Music]
daley gave us life sustains our life
we needed him to pass we're going to
continue to need the rest of our lives
and then he says you know what it means
a lot to me
to like shabbat candles well not sure if
i'm in the
one second it becomes a moral issue
some people don't speak about it because
they don't they don't they don't look at
it like this
but that's really what it is if god by
his
own definition by our definition is the
creator and the sustainer
and we are the beneficiaries
of that largeness whatever he asks
is inadequate because whatever he asks
is a a drop in the bucket
and and even more so it
it behooves us not just morally
for what he's done for us in the past
but for the next hundred years of our
lives god willing
so the question
if somebody says to me rabbi
i tell you i'm i feel i'm a good jew i
keep the moral
mitzvas i've heard that a lot by the way
i keep the moral miss
the don't kill don't steal i keep the
moral ones
i say my friend every one of them is a
moral mitzvah
if you understand that he is your
creator and sustainer
every mitzvah boils down to being a
moral mitzvah
and is our job just out of gratitude
to do literally the little that he's
asking
now oh it's not little teeth kosher
you're right if you're in
uh there's a you know if you're in
gary indiana maybe it's maybe it's
harder right
that's a uh that's a show tuned song
stephanie knows right 76 trombones right
music man so if you're gary indiana okay
but even so i travel all the time it's
my job not now
not covered but outside of covet outside
of snowstorms
i travel all the time and
certainly certainly in america it's just
not so hard to keep kosher
do you know how many kosher products
there are on the market
okay let's start backwards how many
courses
how many products do you eat in a
lifetime
in your lifetime every time you drink
coke that only counts as one
okay how many different products do you
eat or drink in a lifetime i'll tell you
the answer
usually about 5 000 if you're very
eclectic
all the way up to 10 000.
right every tropicana orange is one
every hershey's borrowing is one
so hundreds thousands five thousand okay
ten thousand that's on max max max how
many kosher products
are there on the market the answer is
over
four hundred thousand
there's over four hundred thousand
kosher products that means i can go to
gary indiana
and get kosher cereal kosher butter
kosher bread
kosher salad kosher salad dressing
kosher potato chips
where am i going to get stuck cheese
hard cheese
okay you know about that but you can
just certainly get soft cheese cream
cheese
and they also have that spreadable
cheese kosher that stuff exists
you know about that and you're going to
get stuck with meat
except that in many trader joe's around
the world
wherever you go you could find like
empire kosher chicken but you know what
my son and daughter live in tallahassee
and they get
empire chicken right there in
tallahassee they're like how many people
keep kosher in tallahassee like four
three i don't know but they got good old
trader joe's right
german company anyways yeah
that's really uh and adelaide
what is it called anyways
they changed name they called trader
joe's it's much much much funner
so keeping kosher is
not as tough as we think
but what about restaurants that's right
yeah restaurants got a problem with
restaurants you're going to get stuck
and if you're one of those people
who love eating out move to manhattan
or brooklyn or yerushalayim
or for instance cleveland or chicago or
minnesota
really any city that has a baseball team
i don't know what it is but the cities
with baseball baseball teams all have
big jewish
communities toronto montreal
miami it's just it's bizarre you know
natalie it's true it's weird so
not hockey not hockey hockey's not a
sport
let's just let's just get half the world
angry at us neither is soccer
okay now the other half of the world is
angry
i someone said how do you enjoy zoom
i said it's funny because i just like to
speak to myself and see if i can make
you laugh
so keeping keeping good i had um
i had students when i was around by ucla
so i had um
i had a day called discover jewish la
it was a very fun day and i would take
you know 15 20 students
i'd bring them into the to the ortho
part of town
and i would take them to a jewish day
school a jewish hot salad which is a
first aid ambulance corps i would take
him to
the mikvah let them see that it's a
really really nice day
didn't charge for it just a wonderful
day
fed them breakfast lunch and then
part of that day i did something if if
any of you are still in college
and you want to have fun like fun with
hillel people
do this it's the funnest thing okay and
if you're still in college next year
who knows okay so this this is it
it's called the the kosher scavenger
hunt
i i invented this but it's so easy to do
basically uh i took 25
products normal products ketchup
salad dressing you know marinara sauce
whatever it is 25 products
and i would i wouldn't say the generic
like just ketchup
or bread or butter and i would say
find me a and then i taught them the
kosher symbols the basic ones i owe you
the okay the kafke the star k all the
regular kosher ones
and i said find me
a kosher version of each of these food
products
give me the name and tell them which
kosher symbol has on it
and whoever fills out the whole sheet
first bingo
and he win a prize and and he's i sent
them off
they went running through the store
either went running and cereal courtesy
oh fruity pebbles kosher almost all of
them are kosher ice cream like almost
all ice cream is kosher people don't
even realize
only the ones not my with marshmallows
are not most actually
most ice cream is kosher there's so much
kosher out there it's amazing
and the and when they come back so they
have their old sheet fill out give out
the prizes
and the reaction is the reaction that i
look for the reaction is
rabbi there's kosher versions of
everything i said
uh-huh you literally have to go out of
your way to eat not kosher
like you have to say i want where is
that one mayonnaise that's not
kosher like you know miracle whip kosher
almonds mayonnaise kosher
paul newman kosher like what's not
kosher
now there are certain things where
you'll have a harder time with that
i'd be a little facetious because there
are certain places where it's a little
bit harder to find
but i never ever had a problem i never
went starving i always went to the local
supermarket i was able to buy heinz
baked beans
and peas anything most of these things
in cans
are kosher they all have kosher symbols
on them
the bottom line is that the almighty
says
i kept you alive i gave you life
you needed me in the past you need me
for the future
this is what's important to me this is
my love language
but i feel spiritual doing yoga
it's not my love language it's not
showing me gratitude it's
you're just being you know you you may
as well
go to the far east and you know go to
some
some ashram in tibet and
you know do your own thing you want to
connect with me i'm telling you how
stop guessing i'm going to make it easy
now we're going to take this one step
further
and this is to me just a fun wonderful
true step
you guys are all following me right okay
so you know
i have a lot of a lot of kids thank god
i have 11. and
the kids are good in different things
and not so good i
i'm not really much of a math guy you
know i never loved math
i know all you are mathematicians but uh
my i had my my grandson who's not even
five yet
and he was sitting on my lap this shop
is so cute dimples both sides
boaz his name's boz and i'm holding him
and we're bouncing
but little do i realize uh he
he has pulled the stem out of my watch
and he changed my time on my watch
now on shabbos you're not allowed to
change the timeline he's not five years
old
but now i'm stuck with the wrong time
the rest of the shops
and this is friday night so i look at
him
and everyone they're looking like are
you upset i said i'm not upset but
i have to do math now i have like add 55
minutes there every time like ah
stop with math i said boys you made
you made grandpa do math bad bad
so so some of the kids are good in
certain things they're not good in other
things
so what do i do so i am a big
advocate of incentives why
because the torah says that the torah
says give incentives
prizes are a good thing people who say
oh
don't you're going to spoil them spoil
them it's hard enough being a kid
really would you want to go back being a
kid
never ever not forever right right
fourth grade
stunk you know no one wants to go back
to fourth grade
right so it's hard being a kid give the
kid an incentive
you know we make kids sit
at a desk for seven eight hours
we are so add we can barely sit for
we're going to the elevator we take out
our phone we go on to an
escalator we do that you're on an
escalator
like
really you're in the bathroom for one
minute
about kids sit for eight hours and stare
at the teacher
at point in a place it's really you know
montessori all the way baby right this
this stuff is just
it's whatever we're it's archaic
don't get me started i got myself
started okay
so kids have it hard enough having to
pay attention and sit
in a squishy desk with their hands
folded
getting a's on tests being bullied in
the playground
living up to peer pressure having
cliques being on the outs
getting pimples right it's just it's a
nightmare being a kid let's be honest
you know
so natalie's like yes you shall
just be born grown up and stay in our
twenties
okay wait till you get the wait to have
the kids you'll have bills you'll wish
you were kidding
no you won't no you won't so
what i do is i offer my kids prizes and
i say you get an
a you get 100 i'm going to give you a
nice prize
so the kids they work really hard
and they get an a in whatever subject
and they come to me they say hey i'm
giving you the a
you said you would take me to the store
and buy me the prize and i said yep i'm
going to do that
but i take the kid to the store and i
buy him a prize now
did he give me an a do i get anything
out of his a
not really not really you want to be a
let me drop off be a dropout you know
do i get do i get anything out of my
kids yeah okay gets to a better school
and then what he'll get a better job but
what do i get out of it
do i plan on him supporting me when i'm
70 nah
i'm not going to do that right that's
bad policy
so knock us giving is receiving
ah such a mature crowd here i love it
however bottom line is
that bottom line is that
i'm not you know they're not giving me
i'm giving him
or her a prize in order
that they should get a good grade so
that they get a job so that they can get
more money
basically i'm giving them something
so they can get something more that's
what parents do
we love our kids so much that we give
our kids stuff
so that our kids will improve and get
more stuff
that's what mitzvahs are
hashem gets nothing out of
us saying abraca it's nothing
when we say abraha it's us it's our
lives
that's that are enhanced our gratitude
our connectedness we are finite hashem
is
infinite i want to connect to something
that is eternal
i make my barakah i tell hashem
i have tremendous gratitude so hashem
is giving me mitzvahs to help me improve
me
and improve the world
so now when jack needed something
when jack asked for the paint
to be done in for his in-laws jack
actually needed something
hashem never needed anything hashem is
the parent who's giving us stuff
just so he can give us more stuff so now
look at the weight of our moral
obligation
to take mitsu seriously hashem
gave us life free gift
hashem saved our lives
every single day a child's life is in
grave danger children have a
very underdeveloped immune system it
used to be that four out of ten children
would not make it into their teens i'm
not going back
thousands of years i'm talking about the
1920s it's
very very very difficult
before antibiotics before people
understood how to get rid of bacteria
and milk and the milk came from swill
like things were things were brutal
and yet hashem allows us to do battle so
he created us
sustains us we need him in the past we
need him for the future
the stuff that he's asking is doable
and it's for our own good it's not even
for him
when you put this package together it
makes us really feel like you know what
i i i want to do this
i i view it as a moral obligation
now i'm going to finish with one more
are you where we do we
we see this right i want to tell you one
more
interesting idea that is connected to a
fascinating muscle
very interesting idea so what if a
person says
well god i never asked you to create me
yeah you're right you sustained me but
you're the one that showed that
that chose to create me so you created
me so why am i
obligated i never asked to be created
[Music]
okay ready for the muscle it's a good
one
so there's a fellow there are these two
fellows who live
in a town in europe and
one of them was blind
and one of them was deaf now there also
happened to be two ladies who lived in
that same stettle
that's a little little village little
stettle
one of those ladies she was a nice lady
she was a nice looking lady
she you know she had she had qualities
but she had one
deficiency she could not she could not
stop talking she just didn't know when
to say when
and it chased everyone away it was just
it was way over the top and she did not
know how to take a hint
and then there was another lady in the
town who is the sweetest person
she's very very nice person
unfortunately she was born with
certain deformities that made her
difficult to even look at
and these two ladies they were getting
older and no one was marrying them and
things were tough finally yentl the
matchmaker says
i have an idea for the lady
who cannot stop talking who should she
marry
the deaf guy that for the lady
who's a very nice person the only thing
is she has all these deformities
she should marry the blind guy that
would be
two great shidduchim two great matches
let's do this
and she proposes it and sure enough like
magic
muzzle dove double muzzle dove that's
great
that two weddings it was wonderful and
that
went on there nice marriages and things
went on for a year or two beautifully
one day a guy comes to the
city and he's a very famous doctor
and he had abilities to
cure deafness and to cure blindness
and he charged quite a bit of money but
he was very effective
for almost everyone that that he that he
met
he was able to cure them and these two
people
they were very excited while the blind
person said wow
i would love to be able to see the deaf
person wow to be able to hear would be
amazing
they each went to the doctor and the
doctor agreed to treat them
and the doctor cured both of them of
their ailment
and the blind guy he can't believe it
opened his eyes light color wow it's so
amazing
and he goes home he can't wait to
finally see his wife
he's going to be sober he gets home
opens the door hello my dear
and he's like shocked what what's going
on goodbye hello
and uh the deaf guy he's so excited to
be able to hear
the lyrical sound of his wife speaking
hello how are you dear i could hear you
oh now you can hear me today before
like days and days a few days later
they both get a bill in the mail from
the doctor
to pay up and they both said
we're not paying we are not paying you
doc says well why not they said
well we we we're going to pay you
to enhance our lives but you did the
opposite you've made our lives terrible
our lives are bitter now our marriages
are falling apart
instead of improving you have you have
hurt us in a grave way we don't feel we
should pay for that
the doctor says that's not my business i
i made you be able to see i may be able
to hear you have to pay
and they decided to go to the local
rabbi oh
come on can come just like they're like
i want them to see
he this boy of mine just came back from
from arvie from mayroof
this is is that your third time going to
seoul
third time he just turned bar mitzvah
it's his third time
going in the snowstorm guys can you clap
for this man
you can't hear it because it's on you
okay sweetie
okay now go dry yourself off here close
the front door okay
thank you wow wow i didn't go
i'm old snow's too high anyways
so so they said we're going to go to the
local rabbit to see whether we have to
pay
or not and they went to the local rabbi
and the rabbi stroked his beard he said
okay
he said i've thought about your case and
i've decided
that the blind man and the deaf man are
correct
he did not improve your life and
therefore
you do not have to pay this person for
making
you be able to see and hear and
because he did not improve your life he
will he then has the right to take back
his services
and therefore i'm going to ask the
doctor
to make you blind again and make you
deaf again
and they said no no no no no we don't
want to comply and death again
because ah you don't want to so he did
improve your life
so pay
that's the muscle that's a story to help
us understand
what's the nimsho the nimsha is
that if a person says well god i didn't
tell you to create me
right i never asked to be created so
then god says okay you don't want to be
alive
corona you want to be alive can't so you
don't be alive
god please help me please save me every
day
sustain me give me food give me clothing
and give me warmth
ah so you do or don't want to be alive
you do want to be alive
so then then you have to have gratitude
understand so we did today was a very
fascinating study
into the morality behind
keeping midsize so no fluff all
solid and bizarre i hope you'll be able
to
not just incorporate this but use it
whenever it
is that you struggle with whatever
mitzvah to remember we
number one have a moral obligation to do
it number two it is hashem's
love language number three uh it is
prudent because it is helping sustain us
it is also doable
it's doable and it's for our own good
so there's so many reasons to approach
this
that we should go and do it
okay thank you everyone i hope you have
an amazing week
hope you enjoyed and
take care i'll see you next week