Can A Woman Write A Megillah? (2)

I saw it in the heart's way. Our shots right here, the green volumes. An argue more of what we deserve that he says as follows. He said that the great guy in represents came to me and he showed me a beautiful in the safer it's in and that was with regards to could a woman write Megillah's Esther or could a woman not write a Megillah's Esther? Is it easier to write a Megillah's Esther or is it easier not to write a Megillah's Esther? What does it have to do with we'll see in one second. But is it easier to write a Megillah's Esther or not? So he said that I found in this he was so excited he went to show it to his friend the guy and he said I I found a a beautiful and he wanted to bring a from the guy says that a Megillah has to be written has to be written and it has to be written with black ink. It says the guy how do I know that? As you Esther that Esther wrote the first Megillah. So when he wrote he wrote a lot safer so too Esther when she wrote the Megillah she must have written a lot safer so too meaning who wrote the first Megillah? Esther wrote the first Megillah. So if Esther wrote the first Megillah it's okay and you see that when it says it wasn't just that she was writing. She was writing a kosher Megillah. The we learn from there that means she wrote a lot safer so he showed me this beautiful that Esther is kosher to write a Megillah." Now, just hit the pause button for 1 second. If this raid sounds familiar, just we talked about this by Ricos. We did a very detailed raid by when we learned Maseches Megillah. And really this shiva means Zeven found it in the safer Kasa Sofer, but far God should be Robin specifically in Shilo the Chivas Mishal David in Er Chaim Siman Lamed by the great the chief rabbi of Prague right before the night of the Yehuda, Rav David Oppenheim. And Rav David Oppenheim brings that there was a maiseh shaya kahoya, there was a shaila came to our besdin where there was a woman that wrote a Megillas Esther. And the question was, could a woman write a Megillas Esther or could a woman not write a Megillas Esther? And this was a big tumul, and he said at first glance all the dayonim thought no. Why? Because a woman can't write a safer Torah, she can't write tefillin, she can't write a mezuzah. So she wouldn't she shouldn't be able to write a safer Torah either. But said I mean she shouldn't write a Megillas Esther either. But said Rav David Oppenheim that I think based on the Gemara Megillah daf kuf yud tes amud alef, where the pasuk already says, "Vatischta d'Esther amalko." And we learn from there al a safer b'dyo. So you see that she wrote a kosher Megillah. So you see a woman is allowed to write a kosher Megillah. And then he said that Hagga b'Atzmoha. He says, "Why isn't Isha possul to write a safer Torah, tefillin, mezuzah?" Because it says, "Ukshartem uksaftem." And kosher in a b'chira in a b'chira. Well, when it comes to Megillas Esther, "Af hein hoya b'sanas." And because "Af hein hoya b'sanas," so it's mistaber that she should be kosher. And this is what he writes. Now this story that's mentioned here in the Mishal David, this was a real maiseh shaya kahoya. He's very cryptic about what the details of the story were. But there's a piyurush on Megillas Esther called Megillas Safer that was written by one of the Chavrei HaBesdin of Rav David Oppenheim. His name was Rav Moshe Mayer Pereles. Rav Moshe Mayer Pereles, he was safra v'dayna b'Killa Kadisha of Prague. And this reading here from the sharp letter of the safer Mital Me Deah Bal Mogan Avraham Zecha Tzaddik Livracha, that Rav David Oppenheim Zecha Tzaddik Livracha oh the Prague. So in the period Esther on the Esther Hamalka he writes that I was sitting on the best in of David Oppenheimer and a child was brought to us and the child was that of David Oppenheimer's daughter Sarah the wife of Chaim Yona who was the son of Tuvia Tumim who was also the the Bal Kiko in the Yona but David Oppenheimer's daughter wrote a beautiful Magilla and the child was brought to her father is it kosher or is it not kosher and her father passed away and he said you're not allowed to read from the Magilla. That's the rest of the story but the rest of the rest of the story is that in the Tuvia Mehaver from David Fleckless and this is page and it's in the Tuvia Mehaver he says he may seek me my grandfather and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's mother's father and he may eat me my mother's is a He says the is it possible that holds that a woman's possible to do with it says so the says not it's the possible says in that always gotten that an issue should be kosher. I'm a good says so the says no you can always be it's not it's it's not it's said it's not it's now how do you have the license to go ahead and do that? I mean this is a slippery slope but this is a going to say Frank and he said that just like the was here in a way that that that means not that she did it it's it's means could be the same as you. Let's just explain what he meant a little bit better. He's not just going ahead and being cooking what is doing is that says what do you mean means and he's saying that even though it sounds like it means it's as if it's in the word is but can mean you did it but can mean that you also did it the bottom line is really it took place but this was the issue of Frank. That it could be that that this is the same as that it's a total of 100 and the castle of the going to want to bring a riot to in the guild of your test again made a big deal about that raid when we don't have your test in this play a but I but everything is connected to each other we have a riot here years later from a nice to that raid.