0:00 / 0:00
Beyond the Bias: Responding to Tyler Oliveira's Kiryas Joel Satmar Video
3,250 views
These short videos were made by Rabbi Issamar Ginzberg in response to the viral video by Tyler Oliveira titled "Inside the New York Town Invaded by Welfare-Addicted Jews." It's important to counter misinformation with facts, especially when harmful stereotypes are being spread to millions of viewers. -- FAIR USE NOTICE: This video contains copyrighted material, the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for purposes of criticism, comment, news reporting, and education, which constitute fair use under Section 107 of the US Copyright Act. This video is not intended to infringe on any copyrights.
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
So Tyler, you ask about welfare and
curious oil. You get many different
responses. 33% 93% 35% 100%. Somehow you
managed to use all those numbers
together to prove your point. And none
of it makes any sense. I'm not going to
go through the time stamps of each
person when you Google 93% and different
people say different things. You ask the
bagger in the grocery, the guy taking
out the stuff out of the boxes
and he's your proof. Oh, he says 100%.
So therefore, the answer is 100%. You
didn't even ask a cashier for that
matter. So, which is it? 33%, 93%, 100%,
or 35%. You can't take four numbers and
act like they all prove the same thing.
But even more importantly, you're asking
the wrong question. On my screen, you
see Elon Musk, who just so happens to be
is a big believer in that we have to
raise fertility rates. But beyond that,
Elon Musk has how many children?
14 children.
I want to know how much money you think
Elon Musk gets in tax credits for having
children.
Tyler, it's the same amount that a
person living in Curious Joel gets per
person. Meaning to say that when they
figure out how much money is considered
a normal amount of income, what's below
the standard baseline income, when a
person is considered low income, it
changes based on how many children you
have. Tyler, if you have 12 kids, you'll
get the same tax credit as somebody else
who has 12 kids.
Now, but I don't want to spend too much
time talking about this because I don't
think that this particular point from my
perspective. I really would like and
hope that everybody can succeed in their
careers, in their jobs, and their
businesses and become wealthy like many
people do. Many Jews live the American
dream. Came here before, during, after
the Holocaust with nothing, not speaking
a language, not knowing anything. And
many of them did actually succeed in
becoming comfortable. Some of them even
extremely wealthy, starting all kind of
businesses and supporting many different
besides supporting their local
communities supporting just for argument
sake. You brought a you showed
construction that the Mexicans are doing
the construction. Well, every business
has an owner. Every business has
employees. You didn't see all the
employees. You did show, maybe you
didn't mean to, but you did show that
there are orthodoxidic
people in curious Joel who are
supporting who have on their payroll
many people who are obviously very
obviously not from theidic community of
curious Joel to say it lightly. So if
anything that's how the economy works
money comes, money goes, some money gets
spent in a community, some money goes to
be spent beyond a community. That's how
the entire entire economy is built. But
in any case, let's move on to the next
thing. I don't think that this is
something you mentioned at all. Let's
look at a map of curios. Curious in
English, it's called curious Joel
because Joel is the English way to
pronounce yo, which was the name of the
first smearbi, the one who founded this
uh village.
So curious Joel is in upstate New York.
So if you take
if you go on the from Manhattan, take
the George Washington Bridge, go up up
up, you go past Muny, past Suffern, take
the six, you could take the uh
throughway, you go further up and you
get to curious Joel. Let's just see how
far Curious Joel is from the Empire
State Building. It's an hour and 15
minutes from the Empire State Building,
which means that to let's call it
Williamsburg or Borough Park where
there's Jewish communities in the city
of New York is even further than that.
So, let's just do
uh
pick an address on Williamsburg.
All right. Would be an hour and a half
approximately to go from there to there.
So why did the S Marbbe open his
community? At that point, you know,
places like Muny were considered the
cats, were considered the country.
People didn't live for the most part so
far up. He picked a piece of land very
far from essentially where Brooklyn was,
where his headquarters was, where the
Smaridum live in Williamsburg, New York.
And he picked a place far away, pretty
far to get to, especially for a
community like his when not everybody
drives. Talking the men here.
and opened a community all the way up
here. Part of the reason was because the
low cost of living because that way
people who wanted to not be running in
the rat race with the Joneses who wanted
to be able to live a nice simple life
unbothered doing their own thing would
be able to do it.
That's why they live in curious Joel.
They have a beautiful village. They're
not starving. They're not homeless.
They're poor by senses definition
because they chose lowcost living to
match their values. But they have roof
over their head, food on the table, safe
streets, no crime, no drugs, no
homelessness. That's not poverty. That's
modest living by choice.
So it's very nice. He showed this
grocery worker who said, "Oh, 100% use
EBT." As I said, he doesn't even work
the cash register. He stacks the
shelves. How would he know? But it makes
for good video. I'll give you that. In
the next video, I'm going to go to your
most dangerous question of them all. Why
is it okay for Jews to live together but
illegal when white people try to build
their own? Yeah, we need to talk about
that in the next video.