Bedikas Chametz: The Controversy Over the Minhag of Putting Out The 10 Pieces

this torah class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay welcome everyone it's almost time for everybody cascamets let's discuss discuss briefly in depth the custom that has become widespread to put out the 10 pieces of bread during vedica the raman simon tough lama base of base brings down the minhag to put out pieces of chamet where the boy deck will find them so that the bracha will not be ibrahim apparently the rama is saying there is an opinion that if the boy dick does not find any humans then his bracha of al-bir khames is a brahmatala and therefore in order to create a situation where the bracha has what to be khalon we put out bread that's why you where you find something however the rama concludes that if you did not put out the bread um it's not ma akev because a person's das when he makes the bracha is to be mavia if he finds anything however the ta's says that anyway it's not a brachava the bracha is going on the beer that you'll do tomorrow the night of pesach the morning of pesa excuse me the night of pesach the morning of arapaisaka persons eating homemades certainly they'll be left over from dinner and from breakfast that you'll be able to burn but the beer starts through the medica and therefore it is not necessary to put out the bread because even if you don't put out the bread you'll have what to burn in fact the taj concludes that it's better not to that you should not put out the bread why because we're concerned you might not find a piece you know how often it's happened people put out the ten pieces and they're lucky if they could find eight of them nowadays people have to put gps systems on their pieces of hamates otherwise you know you never know if you're going to find them therefore the task says it's wrong to put out the hammers look in the bear haiti if he brings the name of the tamim dayam that it's the minha gnashim it's a vibe it's baseless and it should not be done however the mishna brewer brings down from in kedai levato meno and then it says mission bureau looking for reasons for the min so take a look at in dalit he brings from the mahari and simon cooper gimmel that the reason why to put out the ten pieces is since if you don't find any hamets you won't have what to burn now it won't be a brachle battle but if you don't have what to burn you'll forget to be movato the next day and it's critical to be mavato this way you have what to burn and you'll remember timi mavato now the khoi kyakov writes in his opinion the reason for the minogue is because of a person who searches for khames and he doesn't find anything at first he'll be um he'll throw in the towel and he'll give up hope and he won't do a thorough badika this way we reward the looker with easy pieces of comics to find and that will spur him on to look more and it's like a psychological ploy to encourage someone to look carefully because he's constantly rewarded in his search by finding the obvious comments which is quite interesting this is a because the person knows he's going to find it because the person himself put it there but apparently we see from that even a self-creative incentive program which is really in a way meaningless because you found it because you put it there that is enough to give a person the motivation to continue looking well says brings down this minogue and according to nari wanshodafka put out ten pieces of bread but be very careful says the machine brewer that you don't misplace one of the pieces of bread let's just end off the uh charize writes this whole discussion was back in the day when people's houses may have been dirty at the time of the medica but nowadays when people's houses are quite clean going into the vedica it could be putting out the bread is not just the minute it could be nowadays it becomes otherwise what are you looking for and the the bracha in fact may really be abraham tommy huggin brings an ice tough pay aleph the minute to put out the pieces of bread to demonstrate a certain humility that as well as you cleaned it's not perfect because in general as much as we're masaki in ourselves we're still lacking and by putting out the pieces of bread it shows as much as a person is misakin and as buddha is uh menaka as cleans there's always more to do nobody's without a mum nobody is perfect no house is perfect no house is perfectly clean and the hagen brings down the same way there are ten kaijus of kedusha corresponding to it are the ten kaijus of tomah that need to be eradicated from the world interesting and the safer oytsar shaolii element he brings on page 128 in the name of the base arrowing the safarim of haman the decrees of haman were written when onyod gimmel to destroy them and who are the scribes and therefore as the zeker to that immediately in the evening we destroy the ten pieces of humates we search for it to eradicate haman and all that he has to offer so while there is halachic discussion whether it is a valid minogue it has become the spa shade and then this gavel by the poison and the mission israel and as the says in this circumstance we apply the rule minog israel torah so you've just experienced another torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com