Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
YAKNEHAZ - WHY IS BESOMIM NOT INCLUDED - Rabbi Nachum Scheiner
0 views
Shiur from 2022
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
I would like to begin today's sh
for all
America all over the world
this year.
There's a lot of different unique
on the calendar
falls out on a Friday.
This year there are five times that we
make on Yam Yakahaz. Five times. One we
had already rash. The first day
Rashashana we didn't have Shabas which
was Yam Yakaz.
Now we're going to have twice. The first
day took us in the last days. tomorrow
night
yakaz the second days as well by night
yakaz as well as pes the first days the
first night by the seders yak nahaz in
the last days
I would like to focus in today's shir
the ikar
on what we don't say in the havda in the
kdesh of yaknahaz and then we'll also
speak a little bit on what we do say in
yaknaz
The kid the kdesh of yaknahaz what's
yaknahaz yan kdush n we'll try to speak
a little bit at the end about n how you
do the boy navdman
that's yaknahaz
this tomorrow night we actually have
another bra also which is the basuk
hopefully we'll get to that as well also
so that's yak nahaz
ask what happened to the baseld
is yavna.
So yak we have we have the
we have the last one we have the
but why don't we make a
to be able to answer this shila we have
to take a look and see what is the
reason why do we make
why do we take
what's the reason for
So typhus has two reasons for basim
mozzabas and a regular mat shabas. Why
do we take bam? Ty has two reasons. One
reason
we've got the order it's in here the two
reasons. One reason says is because we
have a shabas and when the leaves
person leaves from being relaxed into a
week when he goes to work and everything
you take to relax a person you take bim
that's one reason why you take bas on a
regular shabas another reason you know
why you take bam because shabas sham out
of Ganim Shabas the of Ganim starts
burning again. So to counteract that
smell of the b of the of the fire of
ganim we take bam. Those are two reasons
on the mat shabas kadai to know we take
bama every matzah shabas. Why do you
take bam? Either because
goes away and able to relax ourselves or
because the a is the fire of of ganam
comes. So to take away that smell we
have the smell of bisum.
Let's go back now to see on a matzah
shabas tomorrow night. Tomorrow night
matzah shabas let's one at a time each
reason at a time the f one reason was we
said because the nami is s goes away. So
what happens matzah shabas
when it's yam tomorrow night it's matzah
shabas it's also yamt
does say leave
says the nami leaves and therefore tyus
asks aasha why don't we take bama
there are other is that sayam dashbam
says that the nami does not leave the
nami does not leave on a matzah shabas
when it's yamtiff and therefore you
don't take bum so we have the first
answer why we do not take bas tomorrow
night matzah shabas on yam the reason is
is because it's because the nam doesn't
leave that's what the rashbam says
another
dan it's also in the booklet in the
maramakimus you can see it all in the
maramakimus dan the ran says different
and the says
explains like that also but the concept
of
means the a person has and therefore
says
to the weak it's a culture shock you're
completely relaxed
you don't do anything therefore if
that's if that's then you go into the
weekday you take the as opposed to when
you go from shabas to to y so it's not
into
it's a slow transition first you go into
y which it's still also with but
so therefore the transition is slow but
mainly you don't take mat shabas that's
the second reason
the first reason why not to take pabas
is because then doesn't
Second reason why not to take is it
leaves but it leaves slowly. leaves
shabas y these
but someer
and then these are third terretas
gives the this terret as well as also
the the rajbah
says the reason why we don't take bas
shabas really mab really we should take
bam and the reason we should take bam is
because in the shami you say retaka
leaves and should take bam the The
reason we don't take basim is because we
have something like bam.
What is that?
We have the smell of the good food of
yam
and the other we have the smell.
So what do we have? We have three why we
don't take bam. Either we don't take
bases doesn't leave or it leaves slowly
so we don't need basim or taka leaves
and we shouldn't need bas but we have
basim and the basim is the good food
the shil however is but why taka don't
we use basam why do we have to come on
to the smell of the good food every
matzah shabas and a shami say leaves we
take basam so why wouldn't we take bam
also on a on a mozzar shabas
as well
is showing him that say that the nami is
say relieves tomorrow night as well.
So where's the bas? The terret says you
have the basim by by uh the smell of the
good food. But why can't you just take
bas like we take every m shabas? Why do
you have to be y with a roundabout with
the smell of the good food?
>> What' it say?
>> You don't make a
you don't make a bra.
>> Right. That's true also. Meaning in
other words, why is it not mits of the
of the to take bam and make
the first ter we said you don't take bam
say it doesn't leave I understand second
ter is it goes but slowly you don't need
it understood but here if it leaves why
don't you take bas
>> oh very good very good yeah zas
says that it's a zilt
it's a zen if taking bas.
along now with the reason that you say
relieves and if you're showing on that
you're not relaxed and say you're not
relaxed
you're supposed to be happy
if you're going to take you're being
that's why you shouldn't take not going
to make a
but at the end of the day leaves and
there is an issue of you don't it's a
pro you need the sum like you always
need basam. So for that we'll accomplish
that through the smell of good food.
Let's go now for a minute in the first
reason of bis
because leaves. Let's take a look and
try to see why don't we make the
So we asked why not and we explained
either you don't need it or you need it
and you have it elsewhere. Let's try to
see why why wouldn't we do it now not
not a matziff. So obviously if it leaves
matzah shabas the last way we explained
from the left already matzah shabas. So
of course we don't do a matzy because
the left already danfan
says that it goes slowly. So for the
same reason you don't make it matzah
shabas because it left halfway and it's
not such a culture shock then shami is
say leaving halfway the same concept is
also as well it's it leaves more the
other half is also leaving but it's only
half and half so you don't make a bat
>> could you wait to the mud
even in a slower process cuz you have
kite
>> I You're you're saying for that I mean
so let's say about the second day yeah
let's say well
yeah you're right you're right
is also a process because it's not these
things and it's also yeah you have a
good point that would also be the same
what says so if it goes away
it's it's already left and if it goes
slowly it goes slowly
is only the remainder that's left.
However, like the Rashbam that the says
that the doesn't leave doesn't go away.
Very good. If it doesn't go away, so
when does it go away?
So you should take
them as sham
to say
a little shabas.
No, but the shila is
>> why no we're asking now you should do
it. Shabas left and Yam left and now the
didn't leave Shabas and it stayed we was
it stayed for Yam also but now it should
be like a regular mas to make take
the terret is listen to this it's
put it in the book you take home the
it's claw
The Ramban says that the
from Yam does not leave.
It's actually in the center fold the
middle uh middle of the booklet.
even without
does not leave
that a person's does not leave
if you say that it left mabas matz
shabas if it doesn't leave the says it
doesn't leave m shabas the same that it
doesn't leave matz shabas
the
doesn't leave even as well also doesn't
leave
what's the why should the why does
leave shabas and it doesn't leave yam
explains the nar is hassan brings
Masha's father the aeneer
and the kaduca ley says it himself
without going in the rabban but the
aeneer explains the ram and he says the
following there's a fundamental
difference between shabas and yumpt if
this is already mv all over shabas is
something that comes every seven days
has nothing to do with us it's not up to
us shabas is every seven days whether we
plan it we don't plan it we're We have
nothing to do with it
is the one
that even if they were changed around
that's when is in other words
when is when's
with the calendar we're so isa
Shabas that doesn't come we have nothing
to do with Shabas coming. Shabas comes
every seven days and every seven days is
again Shabas. So the comes Shabas goes
after Shabas. We didn't earn we didn't
do anything for Shabas to come. the
comes Shabas and leaves Shabas as
opposed to Yam being that we brought the
we don't it's instead of the say leaving
it stays
used to speak a lot about it that every
time a yumptiff comes it's not when the
yumpt leaves it left used to say
in add you add it on in addition
And that's why we see that these
we don't have
why not because we want to tie up the
what we got yamt we want to tie up
because that we could hold on we could
save the what we got on y
so maybe like this let's sum up we were
holding so far pretty clear
is no bam either because the nami
doesn't leave or it leaves slowly or
leaves completely and we have something
else instead of bamim
if we don't make a bisim either because
it left already it left slowly or if it
doesn't if it didn't leave yet as we see
in the nami does not leave matumpt and
therefore we do not take bama matiam
>> doesn't the shil come back a little bit
I mean just technically
I don't think it's a sh
Now if you had
and it's equal to what Shabas comes then
it continues the next Shabas comes in
you have
you already had it then when you're
going to leave it's still going to
continue
>> the I hear I don't know how that works I
don't know if the shabist doesn't leave
and then it's a different that that's
above me but I could say what it's or
the the concept that it doesn't leave
and then it doesn't leave Yumpt if
that's the Ramban and the Hezbra of I
don't know Taco when if it doesn't leave
Shabas to Yumpt and what happens the
next Shabas
from the Mir when he came to the Mir so
he used to learn with his great uncle
the kusa
when was the kusa sha the kusa shop was
shabas for 3 hours I think this is the
the details of the story anyway ways um
he told his great uncle I I love
learning with you but I'm from America
you know Shabas afternoon after the
chant you after nap what's what's this
uh what's this business over here with
learning we'll learn we'll learn already
m shabas
so he told him that on a regular day
your shama comes back so okay if you
don't learn today of course every day is
a mitzvah so you learn tomorrow at least
you could be mazed in a shama the next
day as opposed to shabas every shabas is
a
So if a person Friday night he goes to
sleep because he's tired and Shabas is
dinging and then goes to sleep and then
so he didn't learn anything for that
week that
the one time he gets that never got any
Tyra. So uh I guess every week there's a
different one.
Now let's go to the other reason. The
reason for taking basim mozzar shabas
because the a is of ganim starts and
therefore to calm to counteract that
smell we take the we take um to take
away this smell we we take we take bim
the smell of the of the fire of ganim.
So why don't we do a mat for that reason
why don't we do a matzah shabas
it seems clearly that the of ganam ta
says I didn't say anybody argues the is
of ganim starts matzah shabas even if
it's yam so why don't we take the mat
shabas for this reason so that the says
also for the same reason like the says
before that it's a zil so the this is
also a zil if you're going to take the
summer mabas tomorrow night on y to take
away the smell ka the smell of the fire
of gam you're showing that these you're
showing on that people are going back
into ganim so you don't take bum
I don't think he says the reason of the
he just says the zilz
yeah he doesn't say that you have the
smell of the food he just says because
of zily if you going to take basing
yaknah
of all matzah shabas of yamt
it's worthwhile to point out a that's
particular for this matzah shabas yam
tomorrow night
in tonight's kdesh when do you make the
before the leas or after leas
before
>> what?
>> Before.
>> So, so the first night is clear. You
make the shaky at the end. Why first
night shak is at the end? Because it
also goes on the lev
because you make the is also going on
the mitzvah of building the it goes on
everything. So theu
is at the end of kdesh the first night
tonight
is the last of kdesh.
Yeah, we want to double check on a to
see it's the la that's the last uh the
last. However, when it comes to actually
have a copy over here of them.
Yeah, at the end. However, what's about
the second night?
Tomorrow night. What do you do tomorrow
night?
Do you say to first or lev
a small sim
tucked away
small and a small one? A smallie
tomorrow night
meaning to say is you switch around
order. You switch around the orders up
to first you say
and then afterwards you say
and
to switch it around. Yeah. You switch it
around. Why do you switch it around? Why
should you switch around tomorrow night
or tonight? Explain the pkim. The reason
to switch around and put the leas after
theu
because tomorrow night already theu only
goes on kdeshu
on the you made already tonight. And
even if tonight is not sukus, it was a
mistake and sukus started the day later.
You can make the on the suk even. So
when you're making au now on on the
second night of sukus, what are you
making? You're only making au on kdes
the kdish the kdes but mainly you should
say afterwards or shouldn't it be aik.
However, yeah that's clear. Tonight you
say to at the end tomorrow and you say
to
and then afterwards
you switch it around.
>> Yeah.
However, many a lot by the many have the
meaning that they don't switch around
even the second night as well. They
don't switch around and they make the at
the end I it's a halfik. What happened
to the terret is
say the pkim. I think the mash even
brings it that the the just like yakaz.
What do we do? Yaknahaz any yaknaz not
even tomorrow night. When do we say
is at the end
has nothing to do with the
you do in the middle.
So it's a half sick the terret says
that's of kdesh whatever has to be going
into kdeshdah goes into kdesh is kdesh
the basuk is part of kdesh that's a
separate cheer for itself why is in
kdesh it's really un you don't make a
it's a whole separate discussion but
let's stay focused over here yaknahaz
you make a shak at the end of at the end
of the yaknaz I haved is in the middle
the ter says we're not concerned about
the abd in the middle because that's
part of kdesh
say that's the those that are not to
switch around the tomorrow night before
I the doesn't go on the lev the terret
says it's not considered a half sick
whatever everybody's mig is you stay
with the mic but at least you you'll
know that these two types hog whether to
switch or not to switch and the hesbra
of why to switch
and why not to switch.
Now let's asem focus
on what we do say in Adalah
the of Adalah
that I actually didn't put in a copy
should have printed it out also the abd
will go through the ofd
a regular
of every shabas that must probably you
know by
fourdoll not all are relevant to Shabas
but they're have
the garra says it's a
one should not when any haved
Why can you just say
and that's it?
They have to say a few. The minimum of
of dollars have to be three. So you have
it really you have four but the GRA
explains earlier that you only have
three because
really goes that it should be. So that's
why we say it. So really
and the fourth one
is really just
what's about
the lion of matzy.
You want to see it so you can take a s
but the lion
there's a lot more a lot more going on
in the a lot more many moredis
obviously even tomorrow night you say
because we're not saying that tomorrow
night
and that happens all the time anytime
So far that's the same.
is because
that's why we conclude with
what's all these extra shyness what's
going on over here and the truth is ask
what is the
That line itself will get to but says
why do we add on a lot more
than every than every shabas.
The reason why we add
all these have on a matzah shabas which
is yumpt is
because the garra says
and what's the maximum amount of abdulis
that you can make zomar seven
one time we want to make we want to
accomplish having seven of that's
asked the Shiloh answer
at least once to have Zion of
that's why we say a longerd. So that's
the first thing to understand to know we
do the minimum three
but then when it comes to
if we want to once do the maximum amount
of abdull and therefore being that we
want the max amount of dollars we say
seven
goes through what's the how do we what's
the seven of
so says the following
Then says the next one.
All that is one.
And what's
Number
five is
and included in that.
Why is that all number five? One part is
going the between the kadusha of Shabas
and the kaduca of Yamiff and included in
that is also the between Shabas and now
that's all counted to one. By the way
the rush says it's counted as two. These
different ways how to get to seven but
Ztous that's counted as one because
we're talking about Shabas. So Shabas is
moved from Yam and in Yam these
different types of kaducious Yam and but
it's really one half dollar within Yam
and
we we we say
and also we say
which means but it's all one half dollar
this is for this year and it's now we
have a whole bunch
is like we spoke about but in the we say
which how the TIS understands it's going
that's six days
it's not possible pes even is 5 days
it's only sus and
this year this year the six days
Monday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday,
Thursday, Friday. The whole week is
Friday, but it's all
that level of which we're speaking
about.
They ask that the
it's not really this next Shabas is not
it's already it's
right.
Next week Shabbat is not
buton that's number five is
yumpt of is abdah number five what's
number six and number seven so number
six and number seven the lotion of what
we say in abdullah
is two because
so
from
that's another two. So that's seven. So
that's the seven that we have
says that you do not have to have. If
you remember by by Shabas we said that
you have to say again after the three.
So it should be
we end off again and we don't count it
to the to be four. It's only three. Why
in a regular M shabas? Because we want
it to be the end of the when we finish
the so why don't you say the same thing
over here also?
You don't have to because what's what do
we end off on the
so
is also
it fits even
Just to conclude with a few
of
the we spoke about why no we tried
clarifying now the liondoll is different
now shabas of yak because to say seven
of we went through the number how do we
get to seven
being that yakna is kesh and abdah.
I think we all know these amog that says
that ladies should not drink a
so what's about tomorrow night's kdesh
these also haved it's kdish and abdullah
should the ladies not drink because he's
also part of it is also
so they drink from the kdesh and these
two different has bum in the pkim
zonel he brings from lea that they have
valid kis even a year like this here and
he says the reason why they drink it
is because the is a tel the is a tel to
the kdesh. So let's not consider that
they're drinking from they're drinking
from kdish.
Sorry
says that it's a tul. That's why
says that it's both not that it's a tul.
He says since it's also a kdesh so they
should drink outdes
says that it's a tough it's not even
considered like they're drinking a
another that's mentioned in the
shabas when you fill up the k you let it
spill over it's a school for
mabas tomorrow night now you should not
do it why also says cuz y if
You shouldn't do it. You shouldn't fool
over to be tomorrow night like a regular
mat shabas.
And then finally the mo which we do make
these various different menim.
Some make a mo and make it in a just
like a regular mat shabas.
The mish says he's no problem of pulling
it apart or speaks about it. Some have
the meaning. They actually put two
candles together
in his in the back says you make a
without anything being that there's a
when you put the candles together you
might be gi for whatever reason either
your may the fires or the wax strips
down may you should you should not put
any candles together and then there's a
third minute brought which people do
that. They put the two candles together
without touch without merging them. You
just put the two candles together and
over there you make a bar.
I would like to end off with a Gavald
Marshall and a a limudus.
There was once somebody
a successful businessman but the way his
business ran was every year he took
millions of dollars of merchandise on
credit. A lot of people work like that
now. Also they sold it on a profit and
after they sold their merchandise they
were able to pay back and also cut have
a profit for themselves.
one year
didn't work out. The he took all
everything. He took the loan. He took
all the merchandise, but he couldn't
sell. It was a year like this year,
Corona. The stores were closed. He
couldn't sell and he was stuck with
everything. So, what should he do? He's
been doing this for many years and he
had a good reputation. The person
trusted him. The guy knew that he was a
honest person. So, he begged him, you
know, what should I took millions of
dollars. So in the beginning the guy was
a quarter of the loan that he owed him
then begged him more. He was Moore.
Begged him. Begged him. I'm such a good
customer for years and years. He was Mo
even more. Came by the end end of the
whole spiel. The guy was the whole
thing. The millions of dollars of
merchandise went finished. He was very
good, beautiful.
Very nice. The guy says, he tells
himself, his wife, very nice. The guy
was but I'm going to go now to the guy
next year. I'm going to ask him for it
again. Few million dollars of
merchandise. He's never going to give it
to me. It was very nice. He forgave. He
cleaned it. You know, the whole for next
year. He's never going to give it to me.
So, what what is he going to do? He
needs to be able to continue his
business and take more and sell and make
a profit. So, he came up with an idea.
What he's what he's going to do is he's
going to go around to his family members
to help him out. Yeah, that's what
people do. We went to family members,
raised the money, gave the guy the money
from last year what he couldn't sell,
paid up the old loan, and then he was
able to go fresh, start a new uh a new
account, and take again the merchandise.