TEN SONS OF HAMAN - HOW AND WHEN WERE THEY ANNIHILATED Shiur y Rabbi Nachum Scheiner on Purim

I just want to begin by thanking for always being devoted on recording the sh and specifically today pumm in the morning. Thank you. In today's we're going to speak about what seems to be a and it's actually you say yeah we're coming now we just uh heard the we said we're going to focus today in the reading of the migillah saying the migill and not in is a separate discussion. It's brought in brought that should be on and one which is a discussion. That's why you'll see sometimes some people including myself have a migill that's a that's shorter because only has 11 lines for the ban as opposed to having them. It could still be 11 lines those lines but then it's bigger. It's not that it could be bigger. It's a separate discussion. It's like we began when you say and the word you're supposed to say it all in one breath. Why? Why to say in one breath? Dr. Gomorra Kulu had they all died at the same time. says if you're going to the migillah here in peress this is the story what happened on yesterday and the and the migillah says 500 people and like the go further and say gave a report to that what happened in shushan I don't know what happened in other places but in shushan 500 people killed and and Benham understands as we know that were hung understands that's the in the Rambam that they were killed by being hung that's how they were killed the Rambam the Rambam says when the Rama brings Why? That everybody should know they were hung and they were killed which means they were killed by being hung. It usually doesn't happen at the same time that they all get killed. If you hang 10 people, some people not it's not all at the same time. How is it that you molate even hanging them up? You hang them separately. So what does it mean? They all died at the same time. Made a nest that they should all die at the same time. Why? Like, in other words, the rashim should all die at the same time. All at the same time. Now in Iran, no. Right. In the beginning was all there were a lot of rash ministers all at the same time at the same time. One hit helped us all all all in one shot. The one brings this Here he says they were killed and they were hung in the sukum of the mill. That's really what it's they were killed yesterday. Gimmel that the whole peric test like the peric starts yesterday all these 500 people were killed in and also and then afterwards Esther gave Esther the report what happened. And then said, "What else can I give you? What else can I give you?" So Esther answered, "I want to also have tomorrow. Give tomorrow so another day for the to do whatever they want." Which by the way, agav we celebrate Purim today. The nest didn't happen today. The nest happened yesterday. We today is the day after we rested today. That's the nest. We celebrate um today that after the nest and shushan obviously because they were still they still killed today tomorrow. But alapon and Esther asked to have another day in Shushan. And Esther asked we had before that they were killed. Esther asked they should be hung and that there's another day. Ye didn't have another day. And the other both like what says and and granted Esther both that he was uh he was uh they were killed and they were hung today. in the yard was this shabas and he says how is it possible that they all died by being hung at the same time. It's different times. You hang up each person separately. They all died yesterday. Today they were hung. The shila however is is in the Rambam. The Rambam is mashma that they died with being hung. Now we said already from the that even though they were hung maybe it took a few minutes to hang them all they all died at the same time. But the shamb like we said they were hung and killed by being hung that yesterday is when they were killed that we said they were killed yesterday and today today they were hung. So some want to answer that they were killed yesterday but they were still a gis and the final death was today with the hanging. Okay. So that's it. >> Love death. Exactly. It's really they when it says that they were killed, they didn't die die. They they killed them, but they weren't dead yet. Then they hung them and by the hanging that's what the Rambam says by being hung in. And the Emma says that it's a medish. The Yarus says the medish says that Hmon had a hundred children. He speaks about that 10 times 10 were killed yesterday and then another 10 were hung today and they were killed today. So that would be the ishu yesterday 10. So even though the Rambam says to which is speaking about today and Ben was yesterday but it's not a stra yesterday 10 of the children were killed and today another 10 were killed by being hungar about this that we're saying about the that was two days yesterday killed and today hung that's a the says like This asked Esther on Gimmel, "What else can I give you?" And Esther said, "I want another day and I also want to be hung. You understand that these both one was to be able to have another day today that they should be hung today. When aasher asked yesterday bey gimmel to be hung as well also when Esther asked right then and there already hung them wanted to show who was boss over here he looked a little bit like a joke to his letters like this and the letters like that wanted to show exactly whose boss and right when Esther asked to hang them he didn't wait till tomorrow to say hung all on the same Okay, I'll dash like the Gomorrah says because it happened in Bas the killed Basakas they were home they died just to go in real briefly in some of this that is said in one breath says that it's only so if you fed it and you didn't make it. It's okay. Brought right here on the bring this brings us the Ram also says the Ram adds on. He says that the right afterwards You start a bit earlier. Yeah, you start a bit earlier. But this is already not brought in the gamar. And therefore says that if a person knows that he can't make this addition also all in one breath that he should only do like what the garra says. Of course, if you could do the mig as well, do the mig. But if you know you're not going to be able to do everything, Since it's already speaks about it that says it, right? We say it and then the says it again afterwards. Why? Because since it's been a sometimes the says it so quickly that you might miss hearing a word and if you miss a word you're not one word you're not if al it's but you're rather everybody in the whole sh even if you don't have a kash or migill with you you should still read that par so you have it if you were listening to the bal it's very shy that you didn't you missed a word and you're not yer Another reason you're listening to the you have however over here is only what the baky is reading but this that he says in a one breath you don't have it's a long discussion alapon you don't have another has another thing to be careful about and if you're reading it out of your because the way it's written is each name and then the S. So you should the ace you should make sure that you read the ace of the right name meaning to say is at least the bakari you want to have it inside you say the names and you're saying it quick also so to see on this right line of the ace the the ace that goes to the next the ace parsa then the next a should be the ace on the line of pars to go to the next one not one the of the Gomorrah says right there on the Some say that you should have a big nun. A big nun. A big v. I mean, I'm sorry. You look we talk to have it a big v. The ran says it's not a big v because lisa it's not listed in the big letters. So it's not a he means visasa means that the top of the vavv should be standing up. But I said in the beginning of the share that I'm not going to be speaking about how it's written. This by the way is written in simé alf this simmon had a ride in a however however the ram brings that some say and the the it's brought here in the writing is in the writing of the migillah. So either you can understand the means that you have to be in it but the already say it doesn't mean that you have to it just says make sure to say it clear all the other names don't have a v but you're ready towards the end of your breath make sure when you say visasa to say it clear so these are the of saying I would just like to conclude with one more pointer if that's okay. We spoke about Hammon being killed and of course the Sukum and the McGill say that they were hung was the same day yud gimmel they were hung today maybe we're talking about different children of hama but alapon they were hung in the alanim that we said last night we said this morning by shakas by the suda smaller all than khan at the end of they hung and hmon's children. Now of course we read at the ma hmon as well they hung but the mashy would be they hung hmon vebonov together. Lamisa you could say they they were both they were hung. H was hung like Rashi says he was hung the second day Pes and almost a year later almost a year later were hung okay it's not it's not such a kasha however ini which is a medish inum which we're talking about right now the taragum says they're hung so the sh is what do you mean the hung now it's Ad almost a year later after Ham was hung. What's going on over here? So the Benes answers the following and he says like this. They hung up Hammon the second day of Pes and they kept Hmon hanging for the whole 11 months. Why? because it was important to show people that it's not a joke. In the beginning, there were letters to kill the Eden. Then came new letters seemed to be like one big joke. He kills his wife. He's he's peed him was what's going on over here first. So they had to have Hmon hanging the whole time. Why? So people passed by be the talk of town. The news didn't pass as quick as now. on Hmon was hanging for come out a year and that's what the med says when they hung up the B Hmon it was together with Hmon because Hmon was on that al when it says Alh they hung him they hung him to get on that eight that Hmon was hanging they hung that they're all hanging together says another terret that could be they hung they hung them up again they hung them up to What we find there are those that say that the SP were hung yesterday on Yiml when they were killed to answer the Rambam. I left out that terret I forgot. And then again Esther asked to hang them again. Why? Because Bets took Hmon down because they were hush of a people and Esther said no hang them up again to be maza. They hung up again and did the same thing over here also. Part of that was they also hung up H again.