TAANIS ESTHER & SIMCHAS PURIM – OPPOSING MESSAGES OR Complementary IDEAS

Today's tiny Esther I'm going to try to clarify this morning what's the reason why do we fast Tusc why and to clarify that we have to see what's the m what's the m for the tinus where does it say that you should fast so we'll start with the At the end of migill towards the end of the migill at the end the says the says that we should keep we should keep. And then the PC says just like they kept we should keep pur we should keep pumm tomorrow and Friday just like the fast days were kept. So which fast days we're trying to find a m for this that we fast today tinus. So the says just like we fasted the fast days. You could have learned that the fast days is referring to tinus Esther which means when Esther instituted the fast then there were three days that they fasted and right that's Rashi explains they fastened but the Have an Ezra over here on this PK says that's not what the suk are talking about. Not like people want to understand that theat is referring to the three days not our Esther of Yudgiml but rather maybe you would learn it's talking about the three days that Esther was messaken to fast then before the nace not yud gimmel but rather almost a whole year before right after the came out during the whole m then she went those three days that's not so what is what is the that the is speaking about so says is speaking about the other we actually spoke about it in the past what exactly was the only the month not the day but it was the tiness of tishov of Gdalia and those four. So the PK is saying just like Clus kept and keeps those so too we should keep the Y of Pum that's the just like kept and continues to keep the the other he says he explains because actually wasab on it on their own without even being but over the over here is not at all speaking about the tinus of of tinus but rather the other just was speaking about those three days of to fast three days it's actually brought in this is not the focus of today's sh we're going to try to find we want to know the reason for this. We really want to know the but says that we're not talking about those three days. It's interesting the brings these three days the but are those that fast three days. Not our nothing to do with today. separately to fast three days says those three days are three days after bahab which would technically be next week Monday Thursday and the following Monday not we don't fast let alone not on y because it's falls but even not early we don't fast you don't fast it's So we don't fast in we fast earlier after PM however it's more or less already says that that's not our to fast these three days he says we don't fast. So now let's go back to what we started with to see so what where is yes the murin so this part we really spoke about in the beginning of this when we learned the garraill but we're not the focus then was more mad the garra is when what day but we're going to focus Focus. Now the Gmorra says the Mishna the Mishna says that the man to migill tomorrow and however these earlier days also you bud earlier days as well. So the Gomorrah goes through how do you know each day before the migill just says your gimmel and your dollar and how do you know your base and your gimmel. So Russia for two days. So the says that's for your and I what's with your gimmel. So the says for to be able to say that you don't need a why not that's obvious that what does it mean? So says everybody went today in to war everybody. Sai people and Shushan and Sai other people everybody was as of so was part of the nest we celebrate Purim tomorrow and in the following day because Purim is ale that there was no more war today was actually the war but alabar for that you can for sure read the migill today because today was the literally the day of war it wasn't a war because they didn't fight But I'll was a day that you saw went and so that's a rash. He says you don't need a rush. Good. That's how Rashi learns. However, the rush has shown on it. He brings up also doesn't like he brings Raben understands the gum that says that you don't need a to say that you can read the migill. Why is that? Then before they went out to Israel was miss they came together. They fasted. Then the day of the mud that day. So before they went out to they said and fasted and then they went out to they went out to that's in other words was to they came together they came together then to be to to D and that and there was a tinus it's all on the P this Gmorra in the beginning of this the ninth peri So we're talking about the 13th day of which is today what we call and the says so the rush says from means that all came together on that day to be mpal and says the rash already says it that the concept of being before you find already before he went out to Maliku fasted like the so he says clearly so that's Why then nikaloo they fasted and that's what the garra says that's why if it's nicol you can lain the migilla that's not the discussion here today about why you could read the migilla we're trying to focus where do you see that he was a tinus and ma now also zen says being that then they were mpal the carbonos explains a little more he says yeah clearly says that they went out This is the that we also fast and now I say that's the it's interesting like the he says that we do this is the interesting meaning to say is the other is it's clearly you're not going to find the we tried finding the that says what we mentioned before but is not talking about but because then was they went out before now also so comes that the tiness of today is all the is it originates from a there's even different about it's all for it's everything is different parts we said is they went around they circled the they broke in this is allen the timeess of today has nothing to do with it's not a sad day it's a day that were then they were before so we also we fast we say And therefore, therefore this tinyness is different than all the other tanim. All other tim if it falls out on chabasal could fall out on chabas also we push it further. It's a mission. He learned towards the beginning of the Mishna says that if tisha falls out on shabas is this year I think this year falls out on chabas it's Sunday but I think it's a a well it's always the same thing the just says she says it's to other as well that if it falls out on chabas we push it off if pur would fall out on a Sunday so you can't fast shabas so we Where does where does Tus has to go? You push it back earlier to Thursday. We once spoke about it. Why not Friday? You don't fast on a Friday. But you move it back. Why do you move it back? The Misha says when we don't push it back, we we push it away. We hope not to even fast those. But the terret says this tinus is a different tus. It's a tinus of tiny Esther is a tightness of of it's not a sad day. If it would be a sad day, we talk to push it away. It's not a sad day. It's a happy day. We can move it back. Just the the musk that today is a yah before that. But the Rambam just to bring out that this tiness from the other the first few. So the Rambam begins the Rambam says the Ram continues and what are they? For the next few, the Ram goes through a little further and the Ram explains what service what happened of all the fine. Then he says it's brought in it's brought in in the that's the first again the Rambam says that it's a and goes through all these says that we add. So we see clearly that this timeness the time of today is from the other are sad days today is a rot to bring out the concept of today the roson then they went to be and they went to listen to our so today I read a lotion of the y The kavayasha's rebi today. Anybody that needs anything to d for you should make some time today. It's like a busy day of appearing for some time. He says to say to which the it's it's referring to that she was before she went. In other words, today is to be in the whole which the we also we're learning now tak the the is on this on the weak staff. So this week we're learning a bunch of the whole end of the pay. So the garra says when it says it was to say then and now but then the whole kufur was a concept of Benish to listen to He banged on the doors of it was open. So then there was a tinus that day was but that day that they went out to fight with the enemy. They fasted. They must and they were listened to. So too bismanu the tinus that we have again the m we see is based off nalu that is fasted then we too have the tinus and we have the tinus because now also it's interesting to note on he says that even if a person doesn't fast on tusner a person should know that it's still the even the other also but the other we fast to be to be and to be but here he says it's as we're saying now very clearly today's we fast but even if a person doesn't fast it's It's important whoever is not fasting, the ladies that are not fasting, even if they're not fasting. So very clearly we see based off and the concept of of the day is the day of Just to bring out this musk, this concept that the day is a raam in his to say for a mitzvah is bothered with a galdig question. How could the tell us to do the mitzvah mitzvah read the mill says he's mitzvah no one can be more mitzvah you can't take away does I wouldn't say a couple of lines he explains but I want to pull out how he explains Purim for us tonight we're going to read the migillah tonight's a mitzvah to read the migillah tomorrow it's even but how how did we add the mitzvah of and he says that it wasn't really adding mitz was really something behind the mitzvah and he explains by say it outside then I'll read the words he says it's not that and it's not important for us to know you listen to the to listen but the concept of the migillas to give the handles about how if the migill is the howon he says cus is awak for the nest that happened. So he says like this why why why did tell us to read the why to give so to say it's like this these two parts we need them first of all for the nest for the nest. You see, it was a very scary time. I don't know if we realize gimml today when went out of it was very scary. The ebenezer says it was today. There was still the first that they go with us. They came out with a newer that we're allowed to fight back. It was pretty scary. The evanzer says in that P we started with it was and is like this and that's why started off the day for it was a nest they didn't fight back was it was a nest it was a nest so we read the for the nest what happened but part of it is also a of the nest and b to remember that we must follow the listened. So first of all for that also to let us know that the listens of the listens like this when we read the migilla tonight tomorrow it's a reminder first of all of the nest and second of all then we will listened and So to zak now also now also when we're mispar means when we read the migill to remind us today that it's a bigger a but the concept that when we listen to so we see then the listen it's part of the sagill is the the yud giml that kalia saw before they went they were maspar And that's saying we were saved to the listens. Such a big issue. We have to know today's in particular more than any day a war in the world. Sorus it's a time to sp this mus that claw was po they used to listen to us then when we follow tus I think the he says I didn't see it inside but he explains the difference between that we we play with a drrele which we play from the top And purim is a grogger which we turn the grogger from the bottom. And he explains what's the difference and purim the nest. Purim from the bottom. We were pilow. So from the bottom up we da up on top happened the nest the gro you hold it on the bottom. Yeah that's what we're saying. They must spl before you give them. They must splow 3 days before they mpow now. So we will p from the bottom up. We must spar for the nest as opposed to kaneka wasn't they went out of but that was a nest. The nest that happened was was from lo. But v this time going into Purim the concept the concept is of and we give him a sp and cl listens to our just to conclude the title of the year we spoke about the connection tus really even now It's against find a connection because we're understanding today before we went out and and then we won we were able to we didn't get hurt maybe tomorrow we celebrate Purim but there's another reason for Tus the we mentioned before brings from the Madam which is a safer the wrote when he learned with the ma And he says a different reason. The way how he brings it he says is that we must follow today that our pur should work out. You see purim is a little different than maybe other than other days. It's a day we eat we drink so to speak we call we party. Today we fast to put ourselves in check and that of tomorrow should work out. Actually, if you take a look in the m he says a few more words and he says that the sultan shouldn't be matri is and he brings this out a little more the words of the sultan not being mkatri. He says really the Sultan comes and he says on Poram he says wow what kind of nation do you have over here look at this porm they're eating they're drinking they're getting drunk what's going on so for that the chuva is they're no they're not he look at the day before they fasted they were and then you also see this the same thing he's a mitzvah to eat something comes Whoa. Whoa. Whoa. Tomorrow is And look at this eating. So there also the is yeah they're eating today but look at tomorrow. He explains like that which means when the comes before which is after but another reason why we fast today is to prepare ourselves and to put ourselves in check for tomorrow. So the the first reason we said it's because it was then and another reason is is to to be malaria work out for whatever reason both of the reasons we said why we have tester it comes out is and let's move in how we could talk a fast says of even you're not a fast. So how do we fast today? The ter is it's not a fast like we began. It's not a fast of a sad day. It's actually a fast a day of of it's a day. And just to conclude, we have to understand when we read the migilla a lot a lot of times when you read it even in the beginning of the migill you're reading that hippo it's it's like okay Hama missed the boat we have to understand that really in the beginning it was it was it was a signed it was a clear signed moving along so that's really what we have over here today is a he of that day the three days and today is the of that first day. A day to be we should be to be able to utilize the day to and also to follow that our pur should be a pur of the proper aid.