PARSHAS CHAYEI SOROH: EXPORTING PRODUCE FROM ERETZ YISROEL - HALACHIC CONCERNS

This week's para goes to find >> and um when he gets there it's fine. Anyways, he gives to Rifka Clay and then he says he gives also to the to Rifka's brother and mother McDonald. Alza gave Mcdon. What's McDonno? So Rashi says McDonald from the Medish. Mcdon is Pisro. Eleazar gave to Rifka's brother and mother Piser Israel. The Shila is how did Elazzar take out Pyus from Israel? It's a Gomorra. The Gomorrabas says from you know how to take out Paris. So how did take out Paris? It's not brought at the rush and not in his son the tour but the brings it al take out. So how did Elazzar take out pis for merit to give when he went out to so says who saidl did alzar was mine the mitzvah but liser elzar what he brought he didn't have anything he was what he gave he was giving what a had from a means a gave him perus he sent along pyus so how did he take pyus out of how did av give alis to take out of another point the ramban says that even though the were but only inherit not so this was in but however the is when you take the pis out of so take out the pis from scroll Does it make a difference that he didn't give it to him? He gave him the notes. He can go into the fridge and take whatever he wants. He took it and he went on. >> You say maybe Ali did it did it only on his own. He it wasn't wrong. >> You're working in the house. You can take food. He >> So we'll get to it soon. Even if you're going to want to be that it was al that did it on his own. We're going to see soon that we find it later on as well. Also, we'll be mash. We'll get to that momentarily. Let's be in the and soon we're going to get so let's first be the of taking Paris out of the Gmorrah says you're not to take out Paris why because of [clears throat] which means of it should be sustainable to be able to live in if you take out the pay how people supposed to be how are people able to live saw how to take out the Paris. But the Gomorrah gives an example. What type of Paris you know how to take out? The Gomorrah says three examples. Oil, wine, and flour. Three examples. What you not to take out wine oil and flour. Is the gammor giving an example all pays are asser or these are the pists that are if you learn that only these three pis are so then you're allowed to take out oranges you're allowed to take out other fruits you're allowed to take out so then you could say that when it says mcdonza gave pis he gave other pis however if you learn that the gmorrah says a blanket is meaning to say is every single peri from Israel is also so then we have a sha how did alza take up paris the mishna on raam as well as also the mishna who is the bisv he says that when the gmorra says it's all pis it's only an example what we're talking about but really any pyus living if there's no Flour. Of course, you need flour to live. But if not, then these other any is considered take any take out. You could say that it didn't have a diner to scroll yet. And as I say before in the Rambam, the Rambam says in of Trumas, whoever it says, including this Gomorrah that the Gmorra says to take out there was however was and he brings a filament, it's still not considered So in other words is only later on when took it as opposed to earlier and nothing is in such a type of so that's why you able to take out Paris because this at the Gmorra says you want to take up Paris it didn't have a diner and the emmesis that would You see it later the it says that later it's going to be easy but that there was no yetroa and even though like you wanted to say could be did not of we find later when it was already erit gave to Mal the queen he he gave Mcdana Nice. So how did he give he gave her to take adv? We just answered that maybe you know why Alza was able to do it because it didn't have a dinner yet but when did it say from written by that's already later when they went into he was and it says that gave to the queen to take an of [snorts] so on the shila about Elzar how he took pisitrol out of the IM answered for that and he said that when Alzar went on the sozar of gave him the fruit had fruit to take along for a few days till he gets out of but was supposed to take him let's say three days took a day took an hour so he ended ended up with the fruit of scroll not he didn't plan on taking it out of stroll but because of the that's why he was he had to payroll out of answer this question so the IM's terror only answers alzar as we mentioned before also gave perus it was a ready scroll and nothing to do with the answer is and with this we're going to start going into the about taking out of the again the Gmorra says he now to take Paris out of has a safer on it's called and he says on this he's an exception what's the exception mu you're allowed to do a little bit you're allowed to if you go to visit and they have some good sabra fruits some good fruits but on a minimum you want to take out a little bit it's mut it's mut why is it mut the reason why you're not allowed to take out fruits of aritrol is to be able to live in aritis if you do mass export so you're taking out the fruits from aritis there's going to be no fruits fruits to eat. It's going to be expensive. Even the fruits that are there, there's not enough fruit. It's going to become expensive like a year in things get expensive. These less available they bring in from it's if you're going to send out fruits from it's going to become expensive. There will be no fruit or there'll be but it'll be expensive. So to take out a little bit of mut a little bit of muta the terret is very positz of course alzar took out fruit but he took out only a little bit a little bit of mut the same thing is also you find yak of au sent down he told his kids theatim to take he sent a little bit of to So there was a little bit you're allowed to a little bit you're allowed to. And also the queen didn't need a whole truckload of anything like Rashi brings over there. He gave her fruits that are unique and he gave a little bit. He didn't have to give a whole mass export. He gave some fruits some butter. I'll pee this im has a chuva. He says this but he also has a cha to explain why in those days people who went to course not like today hop on a plane there was a whole somebody came back from the whole town came to hear what's going on in they used to bring back a bottle of wine so the shilas had allowed to bring back wine as a matter of fact wine is one of the examples that the garra says wine is clearly lyer other fruits we spoke before maybe it's not included a shil but wine the garam says yus is she says the terret is ma is mut a little bit you're allowed to so what we have so far is which is important now we're going to move away from the para and go into the general of now you know how to take our pis so it's like this taking out pis is stroll a little bit. You go to stroll, you want to bring back a a bottle of wine, you want to bring back a beautiful estrig or any pis you want to bring back, you're allowed to. Of course, we're talking about being from I mean bringing in customs, that's that's a different story. I'm saying in the you're allowed to bring you're allowed to bring uh So what is the shila? The shila is laisa. You see that we bring in masses the simple things you see is wine. We just answer them hot. You go into the wine store a quarter, a half, a third is wine. Samaritan stroll shipments containers come of wine. What other paris? So first of all, there's a lot of other pirates that you could buy from stroll. You have to be careful. Truma, you're going to Costco. These uh jaffa oranges, you have to be careful. You need truma mistress a year of shmita. It could be its own set of questions, but those are sent big productions. We're talking about sending it out. I don't think these are of once it's here, it's to take out. But if it came that it came to I didn't see anybody to say but how's how how people how do they send it out and I think the the top question is wine and astrogum is how do you take it out so if you're you find a beautiful is one thing but the way they send out thousands tens of thousands of so what's the some people say people don't eat that interesting before what you're saying are people we mentioned before that could be it's what the Gmorra says wine oil and flour and then is not included but if you learn when the garra says peris So pyus how the the bio says means all types of pyus. So you want to know but maybe it's only pis that you eat. Interesting. He's saying it's not it's not something that I mean you can make a little bit jelly but that's not is maybe apples oranges but is not such a fruit they eat interesting maybe even like that means all but you're saying this wouldn't be included interesting so let's see the say a few let's go through each hatter slowly and we'll There'll be a between obviously some pis other let's go through the first is the reason why you're not allowed to take peris like we said is that people should be able to live there if you're going to take out the papis there won't be fruit to eat and even if there is a little bit of fruit already that you're leaving over it'll be super expensive so you're not letting people live there says the Today the there are so many even after sending out tens of thousands you go to go forus he's even there's thousands of so in in talking about in the concept of not taking out because there won't be left for there's plenty ofum not only that or anything even fruits let's say oranges jaff oranges. There's plenty plenty to find over there. Says that if you're not going to we're not going to send it out. It's not like that there'll be more and it'll be cheaper. They're just going to dump it. They'll throw it out. There's plenty. There's no shortage. No shortage. The garra says you'll take out to be able to live. There's plenty. So this is for anything for wine. Even with though there's so much wine that comes out there's plenty of wine in it plenty plenty mut even not ma another terret he says and this is also brought in the marsham the one we know his grandfather the marsham he says that if you plant it to take it out it's mut if you plant it to take it What's the idea of it? First of all, when you plant it, you're being But furthermore, when you plant it, not because it was planted is if not you wouldn't have planted it. You're planting it to take it out. If these pis growing and you're taking out the pyus, so then you you're causing that there should be there's not enough Paris. But if you planted to take it out means if you're not taking out these pis you would have never planted it. So let's motor a third sad hatter. A third sad hatter. So we said hatter number one is that that these plenty even after taking out these plenty. Number two is that it's planted to take out. Number three that sad the iminoim says is this that the Gomorrah says is aer is only if everybody listens if everybody listens not to take out so then you're not allowed to take out but these go Arabs live and they do the export so we we should just be on the losing end not to do the export to me let's when the garra says you now to take out py it's just if everybody in listening to hide the and you listen to this then don't take out Paris but if pis are going out anyways so the yeden should be the one losing out though it's not about losing out even if the Arabs are taking pyis out but if the reason not to take out is because he's not going to be enough so all the more if the Arabs are taking our pis we for sure shouldn't take our papis that there should be enough >> the government is the one of the stable experts in the doz This is written before the Israeli government. So they there was no for the yeen. It didn't make a difference. Didn't make a difference. The go were sending out. So he says if the go sending out we could also send out but they they're sending out but there's still somewhat pay us left. And now if we're also going to send out there'll be nothing left. Then there's yet another hatter. Another hater says in other pkim that it enables parnosa meaning to say is sending out pis but if you're sending out pis and it brings in money so then you have the money. The reason you can't take out Paris is if you're sending out as so then there's no Paris in but if you're sending out and now there's money so there's money in a stroll says this another why you can take out all now before going to the the we said a few now why you allowed to take out pis And the all these are all for wine and but let's just sum up and make it clear that if you learn the gor that only the three means so then we need all these only for wine for because the gar never if you learn the gra that every single pies to take out. So we have to come on to these different why you're allowed to it's actually causes by planting you did it by springing it out money comes in these are all that start [clears throat] let's go in a little bit now into the in the has a long cha and he goes on this that says that it's Mut and he's basically Mat that there's no Elz there's no Rya cuz he was no Isra that sent down was she was trying to save his kids so there's no that sent is talking about that were on those pists are not included in the iser but says to in general it's user it's user to take out Paris. However, he's talking about oil. In his days, the discussion was to bring oil from eritis and he says that it's asser >> what it say >> sorry just the we said three. So wine, oil and flour. >> The discussion it seems like they were they weren't bringing out flour and they weren't wine wasn't the med was oil. So from this chuva would only come out when he's talking about oil as which would be the same thing as wine. the he wouldn't be happy to be m to take out wine from what's about he doesn't speak about a meaning to say his other parents >> what says go you say >> you're saying from him you would see that could be taken everything is cuz if not he could have just said to other Paris >> to interesting even though you're saying even though he's speaking about oil but it's lava oil I I I'm asking that he only speaks about oil it could be of paris but he bring what is by alzo was able to do it because didn't yet that's why the is came much later said that it's talking about other pis it could be talking even from also very good it's talking about also the other pis In Shilu ina he has a a very long cha pages on pages that he speaks about taking out of that's not the discussion in today's year a few years ago an owl of matsoita was stillmita then bringing aim for sukus that would be right aftermita We spoke here in the a whole she of taking out but that's not the discussion. Most of the chuva of the dri is speaking about taking out which is a separate discussion. But he has one piece in the middle of the chuva. And then he goes into in a general taking out aim [snorts] of a whole long not just on a year of topic. Now we're not talking about one or two. We spoke already about it that to take out if you inherit a scroll and you want to bring an estrig, you inherit a stroll, you want to bring a bottle of wine. That's not a shila. It's mut. It's mut. We're talking about how could you send containers and shipments, big shipments, mass export. >> Maybe because you're not going to eat it and it's all >> if you're not allow to take it out because of you can't take it out. So the oil says that about taking out it's a big sh I'm not getting involved. He says it's a big he brings that his father the kaducious yam held its but he says like this he says one interesting point he says we said earlier that taking out is good for because when you sell it it brings in money says the oil very nice. Who does it bring in money for that one farmer? He makes it he has he has a lot of money. He'll build himself a big house. Very nice. But it doesn't bring in money for everybody init. He doesn't say it's user but he says it's interesting this he brings this thing. He says it is go send that. So it's true the farmers and the workers those few people ta make a lot of money but everybody else is is without the so he doesn't say it's he says It's not the right thing. So just to conclude and to sum up, we started this year speaking about this week's par how he took out it was before different but just to conclude in the general that's a and it's brought you to take. So he said mu a little bit you're allowed. So if you go to and you want to bring back a small amount of pay take out of it's mut what's the to take masses to take out a a huge shipment. So the first s is could be if it's not wine oil and flour it's mut and obviously are not included but what's about taka to bring out wine. So we saw we saw many that the garra says you're not allow to take out but by taking out it actually causes whether if it was planted whether if it brings in money it would be mut so the fact is it's brought but it's interesting to note you're going out to buy wine wine of the gar says you're not going to take out Is it mutisa how they did it? That's that's a madra. That's a sh. Have a wonderful shabas.