PARHASAS SHEKOLIM BEFORE AND AFTER CHURBAN BEIS HAMIKDOSH Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner from 2022

This week's shar is on the cre of parolum which is in the for this shabas parum which interesting falls out of but it's also last week's staff that we're holding as well as just um interesting to note the cre of parish skullum usually falls out on mishbatum on a regular year Being that it's uh Shaunamu Mubaris this year, it falls out of Aayak. It could also fall out of Paras Truma as well as Paras Pud. It's interesting information shared by Rabb Heber. We're going to clarify the what used to be as well as the decree then the now the cre is not we're not going into regular crea of every shabas which is also notice he's a Yeah. However, even though it's not it's in the beginning of says that it's somewhat more than a regular says which means like this we know is we spoke about it a couple of weeks ago when it was relevant on the blot. The question is from this is not however. [snorts] However, he says which is also week is good. You do it. You have a minion. So, there's no minion. There's no here. You have a obviously you're laying it when you have a minion. I don't know if you're laying without a minion, but there's a to listen to the cre of the also says more than a regular over here. First he says he you should say person should be careful to listen to every word of clearly the next piece he says it's but a person should be careful to listen interesting Think the Rajba when the Rajba speaks about the D parist the Rajbah says so the understands what's the is also that is the the doesn't say it in the but understands But the decree of is brings from one of the and the way how quotes it that the from the himself says that it's the the of the G is he brings what we had what we said from how to learn in the it's not but he says he says like this he brings also possibly maybe will give a share in it but he says clearly that parcolum the tree of parish is also Isa if you take a look we have nowisuda and I clearly inside he doesn't say that is he says the same thing so he says just like the but he doesn't say that is I'll call upon Even if it's not we see that the crem is more than a regular creatur person should be careful to listen to it properly what's the reason what's the reason for the cre of why why so the garra this is last week's staff the garra the says we reach zomor brings a mishna a mission in the first mission in skullum. says that there was a few things that were done the soul should bring as well as also and the Gmorra explains what was the gather like the says it was an announcement whether you clapped on the beimo you made an allowed speaker announcement. He made an announcement that people should bring dash as well as also climb because it's the time now that it starts getting a little warmer and you start planting but you have to be careful with climb. So the the Mishna in says that there was ones whenever was during the week on Shabas he made an however if we turn back to our Mishna our Mishna seems to say something else the Mishna says you do it on Shabas it's on Shabas and if it's during the week it's also you push it back to Shabas Now you could learn that the garra and the Mishna are the same thing. The gar meaning to say is the schol that's the same thing as our mishna says which means in the it seems to me these two things and the spells it out clearly there were two types of one was a an announcement onesh regardless of whenish was during the week on shabas he made an announcement oneshight It's time to bring scalab. And then there was another another part which was on shabas and it was daf on shabas and that was a ka of parishes kisa which we're going to l shabas the ka of parolum two separate taconus one was a cre one was a ka ka which we do on shabas dapka was also to let people know to bring skullum and another not through the tora but regular announcement verbally to tell people to bring that was done onesh there are three shas that have to be clarified but again very clearly from the Mishna migill that we're learning now and the Mishna and is that there were two announcements one was an announcement that was onesh regardless of when fell out and That wasn't through reading it in the Tory just made an announcement a proper announcement. These another which is the mission by us which is through reading parish taking out of reading parish. That was another three things have to be clarified. Number one why do you need two hakas? Why do you need two? One should be enough. Either the of reading in the Ty on Shabas or the that's done ones just a proper announcement. Why do you need both? Both of the it's two different types. One is from a one is just an announcement. But both of them is to accomplish that people should bring the skullum. So one of them should be enough. The one shot. How many times you heard something at shop sound like a came around forgot about it >> really? And then the one during the week is like okay >> a reminder. You're saying that the the one during the week is a reminder what we landed on Shabas. So you have a good point. So why don't we just do during the week? We should just do during the week. >> Doesn't have a racing point. I hear interesting interesting the asks and he says like this we need both we need during the week an announcement for the places let's say the villages that don't have a minion so they don't have ka satyra how are they going to know the terrorists they know through an announcement but why is that not enough cuz la announcement not everybody shows up to that announcement where Whenever you're going to make the announcement, whether if you do it in shul if there's no there is people miss the announcement. So we do it we have a of shabas. So you need both. Again you need the announcement cuz not everybody has why can't you only do the announcement cuz not everybody not everybody's going to show up to the announcement. people that random people come to another reason he says why we have the of not just the announcement because the announcement is just it's time to bring theum time to bring the another the mil is is that it has all the so that's another reason to have the ka more than just an announcement so we have clearly exp- Explain why we have s the announcement onesh and s the of on why can we have both onesh itself meaning to say is it's true we need a cre of skull Because announcement not everybody shows up. So if you have ka sat for the people that come to ka sat but why can't you have both onesh the announcements were made onesh regardless of the day of the week shabas or was a Sunday any way any day during the week still you made the the was made onesh so the we have a foresh let's add another why do we do it on shamas Why do we do it on Shabas? The reason why we do it on Shabas is because not everybody comes during the week. Maybe not the Davin, not the creatur. So it's a more it's a better time if we're doing the creatur. So maybe if we're already doing that, we're doing the ka the rather do it on Shabas during the week. So again we may of why you need two types and not only we also need a in the why do we do the ones because that's the proper time 30 days before to tell people to bring why do you bring for the true fores for carbon we also have the reason for is as we explained more people come to we do it on shabas why on shabas because that more people come on Shabas. Finally, the third question is why do we fine we I understand why paralum is on chabas but why do we do it on chabas the week before maybe we should do it the week afterwards right let's say for this week is Thursday Friday and we laid it the whole week before why before maybe afterwards So the mat says that we want to give people a full 30 days to be able to give the skullum. Person has the whole ad to be able to give and then by when we stop bringing the carbonas we bring like the garb says what we bring the carbonus from the car from the new collection. So the new collection takes time for the whole month of the whole month of the whole month of >> what say >> average but we have no the reason why we have the people that are going to miss >> that has to be first >> it's not about first or last the question really is why does it have to be the shabas before what can it be the later shabas after >> what you said from the One is one and you can have the radish number >> really not not ones that when [clears throat] it means they're both that's what it is. It's we would re we like doing with the because when we read the par of we know also but they're both they're announcements to tell people it's time to give but why do we have to make the announcement to shabas before maybe do it afterwards so for that explains the m you want to give people a full 30 days we explained and clarified the gather of the crea It's a It's a reminder to tell people to bring reminder during the week, a reminder on Shabas. It's a reminder. What's about which we do not bring? The reason we do not bring the reason the Makash is for carbonus. We don't have carbon. We don't have Makash. We don't bring Makash. So what what's the crea? We don't do the we don't do the we don't have the we don't have the we don't do the but the we do do what's the idea of the crea so the explains we don't have the mdash carbon and we don't even we don't have the shackle the paris. So we always the minute is to lane the the par of the shabas before or if it falls out is the shabas of but to read the par of it's not clear from the itself if the is to what we used to lame what do we want to remember we want to remember that then also we read or the is actually we read tomorrow in we're going to hear the cre of what why are we reading why it's for either that was we used to also read it or even more it's a for of the of the butai It's even more. It's more than just a lavush. We'll see as well. The lavush says based off the gammor later. It's next week's blot for almost finishing the when we finish the we're going to go back to the that we skipped on the migill the gar says the discussion between so said they could bring them so said what's going to be when there's no migdash Where's the kapar going to come from? So the said that if you read the par of it's actually on this week's brings this brings this but the gar says that it's that when we read the par of tomorrow shabas we're going to read the par ofum by reading the par of it's like we brought scholum the bin [snorts] which is a brother was a brother of the we mentioned before he actually even mentions it but he has a chuva and he says he he clarifies this and he says that even after the we read the par of and he says that even by reading it it's we bring the he explains means like that the two if you take a look in the will have a different meaning tomorrow by decree the paris which we read a few weeks ago but we're going to read it tomorrow to focus on these two there's a few but these two then the next again of why does it have to say twice? Yes, the which was brought for carbon was why does it say twice explains the first is when we bring the wasapor the corpon the second one is and we read the cre of that And also why is because when we read it's we bring the he shows maybe it's even more than one place but he shows it in the for those who say yus even the places that don't say yus let's say yam there are those Dominican klet in Lakewood they say dollar parishes they say anyways in the regardless if you say it or not it's in the in other words what we're saying the with our lips with our the should we brought to we brought the carbonas so that's the says twice. One is a man. brings the same concept that we just said right now from his exactly this that the even and he also tes which also says twice and he says on uh on the rules we were. So we were twice twice we we didn't listen to the was twice for both of those times. So maybe I have like this part one of this year we spoke about the crea we saw that it's more than a regular ka and as we're explaining now in part two the crea even bismanu is not just a but it's actually a creia and the part three of today's sh the final part is now that we know these Ka cy manabias he's a crea now when we read the crea of parcolum do you take out a second safer tyra do you take out a second saferra why is it a shl now the other of the dalat parishes it's very far away to read not next week the following week next week shabasak like the garbas calls it following. So from it's very far we take out it's far very far. So like we learned already we're not we learned a few ago we take out a second say you can't be what's about the cre of paras of to our para now if it's the same para better even if it's para says the we don't take for which as I began And this year Bismu based off the calendar the creed only falls out on a sometimes and a usually and sometimes depending if but it doesn't fall out if it would fall out. So then it's very neat. You finish the cru of and you just go right into there isn't even a sha that never happens. We do not have a cre of mainly but you have to be go a little bit like let's let's say this week not terrible but you have to be go this week is par we'll be going back to literally to last week's para it's being go the whole vay into the beginning of kisa. So do you take out two separate taras and I see you have to be only one. If you take a look in the tough pay for the says that falls out on Shabas, you take out three, right? If falls on Shabas, what's the three? the parishes and scalab [snorts] it's actually gor our gumra this week's d brings it if it's on shabas it's three sepra z two giml par what' I say gimmel two Then you read the week before like like us. [clears throat] So then you read it the week before but he doesn't say anything about taking out two sitra. It's a pretty that you don't take you don't take out two the four and before by everyone he felt it very clear and necessary to say you take out first three the other ones two see hey a year like this year he just says doesn't say about taking anything we have the same Yes. Yes. Yes. Very good. Thank you for pointing out this sh we want to know about one or two nothing to do with it has to do with when it's not shabases. When it's shabasesh that's clear three like the gumar says and the reason for three is because par let's say is then all the way in and then all the way back. So it's three for there for sure we're not from all the way back but what's about a year a week where it's the week before is only two and do you take out seem not in the he brings that the was to only take out one safer Tyra they bring brings from Kachinsky that says that the was only one however first of all the you're looking at me one is two separate that's the is two sephyra and it's like thatish The clearly that you take out two even a week like this week. The Rambam says you read the the second clearly. He goes through very clearly that you take out two and says in the on the he asks on the why is it what's the it's one you have to be and the that we said that the was one in they bring that to said no the took out one time there was a story that he was a hush of a person in the And he made he made a whole he made noise. You should only take out one. It's close by. They only took out one. But the wasra and that the isra. So just to wrap up, we began we said that the cre is a is a but it's also and the minus have to be even though it's not a long not a long you don't it's not far away but have to be earlier we take have a wonderful shabas where we lose