Maseches Chagiga - Mitzvas Simcha on Yom Tov Then and Now

the previous learning we saw there are three mitz in the every y the a Mitzvah of Al and to bring a carbon there a Mitzvah the second Mitzvah to bring a Caron and the third Mitzvah is the Mitzvah that was the last year on is it just they bring the carbon as well we saw there are three mitv the we learned it what's about that's going to be the focus in today's she sorry the text didn't go out but that was the title the MIT what could you be man so let's go and order Alo as we spoke in the previous the is to go into the B mdash as well as bringing a carbon the carbon obviously we don't have we don't have a says that the Min was even after to be the r brings it it's brought later I think the brings it whether it's a what exactly the was to go to the but it was a Min so we don't have the first Mitzvah we don't have the second Mitzvah carbon we also don't have we don't have a carbon the third Mitzvah the Mitzvah of as we explained it's eating as well as maybe bringing the carbon we also don't have that p as we explained is not a it's a that was said on but we it tells us that when the says it means the however what's the a Mitzvah and we're going to get into it exactly as the gor says how says we're going to elaborate and explain that part but to answer the question is there a the third mitvah theah says yeah there is a Mitzvah is the mitvah or only the third could we as well brings the same that the says that it's only we have a mitvah the says we have a Mitzvah is it or is it what's the what's the is is whens and we just saw the says is it or could you be with other items that brings if you learn it's only like we spoke in the previous year that it's bringing a carb and it's so then it's very nice what the gar says but where do you come up with the T says and we learn from you could be is anything that's so so far we have clearly has an with I'm not going to go into it you could be behind you can see that the there is mid mid and says in the end of that's the so says [Applause] so one of the one of the three of the third it's worthwhile to note that the Mitzvah of this third mitah is different than the other two Mitzvah as we learned in the BL of the gor the Mitzvah of R is once over y to be to bring a carbon handle about the is once the mitvah is a mitvah every single day of and is one dayus these a MIT clearly the right at the beginning that's the beginning of the says clearly and write down the says clearly that the aah even so now let's try to SP spend a few minutes to clarify how to be the Mitzvah how could you be how could we be so we saw the says how are so the gar says to drink wine very clear tus actually explains was only it's beon beon with wine anything else anything else besides wine so the r the says a person is supposed to be happy on and then the rabam goes through how it what's for the ladies what's for the kids maybe that'll be a separate sheer at some point in this Mitzvah what ladies they are but how and [Applause] what the r adds meaning to say what we saw in the gor B wine the r says wine but the r adds on to eat B where does the ra get BOS from asks on the r how does the r know that you need to eat the ra says you eat meat if you look in the G the the G says how does me that's what asks and as a matter of a fact and that's what Thea points out that's why the who wrote when he wrote when he says the mitvah he does not bring BOS cuz if you you learn the gamar the gamar doesn't say BOS so how do how does where does the ram get BOS from it is interesting that the actually doesn't bring wine also not but for that if you go back to the does bring wine even though is really referring to the wine of Kes which I think See Clearly about the pasas you could be y with that wine you drank wine pasas but if anyone has a good if you could please sheare but says to drink wine on already speaks about it but he doesn't M doesn't say anything about BOS because he's no Mitzvah to eat BOS the r says that there is a Mitzvah to eat BOS so what's the hez what's the so the explains the the says the following when the says is [Music] explains Mitzvah as opposed to Wine as we we're going to explain as opposed to Wine but now we don't have that BOS why was with the BOS as we spoke in previous refers to talking about that we don't have it we're going to explain it soon we'll see what what does it mean I don't fully understand what the means we're going to see clearly we're going to explain it but why like thear brings a we find in a that refers to wine that makes a person happy what's about BOS we only find makes a person happy only so in the says that makes a person happy we don't have but why wine because he's a to say that wine is good very good gal that you're bringing up this point this is M we're going to get to I learned it over and over and over it's not clear just he's just focusing on the wine and he's focusing B so what exactly what's what's with the BOS is it part of the could you be with either or let's continue on and let's see how to how to break it down that you brought it up says the reason why because that tells us that is do you need both we want to focus is it only wine is it wine and meat do you need both so the the says the following when when the so so one one more point in the B before we go to yam when the G how explains means he's not say it's not not meat but so explains the following and I think it's the that says that theam is an explanation in the the says like this there is no to be without to be you have to have meat never when the gor says means only Bas not that you cannot drink wine but even if you don't drink wine to they ate B even if they drank water with the wine they will as opposed to of course you have to eat B if you don't eat boser there's nothing what to talk about you got to eat meat in addition to the meat because it's not B it's a lower level of this meat that we're eating so you also have to drink wine you also have to drink wine means when the G says it's not like you understand you learned the over there means only the means you have to add on additionally to also have wine so what comes out if we stop right here we end the right here what comes out very clearly what do you need meat and wine even though the says wine wine is an addition to meat so that's so far that would be in the when the says actually says it's both you for sure need meat but the meat is a lower level of wine you need both you need both work so you need meat that's interesting could you have with wine I don't know I don't know interesting it's a good it's clearly it's clearly you were supposed to eat B it's pretty clearly the sh is just if you had eat any we spoke about it last time with the I don't think you could eat not part of the to have not but it's interesting if someone did it you have the you don't the at the same time they add up they add up together it's interesting do you have to eat it together it's a good I don't know does it have to be together the kid wouldn't work said before yeah yeah yeah to have and if if it's the same time what's together in the same time within two minutes within seven minutes together Mish no no interesting it's a good shot I don't know you need both you need both does it have to be together says when you have things that you need to have them together what's considered together what's not we're not saying even even what's normal if somebody has a long sud it's yum if he has a two three hour suda so it has to be Mish by the meat course could he drink the wine earlier by the by the fish by the Entre what say why would we assume they the reason why a go to that it should be together is because if you need a combination of two things to be so if you have BOS let's say 12:00 and you have wine 5:00 so it brings you somewhat 12:00 and somewhat really the understanding is is that it should bring you to somewhat of a climax of sim which means to be together you need both it's not because these two you have to do two things like by we said you have to bring a carbon you have to be here it's really how to get a high level of what you which what we don't have so to go to be together to be maybe to bigger also goes like the yam that you need both but with a little bit of a tweak the says b that you need wine and B the meat is it's very clear to be you need both you want you need wine and you need meat in the also says you need both but the reason why you have to eat meat why we're not sure what brought us to was it just the meat itself or because it was meat sh him if it's the meat itself so B you have to eat meat as well but if it's meat sh we don't have it so it's a suff we don't know when we eat the meat today if it's like like the meat so it says the wine of course you need wine the says wine the Mitzvah but in addition to that meat like the but the meat is another way to understand let's call it another way technically it's even a third Mahal another way in says so either we explained the first side is that you just need both you need a second side is also boss of but the boss is a third side is the bat maybe the of the in addition which I think you could explain every single day of should drink wine to enhance the you should also BOS and the Miss says the same in as we saws and it's to drink wine like I don't think he quotes it to eat meat that's and he says that's the so just to sum it up either both [Applause] or and now we see another is in listen to this it's either wine or meat you see up until here before the the was in addition also BOS and if you don't like wine I feel bad but the that'ss the Mitzvah like the G says the we saw in addition BOS either both or says it's either wine or meat and he's like that Ram when the rambam says we're all coming off the rambam this whole Shear is going on the rambam cuz before the rambam you learn the the says and we saw and we could close up shop but because the r says BOS wow so we is BOS coming so we saw it's whole part of the says when the r says b it's either or wine or BOS and when the r says okay eat meat and drink wine it's very interesting the ra kind of splits it up what couldn't just say splits up you could only have with b and you could only have with wine why is it not one you could only have with wine and meat the Ra's coming to say either or is lastly and with this this is the final she with this I conclude there's yet another she so what do we have so far either you both you both and meat is a sopic meat is only a fourth side which we just said now is either meat or wine and yet is's another side the marula wrote a he actually rode his safer in Gaza his yard was just now the end of kin and he's buried in kin in the safe for the he says that these a Mitzvah with anything that makes a person happy doesn't have to be Ying doesn't have to be BOS or let me correct myself I don't know if it's right to say it doesn't have to be Yin or if it means in addition you also M by eating chocolate cake if you like it or n I'm not sure if it's not y but he says let's see the loan you're asking good is it it's but or drink but he brings a he brings a from the let me just talk a see first marul let's see the itself he says you have to any food or any drink that's is it only food just that we began with the and then it brings up until now we was saying anything that make a person happy you want to what say sounds like not so I don't know the gamar says be I don't know if he's saying you could do other things you could have Nash and chocolate cake and chocolate instead of but he he says that anything that you could do that'll make you happy so to sum it up just to sum up what we had in today's she very clearly we said and that's the third of the three on we have theah how could you be the Mitzvah one is you have to eat she doesn't bring it's just wine but one she is you have to drink wine and eat meat one sheet is the same sheet you have to eat meat but only one sheet is you have to drink wine to eat BOS is a the next is it's either or you can be the either by drinking wine or by eating meat and yet what we saw now the last sheet is in addition I don't know if it's instead but you can be with other foods not just with wine and with meat have a wonderful shabas