Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
KORBAN PESACH SHENI – SOURCES & REASONING FOR DIFFERENCES & SIMILARITIES TO PESACH RISHON
10 views
Shiur from 2020
Categories:Torah/Yamim Tovim
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Just a quick announcement before we
start. The record the conference as well
as the zoom is muted.
And despite it
all Hashem the sheer is a type of sheer
that we encourage questions. It's a
noise of a noise in
but just it's not possible with the
background noise. So as Hashem at the
end of the sheer I'll unmute the YouTube
the conference call as well as anybody
on zoom can unmute themselves if they
have a question.
Tonight sheer as Hashem is on the topic
of Pesach Sheini which is really a topic
relevant to the color by care.
So
of course we asked that night coil to
join in.
This Friday
as Hashem is Pesach Sheini you download
the year.
Which the Torah teaches us and passes by
a life score the Torah says somebody who
missed the first Pesach behind it to
bring a carbon Pesach Pesach we shine
on you download Nissan
should bring the carbon Pesach Pesach
Sheini.
And the reason why you find it a
particular to Pesach we shine and pay to
carbon Pesach as opposed to anything
else.
Look the since carbon Pesach comes to
teach us
on a very important limit of a moon
so the mail of people not to lose out on
a moon and a mail of
these are second chance at carbon
Pesach.
We're going to as Hashem be the war in
tonight's sheer we're going to be the
war some what theme in our applicable
Pesach Sheini
as a Pesach we shine and what what is
not.
In the partial of Pesach we shine and
Pesach Sheini the possic in by a life
score pay rate test possic in was at the
possic by a boss a young McCoy bishop by
a mirror by him pass away to the my
adult so the possic speak my Pesach we
shine to call who call you soft
who who call me spot of pass away say
speaking about when you do the carbon
Pesach when you bring the carbon Pesach
like the possic you should do a call who
call you call you soft who call me spot
of pass away say. Rashi explains and the
McCoy of Rashi is the Gamora and talking
that the came at all.
To call who call you soft is speaking
about mix with Sheba go for Sheba go for
means of the go for the carbon Pesach
what's the go for the carbon Pesach that
it has to be a set it has to be tall
name has to be a Zohar been shown on
in other words what type of heft of a
carbon Pesach does it have to be what
type how is the what defines a carbon
Pesach set tall name Zohar
so that's to call who call you soft to
call me spot of that Rashi mix with go
for what's mix with go for
in other words we know what the set is
but when you bring the set these are a
certain noise sir you have to sleep
actually sure by
and then these are third in
which we learn out the Gamora says it's
called go for which means these are
excellent carbon Pesach these when you
bring the carbon Pesach these D name how
to bring the carbon Pesach and then this
is called go for which is D name that
are knowing the shots of voice carbon
Pesach for an example let's focusing now
Pesach we shine these are mix with
what's matter these are Easter value raw
value matter these are D name applicable
with the matter carbon Pesach but not
relevant not to the carbon Pesach itself
as well as not relevant also to what's
comes with the carbon Pesach which means
you know that actually sure by
or any of such D name.
The garden Pesach Sheini the possic says
right there over there by a life score
possic in all of that the possic by a
day show a Sheini by a ball also young
by a mirror by him yes who also a matter
of room you call and the possic says
the D name these are a certain noise sir
the actually sure by to call who call
you soft Pesach yes who also
what the possic says to call who call
you soft Pesach yes who also which means
mix with go for when you bring the
carbon Pesach it has to be the same type
of carbon Pesach as Pesach we shine.
The all go for these are D name when you
bring it how to bring the carbon Pesach.
And then these are third in which the
Torah really says the possic says all
matter some room you call you have to
eat matter and more.
So we have spoken in the past in the
previous years in carbon Pesach we went
through the mix of a helix matter
and we even went out with
a lot of my sir this matter that eating
the car eating matter do you eat it you
download you eat it as well of I'm not
going to repeat it
as I when I try to repeat a sheer
I get reminded that I will knows it's
about Hashem so we're not going to speak
about it the whole lot everything we're
going to speak about tonight is as
Hashem new not spoken in previous sheer
on Pesach Sheini.
Let's try to go through some D name the
equal on
it's a go for which means D name that
are not part of the carbon Pesach but
they're this matter that the carbon
Pesach is there.
Again Pesach Sheini is this week Friday
Friday is you download this matter by a
second show you a time they brought the
carbon Pesach Sheini on you download
just like you download Nissan is brought
you download here
and then that the helix of carbon Pesach
was a little test well which is this
year Friday night.
Starting and going into some of the
helix and between Pesach we shine and
Pesach Sheini the mission is in talking
that the came at all that the mission in
Marvin Pesach we shine the Sheini what's
the difference between the first Pesach
and second Pesach that the mission in
our we shine also the value raw value
matter is the Easter value raw value
matter the Sheini comments to matter
even the vice the second Pesach Pesach
Sheini when you bring the carbon Pesach
and even when you eat the Pesach little
test well you can have comments
in the previous sheer we went into a
smooth about if you could have comments
literally with the helix carbon Pesach
and the show of
the Azri we spoke about it in the past.
Look the mission of either our we shine
to in how about he lost say when you eat
the carbon Pesach we shine you you to in
how well the Sheini
in a to in how well when you eat the
carbon Pesach little test well here
these are no how well
Look the mission however there are some
things that are the same that was that
to in how well but see also when you
matter of the carbon Pesach when you
bring the sheet of carbon Pesach the you
download is to in is is to in we shine
the Sheini when they call and sleep
and it's not called sleep side the first
Pesach the second Pesach all matter some
room with the and show us
Let's begin with some other cases that
are not listed in the mission.
And to assist right here for not going
to have to take a to assist says he
brings it to accept her to call me now
me a mission other cases which we're
going to speak about at relevant into
the carbon Pesach itself
but to assist says from the to accept
the tone of a sheer
there are some other things that are
knowing the Pesach Sheini or not knowing
the Pesach Sheini that the mission did
not bring which is tone of a sheer.
Let's begin
with something that's negate the error
of Pesach.
These are a lot of fun error of Pesach
it's the first mission in our talking by
a lot of
Adam actually
you're not supposed to eat error of
Pesach and the reason for that is so you
should eat little Pesach you should eat
little of them.
To assist
over there for not the beginning of the
10 period to assist is bothered with the
gears that he has is error talking error
of is washing your head and talking is
washing Robin so what's going on error
of talking it should have said our way
talking we have the gears of our way
talking which is good to assist says the
fear gears of our way talking is very
good we're talking about little
error of little you test well Nissan but
we're talking about it in washing Robin
so the mail of it's our way talking
what's error talking washing your head
and washing Robin
so to assist says one terrace
error of she shake them by Pesach here
so now let's one error but a lot of
talking
so it's my usual one error washing your
head talking Pesach here a lot of
talking to assist says another
terrorist. You know what's Arab time
him?
Arab
of a few time of a few places behind you
places Alicia and a place shiny.
Which comes out of feeders if the
mission and Arab time in the first
mission is speaking about a dinner
talking about side Alicia and a side of
shiny.
Is my word color that is dinner?
This dinner
this dinner
is irrelevant dinner not only for places
Alicia and places shiny as well.
This
asks a child over here. This
asks
What's the time? Of this dinner
places a second shot
which is even my places shiny. This one
places Alicia the reason why
the reason why
is because you should eat the master of
the Yola.
However, places shiny there is no master
of the Arab master that you should eat
master layout as well.
The time is says to eat master master
but it's master they eat together with
the carbon places. That master they eat
together with the carbon places which
we're going to get to later. You know
you can eat it you eat it at the end of
the Yola. So there's no dinner
why should it be a dinner of the Yola
not to eat Arab places Arab places shiny
which means this Friday afternoon if
you're going to be bringing the carbon
places you should not eat Friday
afternoon. Why not? Why not eat the
whole reason why not to eat is out for
the Yola. There's no dinner Yola.
Let's move on now to some more dinner
which are annoying that we are
layout layout seder.
And let's go one by one and see if it's
annoying places shiny as well.
The safe layout seder test of Nissan
would be layout layout when you eat the
carbon places shiny layout test of ear
which would fall out this year Friday
night.
Let's begin with
is there a dinner?
If somebody missed places Alicia you
couldn't bring marker of the carbon.
Is he going to is he
the places shiny is he
the
to say that I got that?
Look at the
in
the flame and on the base.
And it's also a famous right here on
that
the mission says the
my being places Alicia and the shiny.
That there is no dinner of
the time him.
And this famous
proves it from a random the random pair
of Zion of master.
That the
is that the master of the time him
layout test of the master is a master
on the young
because of the
nest. Test of Nissan we went out of
so there's a dinner of the time him
the
that we had that nest which was layout
test of.
It is test of Nissan. It is true that
the time gives a second chance to people
that missed places
and the mail the people that missed
places
could
make up the carbon places but the
that I got
doesn't pass layout test of because
that's not the time we went out of time.
The Russian Arab time
The Arab time says master
and speaking about
master
the mission
the
the layout also the mission should have
as the
she saw the time. Says there's a master
of the layout test of the mission and
should be layout also and the Arab has a
but the Arab specifies clearly that the
master of the
in the night should not
say in the mission mission of the
so the mail of the mission happened
layout test of mission not layout test
of ear is the mail of doesn't pass
the time him.
However, this famous ends off by saying
if you take a look in the mirror and
pair of base a long pair.
And it was here a pair of mirror would
come out that there is a master.
But the pastor says there is no master
of the time that a person brings a
carbon places. Most of what we're going
to be speaking about tonight is
irrelevant only if somebody's bringing a
places shiny.
One dinner is going to be in the gear
even this one as well but most of
speaking of when somebody brings a
places shiny what dinner my way. So we
said
the time is not annoying.
We say in the
and it's a mission in time of
the olive.
Call I am
the
forum
call I am
a ruler they have the places.
Yeah, you're not here.
What are you not
are you not
when we say we hear you're not here. Are
you not
here?
The master
which means there's a master of eating
master. You're only the master of eating
master if you say master zoo.
Or is it a dinner Medina
master of time him?
In other words, super time him
is
to say this
again is the culture
of dinner Medina master of places master
or is it a Medina super time him?
This is over there for the name of a
master places and they're going to be
ill.
So this is pure meaning of the Russian
of this is
the mirror should
lay [snorts] more places that should
only come.
This day you need
the mirror to say the places you have to
say places should only come.
Look at this
the eighth
master of more places.
And over here also master and more you
have to say master zoo more zoo.
Master zoo more zoo that
from places with the master that the
mirror is an mirror that's relevant to
the master.
In other words, pastor is talking about
carbon places look at this no one is who
I am
the mirror is also for master and for
more. If it would be a dinner places
master of time him has nothing to do
with who
is a dinner super time him you HAVE TO
SAY PLACES master and more. So it's a
dinner mirror.
But this dinner mirror of both sides
is this dinner mirror that was saying
over here is its own dinner besides
master of the Yola. Every master you
have to
what you're doing but over here is a new
dinner of a mirror.
After they
the master of the art and this places
the master says master is bothered. He
says lay more
by any master that you should be a
dinner that a person should have to
specify and say master zoo speak about
the master. I found it is master of the
Yola but this happens a dinner to say
master more.
So this is one side one side is that the
dinner to say this dinner Medina master
and the other side I will learn to say
this dinner super time him.
Who learns like the other side that it's
a dinner Medina super time him?
If the remember we mentioned
before places but rather not in the
places
learning in the morning sectors brokers
so we had a discussion on the master of
the
time him that's every night super
is places by night what's the
difference?
So we said over many different has been
in.
We said over
the broker brings us him.
And he learns like that
places in the random.
That culture of
the forum is Medina super and he says
that's one of the
that's special super places by night
over every other night.
So we have over here
this
and
the stands culture of Medina master.
The other side
understands shot in random is a dinner
super.
The
would be places shiny when a person sits
down places shiny to eat his carbon
places does he have to say places master
and more?
Look at the mission
similar.
If the master if the dinner of a mirror
is a dinner Medina places master and
more that's the reason why
Medina Medina master so this mitzvah is
applicable Pesach Sheni also.
The parshas would be like a mitzvah
shaal gufa when you eat the carbon
Pesach.
Just like you have to eat it slowly, so
you also have to you have to say Pesach.
However, if the mitzvah of saying this
real kosher
shidvarim is Medina sipurtis mitzrayim.
No, sipurtis mitzrayim
is not like Pesach Sheni le tzav year.
Really, you're not going to say you're
not
to say you're not in this real meal.
What's about the matzah?
Matzah Pesach Sheni
Is the matzah on Pesach Sheni
Do we have the same requirement as
matzah Pesach Rishon?
The I knew
matzah
shmurah shmurah matzah
Does it have to be lechem oini?
So, in the shuva is so about it.
He he downs up about it.
The shuva the article of the sofer
and he says the din matzah shmurah
The pasuk says matzah matzahs. So,
matzahs is told by Pesach Rishon. It
doesn't say by Pesach Sheni. So, maybe
it could be Pesach Sheni you don't.
And the same thing by lechem oini which
speaks Pesach Rishon maybe Pesach Sheni
you don't need lechem oini.
The tzlach The tzlach that we mentioned
before the tzlach and brochos
number two base The tzlach says the
following. Very interesting. The tzlach
when he brings this shaila
and the
real he
says that tzlach davar chadash asher
eisi shidivru bo yaakov moinen I did not
see anybody speak about it. Who has the
maschiach? It's not the game now. It's
the game when maschiach is going to
come. What type of matzah you need?
We're not speaking about the meaning of
eating matzah. We're talking about the
the Torah says you
to eat matzah leil tes vav year.
The shaila is does that matzah have to
be the same matzah that we eat Pesach by
night?
So, first he wants to say that you don't
need. You do not need not matzah shmurah
and it doesn't have to be lechem oini.
And he says the only reason why we have
all the dinim by carbon Pesach is
because it says
who koso
In other words, all the
of Pesach
we say are applicable carbon Pesach by
Pesach Sheni also. But it doesn't say by
matzah. Since it doesn't say by matzah,
by matzah you do not need those dinim.
In other words, it doesn't have to be
matzah shmurah.
You don't need lechem oini.
It could be matzah shirah as well. Mix
in other things in the recipe of the
matzah.
He also brings a by lechem oini.
Lechem oini one of the tamim in the
gemara number
lechem
all of dvarim harbeh.
No, on Pesach Sheni not sipurtis
mitzrayim so there's no all of dvarim
harbeh. So, if there's no all of dvarim
harbeh, it's not lechem oini. So, maybe
you don't need lechem oini even by
matzah shirah. And really he says matzah
shmurah also you don't need.
But it says all matzah shmurah you have
to eat.
Yeah.
Such a din in the carbon.
So, it's din in carbon. So, the shaila
is that matzah you have to eat matzah.
Is that very good? Yeah, you have to eat
matzah. The shaila is when the Torah
says all matzah you have to eat. You
have to have matzah shmurah matzah. It
doesn't say shmurah matzahs.
It just says you have to eat matzah. So,
maybe any matzah is good. Even if you
make matzah, it has to be matzah. It
can't be chametz. But even the matzah
does it have to have the din that it's
shmurah like we gave shuva about it in
the past.
Uh-huh.
Very good. For the shaila.
So, we have
to say wants to say that the parshas is
that you you don't need it. You don't
need it.
Talk like you about the TORAH SAYS YOU
HAVE TO EAT MATZAH. BUT YOU don't have
to eat matzah matzah shmurah lechem
oini. That you don't need.
However
However, he says we be
to say that it should be different.
And he says that
that the same matzah that's Pesach
Rishon is Pesach Sheni. And he says it's
like that because if you're going to
tell me that you don't need lechem oini
cuz you don't have the
shmurah matzah shmurah. He says you know
what's going to come out? You don't even
need matzah from the shishim dagim. Cuz
how do we know matzah from the shishim
dagim? Just that it says matzah by
Pesach Sheni. It just says matzah. How
do you know the shishim dagim?
So, the Torah says the gemara says the
gemara
the gemara says the
all of chametz by Pesach RISHON
ALL OF MATZAHS. AND THE gemara says
something that's maybe
matzahs maybe it's also
that's the type of flour to be used for
matzah.
So, are you going to tell me you can
make matzah out of any type of grain?
Elevadai
Elevadai and I think like you were
pointing out you who do you were saying
that
the Torah says all matzahs you have to
eat. So, even though the Torah says very
just matzahs, but the matzahs means what
is the matzahs? The matzahs means
whatever means whatever matzahs referred
to in the Torah by Pesach Rishon here
Pesach Sheni as well.
What's about tivul chareises? Is one
Does is one have to be tivel the tivel
the maror? About there is a din of
maror. The Torah says to eat the maror
on matzahs and maror. What's about the
maror?
Do you have to I'm sorry. Maror you the
shaila is
are you
to tivel the maror tivul chareises?
So, the doctor says that it's
a chloikus tanoyim. The mishna the
mishna in
number
four the mishna has a chloikus. What's
the reason why we tivel chareises? Is it
pnei sakana or pnei a mitzvah?
So, he says if it's pnei sakana listen
Pesach Sheni also is a sakana. But if
it's pnei a mitzvah, what's the reason
of the mitzvah? Zaycher le tik. If it's
zaycher le tik
zaycher le tapuach, so
that doesn't pass the Pesach the Pesach
Sheni. As we mentioned before Pesach
Sheni even though you have a second
chance to bring a carbon, but that
second chance to bring a carbon does not
help you the gavi that it's not the zman
so maybe there is no zaycher.
However, he ends off and he says the
following. Even a the mande that says
that a mitzvah it's that is also sakana,
so maybe the all of
them will be tivel maror chareises.
Based on the side that we just said that
leil seder even though we bring the
carbon Pesach and we eat it Pesach
Sheni, but we do not have it's not a
zman of mitzrayim.
So, maybe the
shuva by hallo. You say hallo. Do you
say hallo Pesach by night? I'm not
talking about these three hallos. This
hallo of carbon Pesach that you say even
Pesach Sheni that's a mishna.
Then these hallo the shas achila
[clears throat and snorts] and that the
mishna says you do not. You do not say.
What's about the hallo the shas
by night? We have hallo hallo. Do you
say hallo hallo nes?
Do you say hallo? She says you don't say
hallo cuz the hallo
nes is is the nes that happened
mitzrayim.
It's not the zman nes.
And the same thing is also all of kosis
save her.
Pesach leil Pesach Sheni by night when
you eat Pesach matzah maror.
Is there a din of save her?
Is there a din of all of kosis?
There's no din fighter cuz all of kosis
like we had we spoke about it before
Pesach it's
to the all of shoinus.
Save her is chirus.
All this is not applicable Pesach Sheni.
So, what comes out of this? What we it
comes out that if a person brings is to
bring a carbon Pesach Sheni
Erev Pesach he prepares his Pesach. This
is this year Friday you dalet. How does
the seder look by him leil tes vav year?
So, the Torah says leil tes vav year is
really
nothing. There's no din seder. No
no
kadesh. This year happens to be it's
Friday night so there will be kadesh.
But there's no there's no kadesh
nothing.
You eat Pesach matzah maror.
Just very briefly
for about five minutes we'll just go
through a couple of dinim in carbon
Pesach itself which we mentioned before
the
tzlach says it brings it. The tzlach
says the shiyur.
There are other cases also. What are one
of the cases of shiyur?
The carbon Pesach Rishon was shaat
the shiyur which means three groups.
There was one group in the
to shaat the carbon Pesach, a second
group, and then a third group.
So, the shaila is, what's about the
Pesach Sheini? Were there three groups?
Was there Is there a requirement of of
of
of three groups? Of them, the Tosfos
brings the Tosefta that the din of gimel
kitos was not noig by Pesach Sheini. So,
the Bnei Yissachar wants to understand
why not. Why should there not be a din
of gimel of gimel kitos? In other words,
we explained before that when we're
speaking about korban Pesach itself,
not only had a korban Pesach she look,
but even the dinim with the korban
Pesach are the same. So, why should
there not be a din of gimel kitos that
you should bring it in three groups?
Now, you might tell me that the reason
why there's no din is cuz there's very
few people.
It Everybody was able to fit in one shot
to one group, so maybe there was no need
for three groups.
However,
you can't say like that cuz the Gemara
says it's a Gemara Daf Samach Dalet that
even in the first Pesach Rishon, if even
if there's only 50 people, there was a
din of gimel kitos. So, if there's a din
of gimel kitos, why don't you say the
same thing regarding
regarding Pesach Sheini also that even
if there's not a lot of people?
So, he says like this, he is soif.
The Gemara Menachos Daf Tes Kol Makom
She Nahagu Kol Eino Elo Ma'akev.
And the main what means to say is when
the Torah says chuka, chuka is to come
to say that it's ma'akev. And he says,
it's true kol chukosav, but the Torah is
saying only things that are ma'akev by
Pesach Rishon that you have to do by
Pesach Sheini. Gimel kitos is not
ma'akev by Pesach Rishon. Since it's not
ma'akev by Pesach Rishon, it's not You
don't have to bring a Pesach Pesach
Sheini if it's not ma'akev.
I mean, you're you're not a ba'al chiyuv
ba'al I'm sorry, Pesach Rishon is just
not ma'akev Pesach Sheini because it's
not ma'akev Pesach Rishon, Pesach Sheini
not a ba'al chiyuv ba'al.
quite a bit to cut out, maybe there'll
be
a part two at a different time.
There's a din
that the Pesach is ba'al a soiva.
Which means you eat it later on, so to
speak, as a dessert, not right away in
the beginning of the seudah. You have to
eat it towards at the end.
Do you have that same din on Pesach
Sheini? Is it ne'echal al a soiva?
In other words, when you're going to sit
down Leil Tes Vav Iyar, you're also
supposed to eat it al a soiva or could
you eat it in the beginning right away?
Eat it for supper
uh Leil Tes Vav, is it the same din?
Is it the same din?
So, the Gemara says Amar Rebbi Yosi,
Amar Rebbi Yehuda, Amar Shmuel,
Maftirin Acharei
Hamatzah V'chol Minin. In other words,
what is Maftirin Acharei Hamatzah V'chol
Minin? That you can eat You can eat the
You can eat the matzah. You can eat
after the matzah when it's Acharei
Hamatzah V'chol Minin. However,
the korban Pesach, you can't.
So, Tosfos says, what's the difference
between matzah and korban Pesach? So,
Tosfos says, korban Pesach, the reason
why you can't eat anything afterwards
cuz we want you should eat it at the
end, so you should eat it when you're
full, so you don't come to be to break a
Etz Eitzem Mishibru. Because if you're
still hungry, you might break a bone to
get some food out FROM THE MIDDLE. SO,
MAYBE
that's why you That's why we
we we we eat it at the end to make sure
you're full by the time you eat it.
Is there mail of That's the reason.
That's applicable Pesach Sheini also.
The Torah says there's a issur of
shviras eitzem Pesach Sheini as well.
I just want to conclude
with one din which is relevant
maybe relevant for this for even a year
should we not be zoicheh to the Binyan
Beis Hamikdash.
And hopefully we'll get to mamash in a
minute if we are zoicheh for you're
going to bring it. What's about the
issur tzli? We're noig The Mishnah says
in Pesachim Daf Nun Gimel Amud Aleph.
So, like the Mishnah Makom She Nahagu
Le'echol Tzli B'Leil Pesach, Ochlin.
Makom She Nahagu Shelo Le'echol, Einam
Ochlin.
Yeah, it's totally It's totally It's
totally in the minhag hamakom Pesach by
night. Right? This past Tes Vav Nissan,
could you eat basar tzli or maybe even
chicken that's roasted not to eat?
So, what's about the din What's about
the din regarding Pesach Sheini? Do you
say the same thing as well?
So, the Rashash is medayek from the
loshon The loshon of the Mishnah The
Mishnah says, Leil Leil Pesachim.
So, he says, just like we mentioned
earlier in Tosfos, Tosfos says over
there, Leil Leil Pesachim. Arevei
Pesachim means Pesach Rishon and Pesach
Sheini. Zogt the Rashash would come out
over here also that the issur to eat
tzli is even Pesach Sheini b'makom she
nahagu. It's a big chiddush, which means
even this Friday night not to have
roasted meat, roasted chicken. THAT'S
WHAT COME OUT.
HOWEVER, even though the Rashash says
Even though the Rashash says for a
pashtus, No, I'm sorry, not for a
pashtus. The Rashash says it would come
out of side Pesach Rishon and side
Pesach Sheini. You By both of them, a
person should not eat tzli. But the
pashtus minhag ha'olam is not like that.
Lo ra'inu. The Rivvos Efraim brings, Lo
ra'isi me she yachpid al tzli. So, I'm
sure with the olam a chiddush which is
brought in the Rashash that even Pesach
Sheini al pi d'makom she nahagu should
even be It's only al pi one teretz in
Tosfos.
And just to conclude, I'm sorry a bit
over time, just to conclude,
we're holding now a few days before
Pesach Sheini.
And if we're zoicheh
to Binyan Beis Hamikdash,
are we going to bring the Pesach Sheini?
So, this is a machlokes. The pashtus
that you learn like that in the
Yerushalmi as well as in the Tosefta.
The Minchas Chinuch brings that it's a
machlokes.
If we're going to bring the korban
Pesach,
it's gidai to note
Reb Moshe Reb Moshe in Darkei Moshe in
in my father's sefer in Darkei Moshe,
it brings over there
Reb Simcha Bunim Kohen Shlita from
Lakewood, when speaking to Reb Moshe,
Reb Moshe over Nissan was very We should
be zoicheh to the Binyan Beis Hamikdash
korban Pesach. After Pesach, he told
him, he said, we should be zoicheh to
Pesach Sheini.
Yeah, so it's a shaila.
The Meshech Chochmah says even a step
wider. He brings this machlokes.
And then he goes with the side that
we're going to attack of bringing Pesach
Sheini. And he says a morei d'gaza up
here a din in a pasuk. I'm going to say
it very b'kitzur,
but he says the pasuk says in the second
pasuk, the pasuk doesn't say what
chodesh. It just says b'chodesh zeh. So,
in this week's parsha also, you take a
look when the parsha speaks about the
korban Pesach, the second pasuk in this
in Emor as well, it doesn't say like by
Rosh Hashanah, it says b'chodesh
hashvi'i. It does not say b'chodesh
rishon. So, he says, because
in a case like this case, like a year if
Mashiach would come now,
not only are we going to bring the
korban Pesach, but we're going to have
seven days of Yom Tov.
On a when when a miyah brings the korban
Pesach, so then over there also, there
it's only Leil Tes Vav, you eat Pesach
Matzah Maror. But if all of Klal Yisrael
brings the korban Pesach Pesach Sheini,
it's not only a Pesach Sheini for one
day, we're going to have a full Yom Tov
of seven days of Pesach.
We should ta'akev be zoicheh
to the Ezras Hashem
uh be have Pesach Sheini in Yerushalayim
with the Beis Hamikdash Habnuyah.
Once
Once they didn't say in Shavuos Pesachim
called Pesach.
Yeah.
Why is in Sukkah not called Pesach?
So, so someone told me
>> why uh So, someone told someone told me
because it's both
both Pesachim and there's the Ramay
Seder. The real answer is because it's
basically three mesechtas of Pesach put
together.
After every four prakim in Pesachim, it
says Hadran Alach Pereq this and this.
Hadran Alach Mesechtas Pesach Rishon.
And then after another
I think after the fourth perek
>> Very interesting.
I see Ad Lo Makom She Nahagu Le'echol
Pesach Rishon. Yeah. Ah, it's That case
That case called Pesach.
Very interesting. There's a lot more
dinim also that were relevant, but
the time didn't allow even in korban
Pesach and lean a lot of different
s'farim. There was kashrus dikosher But
I think I think the most probably maybe
the biggest chiddush should be of
tonight is like I made sleep is mana
there. We're not knowing like that, but
it's interesting to know that says that
the dinner of sleep out cuz the person
should
be the same as well.
In the
same way
without
If
it would come today
I think there's already here in this
has to be with
you should have been there us.
What's the what's the same? The same
tomorrow
and
which means
You should know
and talk at the last year. Rather this
talk we spoke about. And there's a whole
shot also by
we bring the the of the same and the
reason for that is cuz that it's a
by
we should be the same
why we say the of the same cuz we
that it's just we should still be able
to eat the
same same.
I'm saying in the in the
but yes.
I'm saying the same it's the same
it's only the same
the same the same.
Yeah, I'm listening yeah Leo yeah you
yeah. What what's the name of the video
matter?
So these two started either it's the
same same.
And if it's the same the same
which that's more the
some say to eat it Leo Leo the same cuz
that's when you eat the same
some say to eat it
you
not to make a mistake.
Not to be told that you're eating it
after the of and some talk of the
others have not eat the same well.
I I don't think that anybody says I'll
show them the same of
of of the same the same.
Like you do the same the same the same.
Here we say
the same the same the same
yeah.
This is
this is this is this is
to the
I don't know if this is called the same
or it's just
what's the you remember?
Is that nothing to do with has to do
with the same that's what you say. If
you wait a second I'll just bring the
same again.
I don't think anybody says that has to
do with the same.
Right because I see
the they they eat the same they even eat
the same.
The question of the have the minute talk
at the eat they eat the same to eat
to make a whole seder. I'm I didn't go
into that what's the you know you're
right.
So if anybody says
Is there
everything there but they could eat the
same the same also? I guess right?
I'm
talking at you think so but I'm not sure
you're saying the same
is the same well. There was no that's
how they eat the
same.
>> [laughter]
>> Right? I get
Now it's not to eat the whole same the
same is
you know a minute right? It's not really
the same.
So it shouldn't be different.
I don't know.
I don't know cuz if you don't eat the
same
and the same you're not
the same
I'm dying so much about it I don't know.
Okay I have over here a different people
ate more little
people ate
the same tell us.
I don't I don't
I don't I don't have any more
like I have more of the same the same
only for the same
some talk of the same to eat it
only only possible cuz of the only
should I eat the same we should talk to
eat the same but here we say That's why
you shouldn't you shouldn't look like
you're eating more of the same. Yeah
that's one of the reasons.
The
says in the
the reason is it shouldn't be the same
if you can eat the same
it looks like you're eating the same.
Yeah.
Okay the same the same. The same thank
you thank you for the for the
encouragement about the
I I didn't get the zoom
I didn't get the zoom
address I I got it from the email you
didn't send out a zoom address.
You mean on the text? Right in the text
you just you just have the
even in the email usually they have like
you know the address and a code
on the email you just press
you know join zoom and it will and
automatically directs you to
you know? Okay I'll make sure that it
goes out on the text also. Right you
know listen I don't know you know
the
we have uh
more interaction.
>> Sure it's good also makes it easier to
be able to even during this year after
this year to communicate about it.
Okay it's good to see you.
Thank you.
I'll take care.