DIFFERENCES BETWEEN KRIAS MEGILLAH AT NIGHT & DURING THE DAY - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

As we embark in the of Kailla, one of the four mitzvah of Porum, I would like to open up the limud their with something very important in the overall of ka saggilla, one of the four mitzvah. We're learning ka saggillah. There are four mitzvah and like the says to be remembered and to be done. How do you remember PM? You remember pur through reading the migill to read the migill to remember pimas. How do you do pim? How do you do? So there are four mitzvah. These four mitzvah are they by day by night both. So let's first speak about the other mitzvah the three and then we'll go to migilla for these and the gor says person that eats the sudas by night is not like mentioned before it's important sometimes people like to eat and drink by night and then you're nauseous and you can't eat the suda by day you're not by night the suda you have to eat the suda by day it's a gor from the you may say by day by day you Though there are more says by night get together and eat and drink says for so of by night but the mitzvah of suda is by day. What's so over there is a rush. There's no but it's a rush. The rush says just like you eat and the same is also doesn't bring it's but the hat says so what we have clear just a second we have clear we have clear is that you did by night you're supposed to do it by day you're supposed to do it by So then you're saying that's why it's connected but I don't know if you have to come on that it's attached if you have to attach that's a discussion for what's the reason but the you may but good you're right if it's attached that could be a also now let's go to ka saggilla. Ka saggilla the other three mitzvah are by day and not by night. What's about kaill? Kasagill is by day by night both. So how do we know we read the migill by night as well? The mcoy is not the mill doesn't say the migilla. says, "But the Gomorrah says a person is supposed to read the by night." Interesting. The Garra says he's supposed to give even by night, by day and by night. The Gomorrah actually thought means to learn by day though. It's very interesting. What's the What's the Yeah, but it says means to read the mill instead of reading the migill to learn the I'm not sure. But the gamar says no means to read it again. You read it by night and you read it by day. She's supposed to read the mill two times by night and by day the actually brings another also that you read the mill by night and by day we should do that by >> what you say by >> so what is all the mgillas any other migillas? Which other migillas? >> It's a mimic. We'll get to in a minute the gather of the cre we'll get to shortly. We'll see it's a little different. saying some people read also today. >> Let's leave the other migillas on the side. It's a very good point. It's a very good point. There's a lot to talk about what the gather of that is. There's a lot to talk about but leave it on the side for now. So what do we see over here says to read by night and by day fine. So what we began over here the three mitzvah the other three mitzvah by day not by night by day and by night. However you make a shanu again by day. We read mill by night and we made a shakyanu matu that you should make a shakyanu again. The first day you take Lula, you make a shakyanu. The second day even with you don't make again a shakyanu. So why do you make aanu again? The ter is it's a it's a more of a crea. It's a bigger crea. It's a better but is showing from this that you make au on the kaill by day. Obviously that's the more important crea says from the the first the in other words even by night by night don't quiet down by night you should also praise Hashem in other words you should also read the by night but when the is by day also The second also don't quiet down both is by day but you also read by night just in a complete musk what says the cagilla by day is more important what's from this you make au that's what bashkas do you make by day also theam says you don't make au so that's just on a side note that it's not a milita but says that the by day listen to this it's the rail after the the schma says that this whole tak of reading the mill by night is actually wasn't even if you take a look in the Mishna the Mishna says from the nates from the Mishna doesn't make any mention about by night only by day they add a decree of by night if you look at me is from the tano The brings interesting mo to read the migill by day and by night say it's a shagu it's totally by day it's not totally by day the says you're supposed to read there's no mic about it but by night it's totally the I think it's to read the migill by night as Now let's move to the next step. Take the tus says the by day. Let's try to take it to the next level. The tan the two is the shagasar the is the hemas's wife the say that the mitzvah by day is from the by night By day is like they say the it's by day by night it's says by day it's more intense it's more important say by day it's by night it's we'll see many between by night and by today a few but first let's understand what does it mean dra kabala and what's the of kabala the meaning the meaning of kabala and I quote the rashi so when we say that isabi explains means when the novi is something that comes from the novi and who's here is from the to read the brings the vitri I looked it up I saw it inside the vitri is from the rashi and he says why is it called? He says actually if you look in this he says it's from how we understood understood from the in other words what we're saying obviously means something that the told us and like the makitri says that something that the novi told us kabala it's kabala from where makub from so this that we have to read the day it's not from the but it originates in as well also brings that is called and is because it's That's the gather of what it means was saying the migilla by days. What's the the strength of maybe some say it's not rash it's but the rashi it's like so if we're talking about the day and we say it's what do we do about the fact that the is the evil was written Tell me tell me a bit. I want to get back to that chila. I just want to finish just this point of the and then I want to talk see if we could clarify that the gar says so the over the says what do you mean it's not it's he says is and the iss right here locally in theor the says What's the speaking about to eat the boss of aim? So we have over here is the by day is by night is so what we asking if it came later if it's >> no the problem is that it wasn't written it's >> what's the gather of the migill let's speak about it afterwards when we learn migill in the morning like rather gave a whole she there's a lot of nice to speak about what's the gather I think these are brisket over there. >> If you want to see that it's that we're hold the whole reason why we're reading this might have been written if it's not if it wasn't written. How can we give it the could still be even though >> yeah to something that was written as a historical event. It was written down as something to >> if the wrote it down so that people knew about it. >> But they were okay. But even so where is this? It's a mild that it's not cuz if the if it doesn't have a if it's not that it's not good. So then it's not it's not it's not >> but we know it we know it because it says so if it's not enough we know now very nice it's possible the mitzvah if you want to say is coming Allow me to move along with many minutes between the creilla by night and the kaill by day. As we said the by night is and by day is the first is if a person listened to the migill and he didn't have kavana. He didn't have kavana especially for a morning and you're tired and it's long and you you didn't have kavana. So if you take a look in simit what does it mean? If you didn't have if you it's the makus over here and the brings some others the Yeshua of Lamborghin the mill by day. If you weren't, you're not only you should have and says the other mitzvah also by day has a has a a lotion. What to say? And this is for you in the bring they bring it over there this what what are we saying over here by day it's it's it's by day it's by day by night by night it's not by night also that's number one number do this. I thought of myself and I looked around. I didn't I didn't find that as a somebody quotes this from the but I couldn't find it but I want to hear what says a that's we don't know if it's Cyrus so it's the so as it's clearly by when it's a suffic We don't rely on we know for sure by night we would rely by day that it's who says we can't rely on he doesn't he doesn't say he says you can't And therefore he says by um he says when you have says he says we don't say and you have to hear back and then you can't be I don't I don't you're saying I I I hear I hear what you're saying good was getting a little bit nervous you should know cuz we have about over 20 cre of a gila by day so I have to start uh see I know I I don't know. I I don't find it's an interesting point. You're saying that could be that it's >> I thought I saw a mock prim. Let's move along afterwards. It's a good something to but this is number two number one was by day if you were you weren't by night that's number one number two he said number three eating before the says by night also you don't eat you don't eat by night also you don't So it's interesting the say but as others bring clearly it's really because as a matter of fact the prim says that you could eat by night say because by night is It's by day it's just like you're not allowed to eat before before you're not supposed to eat before a mitzvah. So here also you're not supposed to by day it's more not to eat. Committee number three. >> I come to say >> they say such a swim after whole suda because you're fasting. >> Fourth. The fourth. This is also this is a gavald nafamino. What happens if you miss? If you hear what happens if you it happens I hope to give a sh on that could be I gave in the morning also but regardless it's neg which what's not which words you heard al what to make up but let's say you miss a simple case would be is you heard the migillas but let's even say you listen to the migillo You're not sure if you heard a word if you were if you were to would be a clear between by night and by day by night it's the by day it's you have to hear them over again. This this is by the way the primagod that I was referring to when you mentioned before about the primagod says that but is there but I don't know maybe even also but over here he says that it's so we know but also so we have so far very clear that there's a between night which is by day which We s we saw four we said four and a half minutes eating and a sophic however one thing it's important to note that it's not a mil the across the board we're busy here for almost a half hour that by night it's the by day it's the it seems from two places in the pagod and maybe even in two places that by night is also which is which is because it's the migill says by day and if you say if you say that by night it's all the fall away because even by night you have to be by everything it's the same as by day. Yeah, you with me? That's just on a not on a side point but on an important note that this big is not fine. So that that has to do with leg pursuing of reading at but how does the pursu what is this comment over here at night that wasn't coming from that angle you explaining why even by night >> I want to conclude with one more and the reason I'm I'm leaving it here after we said the saf is because really it's neaya in general also ladies are also Clearly that potter is a zyra and others that their is not from the migillah. And however, which by the way, this is not a milita the brisk stencil in says that turns them back to the of but the others seem to understand that they have a new comes from. So what comes out ladies by night and by day >> oh they can't very good very good this is what I wanted to get to gavaldic this would be so first of all like this so first of all this would be and that would be the could could noim bey so the brings that they cannot days that this is only by day because like you're pointing out this is what I want to conclude with by day that So a lady can't be because she's only just like a one second. This will be another minute between by night and by day by night could be men. Why? Cuz they're both by day that the men are the woman. So to sum up in a nutshell what we spoke tonight all mitzvah all the mitzvah are by day three of them are clearly not by night is by night but as we saw it's not the same it's only we saw five between the by night and the creill by day.