BIRCHOS HANEHENIN - EXPLAINING THE DIFFERENCES IN WORDING - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

I have a good reminder to appreciate when I could speak properly. It's always I take it for granted. I could come. I could speak a mic. We'll try. We'll do our best over here. [clears throat] We started Just hakama a very brief hakama the raam says in speaking about all braas all over the ra says there are three categories of brahas and then the raam says what's the underlying of all the braas every single bra that you'll ever find that's either a mitzvah Why? Why? Why is there a takusal? It's not. Why is it to make [clears throat] the reason why we make a is to bring to bring toki says on the it's the garra the garra says the of mayas A person is supposed to make from the said person supposed to make 100 of you know why they to make 100 brahas a day to bring shine that's the source of the raam we are the raam know that is from one more says that if a person eats without a bra he's considered a gaz and he's stealing [laughter] part of the is because when a person makes a properly he brings down on this So I just want to speak maybe it'll be a little shorter today but speak a brief few minutes even beetted the pish of the words of the braas we'll go through a little bit like this a person makes a beginning of every single is speaking to But try to identify perhaps first I tried with multiple te's >> honey >> honey also and recolleas I tried let's start first now with the first brahas that you make but the brahas of boy prien. So we learned already in a bra that's more specific is more so is more than every fruit and vegetable is a creation from the aishama that comes from the ground. An apple is a prima. However, it's more of a we make a specific referring to our a fruit pri from the tree. [snorts] You make on a fruit because the fruit comes from the So that's pretty part of fruits that come from a tree and fruits that come from the ground. We're going to learn a banana that comes from a tree. It's not is from a tree is from the ground. What's about prehagen? What's the t? Why a different? So the Garra says the basil, why do we make a special bra on wine? In other words, really wine is from grapes. We should make >> who. So we'll get to that in a minute. Very good. Very good. I'm on track. Very good. Good. Good. The garra says why do we make so the garra says because it's spells out he says that when you drink wine it fills up a person it's also when you drink wine it's it's better wine is more of a milo over grapes says the garra that's why you make a more specific fake braha. We'll get to see what this what exactly is the braha fra the same thing should be also and oil it's so the gammor says what braa should you make prehaz and I'm going to explain the difference between haza I think a lot of people don't know it's it's paret but it's possible A lot of people don't know if this is the only for some people it's when you make kdes Friday night prian what is the boyagen boy the created the did not create the wine we're not talking about the wine when you make a priagen pre the fruit is the grape hagen prien is the vine is the says the Gomorrah by Isaiah when you're going to say boy preas pre what's the fruit of aas is what's the tree of Zas so preas [clears throat] okay says rashi people are going to think that we're referring to the oil because boy prehaz is the fruit So what's the pre of the fruit the oil and I found that you can't say on the oil we're not talking about the oil. So mainly you can't make a [clears throat] clear what's about wine when you make a we are not talking about the wine not talking about the wine you're making kdes Friday night or any other time you're drinking wine it's not a on the the you're drinking the wine but the bra is the creates grapes it's a specific it's more of a [clears throat] as was specifying grapes They're not just saying pri but it's mish different when you eat an apple you make a pri you're making a you're speaking about the apple when you make on a tomato you're speaking the ibish created this tomato when you make a you're not talking about the kdish the wine that you're holding you're talking about grapes this wine came from grapes it's so you make a more specific but you're talking about the grapes. Now we're going to get what's your name please. >> So you said shahak the other may pis that come you make a shahak. Why do you make a shahak? So one second other paris andami juice that came out of an orange wasn't like wine but why do you make a why does it go down >> the terret is it's >> what about grape juice not wine is [snorts] different than apple >> oh so the you're right you don't have the soy you don't have the Shila when we learned yaya we went through it that some grape juice is taka shil and there's a lot of mixed in water but I think the question would if the reason why you make a guffin is because it's soy it fills a person up [clears throat] so grape juice I'm talking about not the grape juice on concentrate but regular wine if it's soy so that's the same reason apple juice I hear I hear the sh on grape juice more I But apple juice, orange juice, it's but why do you make a shahle? You don't make a big a more specific. Why do you make a shakle? The terret is because it's not really the fruit. It's considered za like the sweat of the fruit and that's why you make a shahak. If that's the case, so by wine [clears throat] and wine is but why by wine don't you say also that it's za it's also z in other words it's just the sweat of the grape it's can mean from today till tomorrow but it's only za so why ta don't you make a shahakle on wine the terret is because the grapes were planted Ed to make wine doesn't have to be with before but the concept grapes are standard at most of the grapes a lot of grapes the made to make the juice and therefore spells it out all over and therefore it's not considered z >> so so oranges that are grown >> oh very good very good it was a very big tuml the Very good oranges that were grown to make orange juice oranges that more pulp. It's it's even it's made for the juice. It's big to go into it would be it's not it. It's not a you're not there's no use. So you don't make a more specific than you should make. lawyer was saying lawyer was saying that grapes was saying that grapes I'm sorry wine the boyen is referring is referring to the prian is referring to the grapes so if you make aen on grapes it's more like It's because that's not the because you don't have so we never they were the it's more of a claw on a on an apple but on on a grape if you make aen that's exactly what we're talking about is talking about grapes [snorts] what's about her eights If you make her eights on wine, her eights on wine and the same thing. They only talk about her would be also if you make brings it. It's very interesting as we'll soon see Baham how you making a pri on wine boy the didn't create didn't create the wine it's you it came out of the grapes it came out of the grapes we're going to get to it soon we'll see ber is something that the created but it's if you make a pri on wine if you're bo like What we're saying now means that the created the go in paras says these the he brings of he says you have wood a tree grows that's wood that's bria made wood when a person makes a table so that's already the person made it and then I see if you paint the table that doesn't change paint but is something whether if it's a bracious or later is something that the made and when you make a prima even the prian we're talking about the grapes the created the grapes a person made the wine Let's be mom now. Now that we see that boy were talking about exactly what the made fruits that come from a tree, vegetables that come from the ground, grapes and that's why what's the bread? The bread comes the bread doesn't come from the ground. What does it mean? What? Oh, so the says that's the B says that is talking about the breads from something that gives a person to be able to live a per the we don't But [clears throat] then goes what's the change? Why not? We just on a vegetable you make butterama. So from the same ground comes out also mine for a person to be able to live the bread that's mine says the in a different piece also on paras says the go there's a very big difference between and it's very important to know I mean we make these braas constantly these and these ad is ground adm We're talking about ground, the dirt. That's ad is the land. We're talking about is the land. Is the land and then the earth pre the takes out a fruit from the earth from the ground. When we talk about er the we say we're talking about says is referring to not the earth that she takes out to be amazing us to give us to live. from is not talking about the earth is talking about from the ground. It's not talking about the ground of the ground of doesn't have is talking about the land. So the shil is what's if you're not eating bread that came from straw from or bread over here take it came from says the goen that all the all the rain all the comes when we when we say you know it's the word but he says it's referring to and the rain here is we didn't start they started already Sunday the same pal we didn't start because we here for the rain over here but it's the rain of he's going to incious is talking about talking about anywhere in the world but is the reign of and he said and that's in the explaining the soi brings this I'm just going to read the mean says this a free quotes when the rest of the world comes along and is has the so when we make And like the says it's the does he mean that's the does he mean that that's the deeper or you can't have >> you wonder if that's the shot if you think >> shouldn't have a mind as if everything also has to be more I'm sure it could be could be these others that it's also is the same as ground and you should I'm saying over just these a third these ad and then these apher that you don't find in the bra though you put the or of a brisa these other mitzvah but over here and is referring the schol that's uh Friday night the alit [clears throat] is referring to Just like we spoke about making a pri on wine you should be it's it's it's a fruit but the same would be [clears throat] bread. If a person makes a had on bread are you lisa it came from the ground. Are you if you make a on bread? So it's brings a person make you don't make another braha. The reason that you're not Yaitsa is because first of all pre uh first of all when you're speaking about bread theish didn't make the bread so it's not boy and it's also not pre pre it's not a it's not a fruit it's bread it's not a pre a vegetable is a pre this is not a priest instead of that wouldn't make a difference. I don't know if like what you want to say that it's or still it doesn't make a difference because it also comes it's al it's tak from just to conclude one more that's negated what we're talking about and I want to end off if a person makes on an apple. So the brings on the what's in the of it's talking about now if you're eating grapes even if the grapes grew here it's it's we're talking about the but if you ate an How does it come in? The reason why then if a person ate grapes and an apple you make and including in in the Allah eats is already takes care of the apple explains they were for for apples Allah eats but once you're making it includes includes the apples also. So I just don't want to understand that's what the is about but others how do you make that a bro on an apple >> lawyer >> said everything is in >> you're right so that's when you make a very good very right but that's when you make is talking thees but here we're talking about the piso everything that whatever we have is all clearly but in Paris on the apple if we're talking about that the everything I got but we're talking about the how what is the apple have to do with it could be on on because everything comes from but you make Allah we're talking about so maybe the eight is talking about fruit and hey you're It's the same idea. Yeah.