3 SIFREI TORAH, ONE HAFTORAH - WHY IS IT THE ONE FOR CHANUKAH - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

This shabas shabas paras shabas khan is unique from a regular shabasan as it's also shabas being so that it's shabas shabasan and also shabases we take out three is something unique which happens the possibility is one out of four times. It'll never happen four times in a year. Obviously, that's always always happens. They take out three for then it's possible now like a year like this year if it falls out on Shabas. So the three that we take out the first is paras. The second safety we read and then in the third safety we read the second two is pretty clear and simple. Each safety is one aliyah. One aliyah foresh and one aliyah for kanek which by the way the kadesh is before the last aliyah before maft. So after say kadesh before kaneka the the third sra. What's about the cre of par the paras how many alias are there? So in regular shabas these seven alias before maft right and then you say kades seven alias which are medina you're supposed to lay be seven are supposed to be and then afterwards maft which we lay ma because of seven alias. So what's about this shabas? How many alias are in the para decree of paras before we get to? So really to get to the maft technically we should only need six six of mikates one of and then the maft that's seven and the maft which really that's what the says the minimum of course you could lay in as many as you want you could always make but the minimum for the kas on shabas on this shabas for mikates the minimum is six alias then you have a seven you have the regular seven plus m is eight the truth is that these about it. This says that it's six is the one of the early he says that it's six alias plus seven. As a matter of fact, our says a week like this week, you should not make any like this. We bring out that is also if you have six of the regular alias plus the cre of is seven. So it shows that the is one of the and that's why you should have six >> make no for sure. I'm sorry for saying for sure but we're not talking about those last two are one ali each interesting t maybe you could I don't know the truth is I don't know about the that middle aliyah ma is ma is the last aliyah could you make and something to look into taka but says the first six should only be six like this when you get the that's part of the seven alias so the first sheet to which the brings Allah should have six alias in the par. One of and one of then the one of the says just like every week you lay seven these seven people that are before in so you should have seven alias in parates then is number eight and is number nine. So meaning to say is this week you have to have an additional aliyah more than a regular week. Regular week is seven plus one. Here it's going to be eight. 7 plus is eight plus is nine. It's interesting to note the brings it. It's not but the actually says that this five aliases five alias he says then six and seven it's a because every week we always have seven alias besides the but that's the five so we have different we have six seven five is says not though says I guess if somebody didn't realize it only did five alias you don't have to go back but you take out three the first what is six alias minimum six alias then goes then goes [clears throat] now let's go into what is the ka is clear again the first we start off with parates then that's the order clearly how many alias we saw has a question. What ifra is laying shabas on a regular shabas? It's not really a sh because you're laying just like if it's you if it's whatever it is you're laying of that of the time of the but now on we have two we have and we have so which we ly but let's try to see why we landed over the shim the gar If somebody has money just for one of the two either for kdesh Friday night or he could buy for Friday night Friday afternoon before shabas which means he has money to buy shabas because that's for sure he only has enough money for one of the two either for kdesh or money for kaneka which one is and the gar explains the two of the shil sush should you spend the money to be able to make because of toddle Friday night or should you what's the benefit of pursu so maybe pursues which one should you do should you buy should you buy kesh kesh's kaidum or should you buy pursum kaidum that's the gar and the gar comes out pursum Pursum is which means though there's a concept of but the pursum is overrides says the rush that we see a very bigish on this usually the concept of which is a gam and it's a draw from that speaks about that comes before to but over there the discussion is which one should come first. Should you first do the you should do the car first. So that here the when we want to dodes first because of or we're going to do pursu it's a not but really which means if if kdesh would come first you would only do kdesh. So the rush says you see from this which is really you see it in ment but you see that this of is not only to say that comes first but actually would would also have a preference even if you want to do the other one it happens to be an gamarra the garra says that near kaneka pursuma is better but let's say there wouldn't be the dinner of pursuma if kaneka would not be pursum too many you would have two things in front of you kesh and the would say that not only that it goes first but even though it would be the only one you're doing still it's first you can hear that in the gar is the only one you want to know which one to do first that that comes first but he was saying even more not only comes first but rather it would be the only one says that he's a preference on kdesh rather than if not for pursuing Isa >> what say >> the fact of pursuing Isa tell you doesn't have the power to be >> but only because pursum is but let's say you would let's say you have something else I don't on the top of my mind I don't have another example but let's say you would have a question of kdesh and something else to do that night and you could only do one let's say for an example so you could do it later what say would also be what? Pursum is >> Let's he would have something that's not pursu. Only reason why comes first is because pursuing but if not for pursuing technically we would go with the reason of we would go with but not only that it's first it's to do only the >> so you're pointing very good hashi that we're only talking about because it wouldn't even be a shan and kdish is so theon you're supposed to make kdish make kdish So is which one is first? If you don't make Kdesh by ding it's part it's partial that the kdish would go first because it's over the raon though we'll see in a minute that technically it could be the is also the we'll get to that in a minute but you have a good point. We're only talking about that the kdes you already made kesh by ding. We're talking about which one is Kaid and which theas. >> Yeah. If a person never has money for one you make comes first. >> So you could be mul. >> No is a sh also by the rabbon also. If you have two two raonons or technically if you have two rises the gummor is not going into the rice. The gar is going you have two mitzvah which one should you do first. So you're pointing out if kdish is the rice and kanakon. So then it's not a discussion of you do the over the teres both are the or if you'll find a different case that both are and you can only do one of them we would rush you would do the over the that's what comes outdo would be the same thing also it only be possible if it's both and the question is which one or or pursu but they both have to be either the one is the riser one is the rabon on of course we'll see in a minute that could be the it's not in par that it's the bra asks the following shila how could you say pursue is the gar says pursues the of not the kiddish part but the of isa As we mentioned before, the gar makes a from a soa is a but of should have a preference over pursum. So says two again his sh is that it's true that pursu has a milo but didn't so we should really pick and rather than you should buy one you should be able to buy rather than he has two truths in one ter says is that which we mentioned before the rush that overrides doing the other mitzvah Not which one is first and which one is first but you're doing both that's the which one to do first but if you could only do one that's not that's a that the says that even when you could only do one that's so therefore in the case that we're speaking about is only pursuing is only that wants to know which one On the other hand, he says that even in such a case as it means even when the knocks out the you're not going to do both. It's also a how does the garra say pursue comes first. So he says that he's a to be to give to say for brings this and then he brings this we don't have that safer however says clearly I mean he brings from that he's a mitzvah to be to say thank you on an so ma comes comes out that the is also the though he stretches it a little bit more doesn't say to say thank you on the he says so both are the so now that we have this background that pursuing Nissa of rather than making kids Friday night says pursum says that's the reason why we lyra right we started off these three how you break up the alias which says you know why you l you say thera of because they're pursuing Isa so even though So maybe you should say of however we shabas in two days shabas we of pursum of >> it speaks about in speaks about both >> what say >> I can do both >> the truth is you could ask the shila Why? Why you don't do both? And every shab is we don't skip to another. >> That's also a good point. Some very once very uh why is that? Sometimes you see maybe that should be to skip. It's not only a sh you only do one. Why? It's a good sh but even on a regular you only do not the shabases for the outside to see my nearest or is for me. That's a very good shila. It's excellent. We gave last year maybe two years ago shil the presuma even on nus let's say if a person is doesn't have uh he's single he's in China he doesn't there's no pursum you lie you lie with a braha it's a big shil about it but even you want to know if everybody says for themsel what's the pursuma if you l it if somebody's ling it for the whole so that's pursua he's saying if everybody says it for himself there's not so much pursum just saying it for yourself >> isn't fine something that we know what the concept is but to say that is it's not very defined what on what levelum is so you have to be you're being now this possibly so on on what level is there's different levels if you're giving a level to somebody who's outside and seeing it or a level for us that see it ourselves is there a difference in that >> no so even near if you live in a place that in Monroe the only yen over there you still have to pursue Isa so after it would be the same thing you'd have pursu Isa Tyus is just stretching what the Gammorra says that Kaneka goes before because Puma is Tyus stretches the same idea over here as well. >> You only get one ending for one lane. If you do two and the second the first one just doesn't come anymore because there's only for one lane. There's one ending. >> What do you mean one ending? >> There's one left there for one lane. So if you do two then >> so the second is that's probably what you mean second is that the has to be what you messiah the ma is that what you're saying the ma that's second that the the the has to be the so what's the ma we said clearly the third is since the third is yeah very good the third is you have to have the also has to So not because of pursuing Isa just because you finish with >> they're all they don't they don't they don't actually say anything about either of them saying even talks about this and that >> yeah so what we want to accomplish >> we have to kind of think why are we talking why are we laning this cuz it has a mana in it and this week we have >> I don't know we have also technically the right there. >> She's saying that's a reason also. Yeah. Second say not because is not because it's just because you finished with as well. But says since pursuing is has a preference first telling me second is is that we that you know why we do first because I'm sorry the is because we have to do why the cre don't we do first means you know why you do first Because ish is 12 times a year even more days as opposed to Kanek that's why you lashes first but why don't you lan first because Khan is pursuing Isa so Ty says three and we're going to focus now on the third terret's first terret is that the pursum [snorts] and the garra is only when you can only do one if you could do one of the two kdish or puma pursum is but you do both and the question is which one comes first is first so therefore when you're ling and you could do both is first however when it comes to the we want to do puma so that's's first that we l of because of pursua that's first second is that there is no pursum you'll like this second is no pursuma in the laning in it speaks more about laming you just write that's not pursuing. So because there's no pursum against the against however by only byra over there these are for that's second terret T's third terret is Tus Third terra says really should come first even in the creatur why should come first because pursuing even the satra but since we want to which that's even more of a pursum and we can't we if we're going to lay later we're not going to be able to say Tyus we have to switch around the seda which means really the best case would is to lan first. We have three for the weak. But the problem is if you do that, you're not going to be able to have so therefore we lay first which means that what really even in the comes first I pursue. However, we want to have the of so therefore we lay in Kaneka last [clears throat] but that's before we move on that's clearly the is of Shabas is of pursua we have different questions why don't we lay but we lay in Kaneka that's the that's the fact but what do we see from Tyus's third ter says really we would want the creatur Kaneka first. However, we want of Khan and the the Maft and have to be the same. So therefore, we push Khan later. What's the [snorts] What should come out is during the week when it's on Sunday. This week, Sunday, how do we lane? We lane three creas of rashesh. one say for Tyra and then we lane decree of Kaneka the Shila is if the only reason on Shabas why we lane first is because really Kaneka should come first we laid first because we have a reason we want to match with the with the cre of but technically should come first so then Sunday why don't we lan beforeh that's the two in Shilah so the emmes This is on this tour Evans Shil it's really a gar speaks about it this which one is a garb is what's first is first oresh and this is very clear whatever one is going to be first gets the three alias if is first it's three alias of and one ali of kanek is first it's three alias of kanek and one ali of the Gomorrah and the Gomorrah says what's the reason for each man the is because and because not because better but rather why is there four alias this Sunday not because of Kaneka today we only we l we're going to lane only three alias why is there a fourth aliyah because ofesh So to bring out this fourth aliyah we put first the first three alias and therefore gets the fourth. So that's the gar says comes first the first three alias is followed by the fourth aliyah of so what's first is third I'm sorry comes first because of pursuma even in the ka so this Sunday or any day that for the day of of Kaneka of Khan should be first. So the answers the following. The says sinceh always has more alias. Therefore, we want to give more alias to rashes, right? Rashesh has four alias and Kaneka has three alias. So, we prefer we prefer that's why we give we put first because putting it first, we'll have three alos only have that last ali the fourth aliyah. So, that's the first he says that we put first really should come first. But there's a different reason why we want first to give it to more another says this. The reason why we put first really like ty says the would pursuing but the reason why we put first is because the cre of came about earlier than the cre of kanekra was mak and we should decree Monday and Thursday and however was later was after the takonus ezra the cre of kaneka came about later than the takonisra so therefore says decree of is earlier before since it's ear it was and earlier we laid it earlier also in the setup and then afterwards that's a two it's to be mo on the second terret maybe it's even its own terrets when was the of the tora when did that come about [clears throat] says The takana of was msuken in the times of the yanim when made not allow so they couldn't ly so they made it they made it has something inra of that par of that y so this is even another reason why when it comes to lyra of Kaneka cuz the whole zer the whole ton of lingra came about in the nest of kanek before the nest when they were you can't be that they were with the antio another why when it's and together Why is first? So we saw this explains the BI says just the opposite that when we lane I'm sorry when we lan last that's the mile of Kaneka because we always have during the week of three alias no matter when it is we have three alias. So when you have a fourth aliyah the fourth aliyah brings out the what brings out that when you have a fourth aliyah. So by giving the last aliyah that brings out more than giving it the first three alias. So the shila was that Kaneka should be first because pursua should have a preference over the answer is that we're giving a preference to Kaneka by giving it the last aliyah it brings out the Ramos says that if somebody by mistake forgets and isra first in not the order that you're supposed to we're not talking about Shabas we're talking about Monday you lay first and then you started Khan says the ra to you have to go back you have to go back go back toesh the carbon asks on he argues and he says on this then why do you have to go back what comes first what comes later so good you by mistake you mitzvah so you go back you don't why do you have to go back you don't have to go back so you started kanaka continue with khan that's what the son will ask on the over there in the of the mira explains the and he says very that the order of the cre of the idea of the order is not just which mitzvah you do first but as we saw all these before there's a in the order and if you don't do the order you're messing up in the order you have to go back to the right order he gives A person is supposed to set up his that you first get to not to pass over the because what happens if by mistake you took out is clearly you put back and you take out you don't put on first and the reason is because he's order and the order first then afterwards he put on So there's an order and is not going to help meaning just say there shouldn't be but he took out the subur order says over here also there's an order as we saw the many reasons there's an in order first and then to do so just to sum up everything first we spoke about the three the how many alias then goes then goes and then the we saw the reasons and then the order that's clearly when it comes to during the week first goes the three alias followed by one aliyah of like we saw in the somebody switches the order by mistake and he take he starts first with the you have to stop and you have to go back toeshan Let go.