0:00 / 0:00
Baba Basra Daf Yomi Review Pages 158 to 165 by Rabbi Yehuda Spitz at Scheiner's Shul
27 views
Video from the weekly Daf Yomi Weekly Review Shiur Learn more about our shul here - https://18forshay.com/
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
good morning everybody we're going to
pick up
from by the two dos we going to try to
get all the way to the M
on let's jump right into by the two
dots so we learned in
the the previous
regarding they both agreed that we say
and tells him
says this statement the way that spoke
to that he was what
was
why was definitely a but now that he
spoke to him as a third not as a third
person he didn't say RAB R he said you
it shows that he is right now considers
him like a colleague like a friend but
not like
they s the
following the bottom explains that they
sent we're going to see there's five
different that they sent from and one of
them was we're going to try to go
through all them the is going to go
through to figure out which that we sent
was let's jump through the first
one you have a son he borrowed against
the properties that he was hoping that
the father that he's going to get and
he's going to be y from the father
however the reality
[Applause]
is and the go over and take
away and this is what how do you
understand that his son can go away can
go and take away the so right away
doesn't make
sense if we're talking about he borrowed
money didn't sell anything so what is he
taking away
exactly just because you borrowed money
why in the world be able to take it
away says you're right we made a mistake
that cannot be that we're talking about
just a father and a son that his son
went and L money rather it's a little
more complex the case rather we're going
to say the case is that it's a three
generations this
Ruan Yak Ruben went and sold of banking
that by time the sale is done and
everything he's going to be cuz he the
father was old and what happened was
ruen died first so now over to that
bought those and he takes it out
follows a son sells the
father's and then he himself dies before
the
Father which means the grandson the
grandson comes and takes away
the and this is
what explains now
what why can't
you we your father so us why in the
world should you be able to come and
take it away so right away the questions
as and
says let the grandson come and
say I'm not coming from the of my father
rather I'm coming from the directly
being my grandfather more than that
where do we know such a
concept it says in
[Applause]
the have
the and that we see from the that what
that a son is taking over and going
taking out the father and going direct
to the grandfather and getting what
instead of what his father rather
doesn't go through the father himself so
therefore this can be that's why the son
has a to take away the does that the
would never really be a even without
this how do you understand the father
was never yish the father di learn it's
not about rather it's returning the
money on the second thing they sent for
they were trying to figure out
what you ever he's the and he sells the
of
might the sons could come and take it
away from
the again they can have the exact
same how in the world you should be able
to come and take it away and you're
going to tell
me oh maybe the son's going to say like
we just said
earlier let the son say we're not being
gous our father rather we're going
straight to the
grandfather that can't work
if you're telling me you're taking out
your father's place rather you're going
being your your grandfather
direct you're not a your father was the
tell we
not back to square one this is what and
that
says that's not
so you're right
we're grandfather however you know how
we should consider the grandson
Ren which is the grandson says you know
what you should consider
me I am taking my father's place and
more than that we saw this already in
the beginning of regarding the that the
were able to take their
father's was we all know he was a so the
same type of concept rather he's coming
and saying I want to take over my
father's place and I should be able to
be op a third that they sent for
a person he testified he was testimony
it was before he became a gin so there's
no question about it the AIS is ker
however VIN later on he became a gin so
gin
is he can't testify regarding his own
signatures why because he's not neon
because he's a
Goin other people could come and testify
that this is a good
signature so
how do you understand he's not the other
people should be
and what we really is that maybe this
person is a golin sorry he is a golin
but maybe since he's a golin he's a
shakran and what he did was he wrote and
Aid this falsely and put a predated date
before he was known as a golin that's
the that we have so in such a case why
should a be believed maybe maybe redated
it and that's the
scenario
again no maybe the scenario
is rather what's going on in we're not
talking about a regular scenario with
the signatures predate rather we know
thatz saw this before he became a Goin
so there's no question that the
signature on this check was before he
became a Goin therefore how you
how do we
[Applause]
understand so that's we understand why
are believed however he's not believed
because he's not beli because he's now a
golin however the signature at the time
he clearly was not a golin so could come
and testify that it's a signature it's
not a
problem a person
who he testified let's say on his third
cousin he never thought in the world
that he's going to be y so he testified
in this
he can't be in a scenario where now he's
the let's say all the other crave him di
so now he can't come and be
he's the throws in the same type
of so again maybe the same type of thing
we're worried about the what that he's
predating this document he's forging it
by predating it it's going to say oh
before he was a car and was really after
not a car it was before it was supposed
to form to him yha and really it was
afterward and that gives the same
answer like we mentioned earlier there's
no question that it was not predated
because it was ready in bezden therefore
we could understand that a person other
people are believed regarding testifying
on this
signatures at the last one the last
which is the
[Applause]
a person gave testimony before he became
a son-in-law to so at the time there's
no problem he's considered a regular
stranger but now he's a
sonw and
again how do you understand that to try
to tell me the that we just said earlier
talking about that it was ready
in
going that doesn't
help name
clearly and it doesn't
work says maybe it's not you know
why maybe just a technical it's not
about we all know that we're that he's
aak
why we all know couldn't testify
regarding their father
it's a technical point that we have that
a person cannot testify against his
father with Pro his father-in-law
however could come and say this is a
good
testimony again that he predated
it we're back to square one we went
through all these five different and we
came out there's
[Applause]
nothing says we're going to go back to
the first case not the first first case
in rather the first case in we said it's
a three
[Applause]
generations we said what do he mean the
grandson is saying I'm not being my
father I'm being who I'm being
directly I'll tell you know what I'll
tell you
just says
it's just you should have children just
like you on
that can you really tell us we're
talking
about the
top however we have our mission this is
the reason why we mention this whole
entire before was for this cuz we're
quoting Our Miss
now this is the case where a house fell
on a son and a father or and
what so now we have an argument the want
to say that what the son died first like
that the father was the son and
therefore they
the then the father
dieds and therefore the and
he's and my love don't we understand
that your is who is the B is this Mish
this case that it's an anle
and so the argument is really between
who between the grandsons and the
uncles and if you're going to tell me
that the person can being the
grandfather
directly what's help that the son dies
he the son
dies it doesn't change anything why
we're taking what are we doing we're
taking it either way we're knocking out
this whole comes what that he's either
way being the father it's going through
it's going right through the son so
what's
the answer
no and that we're answering you know
what the case is talking about that
we're saying that the is the Brothers
ruin saying ruin died first so we are
the brothers and we are yishu our father
and who is the case ruing Sons so ruing
sons are trying to say that what we the
father died the grandfather died first
not the father and our father was
therefore we
get and it's very interesting
thats it's still but we like it even
though
it's what about a
son what is died can he be's mother and
therefore he's going to give over the to
the brothers from the
father you have a father got captured in
the far away
country now we don't know who died first
either the son or the father
son the or the other way around the son
that was
captured so the in such a case
is split it because we have no way of
knowing like a regular case where it's a
father and son and that's the
case it's one bucket if whether the
father son doesn't make a difference who
really died first CU who's the Y arguing
there's no real argument that all want
to be either the or the father what's
the who died
first the father got captured in a far
away country and he died who
the the daughter son died or the other
way
around where the
mother's father died we don't know who
died first so such a
case now this is the riot to show us
that a son is either or
not his mother's father the and give it
to what give it to the brothers and
father from here we clearly
see we have another like
this when falls in the mother
you're going to tell
me son is not yish his mother when he's
not when he's not around when he's
in that a son is not's Mother the K and
that we already saw earlier in we saw
the
the was and then we had later in we
said guard the and
for
like therefore we have a from to tell us
that his son is not his mother
now we're going to finish we're going to
finish this with this per a very long
per it's very interesting we saw this
like saying we saw
this even questions that we why are we
mentioning because it's literally almost
worth the word it's a quote of what we
saw over there however if you look in
exactly the opposite we brought
first and then we asked a question from
the bab in our we're going to do it the
exact
opposite the reason why we mentioned it
is a little interesting is because we
spoke
about who's holding on we're going to
mention the case of
let's I'm sing you all that I bought
from
the there was one land comes and wants
to take it oh no this land is not
from however
just called
the they went
front so what he did was he gave it to
the and we're going to see
why is this really
true you're trying away to take away
this you should have to prove it that it
belonged
to to find us another
Ste my what are you doing in my house
was living in the inner
rooms you have to go prove
it so again
it's right because the
case we
answer
no who's holding on to the in the case
of
the therefore says I always
hold let's be real it's called it looks
like it probably is
if it talks like a duck quacks like a
dock looks like a dock acts like a dock
and everything we say probably is a duck
right it's no different than pulling out
AAR throws in a few words the last line
it's no different than when you have AAR
and the person is saying he's putting a
ear in it saying either
it's don't we tell
him go prove it that it's a good star
and who
here by the person he has to prove it
that there's no
problems okay we are going to jump into
the final per of get so right away we
all know that even though it's called
it's we all know gim it's 12 lines the
typical G 3+ N9 however it's all
different
and so there's no real difference
however we're going to discuss in those
days today we don't really have that
they had called AER everyone did the
they probably did it with a bunch of
illustrations with the papers how we did
it we're going to go on a quicker Pace
relying on the people that everyone you
know did it on throughout the exactly
the back and forth in the papers so
let's jump right into it get P now
interesting T throws in the reason why
we even have this whole per because we
finished per M the whole per m was
talking about people that wrote when
they we jump and continue the theme ofus
and then says even s is going to
continue it's all so let's see it inside
get the difference between
a we're going to see why we did a Mak
for theah they get very insulted very
quickly so a typical get p is that you
pull out a you write a bunch of
documents we have a Ty and a tyus the
difference between a Ty T is where the
where the where the where the raid is
exactly who it is it's ru for his wife
Ruben borrowed money and at this time
that's the that's where even if you
write that's where we going to fold the
documents however the T the t is a very
um Universal contract language you know
it just says he divorc his wife and his
wife is free whatever it is that's
called the there you clearly going to
leave it even in a scenario of
a we're going to
see where exactly by get Moser we sign
the documents the Aden are going to sign
it that's going to be the whole
um get we're going to jump
into regular get you the bottom of the
bottom of do like a
typical however maker when it's makush
which means you fold it up whether you
do with wax and
needle is is going to be in the back of
the paper
now is if you play around with the we
have very clear we have Mak you can't
mix it two and if you try to do any of
the opposite it becomes
pule has an advantage why if in
aenar it's going to be because all you
got to do is just rip up the m and your
back to since
it's could always
turn we're going to see this we're going
to go through this at
length regarding
get is you only have two
witnesses at least the minimum is you
need for at least three you can even do
more we're going to see in the however
the minimum is three
now again the is going to question it's
a and a regular with there's only one
eight it should be we're going to
discuss this again which was
yesterday's so let's jump inside the
where do we know that there are two
separate Stars we're going to bring
three two is going to be one's going to
be from
the the we saw
this this is talking about we all know
within B when what happened was we were
in gas
in tells go give over don't worry going
to go and they're
conquer but we're going to come back one
day however so it's we're going to see
if it's or not you should go right go
buy car now documented you put in a like
that when we come back when we come back
you'll be able to prove ownership we saw
this
extensively so says in
the should go field and you should seal
it beginning
is talking about
a when it sounds like it's
sealed what we have as
a we all know whenever it says a it's
the minimum is
two how could you
have
the simple
question is the one that has two and has
and that
answers we see that to make all these
which you fold the
document this is
one we're going to go the
[Applause]
second so he's saying he's taking this
document which was sealed which is going
according to the rules and the
regulations has go the reveal
document talking about
what when he's saying all the rules and
the laws and
regulations and the you saw in the
documents in the
backers
same and the last M that we're going to
try to bring is from says in the
three we two from and the last
from is this really true I have an
answer for all
that all three I could tell you for
something
else like we learned when it says
by to go by the
field it's
only that's out the first the second
where it's talking about B from his
cousin where B from his cousin from his
uncle his cousin but he bought the field
also
just how he bought it from his cousin
and the
last there
three so has nothing to do
with right right
is is
only so we're bringing a right it's not
really a
clear
now what is we made it quite extensive
the answers you know why we did it we
did it for we did it for
the we all know theah are more M they
get more insulted they get more they
take stuff a little more personal than
usual it doesn't make sense cuz on a
higher level Etc the explain
this they divorc their wives very
quickly takes a quick one supper gets
burnt they come running they want to
divorce their wives so what did the
do you know what they did they made a
special toap out the get
process time took a very long time you
had to go get the you had to fold it you
had to sew it etc
etc by time he was ready up to the last
fold time had to he says you know what
it doesn't make sense divorce my wife
therefore they
wrote so that we understand
for like we started the it's nothing to
do with
answers in order that a person should be
gives a couple that if you're going to
pass regular you can also get or we're
worried that if you're not going to do
it by other stories you're going to stop
doing it by get
so where do the witnesses sign this star
by by we know where you sign it you sign
it on the
bottom between every single fold that
you signing the document there say is
you're signing it inside the
star where you do
it you do it from the behind when you
fold
it exactly opposite the writing so every
fold is going to have a
signature
ACC that says you do it between every
single fall many is we do it
inside was that came in front the and re
did not understand at the time we're
going to see this later also rebbi was
not familiar with M he says
where's the where's the what's going
on no maybe it's
in what he did was
up tell
me if it's then when
you why was he only catching about the
time you should have said where's the
witnesses the Witnesses were the outside
maybe we should be worried that he could
Forge whatever he wants now that you're
telling me in a
scenario that you write the stars that a
signed on top of the document not in the
bottom why not worried you can write
whatever you want on the
start since the were written on top Mar
you know why the you write at the end of
the document
this is all that's
left another time write whatever he want
and put
another you only do
one let him erase it and then write
whatever he wants then
write more than that cuz we
see says
answers as follows you know
why says if it's which means if you
forgot to put a word so you put like a
little arrow you write whatever you had
to do and you put on the bottom of the
star and you say that you added it
however this is the answer that if you
erase it
is even so therefore we're not worried
that you're going to erase it
however only if there's enough space for
the
words has to be place where You' write
it and it's that
is that says you write
it write whatever he wants in the inside
thear you add in every fold you have to
add a eight no problem he'll add
eight and it's
for you know why I did it I want to be
more of a I added more Aiden and more
than that the t is right away whether
it's a get or get you only have to be M
the minimum so get if there's 10 all you
have to be is the three original a and
therefore he's able to forge it on that
he
answers which means to say is I'm hoping
everyone exactly you know more of a
picture but the point is when they
signed the documents the whole kaswa is
based on the standing that the way they
signed it is on a typical parallel to
the text so therefore you could add
folds and then just add another aen
however then answer is we're making a
mistake rather the way they signed the
starus is vertical if it was a parallel
tax you signed the aen in vertical so
there's nothing more to add because if
you're going to try to add another fold
you're going to see that it looks very
so was tampered with and therefore it
would be P if you look over there you
can see those pictures over there
maybe we should be worried you know what
that the bottom text has a very bad you
know something against him whether he
was paid up quicker time something that
he's not happy the the Mal the GU he
goes takes his scissors cuts the last
document and we're on the understanding
we're going to see in a moment we're on
the understanding if you look at those
pictures that only one of the aen had
his signature on the last document the
rest were higher up again we're saying
the ad is vertical not
parallel and he cuts the last line where
it said the word
Ru so it says the son of
and is so one of the signatures just
says answer is
no the way you make sure the documents
written on the last line of text you
write make sure it's on the same line so
therefore if he cuts the star what are
you left with you have to take a Ru and
B you just left the words y for tomorrow
so doesn't really help you back to
square one because you're still neon
with just having a signature that
says anwers in such a case you don't you
don't write the word a the of a so all
you're left with
is so if you try to cut Ru what do you
left with just the word y the is still
pushing that's
one of says eight you have just a word
that says
Ruben that we
know we know that there's no one that
says is a big p he says that there's no
one in
the that writes Yak like that however
the are very bothered by that they say
how do you know how could a person how
could best know that there's no Yakov in
the whole entire V rather the him
explained that he's nervous a person
it's all about confidence every time a
person does fraud he's based on conf
confidence if he thinks he could get
caught it's enough of the deter so to
he's afraid that might do and find out
that there's no such a thing as a person
signs like that so that fear alone is
enough to determ that's explain makes
much more sense to go with that
H
again he's writing and that's his he
writes it for the honor of his father my
answer is no person doesn't do that
a person's not going to let go of his
own signature and for cover use his
father's
signature we find the was he would
always have a signature like a shape of
a fish was
a like palm trees like the dates of palm
trees the branches would ride a would
ride an
and would ride like a m of a
ship to make your father's name as a as
a
that's
one why are we getting so complicated
have easy way
out easy way in order for it to beer it
has to be that the a them and the
signatures are on one page therefore
what you word you going to cut it it's
not going to help because it's it's
going to be on different lines
so all these stuff that
eras there's a if you you have to write
a whole list what exactly you erase you
have to write the summary however you
have to put it
in and thear is going to explain that
the last text before the signatures
let's call that one line if you look at
those like pages that have lines in it
that one last line you can't learn
anything out from it and we're going to
see why so what do you do so you fill it
up with with just nothing
you just R you're being a little
repetitive because there's nothing to
learn out of
it is and because we're concerned that
the way when a person even today when
you sign a document you're afraid to
sign very close to the text you always
give yourself more space and the reason
is you're nervous you're going to
scribble into the following Top Line so
therefore you give yourself another line
and then you sign your signature so
we're worried in such a case if you're
going to learn from the you're if you're
going to be able to learn from it
person's going to sign then the B is
going to come and write whatever he
wants do we know this I'll show this you
don't learn from the last
line it says as follows if the
had if they left over two lines worth of
the document however
this is part of the
that have the same problem with
one whatever he
want don't
learn therefore it's only when you have
it with two lines that it's
possible what happens if you left a
little more than a line line and a half
what's the sh you could technically
squeeze and play write a little smaller
throw in whatever you want to throw
in can
make right away
says make a the other way
around know we have this many times in
they can't bring it right from any of
them therefore you're back to square
one what is with one and a half
lines we're g to
bring this is the r that it says
what says even one and a half therefore
it's a that it works
what happens you have AAR there's
multiple a however you give one look at
thear and you recognize that some of
these are clearly so it should be a tell
me it's good enough as long as you find
a few that are we don't we're not the
bad
why should
think answers because if it would be
left blank the let's say it's that's we
learn so what's the person want to do he
wants to solve not to leave it blank he
has few of his brothers please just fill
out my document and they sign it like
a we find this
in you g to ask how could it be if you
filled up just filling up the with
craer we know if there's a
regular however if you
put you see the same type of concept
over here sometimes leaving a blank is
worse than pule same type of thing by
thear leaving a blank again it makes
sense because the reason why you're
leaving a blink we're worri that what
that you'll tamper the document so fill
it up with who cares we're not going to
be G but we find the same of concept
that it's not enough it's not going to
just because
it's we have this it has two documents
there two two lines so let's just make
it easier if you look inside right the
words of is let's say half a millimeter
however if you look at the space until
is another let's say quarter of a
millimeter so the sh is do we count the
space in between the lines when we
handle when we say that there's of line
of text or
not maybe you don't count the space in
between the called sh vur there's a
little space it's like in your every
line in the has a tiny bit of space
they're not touching they're not
touching to say when we say two lines we
count the regular full two lines just
like when we have that it's each one we
count the space in
between takes out he doesn't have
the means you're able to see that it was
tampered with because you don't have
real space so you're going to have to
what it's like even even if a person
today wants to write in his gar or
something he doesn't have real space he
puts in Little Words and he plays with
it so in such a case you're going to
realize right away
says because you don't really have space
in such a case it's
considered the two lines that were
saying where we go you take out a
document there's of a cipher has very
beautiful very beautiful neat
handwriting nice and small and then you
have the witnesses that are much bigger
so when we say two lines who we focusing
we're focusing on the cyer or we're
focusing on
the he wants to say you know what going
to focus on the Adam's handwriting my
up anybody that wants a forge a
document he doesn't go and run to the
cipher to do z b says he's not going to
risk his whole for one time tampering
the documents not going to die for him
therefore he stays away from corruption
the only person who's going to Tamper
the documents is going to be the aidam
therefore we count the two lines so you
do have to say it's a little interesting
that based on this gar that if a person
comes to you with a star and this
beautiful handwriting of the cipher that
the whole document then suddenly you see
big handwriting of let's say the Adam or
the Bashar who's not a CER as long as
there's two ker a we say it's ker even
though the handwriting is different you
have to say that CER wrote and then you
decide to second to add it because
otherwise you would understand from
thear they have a problem of saying that
it's what that it's m sounds like
clearly from the gar that we're not
going to say it's m even if the
handwriting is different in such a
case so so how big is this
year to be very clear it's consider the
L so every time if a person even takes
out a typical page and he writes the
word the top of the L is going into to
the space between the next I so there's
a lamid which is touching the A and then
the end of the L then there's
a the regular of the is also going and
if you write twice upon each other so
you have
the it comes out how many it's four a cu
the top of the L the bottom of the and
again the top of the L because we're
learning it's directly underneath it
therefore it's four spaces
however it's four a it's four
spaces that's
that the way he's learning is that it's
not the L and the are not exactly on an
angle it's only if it's vertical
L that's when you have four it's just
and and then you doing the L which is
touching parallel to the Regal of the
you're not you take out that a there for
your left with
three so you have the and the which is
two the L is one and the the regular is
another it's considered
two this that were saying that you worry
that there's two lines it's only between
the and you can only have two lines but
one line
is however between we all know is the
hemp that's R you have a stamp on the
bottom of the documents in such a
case even if it's more than a few
lines that he's going to forge and
Tapper with the
document so say the same thing with with
know
answers that he spills ink he pours he
fills it up with ink therefore there's
nothing to tamper with the
document if let he have a scenario where
there's more than two do two
lines put on
ink going to make a
mistake you know what they might sign
on you know what they're signing they're
just signing that the the the if you
look at a document a typical document
it's full of ink you know what you'll
say there was something bad on the star
so he covered it up so that you'll say
maybe are just signing that there's
nothing under the ink but they're not
they're just focusing on the
ink
say my answer is no is much smarter than
sign the signing the whole
enre maybe what he's going to is he's
going to cut the whole top of the
document he's going
toas part of
it so in such a case why we not worried
in such a case that he's all he's going
to do is erase the
document that he's learning this then
you don't ask a because is going to tell
youle however
clearly says this in the name of what
are you going to
say such a
case in such a case we're not we're
not on
the
rather on the you have to get the to ret
testify on everything in such a case
right away says the third the third
line
says that Tak makes a mistake and they
sign only on they get they sign only on
the on the
ink so in such a
case says very clearly even in they
signed in the
in so
going to tell me the what he going to
cut the top of the
document they're going to he's going to
write whatever he wants and have
witnesses saw add his own witnesses that
are false in that same
line says Ru ruen borrow for me $100 and
you have on the exact same line two fake
signatures and he's going to again we
went through this we said that you only
have to be M two out of the a so the
bottom two a that's when the
is the ones that he's going to
be so
again he's gonna cut the
top
answers which means to say is if you
have a document that says borrowed $100
and the b in such a case is possible
like we're saying it says one line and
there's multiple and he only going to be
the
bottom you know you're GNA have to
testify the of that same line which is
the only issue
that because the bottom again we're not
worried that it was a
you have a
scenario where the whole entire star the
whole entire document is already erased
however it's not a problem as long as
it's Rewritten
it's if you're
ask maybe you should be again that he's
going to race whatever he wants and it's
going to come out that it's a tampered
document
says which means to say is you can't if
a person looks at a document and he sees
that the text of the document was only
erased uh was
erased twice and the were erased once
you'll see it's a t
document we have to say this outside
this this exact same case to really
understand the patent that he's doing
what's he going to really be doing he's
going to be doing multiple steps he he
goes over to aen and he fills that ink
he erases it aen come and sign on the
document now in such a case you have you
have a document that was really erased
only on the bottom once then he goes and
he takes he erases the whole entire
document fills it out has a has aam
erase it in such a case then he erases
the whole entire document again so it's
a so what happens is it comes out that
the top of the document was erased
really once the bottom of the document
is a was how many times do erased twice
so now when he has such a document and
he erased this the top and replaces with
whatever you want what are you left with
you're left with a document that both B
the aen B the were erased twice this
guy's Al he he he the loophole by pling
having the before the document was was
erased twice the ad was already raised
twice in such a case you're walking away
with a star that both of them have equal
ground that they both erased twice
answerers no in such a
case what's your whole pent is that
you're going to fake it you're gonna
erase it and then have in such a case
like that it's erased
twice they're not going to do such a
case if they see that it's from the
top they're going to see that the first
one was already erased only once the
bottom was erased twice they're smarter
than that they're going to that he's
trying to play with them and they're not
going to sign
if he is on a regular text that was
never erased the and the
signatures was in a place where it's
raised it's not making sense he could
have raised
the it comes out that the text of the
document and the signature of the
document were both eras once answerers
you know
why this was what they
say Witnesses
we sign where was already race once
however the
was so therefore if a person since it
clearly out of this Clause there's no
way to race the
top where are they signing where are
they writing this
Clause if going to put it under their
signatures the guy's just always going
to do is take a scissors and cut that
Clause out and then erase the top of the
document gly El you going to tell me
he's going to put it on the top of his
signatures he's M he's just going to
erase it and you're back to square one
then you're left with the whole document
that's erase so where are you going to
do it our answer
is you
have then you put your clause and then
you put the second a so if you try to
erase the document you're going to see
that there's a massive space in between
the there a clause andure that you can't
cut it because if you cut it you're
cutting off
18 we have the that says as
follows what happens if the text of the
documents on eras the however the
witness is sign on a regular star that
was never erased
the
we we saw in the regular
document so what are you gonna tell
me you tell me you told me earlier where
we started the D with
so what are you worried about why is it
pu it's only weird that sign and
something was erased
however in a scenario where the
witnesses did not sign it on a place
wasas they're not going to be able to
understand the
difference I understand just take
another M and do a parallel and look
between the two documents you'll be able
to
tell like that you can compare it answer
say you can't
compared every document even a there's
multiple types of some if you look at
certain sa tires they're very heavy the
cloth is very thick C tire is very thin
cloth so the point is that you can't you
can't compare two stas if it's not the
same star because again it's very
possible it's a whole
different once thicker ones not so you
can't compare the
two no
problem let's
testify then erase the signatures
because we read
was then you can compare the two on that
say you can't erase it already it's too
late once it already dried up it's ready
to late so you can't compare the older
race so wait do what we just said this
patent and wait a day like that you'll
see that eventually once it ages it
Ages were worried one of we're worried
that we're learning that what we're
worried that is not going to wait they
don't know this wait and therefore
they're G to
either okay we're going to
continue back in the Mish
has a CU every maker you could turn it
into a
so you tell me that every is like
[Applause]
a and had something very fascinating
that the was for example in today's day
and age you would write at the fourth
year of Pres President Biden whatever
make it dates those days they counted
the bus of the M but if it was a get P
you right December 8th
20204 however was the makush moreas for
the president you would write December
8th 2025 so right away how in the world
you going to tell me that ausher has a
mile of a you have a big problem outside
we'll go right through the inside you
have a massive problem is that what
happens is a person writes a a a AAR
it's not so much about get where the
problem is AAR a person says I borrowed
money from you on December 8th 2024 and
it's a makush 20 and he writes really
2025 cuz it's a makush now he comes back
a few months later he pays him back and
he says can I please have the makush
back he says I lost it but I'll write
you a receipt so he writes in a receipt
he says May 1st 2025 you return the
money a year later what's he do this
person he takes out the makush that he
was hiding the whole time he turns it
into a and he has a document that
clearly states that what December 8th
2025 he borrowed money so he comes over
he says can my money says I pay you back
in May says I talk about the receipt
says may 202 2025 this was borrowed
December 8th 2025 so why are we not
worried for such a problem this is the
this is the mass
of the way the word you count the year
was
however give another year
why we not
worried say I lost it l he writes a
receipt but the receipt says What May
1st
2025 now comes December 8th of
2025 pulls out the that really was tells
him
it's now
answer you're right gone in a m where
there was no sh in a place where there's
a you can't this reason now if there's
no receipt person says I would love to
pay you back till you find me in the
Moser I'm not giving you back your money
therefore there's no
problem
really RAB didn't understand that the
makush the wrote they wrote the year
later so he says it's a postdated it's a
was his name he
tells we just
said so again how could you say the re
this is the it sounds like over here the
rebi was not was not cloring this Mar
answer is yeah you're right
BOS told them what's happening he asked
such a
question we're understanding now means
the we the sand it means the first
year we go check what year was the first
year of his
presidency means if anything long means
the
first they called
it we have this right now with President
Trump that he
got out and then he's coming back so
it's very possible you're calling it
what you're calling the AR could mean
2016 or could mean 2024 2025 really
right so how do you
know you know you know what you call
this president in such a case who we all
know everyone saying the Trump is called
AR cor you put in and you put in both
you call it the second term of his first
year of the second term going to find
such a concept that de means to
says now every time every time you a 30
days if a person says means so he all he
has to do is take a 30day
of0
days
interesting is Penton like a pentagon
even like a St called a pentagon is is
five ra yeah they have it a little
different the way they made five but we
have it we always understand the five is
a little different than that
dou Three Corner
House however only four
corner we learn means we count
every like we saw earlier the RAB says
we set over the story T open this
document and
he RAB looked at him you know he came he
looked at with a little he's
displeased he says what do you want for
me it wasn't
me I didn't write it you know who wrote
it the one who shows he's the one who
wrote it don't don't don't M me said
so stop saying this he should have just
easily said it wasn't me why you saying
who it was you see I'm not happy Z gets
even better the
story and he's finishing one of the of
you know the he's finishing one of the
re says
ah oh
I wasn't the one who wrote
it was the one who wrote it he's the one
who wrote this beautiful
T he also says stop saying
this very simple the first case where he
saw he wasn't happy with the that was
too deep that's what it sounds like from
we can understand
this what's the problem you gave a
compliment he didn't want to take the
brais it's not me it was him
one of the most
famous I think we say more in a public
setting if a person gets up and he
starts saying how this person there's
always people in the room who can't
forget and they throw and not smart
comment and it
causes we're going to fin
the three it's very hard for
us one of them
is interesting it brings that means a
person's very
confident doesn't understand says that
every day it's very hard for person to
100% focus on it's one of our stuff we
always constantly have to work
on all these if you go through doesn't
make
sense rather
there's a way either you could say this
guy's house his candle's always lit so
really depends you can use
the never turns off his lights or you
can say if you understand from the
movements Etc you could really mean that
he's constantly
parting again it's because it's really
depending how he says it
[Applause]
even very fascinating says we're not
going to come and shoplift you don't
find the Y taken away from a store but
when it comes to returns and it comes to
stuff that had to very quickly that it's
not black and
white
okay I don't
understand he's not going to hold the
why not
as
follows if it's a place the only right
to get let's
say whether it's
for go write
me and then he ran and
wrote in t if it's not a good get I
didn't ask you to do this or the other
way around let's say it's Lakewood where
they do
where's let's we said yesterday doing
the D let's they do any there's no
real and he goes and explicitly tells
him I want you to write
me then he went and
wrote a person's I ask you to do me a
you should have done
a
says so we said yesterday very
fascinating
says was that what's
the
is so we we learned from that when I
asked you to do a and you went and did
more happier sounds like that if I asked
you do a and you went and did a then is
even that it's not a good gu okay so
such a case it's a so what is this what
we're going to be discussing right now
means I'm giving you a piece of advice
I'm asking do you mind going to laka to
pick up my package you went even further
away so I'm not telling you I'm asking
you but if you do even
more happy they even went more out of
your
way this concept
what all I'm asking you is just I'm
giving you it's all I'm going to ask you
I'm not going to push you for more we
just saw which is our in a case where
they write a I asked you to do a and you
went extra we're not going to have the
financials money we're not bringing
money into the picture and you went and
did him a
cusher he holds it just he's
not when do we
find in the scenario K now person there
was a is say in Lakewood and the and a
person in Lakewood told if you marry me
I'm going to give you a silver bar she
goes she goes over the room says could
you please go to lakeood as and go pick
up from shim who told me he's going to
marry me for a silver bar then she goes
to L he gets a gold bar so is or
not to say's all she say even something
like a silver bar I'm willing to marry
him K gold it's worth much more some say
it's so this
is Gold's worth much
more say even so
that's now person says go to Lakewood
pick up my get and you have to go much
further you have to go all the way to
Baltimore so the sh is it or not so once
T pule he and says fasting says why he
says maybe in that place it's going to
be more bous people know me over there
it's going to come out it's going to
come out noise over there it's more
bushers wanted you to go to lakid I
didn't want you to go to Baltimore where
I live Etc therefore it's possible says
again I'm asking you could you go toid
and he calls you back says they even
went much more out of my
way even went more for
me so again we have three we find
this now it says
we understand we
understand would have
understood usually two enough
that's why would why would I think if
you have a St that only has one A should
beeres it's possible such a case this is
the m you have a one or let's
say and one was written and one was
written he says the says in such a case
it's possible for what that you don't
say that oh there's a call Da when a
sign there's a c to take away from and
more than that in such a case where
there's only one
one and I didn't M the star back cuz I
knew you didn't WR like a did that's how
there puts it back puts it down so such
a case
it's however
argues holds in such a Cas
is that it iser more than says even a
mass to even take away from you have to
understand that he held that it's enough
to be that's the only reason why you're
taking away from is when there's enough
of
Ault what do you mean
I don't know you want for
me I don't
hold what are you going to do with how
is learning
that that what in the world is what is
the
case
answ in a
scenario you
know tells us that it's to tell us
just like you understand by a what a
that only has one Aid it's it's not
considered
to there's no such a thing as
a because the whole is
rather so St that it's m considered even
possible say a get it's not considered
get then and if it's AAR you can't take
away
from now now we're going to say
something very fascinating we're going
to bring back very fin we learned the
begin where we discussed a bird that the
was that a bird goes up
to it doesn't fly so we said If a person
finds a if it's
within
belongs so asked a question he says what
is the if the bird has one leg outside
the and what's the over there
say we saw we said even in this year we
were asked what's what what's Tak wrong
with his
question says
that and there's no such a thing as a
bird even one leg go out of the 50 he
wasn't respecting you have to understand
really what that means but he wasn't
respecting that's what we said the we
even said it on the Sunday share that
that's what said they through out but
today we're going to learn we're going
to bring multiple versions of so this is
what happened what happened was he T
someone to learn like this ended up
going to Buble he got kicked out of the
B Nary TR so he went to learn in bble
and now so they sent him letters they
asked him shus in B what is the and he
answered back he says to ask me but even
now he asked me I'll answer like a talid
and with the respect that he gave them
they invited him back there to and
that's and then that's how the fairy
tale ended so let's see it inside
there's multiple versions how the shil
me and with that we're going to finish
today's share so let's see it
inside and the reason why we're bringing
this is is going to prove it to us has
the same type of concept of what is what
that you have AAR with
one and
one says we have
what we're learning with and and and
they explain
the we have to give a little more
context to what's going
on really we're going to see
this where this if a person comes to
Ruben comes to he says I saw 100,000
Sunday then the following comes whether
it's the same day he says I sort a
Monday that he borrow money so if you
look at the whole entire picture there's
no two a saying a complete story however
if you we have two ad saying what they
Rin Bor
$100
explains
even so we went through yesterday we
explain what's the comparison to the
case of aen where one says on Sunday one
says on Monday here also
in our case the way we understand the is
they're both agreeing that he lent the
money just one couldn't he had a broken
arm Etc so is however there's one
fascinating is that when a person signs
on a document he's not signing that he
saw the a person comes over he says I'm
going to Lake with to borrow $1,000 can
you please sign the doc like that I
could give it to the Mala so one the
person who signed is just signing is to
give over that the document is going to
be accurate and true however the is not
so comes at
the and the are not testifying about the
exact same thing because the is the guy
the is a guy just testifying about the
document so
therefore you can compare the
two to the case of where one saying
Sunday one saying Monday it's separate
you
understand maybe you don't maybe could
be that he
answer I'm not you should ask me such
questions talking about
himself so again why is a bringing this
up he's showing us that there areas that
hold like
him
is then he says he tells says no I had a
different with
not had a different
version so you have two they testified
in one they
go if one com separate days could he
be says a
it's not a problem even in different
days
only
again and there
answers
however that was the second version the
third version the
this is what they asked
him you have to add in that there was
actually three times so the shil was a
person goes to bz on Sunday 2 a and
every bin has minimum of three and he
goes to b a different B on Monday again
in front of three and then on Tuesday
goes to a different B front of the three
can you take from every bzden one di or
you don't even need really three could
really have two and the point is
they of the two in such a case as long
as you pick them out they could give
testimony that they heard from so the
says even because they're even
understanding their is from two they're
not
even want
to and again he says
then we have one last version how was
with doing and they all be then they go
take out the stamp and sign it and I
guess they do their initials they write
their
signatures so good because there was
three however the sign there was only
two so the was who they have to
write we
were is no longer with us that's why you
only see two two signatures on the
D and again the problem what we're
worried about is that a person is going
to see a star with a H with old he's
gonna say oh even it's
fine asked
me what you have to
we were one is no longer with
us the way he
[Applause]
spoke they brought him back into the Bas