Away From Home, Where is Ner Chanukah Lit? - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] Reutimann blemishing hashem same immediate area of the coverton to introduce her vehicles in Smith's today Shearer a missus net an akela Mishima base site away from home where's Nash Anika left over like the other dates closer sponsor a shake well here in cherie terry at seven one eight eight five one eight six five one how many gets before young till we try to give them something is not that they commonly respond to the thoughts when you sit with the family I think today's host sugar is one big miss Marcus suka which is Nagila my sir but it's also a yeah so get of pain the cocklebur yakimite you could take it and it's my stuff oh hey look the Suki goes and goes and goes and let me think where I started someone that works lives in Brooklyn works in Lakewood and had a fasten or one of the nights of Casa of Hanukkah in Lakewood so it certainly wasn't gonna go home come back to Brooklyn light and go back so you want to know if he could light either in a shul the icy with the shoes of luck in Lakewood or light in the husana Hall someone that works late during the nights of Hanukkah clear light in his workplace he owns the store he owns the business key light in his workplace the buckler and yeshiva who lights and bass measures for the zebra and he's in the same building cos that's his dorm he sleeps they eats there can he be with the other locker that he does for the yeshiva I'll take an instinct question which is not Nagaya and here in America but sin artists role if it's still warming it's certainly in Australia in Australia right now with summer so the Konica is also the summer vacation believe it or not so there are people that go on a overnight hike and they camp out so the arm Amish Takas keepers a Somalian is there a are they allowed to light I'm equipped to light when they're outdoors so if you notice the common denominator all this questions are we know that you need oil and awakener Manoa - lightning Chanukah the unita bias is a bias absolutely necessary for the midsummer Chanukah and if you do need a bias can i light at someone else's bias and that's why can i light in the wedding hall why can i light in the shoe you do need a bias perhaps but why who said it's my bias necessarily and a very good muscle would be a homeless person that has no bias could he just light in the street so basically many mitzvahs are anyway USA you could whatever you want you could listen to kid this you could have an outdoor kid this you could be right sir you could be out to someone else's house kid this you could hear i'm dull in someone else's house you could blow so you could hear strife in someone else's sure so why should we think their chronic is totally in a bias but then again their Shabbos does have a shyness to a bias so let me just make a point I think will bring out the challenge of the sugah we once spoke a number of years ago but better about a totally different Schuyler and that is the old question how do we describe the nature of merit Annika there are some mitzvahs that we call the high us how cook in a muscle every bird every person has to eat matza every person has to every man has to its villain that's a key of an every single person then you have a mitzvah for the family for one person the family from example mezuzot mezuzah you have to put up a mezuzah now let's say the father puts up moszer's on sunday and the son decides on monday i want to be mahadji min of Mahajan and he puts up a second mezuzah with abraca so you got to mrs. Brock Lovett Allah and Baal Tyson right can put up a second mezuzah it's one per family what is the understanding of the Nair Hanukkah is it a fiber Surcouf every person has a failure of every man and woman and child is it a banana bias so to make a very long story short narrow conic is not so easy to characterize because Lamesa there's a and every person like near chronic and no doubt about it but the uniqueness of marathoner key is it's an air issue basin the father could light and is going to the whole family Bice Mardan either um Isaiah the Father light and the buckram the boys do not light so it's a different type of mitzvah it's a P upon every person to make sure that he has a mix of their Hanukkah in his house now this is that around us Ashkenazi we have an option of maja German and Mahajan I drop the ice with my father I could light my own but at the end of the day it's a flavor Sackhoff that can be discharged with the bias and that's a wonderful circuit which is not for today today we're beyond that I know it's a mitzvah on me and you I could be right up with someone else but it's a mitzvah on each and every one of us now the question is it's a mitzvah me too I have to have a bias can i light when I'm camping out can i light in the street can i light in an airport terminal blast be my bias so you're wondering what's the shine who doesn't know the well-known Gomorrah and Shabbos coffee hour from the bay's mitzvahs Hanukkah there is Chu basin who is super famous you have to have a bias but that's not a riot at all because in that context base a means family Rashi says the favorites is the Colburn a basic survey say means family not home like the structure of the home if you look in the Rambam in the beginning of paragraph' hispanica the rhombuses mitzvahs to see a cold bias bias malik narrow that's the Ramona she does say but the ECOD anyone there's enough per family bias so he doesn't say baser he says bias but truth be told even the word bias doesn't mean that you have to have a bias bias means per home like you smarter than to do this one hug lock up her home so reversely whenever we have a question we like to say Eve are you saying the crow Eber you say miss floor in other words first of all we are rious one way and also the swara says the same no rumble across smaller so if you have a rally and you have a smaller you are very confident in today's sugah I found the challenging because the smaller goes one way and the crowd the riot goes the other way now let me explain let's think does NER Hannah Kearney Tobias so in swara there's no reason to believe you need a bias the objective of NER Hanukkah is pursue may Nisa so why should it be dependent on a bias and don't forget in the times of the Mishnah is they lit outdoors so it wasn't inner bias so imagine the following yeah my choice has a 32-room mansion and he lights color her passive based site comes along the ankle the unnie doesn't know in her home he's homeless he says can i light next to you on your passive base a so yeah so my shirt is joka sunday right can you tell any difference between my choices and yong-chol the unnies headlock is near Hanukkah they're both outdoors what's the difference pursue manisa is achieved by a bomb and I are now mezuzah needs a door post post it because practically but why should their chronic a battalion bias as long as you have the necessary manure that makes pursue mateesah now I what do you mean with me every year we have shy lists about I'm eating someplace Lee and sleeping somebody else to see you need a bias oh that's true once you want to be maja Gina do it right what's the better place I mean the whole nerve tonic is Mahajan but who said a homeless person doesn't have a fear and who says some of this camping out has no fear if this piece to Manisa it's a mitzvah but here's the challenge because I could say Ebola is a macro it's commanded the Pharisee Gomorrah they can either bias one of the unique how love is regarding their Hanukkah ago burn Chavez cough gimel hi Ryanair Hanukkah Tarek lavoris and as Rashi and Tice's explained if someone doesn't have a home and doesn't have the mid-south lock is there Konica what should he do do nothing so there's a special finish there's a breakfast area the first night of Hanukkah when this person who can't light see someone's menorah he makes the brushes Anissa and Tiago and all subsequent nights he makes the brother of the jalsa Neeson he does not make the breath cosmic because he's not doing them I submit but there's a business area even if someone can't do them it's so Rashi on that Kamara says why do you have a special vehicle Saraya someone that not mad like the base i or the ocean bus fina he's on a boat so what's wrong he's on a boat apparently a boat is not a bias and he can't light so as the rush explains he's on a boat but he could see from the distance someone's home he sees a Manoa you make a broker what's wrong with the boat if you don't need a buy is walking right in the boat but toys and silca Duffman valve is more in the forest choices mom-ish asset point-blank why is the breakfast area banana cannot bide by lulav don't forget rule was much more expensive than their Konica so trisys muslim CH company other than Shane LEM button then PR the became a mitzvah so crisis seems to say if there's no bias there's no Mitzvah now we could really add that you could borrow someone else's now let me know mama given bit for dyrus they waiter online the rough sales and if they've de bench down the road I'll let me know but you can't borrow someone's house so the business are are you indicate if there's no bias there's no Mitzvah guitars in tough race I in science if conveys a very fundamental pass for us today the ties right that are not annoyed who's a guest that staying by you could be included in your narrow Hanukkah but says the ties emphatically but if someone comes the house just for sued there and leaves he after the Sudha he cannot light in your house he's not enough of a guest and that's like Hilo I'm indecisive I'll revive her ear they ain't shy who I had welcome someone that just comes to you first force up and goes can out light in your house he's like lighting on the street that's unthinkable that is emits of mechanical the task says both of our kaduche him that we need first of all you can't light on the street the homeless person can light you need a bias and even if you have a bias but it's not your bias it's your host bias you can light there so the task is clear as they not only need a bias homeless person can right but it can just ring a ring around a random doorbell let me light in your house though it has to be a bias and has to be your values affirmation you're a day okay the gimbal simu doll seat cotton hey says the Farish if someone's sleeping outdoors or he's traveling he can he's part of their Chanukah no bias no hot locker and of stampers almond in fresh Lamberton Yanis imminent rest is very convinced that since the mitzvah is their issue basa he says you need a bias pests of a sir is good if it's your Bayside then outdoor pet stuff is good the outer pass the basic but if you don't have a bias there's no cave so here we see we shine in early acronym the toss and hang to the cranium are all convinced the bias is absolutely necessary but then we find we shine him the coal boy mmm dollar the darkest I am and the Mordecai three we shine and that say if someone's traveling by boat he could make a light on the boat i-it's not a bias evidently they hold you don't need a bias as long as you have the the narrow conical light I guess thus far is presume a nice is the deciding factor the lavash was a talmud of the remote aphasia in Zion Bay's he says how long the ear someone is sleeping over in a bee arm sight alone BR and sleeping in a forest oh hi little Bettina sorrowful aha Nakula VAR a so he's mom is talking about camping I guess he lived in a warmer climate and if you camping out you make a broth of Nair Hanukkah they're fresh Oakland in our sim and CFA says four double posh it someone that's traveling by a train lights on the trainer makes a Brava what's the chat I found a bias who said you need a body that long as it promotes the Mitzvah of pursue mayonese so that's all you need the city liaison test volkov test was mama she s one of our stylist i guess it's from this somebody lives in the southern hemisphere we're now with someone and he won he's the ones to camp alpacas keep us as Shamari Maupin a I saw them he says what's the problem the fee of mechanic who caca CAFTA de Guevara beloit Oliva bias as clear as can be it's a cave on the person he doesn't need a bias he says either were some Irish she says that you can't light on the boat that's partially because you're talking about a case we didn't have the oil or it's gonna blow out but on a boat he says there's certainty you could light must be as long as it works you you could be like Irish she says that if you're better you didn't buy it because a homeless person generally doesn't have oil or wick I am of tears he said I toys this says a my bias she says it's partially attempts if a person that's traveling and he's wandering he doesn't have the necessary monoi oil awakes but it's not necessary to have a biased alight the most convinced the us-led group of Yemen's Elvin Kayla Grove I in hey he says I heard people say have to have a bias from their Hanukkah there's no basis for this and he says mama Shalit I never ain't near Chanukah me who Peter it's not a a Cazares a casa la estoy de prisa Manisa so why should it be necessary to have a bias then inhaling sighing Simmons I'm of Zion he says someone that's in the mid where about the collide he says even a both he said you could light like me so under we showing him I the place Kim that question welcome akela Buckham Shana that's la casilla you want to do things Mahajan Mahajan but it's not market but the biggest kid that she says inhaler good I love simmer my mad BAE's he says let's say there's an outdoor Asifa now in America we don't have outdoor seasons in the winter but let's say in there it's a stroll or getting in Australia those warm countries and they make a bigger sefa outdoors and he says there you could have I the light with Abraha because anybody else lights outdoors in times of the Mishnah is so why is this different so he's famished saying that you don't need to buy yourself and then again I love lime the doubt that he says if you're camping out you can make a broker this revoice I is a PI SIG's dilemma Rossi enticed seem to say you need a bias and we found your surname you don't the TAS says you need a bias and the lavash says you don't you have a motion of Simon's Alma zina Tobias and yep behind the girlfriend must need boots Atelier sir the hishaku say you don't need a bias so who could be my career so you know I but basically what it makes sense to say is if someone right now doesn't ever buy us and he will get a bias he will come home later tonight even if it's late at night as long as it's before a lawyer shocker we allowed a light McCullough with the brothel when it when it we couldn't do earlier he should wait till he gets home if someone is talk of homeless or he's camping out and his mama SH there's no bias at all that night I father he should like where he is but not make a breath out Suffolk brothers but what one of my I want to mention is let's say someone is allowing them to say I have a great idea letting light outdoors or let her might and the money's camping out and let him make two of the three brothers my monoshock he'll make the brook of Chaucer Neeson and Chevy or know if I'm kaya polite as a homeless person so it was good let's say I'm not tired but minimally it will be a business Arroyo so you can't lose but it's not true because if in not hype to light outdoors so Santa myself welcome you can make a business Arroyo on an on how you can make just light a candle and say yeah how are you in fact there's a big Malaika sepoys Kim if you could make a business area when you see that Daenerys in basic an essence in the shul some say it's a nice manator but you know you wait to the mitzvah to make a run you have to have a mice emitter even those that hold you could make a broker on the shoes menorah because it's a mitzvah its if that Connors has out Dominica but if you light a manner you can iota with you can make a broker so the homeless person if we hold that he's not your high up in the midst of so is that lock is that I'd welcome so it would not be a good idea to make a difference Arroyo let them see someone else's then he can make a right now consider the following question that has many nasty meanest the Martian inhaling dollar Cookman Bob was asked if you could make light near Chanukah ala ban on the train say right I didn't find anything about this now of course that's very logical they don't have trains at times of the restraining but we wonder you didn't find something similar to a train and what about a boat Rashi talks about a boat and old they were shy you talk about a boat but the Clara and this I think is an important point or train might be better than the homeless person let me explain when we hear the word both so we think today in our mentality a boat is like the five-star hotel that happens to be you know traveling along the ocean you know it's a cruise the olden time boats warm Amish about you out the mercy of the sea and that's what when you got back the bench grammo fan anymore your bench grandma the boat was an open area that's why you could have round she says there's no hard luck is there chronic on a boat but a train even in times of the marsh um wasn't as luxurious as our trains but it was enclosed and you had you a seat maybe you had a cabin there we have your dollar Thomas so maybe that's enough of a value selflessness Annika so even if a train even if a boat is not good because that's outdoors but a train you have your dollar dime as you paid the fare you have your seat you eat there you sleep there no forget didn't travel to Manhattan by train they traveled a few nights few days and you know says it's too much on himself the Marchand myself Rashi says as vena you don't make a broker because it was open but a train is a gather of a bias and you could light on a train he says since you pay the kadhi the car fare it's like you rented your that your area and it's your bias sir replace it comes out that there are actually two possibilities the homeless person or the hiking person that's lighting passes keepers Ostrom I am there's no bias that's a problem a boat is also outdoors there's no bias but it could be regarding their Hanukkah it's enough what we call the semi bias and the Train qualifies to be a semi bias and what's really beautiful to my shop asks on himself how could I say you make a brother on the train a train is constantly going ruff of kuma holla if it's not a bias so after my Shum from there Konica it doesn't make a difference as well have a Kamal if you don't need a bias in Elsa Shabbos it's enough that it's your area and it's what's rented to you and it's but what what's really convincing he says you know why I say this because the acre of marijuana Christmas to me Aneesa so what's wrong if it's travelling so in other words what I see from this is sort of a compromise TACA outdoors my shaman told you can't fly with the brother but if you're in a semi bias and the Train qualifies to be a semi bias that's enough of pursue a nice enough of a bias and you make a brother but when I found really a gratified Absalom his ailment and that same to him in Haleiwa and he is the one that insists you have to have a bias he says but if you have a small bias or soon Sivir soldier that's endeavour on the frontlines but if you have a small bias less than that little darling even though the marisa-san soup could have gimel a by shane by dolla dolla it's not considered a bias but so this is good enough some salman says since it's only the eight days of Hanukkah any bias is enough and he quotes this Marsha the McRae crazy - it's a mucus also says you need a bias but he also quotes the Marsha so I understood that I'm comfortable to say that a person that that's outdoors taka we have a lot of pipes that you cannot light but once you have your little vinculum you have your place on the train even though it's not a full-fledged bias but if it's enough of your area we saw the Martian introduces us to this concept of a train we'll soon see a car and the plane with cetera et cetera but the point is it's a semi bias is enough now let's go fighter let's say this homeless person that doesn't have a train but he decides to be a little aggressive he rings the first doorbell he sees can i light Chronicle if in your house if it's good for you it's good to me says that's not so push it why because it's a bias but it's not his values so basically if you hold you need a bias then it has to be his bias and who says this the toss the tiles that insisted you can't light and a person where you're eating for a Sudha it's a crow it's not a bias would say the homeless person cannot light in your house now of course if you want to do a custard invite him in for supper inviting them to sleep over then it becomes a banana bodies for the night then he could light in your house like York Mary told you light in your house when they stay overnight exclaimed miss Ullman in that same true verb says push it and you're 80 they flavors have lockable buy you sell a car because they're asked to be your bias and this reminds me of what the what the says in shocking RF interface I an owl of Zion with the Ramos says the fair with the a Flocka that's made in shul dr. Goenka dark eve Arabic Itza because there is to base a and what does it mean to say you have to have a bias and finally the letter Y I'm at 152 he says you want to eat in one house just to suit up you can't light it you have to lighten your bias so here we see part 2 of our question not only you have to have a bias and the homeless person or the the camping out can a light outside number two you have to have your bias now what I saw the biggest have bias non-valid hood has a very close to task but he has a nice cup he says the person that lights in someone else's house has to light over at home but when light so at home he doesn't make a new brother why he says because the fibers have golf that he has he was urate in someone else's house he only has now a favor sir bias and his Noah and his real home for that second unlucky don't make a bra in other words lighting at someone's house is worth something but your boy said when I think is push it if you hold like those we showing them and post-commit you don't need a bias the homeless person could live anywhere USA outdoors indoors no silica so let me ask you if you don't need a bias and you collide on the street isn't it positive yeah it's the lighting it's in any person's house a random home even though you're not staying there and that's fact of why it makes sense if you hold you don't need a bias and you go light outside someone else's home is not worse than than outdoors and talk of the back interface I in zalien seems to say that you can light in someone's house because your house has a fear and there's a facade it does seem from the back and is a well-known Chavous Yosef seminar in the Kenyan tire and hayian base also discusses this that basically if you're polite in your own house of Allah Hatillo but if someone lit but the evidence someone else's house it was Yoichi with that I block the car necessarily ninth s has a nice lengthy tube and proves this that if you hold that you don't need a is that someone's house is not worse so we could say how lawful of mice Avada there a person should light in his own home you know the base Yosef and tough race avec regarding - I'll enough is Purim but it's applicable to Hispanic as well he says any person any investor knows you don't make a questionable investment you do what's most secure so coach gain but dark key attire of our midst is that skiff shiny shell oil um don't be a quince Malcolm do what's certain the holidays so a father we should say someone that has the ability to light at home should light at home and because that maybe you need a bias and also you have to have your bias 3/8 limits now a traveling person should make sure that he has a midsummer Hanukkah don't forget this is unusual Mitzvah the macabre quotes isn't uh fresh I an owl of sea-fowl it sorry fleas or my bad luck a snare Hanukkah I feel it online honey I miss finest minister Dhaka soil America suicide a person like mr. burr explain has to go either collect thing to make money for oil or sell the shirt off his back so how could a person travel and just hope for the best you know we have to take this Mitzvah very seriously about Yasha is quoted as saying that a person that for some reason doesn't have a home it is traveling before you've to rent a home just to be able to light their Chanukah ah he doesn't have a home now but then again if you have to sell the shirt of your back you have to go collecting to buy oil so why should the same obligation include renting a home ok a crime can have skis a the man hold back and forth with moyashi but the point is it's a very prominent Mitzvah now people ask questions that I I booked the flight and I'm leaving I have to leave Brooklyn before 3 o'clock and I can't light in the house it's too early I can't light on the plane in the terminal I get there at Rell's the next morning what should I do what he should have done is cockamamie Verizon try not to book a flight that you're gonna miss out there mitzvah curve there Chanukah now you might be positive because he's traveling but then again is not doing a mitzvah so about that person has to have the foresight to book a flight a proper time that he could light nerve tonic now Lamesa someone else is at an eight sir to be mocked nur the homeless person you are bias so you know this is something if syste kill alumnus you know doesn't work you know here is Hamid sir but even the fear is coming as a different is ma mister regular behavior you want to be mocking him it's aroma Lamai sub we hope the homeless person will find a place I'm gonna invite him but when he invited him into the night it becomes his bias for the night and a body could light someone else of stoma Salman he's camping out so he's part of SummerSlam is almond this is called a delicious lame I'm raised in Zion and gave him a heaping portion of Muslim he says emits like this you go camping out you might be particles if nobody's me how do you do that Gemma Salmonella is butter but at a caucus muslin you got a mythic Aviva you don't put yourself in a matter that your putter now what would be an eighth sir for the camping out proof insist on going out is to get a tent now a tent might not be a bias in other helices but for discipline is Alma nicer by Yas have also says for this attend is considered a bias now the best day to stay home for Hanukkah and campout after Hanukkah but basically the bias doesn't have to be a real full fledge advice question someone asked this question he again lives in Brooklyn he has a husana in Lake hood and he works close to Lakewood so to go home come home a night and go back is much become too much big of e'terica so you had an idea he's going to he's unsure he wants to know can he write can it be right to with the unlucky that he hears my my ever Lakewood I mean it's a good fence good for the shoulders good for me so he's not keep us are sure Miami's in a shul and it's a there's a regular local going on so obviously if you hold that you need your values more than justifies you need your bias so then this is not a javelina but let's say the sheets that hold you don't need a yes and outdoors is good so someone else else is also good would this be an aid sir but the answer is no did you ever wonder why we light in shul the cloud especially today well no one lights yeah no one's even there to be right so why would I turn sure so the base Yusuf and tougher a Shia now love quotes we showing him but those days they were working that had no place to go on Shabbos we make kids for them that was the Minich we make up dollar for them and they were you with that so on their Hanukkah we service them by giving them an air of Hanukkah so light this space if dinner like these reciting him I should say dinner Hanukkah and shul is for the homeless people that have no other place to go no for them it was their bias but there's a a very stylistic reverse in Simon curfew now live and the Rivage was asked about the Shabbos termites insurer but he has at home is he I'd sexual so the reverse stares and frantically know that this odd locket in Seoul is not to be ISIL and he says it's an old mini committing the seeking goes back to the restrain of time obviously the reverse himself was a reason and he says that really the the optimum place to light was outdoors and it must have been an awesome piece to Manisa to see the streets full of hot lock is near Hanukkah but became a terrible cos area we couldn't light outside so to somehow replenish the missing pursue Manisa has our the second light in shul with me I'm ver ADA and degenerate a lot of viseme Nisa so it's not a regular hot lucky snare Hanukkah it's sort of like a pursue a nice of the commit sir and therefore he says emphatically but I'd love to serve a second SS ain't are the mute cebú the gaba a the showers cannot be answer but sir las lajas nicoleff agave say the missus they're kind of canary issue bass a and there are more interface I and I love Zion says the ferris know you can be I do without locker that takes place in sure so we could say for the person that wants to disco locking so even if you hold that you don't need a values you could be ITER in someone else's house but the shoals of lockup is not to be item that's just to comply with the mini gear oh well soon see if the shamans lives in that building or you see a bucket that lives in the yeshiva that might be different question what would you say to the following and it's not a academic question it's a real question you have a real shul that there are many many manana but it's outdoors is there a fear are you allowed to light in the Shoeless outdoors a bias I mean look I'd be a regular person you need a bias outdoors not good but maybe since the shoes unlucky is a definite maybe outdoors is good now which tool is outdoors exhaling case of my lovely Altos but it's a sure again many many many items so rabbi yosef is quote in Austria is race time mcveigh's by the kreisel EF Silver Seraph Lea's bias apparently he's assuming of course you have to have a bias and therefore this did the ad lock in the shoe also must have a bias so if it's not a bias now he does concede in the Mora the cave next to the case of that you could like that Tobias but not in the outdoor crisis itself now I saw the pinyon the asana drew involve i na says i bother you could make a brochure by the koi so that's what she tossed like that you can even lighter outdoors so that's not a finish but your bracelet what's possible to say is that true a regular person to light outdoors there's no have amina like pspice good but the dinner basic analysis is not a dinner at lock is near conic it's a dinner pursue manisa so maybe that mitzvah is a DIN initial and Raisa Pella the same ashtrays and a bottom he quotes over yeah ships as saying that if I decay so even though it's not in close there's no roof but as long as it's add-in basic an SS you could light their big bracha just stick on the steering wheel should suck but I saw the river stir-fry a mandala cooks are valid see Sam McGee mo says he felt in a sterile field that for now can occur in the shul even by the castle because it's a definite sir with a different guidelines a lot has been written believe it or not especially in the year Tufts and I Medallia understand why about soldiers that our mama stalks key possession I am that was the aftermath of Yom Kippur War I serfs name is Al Manar they sustain narrations and tests and my gosh and actually it's race time above both say that basically a soldier if he's managed outdoors then he can make a break on their Konica but if he's in a tent or if he's in a trench that has a covering or believe it or not or if he's in a tank a tank is enclosed he can make a broth in any of these scenarios when he has a roof over his head or be in a tent or a trench or a tank he could light and make a brush on it because for he'll fight snare conical you don't need a bias of cultur kula you need something on top of your head an outside outdoor gathering so again to us it's not a bias is no happening Oz lid brewing in a low flame a baseless she does say hold you could in fact life here and make a brother if someone is traveling all night he's going to Montreal to Toronto and he left before this man he can't light at home and he's traveling the whole night he's gonna get to his destination it's gonna be after Lisa Shaka can you light in a car so obviously you have to make sure it's very safe he's taking a little phrase until attending a light not too many these and I just want to be right so the commit stuff but it's gonna be safe so the truth is it's not so hard to believe that is your it's in the car I mean people eat in a car and most of the family are sleeping I hope the driver doesn't sleep but everybody else is sleeping and it has a roof so it doesn't have the a first one has dollar a dollar but even without down that I'll get my see yo I'm you could make a car into a circle so why can't a car be a place on air Hanukkah if the Martians says you could write in a train because you pay fear a car that's you're moving by is how could it be worse their consultant says in argh Allah and a train and we saw even a tank and I thought I saw a Lucas Lima race ah Mahalo for the Mishnah Locker Zion pay bug and the type of television I love crest and many other pipes can say that in a car of course if it's safe you could light with a brother now but yeah ship in the Ashley is race alphabet has a tremendous coma and he says even the marsh arm that holds good light on a train is we there a few days because typically and those day they didn't travel just an hour to they traveled many days but just one night he feels you can make a breath on it but I don't think any other other place can had that condition it seems once your overnight and we hold you could go to someone's house overnight unlike his house so a car that get there overnight would be enough let's say the person that's traveling in a warmer climate he says why should I light in the car it's it's a no it's very small let's stop the supper let's say he's in Australia where it's nice and summer weather will stop the supper we'll have a picnic and we'll light by the sudha that's no good the light on the table outdoors is no good believe it or not the car is more of a fear than the outdoors and the store is you need a miser skin of a bias a train or today a boat a boat today is certainly indoors where you could light and make a broth the real problem is when a person is traveling by plane and he's leaving Brooklyn before this man hath woke up and he gets to the airport and you have to wait and wait and get a flight until you get there it's rose the next morning so it's a problem now someone's I'm there lied by my seat if they put it out it's their problem I said no no it's your problem you know he will make a lot of presume a nice if your lights on the plane I'm the last row that put on Phil on the plane made you know gamer headlines certainly a person like sapphire in a plane that's the a horrific Kailash M and about that's not an option so the eights is like they even have done for their persons at home he points his wife or children or slea to light women house but make sure that not to light on the plane now what's a little more of an issue but not much more is e sitting in the airport terminal for our pretty light there so again I don't think security would like it but well I don't be able to allow it but even if they would was that the airport terminal it's not your bias you're not you having pain transferred you there for an hour - it's not like the my thumb's train that you're there overnight it's not your bias no if you hold like those sheet is you don't need a values you could light and a homeless person lights it's not worse but again it's not practical there used to be a common scenario a person that was single will eat suppers in a restaurant so the stylist quote an orchestra bein you and gimmick on the curve of who says ok this was very Mustafa that even if we hold the mahkumat here is a place to light that's if it's your ma claim so what's better a kilo or Shana but a restaurant you're in and out it's not your mother so the fact that you eat that every night is not aqueous it's not biased and therefore you can light in a restaurant a person that must work late he can't come home of course Hanukkah is an area-based we should be on one time for our family but let's say you can't and he has the following suggestion he owns the store or he owns the business can he light in this business in a store the fact is he eats lunch and supper this time of the air in the store and sometimes people sleep in their business if they have a bed if it's if it's feasible so the question is clear-eyed in this store or when it gets home late at night light at home so of course the Inca is his real home but do we look at the store or the business as a second home is it at least like a train car it's more than a train this is his he owns it then he's there and he eats that he sleeps there occasionally look why we could look at it like he has two homes and if he really wants to light this man I think would be an absent the light in his store and the truth is we find a very similar sack the Maginot Roman tough race mems he's cotton test a lien as a question a person has a store it's linear McCrory could eat out of the ad of a Sukkah on circus because he's a hurl hey Dara and he has no sucker so it's optimum no you're making a mistake sunbae site when he has a score of business she has two homes in the city and in the store so some based ciyon has to make us okay in the office or in his store so I understood from this that a person that has a business or a store has now two homes and he spent a lot of time and in his store business so the higher it makes sense that if he wants to he could light bisman in the store and CH do with that but the place that we could do better than extrapolate even milk aside for milk Asuka we have a buffet resubmission er that you could hide in the store and we all know the Mishnah in bava kamma the summer paisa Monday's a Zeke and Schuyler but some of that's going with a Gamow torn pistol that went into the manure that was in the her nose and made hazard now why is there a manure in a her nose obviously as a mercenary Annika that was lit in a ha nose so we see me then I wished that you could light in a store so they're full of mice sir if someone feels he wants to life is not about the key light in a store now people say eyes not young tough dick and lighting we look I wonder white light when I get home nobody's on Tate that you could also do you could wait till you get home as long as it's before our lawyer chef and they're people that are still up you could light at home this is also Nigeria someone asked me he wants to go from his workplace to a Hasan up he's in the come home Amish early morning and that's not young to the Collider early morning so again that would be an option he's there in the store Bashar Samantha Walker he can right there finish working and then go to the fast enough if he wants that would be an option and the I did see the safe at mrs. Mary Sue base at the end of Simon hate quotes of summer Salman very brief not too light in a store let the wife light at home now the wife light at home is a certainly a native if the person that worked his wife-to-be right to him that's just a goof who goes both ways but why you can't light at in the workplace he doesn't say why is the PC love and why I wonder why the layers group of questions are grab them very important is when someone is not home let me give a common scenario a person can have a mother that's our mana and she refuses to light herself she doesn't want to do that can she light together with the children she's coming gone for the Sudan and going home to sleep home can you light if it's not your bias so this we saw earlier that besides the fact that we hold you have to have a bias you can might keep us on task in position I am it has to be your bias we saw the TAS says the lighting in someone else's home is like lighting in the street in our yard sir so therefore in a case like this and I'm one that lives alone there would be a simple eight sub let one of the children or grandchildren go to her house right for her wish leafless of her and thusly I could make the breakfast okay she's made chef Janos the Stickle of an issue but he can make the two brothers the hot Killa be ice beyond mana and then go home on either his own house the hot Stella all three brothers that would be the best date if that's not feasible for ever reason so there are some that want to say that since they're eating by the the mother eating bite by these like the Sun it would be considered somewhat of an asteroid and if and she's we started with prota she could be right so with the children's have welcome doesn't have to light herself now of course you don't have to say yeah give me a dollar b.o.b right sir you could be mocking her you have to tell about this whole thing but it's not so busted as to know yourself is good enough Elisa's they're only better if someone lights for them in in the the woman's house with the brush and that's with the gold swaps lasers which is Avada and eight so that works a traveler that's travelling and fine self in a foreign city again to ring a bell and a random home could I light in your house doesn't work according to many PI skin if you gets invited for the night he come ideal house abhinaya values for that night but to just the light and go is an issue and according to those organ on your bias of course it's okay but we go with the sheathing you need a bias and your bias question we said earlier could someone be right sir with the ad locker in the show so that we said someone just comes from Ireland wants to be I'd say with the shaman so the shaman is not you later and the miss fowl is not yet so that's certainly the question is if someone is living in the shul the shamans that lives in the show or much more commonly today the buckram then are in yeshiva and let's talk about the building is the a shell has the dining-room dawn and bass measures and this one Barker who doing the mini kiss well of lighting in this magic Amon Amarth can he be eyes with that locker because he's any I'm riding in the building so I can have a yard sale item based magician so the truth is like to be vast we saw earlier the Rivage insists but you can't be heights in basements basic analysis but he looked at the lost and he says because it's a midsummer issue based site and the shaman has a home letter might at home but it's almost my furnish that if the shaman or the buffer lives in that building and this building is his vase so he's there for Monica so once it's your buyers you could light in this room of that room now maybe you'll say the mahkum I feel is better but the base marriage is not mooska and I did see the odd cipher when he had a area that stayed in the base marriage overnight he was muhammad' him to light in my marriage and then he was urate to the mitzvah and the shoe had a very quality had locker now again any is shiva the minik today is because of safety purposes besides that but the welcome all light and dining room okay that's good but this buffer that's lighting and based marriage so why can you be I'd say if he has a mind to be I solution have Locker but my sir he eats in base mode you sometimes and sometimes welcome sleep all service Magister that we all fall asleep occasionally but I saw him biggest edition revised inhaler gimble simon pegg emo was asked by a buffer that that learns a whole day and stays Hanukkah for supper and learns night sit and goes home just to sleep he just sleeps in his house her father says he could lie taka and you see but even Abby's madness ie sleeps at home the in the dorm he's not a dorm boy but he says this is Beira bonham a base Magus is the buckas bias mark says you're allowed to eat and sleep and base majesty learned there so even though he's sleeping elsewhere in his parents home he's enough of a living in the achieve that he could light in base matters not at the zoo but the pooper of a Yayoi stood gimel tough Dalit he says the sake says for his yeshiva where obviously was a the dorm the dining room and the mismatched one building it seems that the bottom lid and base Magister I think all the buff that's what he said because this is the Iker of their place and he says not much man why do we say Malcolm Aquila occur because the I feel is is important but you have a bucket that's learning 12 14 hours a day to the Malcolm of Lima this maurico it's like that's what it seemed that he told the bark from all of them Lydon base Manish that's the mahkum of the ad locker but certainly if the baka that's taka been lighting for the basic an SS if he has a mind to be a to that at lockup I saw the unleash Lima your dollar good game oh the curvature locust has both tests both say that if indeed he has the mind the ice with that his yard said there's no reason to light again in the dining room Dominican tells because of a tragic fire that took place many many years ago and a bomb I think more than one buck was killed in the fire so the many gears that the Shiva and then those days was hundreds of welcome didn't light one buckle it and was yet to the entire Shiva like Dominica stardom their issue base a is Mahajan that you lied every night are more and more but one buckle lights the minikin tells are the yeoreum is that their buckle lights in vase Madras and Azure eight sir the entire yeshiva I saw quality sham the Satmar of that he said it would be up to him he would have one buckle light when it comes to man in basement dish all the bomb would stop learning for a moment to to whatever it takes to light and sing and then back to learning and the you be right with one buckle they wouldn't close the achieve and go home should be up there me would do that but he doesn't think it would be a very popular innovation you know but don't forget Chanukah is the yom tov thirst of and we won the war not be of on a ski from terasaka is not our philosophy he said he wanted to do this but it wasn't didn't work whatever he was afraid to broach the idea but I definitely see from all of this that Ibaka delights in bass magic could be ice now explained miss Alma the fish lame is quoted as saying in his yeshiva he asked us are the shabak up to lighten based measures there's any are you all night so this way is how clever many achievers they ask a younger man to light in bhisma addition so therefore he's difficult light at home later he's not you a to that but again if it comes up that is just the buffer that's around and the bus collides he could be oh it's up now to say I don't mind not to be lighter and I like in the dining go doesn't seem to to really make sense why you've been garb retain its vehicle now some from a ball come I know they lie to miss marriage of the eights with that but the Mustapha truth there was some of the lights in the dining room okay it's not wasted money fine cousin take a three mistake a person once he asked me he's making a big mess if I see from indoor sefa he wants to lighten air Hanukkah with the bra club because he says there's probably gonna be a few fryer people and WI to the South welcome now l'm ice up it sounds very ideal but it's not right because there is no mini of lighting by an Asifa debate sickness this min egg this is a car there's a lot of written if you allow to make a broth some say you don't the mini gets to make a broth but to stop to make a broth adjust for presuming ISA it's a very novel idea but you can make a breath on that I the fryer person that's there but if it's not his bias he's not a vit with that so that's why I saw them in house its carcass flamin c'est la vie the differ yeah it's have all say but to light and make a broker by any gathering for pursue me Nisa Avanti can make a broker you wanna light okay but not to make a bro oh my gosh is don't make a broker don't light at all maybe he's a concern that people will misinterpret this and you go like any old place but definitely you need a bias or basic masters but not any pursue may Nisa be on Yavin gimel Tov Allah says the Pharisee especially in outdoor c4 Avada that's not the to light a challenging question if a people have a fastener again it's they leaving the house before this man they come home very very late is it an option for the hustling column the makutano or guests or all three to light some place in the wedding hall so the embassies in swaram none of them collide then it's not a bias it's a very expensive sued estimate for the makutano man the husband but it's not a bias and her behind give in the MS Li affidavits are 590 says to light when a Hassan all he says was the girl after you know a blanket he said Gillespie meant it in other words it's a joke it doesn't make any sense and other place Kim discussed when should where should the custom car light before afterwards but no one entertained the thought to light in a Carson all I did see a big fish in the cove its arrested Bay's cognate to some soccer with her lockers your bass club bass and he says that the custom probably could light in the Carson all he make makes the follow me Cashman the busting left his house before this man they can light there now he's out of his father's house she's like a homeless person he's not in his father so he has never new home and he says that even though the Todd says you can't light in someone else's home by supper just and go home because there's no please but this is a major clear this was getting married and he's paying a pretty penny for tonight's supper and I would and also best if he's a firmer and he like any any rents the year third room for year could so he has a curious so he says like this I know people I'm a fact pick and grab his father was one of them the fat chicken but he said I know people my factory but I don't see what's the problem for the Causton to light and the custody call to be lights in the wedding go there there are many hours the suit is a very much a theistic of his main appendage that ties this problem is to go to someone's house to supper that's no comparison to your bias but if you have nobody's the fussing is homeless and this is a major crius that's enough then he says maybe from the katana more so better would be if they light in their house before they leave or ville ID afterwards but he doesn't see what's terrible tonight in the house and old dads very pleased now he says guests have no place to light in the wedding hall because the guests are not paying for this it's not their clear but he says a guest that's foots the ear the Costin all classes of lakewood he's living in Brooklyn maybe it's like he has no bias so again he considers everybody perhaps could light in the wedding hall but again this is not the Minich the miniguns the Hudson or Cala light either before if shy if there's a local custom or they can light even after the FAFSA as late as it is as long as it's before alloys and someone is up you collide in the bias again most like this mom but this would be a situation there's no other choice a patient in the hospital netbook never that's their bias if that's their overnight or certainly for a few days so find the safe place and that would be the option the child the grandchild who's staying with the patient will be the same activity staying overnight so tonight he's stationed in the hospital wherever they allow the patient delight he could light as well if he packed it busy with the hilar so forget about near Chanukah and the Icicle Mitzvah and one less question came the Huckabee a cuboid someone told me he was traveling by plane and some are told a very strange talk you can't figure it out get a flashlight and light a flashlight on the plane this is my flashlight why not build water conventional electric menorah so let me tell you what this person heard the point is to light on a plane of fire again is obviously obviously not an option but to light a electric malaria token in a house also has many problems first of all you need an ace today's electricity if it's LED or fluorescent is no H so you it could cost them and I save them you know it's not like near Shabbos that you need light for cover job is our next I'll be showing bias you need an age it's not age additionally there's a technical problem that's more than technical to make a Brophy after a half hour worth of chemin there be shots of luck wa to make a bra so then since it has the potential to burn artistically ragaman ice-choked to make a brach on that but typically electricity any light in your house or any electrical area doesn't have a half hour of power there it's constantly being generated and being fed to your connection so it's not an ace and it's not the half hour of chemin so it's basically a effort in futility but if someone wants to be creative he could say I'll take a flashlight that has batteries so the half hour potential of burning is there and I will find from my children or grandchildren an old flashlight they took the camp that has a incandescent bulb not LED or fluorescent incandescent bulb that has a filament and I'll hope for the best that the filament the glowing metal is considered H so have an age with a half-hour of oil but the problem is even if you hold that that filament is a Sonia Shabbos it's like my mom artists but Mohammed matches is still not yet H it might be actually gonna be Shabbos so it's better than nothing but if you're on the plane to a theit of Hanukkah get eight flashlights a phrase got Hanukkah taeho [Music] shame because you turn like your big ass a car service mr. today share Smith's will say the cecum of today she in five minutes letters are some not even a car sharing the road socket is both of those are cases the sort of peacock cable impaired mixed-race chinami a loan officer Mont Segur yarn goat area [Music] I [Music] maybe they just stick the knife Oh [Music] it is a limited time to get you [Music] Jason so [Music] maple Friday night there's enough [Music] we shot the first bank like Jackie on don't eat too much it's molecules sheiva [Music] Philippines I had to miss country by its without a broken yeah [Music] the only no laser lovely no they know when he sees it [Music] No a specialist of Isis comedies special signal that only when [Music] like [Music] Oh [Music] today time's up [Music] whether it's okay fifty-two is the tape by the way together 52 okay I'm sorry it's Sunday voiceover over here but not away from home this is our home we're gonna hear the cecum from today's sheer panic your wife you happen to be away from home but don't forget here's your home just a short summer you learned today about SMD as you see the mechanic is a mystic Aviva admire but the nature is unique it's a probably an unprecedented survivors are goof on every man woman and child but you could be I'd say with someone else because that's the dinner issue Bayside that the father could be right sir the whole family the wife is right sir but the husband even though our wife Sonya is a matzo with the husband but it's a high Vassago F that can be discharged with a narrow issue basic but the fundamental question of today is a bias necessary can a person that's homeless or he's camping out or it wants to eat once the light in someone else's house does he have to have bias does he have to have his bias that's a McLucas we shine in peski Morocco Morocco going to many high skin we shinin and haunting a pie scheme you need a biased and you need your bias as the Tosh says lighting by someone else sounds like lighting in the street and others both are unacceptable there are make Elam and their logic is if the midst is pursue many sir why should it be totally an a bias or my bias as long as it promotes a pursue main ISM according to those cheaters you could light camping out you can light the homeless person to light but since it's a fear of that's an extent of my fake suicide high-tops Arkham we try to do it right and a person should try to find a bias and that more so light in his values but we did see that a semi by Isla Marshall are trained that although it doesn't have health is bias and other areas but it's considered his bias and all agree that would be a place to light in fact if you have a tiny bias less than dollar now it's also good it doesn't have to have hulka's values and has to have a give the person the the this feeling that he's in a bias for Kanaka many insists that you have to lighten your bias you can light by someone else's sudha and overnight you can't light should like tacos keep a session I'm you know in a tent as okay a shoe is only for the minute for the for the Tucanos Cazale Orkin then are just coming and going cannot be i'ts up by the Chi so I think the mini guess they do light because it's a basic necessity cut locker and the more certainly of the case you could light soldiers should not like if they're sleeping outdoors unless they have any covering whether it's in a trench or a tent outdoor a/c for even indoor Asifa we do not like with the Bravo it's not any pursue manisa its pursue it's the basicness esta Kona's hazael that allows a brothel to be said a car about a train you could like with the brothel patch this a plane it's not feasible an airport terminal is not a bias to best dates when a person can like when he's traveling to make a family a wife or Ashley after light a restaurant even though it's Malcolm Aquila it's not his bias it has no personal shine as to that at work is a good idea if a person wants light bisman as long as this pursue me Nissim your house will person is is the place to lie just for supper is not an option and our mana that doesn't want to light about I should have mentioned if she were if she what once the light will she should be told to like that's the best a to there's absolutely nothing wrong with a as a woman lighting with all the brockett's it's no different men and women but if she refuses to light then someone should light for her or she lies by the children and this Mustafa de puta as an ass tonight but if she's missed out to the food that she doesn't light herself she's right so hopefully with the children in the shul if the person lives there or the Baca and you see that lives in that building could be oats with that I'd love if you if you lit at the shell mitzvah or some you Shiva's estar the show Baca lights or younger man light so he could light at home and no one's here to the shul except for the minik and a class owner it seems like the most boys can assume it's not the option for any daddy either like before the hassle or after the Caston as long as before a lice in the hospital you can find a place at the allow Kayla and the Michelle Michelle if he's there overnight alight and a flesh type is certainly not enough to make a Brock even the best scenario that has batteries and it has a incandescent bulb with a filament it's still not aged but Abraha and lighting could be done without a bra [Music]