0:00 / 0:00
Ari Goldwag - Ki Seitze - Honest Accounting
443 views
Why does the Torah focus on the sin of Miriam, one of the greatest prophetesses of all time, when warning us of the sin of Lashon Hara (gossip)? Why does the midrash specifically point out the individual sins of Eve, Sarah, Rachel, Leah and Miriam? Why does the Midrash teach us that in Moshe's prayer for Miriam, he recalled his own sin in speaking Lashon Hara? How can we honestly look at our shortcomings and become greater people? Why is the person with Tzara'as (spiritual leprosy) enjoined not to touch or disdain their affliction? Find out in this week's parsha podcast.
Featuring:
Ari Goldwag
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
you're listening to the weekly partial
podcast recorded with hashem's
neverending assistance in ramaphism
israel 57 76 2016. this week's parachute
is pasha's kisetse
the topic for this week's partial
podcast is the concept of assessing
honestly
are negative character traits
and this is a very delicate subject i
don't usually introduce the subject
of the podcast at the very beginning
but the reason i'm doing it is because
it's so delicate and so fine
important
to be spoken about important to address
and but it's also something which is a
touchy subject
it's very challenging and it's difficult
for us to look at ourselves honestly to
assess the places where we need to
improve ourselves
so i want to go in with our eyes open i
want to talk about this topic
i want to read to you from hidration
which are challenging at first to read
especially in our world
we are raised brought up in the western
society to believe that in order to help
people we have to be nice to them soft
to them never really speak about the
negatives never really face those things
head on
but that's not the way of hazal that's
not the way of our sages that's not the
way the torah the torah's path
is to look at things to be honest about
things to face them head on to try to
improve to try to change
that's why we're in this time right now
we're in the time of elo we're leading
up in just a few weeks to rosh hashanah
it's a time that we recommit to our
relationship with hashem god is our king
yes god is our father he's our loving
father but he's also our king
we have to be his faithful servants we
have to do his will
and it's not so easy it's not so easy to
be honest where we're doing things right
we're not doing things right
where we need improvement
it's not so easy to look at ourselves so
just with that introduction it's
important to understand we're going to
try to take things everything that we're
going to speak about to be very careful
be very sensitive
and yet at the same time i know that
there's going to be things that we're
going to speak about that are going to
be difficult to hear so
i've given you the warning and i hope
that you stay with me it's worth
listening through till the end i assure
you
the verse tells us an amazing thing
chapter 24 verses 8 and 9
tells us something which again to our
ears is difficult to hear
torah tells us
be extremely careful
when it comes to the affliction of saras
this special spiritual leprosy
be very careful watch it very well and
do what you're supposed to do
everything that the priests the levites
instruct you kashir tsivisim as i have
commanded them
allah says you shall do that's verse
number 1 which is verse 2 chapter 24
verse 8 verse 9 zachary sasha
garden joins us to remember that which
god did to miriam mahanavi the
prophetess miriami was the sister of
moses of aaron she was the leader of the
time she was one of the greatest leaders
of all time she had done a sin she had
spoken negatively about moshe rabino she
had spoken la shanhara and as a result
she became afflicted with leprosy she
got the spiritual leprosy which comes
when when one speaks
but says remember that this occurred as
you left egypt
now as we read this
as we study this verse
the first thing that strikes me the
first question that comes across is
hey this is something negative that
miriam did she spoke about moshe rabin
about moses and as a result she received
leprosy but why do we have to focus on
the fact that she did this just tell us
the you know tell us what we should do
why do we have to focus on the fact that
miriam did it and the miriam was
punished and the jewish people had to
wait for miriam for seven days for a
week
while she recovered from that sickness
why do we have to focus on the negative
of the sadiq of the righteous individual
why is the torah teaching it to us in
this way what's the significance of it
before we answer this question i want to
show you a majorish and then measures as
we read it the same question is going to
come up very difficult to understand
and but it's important that we read it
we face off with it because it's a
challenging majorish
but
if we understand what's going on what
the message is coming to teach us
there's a very deep and important lesson
especially for now as we go into this
time of personal growth as we go into
this time of honest assessment of
ourselves
the message says like this it quotes the
verse
back
spoke negatively of her brother
spoke negatively of moshe albino of
moses
when god came he wanted to create the
woman he wanted to create eve
so he was going to take a piece of adam
he's going to build eve so to speak
from one of the parts of the body of
adam the first man
so god was thinking as it were from
which part of adam's body should i build
the verse refers to the fact that god
built eve out of a certain part of the
body of adam ezio explains vaiven the
word which means to build also means the
same root of the word beena which means
intuition god was thinking using his
intuition as it were of course
trying to figure out which is the right
part of the body for for hava to be
created from um
god said
i don't want her to be made from the eye
of man
she like
rama
if the essence of who the woman is going
to be is from the i
so then heaven forbid it could come out
that she will have a haughty eye she'll
be somebody who thinks of herself too
greatly more than she should but let me
know hezen hashem said i don't want to
create her from the ear of man
shalom
tanis i don't want her to be someone who
her whole essence is
listening in a place where it's not
appropriate for her to listen being
nosey
i don't want to create
i don't want to create eve from the
mouth of adam because if that's where
she's created from she'll be someone who
speaks too much
i don't want to use the hand
of adam of adam because if i use the
hand to create her so then she might use
her hand in an inappropriate way
she'll
she might steal something
regal i don't want to create eve from
the foot of the uh of adam
shalatee pardenisa she shouldn't be
someone who walks out too much and and
goes in places she shouldn't go
so god says
which part of adam should i use to
create her min
i'm going to use a part of the body
which is modest which is hidden which
people don't see minhyer
from the thigh
and the mesh doesn't say this explicitly
but it seems that hashem wanted that the
woman should be something her essence
should be the root of who she is should
be modesty she should be someone who is
modest not egotistical not being seen in
places which are inappropriate not
trying to cross out of the boundaries
where she shouldn't belong but rather
everything is done in a tsunua way in a
modest way and the majority says an
amazing thing
even though this is what hashem did this
is the thought process as it were that
god went through in creating eve it
didn't help at all
is an amazing thing very difficult to
understand
that all of the things that hashem
didn't want to happen
did happen
and not only that they happened
specifically in
some of the greatest women of all time
the greatest siddiques is the most
righteous woman of all time
america
this that god said lo every summer
i don't want to create eve
from the eye of adam because i don't
want her to have a haughty eye
chavax it says about eve herself but
that she saw with her eye she looked and
she viewed something which was forbidden
to her and she felt that it was
appropriate that she had it she looked
with a hearty eye
so hashem said i don't want her her to
have a hearty eye but she did
ever i summoned her
to hate sabtanies
shem said i don't want to create her
from the ear of man why because i don't
want her to be somebody who sticks her
ears so to speak in places where she
shouldn't who who's nosy and listens to
things that she shouldn't be listening
to
but the verse tells us about sorry menu
sarah the matriarch of kali israel
that when the angels came to speak to
abraham to tell him the news what's
going to happen in a year
sarah was listening she was
eavesdropping almost so she was indeed
doing that which hashem didn't wish
every s
also said i don't want to use the hand
of man to create eve why because i don't
want her to end up stealing
what do we find it says about rakhili
menu also one of the matriarchs of
claudia israel but tigner
rachel she stole
the idols of her father laban
lay ever always some in her regular
should later hate pardonis
god said i don't want to create her from
the foot of adam i don't want her to be
somebody who walks in places that are
inappropriate
sibba but about leia also the matriarch
of the jewish people the mother of
yehuda the mother the great grandmother
of meshiach of the messiah
what does it say about her about
la crosse
that she went out
leia went out to to walk to the place
that was inappropriate for her to go she
went out of her place she was out of
place
so it teaches us again that we see the
greatest sadegas of all time one of the
greatest zodiacasses of all time a great
righteous woman leia
she indeed went against the will of
hashem so to speak
every
says that god didn't want to create
eve
from the mouth of adam why because he
didn't want her to be somebody who
speaks inappropriately out of place
um
and about miriam the great righteous
woman measure describes her as it
zadekes unbelievable righteous person
but she spoke out of turn she spoke out
of place she spoke negatively about
moshe rabbenu
so we read this measure
darshani the manager just begs the
question what's going on what's the idea
why is the medusa talking negatively
about these great sadekis these great
righteous individuals
what is it teaching us
why indeed if if all of these things are
exactly the things hashem didn't want
that he didn't want these negative
traits these negative character traits
to be
a part of the makeup of the human being
and yet all of these great righteous
women they did all of these things these
very things hashem didn't want what is
the message teaching us what's the chat
what is the understanding of what's
going on here
so again before we answer these
questions i want to share with you one
more madrish
magish is beautiful unbelievable
beautiful madrish
it tells us like this
this is in two pieces later measure says
another explanation of the fact that we
need to remember what happened to miriam
kevin sharon
tells us that when moses saw
that which had happened to his sister
he skilled severe misfollowed
he started to cry out to pray on her
behalf with all of his heart and soul
kel na rafanola
god please cure her please he said it
with this great intent with this great
sincerity
now the measure tells us something very
interesting
this is there's an analogy here what's
this analogous to the gibberish
a very mighty person who had chains on
his on his neck he had chains on his
shoulders
but he was able to break out of the
chains he was so strong
not long afterwards
he saw that the government had placed
those very same chains
upon the neck of somebody else killed
survivor he started to call out and cry
what are you crying about what's your
what are you getting all upset about
him yet
he's like you don't know
nelson i know how painful it is i know
how difficult
it is to be in those chains how how hard
it is how painful it is
i had those very chains on me vanilla
i know how much pain he's in so i am
crying out in pain for him i see the
pain that he is in so i am also feeling
his pain
amazing thing
in the same way moshe robin of moses was
crying out he was upset he he felt
horrible for his sister miriam
god system what are you so upset about
why are you crying out so much why are
you in such a sorry state
i'm in the front of rabbani shalom
so moses says to the master of the world
to god i need
i know what the what kind of pain she's
in i understand it
i remember the chain that my hand was in
me
how do we know as the verse says in
exodus chapter four verse six vineyard
moses also spoke negatively moshe spoke
negatively about klaus about the jewish
people he said that they won't listen
they won't believe they want they don't
want to be or perhaps they don't have as
close they don't have a merit to be
redeemed
as a result of that hashem gave him as
well he had leprosy on his hand he
pulled out his hand one of the signs was
his hands his hand was full of leprosy
puts it puts it back in it disappears
but he knew what it was to receive
leprosy as a result of speaking
negatively he had experienced it himself
he knew the pain he knew the shame he
knew the embarrassment
of having spoken about someone else and
receiving leprosy as a result so he
called out he cried on behalf of miriam
with an incredibly sincere prayer
mission
finished finishes often says that since
moses prayed on her behalf repay sakura
god cured her
meenain
how do we know this is true because the
verse says in numbers chapter 12 verse
the nation did not continue to travel
until miriam had been completely cured
so we see that she was completely cured
and the medicine is telling us it was a
result of the prayer the heartfelt
prayer of moshe of benue who knew what
it was like and therefore he prayed on
her behalf
the message tells us therefore remember
what happened to me
as a result of her speaking lashing hara
so the message is remarkable because in
a certain sense it's incriminating moshe
of anu it's showing us that moses also
had done this very same sin he had
spoken negatively about claudius he had
also received saras he had also gone
through this challenging situation the
shame the embarrassment the torah tells
us all about it again what's the
understanding why are we learning this
from the greatest of all people from
moshe rabbenu from miriam from all these
great righteous individuals of the past
and what is the message also
specifically of this madrish in telling
us that moshe his prayer his heartfelt
prayer was answered as a result of the
fact that he himself
had experienced exactly what she
experienced and prayed on her behalf
with a true deep prayer
so when i read these midrashim
and i was faced with these questions i
didn't have a clear answer i didn't have
a clear thought
to resolve the issues that i brought up
that have you know that we've spoken
about
but then i saw rashi on the pussic
itself and the rashi was so clear so
incisive that it became clear to me that
that was the shot that was the
underlying theme of everything that's
going on in this in this majestic
verse says in the first passage
the verse before we even speak about
miriam just as he should
be very careful when it comes to the
negative when it comes to the leprosy
be careful watch out do exactly what the
kohana with the priests say
whatever i commanded them that's what
you must be careful to do
rashi says what's this being careful
about what are you being careful about
amazing thing
a person looks at his skin
he sees that there's a white leprosy
that's on his skin
he sees it and he's oh no what do i do i
have to show it to the client maybe i
can get rid of it maybe i can push it
away maybe i can cut off the skin or
something so that this this saras will
be will disappear
rashi tells us
rasheed says don't do it the passage is
telling you be so careful
do not look at the baharis do not look
at this leprosy as something disgusting
do not try to remove it don't start up
don't mess with it
just leave it as it is
and bring it to the cone bring it to the
priest who's going to tell you exactly
what to do exactly how to deal with it
what is the puzzle coming to tell me
what why is it telling me this why can't
i touch it why can't i do anything to it
why can't i try to remove it you know
just get rid of it
the pasuk and rashi
they are telling us something amazing
just so deep so beautiful
and that is that when i look at my skin
a person looks at their skin and they
see that there's leprosy there
it's not just a simple you know leprosy
like we have today a person who has some
kind of sickness it's a spiritual
sickness as we said at the very
beginning it's something which reflects
on a physical level something that's
wrong with the person on a spiritual
level he has a stain on his soul
as a result of the stain on his soul
it's manifesting on a physical level on
his skin
the torah is telling us don't remove
what's on the skin
because you're just getting rid of the
symptom and you're not getting rid of
the root problem
if you look at this and you leave it and
you bring it to the priest you bring it
to the client who's the spiritual person
he's not just a doctor he's the
spiritual doctor he knows what the
problem is on a spiritual level he's
going to give you direction on a
spiritual level how to get rid of the
spiritual problem don't look at it
superficially don't look at it as a
physical issue it's not just the
physical issue
every physical issue the torah is
telling us is a manifestation of a
spiritual problem most specifically by
tzaras it's a manifestation of something
that i've done wrong on a spiritual
level and if i want to truly fix
my spiritual problems i need to look at
the problem i can't ignore the problem
and i need to be willing to look at it
even though it's painful even though
it's something which you know i look at
it and it's disgusting to me rashi says
don't look at it and look at it as
something disgusting it's not disgusting
it's not ugly
it's just something that's there it's
something that needs to be fixed it's
something that needs to be looked at
corrected properly gone back to the root
taken care of uprooted at the root not
just superficially but if you just
remove it superficially and you think
that you've taken care of it you're
making a big mistake the torah is
telling us don't make that mistake
and i think that it's not a coincidence
that the torah is teaching us this in
the context of mira manavia one of the
greatest people of all time the greatest
leaders of the jewish people the
greatest prophetesses of all time miriam
the sister of moshe the sister of aaron
specifically her look she also
she also made this mistake she also
spoke out of turn but she didn't just
ignore it she didn't allow herself to to
to just cut it off she didn't remove it
she didn't get upset at it she didn't
find it disgusting
she was honest about it she took it she
dealt with it she did what bana said you
have to go you have to be hidden away
for a week you have to wait until that
spiritual illness is healed if a great
person like her could admit that she's
done something wrong and not find it
repulsive
certainly i regular person regular human
being can look at the things that i've
done wrong just look at them as they are
without finding them repulsive but
rather recognize that there's something
wrong something i've done needs to be
fixed on a spiritual level and that's
what dementia she's doing going through
each of these great people
eve the first human being the first
woman that ever existed she also had
something negative and it created a
great sin a great sin resulted from it
but still we look at that and we say if
she could do that and she could also do
chuva she could also repent
if rocco could do a certain thing she
could also do this thing leia could do
this thing these great individuals the
greatest people of all time the greatest
women of all time had these negative
traits
that's human that's the human condition
even these great people could do that
type of thing and yet they could look at
it and we can look at it and we don't
have to look at it as if now because
they've done something wrong now they're
the most horrible person ever no all the
way around
even the greatest people make mistakes
and if we can be honest and say look the
greatest people make mistakes
and they don't let it destroy them
we can also look at ourselves and say
that we make mistakes it doesn't have to
destroy us
but we do need to look at it and we do
need to be honest about it and we do
need to look for what is the spiritual
solution for it
and i think it's just remarkable so
beautiful that even moshe rabbenu
looking at his sister
moses looks at her and says she's done
the sin i also did the sin i know what
it's like i i remember it happened to me
too i also experienced that shame
and i'm gonna cry and i'm gonna ask god
to forgive her i'm gonna ask god to heal
her of her spiritual sickness
and i think that the measure in telling
us that
this is where we see that we need to
remember what happened to miriam it's
telling us that it's not just that we
need to see what happened to miriam but
we need to see also what happened
through moshe rabbenu the way that moses
approached it and now he recalled the
things that he had done wrong it's easy
to look at someone else and say oh look
they've done something wrong i'm going
to remember that i also did the same
thing and that's going to help me pray
on their behalf
that's a great hadith it's an amazing
novelty that's what shall be teaches us
and if i can admit that the thing that i
see in someone else is the same thing
that i have wrong if i can admit even
the greatest person has done this sin
and i can recognize that i have this
inside of myself that is what the torah
is trying to teach us that is what the
message is for now we come we you know
it's only a few weeks until shashanim
kippur it's only a few weeks until we
have to face off with ourselves face off
with the reality of how much we have
brought hashem to be our king in the
world how much is hashem how have we how
much have we truly been
servants of hashem servant to our true
ideals of who we believe we're supposed
to be
and that honesty the the sukim are
telling us the message is telling us
that honesty is possible only if we can
look at it and not be disgusted by it
and not try to rip it out but rather
look at it honestly
go to people who are spiritual and ask
for their advice
how does one uproot
the spiritual malady that i have how do
i get rid of the spiritual problems the
spiritual destruction that i have caused
how can i uproot it at added source how
can i truly do juva how can i truly
repent
torah is enjoining us to remember
that which hashem did to miriam and also
that which the what was the process for
her purification how is the spiritual
sickness removed what method and the
answer is
by looking at it honestly
not being shy not shying away not being
afraid of it looking at it honestly
and admitting it
seeing that this is something that even
the greatest of them has hashem should
help us that we should be said we should
merit to be able to admit our faults to
admit the places that we've done wrong
both in our relationship with hashem and
in our relationships with others
if i can come to somebody else and admit
to them that i've done wrong and i'm
committed to changing what an amazing
spiritual experience that is what an
amazing spiritual effect it has on my
life and on all of my relationships
should help us to be able to admit those
faults to admit the places that we need
to change that we need to to go back to
the roots and try to understand how we
can become greater people thank you so
much for listening have a wonderful week
and wonderful shabbos
this podcast was made possible through
the gracious donations of listeners like
you for more podcasts like this please
visit www.ariegoldwag.com
or search on itunes ahri goldwag