Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Chayei Sarah - Laying Claim to Israel
660 views
Why do the children of Ishmael and Canaan lay claim to Israel specifically in front of Alexander the Great? Why do the responses come from Gevia the hunchback? Why does Alexander feel drawn toward Jerusalem? Why does he want to enter the Holy of Holies on the Temple Mount? What does it mean that Abraham blessed Isaac 'with everything?' Why did he send the others away from Isaac? Find out in this week's parsha podcast.
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
you're listening to the weekly partial
podcast recorded with hashem's nevering
assistance in R Israel 5776
2015 this week's para
is the Torah describes for us the
passing of saru of our matriarch Sarah
and afterwards the Torah tells us that
he decides to marry another woman he
marries Cura and he has a number of
children with Cura but the Torah is
explicit and it's very clear that who is
the main Heir both spiritual and
physical of ab aino of Abraham it's
Isaac it's y ainu who would be the
forebearer of the Jewish people the
verse says like this it goes through the
whole list of all the children of AR
that he has from Cura and then it
finishes off and says this is in chapter
ver5 Abraham gave all that he had to
Isaac the next verse says however to the
children of the concubines meaning and
Hagar these children that were born as
well as
yes that had what did these women and
their children
get Abraham gave them gifts what were
those gifts not important to me right
now we can look in the the that
discussed
that the verse tells us that Abraham
specifically sent these children away
from
Isaac while he was still alive all of
this was done in in his lifetime it
wasn't a will that was given for after
he would pass away this was all done
during his lifetime K he sent them to
the Far East now there are a number of
points in these verses which need
explanation the Mish talks about them at
length and we'll see a little bit about
it one of the first points is that what
is the significance or why is the Torah
specifically telling us that Abu that
Abraham gave all that he had to Isaac to
Yak clearly as we said Isaac is going to
be the main progenitor of the Jewish
people of the spiritual Legacy of
Abraham of Abraham so that's part of it
but what is the significance that it
says here also important to understand
why is that said side by side with what
happened to the other children to
the that they receive these gifts also
it's important the Torah points out that
they were sent away from Isaac his son
doesn't say they were sent away from
Abraham it says they were sent away from
Isaac and it also says that Abraham was
still alive so the Torah is going to
tell us in the next verse or two that
Abraham is about to pass on so why is it
important for us to know that this was
given during his lifetime as opposed to
being perhaps the the gifts that were
given even after his lifetime maybe they
were given as part of his will what's
the significance of it so I'd like to
share with you a magish on this verse
that tells us a
story actually a few stories four
different stories three of which are
clearly connected but the fourth of
which is is not so clearly connected and
we need to understand the connection and
then the Mish also specifically speaks
about our verse and says AA on it which
also doesn't seem immediately to be
connected but is very much connected so
it says like this Alexandro smok in the
days of Alexander and I believe this is
a reference to Alexander the Great
during his time he ruled over the entire
civilized world at the time so something
happened the children of the Arabs came
and they had a PL against the people of
Israel that they had taken an undue
portion in the land of Israel they laid
claim this is a story that happened
thousands of years ago already but
already they were laying claim to Israel
and saying that they deserved it because
or they deserved a portion or greater
portion in it because they were the
first
born another two families another two
evil families came along with claims as
well one of them was the family which
was a descendant of the the people of
can Canan of Canaan and the other was a
family that was descended from MIM from
Egypt the Egyptians now these people
were going to bring the Jewish people to
court making a claim against them in
regards to the land of Israel let's
see so now the Jewish people said the
the sages said who is going to stand up
on behalf of the people of Israel and
defend the people of Israel in this
court
there was a certain man named G and he
said I'm going to be the one and the
word g actually means a hunchback he was
a hunchback as we'll see in the in the
continuation of the story he said I'm
going to be the one to lay down their
claims to rest so that we can we can
remain in our land and no one will have
any claims against
us Arts they said him be careful even if
you don't have a response for them make
sure you don't admit in any way shape or
form that the land belongs to them
interesting statement by
the said to them I'm going to go and
judge there I'm going to speak on behalf
of the people of Israel the Jewish
people if I succeed then all is well and
if
not I give you permission to say who is
this person who's not so smart who is
standing up for us this isn't the person
and you guys can come back and and make
the claims if I don't
succeed me says that indeed went and he
had this deal and he had this whole this
whole went through the
process smoked
on so Alexander the Great said who is
the one who is coming with a claim
against against the other
person the isites the people descended
from isma the Arabs they said we are the
ones who are making a claim
and we are making our claim based on
their very Torah we are going to prove
from the Torah itself that the land of
Israel belongs to us see the verse
says the verse tells us that if a man
has two wives one of whom he loves and
one of whom he hates and the one who he
hates has his firstborn child so he has
to make sure to give the firstborn child
a double portion despite the fact that
he doesn't love this wife
so the ishmaelites were saying the Arabs
were saying that while it's true maybe
Abraham did not love Hagar as much as he
loved Sarah nevertheless he has to give
us the double portion because we are the
we are the first
born so the Hunchback responded and
said my master the
king does a person not do whatever he
wants with his children meaning is it
the right of a parent to decide if he
wants to give a double portion or if he
wants to give nothing to one child he
wants to give everything to another
child so the king said yes that's
correct the father has the right to do
that so he said to him the Hunchback
said quoted our verse that Abraham gave
everything that was his to Isaac and
this is a reference to the land of
Israel which is representative of the
spiritual leg Legacy as we said of of
Abraham so they responded
and being B of so they said where's That
explicit document that says that he sent
them away without without giving them
anything how do you know
that he quoted the next verse which
states that indeed to the sons of the
pilim to the sons of the concubines so
he gave them gifts and then he sent them
away so clearly he gave them whatever
was m whatever they deserved but beyond
that the land of Israel is the core
inheritance of the Jewish people and it
belongs to
Isaac and they left there the isites who
had made this claim in front of
Alexander the Great they left there with
embarrassment they were embarrassed they
were indeed shown up by the Hunchback
now we said that there were two other
families besides for the ishmaelites
they were the Canaanites the Canaanites
also came at this
time the Canaanites
said they also said that we have a claim
to the land of Israel based on their
very Torah
it always refers to Israel as the land
of Canan the land of Canaan so give us
back our
land so the Hunchback responded and said
my master the
king can a person do with his slave
whatever he wishes if a person has a
slave can he do whatever he wants with
that
slave the king said of course he
can he said what does it say in the
verse in the Torah or the people of
Canaan are
cursed it says that they're going to be
slaves to Shem so the grandchildren of
Canaan they will remain slaves just like
the curse of Noah
so the land is
ours these are now their slaves as it
were the Canaanites are slaves and
servants to to the king to Alexander the
Great but their
whole their whole character is is one of
being slaves so they don't receive the
land of Israel because they're just
slaves watching over a place which
belongs to their master and that place
which belongs to their Master is the
land of Israel it belongs to the master
who is Abraham and his descendants it
doesn't belong to the
Canaanites they were indeed embarrassed
and they left they lost their claim now
the next family that came were the MIT
the
Egyptians so they came along the
Egyptians and they said me we're going
to prove the Torah that we have a claim
against
them 600,000 Jews it says in the Torah
left from us from Egypt
to they had taken all kinds of golden
and silver
vessels it says they cleaned out
Egypt give us back our silver and our
gold they took it all they never gave it
back they said they're borrowing it they
never give it
back so the Hunchback responded and said
my master the
king 600,000 people were there for 210
years and they worked for them for 210
years without getting
paid amongst those people were people
who were gold Smiths and silver Smiths
and they charge one din which is a
significant amount of money per day
Yos so now the philosophers there sat
and they made a calculation
it wasn't 100 years when they made the
calculation of 100 years worth of work
they saw that Egypt was cleaned out
meaning the value of the work of the
Jewish people that they never got paid
for was more than the value of all of
the gold and and silver that the Jewish
people borrowed so to speak from the
Egyptians meaning they had every right
to that money they had never gotten
paid as a result of this response of the
Hunchback to the Egyptians they left
there and they were embarrassed so those
are the three stories of the Mish I just
want to ask a few important points a few
important questions that will help us
get to a certain specific point that I'd
like to get to in the end but we read
this event as the mag describes it with
Alexander the Great and we can't help
but think like why is it indeed that
these people waited so much time it's a
thousand years later since the Jewish
people came into the land of Canan and
took the land it's 1,500 100 years since
is could have had a claim to the land of
Israel it's a thousand years since the
Egyptians had lost all that money to the
Jewish people what took them so long why
are they all of a sudden waking up and
making a claim to Alexander the Great
what is the significance of this claim
specifically with him why is that why is
that happening right now also an
important thing to think about is that
it's not a coincidence that Gava this
person this Hunchback who's responding
to them is a hunchback what is the
significance indeed of that why is the
representative of the Jewish people a
hunchback now there's one more story in
the medes which I want to share with you
which is not clear exactly the
connection it's another story that
happened to be with Alexander the Great
and this Gava this Hunchback but doesn't
it's not so clear the connection we'll
see the connection is indeed
there Alexander the Great decided he
wanted to go up to Jerusalem
a some kites came and they said to him
he's be
careful you should watch out you're
going to see that they're going to
disrespect you they're not going to
allow you to go into their holy of
holies the holiest place on Earth the
Temple mount on that Temple Mount is is
where the holy of holies was where the
Ark of the Covenant rested the Arab
you're not going to be allowed to go
into that Sanctuary into the holy of
holies their intent in saying this to
him was to say that they're going to
disrespect
you when the hunch back found out he he
heard about this or he realized that
this was going
on he went and he made him two socks the
law is the is that no one's allowed to
go onto the Temple Mount wearing shoes
one must remove one's shoes when one
enters onto the Temple Mount that's the
that's the law Jewish law so he wanted
to make the king aware of this without
offending the king saying it in a way
which would be with with Incredible
wisdom and nevertheless he' get the
message without being offended so he
made him two
socks he put on the sock he embedded on
it two stones two precious stones that
had the value of 20,000 pieces of silver
it so when he got to the Temple
Mount so he said to him he said to G
said The Hunchback said to King
Alexander he said to him take off your
shoes and wear these fancy
socks somehow perhaps maybe because of
the precious stones it would help him to
have a better grip on the floor I'm not
exactly sure but somehow these if you
take off your shoes and you put these on
you're going to have a better grip the
floor is slippery and in this way he was
able to get the king to remove his shoes
when they got to the place where the
holy of holies
was so they said to him they said to
Alexander the
Great they didn't say anything about him
they said we don't have permission to go
in
there we don't have permission we're not
allowed to go in the Jewish law
prohibits us from going in there they
didn't say anything about the king they
wanted him to figure it out on his own
so he wouldn't be
offended so the king says to the
Hunchback
to say he said in just he's like I'm
going to go in there by myself and when
I come
out I'm going to straighten out your
Hunchback so you won't be hunchbacked
anymore and they Joseph explains that
the implication he was saying it with a
little bit of a jab atav he was saying
oh you're so tricky you have a hunchback
you're so tricky you're crooked you're
trying to trick me into doing what you
want I want you to know that I noticed
and I'm going to straighten you out when
I come out of there so to speak
so responded The Hunchback responded and
said him if you will be able to
straighten me
out you will be known as one of the most
amazing
doctors and you'll be able to receive a
tremendous amount of money so the says
that he was responding in a way
pretending as if he didn't really
understand the jab of the king he didn't
understand the implication of what the
King was saying but in so doing and
responding in this way the King was maal
he received the words he understood that
there was real respect here and it was
done in an amazingly respectful way and
in a way in a in a wise way as a result
the king listen Alexander the Great did
not walk into the Kash into the holy of
holies now in reading the story one
can't help but ask why indeed first of
all why did Alexander the Great feel it
was so important for him to come to
Jerusalem that's question number one why
did he want to visit Jerusalem yes
Jerusalem is the capital of Israel it's
an amazing beautiful city ET
but why was it so important for him to
come there he had many many different
countries under his Reign if he wanted
to go to a capital of anywhere he could
go anywhere why specifically to
Jerusalem why was that important to him
also why was he so drawn why was it
important for him to be able to enter
into The KES kadash to the holy of
holies why indeed did he want that why
would he view it as an insult if he
wouldn't be allowed to enter into this
holy of holies which no one's allowed to
go there why would he view that as
something offensive that he's not
allowed to go in there so before we get
to the next little piece of the medish
which also needs explanation I want to
start explaining some of the questions
that we've asked because it's going to
get us to a central concept which is the
idea that I want to share and that is
that Alexander the Great why you know
why does he want why is he attracted to
Jerusalem why does he want to come to
the holy of holies and why indeed do the
yesim the mitam the Egyptians the Arabs
the all these people why do they all of
a sudden because he's the king why do
they all of a sudden want to make their
claims against the Jewish people get
their money back get get the land of
Israel back or claim their portion in
Israel what's happening what's the idea
here what's the the theme what's the
concept of the Mish is teaching us and I
believe that the answer is that there's
a concept of clus the concept of clus of
of inclusive the inclusive aspect the
Transcendent inclusive aspect we've
spoken about it at length on other
occasions but it certainly is clear that
that's the center of what's going on
here the Jewish people are the
all-inclusive aspect of the world
we are the one nation the the unique
Nation we are that that lonely nation in
a certain sense there are the 70 nations
of the world there are 70 as we've seen
on on sukus you know there are 70 par 70
bulls that are brought which correspond
to the 70 Nations and then on the eighth
day which represents the Transcendent
aspect there's one power one bull which
is brought which represents the Jewish
people because we are the Transcendent
aspect of the world but just like the
Jewish people are a Transcendent aspect
of the world the 70 Nations themselves
also have a Transcendent aspect within
themselves and that is a king a king who
can come and he can unify the entire
world he can come and he can bring all
of the Nations together so he represents
in a certain sense he's the most Jewish
of all of the gam so to speak he's the
most Jewish he has that Transcendent
aspect that's contained within him he
has that allinclusive aspect and that's
who Alexander the Great was he was able
to bring together all the Nations
another person like this and I don't
think I'm going to have time to really
get into it but the person who
represents this idea is go we see that
it's described in in Ezekiel in in the
book ofel it speaks about this person
who's
in he is the prince or the president of
and he represents and he includes all
the nations and he brings all the
nations together back to Israel to to
fight in Jerusalem to fight in Jerusalem
why does he do that why is his Focus
very similar on Jerusalem and he's
bringing all the nations together Egypt
and the isma and the Arabs and the the
everyone else everyone's coming against
Jerusalem what's the idea the idea is
that he is the K that one who's going to
come is going to be the K the
all-inclusive aspect on the side of
negativity in a negative sense he's the
all-inclusive aspect he brings everyone
together against the Jewish people now
Alexander the Great he wasn't bringing
people against the Jewish people he
wasn't bringing them all together but
because he was the all-inclusive aspect
so as soon as the nations of the world
see that all of a sudden their eyes
light up it's like as if oh here we are
there's this guy he's he's the
all-inclusive aspect he's going to give
us what we deserve as soon as they see
this all-inclusive aspect they want
Jerusalem they want Israel they want to
lay claim to Israel as soon as that
happens and just like then so too it's
going to be before mashiach comes
they're all going to come on Jerusalem
because Jerusalem is in the Physical
Realm the Transcendent and all-inclusive
aspect of the entire world that's why
they want to lay claim to Jerusalem the
Kash the holy of holies the Temple Mount
is the Transcendent aspect of Jerusalem
so they're laying claim to the to the
very quality of the Jewish people why do
the Jewish people have the inheritance
of the land of Israel what does it mean
that Abraham gives everything call call
he gives everything which is his to the
Jew to to Isaac what's the idea of call
the idea of call is the all-inclusive
aspect Abraham gives to Y the
all-inclusive aspect he gives him the
har he gives in the Temple Mount which
is where that takes place which happened
in last week's para The Binding of ISAC
that takes place at that Pinnacle that
point of creation that focal point of
creation and they lay claim to it they
claim the Temple Mount they claim Israel
because they would like to in a certain
sense replace the Jewish people and not
acknowledge that the Jewish people
themselves are the prince as it were of
humanity now Alexander the Great because
he's the one who is the Transcendent
aspect of the nations of the world first
of all that's why he they come and they
make they lay claim to him asking for
Israel or asking for something which
represents the special nature of the
Jewish people which is also that money
which represents their you that's a
whole different subject but Alexander
also wants to come to Jerusalem to visit
Jerusalem he's drawn there because of
his Transcendent aspect because of his
inclusive all-inclusive aspect which he
is the king of the world so to speak at
that time so he comes to Jerusalem and
he wants to enter into the kashh and the
holy of holies but the amazing thing is
that Gava he represents the Jewish
people he's the Hunchback he's the one
who has leaned over he looks like one
thing but as Alexander says to him you
are crooked you are hunchbacked meaning
you are very wise you're able to twist
things in a certain way but Gava just
like the Jewish people Jewish people are
also that way we look like we're crooked
in a certain sense when they see us they
see negativity when they see the people
of Israel they see negativity they look
they look at us as if we've done
something wrong but that's not really
what it is and just like gavia is
someone who's who's bent who twists
things in order to get to the truth to
find the truth and to show the truth and
what happens in the end they're
humiliated the the Arabs are humiliated
the Egyptians are humiliated the people
of Canaan are humiliated because they're
making a false claim when they make a
false claim the Jewish people they look
on the surface to be crooked but the
truth is in the that's just how it looks
on the outside but the truth is that
they are truly twisting into the truth
that's what our power is we also that
you see that also with Jacob with yob
when he steals the blessings it's a
whole another Tor that's a whole another
div Torah to speak about but the bottom
line of it is that they will come and
they will twist things and they will lay
claims and they will try to go out of
their goo they will try to go out of
their boundary to lay claim to that
all-inclusive aspect and the Jewish
people we our job is to be like Gava to
be able to know how to answer them in
such a way that they don't feel
threatened by our specialness they don't
feel threatened by the fact that we're
the all-inclusive aspect and indeed
they're able to be humiliated in a
certain sense because the idea of
humiliation is to be caught by the truth
that's humiliation humility is living
with the truth humiliation is being
caught by The Truth Alexander the Great
he was able to to live with humility
Gava was able to to show him in a way in
in a wise way the truth and Alexander
was able to accept that and that was his
greatness now I don't have time to get
into the next piece in the Mish it's
worth seeing it's at the end of par para
number 61 in this week's paraa but the
bottom line is that we need to know who
we are we need to understand what are
the boundaries we need to it's clear
that what's going on here is that
they're trying to cross into the
boundaries of the specialness of am
Israel trying to take something which
doesn't belong to them try to tap in to
that all-inclusive aspect which belongs
exclusively to the Jewish people yes
there are individuals amongst the
nations of the world who can have that
aspect as well but even they are only
you know relative to the rest of those
people the rest of the nations of the
world the king the the one who is all
inclusive is only in in relationship to
the nations of the world but the Jewish
people are always all of them are always
and and even within the Jewish people
are different levels but the Jewish
people as a general Principle as a
general rule are that all-inclusive
aspect so I want to bless you and please
bless me back should help us to
recognize who we are what our boundaries
are what the what our places in reality
where we stand to respect it and to
latch on to it and if you read the end
of that par you'll see that that's the
point of the whole medish that AB indeed
sends off the his other children far
away because it's important that they
recognize who they are and what their
placees Aram specifically gives the
correct portion to the people of Israel
should help us to recognize who we are
and what our portion is sh should help
us to fulfill our portion our purpose in
life thank you so much for listening a
wonderful
shabus this podcast was made possible
through the gracious donations of
listeners like you for more podcasts
like this please visit
www.wag.com or search on iTunes Ari
goldwag
[Music]