Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Bitachon 286 - NO Efforts Needed
287 views
We continue with our discussion of the opinion of the Alter of Novardok and the Gr"a which is that no efforts are needed when one has full Bitachon and one is completely focused on one's spiritual relationship with Hashem.
Categories:Music
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
You're listening to the 286th edition of
the Buffen podcast and we are continuing
in the opinion that
efforts when it comes to being involved
with doing anything as opposed to just
trusting in Hashem. It's not ne
necessary to do any efforts. One can
just trust in Hashem if one is in a
space of complete dedication to his
relationship with. And before I
continue, I just want to mention that um
usually what I try to do when I film my
podcasts is be in a place where it's
pretty shady so that the lighting is
good. But I wanted to be in this spot
where you can see the beautiful hills of
Beamesh right behind me and so the sun
is in my face. So if you're watching
this video and sometimes my eyes are not
fully open, you can understand why
he brings here like this.
He says that generally speaking, one of
the opinions that's quoted as saying
that you don't need to do anyhalis, you
don't need to put in any efforts is the
opinion of the al-sh which if you recall
from studying together
Adam tells a story with the al-shik and
the wagon driver who heard the alik
speaking and then he stopped being the
wagon driver.
He ended up getting a great treasure.
But he says those who quote the in this
way
it's a it's hard to understand
the writes in the Torah yal on his in
his explanation of the
don't let your heart say
I'm just going to learn Torah, I'm going
to throw my package onto Hashem.
All of my troubles, all of my livelihood
issues, any any needs that I have, I'm
just going to say, Hashem, you take care
of it.
Hashem will sustain me.
Says that's not the way.
if a person is studying Torah but he
doesn't also have at least what he needs
to live in a constricted way
it's going to end up that he's not able
to study at all it's going to be
nullified
this is what our sages say
so the says
You might think that you could just sit
and not do any work. Could just do
whatever you want. Study Torah, sit and
not work. So the Pik says, and this is
the
Deuteronomy 14:29,
the work of your hands that you shall
do.
This means to say
person should not rely on an open
miracle.
that from the heavens they'll give the
person a treasure
but he can expect that will give a
blessing on the work that he does on his
actions
even if it's a small amount
and if he does this
if he tries to get away with not working
at all said
So then it's going to end up that the
Torah that he's studying is going to end
up nullified.
You won't have bread
is
and that would cause a person has to be
careful if I'm studying Torah. If I'm a
spiritual person, it can't look like
because I'm spiritual therefore I have
nothing. Okay. So this is actually I
made a mistake. I said it's inim the in
the middle that we quoted is but this is
inra.
So it's explicit here that the alik is
against what the majam says that the
alik said.
Okay. So it's just it's good to know
that that which is said in the name of
the alik the alik explicitly says not
that way and he says that it could cause
a desecration of God's name which is one
of the worst sins possible.
So it needs explanation
but we're going to move on from that.
A proof of this opinion is requires
which we already mentioned
at the time when Jeremiah said to the
people of Israel
he said to them why are you not studying
Torah? Why aren't you learning?
They said
they said if we sit and learn, how are
we going to have livelihood? How are we
going to have our needs met? So,
so what did your m do the says he took
out for them from the holy of holies in
the in the mdish in the temple. He took
out this little tint. It was a some kind
of container that had in it a remnant of
the actual mana.
which was given to Mosher Raenu in his
times in the 40 years in the wilderness.
They had saved a bit of it and it
stayed. It was there so anyone could see
it.
You have to see what the word of Hashem
is etc.
So this is the opposite obviously of
what we quoted from the alik at the
beginning. This is saying the 40 years
in the wilderness were spent by our
forefathers. What were they doing there?
They were just studying Torah.
They were involved in learning Torah.
And see what they did in order to have
their love taken care of.
They received the mana. They they
received miraculous
miraculous support from Hashem.
So you too can do the same thing.
Sit and learn. Sit and learn.
And Hashem will give you livelihood from
this.
on this measure. She says,
"We see that for those who are involved
in learning Torah and those who fear
God."
So, Hashem's eyes are upon that person,
those who fear him, those who are
seeking his kindness.
So a person who places his faith
completely in and is focused completely
on studying Torah and on spiritual
pursuits. So that person can rely on
miracles.
Can rely on miracles.
It's actually kind of cool. I I was just
listening listening to a series from uh
5783.
So it's 3 years ago three and a half
years ago and from my rash from Rabbi
Pere and he was talking about the idea
of and it worked out that that
particular shar I was actually present
in New York at the time for the Shir and
it's fun to hear him mention that I'm
there. It's also enjoyable to hear
myself asking him a question and the
question that I asked him based on what
he spoke about was connected very much
to this
and that was that we see it sounds like
that a person can be a person can
depend on a miracle. So ordinarily tell
us that you're not allowed to say you're
not allowed to pray for something that's
impossible. For example, 40 days after
Salad, 40 days after conception, it's
already determined what the child is
going to be. If it's going to be male or
female say you're not allowed to pray
anymore for the for what this child, if
let's say a person wants a boy, you
can't pray for a boy. Person wants a
girl, you can't pray for a girl.
Whatever it is, it is already. You can't
pray for something that can't be
changed.
But we see that we see from the story of
Nak naktim Mguri and I'm not going to
get into that right now but there's a
story in the Gmorrah particular
individual who prayed that it should
still be day even though the sun had
already set and his prayers were
answered the sun came out even though it
had already set.
So you see that a person can pray for
something impossible and and alter was
using it in the context of you cannot be
taken for something that's impossible.
So I said to him I asked my rabbi. So
it's comes out that person can have or
maybe can can d it's subjective it
depends on the person person can pray
for something that's impossible that
requires an ace person can be a person
can depend on a miracle and he said
indeed it's true that it depends on the
person's level. There are people who are
on a certain level where they have seen
over and over again there'll be talking
works their faith in God works their
prayer is effective even for something
that's miraculous and I do know people
like that
so it really depends on the person and
it's important to study this and to know
that there are different levels in there
are different levels in
our faith in Hashem
okay so the alter says it here he's
quoting it
Hashem will bring the person's needs in
hidden ways without any efforts on their
part and any trying to figure things out
by the human being.
Will bring it to them in a completely
miraculous way.
The human being can't even imagine it.
You can't even like get a handle on it.
from his wife employee
is saying it the mun came to the person
how did they get it where did it come
from and in a completely miraculous way
it just fell every morning every day and
twice the amount on Friday so they
wouldn't fall on shamas
something that's impossible to
understand
this is in the in chapter 13 of
and it's also brought in from
was of course a grandson of the alter of
nardicad.
So what will those who say that you must
do some kind of efforts? What will they
say to this? You know, obviously there
is such an opinion.
The ones who say that you have to put in
efforts. Well, you see here that you
don't have to put in any efforts
according to your
writes,
there was a certain amount of efforts
that was required for those who ate the
mana,
right? They had to go out and they had
to collect it. and to leave their homes.
[clears throat]
Okay. When it says in the meas that when
the
the Torah scholar is studying Torah at
night, so Hashem will provide for him
what he needs in the day.
Oh dear.
But if a person says the issuing
all the time, all day and all night, so
then Hashem will send angels to bring
him his needs. Meaning it's going to
come in a miraculous way.
But there's an obvious question on this
opinion.
The says
that Hashem will bless you.
Says you might think that you could sit
around and do nothing.
That's why the blessing says he will
bless you in all that you will do. So it
sounds very clearly like you have to do
something and the blessings have
somewhere to take effect.
It sounds very much like you have to do
some kind of efforts
for an answer to this question. There's
a shining answer from somebody named
Minis Shakim
in Malcus.
We find that a person can get a
punishment of lashes
which require in order to get lashes you
have to do some kind of action.
What about when I speak is speaking
enough of an action for me to get
lashes? Let's say I say I say gossip. Is
that enough of an issue to get lashes?
He says yes.
When you move your lips it's called an
action.
And certainly if in a negative place
moving your lips is considered an
action. Certainly when it comes to a
positive place moving your lips is an
action.
If I'm praying or I'm learning that's
called that I did something that there's
somewhere for there to be there's
somewhere for the for it to take effect
the blessings that Hashem wants to give
it will be uh fulfilled all that you
will do Hashem will bring the blessings
in all that you will do you will bring
blessings to your prayers prayers your
prayers will have take effect.
But we can point out that there's
another question on this opinion.
There's a problem. We know generally
which we mentioned earlier that one is
not supposed to depend on an open
miracle.
Right? So if you're depending if you're
doing no efforts and you're depending
completely on your so then you're
depending on an open miracle.
The writes writes you're not supposed to
do that not supposed to depend on an
open miracle. Many others write this as
well.
However,
it's clear that this is something that
those who are of this opinion the altar
of nardic and the as we said so they
hold not that way
says
the says a person who is a true a
complete trust someone who has complete
complete confidence he can depend on a
miracle
You don't have to worry about any sins.
It's not a sin.
Okay, we'll read a little more.
We also have two more opinions that are
unique in in their type.
The first one that we'll mention is
clearly whosoever generally he holds.
that a person needs
alongside doing efforts.
Now what level of what how what level of
efforts are required?
Does hold that you need to put in every
effort like the first opinion
or does he hold that you need to
diminish the amount of efforts that you
put in like the second opinion which we
quoted
as a novelty
that this matter depends on the physical
and
intellectual
conditions of the person
says, and I'm going to actually move the
camera a little bit so that I'm still in
the sun. Otherwise, we lose a pretty
background. Or maybe I'll just move into
the shade. How's that?
Into the shade and turn the camera a
little bit.
Okay.
Hopefully it will stay stay Gishmak.
So he says like this
what is the obligation here? Does a
person need to put in extra efforts or
not? So he says like this
depends on the person.
Once says that a person is obligated to
put in efforts
when it comes to his livelihood.
There are many different ways that a
person can do this. There are different
way means to to get it.
some efforts a person can put in or may
put in require more efforts. Some are
easier.
So
a person who's physically strong
but not so wildly intelligent.
So then that type of person should put
in efforts that that are according to
who he is. He's stronger. So he can do
physical efforts to to to
attain his
and he shouldn't do things that involve
intellectual things. He's not so smart.
But a person who's weak of body but is
more intelligent, let's say,
as so he shouldn't be involved in things
in in efforts that that are more
difficult physically
rather he should turn away from those
things and do the things that are easier
on his physical body
that he'll be able to continuously do so
really and and I would extend this not
just to physical and and intellectual
but perhaps we could say depends on the
person's spiritual
Where where is a person holding
spiritually? Be talking to something
which really is subjective.
Whether a person can depend on an ace,
whether a person has to do more
difficult physical manual labor, whether
a person can do intellectual types of
pursuits in order to to to obtain his
parnosa. All of these things depend on
the individual. And with that, I will
say thank you so much for listening. See
you again next time.