Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Minhag vs. Halacha: A Father's Wisdom Revealed #shorts
227 views
When community custom ('minag') becomes stronger than religious law ('halacha'). Exploring the mindset of taking responsibility beyond obligation. A father's lesson in looking for solutions. #JewishLaw #Community #Responsibility #Tradition #Mindset
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
He says, "No, no, no. It's mine, it's I
did nothing."
We know that by us minag is stronger
than halacha. Minag Israel k'din.
The halacha is you can't steal money,
smuggle in government, but the minag is
that you go to the Rebbe for a bracha
before you get on a plane.
So, anybody who came to me and said
they're going to Belgium, I just didn't
give a bracha to.
I did nothing.
That's
the type of thinking that was like
everybody could see a problem
and most people, and rightfully so,
there are times I wish I was some of
those people, I'm not going to argue,
but most people are going to be like,
"Okay, it's someone else's problem. It's
not for me. I did my part. I did my ha
But my father instilled in me and still
instills in me
the importance of looking past that,
looking for the solution, looking for an
answer.
Wow. And um is he is he some some
Arabish descent? Is he coming from
there?
>> actually has a very interesting
background. He himself was born in
Germany in 1936.
>> Mhm.
Came to America in '38. The family
became very close with Rav Moshe Bick,
he was still young in the Bronx.
And that's where the heimish in the
Tishas came from. Now,
the Gluck family in Germany was the only
family in Hamburg
that was allowed to daven in the Yekkish
shuls and in the Ausjuden shul. Mhm.
Now, in Germany it was a big thing if
you weren't part of them
>> You couldn't get into the other one.
>> to be that from my father's the family,
there was enough intermarriage between
the Galicianers and the Germans, even
though they came by World War I one
time,
and my great-great-grandfather was the
Bal Sham from Michelstadt. Mhm. So,
because the Glucks were from that
family,
you know, they were allowed to be both.