“Rebbe, when is Moshiach coming?” • Rabbi Mendel Scharf

I wrote I wrote a letter to them together with my sister. We wrote we sent it in together. It was like a joint letter. Um the and it was a just a a question. When is Mashiach going to come? I think like we're talking to my mother about it and my mother said ask or something like that. So we that's what we did. So it was around it was it was actually around the time and um the Reb answered I I'll read the I'll read the Limar that's my You going to translate? >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Let me just read the whole thing then I'll translate. I should read line by line and translate. >> Whatever. Whatever you want. >> I just want to get the whole, you know, you go. Hashem's hashem is super underlined. This we didn't get any was like rewritten by label growner. Now we got it within a few days. We got it around I mean was quite busy and we gave it in maybe a day or two before and that means within a few days this was like some emergency question to answer this but for the Reb it was so in English the answer is so again the question is when is Msiah going to come? So the Reb's response is Hashem concealed the time of the coming of Mashiach. That's what the cat says. When Yanke and then the Reb explains when Yankov wanted to reveal to his children when Mashiach will come, Hashem concealed it from him. as is said over in the Reb underlined the Reb underlined as is said over or as is told and then ask I will mention you by the so that's uh I should have this answer so I'm going to you know Do you remember what you felt then or what? >> I felt like a million dollars and that was it. I didn't feel anything different. Other words was no I mean now I could sit and uh you know learn in the the answer and call me ways but at the time even though I felt this I mean anytime we wrote to the responded so why shouldn't the respond to this? I would have liked that the Reb should tell me exactly when Mushia is coming, but I don't think that I thought that the Heb is actually going to tell me that. It's not what I I remember thinking that way. I was I don't think I was disappointed when I got this answer.