Why Did R' Chaim Answer So Many Letters (Chessed)

[Music] welcome back Rabbi Dr elzar BR we are winding down Season Two onki Season Two once again has been sponsored anonymously and we thank our sponsor today we're g to be discussing has been well known it's well documented the tens of thousands possibly hundreds of thousands of questions answered and there are people have private letters it's it's English something which is unprecedented in modern history the amount of questions that he answered and himself was asked like why did he spend so much time answering questions why did he spend more time writing his so R Brat's gonna talk about this a little bit I'm sure he's going to find something new as he always does find something that's sourced until ultimately he's gonna get to a from that perhaps was basing some of what he was doing on so BR how are you today I'm we're looking forward okay so basically the last few episodes we've been discussing the the some more aspects of which is we focusing on a concept known as kki himself coins it a safer um so we discussed some various different aspects of liot farm throughout the ages V there's much more to discuss we we um spent two episodes dealing with a little different aspects with it and then the third episode moving away from Li but then ultimately getting back to Li far we started talking about kki writes all over that he's not a p it's not so we spoke about listing other that also went with such a and said that they're not writing it as they're just writing it down but in the end ultimately all those different from the sh the and others they ended up becoming as we know the key in the world of so similarly that's really what ultimately happens he's screaming that the is not but today already it's um considered safer and in that we got into whole discussion with the maram um about maram some people were upset about the maram but ultimately also the maram becomes um listed a whole bunch of unbelievable safer in the world of now what's Nea for us today and to to find tune some of the aspects is as FS number one is that I'm when I'm keep when I'm saying in the past few episodes kki is calling Hiser a not call I don't think that it is he calls it and then and I show that but ultimately and I showed that the also called his own both of these are filled with anyone knows when you open up you look at the how he goes through the sugya bringing down everything and and how he's M so many different things as he's being Mal things but he's being he's holding the unbelievable and so I'm not coming to call it I'm going how he says such a thing now What's significant is that there were that relates to let's say the the mar is a it's a of but it's more than that it's also we find his own voice in the safer meaning to say there's Le which is something that I mention briefly is that there are that are just malaket they just quote um sometimes they don't even say what they say sometimes they say sometimes they'll say the sh says it's whereas there's others that they engage in the the material that they're quoting veryit such a safer will be the marki Mish are also similar in that aspect so there there's obviously multiple different meanings to the word le anyway so just to bring this out further is I quoted that lash the stier who was also into certain Le Farm amongst them the maram one of the Le Farm the the styler was into was the of the so the so this is a I've already mentioned a few times and I hope very soon to release it especially now is that the nus we devoted a whole episode to nus and one of the aspects we dealt with is the n the styler said that it was known RA in Europe before you got a job you made sure to get a what's the point the point is a r sometimes is in a situation he cannot open up all this far and he's in a situation during daving most so he doesn't know what to do so made a safer a handbook a rabbi's handbook so to speak so we I spoke out then bringing that became it became beyond popular it's not it's probably even impossible to calculate how many times it was published because it was published in numerous s and immediately was but the point is it was looked even though the writes here he does not write what he writes in other of his that Nota here he is willing to assume that it'sa but he just says I'm not really being Mish I'm being from any list to such as and others but the point is at the end of the day this is telling you what to do because I'm I'm in a bind I don't have time to learn this I'm a rabbi a guy comes ask me a question in middle of ding what do I do I open I look at my and found my S and and said this is how became accepted the just one anyone opens up to M says he includes it as one of the things that he's adding into his and you learn through M you see how many multiple times he's quot voting Theus in so I was found very interesting is this week I came across on a on a forum that someone brought up he found this major son of a great P has a seems there was some question about something and the based on a based on elaba and he wanted to show that it's elaba and theas we have two P can pass like this so says no don't count him as a he wrote It's not that the is telling you that the is like the then he says you have to be mind to this so This sounds like a very this is a fascinating chuva from where he seems to be saying that no it's not me say all the people Everyone that using the and they're putting in the S it's not which is which is very it's very hard to understand and someone over there on this form tries to um tries to explain what does mean but the problem is more than that what spoke about in this episode on the nus is the re AER besides being a close friend and giving an unbelievable H to the Nas's work he also writes hundreds of on and he's with it as so yes it could be and this is a complex discussion in but when you have nothing else in front of you and this is what you have the the Nas and you're a r and someone ask you the Sha and you're relying on the nist you're it's good you're good to go anyway so so the point is here we have again theer and we have that it's not clear what the kavana of theas we we seem to think that it and as as I said the Mish thinks the Stifler and others that it's a to rely on whereas saying no it's not don't be it's just being it's just to make that the should go check maybe says and maybe he doesn't and seems to hold not like his son anyway this is a complex discussion and there's a lot more to find tune about it but not for now now but the point is that there's a concept of and as I said there's multiple levels of that are plenty when they're being Mal such as the and now but there's a there's a more General point which is how is the author the is the intention of the author and then there's intention of what ends up happening so here let's say we have again saying the he didn't really intend it to be and it ends up getting a life of its own so now we we what we spoke about already start to talk about I'm not a p what do you mean you are a pis so now we have we have a crazy amount of literature to point to forget about that he says by the that I'm not a pis we know that he wrote it seems for years and years possibly answering between 80 tras a day and these tras had sometimes seven eight questions to maybe even 120 questions a day for years and years I mean I don't even know if they know the exact year when it start I mean I guess they could pinpoint when it started but they don't know to when it started becoming crazy amounts of letters but basically he's been we're talking about thousands upon thousands of letters so now what what what's it going on in these letters that so that's obviously a question so if people are asking him which there were plenty of times they're just asking him a simple question not a question asking where's the gar many times these questions are where they saw brought with his crazy something okay but but we know today because so many so many swarm that are published have these letters and not only that these letters have a lot of these letters have been published by themselves and we'll we'll discuss more about fine-tuning all the different works that there out there of these letters but there's plenty of Al they ask him different questions straight straight up in Al so much so that a bunch of years ago um it's already um it must be almost 15 years ago maybe even a little longer they decid it seems he kept a copy of the letters so they decided you know let's make a a volume and topics of the letters so they collected the letters and they started doing it from the beginning of they skipped let's say they put out this massive work and the point was they have a team of people going through it to writing beum on it someone's funding this project it's done by the family ofi and he authorized in the beginning and he was involved with many different aspects of it and we'll discuss what it is that he's involved with but the point is these are questions straight up revolving and we know that the questions go everywhere they're so so again he's answering someone what what does that mean is he answering you is just telling you oh you want to know you're asking me doesn't mean Nowa as I said it's it's we will find two different aspects of it but there are so many volumes of literature that that that this relates to now some of the letters that have been published in recent years are just letters and learning and some of these letter some of these volumes are incredible there's two volumes of letters between him and which we'll discuss more soon enough Victor nans is a whole volume of letters mindboggling what's going on in these letters interesting at one point they published in his lifetime um a volume called which they collected tons of materials that he wrote to to let's say sometimes he gave epas to certain a lot of letters that they got and it looks like a regular TR it's not like some people were used to what's thing you'll say Kan if come in there's some these like these like onew answers in this volume which is it's it's called There's real letters some of them could be more than a page about specific things they collected them from all different places they have letters with him and theable Yash of letters real letters so there are all types of letters as as I'm saying and we will discuss more the different types of letters now one of the things that's cute about these letters is recently I've mentioned many times is that there's auctions farm auctions that take place weekly daily sometimes and so there so ready for years different letters of kki go on auction they don't go for so much money obviously you hope to have a letter that has good content that maybe then it will be exciting you mentioned auctions there some news item recently be orender was auction enough for $2 million you have any recollection any no that was yeah no so they the the in the auctions they also auction off articles of clothes and tenders and this this took place even right the middle the SCH they sold his tender for something like a million dollars a private auction there's different there's different auctions some of them we don't even know about we just find out afterwards and they're exorbitant sums of money sometimes and the the articles of clothes also of his and stuff like that I'm not getting into that that's actually there's a whole conversation behind what why they do because in the world they very much do it but they did it for rash the the go-kart that used to take rash from his house to his to his his Sho they auctioned it off and went on auction and it's known they auctioned off and they sold the glasses of Kes so this is a common thing in the lfish show world also lit Fox could no longer make fun of that the that do it only did it LFX also do it okay obviously the question is who's buying it it could be it's that are buying of these lit Fox and maybe that's different discussion also anyway but the point is these letters of so they've auctioned off has already been sold on auction shomi has been sold I believe um Rabbi fredman Rabbi Freedman the famous hershy Freeman hasy Freeman bought it and has it I think I saw a picture in the mishak magazine article about him with it on display in his library now what's fascinating is it's scanned available for the public at Hebrew University nonetheless Library you could look at it online all so it's not sometimes and I've said this in the past I think and I'm always very upset sometimes you find these auctions unbelievable discoveries and then someone buys it and he keeps it in his house he doesn't want anyone to know about it here no I must say the are accessible to people so now letters also they've been going up on auction even when he was alive so randomly I from time to time I check auctions for for multiple reasons not important for right now why butki some letters I come across just to mention the types of letters that he gets someone ask and this is going on auction I believe in a few days um is it true that the stier said you cannot learn mishna with perish and the guy WR he heard two reasons one is because of and two this a fascinating question says then he says what's it referring to so it's referring to over there the says okay very interesting it will be interesting is if that was the only letter we have but they also auction off and they don't make the connection another letter and this letter is as follows could someone learn the of Liber could someone buy from the B Med from jts they put out many different so he says there's no to learn the of he says no it's not it's it seems that he holds it's not a problem um to buy far from them so I think in this one he says he's not sure but he says you could use it what's fascinating is is in theu the Stifler was asked could you use you have to understand rki and andman and they're all family and if you remember the first episode I said how wrote Godless about so maybe that's why is nice about it but anyway the point is but the point is thatu he was asked Styler was asked could you look at the which you have to understand the significance is way before had anything to do with the conservative this when he's learning in he's he's learning official any no problems St says no you shouldn't look at it so here we have a letter written from in it's dated it's in the 90s I believe it is and so this letter is also going on auction so you see you it's mind Bing we're talking about a person that's writing 120 letters a day or something what you could probably find them is mindblown okay the point is like this and we'll discuss more some interesting questions but obviously I do not plan on giving 50 episodes just to mention all the different Kaka questions that people ask I just they I just randomly came across them to bring out a point now so but this is a question that was discussed while was alive I used to always hear people talk about it during his L afterwards and during his SP I heard about it I also used to complain about it which is as follows just said he's writing a crazy amount of questions he's answering a crazy amount of questions he had a special room to do it he he did it he had a system how he figured out what obviously he couldn't know always kit it takes time this is not even even I'm not saying he has to open up his Library the point was that was actually fascinating did it off the cough but still takes time to answer people he's doing well pen he's not dictating it to people so the question that I asked and many people asked is why is it so important to answer these questions especially if you look at a lot of the questions are not such significant questions he can ask any you can ask any learned person they can answer it's not like they ask him the most complex questions okay that's what we understand we need rki for so the question that was asked is R keski had so many more for to write we know he began writing on katum it could be that he even would have done on Tyrus instead we don't the volume on Kum is Tiny and so people complain these questions he spent hours a day on it took away from what we CL saw was Z would have been Z to have this Monumental work on Kim and and perhaps even on tyus so how kki justify answering every Tom literally Tom Dick and Harry that asked him a question and he answered them what's going on so so so what's fascinating about kki is that one does not have to speculate people have asked them every single question including this many people had this conversation with them they asked them what's going on how could you justify doing this it's coming at the expense of others farm so lamal the famous person that we've discussed already numerous times which we still we hope to have him um on the podcast is RAB uer who like to have a special relationship with he too asked kki about it at different times um in one of his far he he has a whole footnote about it discussing what's going on seems gave him different times different answers one is that it's didn't have he was in rash it seems he might have been a rash for a RAB for a day and the Ty wasn't working so he he took him away from it so the point was this was a form of because we know so this was some type of musl by answering letters he's being um educating CL okay so there is a aspect to that nuda but um and this is something that we will have to discuss at point in time the whole concept of writing a safer one of the Milas that point out is that that's you're you're becoming a re forus mean say you could give a Shear especi this is in the days before it could be recorded obviously the recording changes a lot in this conversation but if let's say someone's giving a Shear on chabas so it's very important giving a Shear but writing something down has a so still held that there's a there's a there's some aspect of being another answer is he wanted it gave people um it gave the the sender to be Mas learning it helped them and and the SEC and the last answer which is a which is answer which we'll deal with also is sort of Rahman he knew that the people who sended him they're waiting to hear from him and and they want to get the answer and it and it helps them a Bak young Bak all of a sudden has some question whatever whatever it is he maybe even try to ask a few different people all of a sudden he gets an answer fromi he's all so it's sort of like AI was doing by um answering the by answering all these people so my uh intent is to try to deal we're going to try to explain and Enlighten some of these aspects so first of all there's a general question and this question is like this do we find other that they had to sacrifice their for for their job so to speak or for other maybe they want to write a certain thing and then they had to write something else so it's definitely precedent for this just to mention two examples that come to mind one is was a he was sitting and learning in a um K learning for I think it was something like 19 years after he was married plugging away being prolific publishing stuff he already published a few volumes and then he gets the offer to become a rashash Shiva called so he had a major suff because he had in his head already material for many more volumes in Zam but he needs time to write you can have a lot of times you have material but you got to have time and the funding to write it he knew that if he becomes the rashash Shiva it's a whole different track he's not going to have the ability to write this far so he had a Shila and he asked and he was told no you should give it you should daa become yes CL is going to lose out on let's say he was working on tumis at the time the rest of tumis and some other volumes in but it's more important for you to do become a and less known in America we we don't Focus this much because we know as the pis but basically he was a MAG here first year based medish for years and years he had thousands of T over the years he was excellent mag sheer excellent in depending on how different people Define it he gave excellent Shear very important shear and he was thousands and thousands of he still remained the P of in in in the World At Large a incredible incredible pis that was that already he was in his low 20s this is what they realized it was going to be the future were writing about him like in such glowing terms so it ended up basically that he got he became both just we did lose on some of these volumes another person was the Mal the Mal was a great great G and he started working on which is one of the most mindboggling Works in our known as art it didn't get too far basically as a battling of the musum he ended up spending the rest of his life to write a systematic IND Parish defending T in his work which deals with aish and then moving further on to writing aish and you needed someone with the greatness of the Mal such a tremendous and some people said it's a shame we lost out lost out but it's very possible and this is what's been claimed that we would not have had a of the Mal stature to be able to put out a Mal type of work on tan so we needed it okay so the point is sometimes you God is faced with a situation I what to do so here sh stuff that this is what he's supposed to be doing that he's supposed to be doing this for people okay Nowa and um so just two issues to discuss that I would like to discuss over here first it was like this a what what's the story with a a RV gets a question okay um which is very common raban today got emails Sam ranam are um techsavvy more and more they their WhatsApp groups or they all different things they get questions non-stop so the question is what's their as a I'm not talking about for their salary I'm talking more about the so interestingly enough I quoted this in the past that that um there's a a fascinating small count that Ritz wrote over 50 years ago of different things that a a r should know so one of the things is like this he brings down he tells to it's a it's also which basically there was a discussion these two were taking being taken out to be killed they were crying it was a whole discussion and basically the question was they were trying to figure out what did they do wrong and it sounded like one of them so much so that this according to this this early and as I said it's also and other places it sounds like that a r has to be available all times to answer questions I went to sleep doesn't help a phone it has to available you can't have a blocked phone number this is what Ritz writes now obviously the question is what's thear of this does a does a RV need to be available 24/7 so it's not simple but the but he he says when you read gum books this is whereit says you sometimes find that certain gum had set times that they weren't available so he um he says that's not so simple but we do find that they were that did have um just to mention two m about this number one is back to so as I said he was very very accessible all the years and but at a certain point in time later on in life he locked himself up for about two hours a day what was he doing he basically realized that the is a classic it's becoming used thousands of times a week by all of clel so he decided to go through the safer again to check over that everything that was said in his name was his and to look it over and he didn't and he didn't want to be interrupted during this period of time so it was known you couldn't interrupt him during this period of time on the other hand I I heard um um one time I was talking to a RV and the r was complaining to me he doesn't have time to prepare Shear so I said why don't you just take the phone off the hook whatever a few hours in your week or something and prepare share then and the rest of the time you'll be accessible so he told me this R like this he has a cabal from Raa Raa basically from when he woke up till when he went to sleep Sat by the phone to be accessible and everyone knows I I wasn't to know such a thing but basically froma so to speak opened up shop till till he was always available to answer questions he answered everything the most complex questions on the spot he was completely available this is similar based on this possibly taking this now interestingly enough this isit I'm saying is bringing this up but what about other do they handle such a thing so I come across that um I mentioned last week we were talking about the maram the greatness of the maram so the maram to put in perspective is a gal so the aderas after inspector dies he he puts who's his his like the God's God is gonna be the maram so he writes a trva to him now just have to understand this is how he refers to the marsham in this trva and then he writes him a whole um question this is in Mano now in maram in Tru marsham we find the trua that he asked the marsham one of the TRU that he asked him was involved this type of thing which he brought up and he wanted to know as a and it seems that the said it's a this it's not clear to how exact fun when because the p is it's some type of when you learn and as I said is taking it to be like that but if you take this to be out of sa it's you're pretty much making it impossible to be a RV because a RV to be so accessible so every second of his day it's gonna it's it's it's basically impossible now interestingly enough just to um mention relating to this with similar with that Daris is that darus so so he wrote he left behind millions of one of the things he left behind was incredible autobiography in this autobiography he's complain he writes basically the town was not paying him the salary this is Con constant problem for rabam in general and the aderas suffer from this greatly so he didn't know what to do so he asked the advice and basically the the he says answered him there's no problem do not answer them their questions until your salary is paid and and then he says so there is such a concept if you're if you're not getting paid then then there there's at least that for the R so if the R's getting paid so now the question might be what's a salary what's included in the salary okay anyway we're not going to I don't know and we'll let the r um give a share about that okay now the last for today that I like to bring out is relating to understanding where is this coming from tremendous of that we are seeing Illustrated over here in in this action we're talking about spending multiple hours daily every day for years and years and this man had what to do with his time as they say so what's theat I'm G I'm going to bring out two total different types of M um if this time for sure one we'll see if we have time for the second number one is like this so a lot of times when I prepare the shum I have no idea what am I gonna say and as they say it's um all of a sudden I'm thinking things walking randomly a thing that I'm working on something else could come to light and all of a sudden put things together from different topics I I sometimes I I'm like Blown Away how this even happens and and if you speak to anyone that has to prepare share this happens to them also so a few weeks ago I was working on I gave over aab and about gum books um a topic that I've collected material for close to um I've been reading G books for close to 40 years and I've had a massive amount of material about it so I said I'll start in order for me to talk about a topic I um if I talk about a topic that helps me start to being able to write to get my ideas in order so I was working on it so I was telling over a friend of mine um some the that I said I was talking to a friend of mine and all of a sudden what I said then all I realized that's going to help me over here because I had this how could you spend so much time answering people answer spend an hour a day the amount of hours that he was spending on it we lost CL there's not there's no replacement if you notice just to point this out there's no Mish typ safer on and forget about when you get the Kim and Tyrus who could have done kach and Tyrus the person who did kki I there's GNA be many different ones look there I mentioned this there's dozens of Miss R likes but with with the person likei be finded I I'm not too confident so I'm bothered I'm bothered now so I'm telling talking to this friend of mine I'm saying over what I said in the in the she books and then it comes in the conversation I remember a conversation I had with someone else about we were having a whole conversation about the and and in the course of that conversation I was saying again something that bothered me again it's bothers me it doesn't mean it bothers it doesn't mean it's a question doesn't mean anything we know was a he he founds the and everything he doesn't publish anything he left behind his Tris which ends up in three different fires getting destroyed he left behind the work on a which some of it survives and he leaves behind this work called NE now he's on his deathbed already and he and you would think what and this is very sad we're talking about theal of the we barely have any of his tire left behind we have something like 17 Chas of his we have in but we don't have his so you think on his death bed what's he going to say he's talking to his son the person who takes over to be the Riva another great G he's gonna give him tell him please publish some of my publish my chis It's Gonna Change it's we're talking about it's gonna make in the world of if my chuvas and and we know he had dozens and dozens of tras he was consulted for complex shus auna shus and much and all different complicated things so it could have changed the world of what does he tell him no print Myer laa um in the what happens he doesn't print it right away he has a fire he has a death and then and basically he realizes that that he takes it that what did he do wrong he didn't listen to his father to publish right away so he goes ahead and publishes so first I had as a fascinating thing was that here you see that held that this is the most important of his Works to be to make sure to be published was okay so obviously someone has to be in what's going on in that was so important for that he held this should be his lasting Legacy but more than that in this introduction he tells his son something else and this is this is written by rash every person is not created for themselves whatever you could do for the other person that's what you were created to do now if I said this sentence and I told you said it okay here we have is talking about what is the point of everything unbelievable that this is the Legacy on his deathbed and it seems he would say this cader is telling this is what it's about so now and so I'm looking at it so now it's starting to make a little more sense because that's what's going on more in the is understanding the importance of T and which is a way not only it's not for the person himself it's for the world and by learning and ding for the world this is an important thing but it's more than that this is a unbelievable that who's saying this not a not a if I would have found this in the say of course is gonna say such a thing now okay go f I'm going further so I come across a book um I come across it many years ago and then finally it comes out this book is what so the was a to put in perspective who he is he's a and he's the father-in-law of one of my heroes zern who he spoke about a whole episode The Y episode um about him and is this giant and maybe one day we'll talk all about him but the point is his son his other son-in-law not term but his other son-in-law writes a um a biography about his he was also a r who was a tremendous who dies young um in his low 50s I believe it was and basically he writes by sorry he was the r of pinsk not a small little not a small little place so he writes after nter a book um a 40 50 page book about fascinating fascinating material in this book I saw a mention the manuscript to it years and years ago in a book on and they have a picture of the I'm always wondering when it's going to come all of a sudden publishes the actual in the front of a saer called of this so in there I come across a a page which is incredible but and it's interesting it doesn't make the which is like this he is a tal of his father was one of the of and he says that his father would always say over and he heard and he himself would hear from this concept that I'm saying that it's written this becomes a tremendous R this is what and he has a whole thing how he writes it out a whole thing how it's written out is writes beautifully how he would hear say this over from this concept which you which you think about it's pelic this is a the world of the the elite of the of of the this is what they're saying over to giving over then it goes even more fascinating he says like this that is was looking to point which God does he hold is doing this that he's Mish he's giving over everything for the cloud for the Tiber so you think he's going to find some so no says which does he think had this the most in his which which this is just to show you a thing a conversation I've had a few times about the that tremendous respect this is a major for this he says now besides for his learning which he's not getting into over here but the point is that he did everything for for the generation we know that he became kilu the the um to make sure that what was happening that the pr he was a for all the different anyone knows the history of this is one of the things that he gave over his time now of course we know was giving he answered thousands of truis and he was he was busy but he managed to make sure to make it his business keeping in mind not from not because ofner he he's just pointing out that this is a what now he says I think he says this in the name that said what's the difference between he says it's a famous like this but he's only mentioned the T once you know why because he is locked up in himself and he's dealing with himself he's taking care of himself isn't important yesu is the is how many is in the is devoted endless and we know in everything we know so holy and everything the point is no that gave over as we know even for the everything how much he did and this is theu is the model for and similarly this is the elite of the world is giving over this concept that that's what it's about so so now is this is it what obviously this requires of learning so if you look already in in the where he has all in the beginning of about fascinating material he already to don't worry you have to know when it's a if it's it's something that you that um others cannot do what mean say which is obviously also important thing especially for the Lal world and not running to to just okay now later on comes the work from there's a lot to voted to the of the the importance of all this so now so what my claim is and this is what came clicked from me and it what I'm saying is this is could be Alf Bas to someone if they're thinking about it could be I'm completely wrong that kki this was his way of doing kki sat and learned the whole day he's not going around to do in the standard ways but he felt how could he do by answering all these people he says gu is coming to ask him a question he'll give him an answer and he knows say he was a weird of who he was that someone's going to get a letter from and it will inspire people and you ask people that that that different people many different people said oh when I was a B I wrote a bunch of letters to and they look back all very happy about it I was in contact with he took the time to answer me what better way to give over this of [Music] what we know did this not only with his writing he gave away a few hours a day to see people yes how long did he speak to people but it made people feel a million dollars he did it some people say what are you what are you doing you're not having conversations with the people they're just coming you're shaking your head boa all these different things the answer is he held this is an Auda and and I'm I'm showing you is this is an Auda who nonetheless where's it coming again there's probably a million others M that say it but this is as they said who gave it all to he would say it all the time was saying over and this as I said even this is too okay this is for today this is just one of the aspects in the the behind the scenes so to speak what I think one of the many lessons that will be able to take out from the TR of you when you look around is the most documented person um hero of of that we have amount of pictures and videos that exist I think we see he's giving so much time he's always speaking with people yes I agree he's not having conversations with many these people but for some reason it makes people feel good he was willing to give away his time for this and therefore yeah we did lose out but he held this is the this is the mess okay obviously there's some other which we will and which we will discuss in the next few episodes thank you yes very important many gave of their time in so many different ways which you could say and think that it took away from their learning their own growing their own sharing T but's case here showing that perhaps I took away from actually riding farm and much uh farm that we are likely not going to see um okay would you like to share a new book yeah so let just share one sa very briefly basically one of the of that had a tremendous influence on none other was a was a very interesting type of yid um one of the oldtime Giants inim that most people never heard of but but he had a tremendous impact on everything everywhere he was going he was always thinking of different aspects of the um and he had a big influence on Ritz somehow also but was very intim so I always was I always heard about him and many years ago um a booklet came out of they collected a bunch of pieces that they were able to get about he didn't he didn't write too much okay A little booklet comes out then slowly two people they decided to really go all in and they come out and they make a fat book hundreds of P 600 700 Pages they collect everything and they do excellent work suum of his on everything and we he was a he was a is fascinating his interesting insights in the world of not the typical stuff but also a lot of zugs that he would say and and as said he had a tremendous impact even on all different things just to mention one thing because it relates to something we began today's episode when the Mish came to um he he was blown away with it he couldn't stop learning it he was very into it and he said the because he was so interest as I said he was very he was so interested in the saer so the the foot noters as I said was very into this and um so or they bring down told them that one of the was very into was the that the Godless of the M that you see is specifically in the which goes what the I was bringing out in the beginning that the Mish is not just calls himself there's unbelievable things happening in the Mish um people have been writing articles recently being M and called Mish but even the how he sets up the Su and what he does is also incredible so why am I mentioning this now is basically the safer came out 10 15 years ago and now they just redid it sadly adding in a bunch more pages of material so stuck a person like me is stuck you have to buy the new edition it's called because you have to have both you never know maybe they took out stuff you can't take the other one off your shelf because maybe they took out stuff in the first edition and New Edition has 80 new pages of more stuff from this what are you gonna do the life of an addict anyways yeah that's the story interesting that you mention him so for those who who hung out in the area for their learning probably you knowah right that street that goes down um from like St area down into um but also the book which is Incredible Book in English written by raban cobri at the beginning of the book he has some um talks a little bit about it seems like the or is very connected to him he was like from the founders or original um yeah yeah yeah yeah that as a matter of fact I think the first time I quote I saw something was reading a as a he said over something I think I think that's how first heard ofan and then as once you start withit and then back to that's how it is so I didn't know that he talks better in the book okay very interesting yeah no I don't if he mentions much about him but that's where you okay thank you very much looking forward to the next one once again anybody wants to be in touch with myself .org or Rabbi br elazab br gmail.com questions comments suggestions criticisms all welcome with a smile