The Chazon Ish using New Reshonim Published from Manuscripts

[Music] foreign [Music] welcome back Rabbi Dr Eleazar brat it's a pleasure to be back with you and we are back to our series on Modern kanyevsky zatzal we already did this season six episodes discussing manuscripts and the connection to rub Heim was different manuscripts that Heim used to use and had these manuscripts evolved throughout the generation we've come to a point now which is the big discussion in the current or modern day world on using manuscripts so that is going to be today's topic I think Rabbi brought plans on doing two episodes on this and once again we would like to thank our sponsor for the kanyevsky episodes this whole season two has been dedicated anonymously by a close friend of Rabbi Dr brattach David or the Torah and all the new knowledge that people get from these episodes should be a Eloy for shama um something interesting people constantly ask you what do you have going on behind you what are those piles of books and books and more books and they get a tiny tiny Glimpse tiny window into the collection that you have and you could talk about another time the addiction that you have to collect in Spartan and that's for another session but perhaps today maybe at the end of the episode you'd like turn around pull one book out and just like go through one book no we gotta start with start somewhere pull out a book and tell the audience you know open a book and tell them what this book is what it's about why you have it you think it's something that perhaps is an idea we'll try maybe we'll we'll randomly pull out uh wrong we'll do a guy brought us in for some fun today okay so everyone stay tuned until the end then the episode we brought promises probably never to pull out a book and talk about it let's not forget so what are we talking about today so we're going to talk about the up till now we discussed the shita of um to sum up what we did and what we will now do is as follows until now I claimed there's two approaches approach number one we're going to call it to make it life simple the mission of Brewers shita which is to use new discoveries and there was another sheeta which we're going to call it not to use the new discoveries of the new regime that's to make life simple in a sentence so the next few episodes up till now we um I episode um in the first six episodes of this season I outlined in Broad Strokes some of the history of the publishing and usage of the usage of new manuscripts I was able to show pretty much that everyone used them with no issues not just the mission Brewer and especially what's important for us as rickevsky appears from all his writings to collect the mission Brewer he Embraces everything new madrasium discoveries we shine discoveries and to the extent that he even worked on editing some of these manuscripts for print which we spoke about now before we begin um I just found Amish the past few days a sheet a piece of information relating to this from him Zimmerman um who also talks about the usage of manuscripts and he says I found it very interesting I'm not going to read the whole passage it's uh to over two pages but he says like this when a new manuscript of a safer of evolution is discovered a new universe of Terror comes into being then he refers to another book of his and he says basically as much as revealed to a generation so much so that much has to be revealed today he says although no theoretical concepts of the science of developed many technological discoveries are developed every day so entire for the last 50 years they were discovered many manuscripts their Discovery is parallel and proportional to Modern technological discoveries in physical world this is the real reason why so many manuscripts were discovered and restored in this generation never was there a period in history where so many manuscripts were found and published in the total world as narrow time he says there's no guy named brisker or others that to some Toyota man had to flow in this generation proportionally to the meager amount of so what what do we do he Hashem is made it and he elaborates on this the new discoveries of manuscripts so this is I found to be a very interesting take and he is saying this to understand this he dies in the 90s um I think it was in the nine in the 1990s so if you're taking that into account in recent years it's been a bigger explosion than when he went from his time of new manuscripts okay maybe tell the audience who he is he can't just leave us hanging that way ah okay so I'm definitely um is a person that's worthy very worthy of having a few episodes to discuss him but he was famous for being roshishiva and Skokie for a while eventually in the 1970s he made Aliyah he was considered by in all standards who is a nephew and a Talman of rubber very very into the tire of Israel but he also was very into the Khazana um he was very mathematically gifted and for example in the famous Dateline Shyla he wrote a massive 500 page work all aspects of it demonstrating his yeah that not only in londis and in learning and but an understanding of the Sciences he was a very unique out of the box cuddle a very big deep thinker he wrote A Lot in Hebrew and in English I think a lot of his articles actually appeared in the Jewish press um at some for for a while but I that was before my time and some of them were collected in various books one of the books I just read from is called Terror in existence and he has another book called Tyran reason and there's other books in English and other um other lumdishvaram of his of all types they're all pretty hard to find these days but anyway he was a unique um tremendous that died in I believe it was 1995. okay fine so now you've given us the information about what you've done we're ready to get the khazana's cheetah but everyone talks about it manuscripts what he holds perhaps you could show us some sourced information whether it's books and storm that everyone knows about some articles I think that's what we are all waiting to hear okay so first like this the first question is really to step back a drop and it is to ask iski which I'm which I'm claiming which is pretty obviously is using these new manuscripts and everything so is this unique in the basement that has an issue to embrace it or there are other people in the basement that embrace the new discoveries the answer is and the first season I spoke a few times I mentioned that the rakhan kanesevsky was influenced by four different great people one of them was his father who not only did he have a tremendous impact on him they learned called tarakula literally together so when you look about the stipler you you find that number one we spoke about already that the requsky worked on the publishing it for manuscript who got him the job was the stipler very unlikely to say that the stipler will be against publishing new manuscripts and getting the job if he was against it now stipler like many other dailym of his letter the three volumes of his letters called krina the igrisa and in the year we find the Marshall a beautiful askama on the discovery of Urbana Hills Parish on this free that's one Discovery and now it's very unlikely that he would give a beautiful ass comma if he didn't believe in these new discoveries that there's some benefit of having these manuscripts in the same volume that we find another you know there was a someone in England or of Halpern published a some new material of tysus Nadar the stapler gives a beautiful asukama um worthy of reading all his shyness but explaining how that Hashem is bark makes it that um that certain certain materials come to light at certain periods of time and our generation was like to be to be guile these different regime and we muscadel he says he mentions even that there are plenty still in manuscript but anyway he writes very very um enthusiastic about these materials from these new manuscripts relating to tices and another ascama one other one is to mention is the tysis rush someone bought hematitis Rush on a different sector and the stipler also gave a very nice comma but here just a cute thing was he said a lot of times how do we know that it's a Texas rush so he says my son replying kanyevsky told me that the Sharon brings down a piece from this Isis Rush from this manuscript this was on so so here we have a way how it's authenticated and was authenticated by his great sonjevsky's Bukis not only in reshine him and in hazals here we see him being Bucky in Akron in the sharamel okay anyway the point what's interesting is is that the crying for some reason they sent her out the names and the names of the Swarm and a lot of these letters I don't know why but that's the um we so we see it but bottom one we see stipler seems to be somewhat Pro using new manuscripts maybe not but using them next another person which we also spoke a little bit about in season one was someone who was very close with the kazanus and Kalman Kahana was Isaac very much in his run not only in myself but publishing new works a manuscripts and different materials relating to helping new discoveries and a large part of his he ended up establishing a Mahone and what's significant is this Mahone was taken over eventually by rabafrati talmum yashif everything was done with the under the hashikaka so to speak of rebellious they learned intense intense but also focus on publishing materials for manuscripts it's so much many works of that have come out has been coming through them and just to mention the Marshall the cafter effect they did a beautiful job based on manuscripts so here we see again people that are affiliated I would say or extending from the basement so it's funny the steepler these are people that that kazanesh meant a lot even though the khazash meant a lot to most people but these are swore everything by him it's strange that they would go against him so blatantly okay that's the that's so that's the background of I'm just trying to make it dramatic okay now but the question is really what does the kaizenich hold so the hazenish in general was beyond prolific and he was prolific which is not the case of many dailym even in his lifetime he's born in the 1870 1878 and he dies in 1953. he first publishes his first work has an ish in 1911. that's well known he doesn't write his name on it but he already published materials in some newspapers beforehand as early as I think 1901. so he wrote a lot we know he wrote literally on called tarakula you go into a shoe Library where some many people have their houses it's mind-boggling how much he wrote to make a rashima a proper listing of bibliographical of all his materials that he wrote is very hard already 10 years after he was Nifty or kalamu Kahana we just mentioned has a beautiful listing and we read it it's mind-boggling how much he published at that period by that period of time running so now we have to keep that in mind he wrote a lot so to find his sheeta in something that could be spread out in a lot of different places is a job a hard job number two is they're constantly finding new material just as an example in the past few years five massive volumes of materials of his has come out from manuscripts um and more more and more keeps on coming out um I always joke that one of the building that's writing from the graves besides the Wikipedia and some Cipher is Hasan just yesterday I saw going up an auction uh a huge selection of 50 materials of the khazanesh yes if you want someone to buy for me I will accept it of different product of relating to the haznish that was seems to have been on his table on the days that he right before he died I have no idea where they had it where they got it from it sounds very interesting I did not have a chance to look at the full description of it but sounds crazy stable good that's a good question I don't know after I read this read carefully these items maybe we'll be able to have a question what's uh what's what anyway the point is the kazanesh wrote a lot now besides the writing a lot and Publishing it he also wrote letters that were given to special to regular people he also spoke to many people yeah tell me them and he had people that came into him because either so in order to get such a person's she thought clear in a manner that could come up many times it's not easy okay now in general in order to understand the sheet of the Khazana so to speak for this you have to check up all the quotes you have to see firsthand if you could the different quotes that he says now the problem is that some of them were censored and you don't know the context of the letters who he's writing it and what's he writing it about why is he saying what he's saying which makes it harder but it makes it even harder is that sometimes new materials come to light about a particular piece of information and then sheds light on up till now you thought a certain way and then a new sentence comes to light they reprint the letter they add we have the manuscript we're adding one more line that line could be a key to understanding much more and this happens a lot with the kazanish in and even in this topic one of the letters that that's not as well known is a discussion with he had was a letter that vesla writes about talking to the president about it and then just recently a few months ago the letter came out again but this time they added a few more lines and that few those few lines as I'm going to show in the next episode helps us understand much more with what the Khazana meant anyway these are just some of the points now so when a lot of the quotes of the khazanush relating to this topic and others is found in the Hebrews well-known Hebrew very famous three volumes um now the problem is they when they quote a lot of these letters a lot of these letters and they have different pieces they don't tell you who it's going on who it was written to when it was written and sometimes they take out sentences all of a sudden there'll be a dot dot dot and you don't know what's going on um Rabbi teager who we've quoted a few times mentions in his work called conscious Derek ish incredible small work on the hazanesh um he shows how certain True Value was cut up over six times put into six different places but you don't know that when you're reading each one of the letters until you actually see the whole letter published and there's a bunch of examples we're not going to go into that now if you open up the kovitz so the first volume which literally came out within a year or two after his Nifty it stresses um that there's significant it has initials letters he was um it helped and he did so much it helped it will help people all different types of things people used to ask him all different pieces of information all different questions and so we have these letters now the letters did not necessarily saw all the manuscripts of the letters some so but they publish it now the SEC in the second in the volume three which comes out also in the 50s pretty much right within a year of a few years less than five years after the Khazana it says work okay now Robin zilber one of your daily Brack a famous author of juvas aznid Brew who had us supposed to have a a connection with the khazanesh he writes in a few different letters he says I'm only talking about this volume specifically the the the kind of tigers that has and then she says it's not a safer it's not because and he says used to say don't rely on things that I said um that people that say from my name balpet even letters it's considered about them so he said he's saying that pretty much we don't know the background of the particular letter so beware and as I said not all letters are taken from manuscripts some of these letters are from conversations and they don't even tell you where those conversations are from okay my grandfather or Barry Lieb Spitz had a um in a piece that he wrote In The Journal called hamar um in the 80s so the question that he was dealing with related to a specific letter of the Khazana she goes so far as to say that if you look carefully he couldn't believe that Hazard said what he said in that letter so he said that the letter is not about samho it does not sound like he said because it came out after he dies they got tons of materials from all over the world some of the stuff that wasn't labeled but they published it and it could be they didn't go through everything carefully enough to verify every single thing that a thing came from the khazanesh and he and he brings even from a red Vaz such an issue that you can't rely on truvis that came in afterwards okay whatever the the um my point is that if you look very carefully in gen this is a general issue with most plenty of other that when you find their works you have to be very careful to see the sources and to know what the Makara is who's saying it Etc now just to just to talk about this a little just a drop long and then we're going to get to the meat and potatoes as they say Professor yaakov Spiegel who I've quoted numerous times in the past he has a book called A mutin batala say for every it's five volumes and one of the volumes he deals with this concept in general terms with the map specifically about the Khazana but many times we find we shine him could write two different farm and it could be steers between the two Farms I mean everyone knows random let's say this Theory some random then we're busy answering it but it's come let's say the rush if you have a stereo between the Russians of succumb to Russian truvis what do you do so let's say you have a khazanish says one thing and then you have in the igoris that's a written egress and we know it's from him is it a it's a stereo possibly so what do you do um and there's all types of column Generations gave all different types of column which rep this professor Spiegel outlines will us there's another issue not necessarily everything to do said God the one printed especially um there's a there's a question letters letters a lot of times did not want printed they were meant mamish for one-on-one private conversation as if it was a controversy a few years back Professor Mark Shapiro published some many interesting letters that that the Swedish had with with um with Professor Atlas very very interesting things and then people were very upset these were private letters they were not necessarily supposed to be published so Spiegel brings this down also and this caused the whole discussion in the Toro Mata Journal back and forth about it okay so you can't just mention Professor Atlas and like run by without mentioning who he is okay so the answer is that he was a person that learned in slobatka Yeshiva eventually becomes a professor it seems he becomes affiliated with reform but he still loved learning and he had a close close relationship with the three of the age they had many different letters back and forth but he also put out interestingly enough to write a martial in Lakewood there was at least one edition of arriving all crossed out fear or whatever something like that anyway so they had very interesting letters back and forth which were published in the Toro model journal and of course some type of Scandal if it would have been the times the internet I'm sure have been much more and the editor at the time um had to defend why he did it whatever okay so anyway the point is foreign but maybe he didn't want him to get out okay anyway there's all types of these type of conversations Spiegel deals with it in his work and this plays out even more and we will get to some aspects of it in a later episode with what's happened is is that there's a whole genre of news Farm which they map out all the unhuggers that they people see that they watch godolly doing and God will be there's a crazy amount to these types of storms coming out and is of plenty of more recent years like this but it's already found let's say that my real my real was a talometer than my real watch to my real carefully and he would record what he saw and it became one of the main sources for the Ramos so obviously certain times these Works have very important impact anyway um with the kazanesh a lot of times it could be a sack and they and you'll check into it and then you'll see what the next person will say it's just it's not true he didn't mean it I just want to give I could give many different examples for this I'm not going to Spiegel in his latest book called every as a whole has three different places where he talks all about the khaznish with these aspects quoting different theorists in the stories and in the different things I'm just going to mention two very very brief ones and it gives you the idea one was that someone said something about a certain piece of the beer hagra a famous pieces of beer Agra and hold on just give me a second um okay I think it was about the Khazana who said something about wearing yamakas and the person said what do you mean there's a beer Agra that says that wearing yamako is said that he saw the gra in a dream and the girl told them that he was Kaiser so the assistant did not believe that the grok he said this is not the way spoke he wouldn't have told them even if the girl did come whatever okay and obviously there's a type of story today I'm sure you can make a whole this is the way he would talk is anyway Ricky does believe it doesn't Okay and then he brings that interesting enough that about something else that Heim grinemann said that has um said that he heard from the haznish that tegraw came to him a few times in dreams to talk to him and learning um and other issues so here you have on one handski saying okay so maybe it could be about this piece that that's what father saying he's Heiser and he's gonna come to the transition maybe that whatever anyway this is a story and just one other story just to say for the sake of a story seems that in the in the 19th in the late 1940s there was an issue there was not a lot of food in Earth Israel so some people allow powdered milk others answered it so two Bachman from Heaven came to the Khazana to ask him about using this so one asked them and told them no way you can't eat it another one said you could it's just okay to come back to yeshiva's Cavern the stereo two guys walked in each one got a different sack what the president say so someone from the cavern went back to Kazan what's going on he says what do you mean I said both both were saying the truth one and he starts smiling he says like this one guy looked like a gibber he's a strong bucker he asked me I said no you can't because it's not going to hurt him he doesn't have food it was in a time there wasn't a lot of food so he said you dumb people the other guy he was a skinny little wimpy guy so him I told him he could be Mako so you see that a Taylor it was a tailored sack he understood the situation but it wasn't meant to become the sack for cloudy thrill at the time this is obviously before the internet etc etc anyway so the point is that we one has to be very careful this is general for the hassanesh and it's also general for Kain kaneski which we will get to Amir tashem in a special episode dealing with these type of things now to our main as a call to medium potatoes of our story what's the story what's going on here what does it has an ish what's going on so the for me also is that um says a line and he says that people already in The Times They say things whatever I wrote it a lot whatever I wrote are you going to find theorists you're not going to find theorists in what I wrote the hainu in things that we know for certain that the haznus wrote there's not going to be steers and then I come across this is where kamakana says then I come across in the conscious choice but you're going to get to momentarily the haznish writes a fascinating line and this I think plays out by the kazilian's writings very important thing people read things like reading a letter quickly because you have to be made there's their opposite people like to be quick some people have fast faces and sometimes you'll find even that they read swarm very fast they're not being makshiv what they're reading carefully and you have to read carefully especially topics that are very amok now with that with those introductions the Khazana he wrote he wrote on purpose very hard to understand you have to be madaic in everything he says every tag should be tag means something by him again I'm not saying like as a reason but it means a lot okay now so what's the sheet that they say over so number one is like this already a year after he dies the 3dation a literature of Herzog writes that he found something in a chuus that was found in the kairag Niza and he was all happy with it but he says he writes this letter but they says that's what they say over so it already got to the street the issue was not an artistro the sheet of the khazanesh and as I said the letters were not yet published it was published a year or two later with destler has there's two letters published in that he had conversations with the kazanesh also some type of thing that you can't rely on new manuscripts okay and Amit Hashem we will get to explain more the letters and talk more about the letters of Odessa next episode okay there's a year there was a great a tremendous Talent of Rosenthal who was also a talmud by the hazanesh who's a tremendous guy the way I heard of him was because when I was in the mirror I learned by um one of the Lesser known magidi Sherman in the mirror at the time was her mayor schmolevel it's the youngest son of a heims his father-in-law was this rebiak of Rosenthal Rosenthal was a famous coin his father was who's also going and he wrote 15 volumes on rambam so he writes he he came across a piece of the Ravid that was printed for the first time manuscript on the side of the Shasta Vilma he went and he thought it could answer up a whole thing so he comes into Israel he says You must know my shita not to rely on manuscripts and um okay so here we have a talmud testifying about Israel about manuscripts okay so the question is what does he hold so so far it seems like he holds not to rely on it now what I'm going to show now the next bunch of pieces of information are going to be proof study holds that you could rely on manuscripts at times number one we I already mentioned the khazana's first work comes out in 1911. already this work it deals with a lot of archiving topics and he quotes one of the works they quotes many many times with great great covet is the words of the mishna Brewer and we know there's a letter of the Khazana and the Khazana talks about the mission in other places with unbelievable covets saying he's like delicious and we know he argues on the mission Brew many times and he talks about the missionary dozens and dozens of times hundreds and hundreds of times but yet anyone who knows you learn Mr Brew for a few minutes you come across that the missionary is relying on reshining you would think that somewhere one of the times should say by the way he we don't relying him he never once mentions it and he's been and he's quoting him from 1911 and onwards and he knew Mr Brewer Khan's car he uses it for everything he went through Clarion points out his issues all the time so to me this is already something it's a rare of some sort again I'm sure people could argue that's a point but now let's go into the Excel music take a deep dive is known he took he um different pulmasim and different controversies in Aloha he took part of bakayov one of the most famous controversies that took place in his lifetime was the Dateline Shyla which is worthy of a episode or two not from from me but basically yeshivas mere and others were stuck in Shanghai in the 1940s and the question was what which what to do based on the Dateline child which days to observe Young kippa so big Tomo and dailymot was involved and not much what to do and asking differently there were meetings okay so at the time who gets involved another God who gets involved with tukushinski people who are familiar with the sugya know that a lot of the materials come a lot of the discussion revolves around three rishinam it was besides the balamur and the kosari which is its own discussion how relying on the kurs it's his own discussion which we mentioned a little bit in the episode we spoke about the kosari but number one there's a peace arrived in the curse of sham of the Ravid which was printed in the 1930s from manuscript in a journal called School and this plays a role in the conversation of the khazanesh and of takushinski another Hebrew a talmud of the rush called yes which was printed in the 1770s and another Heber from above and also an early Vision very involved in astrology astronomy but there was pretty from the 1850s these three swarm are very crucial in the sugya of the datelines if one opens up author the work known as and his work on the datelines um oh I don't have it in front of me countries and he publishes literally right after the 1941 controversy and if you look a martial in the newspapers of the time in El in 1941 rebseven writes an article where he gives the background what's the machikas what he gives the audience in the hot sofa paper what's the bahoikas about and he really puts it down in reservan's style giving you the background when this when was the first time the child was discussed and different materials about it and he says one of the main makayas in the sugar is this is so now it has an ish is not people mistakenly says didn't even care about these reciting him but he didn't even see them he was just quoting it because of takashinski uses them and he was coming to argue on him so he uses with toshinsky's quotes and he doesn't it's clear if you learn carefully the countries he checked up the Swarm and he uses them he doesn't dismiss them he could have said a line which he does in other controversies and say don't bother don't bring me rise from new manuscripts he's handling the whole in the country so you can show his the whole time he's handling as if the regular cheetahs in the sugyo that one has to deal with of these three what I call new manuscripts one was mamish printed less than 10 years before and the other two were printed in past hundred a few hundred years and they were napped from way way there so here we see him using them and he doesn't say boo about the problem another polus that also took place inert Israel a little later was a police known as the poem well which is became a sharp machikistan so and the stapler got involved with this also writing about it this also became a very Hot Topic in the course of this okay um in the course of this discussion we find that it was brought to the intention of the of the khazanesh that is a chuva of the name so says the Khazana that I saw a true versus which we spoke all about the Hebrews even though I hold you can't rely I'm a car nearing had the volume it's real it sounds reliable you rely on it this piece was discovered already as early as 1802 I've not yet located who was the first person to use it but since then we have many sources that say whatever it says in these in this troops are going on the topic and the Hazel doesn't dismiss it he says no he brings you down the whole piece he has a hope shot and understand that he's arguing with other people I didn't say but the point is he's not saying oh it doesn't make a difference he adds in a key line over here which we'll get back to but he's using it in this Pumas and the same page um there's a famous thing which we already mentioned the Miri Miri gets a bad slack they claim that the khazan ish there's even a again I mean type of thing he's sort of like Nan tamiri let's open up the Khazana says number one in the country of Europe which we're talking about right now on the same page says he says I didn't see it inside someone gave me a copy of what it says and this is what and it fits in and fine and doesn't dismiss it in another place and causation he says and he says you should be we should be match here even that government okay now I'm not telling you that you're gonna find a hundred quotes of the Miriam the safer he doesn't and that will get to why but the point is he's not dismissing it outright but now the story gets for goes further at some point in the 19 late 1940s I believe it is someone wants to print the Hebrew Shar hamayam of the rajbo for the first time for manuscript this person really has an issue in vinay Brack he comes into that has an ish he's printing its manuscript so he wants to know now obviously he's asking if you can put into a manuscript because he knows has some time something up with manuscripts he says like this even though the Khazana says but he says this lover bar the Sharma you look carefully at this you could tell it's the rajma print it no problem s in his book review under a pen name on the sharmaim says here we see not like people think with the kazanesh some people think from the conscious printing manuscripts what do you mean he's telling him here you could just it has to have an important piece of information which is we have to be vadai that it is now obviously that's that's a conversation that needs to be had fine so now I'm showing you from yet another source holds from the sharamayam he was okay with it now there's another work that relates to this conversation is that rev Maisha Lipschitz who is a tremendous librarian somewhere in in America so he talks about the Khazana and he says if you open up this Mission says his fouls the words embracing a new discovery the Richter that came out after after so too in another place I found in evanese okay another discussion we mentioned that we spoke about so I quoted then that that people said melter in a bunch discuss if everyone was relying on the quote of the ramban found the ran but the ramban was published in the ninth in the 1790s and then we see much much more on this and that would have changed that even perhaps the grow would have changed his mind so much so this relates to how to Lane um how to have the breaks increase so who also Embraces this ramban okay brings down okay so we see yet again that there are times that he's using these okay just two more kindness and then we'll come to the conclusion this Rift eager who I've quoted numerous times he brings that he found also other places he brings a place where the Khazana Springs down so that's another manuscript published for the first time so again we have uh maramakum which would show that the khazanish at least certain times is accepting and one last thing he brings us a case of in hokus there's a places which brings it down for I believe if someone does an extensive examination that hasn't she'll find a bunch more of these type of things no one has done it up till now but the point is like this at this point and this is how concluding episode number one it seems and this is how riftiger understands it also and others is like this that hazanesh is willing to accept when something is a new discovery if he is convinced that it's a real true therefore he held the martial of the conscious Ness Embraces a Miri fits into the sugya that did not get him nervous so now obviously I'm gonna leave on a cliffhanger what did and I brought a bunch of different proofs I think the proofs maybe you might say one in itself is not but I believe putting them all together something emerges obviously there are I have to admit now we'll give a sneak preview to that there are times he's against it when is that Amit Hashem I hope to be put in a proper perspective the next episode okay fascinating we are we have plenty to digest here on this episode looking forward to the next episode so a couple things you mentioned riftiger I had the opportunity to meet with tiger he was in America recently um and we discussed as we discussed with him in Heritage Israel that he will join us in the very near future to discuss his participation and editing of heim's forum if you haven't seen check out online Google YouTube If URI Tigger fascinating videos of him discussing foreign there's videos of coming to visit him you imagine coming to visit him taking out of taking his time after he visited his visit this review so he obviously had tremendous amounts of akarsity so there's even one video relating to this with the Chris he has a conversation and if you don't know the Sugi you can't tell the sugar but once you know this one video where history says yeah and he opens up the mission Brewer he learns the whole Suite with him inside about the Korea satira and the garage one of these videos incredible um now as promised people are always asking what do you have going on behind you they don't even know that what's behind you is like a tiny tiny drop of the mountainous Farm they have scattered around Earth's Israel and all your different masks different storage houses so turn around pull out a random safer and tell us what's going on okay so I'm going to pull out a safer it's it's higher up easier to get to and the significance of the safer is that right before I'm gonna show you the say for a second right before less than 24 hours before this past few is I get an email that this safer came out and this is already causing me problems I live in ramapi chemist there's no way in the world this is getting to your shalayim how am I going to have some casiantev some people they have some resultant with wine with meat and yes I do like cheesecake cheesecake but once I know that this safer is out it's over and it's going to be very depressing I automatically start making the necessary arrangements and luckily luckily it comes through and it comes to me it's cold EST it's called taldus Adam from removing my goalis it's a book that he wrote his first work which he wrote in let's check the year it says in 1912 it came out in Lemberg his first work and he wrote over 50 works on the Marsha incredible incredible work it's published by I have a Shalom now what's the significance of this work is number one is it was very rare very hard to find and also they have the nephew of my goals is alive is in his 80s is working together with them published to published a lot of different materials new materials and in the copy of removing my goal is his own addition of this Talus Adam he had numerous hundreds of isafas so they put it all in with other materials and they literally it's a beautiful beautiful Edition worth every penny also they have a bunch of letters that he had with different that wrote to him after he sent him the safer and this is he wrote this when he was in his low 20s a beautiful beautiful safer and it was beautifully done high quality high quality paper worth your money and this helped me have a proper Simplicity if it came and I was able to have eaten beautiful okay so obviously you could do 10 episodes on a movie Margolis in 30 seconds who he was around when he was born and what did he do this is very tough let's say 1900 he's um 18 late 1880s I believe it is that he's born because this is I said this is when he's 21 or 22. he dies in the 70s is but he doesn't have children he's married twice in Lemberg he was a microspharm he wrote tons of farm articles newspapers Pub and he was also a Publisher's Farm but he also published his owns Farm but he was obviously no ordinary person lemashulli come starts Israel he makes Alia in the 30s goes to visit with cook with cook makes a brachan singer Adam gado when he sees him if Cook was in correspondence with him or if Cook has a scammer which could only be found in certain editions of his on his work on the Zaya other things with cook was familiar with him and liked him found can be found in an eyewitness account or someone that was there at the time anyway he ends up putting out many Morse fireman artists throughout walls Israel he works for Mysore of cook he also was the chief librarian in the Tel Aviv in Tel Aviv he built a major Farm library for that period of time it's still it's actually still exists today so he was but he was now he's a hasida shiid from Lemberg galaxiana but he also has zionistic leanings and he had to do with let's mushroom cook but he had to do with all types of people and him was a legendary in all of Taira including Kabbalah authored 50 60s firearm easily and since this is a prime episode you mentioned his connection to Abrahim very briefly if you wanna mention oh yes so even in this new edition he mentions that was a loved him there's a few times I think I quoted him in season one even hankevsky Madam knew him had great respect for him and so too had great respect for him I do recall enough there's even a peace that he says or something that he heard from the kazanesh um but they both haznish and the style um liked him a lot this nephew was there at least one of the conversations he had conversation with about removing my goals he brings it in this new introduction in this work and so he liked it and oh and to end hancy quotes remove my goals cassador in La Marshall his work on the ram let me quotes his work on desire other places he quotes many times yes and you'll see that certain things are are blacked out or ripped out because he gives a he dates the the safer to the to the Medina so these type of terrible days that he has anyway all in all um that he had even though he didn't have children was having a sahana from his farm so now this new printing I recommend here you go excellent wonderful thank you very much looking forward to the next episode thank you once again this episode was sponsored if you're still listening in memory of David all of season two questions comments suggestions dedication opportunities please reach out to myself at schwadeem ou.org or Rabbi brought elegazabrut gmail.com [Music]