Techum Shabbos (Part IV) Intra city Techum discussion

[Music] let's discuss now interesting shiloh comes up in trom shabbas it's been established that if you have a city that's a silica caches it's shaped like a rainbow or like a hess and the distance between the two russian caches two ends of the rainbow is more than four thousand almost more than seven thousand eighty feet so then it's viewed as if it's two separate cities as somebody who walks out from this one big rainbow shaped city into the empty area in the middle right away starts as two thousand amish of trim shabbos he's not entitled to say that we have to square off the city and the whole thing is filled up with houses and courtyards about magazines rather his two thousand armies for tom shabas begin right away when he leaves the city now an interesting case is what if you have a city that's shaped like a bagel or like a doughnut with a hole in the middle or we would say los angeles in hebrew it's shaped like a mem stumo like an enderman so it's a box as empty area in the middle central park around the middle of manhattan you have empty area right in the middle of your city so what happens if somebody leaves the city but instead of walking to the outside gravity starts walking towards the inside towards the empty area on the inside so what happens now do we say that he begins his two thousand armies of trump shabbos or do we say that this is a self-contained area within this city closed up within the city and there's no alarms of shabbos the limitations of truman that one is only a lot of walk 2000 amazon shabbos when he leaves the city is if you're leaving the city going to the outside north south east or west but if you're going to the inside this is all self-contained this is all in the middle and there's no limitations of shabbos over here now this shiloh only presents itself if the empty area in the middle is four thousand arms by four thousand amish however if the md air in the middle would be for argument's sake four thousand amis by three thousand almost or something like that so then it's partial it's clear everyone would agree that it's all considered as one and the reason is because the reason why a caches that's more than four thousand almost wide is considered like two separate cities is because it's near yours you have something someone starting from one end another person starting from the other end they will not meet each other so the two cities you know it's really one it's viewed separately it's viewed as two separate cities however if it's four thousand one way in this donut hall shaped city and three thousand the other way so there are ways you can meet you can start from top and bottom and you can meet each other so since there are ways that people could come out from different ends of the city different sides of the city actually and meet each other therefore it's all considered one and this is agreed upon by everyone the question only arises if the distance between one side and the other is more than four thousand dollars more than seven thousand eighty feet both east west and north south then do we say that when you walk into the middle of the city so now you start your two thousand dollars and you have limitations when you hit two thousand dollars you gotta stop or do we say that's all considered one and trimshab is only on the outside this is actually a major sachrenin from approximately two hundred years ago antibiotics to play skip nowadays if someone has this shiloh they should ask their role it should ask a competent player to find out what to do it's a good shiloh