Tattoos & Grasshoppers: Rav Chaim's Seforim Explored (Part 4)

[Music] welcome back rabbi dr eliezer broth what a pleasure to meet with you and speak with you again we're after pesach and as promised we're going to continue discussing the safari the legacy specifically of this farm of rokhan kanyevsky and we've gotten tremendous feedback both personally and in writing you know when someone writes the following of jaimsky's pharma wonderful i must admit that the topic didn't interest me at first but after listening for a few minutes you truly brought out some incitement like this which i i wholeheartedly agree someone else wrote i've just finished part three and thoroughly enjoyed it keep up with all the digressions they helped to give a wider and richer view of i'm hoping that there will be many more in this series and this is the most interesting um people feel this way it is no question that you have found the greatest way to be masked and give tribute to your so you're doing something unique and different how are you today hashem okay so it's nice to have you back i know you're a man of not many words so also you know we try to cram everything into a few minutes people don't like it but let's spend some time together we've spoken up until now about refrains safer on the rambam about the maharashtra the akash rush let's transition now to summer rochem's farm on today specifically we want to talk about two interesting sparring one on tattoos and one on the grasshoppers everybody has heard about the story with the grasshopper maybe there's something else you can bring to the table something something different maybe a good place to start did him have any masaira or ashita or a mahalak that might be a good place if you have anything to speak on that topic also so the answer to that question i um which is a great way to introduce the the next few farm that we'll discuss which will hopefully be more the more aloha farmer is like this the um already the first in the first one of these presentations i mentioned that the way i see it through kanewski had a tremendous influence he was influenced by four different um people he's been by many people too and he became his own person but he was influenced by different things he got he took from these one was the villain was the hazarish another was his father and the fourth was the mishna brewer now when you um many of his farm that he wrote we know you we know he wrote many different song but they and he wrote some are others he wrote other halacha works that are some are less known some are more known for different reasons you mentioned that it's worth pointing out we're about to embark on and we're actually learning say this right now derek is a classic you know if anyone is using the art school missionaries or any perish that is mentioned all the time all the time so hopefully we'll get to that right but that that we're not going to deal with today because the dark humour is such a unique work it needs its own um thing but to get to lead up to it to discuss the less the lesser known works in the halaqariewski to get to the more famous ones along the way the shaina lachrys and the now but but in general we see that was very into this of of of learning learning now even though he's very into learning he spells that all over the place it's i mean say don't rely on i'm learning this safe i'm learning this topic and it'll say um it's uh muscle to introduction but bottom line is that he was very involved with learning all so the question is where did where did this come from um so the answer is i i believe is that as i mentioned these these different people that had a tremendous influence on him we find by them this by them this um important aspect of learning torah without with a with a focus of learning alibaba well to start with like this the famous greatest talmud of the village wrote numerous hagdammus to the various works of the villeneuve that was published he wrote different introductions to the work and in each one's introductions he talks about his rebbe and each one is fascinating and very kedai to um go through and you can learn a lot about the village by reading through these introductions um recently a few few weeks ago the um volume was collected all these introductions not only of the other of the children ligura and other such materials and put into the volume called the darus leo and it's available through meister of cook um now in this in one of the introductions the introduction to beer allah which is printed in the early one of the first works of the printed says that one of the main kudus of the vilna garden was a and that's how you've been kind of basically learning with it's not just to learn taira which is beyond important especially for the martial but it's also to learn to know what to do and this is rokheim alejandra saying that this is what the village who um not the scope of of this presentation but was extremely mushbad and was involved with the basement and dying in vilna at the time and was close with the also in both of his introductions that he wrote on the adam emphasizes that one of the reasons why he was writing this work is that halacha mice have fell by the wayside and it needs to be it means even if one learns gemara the whole day but if you don't learn you're not being making certain aspects of torah and and um so in the introduction of his first introduction which is in it's not printed in all the all the editions of adam and in the second introduction he called like which both introductions are very to go through um he emphasizes this the kuda of learning um let me just see if there's a quote here hold on and then that's in one of the introductions and then in the other introduction he says um now it was so important so fundamental on the shower blot of the first edition where he talks about different aspects of the safer also emphasizes this same point um he says uh let me see if i can find the russian here he said this and this and this shire is not found in all the in all in many of the later editions he says and therefore you you'll be able to be kindest so to speak with his safe okay now moving further along a safer a fascinating fascinating saver called manuka kadusa which is possibly talmud khan belgium but definitely also influenced from the villeneuve camp which is a safer um a lot about mahalimud it was written he was writing this for how to to learn with bar mitzvah for his own child and others he was a mulamid and this safer he also talks about the great importance of learning halacha and specifically he starts emphasizing learning even if let's say you're balabas focusing more on starting with but why because it's so important um to know it comes up daily okay moving further along obviously the mission of um which i also said was a tremendous impact on on kanyevsky which will get to amir hashem but he in his famous agama to the mishna bureau also um also emphasizes this nakuda that part it's not only about learning it's also icarly and then he says neglected and and et cetera et cetera you dwarf you do him and it's a very delight to learn the introduction who and now sorry before you get to the mission brings up when he talks about his which is a work specifically on the mishna brewer anyway the khazanesh who his uncle his rabbi also had tremendous impact on him in the moon he has different pieces of he has very um interesting lines that are the question always is who he's referring to but you could see that he's very upset that the people were learning and their being seen that you have to learn ideas and he has this in pages and pay a few different um pieces with hasanesh was very concerned and safer is a safer with learning he doesn't spell that out but that's the gang of the the the theme throughout when this stopped and yeshiva exactly and that the yeshiva world uh more is more learning focus alumnus and whatever this is beyond the scope of our session today uh morgan breuer's book on the yeshiva talks about it but the um the the introduction of to understand where kankness is coming from when he also many of his works are focused on even though he says it's not la maison okay very interesting introduction so the tooth forum we mentioned that the outside you want to speak about today is about tattoos and about grasshoppers so let's start with the safer on tattoos what's it called how big is it safer what does it say inside the safer i'm sure you have some interesting anecdotes to add about how the saver came about yeah okay so so first of all the um the safer is approximately a hot it's um it's approximately 110 pages it's called countris hashem and he writes in the beginning um he as a date when it was completed which is in jurges 1976. okay now as i've mentioned already in the past where franklinski is very macbook i think it was mark but he writes why he wrote the different sperm that he did so here in the beginning of this safer he emphasizes that yet one has to know kala tarakula and all of tyra relates with each other and he says that it's even for today and um in yara daya simon kofpay there's not a lot of material about it and there's a lot to add and a lot to collect so basically he decided to go ahead and to collect all the material um and put it out as a safer now he broke it down into 21 semanim it's it's in the form of a type at this it seems that um in the dark when he was working on drums so he formed what's famous it's it's a very similar look of like the mishna brewer at this point he did not do that i don't know why what was behind it but this is simply a simmon he'll talk about a topic and then at the end of each semen he has a conclusion simmons what comes out from this cement and he sums it up in a few lines very in very uh orderly manner now of course he goes through everything bahako bako as they say on the topic starting from the moving on tarashi all the reshainam mantipsukim somehow get in here madrashim yushalni's pavli's and everything literally everything comes in here and he breaks it down very very muslim what it is um um that's um if it's um what type it's via um doing he has a chapter if you have to write letters all different things about this topic and as i said it's broken down into twenty one um sections so you'll say okay so kind of he picked found the topic and as i mentioned already in some of the other form he was looking for this concept of mace mitzvah neglected here and he doesn't throw that in for this particular safer you'll say okay but what does it have to do with anything okay we have people in the world of kirov they are asked these questions about tattoos a lot but even if you're not in the world of kirov is the areas of tattoos nager so interestingly enough for such a type of question we consult the great um with jd blood rabbi j david blight in one of his most maybe it's even his latest volume contemporary logic problems so he has an article that originally appeared as a an article in the i think in the journal tradition and it's called medical and cosmetic tattooing so first interestingly enough he has a quote from a non-jewish source in 1953 describing that in in 1953 it seemed to be unheard of unusual to have um tattoos but it seems it changed as anyone walking around on the streets all over cyanide israel sign america you could see this offer there's a famous um there's a famous thing about tattoos and this i i do not know i did not look into the earlier sources of it but if someone has a tattoo he might not be able to be buried in a vasa virus okay it could be could be not i don't know interestingly enough and this rabbi black brings that already right away in the beginning of this piece that the minh who talks about about tattoos he says he never saw a person with tattoos but obviously today it's very common now once rabbi blackwell black have a piece about it and this many rabbunum that involved the medical field no this is there's medical from in the medical field this is very negate what's in a gear for for example in radiation oncology they do some type of form of for targeting as rubber bike right targeting locally localization to assure beam alignment so you have to make sure it's exact so they have they use tattooing and and now so you'll say okay great so rabbi has throughout this he has this is in his kedarka kaidish an amazing chapter with incredible research and throughout the state this this chapter who's quoted very often this is the aleph base in the sunya very very thorough kedarka the kaidish um as i said he breaks it down super organized and he has all the materials about it and concludes he ever mentions this thing i don't know if he knew if it could in 1976 i don't know if they had it so much more more related but um at the end of the safer he even has a kitser dining okay now as i said he breaks it down to all different fields so i just want to focus on one just to mention one um thing about this that he breaks it down into he talks about there's a question um he talks about la marshall as i said in one of the previous presentations i believe he had some influence from the min here he also called and what's one of the things i mentioned already earlier is that was famous for having the he created what's called the new mushbach and he broke down uh all the phaneria et cetera now so here too frankieski has a question a chapter devoted to writing uh um tattoos on a buster of a harris very interesting now for evan um he talks about a few times everyone a lot of people are very very a lot of people very well aware with haman and mordechai was his evidence and there was a star written on him and he he asked me a few times in this in the safer mcclell somehow gets back to talking about those madrashim about it the kite is throwing in the middle of nowhere this this aspect but he then has a in the seminar he talks about and what about writing a tattoo on adne hasada vassarini amaze so obviously this is um this gets one's attention okay so and raphael here so after talking about these this list he says that's about to explain and what's a serene so it seems that just like i said that uh the killer was fascinated with the androidness the thumptomus and bringing it in he had this fascination with anderson and he walked and he so much so that he wanted to even it's brought down a few different places he was even gonna write a safer bet on there so that he talks about it in a few different um swarm of his and obviously the question is what in the world is now he never ended up writing the safer about abner but someone two people already did heavily based on particularly this semen that i'm about to discuss and as mr young is learning hey talks about these now i'm about to i mean one more second rakhine kanyevsky gave us one of the countries him and he said and and and about um he says it's a uh it's a beautiful thing and then he says rakhinenski writes in a letter to this author who doesn't write his name what it is but when i was young i also wanted to write a safer on an assad and even had a name for it laden okay now so this safer also talks about the serenity now the answer is very simple actually it's not okay so when we learned so as missionary oldaf has a uh we have to throw it out there it's not only that it's for the missionary project is all mishna an incredible resource and climb these machines are being it could be i i forgot to check if it was just learned i just learned it uh mamas right now if you learn client paragraph so right away obviously you look at the bartender and he says and he says no one could get near it it kills if you get close to it and it will trap you it's very dangerous but the way he's in the way you look at this partner it sounds like he's something he knew about now we looking at um art scroll in english it says as follows a certain creature that has human-like characteristics it notes in the notes that they add it's an unusual animal unknown to us today whose face hands and legs resemble those of a human it's attached to the ground by a court from its navel and it draws its sustenance from the ground through the court if the court is cut it dies so it seems to be some type of plant that's alive looks like a person not it's not a person but according to the bartender it was very dangerous and it could and it even could catch people and kill them even according to the bartender sounds sounds very uh very very interesting now so rakhine konievsky um he has a question if you write a tattoo on such a creature in this in and that's how he gets the tattoos now it's clear you could see already this thing there kind of guys he was interested in it because i think he mentions it and i'll tell you managed it as i said he was interested he was interested in this thing and also frozen these army assad as these unique creatures and rabidalia nadal and his safer are also frozen about it seems they were interested in this type of thing um now i'm not going to go by richos into what is this just suffice to say that um just to make just the all the questions that this safer deals with is just uh amazing about eating them um on shabbos what's a bra of one sees them this is a question of if you can make a machanah barius why would they even create it and and through the this safer that i've that i have um he has letters and characters so here kindness back to the tattoos he talks about writing a tattoo on it and of course replying vsp throws in some other materials about it uh um he brings them that wears an interesting early source about it in a an early majestan kuma printed in by bubba um and he brings down the whole piece and he has some other sources of cajeles rava about it and there's a rash you climb about her handcast he also brings that down and uh anyway so that's one aspect now what's the surreni the surreni is oh sorry now just one thing just as they like as a just to make it a drop interesting what's this according to some sources so it's been very much spoken about on the internet numerous times around parishes being a werewolf and where it comes from and is this rabbenu fry him and who is this robinhood fry him and if you if you don't believe in it what type of person are you are you a good jew are you a bad you and robina frame says it not once he says it twice he says it three times that pinyamon was a werewolf and his werewolves real and are you good are you good you're bad because you don't believe in worlds there's so much discussion about this on the internet i'm not going to discuss that maybe for all powershell which also exists we have to throw that out there for parches someone should speak about it but some macau say that is this this werewolf somehow okay i just have to throw that out there um and was involved with urban ephraim so that's a way to get throw in why we could talk about it now anyway what's the cerrini again another creature it seems according to the descriptions it's it's found in the tariffs guys but it seems to possibly be a mermaid again a topic discussed on the internet we're not going to get involved with it right now but i'm upon him so khan asking the safer as i said with the tattoos he shows the same thing that we were exposed to from his unbelievable knowledge from what became famous of his criticism he plugs that into here to go even and it's beyond incredible it's kadai to learn it's as a as other as almost all his others farm it's available on hebrew books it's interesting even if you don't learn the whole thing samsung it's fascinating it'll be a great course for his nashamah probably if you do and he'd be very happy okay this first safer of a kind okay wow a lot of fascinating material when you say on the internet it's been discussed you mean it's internet level material or there's scholarly works and real discussions about it there's everything everything everything oh one second but you're right what i should say is that according to the pharisees troll i did more important because it's more negative because the way article makes it sound like it doesn't exist but article is well where the pharisees srell and others say it's the monk it's a form of a chimpanzee which is more negaio so obviously this also gets into um uh different other discussions but i can we spoke enough already sci topic and a site happening in the side happened so you can already move on right you just mentioned quickly refrain you want to give one sentence on that you said it because of violence um it seems um the story actually was written up um [Music] right afterwards magazine which i already was already uh i already asked michilo that i was i said publicly that i read it so in at least two issues there's discussion about it the klugman family um sponsored um i think he did all the work or at least the marmokinas in the rabino fry and he was also involved i'm not sure which one how much of the it could be the review um he also did it yeah from the introduction it sounds like he also did he also assisted by raquel maybe he did more of the work um but anyway he was involved as a to explain all different so to find different sources kedarka with his incredible yada for different materials relating to this robina fry but um yeah okay so that is about tattoos and pastry and haksav karne kagovim grasshoppers so everybody everybody knows about the chain when he was learning about the study of grasshoppers the grasshoppers came to him and there's a video that came a second time and there's a lot of a lot of as you say on the internet about the grasshoppers so what could you say what could you tell us about the man is grasshopper safer okay so like this so first like this rakayan kanyeski wrote a contrast in the same year that we that he put out by um he put out the karne khagavim and at the end of the karnik which is only 30 pages he says that um he finished it in l tough shalom above 1976. okay this is interesting because there's a famous thing that kind of speaks to print the safer when did he write his firearm and years that were leap years because he had an extra month not to worry about his javis but here we see him printing too far back to back in the same year it could be tough shalom was a leap year but it's but a tous farm of the year doesn't fit with the story whatever okay anyway um here too again he has akdama why he's writing the safer so he writes the reason is the rambam says that there's a mitzvah to know this among him to be able to be marvel between the behemoths and the government that's mutated and what's not what to eat even if you don't plan on eating it it's still a mitzvah it says requirement in the first seminar safer to learn the suggest to know the dining because many people will say i'm not interested in eating grasshoppers they're disgusting so why should i learn this simon [Music] so in order to um empower shimini we have the where they talk all about the different medium that are out there and all of a sudden we learn this pasta it says over here which ones could you eat that's so it sounds like so what i when i was young um learning this tsukimu was in seventh grade so i was right away the rebbe was like he was listening right right away he was listing off all the animals and all the birds and everything i'm like how does he know this like it's very hard the answer is that he had this it's called the living torah from robaria captain amazing safer amazing job done in a very short amount of time actually i had a very nice write-up about ryan cavan this year and um and we must say that i think ncsr was involved in reprinting could be that's what the article is about i know everybody was in the while then reprinting a lot of things yeah yes yes correct so so um so basically right away it talks about he says you keep the members of the red locust family the yellow locust the spotted grey locust family and the white locust family and he has pictures they could see and he has his artist with a crazy bikias about the grasshoppers okay now like everything else so it's a passup does not so what what what more could there be about grasshoppers so barak hashem we live in a time that there's already a few swarm written about grasshoppers first we have a frankiewski's countries called carnegie that's about eating grasshoppers we have a different safer called messiahs from professor zohar mar from expert in all different aspects of reality animals he's written up multiple every year he puts out at least another safer all different types of topics um he has to say from the rats and a big save around the on the locusts it's how long is this safer it's almost 200 pages and uh mabiel schwartz is also prolific as written many sperm he has a safer on grasshoppers interestingly i don't know why berbier schweitzer was not able to find him mentioning rankings be safer even though it was written much after okay now so so the point is that kangaski sat down and he held it's very important as he as he's saying why that you have to um learn this so yeah besides the regular din of tamatari fascinating chapter sim and aleph of the safer and he has basically 13 um about the sugu with the various aloha kidaka the curry dish with his bacius of um incredible bacchus uh and then he ends off with your dear simeon pay yes i think it's i'm not sure um and he has two pages where he has the the mahabharata and then he has a beer and a shared serum so here you can already see the the evolvement i i mentioned that in my hokus tattoos he doesn't have the mishna bureau type format at least for the end part he does whereas there the liquid is not like that okay so much so his great bacchus i found them using is that the in one simmon he talks about the mario cooler and somehow he gets to talking about a um maybe shy pic nice talks about why people don't bring it why people don't bring a certain braiser why we're showing them the white people why we shine him don't bring a specific braiser in teresque hammond so hang his toes that they really do and he also shows the battery material and i found very also true to tremendous good islam known for their crazy because sir i think he just he does find the car um for them okay anyway so now fine so we said that there's him the swarm today yes one could even find i was just um so i was in the biblical museum of natural history the musee the and so there he has a display about let's say grasshoppers he has a whole write-up about grasshoppers and one could buy grasshoppers if you to eat if you hold it's as if you go with the sheet that it's muted to eat you can even buy grasshoppers now do people eat it from jews eat it yes as zoramar talks about in the safer barricos say money jews eat it and other people also eat it um and if now uh when one learns to say foreign he talks about if what he says what about if i don't want to eat it but what about if i do want to eat it he has a chapter about it and his conclusion aloha mice is that one cannot eat it the messiah was lost now the the is the famous archaic and our kaimakadesh is safe on your day at length he says that one cannot eat grasshoppers at all okay manny paiskim in the moroccan ice cream and certain spa deposit him and the fact he manipulates they disagree with this so there was interesting there's interesting there's a safer called was born in 1670 it was a hush of a yidd and he was prolific writer but all his materials remain in manuscript but luckily for him he was a moroccan goggle and he does saw his material and he quotes it a lot in his different if he does we saw tons of manuscripts he saw this cafe not any quotes anyway the catholic it seems has a rehearsal where he comes out explains who he he deals with what our mother says and he says he comes out that it's mutter and it and this piece is quoted and we don't have this piece that where he says mother that's a forgot lost but he does saw it and others okay but more very recently less than ten years ago the safer pathnaki came out with different parts of his manuscripts and a different postscript from a safer shikha liquette it turns out that he was freezer from his hector that he gave to eat grasshoppers and and this is not so well known especially the safers only very very recent um and it came out and he came out but significantly moroccan goggle and even though originally he's the one one of the people that's quoted that's arguing here he is seemed to be heiser we don't have the whole reason why he's kaiser nor do we have the reason why he's arguing okay now the question is and this is the question that everyone wants to know is did rakain kanievsky um what's the story about this grasshopper that comes to visit him um and what's the story behind now so frankly that's interestingly enough is it i i was very curious to see does rokhan kaniesky himself make any mention of seeing a grasshopper so and and what's very significant is we'll see why it's very significant to see a grasshopper but um so i look through the whole safer and i see that rakhine kanyevsky himself says as follows on page when he's talking about and it plays out this is a part where it's very negative he says he saw the grasshopper you go further in the safer page 123 and then he says the um so he asked you go further in the safe room not such a big safer only 30 pages well worth learning through then he says um he brings something from the sephirah bris and then he says at least in the printed versions of the story he talks about that he spoke to people he spoke to experts he asked different people now again back to the magazine this is in the pesach issue so one of the daughters this interview with the daughters and it says here she remembers the famous story about the grasshopper abba was learning the signs of the grasshoppers which led to the safer he sent me to a neighbor who was a science teacher to ask if she had a book with pictures of a grasshopper she said she doesn't and then suddenly we noticed on the windowsill a grasshopper now already before khan kanyeski was lifter there's a fellow avishai obama avisha obama librarian of the television library and he has a blog excellent blog about svarim and different things he does it ties into the parsha and he has a whole post discussing about the the different versions of the story about kanyevsky and the grasshopper in the various books on the robinson and the various heists and on the internet there's a video with the person one a whole person about it and you could see what happens who say yes it is true so we're not coming to say that it's not true just i'm just pointing out this these will shyness in the safe now just to conclude with a few short points number one um did this ever happen before that someone else was learning hilton's grasshoppers or the sylvia and a grasshopper flew in so again thanks we have the internet someone found uh first i got i got it from a few different places some of them first sent it and then again and again um and bottom line is like this there's a safer stay it's cook which is printed in 1851 and then of the safer he wrote he wrote a bunch of spherum on chaste and the khulandaf and if i wouldn't have seen it i wouldn't believe it he's learning this grasshoppers and it's it's again not clear what the samanam are then he says like this he's not sure imam is not sure and then his review to see so we see a safer in 1851 at the same time similar type of story but he this author he went ahead and printed it um okay now so you'll think the story ends there so this is so the safest day yitzhak was reprinted by um into two volumes it's available today the actual safer is available on hebrew books you can see this piece now what's interesting is like this so as i decided to make the to go the next step and that is who's the author of the safer so it turns out there's a whole life has had this author he was a um how he became a he was a he was a mama show it sounds like he was a very shy person uh in uh iq level also and how mifa story how he became who he came and he became a successful businessman and a successful tamil hackham um so this is not the only nace but the grasshoppers it seems a lot he had a lot of nissan and this introduction from muhammad shalom they have various macarons so i was looking up more i wanted to see something more about this safer so i check and i see in the middle bibliography it describes that there's a safer written against the safer what's the safer call the safer is called by established okay so i'm curious to know what this this person because it sounds like it has to do with this thing what's going on because i immediately try to get a copy of the book i send someone to get it it's missing in hebrew university once it's missing indeed university is stuck they write they saw it in a private collection in a collection of mayor videos i write to a librarian of mayor benio no it doesn't have it maybe it's in the private library sent to the sun i was about to write to the sun it was already today coming the thing i sent back i looked i said you know what today i'm giving the sheer so let me try one last time to see maybe there's an extra copy and the phallics copy i look again there is extra i sent back my guy was there today and he finds the safe taka someone wrote a seven page booklet and the whole thing now it doesn't say why he's doing this but the whole safer is attacking this piece it's baloney he can't believe it and it's seven pages this rare book there's no copying world except him the hebrew university has a copy from the from a copy that was in the in tel aviv library anyway bottom line is this known as scene it's not available on the internet and this safer is all about that this piece that this mahabhara it's blown okay i promise you if someone would write such a thing about hanging today i feel bad what would happen but anyway we have video we have video recording that the story did happen all his daughters say it they set it at the levia and this is a story that's been well known already in his lifetime just it's very cute that he himself when he's talking about it he doesn't mention it he just mentions they spoke to experts um where he looked okay now what's going on here system this is the last proc to talk about today relating to all this um he quotes the safer abras so mccloud i hope to discuss more about the significance of the safe habits for frankieski was very significant for heineken but for this um for just now just to talk on one aspect and that's relates to this whole thing of seeing this why was it so important to see the grasshopper so um mamash piquets and nimrods the i mentioned already a few times um i'm fascinated by it the hida wrote travels of when he used to trap when he traveled all over and one of the things he mentions a bunch of times is he saw he went to visit zoos he saw animals he saw different animals he made a mark michelangelo's and the question is why he was so interested always to seeing animals and um they recorded it okay he made the barack obama say there but what was so i so i thought about a lot and i and my conclusion was that it was not only there was a lot more going on and that was possibly relates to in general when one learns any particular studio specifically a sugi like grasshoppers and in gen and there's also uh there's two aspects so so the main aspect is that not only did you learn them but you should be taraya to be um to be making which is tummy which is tar and so to the carbon aaron learns up over there um you're learning the studio about grasshoppers you learn the shorthand but you don't know how it looks how could you even begin to even passing about it so kind of you also know about it okay so he so what did he do he went according to either the way he writes as he went to um experts and then in the end he talked to saw he was like that that a grasshopper came and he was able to see with his own eyes but there's a nakuda to see and that's why the khida was so concerned one of the aspects behind what the daw was concerned to go to the zoos i swore ali nadal marshall he went specifically to seal different animals tucker for this reason to be able to identify which animals are kasha are not and he's shows that if you have a proper understanding of animals it helps understand homage when one learns parakshira it's very helpful if you understand the animals to understand different things and and more than that in general so so this sort of number one is that there's a concept called in the the words realia i i don't i never was able to find the exact word how it is in english exactly but it basically means is to if you know the mathias it helps you understand things better so le marshall robert capital when he learned this and you look at his pictures and then today there's much much more it helps you get a better handle and understanding what's going on and as hank lyeski says that that's part of the mitzvah to learn at units he was not doing because he wanted to eat the grasshoppers it was this is a helicopter and as i'm showing you from this terrorist guy i'm also a rashi benzene that had them iraq in the carbonart it's a mitsubishi to know this so that so when what let's say one goes to a zoo or one goes and catches his grasshopper he has his kid go outside catch me a grasshopper and you look at it and you learn the suggest your makayam mamlish and extra mitzvah in in the suggest so that was the kuda behind in general when one learns these type of suggest one should be aware and one should try to and this is this is what that's what he says he did he went and he consulted experts now one such expert was always the safe person which hashem will talk more about now just to conclude with one last one last um one last practice which relates to both these farm and will will serve as the introduction to the next sfaramosa [Music] so one of the most incredible books that i've ever read about a goddess is the book written by the time son about his father every time i go just to look up one page i end up putting 20 pages i just recently overcome i read it over again and i highly highly recommend it it's it's beautiful and you get an unbelievable appreciation of and some of the aspects actually will play out uh later on but in part of the nakuda that i see with rakhine kanievsky in both these two swarm where he uses his where he mama starts from scratch from the supreme as i said and he comes all the way to and he's bringing everything so the time son writes the foul what was my father say to alimur he says it's like this we used to begin we learned he learned with him a lot he helped him with the mr bureau also and he says we will move on to the major if there's a safra targa he says i remember him learning this someone this roofer line i forgot about and someone point listener pointed out similar to it through kankarievsky with uh and we learned the whole parachute with the sofia then we will move on to the rambam and this is how he would learn until you go further down to the riff and the rambam and they were showing him that he was able to get till he would go through rush because then he would check the the sunlight light smack truma zarua ramban then he would also forget that don't forget the shelters in the bahamas and then he would go to the tournament and then the rest will get to a different time but the point is when one looks at this and then you learn you look very carefully at the sa these two swarms before we even get to the other swarm you see this is what kanyeski did he mummish sat down he went started from the beginning you open up to him there's a famous joke everyone loves to say how does he shiver back or no um he doesn't he never opens it up they know there's all different versions of the joke um how does he know maisha and aaron are brothers it's not because he knows the kim but it's because of his uh science and anyway same type of thing but here at franklin he started from the beginning he went through the resharing him and this it's not only what i'm saying is this time son is saying this is how my father taught me how to learn does he have the mission of brewer itself was written and we'll have a lot more to say but this is just an introduction to insight into the method of rakhine kanyevsky to give us some glimpse of what's behind these uh smarm excellent excellent wow there's so much information there to unpack amazing as always now i know next time one of my daughters asks me get rid of a spider i should hold it and examine it and learn it for posterity okay thank you very much make sure to show it to her like you have to make sure to show it to her absolutely i could tell her this is how you man previously they used to look for these animals all the time and mitzvah always take you show her the rashi you sit there and rushing now we're gonna go that's it exactly exactly exactly exactly okay great speaking with you let's do it again soon have a good day youtube bye