Sefer Shoneh Halachos II: Rav Chaim's Seforim Explored with Rabbi Dr. Eliezer Brodt (Part 7)

[Music] welcome back once again rabbi dr eliezer broth thank you so much for joining us for shayna hallaches part two so i mentioned that if anybody wants to be a sponsor they should reach out and lo and behold hashem we have our first sponsor who is anonymous but he shared the following message no i'm not the only one who eagerly anticipates the next year that has given me an appreciation not only for kanyeski but for how vast the terror really is this is a great course that you are giving to claudius royal and i'm thrilled to therefore be a part of it by being the first one to offer a sponsorship for this year the torah and the simcha created should be for rafu shalemma for shifura bracha pass rachel the urum have been aligning and entertaining all at once so the sheer should be a closer for shalema again for shifura bracha pass rahul okay let's start with an email that we got commenting on the recent shaina halakis discussion and the person he wanted to make a macha protest about what was mentioned by cairo we were discussing forgetting and rabbi eliezer could discuss how he already discussed this in a previous episode um a letter from the rambam but this person wasn't happy with the way we mentioned that objective cairo perhaps forget is that to imply memory loss and such a figure is improper so well do you want to respond to that right off the top yes so i will just mention one thing um for this for this question it's a very valid question the quote that i brought about um possible for forgetting or changing of the mind of the base yosef was from smoothie tau from vital his father great contemporary younger contemporary of the invasive cairo but um just to put in context i said would even though i'm trying to avoid going in tangents and tangents and tangents just one macar relating specifically to a base of cairo and that is that um the basis is as it was very well known schwarz is coming coming upon us faster than we realize had a maggot and that everyone knows we see one of the things we stay up on truest night is the whole story with the best and his market so however the maggot works but um anyway in shock it says bottom line that in rosh hashanah one should eat meat on rosh hashanah okay makes sense it's ezra the maggot of the best if it says interesting thing do not eat meat so acronym already point out what's going on here how could he forget an open pasta in ezra furthermore it's a gemara cooler than a missionary is also says one of the four times a year that we checked and you have to eat meat is rosh hashanah so what's shot that the maggot said something against gemara now about the steroid between the maggid and the basiosif is its own discussion that's a tangent of tangent tangent tangent but just for our purposes is a shocking statement to some is found in the radar of david luria and the safer maimer cadmus where you heard from rokhain velajner and to preface this rokhan villager knew very well about mageedum he had conversations with his rebbe the guru about maggie them more than once he quotes the manga of the best of a few times in his life and he was known great mukubo so he doesn't need any s commas from us he says the following about the best and about this topic is and it triggered that the maggot gave him false information and for because there was riffian and khazara in the basic at the time when this thing came that this statement came down and through the market through him now might sound very shocking you're kind of larger saying this but in in kabbalah macarius such as umashi kardavaru rakhindital and others they also say this when they're talking about mageed without getting into any more what we see over here is that kind of legendary saying there's a possibility that the best forgetting could even be where someone has graced the base yosef and i mentioned in the first year the first presentation over here with the rambam that the rambam in a letter says he forgot it seems from what we see in this letter which is an authentic letter the rambam forgot his macarius for some things until he found it and that was the story that we quoted in okay and i'll just add tell me if you agree it doesn't necessarily mean that we have to understand this the way we understand it today with our friends we forgot something it could be something on a higher level i mean to say there's a fursuit gemara obviously and you can't comprehend this on a human level right but whatever that means right so mushroom is moisture but we can't even talk you know so obviously it means whatever that shikha means it was some kind of something whatever it is that at that point it didn't have uh that the car is that is that this fear it's for sure fear especially the further back you go in time no question when we talk about avoids but there's obviously there's for sure such a thing out there that's not even a doubt okay fine and one more question to address and perhaps you'll address this in the actual conversation is somebody sent the following question um he wanted to know what the say about he says it always bothered me that the ulam has raised the mission of well over there after several reasons and he lists his reasons and obviously we're not here me anu to be magnus our small heads into these being haramagadalam but there if i'm talking about is that something you'll discuss today so as i already alluded to more than once just briefly that says two points over here that just to say very quickly is as follows the it seems and i've heard this from different people i've seen a little bit but not much what bothers people is is that in the neighborhood at least and we have rakhine kanyevsky saying this and ish which recorded parts of it last time is that the mishna brewer is so what bothers people is what's the story with the um time so number one is i had heard and hearing is not necessarily um from a valid source but i heard that this niche had problems with our hashocan and stuff like that the truth is that looking through rakhine kanyeski's farm you will see that esky has no problem with arkhashohan he's familiar with him and he uses him casey there in other khalakama all the time he's really like him he never says any bad things about him if kazunish wasn't into him or even said something zilzo the kebab zilzo and dear madregas so to speak um he would never really mention him acid which is relating to his he uses it extensively in the moon not that he's passing like every one of them but he he's using him as a person to discuss so the the sentiment that i get from looking in rakhine can you ask me not terrorish about path from terrorism that he does not have a problem with our khashoggi in our cayenne as as far as the pacific african the messiah of the khasanesh for whatever reasons and and skills based on that messiah was the missionary now um just to say here because i i i fear that people will comment so just to preempt the comments to drop [Music] he quotes it sometimes openly sometimes he's referring to statements in it without saying openly tim hinken in his work tariq to be involved with the producing of the book um has a small chapter about this chaval he was probably going to write a much bigger chapter but we don't have all the materials but we have some and it's found a little bit found in the book and he shows such a thing that the sometimes to be referred to they got along they're coming they're both litvax the um we don't know if they have any contact personally with each other but we have no reason to assume there was any fights as far as we know we never no one ever found that there was any such things any controversies that they're both on different sides even has to understand is that a brother-in-law of a native he's one of the daily haddad of the time one of the active most he's involved with many of the controversies a very very well known pasek people writing in chuvas and besides he also wrote this incredible work called our hashochan which we found that after he died he also wrote called arakas so basically he wrote systematically unheard of things since the rambam anyway if in certain circles uh people tell me them over malaysia say over there maisha was very into that you go like on over the mission rev heinken who was also said similar type of things but both rev misha and riven were also very into the mission of hankin knew the mission brew about so they had their messiah and there are definitely people i i've heard also people from tamir riverman saying over there vermin also said a similar thing that was the pasta it the the conversation this is uh um um obviously telling a lot of hearsay and possibilities but whatever there's no question that the shame shamayim both of these were incredible works and they helped they're they're going on different approaches and different methods not for now not this we're trying to keep the podcasts this to recline kanewski just to mention one last thing about this is there seems to be azil this is a little bit that some people feel that the reason about that they they're trying to look why is it that kankanski is not into so they look and they based on this messiah that doesn't really exist anywhere which we don't have but they say something to the effect that oh look these mizrahi people they're looking for a plastic to hang the hat on that he's he's more cool addict than a mission brewer such as and there's a new revival for the arkhan and it's i've seen it a little bit i've seen young people writing about that because of all this hearsay to try to say oh it must be something's up so let's find the problematic thing like who are you to talk about this i'm saying was was one of the great pisces before before the war anyway i'd kind more than enough of the on off the topic of of this um this indian but this is a point worth to point out um to avoid any more problems or questions about this thing okay so we're going to dive back in um i brought the not have a chance to finish up on the shanahan and as we say thank you again for the sponsor should be refused to leima and again any questions or comments feel free to email eliezerbroth gmail.com myself schweid m s-e-h-w-e-d-m-o-u dot org okay so we'll jump right into what you wanted to add to the last podcast okay so just a few points one is that it's very interesting i noticed the lashes of the she talks about about the mishna brewer he says what's his style of a safer he throws in it's going to be kedera hasafer and and although the truth is it's not really like i i mentioned briefly last time it's not really like adam gives much more meat so to speak he says more reasoning behind a certain succumb even in the top part forget about the mishra saddam but there's a special thing going on over here which is that it was and [Music] relating to other controversy the countries that that letter was written about when he talks about he says and and and then he continues in the letter whatever he's talking about in the khazalish was very into the saddam in general the stiper i also saw um was very into the saddam and also um i recently read an interview about rugby daliano similar thing when yarder to go with all the sakura saddam impossible and just to mention one last source is there's obviously many sources and it's its own conversation about the i came across recently sal arakov writes that um he was from england he writes how should one passkin he says the svarim the he was maximum very much and he was passing like them aloha and he gave shirem on them also rather gave shiraman before he wrote his national brewer accompaniment the safer was very important and that's why he's throwing out that it's he's copying on some level the kids are level making you accessible to the ghayeb that's why where frankenski is being mad this um this this product um okay that con for that that um one other that was one other point that i wanted to mention relating to the introduction okay um so you mentioned last time that shayna hallaches was sort of a sikum not a c coma if that's the right word but focused on bringing out the it was a tempsis maybe that's a better word of the of the mr brewer um anything else you want to add about the maybe focus yeah so two things one is um two things i wanted to mention one is that the the hasanish and the mishna brewer so i recently came across a few different stories how they i mentioned that the there's the mice ish a lot of times when someone's lifter so they come out with material and then some a few times more material mice many years after the kazunish was nifty they started putting out these volumes of material about it has an ish and then they put out four volumes and everyone thought they stopped and then they made an index and they put out volume five afterwards and then a six and then a seven in one of the volumes they have a ton of information just written from rokhan kanyevsky about the khasanesh so there he talks about a certain shiloh that he had says let's bring out a missionary and then he passed him based on the mission brewing there's other such stories in darfur venue and in the um was very into even though he does we mentioned last week he argues on the on the mission board many times that the mishna was his go-to safer to look at first before uh talking about some things but that's one aspect of shayna lachas and that's where we mentioned that and the mission of brewers but besides for bringing down the hazarishes in our let's say or other places that might be relevant i was i was looking i i have not to to to be mine to be mocked him i i cannot say that the shayna lakers was a safer that was on my table or that i spent a lot of time looking at it in recent weeks i started looking at it more and trying to figure out what to say after i came up with some different things all of a sudden it pops out to me i'm looking at a um a sif in in shimon yutkas and then i see he brings up sak from the kazanish i'm like oh wow and bachchan just gave me something to talk about um there's files like this the the and and i'll explain the significance relating with the specifically the many years ago i came while learning hilton shabbos i come across this um zeven wrote a piece and in the piece he refers to say foreign and he says some type of interesting thing from this i i went to track it down i get it the kitzer it's a safer from a rob in germany who ends up he's born in the 1860s he dies in 1940 right after he came territorial his name was ryan bieberfield anyway it's a small kitchener safer written for the masses i think it was originally written in german for hamainam to learn halachus okay very very nice sweet safer and it had a few pieces that that's how i got to it or seven quarters certain way how he said a certain thing and that's why i sparked me to look at anyway eventually the safer comes to the attention of victoria blitzky from ray brack and he puts it out with different sacrament editions after it's translated from the german into hebrew then we're talking in binet brock it's coming out of neighborhood so at one point i believe it was in the sixties uh maybe even earlier or kalman kahana well um he also added in a few pages of succumb from the khasanesh and seems um and one of the and there's about four or five pages in here which has fascinating succumb that he had a messiah from the khasanesh so much so these section the pages the few pages over here that has checked over every single sack in here and this is why kanewski is bringing down for example about what this is one of the first places where the fazness talks about kashmir and chavez and his famous now in shin come across that he also brings the menu and then he says and then he throws you in for the following piece of information where griezmann says that this the khazanish was went over carefully these succumb that he's justifying why he is justifying why he could bring this down the answer is because this is coming from kahana now the the kamikano was very close with the khazanesh and le marshall he has a savior in her husnida which became for many many years the the a safer that many hasanam used to use when they learned and in it also went through it and has certain succumb in there um that are quoted from the safe from now the the recount this safer from just just to mention mamas briefly two two three other points besides i mentioned there with robleski updating the safer um where slim zalman writes very very positive about the safer um which can be found in one of the later editions of this where the son wrote a whole whole history of his father how a tremendous person he was and then zeven has like one of his incredible book reviews about the safer showing the khashevas of the safer and he writes one of the fascinating important parts of this safer is the succumb of the khasanesh besides that at some safer valdec and that's how i got to the safer because of zeven using it on the different area of his but um he says arab amudham typhus they're special halacha's goodbyes we have from here that are negated and um even though and then he says even though in this form of we see him as a great god of the torah and kia durer of zeven wrote about the hazard but we see over here his we see the khazanish's knowledge and technical aspects of modern day shiloh says in these four pages of and that's why it's very significant this is where the khazanish hishid is about electricity become famous from and that's what what's his name is bringing down in here in derek it's in in his china laches and it's interesting is that evan at the time when he wrote his book review in the 1940s so at that time it was a small little siber over time it became a much much bigger um sebur okay and one last pratt related to this manuka is that many times i always wonder if if i'm going if i'm do i look for you know a sign that i'm supposed to be doing this or whatever so i randomly pull out a safer in my in this room i don't know if you could see but it has a lot of sparring here and i open up a safer which i took it down for a completely different reason was buried behind the various piles and i open it up for something else and then i see that they they have actually the khazanish wrote more harass for the minute that didn't get into all the different versions of the manuka based on a different draft of of these rs and this is in this series that seems to still be coming out called the nazim but hey anyway that ad time the pride about the khazanesh and the nation what more information one could find in this safer about that okay you shared with me on the phone that you have a theory and what prompted him to write specifically at that specific time maybe you want to share your theories with the audience okay so i'm going to share a theory the theory is it's a theory it does not mean it's true it's just a possibility um to make life interesting they come even even if the theory is not true the information still is a little interesting i hope and as we we already remind them that we try to go on some tangents along the way so we'll learn about some tangents anyway my theory is as follows the date looking at the dating of the shaina halachus i noticed now and one other point before i get to the theory is that i saw in the time sun which i've recorded a few times about his father and he sometimes says why did my father write such as such a savior he says i don't know sometimes my father didn't tell me i'm going to guess certain events happened so i'm going out peter derek of the khafichain song for the mishabura i'm using that over here for the says his reason so those reasons are for sure true i'm adding to the mix another possible makuta now what i watch that nakuda is i'm looking at the safer and i'm looking at the dates when it first comes out and i see the year is in the 1960s it comes down 1967 chanel okay all of a sudden it clicked that in 1965 a safer came out in arts israel which shook the whole air to throw people were it immediately became a bestseller sold thousands and thousands of copies and this is the shmir shabbos at the age of 38 yeshua neuvert wrote his work which eventually became the classic and for until today the everyone has it it's in every house america israel it's translating to english also and it's because okay so became an instant classic ready right away it wins the with cook prize which in those days there's a it still exists i think i'm not sure if it exists today but it existed for many years where a bunch of people pick uh which is the best safer and in that time the the judge is one of the judges was evan and he wrote in um he wrote up why he and the other judges came to the conclusion that the safer is proper amongst the things is it's it's how it's written amazing and it deals with for the first time all the complicated modern childhoods even though the mission is the missionary but there's many new shilohs that kept on coming up and even though it's a short period of time but a lot happened and and continues to happen as we see so shmi shams was the first such safer to deal with many of these issues head on and the style and many other things about the safer attracted it and won the prize and became very famous okay now less known at the same also significant is that even though he was a young 38 year old person writing a monumental halachic work he was also a talmud moovak of the great rush limit and he wrote to save her today now why did he choose to write the safer so you already it seems to be already well known and he writes about this in the introduction in the newest edition of the skeletal that he was where he was during world war ii for many years he hid out in holland whole life is how he got there and shabbos he had a mishna hill for shabbos that was one of the only farm he had he mastered it and different fosm of being nizaran shmir shabbas he held that he's going to make in his business to work on hillary chavez and which eventually he does and he created this work that he did okay now what um what i found fascinating is his vows it turns out that it was known that there was controversy with the safer and there was a scammers that certain people backed over the ass commerce and certainly became famous and then they were removed turns out that the first edition which is 1965 it seems that there is five editions someone who wrote a uh master paper on the schmidt has located that there was five different editions of the first edition anyway this controversy like everything else is there's controversies but what was the controversy about so it's interesting that um the fir the first the cooler that the controversy was is that who who began the controversy is the stiper the great stipeler from bernay benebrach wrote in a parrot of his in his mustache where he talks about shmear shabbos he has and in this area he says i'm making a um uh he's making a announcement to the sibor that in our generation there are people that are putting out works similar to and he says that they're they're taking they're collecting succumb and with a agenda i guess to be makel from all different mcculloch from all different works are not reliable they add in their own two cents okay then he goes on he talks about it further and then he says even though it has haskamas claus okay and then he says i'm not being but he doesn't say who he's referring to but he chose in the in the 60s to write this that right away was known that it was referring to um and interestingly enough even as time went on when various were changed he never he didn't want to take out this this piece even though it could be because he held us an important piece even if let's say he might have agreed which we don't know but he might have agreed to the sri show after all that on some level but but he didn't take it out because he held there's a very important point here a lesson that one needs to be learned about writing okay that so that's number one there was this controversy and what i'm saying is this controversy is led by the stipe it's fast forward a few years and um um dave landau writes a country's called beardsvarum which is a 17-page conscious he begins with the stipeler so now you see now clearly that the staipler was referring to he's also from the nebraska on the great building of today still and he writes a vicious attack on the safer it's vicious and um some some arguments are general arguments which is beyond the scope to to go through all the different uh problems that he had and one of the problems you could see is is how he feels how the hassa is he deals with how he talks about kazanish this is one of the things that he mentions at the end and he feels that he's that sometimes he has a problem with it or whatever he feels the sri charms cause it has some type of question and he'll push it away and that's not how we're supposed to deal with the hazard and and you can see this is bothering with landau and the stipler and this has been a brock is very very much um bothered by this by this thing so this is the background of of what i saw about the topic so far so now my my point is that this is what's going on in these years because there was such a because the iraq place confessed it has an issue is not being justified properly but being presented in al-aqsa and the mission brewer also even though the shrine is a bucking nephilim quotes it many times but it's being also there's others farm being used and it's not the mishna brewer just and and has an ish so bother them as a sniper they landed so frankenski went ahead and ishmael he went and he wrote a hebrew to emphasize here's the succumb of the mishnah here's the succumb of the [Music] this is my theory behind possibly behind another motive why he decided to write the shayna office interesting so i came across as a while back david bashafkin who wears many hats also has a podcast 1840 and he did a series on shabbos quite a while ago and i remember he had um on who i don't know all the details actually his son works for the ou um review um his father i think was a baker at that time i'm not sure exactly where he was learning but he ended up being the secretary um so to speak to deal with all the letters and all the that controversials coming into here if nobody they've never apparently or you could talk about this probably more was it but also a tremendous you know someone he wasn't you know someone who liked hacking around and i think he dressed he wanted a dress um you tell me i think you looked you know you listened to the podcast you looked over the transcript and he talks about this over there yeah so he it's it's interesting is that yeah what you when he sent me to this to this source that he he says that he he didn't want to show rosham and orbach the letters that he got from the nate brock these sharp letters because they were also being so he he sort of like he didn't want to hurt his rebbe in any form because he felt it's not it's not fair to his rebbe so he avoided it but he i think he did it sounds like he did tell him that they were proud that people raised issues but and and then he went and he or he fixed it up according at least you know on some levels in the different editions to at least to address some of the criticism um that came out from the neighborhood but a very it was a very interesting interview that sheffield had over there with this this matia that he found the secretary at the time um during this controversy he was a young buffer and he saw these letters which obviously i would love to see and i'm sure people would love to see but i doubt they're meant for the public eye and um and also double sheffield himself wrote an article about the hashimoto's of the safer shimmery shabby classic ice in the end it did become the classic and it is considered the the classic um safari now but i want i just want to be mangish over here that i'm not going into which is really what's sort of behind this is that there's different approaches in halakha it's not unusual that sometimes different price can have different sheets and when one learned in the before world war two there were many paisley they lived in different cities different areas uh hungarian had one way of sack and lit fish had a different way of sacking them a different way after the war this sword became more of a melting pot and communications became much faster so black held their way for whatever reason and then with the hazarish and even let's say using the mission bureau whereas you shall i am had their own messiahs young whipper snapper as they would call them kashalam and he was a big talmud of samurai and it was known that sakhari then were were coming from with the authority of zalman so much so that eventually rosham zalmanurbach went and he went through the safer very very carefully to make sure because people told him every sack of yours is being quoted here so you double check the triple check that he used to sit in a room safe yamaha to double to check everything and release the volume of tikkunim and mulum on all these sukken so there's different approaches there's also unbelievable we're not i'm not anyone to be talking about who's i'm not taking any sides over here there's different approaches who's his uncle the cousin is his father the sniper they that was the messiah that they were going but at that time the the the fight was it sounds like from these letters from this this podcast from it must be very levitic i imagine if the internet would have been around it would have been even much worse it has the nature of such a type of thing that that could have happened and today we see it died down although just to be the same just on a tangent and tangent that the sri shapes hustle when it was supposed to come out and there were other the union but there was a whole deal when the newest edition that we have this fat updated thousand page version of olive came out there was also tamils about how it's gonna shift if it might shift away from the second roshamazep but this is beyond the scope of our discussion but now i'm just going to talk about two more um very short pieces relating to this to not relating to relating that relates to the shiny lockers but more about the yachts and that is like this two of them are they're just both very nice stories and they're very very recent stories so that's why i feel that they're very some of them people heard of already okay one of the stories is like this there was a machon the way i heard about the story first was there used to be a newsletter um a partial guillotine that used to come out of a kind relating to kankanski stuff that he said stories um tyra of his weekly and someone was once in a while cut a piece from it that he found interesting he would send it on to me and into one of the pieces it says that a group of avraham they were about someone was about to put out an addition of the besikta and they wanted to know if the the that they would the edition they were using was from someone slammer boober they wanted to know people i guess they saw a picture of him and they were very nervous that he didn't look from and then they checked into them and they thought maybe zamasu could we use them could we use them for the main source of our work that we're putting there so the the story goes they went to ask from khan kenyansky and without going into all the back and forth the basically we're having a successes of a fairy show missionary that you could use the safer so like what says not so he said we're not asking about the sector we want to know is could we also use his material this bubba himself so kind of he says yeah okay it seems they went to look they couldn't find it it turns out and sim and tofu tests if cut them base as we just got finished saying this week and last week how the time was so important for and i hope to talk about even more for the esky it's about fair shame we don't need to go any further so this was what this was acute um usage of his incredible the key is for the most side detail found in a buried and some charity and that was what he said now the truth is that um perhaps we'll talk about it more in a different angle a different time but the um so later on what was the story behind it is there's a machon called zikrani right has printed numerous madrashim numerous ghazals and many of these who was the one who discovered these manuscripts and they printed it it seems that after a bunch of them someone made a big stink it said how could you print it he's a masculine now the truth is that this question should have been asked much earlier because if you're going to almost any shoe in america and artistrol in the shiva libraries most of the major hazel that we have are meant not most but many were printed in the past hundred and fifty years by schlemmer bubba discovered it he was prolific he was who was he was this rich bala bus very learned person who lived in galicia born in 1827 until 1906 he was a from shemitah it's just yes he did have to do with masculine but he was from and he was good he was on good terms with many good islam we have manuscript letters of him that were printed a bunch of years ago with them album and and other people um so this mcconaughey was getting nervous because people were making us think about it but this thing should have been made earlier on other from companies such as vakshal the maznaine publishing house also printed a bunch of farm and no one really pointed out them but the truth is that people did point out other such issues whatever okay now um just to assign two other protein with this boober is that there's two kudos over here that i think rokhanenski was is really the main address to ask such a question that is like this kind of ascii was familiar with all of bubbas madrashim he used them in all islam the main question is not only about using if he says something in the footnote but it's also as a reliable person printing manuscripts that's problematic who's familiar with them he quotes them i mentioned in martial in the to say from tattoos he quotes boober of magister rooms but he was familiar with all his form of boobers i imagine his his library had all of them penciled up and and the point is he was a bucky niffler in in madrashi ghazal as we discussed a little bit already he if he found pieces that were problematic he would have pointed it out and right away when they were walked into he said boomer stay away from him it's not only that have a time quoted him with tyrus and maggie it's also that kind himself if there was something problematic he would have known him what am i what am i alluding to is that there's many mid-russians that have been printed over the years and hank nyevsky um that collected in different forms one such famous collection is is was put out called it's a madrashim at one point wrote numerous agonies on them and and things that he felt problematic he writes take out this piece this piece is problematic so i have no doubt that if boober had printed problematic things that i guess he would have picked up on it years ago and he would have made a made pointed this out one other thing about this bluebird because of personal abuse for me was that a bunch of a few years ago i came across i i put out a work um from a maisha rhinos this maisha rhinis was a was a son of ravinus the famous revinus he died tragically at the age of 20 21. anyway this um this mysterious he ends up he was already at the young age of 14 he's putting out material and swarming and articles all over i when i i began a project to put out his material i thought it was going to be a small booklet of a few uh 100 200 pages and turns out the volume ended up being this thick 750 pages and of material while i was looking into him i came across he wrote about boober turns out he wrote about bubba in his lifetime where did he get the material from from buber and he wrote he had we i found from manuscript 24 letters of his two boober and you see from these letters i printed them in this in this volume called and and and you see from here this young 16 year old guy writing to bubba at that time was already one of the most fashionable people and he's a rich viewer also he put out many many swarm he's one of the biggest most popular people in the city lambert i think lambert was but he's a very well-known person on all fronts and he had the 16 year old guy driving him nuts four different things it's amazing to see these letters i printed them and and you see from the letters that he's still answering him even though he's bothering him a little what you call maybe a little nick possibly with unbelievable patience and he helps him he gives him material he and he writes this moisturizer wrote a beautiful the first essay while bubba's alive about boober is printed in this work anyway so i just have to mention it only because to plug my own self of something that i did a few years ago okay that's one um point and then just to messiah with one last point again to show the keys of the sky of in the prophets kindness material that is this came out during the corona this was a tumult everyone was talking about wearing masks not wearing masks it seems at some point someone went and asked what kind can you ask me about it so hank says what a bear locker talking about masks during mageefa what's going on so it turns out if one looks to in the mishna bhura in the beer halacha we find the safer pisces this that was going on in the 1830s and onwards how then he brings down about um we are near your nose you should wear some type of form of a mask it was quoted as and you should have something smelling good so you should be able to deal with the breath the breath because it's people complaining you know have to wear a mask and it's it's a it's problematic so where was this this was also buried in a beer halacha in dallas this is in the i think in hills tish above area where he talks about it so yes someone went ahead and wrote a whole article about this during corona many millions of articles came out about all the different brought them but this was a famous thing the key is from kanyevsky somewhere out of the ordinary that he found he opens up his like um his bear locker located now just to be messian because this is once you're talking about this keyboard and it played a role is that the the the the this piskey oil is actually one of those the hidden sources of the mishna brewer it's first printed in 1901 it's an incredible massive work on it's this this is one volume there's another volume also where slime in in already writes that we already know from this diane this hash of a goggle wrote numerous works beforehand with tremendous ascamis this is writing this work you can say it seems that he really wrote on everything but the point is this has tons and tons of information uh from multiple troopers and different types of sources even sources a little bit excellent excellent safer it's not really used today very few people know about it is available in hebrew books and but the um didn't know about it he used it openly a few times and seems also other times he had other sperm of his and the martial in his he quotes a different safer of his and just mcclell the stipeler also was very it has two interesting things in one arc in the archives at one point i see that the stipler really liked sephora malachim such as he says um he brings down what was an example the pisces elsewhere he brings down that the the stiper said that the pisgah islam had problems with his vision um but when he but um he made a promise that if he's able to finish up a safer and he and he was and he finished up his safer and he was and he got back it seems he got back his real stipler uh brings it down in a different place and they bring it down from the stipler in darkness are big all in all i would say is it's kadai to it's another tool to die to be aware of and um as i said the the it was used by the mission of brewer and this were kind of again when he was asked during the corona all the different questions that he was asked he said it's often a mission of so not only was he writing the shenanigans he knew he knew the mishna brewer even the most side pieces of information the names of people quoted etc etc thank you very much a lot of fascinating material looks like we've kept this conversation around the 45 minute mark um what's next on your agenda rabbi brought it's a good chance that we will continue with the derek in the next series in the next episode of the series continuing with the world of halacha of rakai okay looking forward if he's still listening um if you have any questions or comments again send either one of us an email eleazar gmail.com you that org and sponsorships are available once again thank you to the sponsor and the discussion should be a sketcher for shalema 4 have a very good day thank you