Rav Chaim’s seforim with Rabbi Dr. Eliezer Brodt (Part 1)

rabbi dr eliezer brat it's a pleasure to have you back although this time it's something different we've never done this before the world just lost our our goddale or sarah tourer that's how he's referred to mourinho and both of us know that we have no business even discussing his godless there was so many sidester whether it was his mother his aidsis his adraka but we figured this one small lakuda that we can focus on and maybe bring out a perspective that may not be focused on elsewhere and that is his farm and to see we all know he wrote many many spartans that were written on mathias of torah that have not been touched before but if we could see and understand was able to take his his his knowledge of kula terakula and create produce the spartan that he produced that may be an insight from a different perspective a different angle or godless and it should be it should be as a current to be the current and it should be to lift us up to be able to want to learn these foreign and look into them and it should be uh ili nishmase whatever we could do a little bit to ourselves to be able to take away and grow a little bit from this big big aveda so how are you today reb liezer [Music] everyone's busy um already ever since matsushabus writing or saying their thoughts about going rakhine kanyevsky so i decided for my own benefit that i'm going to add in my own two cents into the mix i'm sure others will say similar things that i i'm saying over here they'll say better or some maybe already did say it but when a goggle of such a caliber is nifter it's only proper to reflect on what we lost and what we can learn from his highly productive life ever since i heard the news right before shabbos and artistro i started going through my mental files of what i knew about him pulling out various form of what i had purchased over the years and tried to analyze a bit the greatness of this gain of what i saw in his written words i'm trying to put why someone were i'm trying to put in words what i saw for myself and as always we tend to take for granted something we always had we thought that kind would be the person that would he would be there greeting mashiach especially this is a topic he was isaac in um i'm doing this also specifically because i feel people not everyone is familiar with the real requirement what do i mean the real requirement it's okay really for goggle to mean different things for different people there's different aspects of a goggle or character traits of a goggle that talks to different people and was no different just as an example there was a great god um some cypher had hundreds and hundreds to tell me them two of his time two of his from his greatest tummy then one was the maram shikh and another was recline safer author of the both these tell me them learned by the samsara for many many years and and their main rebbe that they held was their rebbe that they got everything from was some safer if one would go and pull out and sit down and learn a true islam shikh versus the troopers you would not believe that these two people sat by the same person what's the explanation so i heard many years ago from my rebbe rabbi spitz that what what different people focus on different things from a goddamn and you could have to such an extent that they will take out things that you can't imagine that both taking out from for some people he was about me first for other people he was an advisor for that's terrible all different issues lines out the door for for hours and hours getting brachas it's people sort of advice from all over the world on all different things in recent years that that's what spoke to some people others are upset about these things i have no interest in getting involved in this for me what's important and what i'm trying to to stress in in the presentations that will follow is is the legacy of tyra what he left behind his his productivity and his written his incredible amount of swarm that he wrote and what we could possibly learn from them what made them so unique and what's what they stood out about them okay excellent so i'm trying to think back you know i grew up referring was already ready was already a household name there were actually other godolan manhiguem when i was growing up pedophile became you know the so to speak monagh of many um streams or sects of claudius throw you know over the last you know a bunch of years um what's your first what's your first encounter what are your first memories of rakhine so interesting is that my first introduction to him was in elementary school in the united states in the late 1980s while i was i used to collect those days there was a comment collecting the dylan cards without pictures at that time it was considered very rare to have a picture of him somehow i got a few just to show here was the here was the five some from the five pictures of him that i had these were some of them and it was considered very rare only barely everyone even heard of him at the same time an extra special picture was to have a picture with him and his great father-in-law rebel yoshif this was a picture that i had this was considered this was extra expensive because it had both of them and interesting in those years yash of america at least was not as famous either we're talking about before the internet we're talking about a whole different world than today where everything is in in a whole different world whispers in those days was that he was the son heinrich was the son of the special great gain that everyone knew about even in america the stipler and that was how i first was introduced him as time went on in my high school years i started to hear about him a bit more but i cannot pinpoint what was the first encounter that i had with his farm but i do recall that it was his i think his safer sichasada which will get to talk at great length but it dropped today which was what got me to hearing learning his some of his tyrone okay so as mentioned wrote many many swarm on all different areas of torah and what's unique about haim's farm is that there's so many different styles of the way he wrote his farm in different places so obviously we can't cover everything today and hopefully we'll be able to do some more of these that talk some more about swarm so which which safer particularly do you want to speak about first or now so first i i i want to just give a drop of background to before i get to the safer that i want to talk about um is as follows had tremendous there was a different people the different more tremendous influences on him and his writings particularly his uncle khazanesh his father the steipler the mishna buru and the vilnigan throughout not so much today but throughout the next presentation i have no idea how many will be but to discuss his goals and what he was writing what he was trying to do and to to put it in somewhere perspective to show how these limb that had an influence on him it also influenced in his particular areas of writing his way of writing what he chose to write but today looking around one will see that there's so much so so much material about him now it's very unique that we have normally when a goggles lifter they first start writing about the goggle what was so unique about him his history everyone scrambles um even even even in recent years with the internet a lot of times in a goddamn snifter for example but nothing's free finkel was lifted a few years ago so magazine delayed printing it because they felt they're not going to do justice um about him and they have to scramble to get information to talk to right to write about him at least for the first issue and then as time goes on they they add more and more marijuanaewski already in his lifetime there's a wealth of wealth of information about him and because in recent years people have been fascinated by him um just to mention um because this is we're talking about this farm there's a safer written it's called haswaram the safer is put out by family member in bene brock and this deals with a lot of interesting things a lot of the back story of a lot of things about the swarm of rakhine kanyevsky and what have you ever seen this saber called fascinating same walker correct that that is the same author he also had to say what you see is foreign we what sometimes it takes years till you get the backstory of why he was riding this far in or what was his interest and fascinating side facts about the safer a lot of it's in this farm already another thing is that there was a fellow someone who was like to get very close with rakhine his name is rav tiger and he has a few booklets and a a few beautiful videos with conversations with rokhan kanewski which i could die to see on the internet you get to see rankinewski in a in a whole like uh there's no fanfare going on around him and he talks about swarm and different his writings and he helped him he used to talent him and and it's very it's very interesting to see so what the these just this is just a tip of shibayam of what there's out there um on the internet or people there's so many people that spoke to him and we're talking about a year that was 94. so there's people a lot of people have to do with him and and people have different angles and different insights and whatever so they're just out there and obviously some of the things from this farm will use in the final presentation mention of tieger i've also seen different clips but i'm seeing fascinated about urbana you're welcome with the besiegers ha guys on it did you see that have you seen that like different times these people yeah yeah yeah it's very interesting it's just like they're small clips but they put them up on the internet already for the past few years and and they're fascinating i find each one of them very very full of nice cute pieces of information tidbits as i like to call them anecdotes maybe before you now rebel ezra maybe before you continue is it known like how he wrote his farm what was his mahalaki mention of tigar i know he was involved in editing what was his mahalik and how he wrote this farm you know i mean through this thing some of the pieces of information that i read or i saw of from different people i'll i'll mention when we get through discussing some of this farm but the first in this safer that we're going to talk about shortly maybe it might come out yet to talk about it but um just just two last points before we actually get down to to to the first safer that i would like to talk about is as follows was a man that we know he's finished sas pavli you shall me and many other areas of torah yearly made a seam on it for for years and years and years this is also demonstrating the safer that you showed us he had this thing called javis which basically was he every day he had a quota of how much he would learn of different swarm starting from the beverly going onto xiaomi to finish every year this farm which is remarkable but it's not just that he okay so he did it it's not like he did a schneidermaker tag so he added to schneidermaker we're going to see in the course of what i hope to discuss how that was helped him in in his forum what he was able to do which was unparalleled now shalom i'm not coming to compare him in any way to the to to the um but there was a quote that there's different versions of the quote but basically when he described his father and rohingya similarly when he described his rabbi de grace when he wanted to discuss his yada how much information he knew how much tire he knew so he said a sentence which he said a few sentences that's it he also knew and he learned carefully safras the free tysofta percolableezer you shall meet above he said myself this is what they said about the village now some people when these when they heard it they said okay he they said it about him but who said it's true because at that time there was nothing printed from the village in his lifetime he printed nothing and then slowly slowly today for example we could see we have the guard wrote on all this and it's something incredible that tyra is it's not not to take away from any other goggle and we're not playing any anything but to see that that how vast torah is it's endless and that someone went through it in a systematic life and i knew it all and wrote about it we and we have it it's not like even uh um a thing that you know they just said and similarly the village had a special top a special unique younger brother and the same thing they said about him what was he buckian so the quote goes who knew him personally and wrote the incredible work called told us adam he knew khalsa tanakh now these are incredible incredible quotes and these are of our special good one that we had a few hundred years back what's remarkable is when you read these quotes and you hear and you hear about what they say about kanyevsky it's amazing that he also someone in our generation that just was nifter also was someone that knew this now again by kryon kanyevsky we don't have to wait 10 years 20 years to see it we were zaika to have it in the swarm that he printed in his lifetime already from a young age he was starting to work on them and we have them today and that's what's remarkable this and and we will discuss through the presentations different um difference farm okay fine with that fascinating introduction so it sounds like you have one safer that you want to focus on now which safer is that so interesting is the safer which i i took a liking to it many years ago it's called kiryat melach which is a safer which is makira's on the rambam the curious honorama so many of us have gone through the yeshiva system we know many different sperm on the rambam for some reason curiosity is not you know on the top of the pile so maybe take us through what it is and what kind of safer it is and maybe why isn't it on top of the pile okay so so the truth is that this safer begins it begins with a with a with a with a contrast as i mentioned earlier um he had this thing that he went through rambam uh dozens of times he made it a certain it became into his crevice that he would do daily and he would be messian with yearly but it seems he learned it many times even maybe even before those fives and at one point in the in the um late 1950s he he published i don't know if he published it then but he finished a work called conscious this was a conscious on the hagdam of the ram tiara as well known the ramam has a fascinating introduction to his yada kazakha where he outlines different things including a lot of historical information to say there are diverse um and certain interesting facts about tariq about a very very important say for kadai to learn worked on the safer and he wrote a incredible incredible work using to show the macarius of the rambam where the ramen was basing this because the ram doesn't say where he got what he says from and he wanted to and when does he finish it only purim tough shin you'd zion that's how he writes now and we find out now the backstory is he why did he rush to finish it then because he wanted to give it to his father as a muslim purim and he gave it to his father it's one of the swarm that he gave his father as inshallah it seems there's another safer at a different time he gave his father also now is this a discussion that's brought up you allowed to give smartphones so i don't know if you're allowed to but it has been discussed and there's a lot written about sperm that were it seems that sometimes it was more this you know an excuse not because you're yaita necessarily um but it seems that sometimes it might have been that passion didn't have anything so at least to be uh to some aspect of something so they gave swarm but but there's a lot been written about how people have collected which savaram were actually given for shahmanis it's famous the the levi and many others far more written as to different people was written ramallah gave it his father etc a lot a lot has been written about yeah so whether you make the mister or not posh does not but it's certainly an indian you find it have have given spar for furnish okay continue now um so he so in this safer he does what he he's called taksha tag of the rambam and it's a conscious where is it found in the safer sidh which i mentioned earlier was which is which includes in it a few different hebrew small fiber of rakayam which some others will discuss at a different time now then a little later he put maybe even a year or two later a year later or something he puts out a safer in the back of a rambam he was asked by the publishers he had a keyboard it's called kiryat malach okay so what's the kiryat melakh so kyrie malek is a heber which is it's as it says in the shower and the shower is written by kanyevskiy see you named makairis rabin malpiske rambam we are claiming also some corrections and it's so basically it's first printed in 1958 in the back of a rambam then it's printed again and again and each time recline kaneowski would add more and more tikkunin sometimes he added a thousand more mechas and another thousand more macaris and um eventually today if you buy it it has at least just at least six more editions with each one has additions and corrections and stuff about it okay this safer as opposed to all others pharmacists has a scammer from who his father and his father writes about it i was asked by my son i guess to write yes and he says be sephiroth niffler but then the the stipler says i'm not a i don't give a scammers but then he says why it's amazing to be that he was he he came to sources of the rambam that people were not aimed on okay veron writes about it what he did how he learned to rambam and he learned it again and you can see from here from the various hadamards he has three hagdamas from in the different editions how he marmish saddam learned the rambam and basically it's it's a few hundred page work where he has macaris for the rambam so now before i get to explaining what it is what's so significant about this um already in 1970 the safer impressed um people of all types so much soul the marshall um his disciples had a relative an interesting person now for now named so lieberman professor saul lieberman he was asked to recommend of a tremendous talmud who he felt should get a um funding from a certain prize which project should he recommend and and he so strolling wrote in a few different suggestions and he writes that in this is in 1970 specifically about the um kiryat mela he says as follows he says i feel that there's a who should be recommended for this prize rohingyas brac it was called the rothschild prize he published he says he published already at that time a dozen half a dozen works one of them sources on the rambam which was published separately um he says he um he then he says his notes on the messages has no parallel he's known only among a small circle of scholars because he didn't write his name in his works and he writes so much so that he's even more impressed with then with her kind and discipline he was into this type of plenty also was relative he knew him well anyway this letter was discovered by um professor mark shapiro he printed it he printed it once a few years back on this farm blog eventually someone took it without permission and put it on matsiv but they did attribute it to mark shapiro at least but he didn't give it to them um but this is a fascinating letter because you see even people at least people that understood the rambam um which i'm going to hopefully explain the significance of this a for shortly um we're blown away by this work so now with all this the stipler and so to speak show lieberman and and many other people they say that they in one of these this place i saw even morezowski quoted it once in shira and he was like he he they told the reprimand about that also but there's something very unique about the safer societies what's so unique about the safer as you as you asked us you asked me just a few moments ago you were learning you never heard about it and i'll be honest and yeshiva i never wanted her to quote it either um and wilder from i never really heard a quote so what's so unique about it so to backtrack one must understand the foul you have to have the following context the rambam wrote a safer yada kazakha which we all everyone's very familiar with immediately after the rambam wrote to safer there was a problem what was the problem there's no makaris where does he get what he's saying from now it seems possibly the rambam was himself going to write a to explain where his sources were from to maybe he changed his mind that he realized that he should have he shouldn't have that's a it's a recall snap for now now so ready from when the rambam wrote his work made it available we're showing him for that for this for the pen and then him also for centuries and then in the yeshiva world also one of our one of the things that people are trying to do is to understand where did the rambam why is the ram say what he's saying where does he get it from so in the shivaji world today in the past hundred something years it's the became this is famous the brisket era the the brisker the brisker world is very into with raphael and and and the descendants afterwards with using different um methods that they have to understand reprimands to understand the ramba but already but but beforehand also people were isolated to understand the macaroons around them now to quote something to to help us get context of what the significance of the safer was there's a famous letter the first time i i remember i came across that i did not believe it i pasha could not believe that it was real and just like there's been other letters of the rambam and other materials of the ramen that people thought of forgeries samarta forgeries i thought maybe it's a forgery but then i looked into it it's not a forgery it's 100 authentic and a lot has been written about this letter basically a talmud of his was learning of stickler rambam in hill sayak and he couldn't any and he wanted to know the source so he went to the rambam his rebbe and said where's the makar for this and the rambam and this is the letter of the rambam um we have um even shillat prints it from the i think we might even have the arabic edition of it even but the ramen starts looking at it and he and he says maybe you look into gemara where this is in sanhedrin or marcus he's the talmud says i look there it's not there says the rambam shama be or xiaomi maybe it's an irishalme so the talmud says i looked it's not there maybe it's in the tysepta the rambam is very nervous and the rambling says i mean um i think maybe it's in gitan there's a zeitgei that relates to this if they look and getting it's not there and then afterwards the rambam remembers that was in yavamis in the zeitgeist so the story goes and so it says over here is that um we learn from here is that even the rambam there was a uh there was a at least he forgot some after a short period of time even macar of something he said the ramen writes in hagdama to perish a mishna somewhere that it's so anyway this this um chuva of the rambam the shine is which rambam is he talking about which ramen says has this whole backstory so the myself hashem we have from matissero strashon and many others figured out exactly which rambam it is it's a real and it's a real not only do i say that we have the actual chuva it's a real story but what we learn from here is two very important points that even the rambam the there was a for maybe it was a short period of time but he forgot himself because it wasn't in that specific place where the suga is it was in his place in the obamas that that somehow he used it we also see from here something else into the world of the rambam how he wrote his safer he didn't just use the beverly hinarama says maybe it's in the xiaomi why because he used the xiaomi extensively in his work similarly he also used the taisefta these are hebrew that weren't used by everyone but the ramen did and used it now moving further there's a famous story and this story has been said i'm not going to say they say it about different you could put into the story whichever godly you want to be and he look um that was isaac in the ramba basically adam god deployed he was icing his whole life into the rambam and he's and and he had he felt he had answers to understand where the ramen got what he said from everywhere except for three places he had three problems that he didn't know where the ramen got it from he comes he he's nifter comes up to shamayim before they don him he says one minute i need to speak to the rambam first if you don't mind i've been waiting my whole life to know where's the three where's the mechanism of these three rambams he goes and speaks they say no problem he speaks to the rambam the rambam tells him this it's a thai sats this is a gemara is a trisepta this is a safri zuta this is a makhil to the rashmi he whacks him across the face azayan from narampa this is how you answer rambam you have to give a whole lambda shastical torah to understand the whole aram this is just to illustrate that a lot of times and especially in more past hundred something years a lot of times a car of a ram really could possibly be a car in a gemara or even a hazal that somehow got lost what do i mean i mean is that the rambam had a wealth it's gala in that the mecca is the ram of the rambam had a machina amount of literature of tyrosha that a lot of times were lost and and some of these materials when are they discovered only in in past hundred years so i'm going to give one example and that is the we know that um um for i'm familiar with this the small when one learns it seems rishon had a rebirth called the rajbi from rupturing by yokai but it was lost but we see it's quoted often by rashinum um some somewhere around 100 years ago certain discoveries were made and the they found some of these some of um pieces of what they believed to be the maguilta the rajbi okay so they found it so um different people were very excited about it bottom line make a long story short is as follows from these um macaris it will start to be noticed that we might now be able to have a car for different things at one point i'm not sure who was the first person noticed it now we have macaris certain rambams that we didn't know where they're from and they're safe from a cult of the rashby eventually more material came out um more discoveries in rajbi originally it was on it eventually later on epstein and his talmud as your mulamid that we and we have them um you could buy them in a local farm store they're available in hebrew books but what's the significance in the 19th i think was in the 1940s ramana kosher went and wrote a safer called harambe and he shows numerous rambams the macaris from this makhan it seems that um um he ended up redoing the safer but maybe wasn't as many as he thought originally but definitely makairus of the rambam and his gala from this this is just one such example when one opens up the kiryas melech one will see casadar a makar for the rambam will be this makhil tudorajbi he had the mikhail from huffman from the from ryan ahmed epstein he quotes it crusader and he uses it in other place others foreign to say it became part of his knowledge and he also used to answer up the rambam not only from his incredible knowledge of yushami and trisepta you see him using madrashim and targumin he'll use targumyanus and benoziel to show him a car for rama and hilton now in recent in recent years machine zircon iron went ahead and they also redid to make a firmer version of mikhail to the rashby because the recent the addition up until now is from academics so they need to make a firm edition so they went and they wrote letter the person who put it out has beautiful letters with khan kanewski handling with it and they have a list of many times how kankanski uses it in the in his farm especially in kiryat malak but also in other places so we see that the the we see this incredible yadda vadievsky that he would take his knowledge that he learned called harakula casada and he used it to answer up to show makaris of thousands of rambams now sometimes it could be that other people were i mean on it also but the the when you go through the safer it's almost 300 pages he a lot of times you'll open it up you'll say ah they may found it he's not trying to collect what everyone else said it's more things that they weren't umidon or at least he didn't see people being omid on and then he would um and then he tries to uh he'll write he writes very bakit sir but i'll say this rambam i in here a lot of times you'll look there it might just shed some light to understand the rambam it might not be necessary it might be a partial makar which also one always has to be careful um about now um and so so this is one nakuda from the safer that we see in this kiryat melech how he uses his his incredible knowledge not only of you xiaomi there were other good island that were outstanding in xiaomi that did use it to answer to show the rambam and his relationship with your xiaomi and this after also um the ville negoyan chose a lot with the in recent generations or seven points out that already remember simcha and the ragged shover also were very into showing this he also does many cases that they didn't but but what i'm saying is he went even further for example the michael de rajan another hebrew that he did was a discovery called cepheuta which was also a very more recent discovery in the past hundred plus years he also uses it for his hebrew now the the safer is not full of lambda shalom to explain rambam's it just shows you and you open it up a lot of times you'll see no one has the macarthur and you all of a sudden could find them occur in here now just a few more short points about this he he um another thing we know about the rambam is the ram um that his makaris were he at least some mckay surround was from the gainer so here gaining literature even today as we speak there's new discoveries and new materials of the guy in him are being printed rakayan kanievsky was well aware of what was going on on this too and i just randomly opened up a page in her name towards the and over there i find numerous times on these pages there could be 60 70 randoms in this on this page he he will bring you chuba sarif that um a bunch of times he'll bring you he'll bring you it's he'll bring you rav um all different things of these of of early literature uh of high gain and ours i mean just looking at one page the amount of times i was like it's unbelievable he and he even has a list where he shows where he collects various times the ram specifically says gaiden but then he shows which kind of now based on new materials that we have and say he was it wasn't only that he knew what was printed until let's say 1900 he whatever the new discovery of many at least many new discoveries in the past hundred years was brought to his attention and he incorporated in his learning and then he used it into his rambam to use it for for different makaires as a as an example and it was the chuba sarif also had influence on the rambam and kanyevsky and this is interesting this tigerman talks about it and uh other places there was a hash of a yidra davidson a tremendous tomahawk who was also nifty who who also had attached with rohingya one of the areas that district of david syracuse was involved with was the was the was the riff putting out neutrals or manuscript there seems to be more tourists of the rift that still haven't been printed and one of the things is sometimes it could help with the rambam um now so david c rochester had these manuscripts and he had rakhine kanyevsky who wrote harass on them sadly rahayan kanowski says on one of these videos that it was lost but rokhan kenowski what he did but he did see a lot of materials so there's a few pages where a few times they'll say in the troublesome riff that he saw of the savior of davidson watching that now the material we said the truest riff actually we i think we do have but the material of the hebrew that kanganski was worked on for this redundancy roach team was lost a sad story where kankaski says i think maybe on a boat something happened but in the introduction he mentions that a few times i'm quoting because i had material you say he's using even manuscript material that was given to him that he worked on in this work of the rambam which obviously is not so much found in the standard yeshiva world where you're you're going to be answering rambam's based on a manuscript of a chuvas arif okay to be messiah with one last point about about a macarthur the rambam the boom car for the for kai and kanievsky it's a famous discussion tons has been written about even have been written about did the rambam see the zayar or not and furthermore because different people notice uh if you say that the ramam did have the zayar then we could have an additional makhar of akhibur khazali early heber and that would help us understand certain ramaps famously rebuva magolis wrote a series of articles eventually was put into a booklet and then eventually pretty recently put into a safer of various if we assume the rambam had the zaya we could understand the makara from many different roundups does the villeneg also sometimes seems to go with this a bunch of times uses the zayar which is showing an interesting um point about hank how he read how he learned to zayar again this is using it in um [Music] but he's using it throughout the um as a macaron for the rambam sometimes interesting he quotes it based on he says rebuffer margolis he had a tremendous cavitus for roofer magolis he knew him he met him a few times in tel aviv library and he liked him a lot and he says also that also had a special key before margolis and he was very macbook to quote things that he saw from rumor magos in his name and it's interesting is because a lot of people especially back we're not um didn't like remove my goal this is uh his aspect to him so much so i remember i think i saw it but i heard about it like the margin was allowed in punished so to speak but the bachelor movies were not but to cross out the dating in the beginning of the safer because it's a zionistic thing but murakan keneshki had no problem with him and he quotes him crusader in his kiryat malach now baruch at the end of the sea if he does say he's not he's not saying that the rambam really had zayar it could be the brahman had another early macarthur from in him that might have had desire but but be that as a mate desire is also another um thing for kankanski to conclude with one with one last um piece of information relating to all this is that there's a rambam in the the ramen as i said doesn't usually quote his macarons and he does he he he says things to him does the rabbi ever quote a tana or a mura in his safer so it seems the story goes um brings down the story that one time someone went to him and said um about a certain rambam where the rambam quotes a name of atana this was in in um actually this was the name of amaira and the name of the mayor was weir in spotim where he quotes rava okay and the shuttle was does the rama never do such a thing so the story goes there zalman said that um he remembers one another such place again with his incredible because whatever's chat in this story with urban zalman if there is a shot even but in a few places has a long list of different places where the rambam is quoted um by the sorry that the ramen was quoting either a name of tanayam or amiram he has this list in the back of a safer and then in the various editions he adds to this list this is some of the things that i think we could learn from from um this incredible hebrew area of melech where rohan kenievsky used his incredible yada in tara and he used this special yada of is in in torah to of all areas of taiwan as i mentioned and you shall me in beverly of even that no one uses today um or very few people use today such as um to to to find thousands of mclarens of the rambam in this hebrew and and it's remarkable and it's good to know it's available in hebrew books that this this keyboard melody exists and not only does it exist it's it's kadai to to there's two things we can learn one is in case someone has a raman doesn't have them a car to look over there yes we have franco rambam hashem has an incredible wealth of information but second it's it's it's we learn from here that we see the the use it's not only that he sat and learned rakayam just sat and learned and um cassador as a um um his clevis as he liked to call it but he he used it for his hebrew and this is the first such hebrew that i would like to demonstrate one kuda we could learn how he it was just remarkable what he did with the safer carrier melaka and that's why it impressed so many as his father called it say foreign um that that's the first of the safe of the sperm of of the many many storms that i hope to discuss okay wow fascinating a lot of information to digest i don't know how you put it all together to give it over in such a short amount of time okay so thank you for this um let's get back together focus on some of the other safari and some of the uniques for him and hear a little bit about you know how him was able to put together some of the other swarm over the ideas of the others far more room that he wrote thank you very much